#may i say: fucking impressive
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Nobody does it like Italy: in the top 6 for 6 consecutive years*🍝
//
2017 - Gabbani, Occidentali's karma (6°)
2018 - Meta and Moro, Non mi avete fatto niente (5°)
2019 - Mahmood, Soldi (2°)
2021 - Måneskin, Zitti e buoni (1°)
2022 - Mahmood and Blanco, Brividi (6°)
2023 - Marco Mengoni, Due vite (4°)
*except for 2020, because of 'rona ✨
#nobody else has done this#not even 6 consecutive top 10#may i say: fucking impressive#eurovision#sanremo#escita#eurovision song contest#italian tag#esc#esc ita#eurovision 2023#francesco gabbani#ermal meta#fabrizio moro#mahmood#blanco#pure#diodato#anche se non ha partecipato ufficialmente#måneskin#marco mengoni
138 notes
·
View notes
Text
I saw this from the female separatism subreddit & the responses are some of the biggest reasons for separatism et al (or extinction if I'm being candid here). Moids cant be reformed they are fully aware of the hell they force women to live in. MaIe achievement & happiness is rooted in female exploitation & life. Their glory days are based on our horrific days. No amount of love, kindness or facts will change maIes and we cannot happily or even neutrally coexist with them.
Main points across answers:
Many want to experiment but not permanently be women
They dont want to be in constant danger or lose their autonomy at the hands of maIes for merely existing
They dont want to deal with childbirth (& periods)
They dont want to have to share spaces with species much stronger than them with ulterior motives
It makes me go crazy seeing people give moids benefit of doubt for their evil like "maIes just dont understand", "we need to teach maIes", or claiming that maIe violence is a result of maIes struggling with (expressing) their feelings. I get that women love maIes and it can be hard to imagine that people can intentionally be so evil but it is what it is. MaIes have no problems expressing themselves, abusing women is what maIes choose to do because they enjoy & benefit from it - that is their expression.
MaIes see the same news of women being abused, raped, and killed like we do except rather than be disheartened or alarmed they're either apathetic or satisfied. It isn't aliens that's committing GBV it's maIes & maIes have no problem reminding women of this when women anger them (such as rape threats & threatening women they'll end up on the news/true crime). The victim blaming, denial, and derailment of misogyny is part of the game to keep the system alive, they know the events occured & are a systemic occurence they just dont care. Hell not only do they not care, they rejoice in it or get off on it.
MaIes set up environments that work in their favour which simultaneously ensures that women will lose. They know women are set up to live in damn near impossible conditions for us. It's normalised for women to defenselessly share personal & private spaces with beings much more stronger than them with ulterior motives for us, it's trap. It's interesting how these moids aren't saying that they'll just cover up and *poof* harrassment gone, or they'll just pick a nice guy & they'll be okay. MaIes know the net negative they are towards women.
MaIes know that childbirth is a painful process & what do they do? Demand it happens and make it even MORE painful for women. MaIes that impregnate women do not love or care for them. Pregnancy itself is dangerous & sometimes lethal, often comes with a range of health issues, to cause someone to be in that condition especially in a environment where abortions are illegal is reckless & unloving. Now imagine how sinister & full of hatred one has to be to impregnate someone and abuse them on top of that. Many women risk their health & lives to reproduce with a Y and they get abused by said Y instead of being taken care of. Deranged.
Realising that maIes are aware of the evil they inflict is one of the things that radicalised me. It isn't a miscommunication or ignorance issue, their violence is intended. They want control. The cruelty is the point. Instead of wasting time & energy trying to change maIes or hope that they "understand" one day, focus on yourself & other women (who prioritise women). Moids aren't oblivious to female pain they enjoy it. A lot of women treat maIe evil like it's a mistake on maIes part but it's calculated terrorism. I know that this will go over many womens heads as they refuse to hold strong negative sentiments about moids as a collective so if you're not a woman like that, take this post as a sanity check. You aren't crazy, it isn't all in your head.
