#Anti evan rosier

[loserboyfriendrjl]

marauders era unpopular opinions, once more

i really don’t like fanon regulus. i don’t like him being helpless and kind and a sirius variant. he’s morally grey, leaning towards morally dark, he’s selfish, he agreed to his parents’ and voldemort’s ideologies, having joined the death eaters most likely by his own will (unlike draco malfoy). but obviously, everyone is allowed to characterise characters the very way they want to

and while we’re on it, i don’t like evan and barty either, for the same reason. maybe i would, if they were realistically characterised (i LOVE reading morally grey or morally dark(er) characters), and once again, i believe that just because one likes a character, that doesn’t always mean that the character is a good person

and continuing on the same topic, the sunshine james potter, although being a topic that i like and delved deeper into myself, is nice, but i would also love to see more of arrogant, spoiled james potter, too

not liking severus snape and peter pettigrew but liking evan, barty and regulus is kind of hypocritical

i don’t like jegulus

i also don’t like the casanova, bad boy characterisation of remus, and the helpless, needy characterisation of sirius either. to me, they’re out of character, overly done and absolutely not enjoyable

and because i earlier mentioned severus snape, i think he’s an interesting character, actually. that doesn’t make him a good person (once again, i believe him to be morally grey, too) and i can’t call myself a lover of his, however i find his story and character very interesting and compelling

i don’t like a lot of the wolfstar dynamics in current fandom

“we need more content about the girls!” literally do it yourself. please. whenever i write content about the men, i get a wave of new followers, and whenever i post about the non-men, suddenly i have tebs of people unfollowing me. oh, and my posts about the men have twice or thrice the notes of the other ones

sirius > regulus

and speaking of which, sirius is such an interesting character, and he was reduced by many people to nothing, or whatever is relevant to the plot

james would pick sirius over regulus any time, with literally no hesitation

i don’t care about popular fics (read or don’t read, i generally don’t read popular fics to be honest), however i do care about the way creators, especially writers, are treated in this fandom. i made a few posts about this topic, feel free to ask me to link them to you, but the way some people feel entitled to fic and fandom content is horrible

“x is the female version of— !” please stop. i’m going to stop you right here.

stop tagging jegulus and wolfstar and other mlm ships with wlw and nmlnm tags, for god’s sake. you’re just clogging the tag, and if i came looking for a certain ship, that’s what i’m going to expect to find. besides, why would you tag jegulus with, say, pandalily, when jegulus is by far more popular?

jegulus < jily

[alexandriastark76]

“Imagine how Barty felt masquerading as the man who killed his lover?” He didn’t feel babygirl, he was busy torturing Neville’s parents to insanity to hold Rosier’s body and sob his heart out.

The babygirlification of death eaters is insane, and the double standards <<<

When the Marauders do it, it’s cool and nice and the fandom was built on headcanons so we can do whatever the hell we want

But when other part of the fandom does it (*ahem ahem* Snapedom *ahem ahem*) it’s stan Bambi and he bullied kids (yeah Barty did what exactly? Dance the Macarena on tabletops cause Neville was traumatised?), and he is an irredeemable monster (knowing damn well that Crouch Jr. had hands in the resurrection of Voldemort)

[strawbxx-blog]

Hate when I'm putting up a well constructed argument to defend my favr character with canon but they read all that and still go"have you ever actually read the books 🤓☝️?"yes yes i have.have you though?cause I don't remember regulus black/Barty crouch jr being a cute sarcastic feminist fighting alongside the marauders in the books huh

[suncchaser]

I find it insane how it's primarily the fans of canon Death Eaters, who have created completely deluded fanon versions of bigots, that have the most to say about Dumbledore. Imagine sitting here whitewashing terrorists while blaming a man for things he never did.

Also, repeat with me: IT WAS NOT DUMBLEDORE'S RESPONSIBILITY TO STOP YOUR UWU BABIES FROM BECOMING TERRORISTS! AND HE NEVER FORCED ANYONE TO JOIN THE ORDER! ALL ORDER MEMBERS WERE OVER 17 AND ENTERED WILLINGLY!

