#High Court ruling

[seemabhatnagar]

A Story of Legal Battles and Marital Discord

The Beginning:

Sudeep Chatterjee and his wife were on the verge of divorce. The once-loving relationship had deteriorated into a conflict marked by distrust and discord. Amidst this turmoil, Sudeep was confronted with a complaint filed by his wife, accusing him of cruelty and demanding dowry. Fearing imminent arrest, he sought pre-arrest bail from the court. His pre-arrest bail application was dismissed by the Sessions Court, Katihar.

Sudip Chatterjee v. The State of Bihar and Another

Crl Appeal 2011/2024

Before The Supreme Court of India

Heard by the Bench of Hon'ble Mr. Justice C T Ravikumar J & Hon'ble Mr.Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra J

High Court's Improbable Condition:

Sudeep's quest for bail led him to the High Court, which granted him provisional pre-arrest bail but with conditions that seemed almost impossible to fulfill. The court required Sudeep to file a joint affidavit with his wife, stating their agreement to live together and his commitment to take care of all her physical and financial needs. Additionally, the court mandated that there should be no interference from Sudeep's family members. This arrangement was to last for only four weeks, after which the couple was expected to withdraw the divorce case.

"How is this possible when there is matrimonial discord?" the condition seemed impractical and improbable, given the existing strain in their relationship. It felt like an imposition that could further sour their already fragile relationship.

A Husband's Struggle:

Sudeep was caught in a dilemma. On one hand, he wanted to avoid arrest; on the other, the conditions set by the High Court appeared to dominate him and undermine his sense of fairness. The conditions suggested a forced reunion, which seemed unlikely to heal the deep-seated issues between him and his wife.

Moreover, the conditions risked giving his wife a sense of dominance, further complicating the possibility of reconciliation. Sudeep and his wife had shown a mild willingness to rethink their relationship, but these unrealistic conditions threatened to extinguish any remaining hope of a reunion.

Supreme Court's Intervention:

Realizing the impracticality of the High Court's conditions, Sudeep approached the Supreme Court by way of Criminal Apeal. The apex court granted leave to hear the case.

Hon'ble Mr. Justice C.T. Ravikumar J, presiding over the case, noted a fundamental legal principle: 'Lex non cogit ad impossibilia' – the law does not compel a person to do what they cannot possibly perform. The Supreme Court emphasized that conditions for bail should not be so burdensome that they effectively deny the relief sought.

The Final Judgment:

After careful consideration, the Supreme Court set aside the impractical conditions imposed by the High Court. The court recognized that expecting a couple on the brink of divorce to live together harmoniously under such constraints was unrealistic and counterproductive.

The Supreme Court made the provisional bail granted by the High Court absolute, subject to standard conditions under Section 438(2) of the Cr.P.C. Meaning thereby that Sudeep could avoid arrest without the undue burden of improbable conditions, allowing the legal process to proceed fairly.

Seema Bhatnagar

[yaralulu]

I do think it’s funny how little he cared about her being dumped in the blood rite and was wayyyy too comfortable with doing nothing.“Oh sorry cassian there are rules even l can’t break 🙁” babe you’re the high lord of the night court I think you’re allowed to break some rules to save your brother’s mate and your mate’s sister who was just wrongfully thrown into what’s basically the hunger games.

[swordmaid]

i am wide awake thinking about that post canon jb au again when I should be sleeping …!!! such is the nature of the jbrainrot…

[stargirlfeyre]

I would take the “Feyre can’t be a ruler she was just illiterate” people more seriously if Feyre’s former illiteracy was shown to effect her abilities as High Lady. But it doesn’t. Her formally being illiterate has 0 (zero) negative effect on her role as High Lady.

Also illiteracy does not speak to her intelligence in this case because it’s something that was born from her childhood abuse, not because she has some learning difficulties.

[patchw0rk-quilt]

they should have recess for high schoolers too like come on let those teenagers blow off some of that teenage angst by going on the swings or something

[cryingoverfictionalcharacterss]

One thing Feyre does a lot trough the series, after she leaves Tamlin, is that she constantly compares Tamlin to Rhysand. One of the things that made a big impression on her is how Tamlin said to her how there wasn’t a HL but then Rhysand made her one(undeserved). 

But the funny thing is that in the 4-5 months she spend in the SC (after UTM) as Tamlin’s consort she was WAY more loved and respected than she is as the HL of the NC for 3 years now.

[living-undead]

I love Sims drama because I am so uninvolved in all of it that I feel like I'm in a theatre, watching a movie with popcorn and my feet kicked up. Don't mind me while I sit from the sidelines and watch nonsense unfold before my eyes. Seeing factions break out over who gets to make more off the back of a multi-million dollar corpo.

[acourtofquestions]

PT. 2 CONTINUATION ACOTAR

Read/Re-Reading questions, theories, fandoms & more!

1 & 2. What did the inner circle of the Night Court do while Rhys was trapped under the mountain?

Did he trap them in Velaris to keep them safe/from trying to save him? — If not, how did he convince Azriel, Mor, & Cassian not to try & to rescue him?!?

Rhysand may be able to care for himself, he may command mad respect; it may have been a known death mission; but even if they didn't know the full extent of torture UTM, & even if 50 years of time is experienced differently/faster for 500+ aged immortals... I just can't imagine them leaving him there unquestionably (even if he told them to).

[clockwork-ashes]

7 for the Elucien week ask game! 💕

thank you for the ask 💕

7. i love elain and lucien being able to relax for a little while, and travel around prythian and the continent!!!

