#that they can exist and not contradict
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
you guys know that pretty much every single political group in history has had the moderate reformists and the radical revolutionaries, right? and that even though they disagree about certain methods, their goal being the same means that they cooperate in order to achieve more attainable short term progress while actions are taken at the same time for long term progress? this is what liberal feminists used to be to radical feminists, the two groups did not hate each other, they just had different outlooks, but generally respected what the other group was trying to (and had some success to) achieve. we lost this dynamic and relationship with the post modern, genderist overtake of liberal feminism, and so it is clear to me that we are in dire need of that role again, with the same repeating schisms in approach that appear under the singular label of radical feminism.
at the very least, we need to establish a differentiation in reformist (i don't mean surface level equality feminism, but looking at practicality and realistic, incremental actions, and harm reduction for women while the other group is more about instant action towards the big picture of abolishment of the system, which won't occur tomorrow or any time soon considering most of the world is NOT radical feminists) and revolutionary radfems purely for the sake of having that instant understanding of how the other faction thinks, and not having these aggressive arguments over and over again when it is clear that it's not a misunderstanding or hypocrisy or bigotry (well, sometimes it is, but i mean the core issue), but a fundamental difference in worldview that is unlikely to heavily change with defensive and highly tense online debates that keep happening over and over.
this is all i'm going to say for this round of 'oh my god everything is imploding again'. this is also not saying anything specific about certain people or making judgement upon individual incidents on either side, i'm not getting into that. just a general thought after looking at repeating patterns of conflict.
#this is one of the main reasons why i don't get involved#i think both groups are correct in their core beliefs but just serve different necessary purposes#the best comparison i can think of is the hong kong protests#they had a group that fought directly with the police#and another group that didn't want to do that but instead provided supplies first aid shelter and great pr#or the two factions of the civil rights movement#i'm genuinely not both sidesing this though i do think both sides go too far with the insults and bad faith interpretations#BUT a lot of it is self admitting non radfem bad actors that excitedly jump in to insult whatever women they can#plenty are self proclaimed radfems though so i won't place all of it on them#but yeah i genuinely think both sides have not just valid but correct and necessary points that many don't seem to understand#that they can exist and not contradict
31 notes
·
View notes
Text
there are many arguments for why light could be transmasc but chief among them to me is that it explains why soichiro and sachiko yagami have one child named "sayu" and one child named "light but it's written with the kanji for moon unusual isn't it"
#im not particularly married to light being trans but im just saying he could be. he could be trans#he could be trans in a way that never comes up and it wouldn't affect or contradict the existing narrative at all#which to me. is compelling#rookposting#death note#im just saying if light got to choose his own name he would not choose a normal name#nonbinary person naming themself leaf energy#i also think soichiro and the yagamis are one of few fictional families that would earnestly do their best to switch pronouns/names#like if i can picture any fictional dad not knowing how the hell to connect with his transgender child but like really Awkwardly Trying#In A Distant And Clumsy Way#to Validate his Son (Son)'s gender (son) despite not quite understanding it (him) (son). i can picture soichiro yagami doing it#in a more modern au he sets 'daughter' to autocorrect to son in his phone which doesn't quite work since he also has a daughter
175 notes
·
View notes
Text
sometimes its really obvious how much people dont actually believe presentation=/=gender when they see their nonbinary friend go from extremely masculine to relaxing back into femininity once theyre comfortable with their gender and every time they call it detransitioning with zero indication thats what their friend is calling it. i dont know how to tell you this but sometimes you present a certain way for social reasons and not because thats how you actually feel. sometimes you experience dysphoria about your body that is actually related to how people view you and not how you feel about your body. i really dont think its that uncommon for trans people to swing really hard in one direction for the affirmation and then relax back into a different presentation once they are more comfortable in their gender
#txt#gekkering#idk how to word this but genuinely if you see your friend growing more comfortable in their body and presentation and assume theyre detransi#tioning without them telling you that you should be ashamed and i hope your friend finds someone who is more accepting of experiences they d#dont personally relate to#butch trans women exist femme trans men exist and very masculine AND very feminine nonbinary people exist#i hated my body most of all when i focused on how other people view me. and before anyone accuses me of anything not that you need to but i#do have other dysphoria but its not NEARLY as severe as when i was younger and was obsessed with how other people gendered me#and if that does still bother you thats okay im not saying people who arent bothered by being misgendered are unreasonable or should get ove#r it or anything#but THATS why sometimes your dysphoria from when you first came out can drastically contradict the way you present later in life#such as transmasc people no longer wanting to bind or transfem people no longer wanting to tuck
173 notes
·
View notes
Text
I really wish things could be different, you know?