#Will women listen to any of this? Nope. But I will still speak anyways.#I say all of this as an osawoman so attraction is not an excuse. The time for reconciliation & reform has long gone.#And stop fucking creating more maIes ffs#While many women are under the impression that moids are clueless about our oppression; some want to believe so bc they dont want to come#to terms with evil moids actually are. Because if you want to reproduce or have a positive relationship w/ moids theres no way you can#consciously do that bearing in mind what moids are so many women push it away. Anyways#blackpill feminism#blackpill feminist#female separatism#female separatist#males know what they're doing they just dont care#radical feminism#radical feminist#feminism#moids are terrorists#feminist
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
oscar: (*random priest who seems fairly sweet and helps people as much as he can*)
me: okay seems reasonable
oscar: (*reveals that as a kid he bashed a priest's face in with a hammer for bullying/murdering his friend*)
me: (*dimming the lights and lighting candles*) COME HERE LOVERBOY-
#my outloud reaction was me saying “oh OSCAR”#in the same tone of voice john uses to say “oh ARTHUR” when he's like deeply impressed and also very turned on about it#like ngl i went from being like “wow he's cool!” to “i nEED to fuck him”#i love sweet characters who are capable of/have committed tremendous acts of violence#bc that means the sweetness and kindness is a very conscious decision#and that should you cross them. well. let's just say you may not live to see the sun rise.#malevolent#malevolent pod#oscar malevolent#an eldritch being and his wet cat#malevolent spoilers
46 notes
·
View notes
Text
Fuck it, Emilia Perez is going to win Best Comedy/Musical, isn't it? Jeeezzzz.
I think Conclave is going to win for Drama and while that wasn't my prediction I really enjoyed that movie so I'm not complaining on that front.
#I haven't even seen The Brutalist yet so I predicted it on buzz alone (I[m seeing it next week when it comes to my city) but I definitely#would not be upset about Conclave doing well#lior liveblogs awards season#Emilia Perez....ugh#I know why the Europeans like it but it definitely did not go over as well in the Americas#and I say Americas and not America/USA bc it is.....well...obviously a French person's weirdly romanticized yet also condescending view of#Mexico. I'm not Mexican or of Mexican descent so I'm not going to speak for anyone from that backgroudn who may like that movie#but it is definitely the kind of thing that Europeans who assume they know more about this hemisphere than they do would like and also a lo#of weird fucking shit with the trans character#(I am not going to go SO far as to say actively transphobic but definitely fumbled) that gives me a headache#so hereeee we are#but honestly my main issue with the movie is the music sucked#and most of the voices were mid#Garcon and Saldana are such great actresses that they were engaging but I can't do with musicals with mid vocals#and especially mid songs#I can sit through mid musical plots if the songs are good and while the El Mal scene is great in that it is a really entertaining scene#bc of Zoe Saldana's dancing and performance in general I'm just not impressed with the movie's music#or what it thinks is its message#ugh all this wanting for the US awards circuit to get more international and actually the Europeans voting for this thing (which is who is#voting for it based on international critics circles) at the Globes are actually kinda annoying me for once
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
i will give skyrim props for making both sides of the civil war acutely unlikeable
#voxbox#skyrim#my characters may have loyalties one way or the other and i follow through on that but i seethe with hate in real life the whole time#stormcloaks put the work in i will say. my initial impression was Fuck The Empire because 'let's execute this person to save time#on paperwork' is one hell of a look at how the Empire conducts itself. then i visited windhelm for the first time
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
Had a really stupid conversation via minor emotional breakdown with a queer friend about what makes an LGBTQ person 'assimilist'. From what she said I'm kind of forced to draw the conclusion 'if you say you're not assimilist, then you're not'.
