#down with the status quo
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
People are waiting for things to be history while itās happening so they can say āoh why couldnāt we do anything to stop it?ā
You can do something to stop it.
Murder is happening right now. People are being killed right now. Starved out. Infected with disease from manufactured conditions. Their homes and community being torn apart because of sickening and disgusting wishes from the people in power above us assuring it happens.
Stand up. Do something.
Donāt wait and say we shouldāve done something to help when we couldāve. Youāre complacent if you arenāt helping now.
#og#free palestine#free gaza#save rafah#save rafah city#save Gaza#help palestine#save congo#save sudan#stop the bombs#stop the war#stop the genocide#stop killing civilians#end colonialism#end colonization#down with the status quo#fuck the status quo
547 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Transformers : One spoiler
I dread for the day that most people watched Transformers : One, because of the amount of takes that basically put the blame on Orion Pax for pushing D-16/Megatron to snap (And then sneakily calling Orion Pax as someone wanted to protect status quo and didn't want to tear down the system simply because he didn't have that need to violently put the oppressors down like some types of common low-lives and force everyone to follow his crusade to screw the system).
Very spoiler!!!!! Warning
Orion Pax tried to stop D-16/Megatron from killing Sentinel has nothing to do with "we became as bad as him if we murder that cunt". It's more like "You're being unhealthy with your hatred and I don't think you should continue with this train of thoughts". And I promise you that Orion didn't that much fuck about Sentinel's well-being. He's afraid for D-16 and whatever direction his friend would become.
Orion Pax noticed how his dear friend began to go down to a very dark part, and he would never stop to spiral down further, even if he murdered Sentinel and his lackies brutally. And D-16 hasn't expressed any contigent plans to change the system into sth better, and all he cared about was how to punish and humiliate Sentinel in a most terrible way possible. And the way he acted toward Starscream and the High guards is peak red flag for potential dictatorship and oppression that use fear, violence, and hatred, which is parallel to Sentinel's own brand of opression that filled with lies, manipulation and exploitation.
And sorry to burst this bubble, but D-16/Megatron isn't the one who is revolutionary. That's Orion Pax's thing. Orion was the only one noticing And it will be funny to see the take "Orion wants to maintain the system" when this little shit first thought when learning about the truth is to expose Sentinel's fake-ass to the mass and rally the oppressed folks to rise up against Sentinel and the system. But I guess it's not violence or brutal enough for some people to acknowledge that Orion is going for the least destructive route to tear down the system because he valued life more.
This is not saying Orion Pax's solution for dismantling the system is the best and only way to go, and sometimes violence can be the best answer in certain circumstances. But if your the whole revolution is based solely on violences, killings and basically tearing down everything to satisfy your hatred/grievances without any considerations for the casualties, consequences, and priorities to rebuild the system, it become a pointless and selfish movement that will actually never bring any substantial changes besides sufferings and tragedies.
#transformers: One#You can call me a Orion Pax/Optimus Prime kinnie#I may be biased towards my dear rebellious Princess#But I can't stand the potential takes of Orion Pax wanting to maintain the status quo/same system#Y'all are free to sympathize D-16 spiral down to dark part but don't act like he was 100% right#This is a hard pill to swallow but not all oppressed folks have the best intentions in mind for others' well-beings#Everyone is susceptible to corruption#Orion Pax#D-16#Megatron#Transformers One#TF:One#tf one#Transformers
129 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
So long as the political and economic system remains intact, voter enfranchisement, though perhaps resisted by overt white supremacists, is still welcomed so long as nothing about the overall political arrangement fundamentally changes. The facade of political equality can occur under violent occupation, but liberation cannot be found in the occupierās ballot box. In the context of settler colonialism voting is the ācivic dutyā of maintaining our own oppression. It is intrinsically bound to a strategy of extinguishing our cultural identities and autonomy.
[...]
