#anti rosekiller

[theflorasdiary]

Do you know who hate women more than men?

Women that ship a (non canon)gay couple and there’s also a girl in the picture(the canon girlfriend/wife/love interest of one of the male characters).

[deathnguts]

I need an endgame Bartylus fic where James is the toxic ex to Regulus as reparations for the sheer amount of slander on Barty Crouch Junior’s name in fanfic

Like I know Barty is crazy, but SO IS REGULUS ANSNEJND.

Jegulus being a toxic past relationship makes sense (don’t gun me down) because James is just too warm and vanilla for Regulus, I can see him like unknowing guilt tripping Regulus to be someone else (someone James views as nicer and better) while dating him.

AND THEN BARTY CAN COME IN AND BE LIKE ‘THATS FUCKED BE YOUR CRAZY SELF’

And they kiss and live happily ever after the end

[beefmcgee]

There is something that makes me feel nauseous about the new marauders era fans (but this is just generally a Harry Potter fan problem) is like, fascist apologia.

Because like, fiction is fiction. I'm not going to pretend it is real. I love evil characters. Characters don't have to be morally pure, or even morally good, to be compelling and interesting and worth writing about. Concurrently, the broad trend of babygirlifying men, fascist men in particular, concerns me.

Regulus is not baby girl. Barty Crouch Jr. is ABSOLUTELY not baby girl. You can write interesting and compelling stories about them as characters without making them into soft men who didn't really mean it uwu. They were bigots, canonically. They were fascists! You can talk about their upbringings and what drove them to fascism! You can say they were abused and hurt! That doesn't mean they weren't fascists who wanted to inflict pain on others. And I think it's a weird trend to ignore that or water it down or justify it.

And this is just petty, but I don't understand jegulus or rosekiller. I'll accept rosekiller because it's so meaningless to me that I'm only actually bothered by the babygirlification of the main characters, but I genuinely don't see any appeal to jegulus. Not really hating on it, just confused. Like, the things that I think make James Potter interesting and good are his loyalty to his friends and his anti-bigotry thing. Without those, he's an arrogant, popular prankster who is mean. I think jegulus kind of changes those interesting characteristics unless it's AU or OOC. It kind of seems to me people are looking for James to be gay and trying to find any man, and Snape and Peter are less sexy and liked. Which, I guess is fine. It just doesn't bring anything to me.

But also most of my Harry Potter headcanons would make people side eye me. Regardless, fight me.

[albi-bumblebee]

idk if youve already explained this or (i dont think so?? im sorry if you have 😞) but uhh why do you hate evan (and marlene?) . is it bc they dont have canon personalities?

it’s not entirely because they have no canon personalities 😅 i like emmeline and caradoc, and they have no canon personalities. the thing about those two is that people routinely give them the same status as canon characters when that’s not the case, and the fanon surrounding them both is much more annoying than the one with lets say mary macdonald.

with evan rosier, it’s mostly that i think it’s a shame he’s who barty’s popularly shipped with when i think there are choices that actually make sense(like rabastan or peter), but also that he gets that generic “sarcastic boy who was forced to be a deatheater” thing that originated with draco 😅 but also that i hate the way people try to connect the lovegood family with the death eaters(what xeno did in book 7 feels like it is minimized by hcing stuff like that). i think it was originally people hcing xeno as a malfoy it’s just that rosier pandora is more popular nowadays. with marlene, i feel like people acting like she is anything more than a character mentioned literally four times at most in the series is worse because she was also popular in the og marauders fanon. dead gay wizards people act like you’re a misogynistic homophobe for not particularly caring about her or not shipping her with a woman, and modern blackinnon shippers act like they’re being oppressed for liking a het ship and like their mid ship is a lost treasure. fanon marlene is also just deeply uninteresting anyway(she’s usually just the same as fanon sirius but a woman in my experience.)

i officially became a hater when i saw someone say that sirius canonically got marlene pregnant.

it’s chill if you like these characters my opinions aren’t the end all be all of things. :)

[marauders-fandom-confessions]

marauders era girls are just so underrated man.

lily is just smart and perfect, either james' gf or jegulus' enemy. as jegulus popped up, marylily/marlily got more popular too. almost as if people think the girls should always be paired off...

mary is just a popular girl (who's shipped with marlene or lily)

marlene is girl sirius, shipped with mary or dorcas.

dorcas: slytherin girl.

pandora: evan's spacey twin sister.

