#sonic prime canon
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Sonic Prime Inconsistencies Part 1
Okay so I wanted to make this post to ramble about the inconsistencies or just straight up lore problems of Sonic Prime. While I get it is supposed to be more oriented towards kids, such a thing is not an excuse for simplistic story telling. In addition with the recent focus on Lore in recent Sonic games with the addition of a lore master, I find the inclusion of Sonic Prime to the canon of the games to be the big problem.
The whole if it doesn't contradict the games and unified canon thing. It would be alright if it wasn't canon though still frustrating. But one Logan McPherson, Takashi Iizuka, alongside others has confirmed it is supposed to be canon.
So my first problem is Sonic and I am not going to talk about his blabber mouth, yet. You see there is a problem with his power level, he is way too underpowered for at this point in the timeline. This Sonic will inconsistently smash through Eggforcers like they are your basic Badnik but then also having struggling with them fighting forever like this was a DBZ fight. The Eggforcers I would best describe as slightly beefed up Badniks, but still Sonic should not be having such a hard time with them.
Using characters like Shadow, Orbot, and Cubot as a way to set down a placement in the timeline. This would mean this Sonic whose struggling with slightly beefed up Badniks is the same one whose faced off against the Death Egg Robot, the Great Egg Robo, Perfect Chaos even fighting him in his base form, the Black Arms, Dark Gaia, etc. among all the various mechs and bosses in up until this point. However, if the claim Prime takes place in the far future, that means he would have been through even more up until Frontiers!!
My next problem is a nitpick but why is Birdie not only hanging out with Amy now but why are they pink? Birdie was blue in Sonic Adventure so why are they suddenly pink? Imma ask is to match up with Amy the pink female hedgehog? Because if so that is pretty questionable.
Part 2
#sonic prime#sonic the hedgehog#sonic#sonic lore#sonic canon#sonic prime inconsistencies#birdie#sonic prime birdie#sonic adventure birdie#eggforcer#pink birdie#blue birdie#amy#amy rose#sonic adventure#shadow the hedgehog#shadow#sonic prime sonic is weak#sonic prime sonic#orbot#cubot#orbot and cubot in sonic prime#perfect chaos#sonic generations#dark gaia#sonic unleashed#sonic prime is canon#sonic prime canon#sonic prime lore#sonic prime contradictions
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
Stylin'
6K notes
·
View notes
Text
It's been established that when Nine gets scared or feels threatened, he reacts by intimidation or anger, depending on the situation. It's his go-to instinct developed as a reaction to his trauma. As a way to protect himself.
And here, Nine is fucking terrified! He started hyperventilating, his pupils contracting with terror. The root cause of Nine's trauma was getting bullied and beaten up for years. All he wished for was for a safe, isolated place to call his own without having someone invading it.
And now, his greatest fear is coming true... His safe haven, his home, getting invaded by people who hold malicious intent for him.
Can you imagine the flashbacks he could've been having? The fear? The past coming to haunt him again, the thing he dreaded most coming back around to hurt him even worse. Can you imagine encountering the root of your trauma striking with a vengeance? And on your journey to try and heal from it no less.
He doesn't deserve this
#istg if canon doesn't let Nine have what he deserves. I'll fix it myself#sonic prime#sonic prime spoilers#sonic prime s3#sonic prime s3 spoilers#sonic prime season three#sonic prime season 3#sonic prime sonic#prime sonic#nine the fox#miles nine prower#tails nine#miles tails prower#sonic prime analysis
934 notes
·
View notes
Text
"help a brother up?" "we are not related." is a certified shadow autism moment btw
#sonic prime#sonic prime spoilers#the exchange being funny aside im kind of glad they had shadow say that#with the way they kept being compared to twins appearance wise#i was worried newer fans would get confused and come out of it thinking theyre Actually brothers or something#(canonically anyway. if you see them as brothers thats fine idc)
554 notes
·
View notes
Photo
new yoke sonic :^)
the palm tree is great and all, but what about the flickies?? in this backwards world, those little animals are his only friends, so he’s willing to do whatever it takes to protect them. when the chaos council took over, they were in great danger, and bullet made the tough choice to trade his freedom for their safety, acting as an enforcer on their behalf.