#i love her but none of it makes any sense to me#i think i really just wanted her to see that this kind of rhetoric is no good if you're fundamentally unable to see yourself as having valu#to a community- which is where i'm still at sometimes unfortunately.#i would say that i may not be the only one since mental illness + self esteem issues + being lgbtq are not exactly unlinked#but i have basically never found anyone else who has my particular hangups...maybe online once ages ago#so in my own mind i'm the most assimilist lgbtq who ever existed- not even worthy to call myself queer#and it's nice that she thinks i am not like that and in fact am 'one of the good ones'#who is not assimilist- look i know that 'one of the good ones' usually means the opposite ok i know! it's just an impression i get#she's like telling me obviously i'm all good because i look like i do but all i can hear is#that if i didn't look like this then i'm an assimilist#i fucking hate my brain honestly no one asked me to have a mental breakdown at their house (thank god i didn't cry)#and then go home and that's when i cry because i saw a trans guy's 'this many years on t' post and i felt like shit because#i haven't done anything about transitioning in ages and i'm not even out at work :'(#like i know i'm an assimilist because my main reason for not coming out at work is not wanting to do the beaurocracy#of changing my name on my email and every fucking log in i have on everything- telling every single person i interact with#i just can't it's too much and my line manager is worse than useless#but i have 'my job is computer and doing emails all day' privilege so i don't like to talk to people about it
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
When I finally get a second to sit down-- i sill be ridding that Female-Shuro x Laios train until my heart is satisfied
#some ppl may think 'fem!shuro was probs complaining about Laios to Falin and Marcille' in the mirror strip#But imo fem!shuro is admitting she thinks Laios proposed to her#Marcille is like HUUUH?? HIM??? PROPOSE...??#While Falin is like oh god... what the fuck did my brother say to give this poor girl that impression + he is NOT marriage material#So now I want flustered fem!shuro looking at Laios doing basic ass shit like Shuro does for falin in canon#And I think she's gonna fall in the loop of thinking Laios is a brave warrior#the same way Laios thinks Shuro is sooo cool.*closes my diary*#text
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
i hate them with a passion
#this may turn into one of my long ass posts with hundreds of screenshots of quotes from the books#but i dont have the energy for that just now#anyway. this moment makes me wanna throw shit at the walls. their relationship is my favourite thing from the very beginning#but dumas went really went out of his way to make it even more insane in the last book#and dont hit me with a 'aww they have such a big/little brother energy its so cute uwu' please im begging you stop saying that#nothing irks me more than hearing their relationship described as something that innocent. its so much more complex and intense come on#there is pure visceral hate there. jealousy. bile. cruelty. some fucked up form of codependency even? maybe? from d'artagnan's side?#there's nothing more horrible and cruel than the fact that THEY are the only two left alive in the end (not for long but yknow)#they would NEVER be friends if not for athos (and they would never hate each other so much if not for him too)#they hate each other so so much. but remember that d'artagnan starts out being absolutely bedazzled by aramis and looking up to him#his first impression of aramis is just. hearteyes and 'wow i wish that were me'. he doesnt do that even with athos at first.#he grows to adore athos yes but upon first meeting him he doesnt think much of him. unlike with aramis.#and then it changes instantly. does a 180° flip when aramis is a bitch to him.#and it stays that way for the entirety of the trilogy. until this moment. this one short moment when d'artagnan#who. mind you. is not innocent himself and was also manipulating the hell out of porthos and talking shit about aramis behind his back.#but he makes that step. he reaches out. 'i fucking hate you let me help you you dumb evil cunt' and aramis says 'no <3'#you know i have this thing where i am OBSESSED with finding the one moment where a character condemns themselves for good.#the one moment when they figuratively sign the contract for their perdition. that up to that moment they could still be saved somehow.#for rodrigo it is when he tries to kill eboli (in the play). for don giovanni it is when he refuses elvira's plea to change#(NOT when he accepts il commendatore's invite mind you)#and i feel like THIS is that moment for aramis.#the fact that it comes from d'artagnan is so just so fucking agsjssgsgsh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and of course he says no.#there is no version of this where he lets himself be helped. he has to say no he will always say no.#but boy oh boy is this making me bang my head against the wall.#the three musketeers#les trois mousquetaires#vicomte de bragelonne#alexandre dumas
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
Playing Bomb rush cyberfunk has been a crazy experience so far because i feel like I've been enjoying the game just as much as I'm not doing so