for @wincestwednesdays prompt: performance/underrated words: Warsan Shire
#spnedit#wincest wednesday#samdeanedit#wincestedit#something about genuinely wishing a better life for each other#the contradiction in knowing the only meaningful thing you have and count will only ever exist in a life full of pain and suffering#but also on how there's no easy answer to how much value you can place on a life you've never known compared to the one you have#its on my mind a lot#you and me#whatever it is#**
116 notes
·
View notes
Text
what i love about the Famous Actor Natori Shuuichi of it all is that...it's not just that he's famous and therefore widely recognizable wherever he goes. like yes that is very funny because he was an exorcist before he became a famous actor, which means he CHOSE, on purpose, a day job that would make it harder to hide his double life/secret identity from the hordes of his adoring public, but it's more than that. it's not just that he's famous, it's that he's famous specifically for being an ACTOR, aka a person whose job it is to dissimulate, to make believe, to inhabit roles and emotions other than his own. like he decided he was going to become as visible as possible (which again was literally not necessary! he could have gone into any other career for his day job!!) but in such a way that everyone would see him but no one would see him - they would just see his various made-up personas, including the Famous Actor Natori Shuuichi persona. i can't decide if he's a genius or if he just made so many absurd decisions that they canceled each other out and circled back around to working out. he's either playing 9-dimensional chess or he's eating the pieces. too soon to say.
#the other thing i love about it is that in a very real sense it's his actor day job that is his alter ego#being an exorcist is his normie job. he's just a famous celebrity on the side#which isn't that uncommon in secret identity setups but it's still very funny#natsume's book of friends#natsume yuujinchou#natori shuuichi#natsuyuu meta#my posts#f#i think probably the actual answer is that acting was a very natural career choice because he already masks so extensively#both to hide that he can see things other people can't (and that youkai exist and that he exorcises them)#and to hide what he's really feeling so that no one can use it against him#so if it's already something he has to do & he's good at it...why not have someone tell him exactly how to do it & get paid for it?#and the other part of the answer is that most ppl don't go into acting assuming they'll get famous. the fame was a side effect#so each decision as it was being made probably made perfect sense. but put them all together#and you have this hilarious assortment of elements that seem to directly contradict each other#okay also i would be remiss if i didn't mention the other possible answer which is that the attention came first and was unavoidable#and the acting developed from the need to protect himself from the attention that he was going to be attracting no matter what he did#because he's so beautiful. and (in the exorcist world specifically) because he's the last of the natori#the more i talk about it the more i'm like no becoming a famous actor was the only path that made any sense for him lol#1) he's gonna be watched no matter what bc he's him -> gotta figure out how to hide his secrets -> learn to act as self-defense#or 2) he's got secrets -> he's gotten a lot of practice hiding them -> hey you could make a career out of this!#all roads lead to actor natori shuuichi. and since he's beautiful...all roads lead to FAMOUS actor natori shuuichi#i love it when i ramble so much in the tags that i end up contradicting my own post lol#he's neither thinking ten steps ahead nor is he irrational. he's simply making sensible individual decisions#that follow logically from what is available to him and what his priorities are
158 notes
·
View notes
Text
Kaleshwi is such a good ship. It's such a good ship it's so good and so beautiful. All the mirroring they have going on, the mutual respect, the friend among enemy lines situation. We might kill each other today but at least we get to hang out. I'm so glad you're here. I'm protecting you but I will never admit it. I'm so glad you survived. We are enemies but I will try to bring you over to my side because you're worth saving. I respect you even more for not giving in. You are my equal. You challenge me. I'm so glad you're here.
#don't get me wrong i looove aro/ace/aroace kaladin but multiple headcanons can exist at once ok?#i feel like it doesn't even contradict#ahhhhhhhhhh
202 notes
·
View notes
Text
what do you mean WHAT DO YOU MEAN that castiel reached down into the depths of hell, battling hordes of demons to reach dean, scalpel in hand and star protégé of hell’s best torturer and dragged him fighting and screaming, soul cradled close to his grace, up to earth and in his body that he reconstructed atom by atom to make it habitable for him again and then they just proceeded to build a RELATIONSHIP that was NORMAL???? not in my spn, oh no you don’t.