Since we cannot expect those selected to rule in this system to make decisions that benefit our lands and peoples, we have to do it ourselves. Direct action, or the unmediated expression of individual or collective desire, has always been the most effective means by which we change the conditions of our communities. What do we get out of voting that we cannot directly provide for ourselves and our people? What ways can we organize and make decisions that are in harmony with our diverse lifeways? What ways can the immense amount of material resources and energy focused on persuading people to vote be redirected into services and support that we actually need? What ways can we direct our energy, individually and collectively, into efforts that have immediate impact in our lives and the lives of those around us? This is not only a moral but a practical position and so we embrace our contradictions. Weāre not rallying for a perfect prescription for ādecolonizationā or a multitude of Indigenous Nationalisms, but for a great undoing of the settler colonial project that comprises the United States of America so that we may restore healthy and just relations with Mother Earth and all her beings. Our tendency is towards autonomous anti-colonial struggles that intervene and attack the critical infrastructure that the U.S. and its institutions rest on.Ā Interestingly enough, these are the areas of our homelands under greatest threat by resource colonialism. This is where the system is most prone to rupture, itās the fragility of colonial power. Our enemies are only as powerful as the infrastructure that sustains them. The brutal result of forced assimilation is that we know our enemies better than they know themselves.Ā What strategies and actions can we devise to make it impossible for this system to govern on stolen land? We arenāt advocating for a state-based solution, redwashed European politic, or some other colonial fantasy of āutopia.ā In our rejection of the abstraction of settler colonialism, we donāt aim to seize colonial state power but to abolish it. We seek nothing but total liberation.
Voting Is Not Harm Reduction - An Indigenous Perspective
#indigenous action#2024 elections#voting#on one hand i think if one opponent is a mask off fascist white people have an obligation to vote against them As The Least We Can Do#but if that's all we're doing? that and bullying other people who see a futility in participating in a colonial institution of 'democracy'?#sorry but um. shut the fuck up#if we spent half as much energy on direct action to support each other in ways that help people REGARDLESS of who wins what election#as we did on yelling at Other Leftists about voting i think we would get a hell of a lot more actual shit done#and sure as hell help more actual real life people who we claim to be helping by yelling at other people to vote#i'm talking to me here like#our current blue harm reduction candidate actively supporting a genocide should make you feel like maybe this shit doesn't fucking work#because it doesn't <3#harm reduction as the least we can do needs to be a call to action via vote AND actual action or it's not a call to anything at all#the least we can do needs to be motivating AND convicting#it's the least we can do so fucking do it. it's the least we can do so if that's All you do sit the hell down or stand the fuck up#for people who the status quo serves it needs to be the ballot AND the bullet or our ballot means fuck all for real liberation
321 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
The fans: Ugh Sonic was just so preachy. I mean obviously he's supposed to be the good guy, so any uncomfortableness I feel here and any way I feel like Sonic's choices are framed as being why some other people have shitty lives is just bad writing because he is obviously supposed to be right always, but this characterization makes no sense. Isn't he right for the things he did?
Ian Flynn, using Kitsunami to say the (barely even at this point) quiet part even louder: Hey it's almost like ever since the Mr. Tinker event we've been purposely running with the critique of Sonic as being more selfish than he appears. Sonic is upholding a system of Eggman v Sonic that currently benefits him and shuts down talk of how to improve the current system because he likes his own personal enjoyment and he's attached enough to Eggman that he'd rather Eggman pretend to be a good person than be stuck in prison for life. He doesn't even quite practice what he preaches. We are trying to show that the current hero v villain system and Sonic's recklessness currently affects some people poorly and that Sonic isn't a perfect hero.
