#queer tara lewis

[0o-junebug-o0]

It's A Beautiful Thing

summary: Emily struggles to come to terms with her sexuality and goes to Tara for help after a disastrous hookup

genre: hurt/comfort

cw: internalized homophobia, comp het (compulsory heterosexuality), implied/referenced sexual assault (NOTHING HAPPENS it's just assumed that it did), religious trauma, religious guilt, mentions of pregnancy, mentions of abortion, using sex as a coping mechanism, unhealthy relationships to sex, Jemily mentions, coming out, unrequited love (or at least it's believed to be)

wordcount: 1.9k

Emily sits on the corner of the bed and sighs as she pulls her pants back on. Her whole body feels wrong and she wants to leave. She looks over at the door to the ensuite bathroom and listens to the sound of the shower running. She shouldn’t leave while he’s still in the shower. That would be cruel. It’s not like he was bad or did anything she didn’t want, it just didn’t feel right. 

She picks her bra off the floor and looks around for the first time as she clasps it behind her back. The whole room is painfully male. She hates it. And she hates that she hates it. 

Emily closes her eyes and runs her fingers through her hair to detangle it as best as possible. Her chest feels tight and she leans forward, burying her face in her hands and tucking her head between her knees. The sound of the shower feels like it’s drilling into her skull and the smell of sex that surrounds her makes her feel sick.

She presses her hand over her mouth and chokes on a small sob. She needs to leave, she needs to get out of here. She lifts her head and takes a deep breath before picking up her shirt and pulling it over her head. She then grabs her purse from where she’d discarded it in the corner of the room and pulls out her phone. 

An idea strikes her and she slips her phone into her pocket before knocking on the bathroom door. “Jackson?” Emily calls out, keeping her voice steady with practiced ease despite feeling like she’s about to implode.

The water shuts off. “Yeah?” he calls back.

Emily squeezes her eyes shut for a moment before speaking. “I’m so sorry. I have to go. I just got a call from work.”

“Yeah, yeah, you should go,” Jackson says sounding surprisingly okay at the thought of her leaving. “Go kick some ass.”

Emily opens her eyes and pinches the bridge of her nose. “I will. I’ll call you,” she lies.

“Yeah! Yeah! Just lock the door on the way out, you can do it from the inside.” There’s silence for a moment before the shower turns back on. Almost immediately, Emily rushes out of the room and out of Jackson’s apartment, making sure to lock the door.

She takes the stairs instead of the elevator, unable to stand the thought of standing still for a moment longer than necessary. After five floors she makes it to the basement level parking lot and she thanks her past self for not drinking because her car is here and that means she can leave now. 

Emily unlocks her car and throws her purse into the passenger seat not caring that it immediately slides to the floor. She climbs inside and closes the door behind her before slamming the heels of her palms against the steering wheel. 

“Fuck!” she cries, curling her hands into her hair. She feels like she’s about to explode. Everything is so wrong and she doesn’t know how to fix it. Sex with Jackson was supposed to fix it but that just made it worse and now she feels gross and dirty through no fault of his. A strangled scream tears its way up her throat. Why does she have to be like this? Why can’t she just be normal? Why can’t she just have sex with men and enjoy it?

Tears pool in her eyes and Emily angrily swipes them away. She needs to leave, to get far away from this stupid apartment complex. She starts the car and it takes nearly all of her self-control not to tear out of the parking lot. She’s already distracted, adding speeding on top of that would be a recipe for disaster. She needs to talk to someone. She wants to talk to JJ but she won’t understand and Will and the boys will be there and she just can’t. 

Emily parks along the edge of the road and pulls out her phone, opening her texts with Tara. She stares at the screen for a moment before typing, “Can I come over?” and hitting send. Emily closes her eyes and tries to calm herself while she waits for Tara’s reply. Her hands squeeze a white-knuckled grip on her steering wheel and each breath rattles in her chest. 

Her phone buzzes in her hand and she looks down.