#which is crazy because i went in with the impression that this would be jet set radio but better#and really? the biggest thing is doing for me rn is making me wanna play old-school Jet set radio again#who the fuck looked at Jsr and thought “Hey you know what would make this game even better? 300 different inputs”#which makes it impossible for me to play this solely on the controler (the main way i play games since i suck ass at the keyboard)#because it just doesn't have that many buttons#so at times i gotta be fucking double welding this shit with both the keyboard and the controler and it's awful#because I don't have that good of a motor coordination or whatever the proper term is#on top of that. why did we need a fighting mechanic? that's so fucking unnecessary when Jsr already had a gret way of dealing with that#which was by integrating the grafitti mechanic with the fighting by having it be the way you damage opponents#just adjust that to make it take more hits/graffitis in the fight and boom. you're done. perfectly functional#all it does is take away 3 BUTTONS in a game that already has a shit load of inputs#and ik these same buttons are also used to doing tricks on rails but like. that's such an useless addition#because I'm not actually doing anything like this isn't pulling a move on a fighting game. no skill is needed. I'm just mashing buttons#so you might as well not have both of these machanics and have the buttons be set to do other. more important comands#like the one to manually continue a combo on the ground after getting off of a rail. i gonna hold control on the keyboard and move#my joysticks at the same time whenever i need that and it fucking sucks#so yeah whenever i play it again I'm definitely gonna try mapping my controler to my liking and we'll see how it goes#unrelated to the gameplay i just gotta say. sorry but the songs are so mid#if i knew how to mod things i would replace every single one of them songs from jsf and jsrf. absolutely no doubt about it#like the songs in the jsr games are so unique and distinct from one another. even the ones that have a similar style. which makes them#incredibly memorable like i still remember a good chunk of them from the top of my head and i haven't played that game in months#bomb rush cyberfun songs just feel so samey and forgettable#a similar thing can be said for the environment designs and especially their colors imo#everything within the same area feels incredibly samey and not memorable. and you may think “Carol it's a whole area of course it's gonna#look similar to itself“ and to that i say. yes. cohesion is important but take a look at Kogane and Bento from jsr and you'll see#how despite being the same area and having the a coherent color pallet and overlay applied to it their locations are distinct from eachother#and memorable to the point where i can recall how to traverse thought each area and where they lead to easily#in bomb rush it feels like I'm just looking at the same place everywhere in the map#on a good note! i like the story so so much it's definitely what's gonna cary me through playing the whole game#because jsr really needed more story and fleshed out characters that aren't just different designs you can play as
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
tbh i know ppl have said cn players are speaking up but i don't actually know how true that is lmao. if hoyo took the initiative to make brown people actually real in game maybe they'd learn that pretty characters =/= pale skin but 🧍♀️
why i say this is like: (last time i checked) on twitter the english drip marketing has gotten vastly fewer likes/rt's than clorinde, emilie, or sigewinne's etc, while the jp twitter drip and bilibili posts have gotten basically the same amount of likes/shares as 4.7's. also maybe my search keywords are wrong but if you search natlan dark skin/纳塔黑皮 (on bilibili: video sharing site): there are some videos posting edits from twitter, and a fair amt of people comment 'oh this actually looks good' or 'oh not bad' etc, but there are also people just. being straight up racist, a good amount of people just writing this off as global fans organizing drama, and the usual retorts of 'just go play/make another game, genshin's supposed to cater to chinese aesthetics/beauty standards anyways' and im like. 🧍♀️
#it's heartening seeing people say oh x actually looks good/better w tan skin! < for a lot of the brown edits being reposted#but im also mostly sure tan/brown is the darkest they're willing to go ......#< ignoring that ka.china's intro uses a swahili word. ignoring that talking stick has a bunch of african refs#anyways. im glad (at the en backlash) i guess i just don't like false hope. also i really dont think gnsn's going to change anything even#if all cn fans collectively yelled at them. which isn't happening#i probably just wont talk about 5.x until the storyline is done#ramblings!#trying so hard to censor things so it doesnt show in tags; im just like. disappointed but not surprised. like from my limited literacy#if they make 5.x charas darker like how most edits have been making them; a lot of (cn) people would be like . oh not bad#but theyre not going to beg gnsn to change it after theyve already released the pale versions just to be '''''''''politically correct''''''#so then it's just the company. people are either neutral or liking the darker skinned edits so gnsn couldve not been a coward and made them#darker and they wouldn't have lost a significant amt of money. but like what the fuck is this#also my impressions may be skewed my sample size is limited and may not be representative of the population etc
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
...
#tumblr is so fucking awful for people who want to be skinny it's unreal#show me one place where i've been fatphobic. and while i wait i'll find xee a hundred for posts that are crushing to read as person--#-- who just personally wants to be thin without ever extending that to anyone else#root post#sprout post#vent#you're laughing at my transition goals#you say it's impossible to get thin#you say i'll die if i try#you attribute attractive traits in skinny people to their thinness as if it was the devil#i'm sick of it#sick#sick sick#what gave you the impression that the best way to fight fatphobia was cruelty?#you genuinely believe that shit you say may only negatively influence natural ~skinny bitches~?