[snape-fans]

Okay, but can we talk about how Marauders fans have questionable things? Example: They hate Snape but love Regulus, Evan, Barty. The cules are much worse than severus

Or that they say that Snape's friends are bad, when the marauders were too. Another example: Lily and Remus said that James liked to practice spells on children

The Marauders were not self-centered: Yes, they were. No matter how much they doubt it, they were.

"Regulus has a better story than Snape" No, he doesn't. He's just a Death Eater and he died, he has no history.

"James changed" James I don't even think he would have changed, he did everything for Lily not by his will. And I'm sure he would have continued to bother Snape if he were alive. Example: Sirius was still bothering Snape as an adult, Sirius and James are the same shit. What makes you think James changed?

"Severus deserved everything the Marauders and his father did to him" yes, I've also seen those comments on TikTok. That's disgusting, really disgusting.

"Lily didn't even laugh at Snape's joke." I know, but I was going to do it. In the books you can see how Lily almost laughs or smiles. He is your friend and maybe in such a situation you don't laugh or you just say stop. You intervene!

I was wrong about Mary and Dorcas. Excuse me

[bi-peanut]

I'm so done with the new marauders fandom.

[urmumsgyatt]

i immediately trust anyone who’s anti slytherin with my life, i just KNOW they’re the most politically safe people in the hp/marauders fandom

[hp-confessions]

i hate how certain less prominent male characters like barty, regulus and evan rosier have been fully developed by the fandom but female characters we see more like the black sisters get so much less attention from the fans. i just feel like if they were three brothers instead they’d have the fandom in a chokehold :(

~

[albi-bumblebee]

idk if youve already explained this or (i dont think so?? im sorry if you have 😞) but uhh why do you hate evan (and marlene?) . is it bc they dont have canon personalities?

it’s not entirely because they have no canon personalities 😅 i like emmeline and caradoc, and they have no canon personalities. the thing about those two is that people routinely give them the same status as canon characters when that’s not the case, and the fanon surrounding them both is much more annoying than the one with lets say mary macdonald.

with evan rosier, it’s mostly that i think it’s a shame he’s who barty’s popularly shipped with when i think there are choices that actually make sense(like rabastan or peter), but also that he gets that generic “sarcastic boy who was forced to be a deatheater” thing that originated with draco 😅 but also that i hate the way people try to connect the lovegood family with the death eaters(what xeno did in book 7 feels like it is minimized by hcing stuff like that). i think it was originally people hcing xeno as a malfoy it’s just that rosier pandora is more popular nowadays. with marlene, i feel like people acting like she is anything more than a character mentioned literally four times at most in the series is worse because she was also popular in the og marauders fanon. dead gay wizards people act like you’re a misogynistic homophobe for not particularly caring about her or not shipping her with a woman, and modern blackinnon shippers act like they’re being oppressed for liking a het ship and like their mid ship is a lost treasure. fanon marlene is also just deeply uninteresting anyway(she’s usually just the same as fanon sirius but a woman in my experience.)

i officially became a hater when i saw someone say that sirius canonically got marlene pregnant.

it’s chill if you like these characters my opinions aren’t the end all be all of things. :)

[marauders-fandom-confessions]

marauders era girls are just so underrated man.

lily is just smart and perfect, either james' gf or jegulus' enemy. as jegulus popped up, marylily/marlily got more popular too. almost as if people think the girls should always be paired off...

mary is just a popular girl (who's shipped with marlene or lily)

marlene is girl sirius, shipped with mary or dorcas.

dorcas: slytherin girl.

pandora: evan's spacey twin sister.