“Come on over.”

Emily shuts her phone off and drops it into the cup holder between the seats. She wipes away the tears that had managed to fall and, checking to see if the road is clear, does a U-turn and drives toward Tara’s house. 

The turmoil Emily is experiencing makes the drive feel simultaneously seconds and hours long. She turns onto Tara’s street and parks along the curb in front of her house. She leaves her purse in the car, only grabbing her phone and keys, before climbing out and walking up the steps to Tara’s front door, locking her car behind her.

The closer she gets to the door the more panicked and ashamed she feels and by the time she knocks, she’s barely holding it together. The door swings open and Tara takes in her appearance with wide eyes and clear concern. Emily opens her mouth to speak but all that comes out is a choked sob. Tara pulls her into a hug and Emily nearly collapses in her arms. 

They stand there for a while, Emily sobbing into Tara’s shoulder, as they stand on the threshold of her house. Eventually, Emily’s crying subsides and Tara leads her inside with a hand around her waist, closing the door behind them. Tara guides Emily into the living room and onto the couch, keeping her arm around her. 

Emily leans forward to rest her head in her hands and Tara pulls her hand away to brush Emily’s hair to the side and tug on the collar of her shirt. “Emily,” Tara says softly. “Did someone—”

Emily shakes her head, recognizing the voice Tara uses when speaking to victims and realizing that there must be a hickey on her neck. That combined with the state she’s in: it’s only natural Tara assumed something had happened. “No. It was–it was consensual. It just–“ Her voice breaks.

Tara doesn’t speak, waiting silently for Emily to continue. 

“It just felt wrong,” Emily whispers. She keeps her head bowed, too ashamed to look up at her friend. “How did you do it?” 

“I’m afraid I don’t understand what you mean,” Tara says kindly. 

Emily uncovers her face and sits back against the couch, chewing on one of her nails. The tightness in her chest is still there and she doesn’t know how to say it. She doesn’t know how to ask the question she so desperately needs to ask without sounding offensive.

“You can speak your mind, Emily,” Tara says. 

Emily chuckles. Thank God for profilers.

She pinches the bridge of her nose with her free hand. “How did you let yourself be with a woman?” she whispers. 

Tara is silent for a moment. “I don’t know how to answer that question.”

Emily sighs. “I think I’m gay.” She opens her eyes and looks over to Tara to gauge her reaction. She knows she’ll be fine with it, she has a girlfriend for Christ’s sake. But this is the first time Emily’s ever said those words out loud and she’s terrified. 

Tara nods and smiles softly at her but doesn’t speak and Emily knows she can tell that she hasn’t finished saying everything she needs to.

“I’ve tried so hard not to be,” Emily admits. “I’ve had boyfriends, I’ve had sex with men.” She lets out a pained laugh. “I’ve even gotten knocked up. Did you know that, Tara? When I was fifteen and living in Italy, I dated a boy I didn’t like because I wanted to fit in and stop thinking about a girl. And we had sex that I wanted but didn’t like and he got me pregnant. My friend helped me get an abortion. All that because I didn’t want to acknowledge the fact that I liked a girl. And–and I’m doing the same thing now! I went to a bar and went home with this guy to have sex that I wanted but didn’t like, all because I want to stop thinking about a girl. Like maybe if I let enough men fuck me I’ll stop liking women. I–I know that’s not how that works and I know being gay isn’t something that needs to be fixed but I feel like I need to be.”

“Emily,” Tara says gently. “There is nothing wrong with you.”

Emily sighs. “I know that, Tara.”

“I know you know that, but I think you need to hear it. There is nothing wrong with you for liking women. I know it’s hard and it will take time but you are going to have to accept the fact that you’re gay. You can’t keep doing what you’ve been doing. It’s not healthy. And it’s not fair to yourself or to the men you’ve having sex with.”