#fandom wank#sonic the hedgehog#idw sonic comics#idw sonic 2024 annual#2024 sonic annual spoilers#idw somic comic spoilers#idw sonic spoilers#idw 2024 sonic annual spoilers#i just be ramblin#god one of these days I need to commit to the sonic character essay#because you HAVE to be able to see Sonic as a multifaceted character that is surprisingly selfish and a bit self centered despite his image#as a good hero who is always right to understand what the writers for Sonic Prime and Idw Sonic are trying to do#The point is not that Sonic is secretly a bad guy or anything#the point is that we're already primed to assume that anything Sonic does is a good thing because he's a hero and protagonist of what is#considered a 'children's media'#And people who can see those moments in different games or properties times where Sonic isn't being so good as him actually not being so#good of a person are primed to explain it away as flaws of the writing or the genre at that time *because* Sonic's behavior is not said to#be bad or punished in those games#And become we're already primed to assume that Sonic is already the good guy who's making the best choices no matter whatā it's supposed to#be shocking when the narrative takes a step back and gives a critique of this status quo by showing us the effects of it#But instead of having some sort of eye opening event or being willing to meet the narrative where it's at#99% of the people who post here got uncomfortable and just doubled downā saying that because these things are being pointed out and some of#Sonic's actions (that aren't even alien to the games)#are being framed in a not so good lightā then it must not be purposeful. That it must be bad writing through and through and just bad#Sonic characterization#because for people who claim they want Sonic as a series to be deeper and more thought out they sure start to pearl clutch when they feel#like a property isn't being as shallow as the very same games they think kinda suck#anyways anyways sorry about the rant I'll get back to regularly scheduled posting after this#vent post
91 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
i donāt know if iām ever gonna write the fic but iāve been thinking abt like. the eternal stockade. the implications. lup, a lich who was trapped in a dark featureless cell for a decade completely isolated with nothing to keep her sanity but her own mind. she has to put people in the eternal stockade. how many liches does she see herself in. how many liches started out just like her. how many liches are truly too far gone. and the only liches we ever see other than her and barry are edward and lydia. theyāre certainly evil, but mad? they seem pretty sane. theyāre not, like, tattered echoes of souls, theyāre definitely still people. even as much of a grudge as lup surely has against them, wouldnāt they remind her incredibly strongly of herself? do they deserve to be trapped just like she was? for eternity? isnāt eternity what turned john to existential despair in the first place?
#mine#taz balance#taz lup#lup#like idk i think lupās down to kick necromancer ass but when it comes to being like. WARDENS of a PRISON. would that not be uncomfortable??#but like taking the job is the only way to avoid HER being thrown in prison??#idk the raven queen being a cool & chill goddess boss is definitely fun but when you actually think abt it#i donāt think iād agree with her. i think if i lived in that world iād think she were sort of evil#which like also to get into the hunger vs authority its not very explored because its not at all the point#the hunger is meant to be nihilism and despair and dissatisfaction its at its core an emotional story about joy & love#but like john starts out rebelling against laws. laws of the universe; except that it turns out a being wrote those laws (jeffandrew)#so the hunger is also sort of a force of rebelling against unjust constraints in the pursuit of freedom?#and the heroes end up preserving the status quo and saying you just have to find joy within those unjust limitations#which again. like. the point is that life is unfair and you can find joy and meaning despite it. which is true to real life.#iām not saying the hunger was right or that despair is the only way or w/e like#yk like taz balance is not a story about society its more about. philosophy i guess#the point is that lifeās really hard and you find meaning anyway and thatās preferable to despair and death#thematically for the audience we understand these are standins for ways of viewing reality#and in the real world reality is what it is. its just the world. thereās no authority that writes the laws of nature#like its not a āman vs authorityā story its a āman vs natureā story#but IN UNIVERSE nature IS an authority. jeffandrew and the gods. regardless of how much joy you can find in an unjust world#if i lived in it iād want to make it more just! but anyway like yeah barry & lup working for the raven queen#is kinda an extension on that idea of preserving the status quo#although i guess you could say gods are just forces of nature. theyre not PEOPLE theyre just personifications of existent natural laws#and it ties in w istus and fate as well#although fate is like a comforting guiding force rather than restricting & horrifying#^ pay no attention to any of this i donāt think it really means anything iām just like. writing thoughts as i have them#not like a hard stance iām taking just exploring some ideas#any ways#THERES A TAG LIMIT??