#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#sth#sonic prime#bullet#YIPPEE!!!!!#scribbles#reluctant villain sonic let's GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO bro#his ear is bent like an orca in captivity :)#i'm thinking there'd be a role reversal too like you know how in canon it's sonic who comes to tails' aid and that's how#they become friends well in this it'd probably be nine who (eventually) comes to bullet's aid#but in the meantime him and rusty fighting together? scary. the resistance definitely has their hands full lol
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
Sonic knows Nine is not Tails.
Tails is a happy, brainy, not so little fox, he likes beaches and technology, his favorite food are mint candies and he loves to tinker, and to fly with his twin tails. He has a lot of friends that care about him, and a big brother who loves him.
Nine is an angry, brainy, not so little fox, he doesn’t like hugs, he likes to build technology on his lab and he uses his nine tails to protect himself. He doesn’t have any friends, he is alone, the only person he can trust is himself.
Miles is a not so happy, but still brainy, little fox, he loves planes and technology, he has two tails, and he’s been beat up, bullied, and left out through all his short life because of that. He is smart and kind, he hasn’t done anything wrong, he is just a little different.
Sonic knows Nine is not Tails, but Nine is Miles, and Sonic loves Miles.
#miles tails prower#sonic the hedgehog#sonic#sonic and tails#sonic prime nine#sonic prime#practically canon headcanon
436 notes
·
View notes
Text
they have a point tho
and it’s the cold truth
#it’s sad but#yeah#sonic the hedgehog#shadow the hedgehog#sonic prime#sonic prime season 3#sonic#sonic prime spoilers#sonadow prime#sonic movie 3#sonic x shadow generations#sonic x#sa2#sonadow#spider man#spider man across the spider verse#canon events#maria robotnik#shadow the ultimate lifeform#testing out my new video editing skills#CapCut#mars edits
136 notes
·
View notes
Text
rouge >>>>>>>>
#rouge has never really been a favorite but theres something about how shes written or animated or designed that just clicked and i love her#so so much now#ive always loved her !! this one just hits different#struggled so much to make the pinks purples and blues work together tho .literal bisexual mess but it works somehow#personally a big fan of her bigger wings theres no way game canon rouge can fly insert bee movie script#sonic the hedgehog#sonic prime#rouge the bat#sth#doodles#this show will be the end of me
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
Hear me out
#Theyre literally the same#Like#i dont know how to explain#But they are#especially#prime sonic#prime sonic just gives wukong vibes ok#I dont make the vibe rules#God put us in different universes because he knew we would be unstoppable as canon besties#The sequel#sun wukong#wukong#monkey king#lmk#lego monkie kid#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#sonic prime
154 notes
·
View notes
Text
fantastic news for mdlhea fans
#SONADOW CANON IN FRENCH SPANISH AND PORTUGUESE ONLY!!!#sonadow#sonic prime#sonic prime spoilers#text#mdlhea
571 notes
·
View notes
Text
So, I noticed something, specifically about the Shadows
#sonic movie 3#You guys are getting paid?#meme#shadow the hedgehog#shadow#Sonic Boom#Sonic Prime#Project Shadow#Literally Movie!Shadow is able to be with Maria in her last moments from the trailer#Boom!Shadow? Doesn't have a fucking clue who Maria is nor does he know of the ARK#Prime!Shadow is in a similar boat - loosely implied that his origins are still canon to Prime but very loosely#meanwhile Shadow and Project!Shadow are both fuming#my contribution for the timebeing#an actual art piece will be made#this is just for fun
96 notes
·
View notes
Text
Inconsistencies Of Sonic Prime Part 4
Part 3
So Shadow using a Chaos Emerald is unaffected by the Paradox Prism with no explanation to why, but regardless just like Sonic this seems to have resulted in his lack of alternate versions of him. So with the Shatter Spaces most notably New Yolk seemingly being the Sonic world but different in the absence of Sonic wouldn't that have applied to Shadow as well?