Emily nods, leaning forward to rest her elbows on her knees. “I know it’s not. It’s just my whole life I’ve been thinking that maybe this guy, maybe this time it won’t feel wrong. Maybe this time I won’t feel gross and–and—“

She shakes her head, unsure of how to finish. 

“I know there won’t ever be a ‘this guy’ or a ‘this time’. It won’t ever feel right with a man. But that scares me, Tara. I don’t know why it scares me but it does.”

“Because it’s a scary thing. Realizing and accepting a part of yourself you tried to push away is scary and it’s hard. Especially if you’ve spent a good portion of your life hearing that that part of you was wrong like I suspect you have.”

Emily nods. “Catholic guilt,” she whispers.

“Catholic guilt,” Tara echos. “I don’t know if you still believe in God, Emily, but in case you need to hear it: you wouldn’t be gay if it wasn’t God’s intention. He made you exactly the way you’re supposed to be.”

A violent sob forces itself from Emily’s chest and she can feel her whole body shaking with the force of her crying as Tara pulls her against her chest. Emily doesn’t know if she believes in a God anymore either but knowing He doesn’t hate her fills her with relief.

Emily doesn’t know how long she and Tara stay like that, holding each other close as Tara runs her hands through her hair. But eventually, Emily’s sobs subside into sniffles. 

“It’s JJ, isn’t it?” Tara asks softly.

Emily stiffens and sits up. Tara’s hand falls into her lap. 

“What?”

“The woman you’re trying not to think about. It’s JJ, isn’t it?”

Emily opens and closes her mouth before slowly nodding. 

Tara looks across the room to a photo of her and her girlfriend. “It’s a beautiful thing, loving a woman. Don’t you think?” 

Tara looks back over to Emily, who is still looking at the photo. 

Eventually, Emily nods.

__________________

Tag List:

@lover-of-books-and-tea

Fill out this form if you want to be tagged in future fics!

[church-of-lilith]

I’m upset about the way they handled Tara and Rebecca’s relationship this season, and I’m wondering if it’s just me? After sixteen seasons we finally got two sapphic characters and a sapphic relationship, and this is how they treat them?

Criminal Minds Evolution Finale Spoilers Below

Let’s be honest with ourselves. Rebecca was a plot device the entire season. Her sole purpose was to give the BAU information they wouldn’t have otherwise. She was their way to cut corners. And then when she had to finally make a decision to prioritize her own well-being over the team’s, they made her a villain. She was willing to withhold information that could’ve led to Rossi’s death, something I doubt Tara could ever forgive her for. They totally left her in a position to be a villain in the next season. Or if not a villain, at least a huge part of the problem. I don’t think that’s a move they should’ve made. Why do we have to villainize 1/2 of our queer characters?

And then we have poor Tara, who is so deeply in love with Rebecca despite everything they both go through. She was put in a terrible position all season, having to decide between saving lives and saving her relationship. I hated it. It just felt like tragedy after tragedy. We also didn’t get to see her full reaction to Rebecca’s perceived betrayal in the end, but I can’t imagine her not having terribly conflicted feelings about that whole situation.

If they wanted to create tension in the relationship, they achieved that the first time Rebecca was hesitant to give up the information that ended up ruining her career. That was enough to fill the quota and leave them both in an uncertain place. Making her part of the ‘Gold Star’ storyline and basically pinning Rossi’s chance of survival on her was like twisting the knife.

Contrary to popular belief, it is possible to create sapphic relationships with nuance and depth without making the entire season about their misery.

I appreciate CM finally giving us representation. But it was, and I cannot stress this enough, the bare minimum. I hope they take the time to learn how to do it properly for next season.

If you read all the way down here please lmk your thoughts.

[bambinafangirls]

i love you, tara lewis!

As pride month comes upon us, as we can of course mourn the fact that the network scrapped bisexual Reid and lesbian Prentiss- please do not forget about our canonically queer legend: Dr Tara Lewis. Give my girl the recognition she deserves.