#i want dean to constantly have to live with the fact that castiel saw him at his very worst#saw his soul#saw everything that is dean#i want him to wrestle with that fact every time he has to face the fact of cas’ existence#and i want cas to be. so so enamoured#as much as an angel can be. with all the contradictions that is this measly human#i want them messy and tangled and hell#plessly drawn to each other#supernatural#dean and cas#deancas#.txt
110 notes
·
View notes
Text
The way it's depicted, Cybertron's pre-war societal issues had a lot less to do with Functionism and more to do with unchecked government corruption, massive wealth disparity, high layoff/unemployment rates, and disenfranchisement.
People were starving, they needed work, they weren’t getting any. Those that were fortunate enough to have work didn’t get paid living wages, much less have anything to spare for health contingencies. Even then stability’s still the luxury of the top few tiers; they live one cut away from layoff. The government cared only enough to exacerbate these issues by coming up with new ways for exploitation. Any attempts to protest or lobby were shut down through political persecution. As a result the masses turned increasingly to crime, drug abuse, thuggery, and violence. Extreme acts of terrorism gets lauded as long as the collateral damage's suffered by someone else. Morality and caution are eroded in the face of desperation.
Meanwhile the many alleged restrictions of Functionism are just lip service complaints made by the characters which doesn’t match up to most of the stuff we’re shown. Like if Rung could become a psychologist, a specialized job that requires higher education, despite having zero background on top of such a weird alt that he had to be classified as an ornament, then wow the functionists must be open-minded. If Dominus Ambus could be a scientist/doctor/explorer/author/successful social rights advocator during the height of functionist control with a minesweeper military-use alt (assuming that his secondary alt's the same as Minimus'), then wow the functionists must be accommodating. If Tyrest could become chief engineer under Nova and later go into law, a complete change of profession, while being a jet, then wow functionism's flexible. If Ratbat and Momus could become senators in a society that discriminates heavily against beastformers and labor frames, then wow that’s progressive. If every Prime from Nova to Zeta (with the exception of Sentinel, his alt’s a tank, he only has wings in Megatron Origin as part of his Apex armour upgrade), every single named pre-war senator other than Proteus and Momus, and four out of five of Nova Prime’s buddy club (only Galvatron's a grounder) were wingframes in a society that supposedly discriminates against wingframes, then wow that’s… inconsistent worldbuilding.
Megatron didn’t get into bloodsports or start a war because he didn’t get to pursue his dream job. He got driven into the pits and down the slippery slope of moral degeneration because his only source of income was cut off by the mine closure incident. People wanted livelihoods above anything else, it's the failure to provide that that made the miners go off the deep end and resulted in the death of a guard. If Functionism actually ensured that everyone could be guaranteed a job or at least minimized the unemployment rates, then stratified castes or not, there would have been no war. People, or societies, are generally capable of tolerating an incredible amount of injustice as long as the majority still have a chance at scraping by at the end of the day. But the government, and later Megatron, kept yanking the rug out from under everyone over and over until they no longer even had a chance at that; there's no other choice left but fight or die.
#I get that all prejudices are full of contradictions and inconsistencies meant to cater to the needs of the ruling class#for the sole purpose of upholding the social stratification#and tokenism is a common thing#but when you can pull out two or more examples as shown to the contrary for every one of a character's complaints#about how they suffered from functionism discrimination#then it's just a really bad case of inconsistent writing with all tell no show#like you cannot expect me to take the 'flightframes are low caste' thing seriously#because the entire pre-war upper class is almost exclusively comprised of flight frames. it's the ground vehicles that are the minority#honestly it just feels like something made up on the spot for Starscream's sake#and Thundercracker Skywarp Jetfire got benefitted by association#when was functionism introduced as a concept in the comic anyway#was it in that Megatron/Optimus conversation in Chaos Theory?#b/c I'm getting heavy retcon vibes there#I got no impression that functionism was even a thing that existed when reading Megatron Origin#Autocracy's written later but still no functionism#The main social issue is widespread poverty like I'm sure a lot of those ppl would be pretty happy if someone could assign them jobs?#the miners in Megatron Origin weren't mad because they had to work in the mines#They were mad because of the layoff and automation and knowing soon there's going to be no mines for them to work. and then they'd starve#idw transformers#transformers#maccadam
54 notes
·
View notes
Text
how it feels to read people on this site criticize death of the outsider
#hater corner <- out of love#before i speak tho. its an criticism of the game and not personal connections people form with it. hope this makes sense#i like the outsider mortal and daud and billie of all people freeing him! there is so much potential in this idea#this is a /j but if daud wanted to fuck around and find out whats made the outsider it would be more accurate to his character#than daud blaming the outsider for his own actions. and billie would have her own journey of self-discovery#they could do it together without being reduced to an old man and a caretaker#when i first saw the playthrough i actually really liked it. and i still stand by it being a good game if it wasnt in dh universe. it is fu#and it has interesting themes. but none of them relate to the other dh games. or contradict them#anyway. all of that has already been said and in way better than i ever can#the saddest thing to me is that its trying to sell a story about the characters that we already know and love - and the world we love too#without getting deep into any of it. instead of working with existent depth its creating new lore thats loosely tied to the old one#or overexplaining it when dh1 proves how ambiguity can enrich the narrative#and i dont want to defend it bc of the development hell it went through.its not genuine and its not meeting the standard games before it se#and it the end its just sad. id love a good billie game#talk tag#dh related#sorry for grammar mistakes and typos. im tired
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
youtube
HERE IT IS!! after Many moons of chipping away at this OC song comic for my scifi-noir android character Whitney and his bodyguard Bast, it is finally as complete as it shall ever be;; I’m proud of the work I put into this one! Pretty niche, but maybe some folks out there will enjoy UuU
ps: there's also a video for easy viewing!