[listen-to-the-inner-walrus]

me, listening to a podcast about a guy in prison based entirely on a coerced confession: what do you mean the members of the jury still think hes guilty now that they know about coerced confessions??? did you not hear four police officers interrogating and shouting at a 19-year-old while hes sobbing through a story inconsistent with the actual evidence???? there was no other evidence, how do you still think hes guilty???

me, ten minutes later: ...oh, right. if they say hes not guilty, that means they sent an innocent kid to prison. yeah, now that uh makes sense.

[peppermintquartz]

"isn't it time you forgave (friend who defended homophobic ruling in a local case and showed they were a bigot)? It's been so many years."

Well, see, (1) they haven't apologized although I've made my stance perfectly clear re: being an actual queer person and that I stood with queer families, fuck the law,

and (2) made zero attempts to do so when they were able to contact me, nor have they asked our mutual friends to convey their apology now that I have them blocked

and (3) I owe them nothing. Not my forgiveness, not my space, not my time.

[izzysarchivedblogs]

Okay, but there's something about Clint who in general hates space

Being a pilot

And going into navigations in ST au

Cause he is just a little lost boy

Lost boy. Navigations. Pilot. There's poetry there.

But you ever point that out and he will glare

[vroomian]

Can you tell us a bit more about Florece? 👀

sure ! she's 27 years old mage who lives in a city that's mostly made up of fae of some variety -- it's the only city like it in the world. humans are super rare there, as in she's never actually met another one. Florence is a magical handyman who works primarily in magical devices for the poor side of town where she lives. She spends a lot of time going through magical trash, recycling parts into other things, fixing heaters and fridges, etc.

because humans generally have shit magic sense, she built her glasses to make it visible to her. (magic itself comes in three different versions, called scripts. First script is spoken, the second is musical, and the third is written, which is the one used by artificers and what Florence focuses on. master mages are called Scribes.)

she's extremely independent and keeps herself purely neutral among the various gangs of fae in her area of the neighborhood. good traits: intelligent, resourceful, rational. bad traits: standoffish, secretive, self-centered.

at the start of the story, Florence only has one real debt to clear before she can consider herself free and clear - a life debt to a high-fae dryad called Evergreen, who picked Florence out of the gutter at 15 and nursed her back to health. Florence always keeps her word and repays her debts. To pay back this debt, Florence agrees to search out a sample of a dangerous new plague that's devastating the Undercity, only it's not a natural plague. something far more sinister is happening to drain the residents of the undercity of their magic.

[stargirlfeyre]

Y’all call Feyre a bad ruler more than y’all give evidence of her actually being one.

[lexlawuk]

Companies Winding Up Cause List (6 November 2024)

ROLLS BUILDING BEFORE INSOLVENCY AND COMPANIES COURT JUDGE PRENTIS List updated: 5 November 2024 1:26pm JudgeTimeVenueTypeCase  numberCase nameInsolvency and Companies Court Judge   Prentis10:30amRolls Building, Court 17Winding up petitionsCR-2024-000967 Park Publishing Company LtdInsolvency and Companies Court Judge   Prentis10:30amRolls Building, Court 17Winding up…

[sapphia]

USA please listen to me: the price of “teaching them a lesson” is too high. take it from New Zealand, who voted our Labour government out in the last election because they weren’t doing exactly what we wanted and got facism instead.

Trans rights are being attacked, public transport has been defunded, tax cuts issued for the wealthy, they've mass-defunded public services, cut and attacked the disability funding model, cut benefits, diverted transport funding to roads, cut all recent public transport subsidies, cancelled massive important infrastructure projects like damns and ferries (we are three ISLANDS), fast tracked mining, oil, and other massive environmentally detrimental projects and gave the power the to approve these projects singularly to three ministers who have been wined and dined by lobbyists of the companies that have put the bids in to approve them while one of the main minister infers he will not prioritise the protection of endangered species like the archeys frog over mining projects that do massive environmental harm. They have attacked indigenous rights in an attempt to negate the Treaty of Waitangi by “redefining it”; as a backup, they are also trying to remove all mentions of the treaty from legislation starting with our Child Protection laws no longer requiring social workers to consider the importance of Maori children’s culture when placing those children; when the Waitangi Tribunal who oversees indigenous matters sought to enquire about this, the Minister for Children blocked their enquiry in a breach of comity that was condemned in a ruling — too late to do anything — by our Supreme Court. They have repealed labour protections around pay and 90 day trials, reversed our smoking ban, cancelled our EV subsidy, cancelled our water infrastructure scheme that would have given Maori iwi a say in water asset management, cancelled our biggest city’s fuel tax, made our treasury and inland revenue departments less accountable, dispensed of our Productivity Commission, begun work on charter schools and military boot camps in an obvious push towards privatisation, cancelled grants for first home buyers, reduced access to emergency housing, allowed no cause evictions, cancelled our Maori health system that would have given Maori control over their own public medical care and funding, cut funding of services like budgeting advice and food banks, cancelled the consumer advocacy council, cancelled our medicine regulations, repealed free prescriptions, deferred multiple hospital builds, failed to deliver on pre-election medical promises, reversed a gun ban created in response to the mosque shootings, brought back three strikes = life sentence policy, increased minimum wage by half the recommended amount, cancelled fair pay for disabled workers, reduced wheelchair services, reversed our oil and gas exploration ban, cancelled our climate emergency fund, cut science research funding including climate research, removed limits on killing sea lions, cut funding for the climate change commission, weakened our methane targets, cancelled Significant National Areas protections, have begun reversing our ban on live exports. Much of this was passed under urgency.

It’s been six months.