5 notes
·
View notes
Text
Me: I don't like Sci-fi, space operas, or fantasy. Me: *sees fanart of some characters* Oh these look cool. I wonder why their arm looks like that. Why is that one person dressed in skull attire? I keep seeing these guys everywhere, let's get the book on Audible what could possibly go wrong? Book: *Sci-fi fantasy novel in space* Me:
#the fanart didn't give the impression of any of these TT0TT#maybe like modern fantasy...which I guess this is more 'future fantasy' but ahhh#silly talks#dazed lost confused#naked in the woods i am#where am i what's going on????#i think the 'houses' are based off our solar system#there's so many fucking names too many fucking names TT0TT I'm listening in a car while driving I CANT KEEP LOOKING UP FUCKING NAMES#I may have printed out the list of names that literally listed at the beginning beCAUSE I CANT REMEMBER ALL THE FUCKING NAMES TT0TT#I had to re-listen to the first 4 chapters twice because I was confused *sobs*#who are you people#MC funny tho she says curse words....I can understand curse words and the character work so that's good#turns out it might be a murder mystery? Annnnnd we've looped back around to a genre I'm cool with#literally had no idea what the plot was but "uhh competition between families/clans? Maybe?' TT0TT#i'm liking it? now that I kinda know what's going on#apparently the other books might have more mystery? I'm down for that I guess#i really need to look at what I'm about to get sometimes TT0TT But monkey brain was like 'oooo i like the art/chars looks lets do it!' TT0T#fun fact dipshit me bought another fantasy (I think it's high fantasy) too so fuck me I guess#look at me expanding my horizons!#anyway I thought this would be a funny 'point and laugh at silly' considering my stance on these things#let's see if anyone can figure out what i'm talking about based on what little i've given you to work off of laksdjflkajf;a#mistakes were made....but at least this looks like a happy mistake#and i might make a custom nendo of one of those jackasses klfjdalksjfas#i was NOT vibing with the prose the first time through. TT0TT but I think i got a handle on it now mannnn#this is so outside my wheelhouse orz#i was expecting MAYBE some fantastical elements but not high fantasy (i don't think it is??? maybe more modern??? post apocalyptic future?-#-ahhh another genre i care not for klfajdslkjf) but the space thing THREW ME FOR A FUCKING LOOP! that was a blindside! TT0TT)#i heard the 2nd book is a bit of a mind fuck......now THAT'S something I'm invested in 030
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
Magenta.
#i love my team i rarely if ever say a negative thing because i am grateful to their humanity and compassion toward each other#but I'm aggravated#i don't like imposing my will against others especially when it comes to children#no matter how verbally abusive or physical they try to get when they throw a trantrum or are legitimately triggered#i know there are times where these situations call for more strictness and redirection#but god damn if somehow I'm getting through to that kid in the middle of that and they're talking to me and telling me how they feel#and trusting me to hold space for them#the last thing i need anyone doing is coming in cornering them and being like NUH HUH NOT THAT#“your options are sit in the rain or attend pe!”#cause we're right back at square fucking 1 and also you underminded me in front of the kiddo which hurts me and also may plant the idea#that they can undermine me in the future#i was hired to be a mentor and a specialist#let me be a damn mentor and specialist and work my magic#i had this kid coming down from a 10 with aggression to a 6 within minutes then the conversation got derailed#i like the teacher i work alongside but sometimes i get the impression she doesn't like my methods for getting on the kiddos levels#cause it can be very childlike and yes it does take away time from their education however this is also a treatment facility and school#the mental health component is just as if not more important#cause how can they function and learn if they can't get their basic needs met?#ok off my soapbox#i love helping kids but damn it do the adults in and out of the job don't appreciate that#magenta is my safe word for venting lmao
4 notes
·
View notes
Note
Glad you were able to go to the Amsterdam show! What was it like perceiving Park Seonghwa in the flesh for a second time? Did you survive the Cyberpunk shoulder move? 😉