#song comic#comic#comic art#character illustration#sci fi fantasy#dark art#character art#my scribbles#lyricstuck#an ode to this complicated traumatized morally twisted delusional bastard capitalist#as he becomes that which shaped him into the monster he is#the reality of his existence as an android (marginalized identity in this world)#is at odds with the power-hungry hierarchical worldview he's developed (as a coping mechanism) and is now consumed by#he will Never be one of the self assured entitled elites whose lives/positions he covets#but he can never acknowledge that or the path/ identity he's constructed for himself unravels#at the root of it all#he has vowed Never to be at the mercy of others again#which makes it all the more ironically tragic that the path he sees as granting him the most power is actually just selling himself#to be used as a pawn by the Hijaratha (illuminati-esque organization made up of the same politico-corporate elite#who ruined his life in the first place)#he's so full of contradictions/ hypocrisies and he doesn't even realize it#I find him so fascinating#rotating him in my mind forever#lots of little symbolism things in here#just as a treat for me lol#if you've read down this far- bless you you are now my boon companion#Youtube#whitney
45 notes
·
View notes
Text
Since we’re talking about the Witch’s Castle artbook I’d like to bring up this one thing I saw
Apparently Earthbread was a normal island in the world, one that basically no one went to, and then it was transformed to how we know it today, being all food-ified
This is Witch’s Castle and not Kingdom, but it feels like this is the only explanation for Earthbread we’re gonna get. Also it was made by Studio Kingdom, aka the people who make CRK, so I feel like this has grounds for being canon in that game. Also it just makes sense
#I don’t know yet how canon Witch’s Castle is to Kingdom#like if they’re completely canon and simultaneously take place in the same universe#or if they exist in slight separate universes#I mean as far as I can tell none of the playable Cookies we see here explicitly contradict CRK canon#though I could be wrong and misremembering#though that would also mean no Chili Pepper or CoD members#who knows?#I guess we’ll find out#cookie run#cookie run witch’s castle#cookie run kingdom#earthbread
37 notes
·
View notes
Text
The way people sometimes refuse to acknowledge that writing choices that clearly go against established canon should mean something is endlessly frustrating to me. We don't have to agree on the interpretation, but these writing choices SHOULD mean something.
Otherwise, it's shitty writing.
#'the ga wouldn't even notice'#'the character doesn't seem to mind'#'you're reading too much into things'#no actually the fact that so many people think writing doesn't have to involve any stylistic or thematic choices to build meaning#and that writers just do stuff and as long as the character doesn't say anything it couldn't possibly mean anything is absurd#like y'all can pick up any classic piece of literature and think the writing just manifested on the page#and nothing is any deeper than some author saying what happened to a character like the character's just recounting real-life events#and that nothing really means anything except exactly what is said outright or some shit#but that's not how good writing works#in any form of media#and if the blatant contradictions are not being addressed then maybe the writing is shitty actually#and also even IF something wasn't intended to mean anything by the author directly doesn't mean that no meaningful connotations exist#for the audience like jesus christ y'all#i get enough of this bullshit from my students i don't need it in fandom too#let people analyze things and dig into them and spec and 'look too deeply' it's fun#and also it's okay if someone has a different interpretation than you and wants to talk about the possibilities behind that interpretation#or about other possible interpretations#it is not hurting you to see someone 'read too much into something' let people have their opinions#without trying to shut down everything you disagree with goddamn#anyway#911 discourse#fandom negativity#and actually i do think it's mostly shitty writing at this point#but that doesn't make it not mean anything that it's shitty writing actually#and it shouldn't be viewed as some awful character flaw for someone to point out why certain choices don't make sense#and to talk about what they would like to see addressed because of that
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
i think america is a top by necessity, not by choice. he would probably love to bottom for canada but for one thing he's so fucking pushy and domineering there was just never any hope for him and it'd be less embarrassing for everyone involved if he stopped trying tbh. second of all canada would never let him, and somehow canada is even more domineering than him (no one believes america when he says this) so really america has no choice in the matter
#amecan#caname#my ideal dynamic can't possibly be explained in one shitpost but that won't stop me from trying#canada is my ultimate domsub freak and yes i believe this can exist without contradiction#mic check#i didn't pause my timer to write this so i'm posting amecan sex positions on company time ayo
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
alright time for my two cents about it
imo not officially addressing some of the big world-shaping decisions from the prior games is the right move? even a non-central decision like sacrificing the chargers or not recruiting a companion splinters the game - if every world state gets to be the canon world state, where all of the decisions are referenced and included and neatly lined up, how do you continue to build a cohesive narrative? the more decisions you import, the more the state of the world continues to branch. at a certain point I think you have to make a choice - either embrace the idea that no two players will ever create the same thedas so there can never be one central world state for the series as a whole, or leave the bulk of those choices offscreen. if it isn’t being addressed onscreen, to either canonize a certain choice or to redact it, you’re walking a fine line where you can have both player freedom and a cohesive story.
