#Debunking Myth
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Debunking the Myth: Chicago Outlaws MC and Chicago Mob Collaboration
#OUTLAWS #CHICAGOOUTLAWS #OUTLAWSMC We delve the truth behind the rumored partnership between the Chicago Outlaws MC and the notorious Chicago Mob. Join us as we separate fact from fiction to reveal whether these two powerful entities are truly working together or if it’s all just a captivating myth. Discover the web of speculation in our quest to tell the real story behind this fantasy of…
View On WordPress
#Biker News#Chicago Mob#Chicago Outlaws MC#Chicago Outlaws MC and Chicago Mob Collaboration#Collaboration Rumors#Crime Syndicates#Criminal Alliances#Criminal Underworld#Debunking Myth#Fact vs Fiction#insane throttle#Investigative Analysis#organized crime#Truth Uncovered#Unveiling Truth
0 notes
Text
i have to remember not everyone in florida voted for these people in power because it's hard to feel sorry for them sometimes. really hard (watch til the end smfh)
and she's going to turn around the vote for him AGAIN smfh
#hurricane milton#ane milton relief#republican misinformation#maga lies#disaster response#political blame game#republican accountability#disaster relief facts#conservative disinformation#blaming democrats#political manipulation#fact checking hurricane aid#right wing narratives#republican voters misled#partisan disaster politics#spreading false claims#hurricane milton aid#debunking republican lies#gop misinformation#hurricane recovery facts#republican deception#false narratives in politics#disaster relief funding#blaming democrats unfairly#maga voter misinformation#republican disaster mismanagement#uncovering the truth#political scapegoating#disaster response myths#partisan blame shifting
210 notes
·
View notes
Text
In investigating this theory, Dr Newman demonstrated fundamental and comedic mismatches between longevity claims and observed patterns. In the process, Dr Newman revealed that the well-publicised "Blue Zones" claims for the secrets of longevity are infallibly flawed. Dr Newman showed that the highest rates of achieving extreme old age are predicted by high poverty, the lack of birth certificates, and fewer 90- year-olds. Poverty and pressure to commit pension fraud were shown to be excellent indicators of reaching ages 100+ in a way that is 'the opposite of rational expectations'.
172 notes
·
View notes
Text
Oh boy, I sure can't wait for Intervallo 7.5, where the bus goes on yet another wacky roadtrip while the gang goes to Hong Lu's home district and learn about his extremely complex family dynamic and the many many references to the original novel, it's multiple remakes, and/or the series adaptation.
The next Walpurgis is most likely the Safety Team with Netzach as the next Announcer; and the next LobCorp IDs might connect to Abnormalities of denial, blissful ignorance, or the constricting force of family (Queen of Hatred, Queen Bee, Void Dream).
Even if the Sinners adjust to the fact that one of their members is a Second Kindred Bloodfiend, everyone keeps eyeing Outis just in case she tries to kill Don mentally or physically. She's still salty about the "betrayal" of having a definite threat in their ranks and were possibly waiting to backstab them at any moment (...Did something happen with Eurylochus, Outis?).
And even if she's also adjusting to a modernish life without the fanatic belief in Fixers, Don Sancho Quixote the Second reads them the riot act on their multiple attempts to prove she's a "real vampire" and committing elder abuse: shining light in her eyes or putting her in direct sunlight, putting garlic in her food, Dead Butterfly's coffin and Hundred Sins cross mace in her face cause Christian symbol or possible vamp bed, chasing her with a water bottle or spray bottle, so much water, so much water...