Thank you anon!! 😊 I'm glad you ask because now I can just ramble about this ajsushsh. the thing was that this time i was actually close enough to SEE him, like see the sweat on his skin close, because of the extended stage and like. WOW what a man (all of them though they're all so fine and once again i wonder where kq manages to find them). tbh i knew it was over for me when during soundcheck they did say my name and for the last chorus he put sunglasses on and then did the tongue thing he always gets bullied about with this stupid small smirk on his way too handsome face 🥲
the shoulder move yeah....yeah i survived. barely. I usually only have very short and random memories of concerts because of all the adrenaline and whatever but man that's something i do remember Very Clearly. He wasn't even on the extended stage but the main one and yet. just. yeah. user hwanswerland isn't doing well rn bc like he looked EXACTLY obviously like every gif in the black outfit ever but i saw it with my own eyes and i can't believe that. I barely film anything at concerts but i did film his under world part at the end of the song bc I needed to have my own video of it and ASHDUEZDHDUDHDHDHDH. i don't know words I'm sorry he's too powerful
#ask#anon#sorry this is so long ajdjshs but if you give me the impression you're even mildly interested in what i have to say#i will tell you and start rambling and then be unable to find the words because#how could words even do this man and whatever i may be feeling justice#< sorry about tjat i know it's cringe ig but it's 2am and i just#i have many thoughts and feelings about him#also very much unrelated but i have to say that i know there's been differing opinions on mg's hair#whatever they may be the man was on fire and certainly feeling himself and that alone made him really hot with the hair#not to sidetrack this even more but#wy and jh are so cute and yh is just so nice and fine and just INSANE as a dancer#hj is fucking unreal there's no way he's that pretty and same for ys actually#idek what to say about san tbh. he's crazy man what the hell are his genes#okay now I'm done ajdudzd
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
Incorrect Quotes Tag
Wasn't tagged, just having fun
Rules: generate incorrect quotes for your WIP using this website
-
Felicity and Rosalia: Didn't you die?!
Tobias and Sirena: That was years ago, dude. Things change
-
Sirena: -walks into a room-
Holly: She's covered in blood again. Why is it she's always covered in blood?
Tobias: Well, it looks like it's her own blood this time
-
Felicity: I'm against crime, and I'm not ashamed to admit it
-
Holly: -sees Sirena and Tobias together-
Holly: They're cute. I would put them on a boat
May: You mean....you ship them?
-
Sirena: Subs are so fun to play with. All you have to do is hint at what you might do, back them into a corner with a look, or grab their wrist in a certain way and they're a wide-eyed mess.
Rosalia: What the fuck kind of Subway are you going to?
Felicity: Substitute teachers deal with so much shit.
Tobias: Guys
-
I tag: whoever the fuck wants to do this, go nuts <3
#writblr#writeblr#tag game#wip#space pirates#I am aware that no one else knows who the fuck these characters are especially since I've only mentioned Sirena and Tobias before#and I've not said all that much about them tbh#I gotta do a WIP intro for these fuckers at some point lol ANYWAY#Holly is Sirena and Tobias's bestie May is Holly's gf#Felicity and Rosalia are twins who were under the impression that Sirena and Tobias were dead for ten years#Sirena and Tobias are obsessed with each other and in love#and when I say obsessed with each other I do mean it this is not healthy but damn is it fun to write#and hopefully will be fun to read lol#oh also Rosalia uses she/her he/him and they/them#I refuse to let anyone be under the impression that he's cis lmao#Felicity is aroace and I was gonna include a thing sort of referencing that but this was getting long lmao#Sirena is bi Tobias is demiro demisex#Holly is pan May is lesbian#I think that covers everyone mentioned here just in case anyone was curious#oh Rosalia is also bi lmao#I'm gonna give them two partners only one of which I've invented already#this is what happens when you're a plantser lmao#also also Felicity isn't a snitch she just doesn't approve of the pirates way of life lol she would never sell them out or anything#and not just because she needs them to get her and Rosalia to Pluto because of a curse!#again I really should do a WIP intro for this lmao
2 notes
·
View notes
Note
Alison Bechdel has written a huge body of work reflecting on her discomfort and bias against trans women. It is as much a part of her memoir work as her lesbianism or her father's death.