I personally just think that at a certain point, addressing every decision a player has ever made is going to make the world smaller, not bigger. how far can all those branching narratives splinter before they run out of story to safely tell without doubling back on prior player choices? why would they even want to take that chance?
#da posting#dragon age#like by all means contain the choices into their individual games and have them impact that#but if you lock some of these things into the canon there’s no going back on them#like if you say ‘okay so here’s what happened to the well of sorrows’#then you’re creating at LEAST separate world states/timelines that you can never weave back together#either it’s true or it isn’t but either way there’s no going back#I think that not addressing things like that keeps the overall narrative tighter and prevents the world state from bleeding out everywhere#but that’s just like my opinion man#and makes it so that you CAN have a canon world state that exists in your playthrough that isn’t contradicted by actual game canon#without narrowing down the possibilities in future games#idk man! that’s just how it feels to me!!#feel your own feelings and take that article how you need to#but I don’t think that ‘they aren’t gonna make certain choices canon or not’ is like…..#the big gotcha on the game being ~terrible~ that people think it is
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
I think the dumbest thing about shipping wars is the absolute failure to acknowledge that shipping's not about how "they'd be so good together" over another lesser suited ship. In fact, it's not even quite about the characters.
It's about what this specific dynamic made from these specific characters together, brings to you. Whether because you find it wrong-bad or fascinating or soothing or inspiring or whatever.
Like, when push comes to shoves, shipping is about you. The person doing the shipping. And that's not only fine, that's also what fiction's for, ultimately. The reader. You.
#fandom#carrot has an opinion#anyway i had an irritating fandom exchange and because i'm chronically unable to let things go it's been niggling in the back of my head#they won't see this but maybe somebody will and idk maybe this'll encourage a spark of nuance in this specific discourse?#shipping#shipping discourse#and it's because shipping is so deeply personal that it can be so difficult to accept the existence of different contradicting ships#but that doesn't mean we should freely give into the impulse gdi#there's no right answer
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
my sources for shuichi being trans:
girl voice (in the original jp - voice is noticeably higher and more feminine sounding than any of the other boys)
general appearance (prominent eyelashes, fairly soft features, pretty androgynous esp when you pair with the jp voice, at certain points if ur insane enough it kinda looks like he has a binder outline)
wears a hoodie to the beach
gets really weird about having to go into the girls bathroom (obvs for different reasons but if you view those lines thru a trans lens then it honestly makes a lot of sense)
depressed and suicidal (not explaining)
im trans and i said so
#all of that plus the fact that there rlly isnt anything that contradicts it (which i do usually take into account) ....its literally#just canon to me. also i like it bcuz it adds another level to his dynamic with kaito <- that being that shuichi is a queer person#whose best friend says some homophobic and transphobic shit in the game. thats such a painfully real experience being friends with#someone and really admiring them but then they say something and you're just hit with the painful truth that you can probably#never come out to them. and like shuichi IS bi already so this already exists as a concept but i think him being trans adds another#layer onto it. also this isnt actual basis but when it comes to pregame the way that i think about him and interpret him is#very tied in with him being trans. and like guys hes literallyyyy a dr fan ofc hes a mentally ill chronically online pre-t trans guy /lh#serena.txt#suicide mention tw
8 notes
·
View notes