In other words how does the Chaos Council exist without Shadow? The reason I say this is because it is now currently being heavily implied that the events of Space Colony and what happened to Maria, majorly impacted the Robotnik family. From there affecting Eggman possibly being a major cause for his villainy. So in the absence of Shadow and by extension Project Shadow shouldn't things have played out much differently?
#sonic prime inconsistencies#sonic prime lore#sonic prime canon#sonic prime#shadow the hedgehog#sonic prime shadow#shadow#sonic prime project shadow#project shadow#eggman's backstory#eggman's villiany#chaos council#maria#maria robotnik#robotnik#dr ivo robotnik#dr robotnik#dr eggman#eggman#chaos council motives#eggman's upbringing#chaos emeralds#chaos emeralds sonic prime#paradox prism#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#sonic lore#sonic canon#new yolk#space colony ark
32 notes
·
View notes
Text
( taken from sonadow wiki)
this might be the most crazy ive sounded but like i feel like something silly is going on…. like ok the sonadow bumblekast ian flynn stuff i still cant get over (basically he explained his take on sonadow and said it could work without changing the characters personalities) and that was the last day of pride month ya. but um.. 5 days before the first episode of sonic prime s2 releasing. on yt! 16 days before it will release fully..!! But um. i dunno i think something is goin on cuz with this thing i saw!! july,the tanabata festival…the celebration of the annual meeting of 2 separated lovers.. n what happened in the first episode of sonic prime s2 that was released in july..? what 2 characters were reunited..? hmmmmmmmmm
#sonadow#sonic prime#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#shadow the hedgehog#i sound crazy#but in my head i am smart#Believe me i never believed sonadow would actually become canon#for a lot of reasons#But.. i feel like something is gonna happen#also stilettos shadow bumblekast thumbnail i think was silly#if nothing happens ill just turn into dust ok
517 notes
·
View notes
Text
HELLO (TAILS) NINE NATION HOW R U FEELING????
yes i want to add more features to his design
#Sonic prime#nine sonic prime#miles tails prower#tails#tails sonic prime#OH LORD HE IS SO FERAL AND AGGRESSIVE SOMEONE CALM HIM DOW#i just love the fact that he canonically bristles and shows fangs as a sign of aggression#I LOVE HIM#my scrunkly
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
SONADOW ALERT!!!!
OMG
SONADOW EFFECT!!!!!!
#sonadow#sonic prime#shadow the hedeghog#sonic prime spoilers#sth#sonadow prime#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#I COULDN'T HELP BUT SCREAM ALL OVER THE SCENE.#fav#sonic prime s3#sonic prime season 3#sonic prime season 3 spoilers#I did wait for them to kiss each other...#sonic prime = sonadow is canon#sonic x shadow#shadow the hedgehog#shadow x sonic
219 notes
·
View notes
Text
Why Sonic Prime Shouldn’t Be Canon
There will be 0 disrespect to anyone involved in this post.
Introduction
Think whatever you want to think and make your own conclusions after reading this. Prime is an entertaining show. This is only for whoever wonders why I talk about this show a certain way. Yes, the consistency in the franchise is already shattered to pieces, (no pun intended) but the excuse implies the mistakes in the past shouldn’t be improved upon. Making things worst doesn’t fix anything. Also, give the franchise a little credit, there’s more obvious reasons to believe this show isn’t canon then stuff in the games and IDW.
Why Are We Told Prime Is Canon
1. The writer for the games/comics and the director stated Prime was canon. I assume in order to sell the show and make it seem more important than it is. That’s not even an insult because so far, Prime impacts nothing in canon.