I don't think she's a dyed-in-the-wool TERF in that since the 2000s she's been consistently. discomforted? I think? by her own bigotry, and in most of her work she seems deeply ambivalent about it - whereas many big time TERFs do firmly believe that trans women are Wrong, I think Bechdel's work and interviews suggest she's broadly politically pro-trans but personally deeply uncomfortable with trans women's presence. which to be clear IS transphobia and it IS bad.
like a lot of her direct transphobic statements are put in the mouth of Mo in Dykes To Watch Out For, who is clearly a self-deprecating self-portrait. Mo is transphobic in the same way she's neurotic, egotistical and holier-than-thou - at least as far as I can tell, these are things Bechdel knows to be true about herself and doesn't like about herself.
Both in DTWOF and her directly autobiographical work, there's a real tension between her transphobic opinions and the worlds she writes which don't at all validate her opinions. The stories dealing with trans characters in Dykes To Watch Out For, for example, definitely seem to be designed to repudiate Mo's transphobia, which in the context of how Bechdel seems to relate to the text is interesting.
Someone in another reblog chain said that Bechdel has a sort of liberal winemom transphobia - I support trans women but not in any material way and not near me - which I don't think is unfair. I think she's got an attitude common to a lot of cis feminists her age who I've met, which is Transphobic But Also Knows Transphobia Is Bad And Has A Lot Of Messy Feelings About It.
which is to say I don't think it's necessarily fair to call her a complete TERF, partially because based on her work, I do think that she was a full on TERF in the 80 and 90s and spent the late 90s and early 2000s trying to reckon with that and hear out her trans friends more. Because of that though I also don't think she's a great trans advocate or anything - she's clearly still got a lot of transphobia, and quite importantly she retains a lot of affection and social connections among other 80s and 90s TERFs so although she is trying to be trans-positive she's also definitely still tied up in that trans-exclusionary lesbian separatist culture.
ie she's both pro-trans (in an abstract and general sense and in the sense that she's aware that her bigotry is not rooted in rational fact, and she's vocal about the fact that transphobia isn't a reflection of an actual threat from trans people) and transphobic (in that a lot of her politics and discomforts are rooted in the Michfest TERF scene and she's not nearly far along enough the process of unlearning that shit, which comes out in her sympathies for committed TERFs much more recently and in her ongoing discomfort with trans people interpersonally). most of her work and public persona are about being in conflict with yourself and tbh this is a conflict a lot of people are constantly working through - 'my rational and political outlook says one thing but my biases and anxieties say the opposite, very loudly, and I'm aware of both conflicting ideas at once'.
it's better to know that a shitty belief you hold is shitty than it is to uncritically accept it as true. it also doesn't absolve you of having to push back against that shitty belief, try and get out of it, and avoid acting on it. Bechdel is not a good role model for trans acceptance; she's also not someone who's uncritical of transphobia; she's got a lot of blind spots and there's no reason why the transphobia she does hold should be ignored or immune from critique.
Alison Bechdel is openly pro-trans are you on meth
then why was she at michfest when trans people were protesting it? and why does she hang around with terfs? why was she praising a terf in her 2017 obituary and claiming that it was good that Michfest was free of the "male socialised".
like you can look all this shit up. drawing a couple cartoons that say "i guess i dont mind pissign next to trannies" doesn't like... overwrite a lifetime of befriending terfs & dismissing genderqueer lesbians & ignoring trans women protesting your precious Real Wombyn's Music Festival.
like... why is it so unbelievable that somebody who says they are pro trans is actually transphobic? i mean... the fucking president of the united states says he's pro trans. IS he?
#red said#i have been thinking about this for a while because i think dykes to watch out for is really interesting on this front#she is clearly NOT IMPRESSED with her own transphobia. she understands a) that it's there and b) that it's bad#but nonetheless it's still very baked into her politics and worldview even in much later works.#it's a kind of progressive cis guilt analogous to white guilt - a kneejerk reaction followed by a defensive panic#but there are multiple ways to process that guilt and i do think it's better to do that by saying 'that may be a fucked up thing i believe'#than what i think leads to the level of radicalisation we see from people like rowling linehan or bindel#where that discomfort and tension makes them double down and double down and double down#this is not to dismiss the actual impact of Bechdel's transphobia#but to say. i do think she is TRYING and that's an improvement on a lot of her compatriots from the Michfest Wombynynyns crowd
5K notes
·
View notes