Reasons that are obvious why Jasmine and Ryan are not a good relationship:
The only time we ever hear Jasmine speak, it is her being afraid of Andrew Ryan. The fact that she knows her actions, despite being unintentional, will result in something that clearly causes her a lot of fear and stress indicates not only his poor morals but also his lack of respect of her.
She never, in the several years she has known him, calls him anything aside from "Mr. Ryan". This is a very formal way to refer to someone, especially if you have known someone for a very long time and are supposed to be as close as they are. Did Jasmine choose to do this herself, or did Andrew Ryan never allow her to refer to him as anything else to show the distance he holds with her? The "respectability" and "formality" indicate something detached, a very clear gap between them. Diane McClintock is heard calling him "Andrew", so this would reveal that he views and approaches Diane differently than Jasmine.
When he finds out her honest mistake, a mistake I'm sure she never fully understood (I can't imagine the 1940s boasted good sex health education), he does something I'm sure many would think out of character for him, at least in regards to his well-known, self-crafted image of a suave, refined intellectual. He savagely murders her. No talking, no trying to find another solution. He decides in that moment (whether a "crime of passion" or not) that she deserves to die for her mistake, no matter what she says to him or how she pleads for him to stop. In that moment, her life meant nothing to him, and he took it from her, as if he had the right to choose whether she lived or died. To him, she had to pay for betraying him, even though she never would've done anything to hurt him before. The very moment she tries to step free of him and be on her own, he takes her life.
My headcanon is that she met Andrew Ryan young, which I think we can infer from her story, or at least she was in a difficult position when she met him. Women were paid less than men (they still are; fight me if you want), and she found herself stuck in her career as she only made it to the esteemed Sander Cohen's gallery of chorus girls. Ryan already offered to help her once. Jasmine trusted him because she believed his intentions towards her were more honorable, that he did genuinely care about seeing her become successful. Maybe, for a time, that was true. But I don't think it lasted very long, especially since Cohen most likely knew of Ryan's interest in Jasmine and became jealous, set to hamper her chances of rising any higher than that. Cohen probably told Ryan that Jasmine didn't have the right stuff to achieve her goals. Ryan and Cohen obviously respect each other enough that I'm sure Ryan would've listened to him. Cohen obliterated her chance of ever having Ryan's respect by hiring her as a stripper. He knew this, knew Ryan well enough that if he did this, Ryan would never take Jasmine seriously, never see her as anything aside from a sex object.
EDIT: additional point. It is also obvious, I think, that he treated her with a lot of suspicion. I mean, following his attack, he cruelly and harshly calls her a whore. I can't imagine that was the first time he ever did that. Most people know that there is a common suspicion around sexual women. And, seeing their dynamic, she accepted his help with trust, and he saw it as more transactional, i mean- ugh. Just ugh. Edit to the edit: ALSO that shows he had no remorse for killing her! There is never a point where he ever shows any regret or sorrow for doing that to her!!!!
1 note
·
View note