64 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
i know the knowledge is Not Secret and Pretty Damn Obvious but remembering the fact the wc writing team changed between oots and avos makes so much sense. like ohhh that's why mothwing is Like That now despite her previous characterisation being far less bitter and aggressive, along with other personality shifts or new directions for characters. that's why onestar's SE zeroed in on the darktail thing they came up with instead of older key scenes or points about his character that they may not remember as well if at all. that's why each arc is structured more episodically, repetitively, and self-contained now rather than having a lot of wee overarching character arcs and plot threads or messing much with the status quo. sometimes i wonder and then i remember the obvious answer. like. to both improvements and its degradations it explains a lot of writing switch ups between then and now doesnt it
#anyways. considering the fact the new team's first action with cinderpelt was solidifying her being in love with firestar as solid text#god i hope they never make her a book#also not that old warriors changed the status quo much to be clear#but we had an entire setting shift in arc 2 along with numerous shake ups to the pov structure#and theologically regarding how starclan and the dark forest were written in the books#some of which is down to them finding their footing and some of which might be down to the series being written from a new angle now
62 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Sketchy sequel to this little thing I drew on an 8 hour plane trip without references because no wifi :(
Shockwave's logic tree of 'only breakdown's brave/stupid enough to call him breastie' and 'breakdown saying "hey breastie" is in reference to him' meets Breakdown's rarely seen mischievous side like a downball piffed against a wall-
#shockwave#tfp shockwave#breakdown#tfp breakdown#transformers#tfp#maccadam#fanart#funny this is the only transformers thing i've drawn in a hot while#not for lack of drawing but#...my friends dragged me to sit in line and wait with other fans of someone's runes being deltaed that i discovered a new favourite charact#a little bit of a shame that i immediately started binging a canonically diagetic monochromatic timeloop game where i can't pick a fav#but regardless shockwave is experiencing a series of unfortunate events but they're only minor infractions to the status quo#and breakdown is being a little bit of a menace which is not something you often see but#look if you can rile shockwave up and not have him immediately put you on his list of test subjects or stare down the barrel of his cannon#i think you have full authority to be a little bit devilish even if the worse you're gonna do is compare tit sizes
83 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Fanfics in which Marcy and Sasha idealize Anne as this angelic being filled with kindness and light are so sweet but also so funny. It's always abt how they feel like they don't deserve her because of all the harm they caused her but also. Lmao you can tell they weren't around Wartwood in S1. Anne was such a little piece of shit back then.
#amphibia#my posts#sashannarcy#s1 Anne still ends up coming across as leagues better than sasha and marcy because her bad deeds were more of a#they were very casual and small potatoes. Anne's shitty behavior was more of a matter of quantity than quality#pressuring sprig to confess to ivy as a main attraction at her frog of the year party#shaming polly for not being girly enough#pretending to be sick to avoid work causing the plantars to get sick themselves#this is opposed to marcy committing only three big crimes. but those were BIG#1) kidnapping her friends 2) doubling down on it by striking a deal with Andrias. lying to them and manipulating them for months#and 3) never taking a side in sasha and anne's argument. which i think is a BIG thing and i wish we mentioned it more because#she's not brave enough to take anne's side she's not brave enough to question sasha and her struggle to maintain the status quo#is hurting everyone#and sasha... do i even have to elaborate š
26 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
honestly, maybe it's a hot take or whatever, but I think that tearing down the veil and *potentially* bringing back the immortality to the elves would not have helped them a lot
#like ok i'm not 100% sure that tearing down the veil would even make them immortal again#bc the problem is that the elves of today are so far distanced from the ones is solas's time i don't know how that would even work#or maybe i'm stupid and missing context clues but whatever#but like what service would that *actually* do to the elves?#it won't bring their erased history back#it won't suddenly break all the chains of the ensalved elves#or give better quality of life to those in the alienages#bc take fucking tevinter#yeah if suddenly all enslaved elves became mages it sure would help them#but their enslavers are ALSO mages#who had way more training and years of practice#and then the ones in the south#if they suddenly all became mages#what would stop the templars of jus rounding everyone up and committing a genocide?#what would stop the ruler of orlais of burning the alienages again#like waht gets to me is that#the current situation of elves in thedas is a political problem#that needs to be solved through that#through rebellion through changing the status quo#to pushing for political powers to protect their elven citizes#not through magical means#bc that time is gone#and the dalish and the city elves have SUCH different cultures#than the ones of the first elves#that like...what would they gain?#solas could have spent his time actively encouraging all elves in thedas to rebel#to break their chains and rise up against their masters#but instead he's choosing to risk literally everyone's lives bc of HIS regrets#like he is only thinking of the past and of himself and of the people of his time#the way he treats the dalish is a good example of that
23 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Dennis shielding Dee whether it's physical harm or a verbal confrontation. And thinking about ada's tag alongside the gifs
They're both of equal threat to him...