Ian Flynn: “It doesn’t matter, b/c Prime wipes itself out. It’s something after Advance 3, but otherwise, it’s moot. I didn’t want to sour anyone’s expectations or investment by spoiling how Prime resolves, that’s all. If you enjoyed it, awesom. Savor it. If you didn’t, then you can safely ignore it. Simple as that.”
2. While I don’t remember who said this, it’s also been stated Prime went through changes. It was originally meant to be written as its own thing and hilariously ended up feeling less canon because of this change. Which you’ll probably notice in a bit. Long story short Sonic Prime, like the movies and shows, is a disposable adaptation you can love or hate.
3. Aside from Sonic and Shadow, you aren’t able to spend enough time with the OG cast or world, so you’d need to know and understand them outside of Prime. Which debatably isn’t enough, but that’s a can of worms I feel plenty have already opened up, so I’ll only simplify it later. In the end, the show never gets time to establish itself in the OG world. Which has a terrible impact on the writing, but let’s move on.
Side Note: No, the shatterverse crew don’t count in my opinion. While they are similar to the OGs they are still their own characters with separate personalities and issues in their own worlds. They are similar, but not the same.
Evidence
Prime feels more like an origin story without the continuity of the games.
Example 1: Green Hill is Sonic and his friend’s home. Despite the games and IDW have them live everywhere that isn’t Green Hill. Classic timeline included. They barely talk about the place. I recommend watching “Where The Heck Does Sonic Live?” on YouTube. If you want the short of it, I’ll explain a few points and add my own as well.
Here’s most of the different homes these characters lived in.
Station Square, the Mystic Ruins, Emerald Town, and others use to be homes they stayed in and they’re never mentioned. It’s like they put the modern cast into the classic timeline. Which still had them not live in Green Hill. Heck, Shadow, Rouge, and Big are shown in Green Hill too and they didn’t even exist during the classic era.
This is how Green Hill is seen in IDW.
Sure looks like people use to live in this place. Sarcasm aside, Green Hill either wasn’t special enough for them to keep living in or they never lived there before and this was conjured up because Green Hill is constantly used in the games.
Even people who knows the bare minimum about Sonic lore would understand how baloney this is. Especially since Sonic and the gang has been established to be found in other places. Which is shown in the Origin cutscenes. They don’t clarify in the show who exactly lives in Green Hill and who doesn’t. They treat it like everyone’s home. Shows how much we know about these characters within Sonic Prime, doesn’t it?
Example 2: No other group of Sonic characters, locations, or worlds are ever mentioned/referenced. In Prime the blue blur meeting Chaos!Sonic should’ve reminded him of Metal!Sonic, but he talks as if he’s never seen another version of himself in his life. “Is that a… knock off me?” The lack of robot knowledge in this show is crazy when given more errors.
“Robots without flickies? Now that’s new.” I believe everyone knows how false this line is. Also, Orbot and Cubot doesn’t exist until Colors. (though Orbot is in Unleashed) Which is a problem because Prime is suppose to take place directly after Advanced. Which had several games before Colors. Where they didn’t exist.
Example 3: The OG cast though similar, still have their differences.
Big: He’s treated like a core member of the team when he’s not in anything else. Bro doesn’t even get much to do or say at all. He’s just there for the most part.
Knuckles: He meets Sonic in a completely different setting then in actual canon and doesn’t seem to live on Angel Island for some reason. At least not by what was shown.
Eggman: Still relatively fine, but teaming up with anyone even himself never turns out well. He usually doesn’t care for sharing his spotlight.
Rouge: Same thing as Big besides Dream Team. In the games/comics she usually does her own thing. And is also more sneaky and unpredictable while Prime shows off her more leadership side. She’s kind of half and half in the same to different category.
Tails: Surprisingly more closed off then usual and almost seems to switch sides with Sonic in the personality department. Emotionally that is.
Amy: She’s more of a motherly figure than anything else. Amy’s bird friend is pink instead of blue like in SA1. They also treat it like it’s always been with her but hasn’t. She’s also incredibly calm and collected compared to how she was during the 2000s. The time the Advance games where coming out. She was written pretty differently to say the least.