"oh but theyre based on like 3 lines the boys have more based off them" what about the skittles boys? they also have little mention in the books, yet barty and evan have so much content about them and their trauma or friendships w the other skittles. they have a more defined personality than the girls despite having been in the fandom for less time.

like im not being anti ship here. but nobody creates content about the girls' friendships. when you see them it's always shipping (with one of the guys or with each other) or friendships with the guys (lily and remus, marlene and sirius, pandora and evan)

this indicates that a LOT of people in this fandom only think the girls have a place/value in a romantic relationship............ idk guys

…

[elysian-writing]

💛 ?

'what is a popular ship you just can't get behind, and why?' gonna have to go with rosekiller. i can see platonic rosekiller and rosestarkiller and just about any other dynamic but romantic rosekiller has just never interested me. i think it's because the ship tends to reduce the both of them to very basic, one dimensional characters while also twisting the characters actions and sometimes romanticising them? ( eg. barty killing moody for evan )

[demonic-ninja-cat]

I finally got around to deleting my old Harry Potter sideblog

TBH most of that sideblog was just shitting on Snape(and also i was a Marauders fan, before they started woobifying the wizard fascists and pairing James with Sirius' racist little brother and shitting on Lily), but even that started to feel uncomfortable, with all of the shit that JK TERFling has done.

So, I deleted it once and for all! Harry Potter hasn't brought me joy in a while, and all I do lately is talk about how awful the bigotry is in it and how horribly the nonhuman races where handled(especially the House-Elves oh my fucking god),

and i can do that with the occasional main-blog post without having a whole blog dedicated to talking about that awful show, so adios old blog! and fuck jk rowling i hope she gets unalived painfully!

Also fuck HP, and especially fuck Hogwarts Legacy(aka Blood Libel: The Game), and fuck anyone who thinks a stupid shitty game/book/movie is more important than trans people's lives!

[sunnysaystuff]

not to be a hater but rosekiller bores me😬😬 it's also weird to me that we have hot people like andromeda and narcissa black but we choose to characterize evan rosier instead??? like who is this guy anyways... and why is barty always the dumbinsane one while evan is levelheaded and smart...my boy barty got 12 owls don't do him like that (that's why bitchkiller is such a fire ship shoutout to bitchkiller shippers yall like to make smart weirdos kiss and im here for it)

like we get it, it's really hot and unique to ship two crazy people together like wowewww ur so original!! but me personally i think we could do better����‍♀️🤷‍♀️ instead of giving life to yet another basic tiktok white boy we could actually explore barty's Actual Established Canonical self or smth??? manic nerd works for me just maybe don't strip him of all possible complexity so u can put him in a cute little box in the back of your mind and then decide to spontaneously attack people who don't also want to put him in that box :/

(people who don't go along with the accepted fanon for barty get so much hate it's actually mindboggling)

anyways rant over in conclusion be less boring

[wolfstar-supremacy41]

I feel like one of the most problematic thing about the marauders fandom is making characters bi/pan and then just shipping them with the same gender. Like, there are so many characters like James/Lily/Remus/Barty/Dorcas/Mary etc who are headcannoned as Bi/Pan only to put them in a homosexual relationship. Yes, being Bi/pan means attraction to 2 or more/All genders respectively, but those genders also include the OPPOSITE gender.

Whats the point of making charecters Bi or Pan if their opposite sex attraction isn't even recognized. Thats just making them gay or lesbian and then claiming they are Bi or Pan for brownie points.

Example: I am pan myself and I love Pansexual James, but pansexuals can be attracted to the opposite genders, so James can just be with Lily and be Pan at the same time🙃

No need to put him in a relationship with a dude to prove he is pan

[theflorasdiary]

Being called homophobic from shippers of non canon mlm couples,meanwhile they fetishized gay people and sees them as objects of their own fantasies and not real people.Treating women as baby machines,forcing sexuality on people and stripping down their traits to adjust them to their ship.

And then they go:“But the author and the character never said they were straight!😡”

The same character that only had girlfriends/have a wife and kids/has only been interested and sexually attracted to women.

[albi-bumblebee]

every single ‘rosekiller’ post i’ve seen on this website has made me want to rip out my hair and scream “you people know nothing about bcj”

[annabellelupin]

I swear I'll post actual content that isn't just me ranting about things I hate in the fandoms im in eventually but first I really need to know if the marauders fandom is finally over the whole death eater thing with characters like rosier and Barty. please tell me the fandom is no longer worshipping irredeemable murders anymore

[mercurygoldfish]

guys i hate rosekiller It's disgusting

[sunnysaystuff]

evan rosier is no one to me btw. some incel friend of snape's. boring as all hell

[glacierberries]

rosekiller makes me gag

[starsmacabray]

“how can you hate snape but love barty crouch jr?”

first of all snape isn’t cunty OR babygirl