#sorry i forgot who the 1st gif is from#i know its subtle but on one hand dennis distrusts strangers#bcuz they dont get him and they disrupt the gangs status quo#but dennis also just...doesnt like anger and will always calm people down#usually he puts his hands on their shoulders and massages when they get riled up and eases their tension#but here he's acting as a shield bcuz the threat isnāt coming from inside#it isnāt their emotions and their anger that needs to be hm let's say treated/controlled#it's an exterior harm it's coming from other people#dennis here understands dee's anger and sees reason behind it but he'll handle it instead#shields her away from it and speaks out#to me dennis doesnāt like anger and doesn't like himself when he's angry#so since he's calmer and more rational than dee in this instance he'll take over#cuz he knows anger doesnāt lead to anything good#he will always be the last to snap and he prefers running away to anger anyways#i feel like I've tackled too many subjects in the tags now I'll shut up#dennis reynolds#iasip#trash twins
143 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
I think one day Iād like to write something about Kusuke and Kusuo trying to have an actual sibling relationship, but I also think it would be painful. Thereās a degree of bittersweetness in any universe that Kusuke mistreated Kusuo surrounding them making up, whether from Kusuo trying to learn to recover from it all (or at least not be in survival mode around him) or Kusuke being forced to learn things about himself while trying to connect with his brother/become a better person.
#they drive me crazy and Iām unsure if itās in a good way or not#Ill be straight up I donāt like Kusuke#but Iām also more sensitive when it comes to familial abuse#And I know with families that experience that (especially between siblings rather than a parent and a child) itās very fucking complicated#I think I get Kusukeās character uncomfortably well even if I usually boil him down to simply an antagonist in my fics#my closest hint at that is probably in Status Quos tbh#saiki k#tw abuse
72 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
an ongoing networking discussion has resulted in a job enquiry that im really disappointed by (lower down position that's only temporary) and im kinda upset that this company thinks id go for that as im already in a more senior permanent position. Was moaning to my friend like I'm kinda sad about this, this doesn't seem worth my time and maybe I'm not putting my experience across well enough?? etc etc and she basically told me to get over myself and stop getting ahead of myself and yes she's right but also would a man be told to decrease his expectations and put himself down to secure employment? idk if I've been lied to by my boss and am a lot less senior than she's making out or whether I should stick to my convictions and demand more???