Not to mention one line in the entire show is the only indication of Amy’s crush on Sonic. It was implied not shown.
Sonic: He’s almost treated as an amalgamation of different variations before him. Except it’s his first time getting into an issue he isn’t ready to handle. Because he caused it. On top of that, this guy also carries most of his friends emotional traits. Amys’ excitement, Tails’ saddens, and Knuckles’ anger. Here’s why.
Prime!Sonic seems to be naturally affectionate then in canon since he hugs almost everyone in it. He’s also more emotionally triggered, childish, and inexperience while Game!Sonic isn’t. And has never been shown to be either. Not even in the IDW comics or games with Classic!Sonic. A younger version of him. Don’t get me started on the differences to the 2000 games like Advanced. Game!Sonic then was more introverted while Prime!Sonic is very extroverted. He also panics a bunch. As if he’s not use to terrible things happening frequently.
He can be very wimpy and whiny when it comes to confrontations. Which was never a thing before in any other media. At least not to the point where he’s begging and pleading to people over and over again. I’ll even admit this Sonic isn’t the smartest either. He’s the Sonic you’d be the most convinced to believe is a teenage boy. Besides Movie!Sonic.
Of course Prime!Sonic is still Sonic, but he’s as much of a Sonic as every other version of him. He’s not the same guy who use to not be a fan of hugs. Who can deal with atrocities without freaking out once. The character who hasn’t even officially cried up to this point. Who is just now starting to open up and is still having trouble with it. The silly hedgehog isn’t too out of character but is enough to not be called the same character. Sure, Sonic’s characterization is inconsistent in the games, but I’d say the 2010s is less out of character and more one noted. He at least carries these traits even if not written well.
- The “sentimental” line in S1 Ep6 is one of the few out of character things he says. Even if the blue blur thought this, he’d never say it out loud.
Shadow: He’s the best written character in the show. Not to mention the most accurate to how he is in canon. Even compared to some of the games and comics. He’s the true MVP of Sonic Prime and has the most common sense. I only hate how he’s literally pushed to the curve in every season. And how Shadow’s backstory is never referenced. Only implied by Sonic screaming his name when he plummets to his doom. But I’d argue that’s more so because Shadow is the last person left who isn’t implied to be dead. Sure, it reminds people of SA2, but that’s all it really is. A reminder not a direct reference.
I will clarify I don’t dislike the show for being different. I dislike the show calling itself canon despite it’s differences.
Conclusion
I know Prime “wipes itself out” but the original world doesn’t have the same continuity of the games either. The established world and lore in Prime is barely connected to the Games due to the writing, so wiping the shatterverse out doesn’t help. These may be small details but if you’re a person who might be interested in getting into the fandom it becomes small details that makes big differences.
I’m not saying if you think the show is canon you’re wrong. Actually you are 100% correct. It’s been confirmed multiple times and the deed was already done. I just don't think it should be. Does it really matter? It depends on what you think. Is Sonic Prime being canon a bad thing? I’d say yes and no. While I don’t think it was the best move, as long as Sonic Prime exists on its own, there’s nothing to worry about. Prime being canon isn’t a crime. It just makes no sense. I’ll leave it at that.
Stay Creative! 💜
#If you’ve read through this all I hope what I said somewhat made sense#sonic the hedgehog#sth#sonic prime#prime!sonic#tails the fox#miles tails prower#amy rose hedgehog#amy rose#amy rose the hedgehog#knuckles the echidna#knuckles#prime!shadow#big the cat#rouge the bat#shadow the hedgehog#shadow the ultimate lifeform#movie sonic#sonic wachowski#orbot and cubot#sonic orbot#metal sonic#green hill zone#sonic idw#sonic battle#sonic advance#sonic adventure 2#sonic canon#sonic franchise#slight rant
77 notes
·
View notes