[scarlettjemily]

Watching criminal minds is a wild experience, because one minute you’re interested in the serial killer stories and then the next minute you’re a whore who has a gun kink

[blackbird-brewster]

TARA LEWIS + Meeting the Women of the BAU

[Belated post for Bi Visibility Day!]

[sunny-rants]

Happy Pride Month, here’s some of my favourite queer characters!!

[artcake]

Could we have Temily sharing a bottle of wine by the Christmas tree??

[ihopeineverloseyou19]

What if Garcia sees her team disconnected from what they were. This takes me back to 15x10 when JJ told Penelope that 'she was the glue of the team, she kept them together' hear me out. What if Garcia plans something to get the team o work together as a family. She gets Emily and JJ looking at each other. She goes on another date with Luke anddd she gets trebecca back together. Would it be so much to ask..

[storiesofsvu]

[wereoz]

nothing in cme is canon to me except the gay stuff 🫶🏻

[lowkxytears]

idk should i right a fic on a heartstopper oc/self insert that is muslim and queer and struggling with guilt and fear because they’re queer, and just them being loved and accepted by the paris crew? idk

[thundergrace]

Criminal Minds fans, including myself, really wanted Emily to be queer.

But they made Tara queer instead and I guess representation doesn't matter all that much depending on who it is because fandom is quiet on it pretty much everywhere, as far I've seen.

Very much giving

CM fans: PLEASE GIVE US SOME QUEER REPRESENTATION! IT'S BEEN FIFTEEN YEARS!

CM writers: *bisexual Tara*

CM fans: ... wait no, not like that

[ssa-inge]

CRIMINAL MINDS EVOLUTION SPOILERS

My opinion on our beloved characters so far

.

.

Jennifer Jareau

I'm really loving it that we get to see more of Jennifer and Will. Of course it's normal that they're having a few relationship problems because of their jobs and I love seeing them both trying to fix it but I'm having a problem with the end of 16x04. Like don't try to save their marriage by making Will sick. Also I love her to death, she's such a badass and I'm loving seeing her at her house.

Emily Prentiss

Good for her for getting that promotion but hello? Give us more insight on her life, is she single? Is she still with Andrew? (my guess not) one thing is for sure, she's such a boss lady and I'm loving her outfits so fara

Tara Lewis

Holy hell I'm so happy for her and Rebecca, yass girl get it!!! I hope we get to see more of them together :) I also do hope we see her roasting Luke again

Penelope Garcia

My god, maybe the one character that has evolved and grown. Look at her!! She's living her best life and being an absolute queen! But why did she and Luke only went on one date?? Stop teasing us like that and they better get together when they catch the unsub.

Luke Alvez

Honestly Garcia might be the only one who knows what he has been up to cause the CM writers don't for sure. At least give us an update on roxxie for God's sake. GIVE THIS MAN MORE DEVELOPMENT AND STORY.

David Rossi

Am I the only person who is actually pissed off that they killed of Krystall? He had been married three times and now he had finally found happiness with her. Okay yeah they are the age that is more likely to get covid and I get that he's mourning her but good god seeing him in that hotel and being grumpy to everyone just annoyed me.

General opinion

I'm sorry but hearing them all swear is funny as fuck to me :')

Also seeing them deliver a profile at the bureau was so nice, it's bringing back old vibes

I wish the episode were an hour long

Zach Gilford is doing a great job playing the unsub and I love that his wife is playing his wife on the show! I also love seeing that the unsub has like a normal life and we get to see it.

Am still pissed off he killed moose the dog :((

[blackbird-brewster]

Happy One Year Anniversary of Tara Lewis becoming the first canonically queer main character in Criminal Minds history! (CM Evolution 16x02, aired 11/24/2022)

Cards on the table. This is not my first time dating a woman, but, oh, man, it is my first time being this happy.

[scarlettjemily]

women women women women women women

cm 17x08 'North Star'

[blackbird-brewster]

Tara Lewis Phone Wallpaper