#im already employed like why on earth do they think id be jumping to take a position lower down and only for 6 months lmao#unless they're gonna pay be double or there's scope to become permanent i dont see the point š#so sad i was hoping this would pan out into a genuine opportunity that might help me escape my current unhappy status quo
14 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
when Some People say "solas is genocidal!" is like... omfg yall are so fucking boring š
#like girl idgaf if solas kills people. like i literally dgaf. hes fictional. he's not real.#idk i think tearing down the veil is a good metaphor for dismantling the status quo and what is necessary for change but id be getting into#delulu territory i fear LMAO#.txt
12 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
imagine if westley rlly betrayed wander n sylvia n stayed in the hater empire jk jk unless
#hmmm how do i make him suffer more#hed live such a miserable life#idk i just like that ācharacter gets all they wanted n then realizes it doesnt fulfill themā thing sm#imagine how getting special treatment n then being instantly demoted back to just private again after wander n sylvia escape would feel#im saying like cartoonishly instantly back#its like everyone forgot abt his stupid medal of evil n stuff its just all back to status quo except westley being less enthusiastic n#more n more hyperaware of all the brainwashing#which is actually funny asf cuz peepers n haters brainwasing n propaganda is so bad it only works on westley n maybe like 3 more watchdogsš#if the watchdogs still have a home planet i like to think they have the craziest propaganda going on down there actually to the point#enrolling in the hater empire is a lot of watchpuppies' dream#its like our thing w every kid wanting to be an astronaut except its every watchpuppy wanting to serve the hater empire#which was def westley at some point#except bro somehow kept that enthusiasm going for 3 years of witnessing hater fuck up n peepers violate workers rights all day every day#wait nvm the propaganda might actually work rlly well considering the eye on the skullship n andys whole thing abt being absolutely#engrossed w haters whatabouts n shit despite never seeing him up close before#damnn imagine that#imagine their war machine evil empire being actually bad n not just silly cartoon aliens (its still just silly cartoon aliens)#this got long asf idk i just lkke#i wanted to say āi just like propagandaā idk how to phrase it right n not sound fucked up in the head#its all propaganda pro propaganda i have a feeling im not alone š„š„š„š„š„š„š„#pbj
20 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
Henna not being back in any capacity in the second Mariposa movie gives me two impressions:
1). untapped potential for a 3rd movie where we get Henna reformation or some such.
2).
Mariposa: I wonder how Henna's doing out there.
Willa: ..... what if she's dead š§
Mariposa: šØ
Honestly it's entirely possible that she IS dead; a lot of her control over the Skeezites hinged on the promise of invading Flutterfield, and we can see their patience wearing thin throughout the movie. It's possible her failure to follow through would be the final straw, and that her lights would only be able to carry her so far when her entire army is against her. I do like the potential for another sequel to tie up that loose end though, in no small part because "dramatic revenge declaration followed by offscreen death that's never mentioned" is just kind of anticlimactic. Even if it's been a decade and that ship has sailed at this point. We could've had it all. Two fairy trilogies. Also consider: The Skeezites don't seem to be a threat--or even present at all-- in Fairy Princess. They're not once brought up unless in past tense. Regellius brings up Flutterfield defeating them when that's not necessarily how it happens in the first movie(which she does point out but focuses more on the method than the outcome so it's still unclear). Yeah they succeed in driving them off, but if Mariposa's quest or the fact that they've been terrorizing the kingdom for centuries says anything, it's that there are probably way more hanging around than Henna's immediate army. I'm imagining a midquel where she manages to get the Skeezites to hold out for a little longer so she can get her Revenge Plan in, and Flutterfield deals with them for good.
#My biggest thing at the moment would just be that Mariposa specified that it never came down to a fight#so I'd have to consider a Non-Fighty way to do that. Big magic.#She does have the flutterflower so I guess traveling wouldn't be that much of a danger but that gift was framed as more for#sentimental value than for protection.#Bringing Marabella back to life restored flutterfield to its status quo but didn't get rid of the skeezites or anything.#And like yeah they have the thistleburst lights now so maybe transportation is no big deal#maybe the skeezites stopped hunting butterfly fairies when they realized they had some form of defense.#But they're such a non-presence it's still just weird. Walk with me here.#It's still been too long to bring the series back but. Mariposa 1.5 where we find out where Rayla and Rayna and Zinzie went#pieceofcake.txt#cakeasks#Was so deep in Henna Denial when I found out she wasn't going to be the villain in Fairy Princess that my mind just instinctively went#'Oh wow she's aged a lot since the 1st movie'#In my mind if she survives she could maybe eventually get a redemption but she wouldn't continue living in Flutterfield#cakeart#The dialogue for the image was heavily paraphrased but inmy defense my internet has been supreme dogwater lately#So I was working off memory at like 4 am
38 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
What do you think about the changes to Lukeās confrontation with Percy ?