"oh but theyre based on like 3 lines the boys have more based off them" what about the skittles boys? they also have little mention in the books, yet barty and evan have so much content about them and their trauma or friendships w the other skittles. they have a more defined personality than the girls despite having been in the fandom for less time.

like im not being anti ship here. but nobody creates content about the girls' friendships. when you see them it's always shipping (with one of the guys or with each other) or friendships with the guys (lily and remus, marlene and sirius, pandora and evan)

this indicates that a LOT of people in this fandom only think the girls have a place/value in a romantic relationship............ idk guys

…

[demonic-ninja-cat]

I finally got around to deleting my old Harry Potter sideblog

TBH most of that sideblog was just shitting on Snape(and also i was a Marauders fan, before they started woobifying the wizard fascists and pairing James with Sirius' racist little brother and shitting on Lily), but even that started to feel uncomfortable, with all of the shit that JK TERFling has done.

So, I deleted it once and for all! Harry Potter hasn't brought me joy in a while, and all I do lately is talk about how awful the bigotry is in it and how horribly the nonhuman races where handled(especially the House-Elves oh my fucking god),

and i can do that with the occasional main-blog post without having a whole blog dedicated to talking about that awful show, so adios old blog! and fuck jk rowling i hope she gets unalived painfully!

Also fuck HP, and especially fuck Hogwarts Legacy(aka Blood Libel: The Game), and fuck anyone who thinks a stupid shitty game/book/movie is more important than trans people's lives!

[xixovart]

oh “starchaser this” “bartylus that” regulus black is aromantic-asexual and agender.

[annabellelupin]

people: *romanticize literal fucking murderers*

me: .... you do realize they're an absolutely terrible person right??

people: um well they're fictional and hot so its fine

me: *blinks intensely*

[loserboyfriendrjl]

why is it hypocritical to like barty and not to care about peter?

i like (canon) barty because he’s completely unhinged in his doing for cause he chose to believe from quite young age and he stood by his beliefs until the end. (id like to say, i like him in the moments he had in the story, apart from them, i don’t care about his character)

and i don’t care about peter because he’s too much of a coward for me to like him. it’s not even about the betrayal although the reason why he switched sides was never provided. yes, it could have been out of fear, but he stayed on voldemort side by his own choice and he could have believed in pureblood agenda since the beginning but it was never mentioned.

and snape, well, he’s interesting character, not really pleasant, but he’s interesting. i feel like his potential was bigger that jk writing skills.

now, i will repeat, i like neither evan, barty, and regulus, at least the fandom version, nor snape (i don’t like post 1981 peter either, but right now i’m not talking about him), but this is just my two cents.

(also, your reasoning is valid, i am now talking mostly about the fandom’s attitude towards evan, barty and regulus being death eaters, in comparison to snape and peter)

it’s mainly because of pretty privilege, in this case, that’s what i think, because think of it like this:

this fandom made evan, barty and regulus (people who have little to no canon personality (this is mainly referring to regulus and evan, who were literally dead before the series started), but barty does have a canon personality and he’s definitely interesting), conventionally attractive, and now, because of being conventionally attractive or because of any other reason, they’re characters that this fandom loves very dearly, despite being death eaters.

however, with snape and peter, who have both been described as either ugly or unconventionally attractive (leaning towards the first one, actually), this fandom has a far different approach to them being death eaters. i honestly think that the best example i could give you is how marauders stans go on tiktok, find snape edits, and then go out of their way to comment “stan bambi” on many of them.

again, this is towards their attitude towards them being death eaters, not generally speaking, and everyone is more than welcomed to have their own opinions on this topic. this is purely just my thoughts.

[snape-fans]

okay, I was browsing TikTok and saw a post. And the comments, "why wouldn't I hate Snape? He's arrogant and stuff like that." And it is bad and many things. to which I commented "there is also Bellatrix, Regulus, Barty, Evan, Tom" OH MY GOD. They jumped on me and justified them (more regulus) we already saw the canon, they are death eaters, why do they still think they are good?

[witchygfsgf]

i hate hate hate this fandom rn. why is it a hot take to say that terrorists and racists aren't sexy??? i thought that was normal??