Got this ask, got really confused, realized the final episode was out, went to watch it, came back here.
So.
Mh.
As with the majority of the many changes this show made to the books, I have... mixed feelings on it.
Part of me loves this much more than the books - much - more. Because it made so much more sense. Luke, trying to recruit Percy instead of just... flat-out trying to murder him again.
And! That Percy was the one who figured it out, on his own. I love how clever this show makes Percy.
It was a really tense and interesting confrontation.
Now here's the part that made me dislike it. Because it made so much sense.
In the books, Percy not taking Luke's side made complete sense, because Luke just flat-out tries to murder him, for the second time, and he is screaming and throwing so much stuff out in such a frantic way that he does sound like he lost his mind. It's very easy to conclude "My guy, you're being brainwashed by Kronos".
But this Luke? And this Percy?
The Percy who literally spent the entire damn show MAKING Luke's points. The first half of this show, every single conversation between him and Annabeth was basically Percy reciting Luke's bulletpoint list of why the gods suck and demigods shouldn't do their bidding.
And now, what? All of the sudden, just because, what, daddy dearest showed up once and saved Percy's life from Zeus, he is Team Olympus? C'mon. That was weak as fuck.
A very brief summary of a point I've made in the past, I don't want to drag this argument out again but it's important to bring up in this context: PJO is inherently a story about keeping the status quo. It follows the very tried concept of giving the villain (Luke) a very good and valid motivation to rebel against an oppressive force, but undermining the good points he makes by adding something that nobody can argue is bad (Kronos controlling everything in the background), so the hero fights the immediate problem instead of the shared oppressors, instead of just giving the very good and valid motivation to the hero and have them fight for real change.
And in the books, at least there really wasn't much of a reason for Percy to join Luke, and Luke doesn't even really ask for it either.
But this Luke asked. This Luke very coherently expressed himself.
And this Percy has made his exact talking points in the past. And nothing, aside from Poseidon stepping up once in his fucking life, has really changed. If anything, I'd say the bad - Ares, Zeus, ATHENA - really outweigh the good.
Why is Kronos worse than Zeus? Because he ate his children? Zeus did worse things to his own children in mythology, to be quite frank. Show Percy is too clever - too knowledgeable about mythology and the past of their godly family and good at putting one and one together - and too bitter toward the gods to so fully dismiss Luke, in my opinion, especially considering we removed the "I will immediately try to murder you with a killer scorpion" and added Luke explicitly trying to recruit Percy.
And I'm not saying "Percy should have absolutely joined Luke's side", but I am saying that it felt far too much like a 180 on Percy's part to be defending the gods and pretend that Luke isn't making sense. I liked that Chiron called that out in the end, but... Percy's reply was even weaker because there was no foundation for why he would be so stubborn about this.
Even if you don't pull through with it, I think that an angle of doubt, an angle of temptation, should have been played up here.
#Percy Jackson#PJOTV#PJOTV Spoilers#Percy Jackson and the Olympians#Luke Castellan#PJOverse#lords have mercy this awakens my need to do a rewrite AGAIN#where Percy DOES join Luke because LUKE IS FUCKING RIGHT#THIS Luke even MORE SO than the books Luke. I need to lay down#ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS REMOVE KRONOS FROM THE EQUATION#AND YOU WOULD HAVE THE INCREDIBLY VALID REBELLION#OF THE OPPRESSED AND MISTREATED DEMIGODS AGAINST THE GODS#I'll never get over just HOW much more enticing that storyline would be#than 'and so he fought the gods' battles over and over - but he did it for his FRIENDS though!!!#because it truly Does Not Matter. he still fights FOR the gods and for THEIR status quo
38 notes
Ā·
View notes