#limbus company#limbus company spoilers#limbus company canto 7#limbus company canto 7 spoilers#limbus company don quixote#limbus company sancho#long tags#text shitpost#So how's everyone doing with the finale? Rose Hunter has been kicking my butt since day 1 :')#Other than that I'm all for calling DonQui 2.0 as Don Sancho cause it has a nice ring to me#Ultimately taking her “dad's” name as the real Fixer and a memorial is really sweet but I'll see if new development on Sancho's side too#...By that I mean the Sinners pushing all her buttons to debunk every vampire myth there is#She could still be squeamish about water but if they ever mention the Lake she might burst into flames#The Bloodfiend fam announcers did mention how they're not afraid of garlic but what about everything else?#Dante *might* try to connect more with Don Sancho even when she's still acting as DonQui but who knows#Depends on how the next Intervallo goes but I'm also here for Jia “Hong Lu” Baoyu to take the stage too
62 notes
·
View notes
Note
Just wanted to let y kno that people are accusing you of being a zionist and all that? Idk if its true but im assuming it isnt
I support Palestinian liberation, think the government of Israel is absolutely committing a genocide (& is awful in many other ways), and that Western nations are invested in Israel to help further their own imperial goals in West Asia. However I also think this situation is not 1:1 comparable with Western colonial states like America & I'm concerned with how many people (largely white, large Western people) have taken an extremely black and white view of this issue where "says nuance is important" is synonymous with "denies Palestinian oppression." There is a real and bipartisan antisemitism issue here & a lot of people are not taking seriously enough how antisemitism & the legacy of Jewish oppression shapes this issue in ways which make it fundamentally different to talking about White Christian colonization of America.
I am an anarchist & have no attachment to any state's existence. My only hope is that the war ends & a way is found to have everyone in that region (including Palestinians who have been forced from their home and current Israeli citizens) living safe, fulfilling lives in a community which is free from the control of imperialism and other forms of injustice.
#m.#ask box#i/p war#i recommend reading The Birth of Israel: Myths and Realities by Simcha Flapan#a book which palestinian scholars themselves have said is a great methodical debunking of#israel's justifications for its crimes#which was written. by a self-identified zionist!#so like while i dont identify as a zionist. there is a lot more diversity of belief in zionism than it seems
162 notes
·
View notes
Text
There’s no way ShivRome are twins actually. Shiv would’ve absorbed Roman in the womb first chance she got
#twin truthing myth debunked#(this isn’t serious btw. y’all keep on truthing)#((but you can’t tell me it’s not true))#roman roy#shiv roy#roy siblings#succession#succession hbo#noodle rambles#duo: your face is giving me a headache
159 notes
·
View notes
Text
If i could go back in time, I would share these screenshots with young Milo and tell him how much of a legend he's going to be.
146 notes
·
View notes
Text
😱😱😱
#dungeon meshi#delicious in dungeon#thistle#thistle dungeon meshi#if anyone’s wondering what I was reading it’s an article about how the alpha wolf stuff is a myth#I already knew that but my dad was spouting some bs this morning so I whipped out an article to back myself up as I debunked him#I pulled up like three different articles and he still had the audacity to say there’s always a natural leader so there has to be an alpha#bro wants to be an alpha so bad he’s refusing to listen to facts 😭#ok sorry for yapping in the tags but there’s just so much info about how that study was dumb and yet peoppe still say alpha beta omega#there is no Easter bunny there is no tooth fairy and there is no alpha wolf#long post#I don’t know why the image got so big sorry#rope/spider post
44 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm planning to start writing short articles, or discussing memes on various gods and posting them here. First I want to express my hatred for memes like this.
To start, judging from the dates, they are conflating Mithra and Mithras. Mithras is a later Roman version of the Indo-Iranian Mithra. They are using (false) claims about Mithras that also were not true about Mithra so that the date can be pushed back further. The date for Dionysus is also wrong. He is mentioned in Mycenaean inscriptions from centuries earlier, though he was thought to be a later arrival for a long time before this was discovered. These probably aren't deliberate since they get repeated often, but yet more shoddy research.
Every deity on this list had a miraculous birth, but only Jesus is said to have been born of a virgin. Horus was conceived after his mother Isis temporarily raised Osiris from the dead and slept with him. Mithras emerged fully grown from a rock. Krishna was conceived normally to a couple imprisoned by an evil king and released divine light which knocked out the guards and swung the prison doors open so he could be smuggled out, and Dionysus was conceived when Zeus slept with the mortal princess Semele, so not a virgin. Hera then tricked Semele into seeing Zeus in all his glory, causing her to burst into flame. Zeus saved the unborn child and sewed him into his thigh until he was ready to be born.
Neither Mithras or Dionysus have any date recorded for their births.
Krishna's father was a prince and his foster-father was a cowherd, not a carpenter.
Neither Horus or Mithras were ever said to have died. Krishna did die, but his resurrection and return to heaven is believed to be strictly spiritual.
Mithras did not have twelve disciples.
Horus never walked on water, and while Egyptians did pray to him for healing the same can be said of pretty much every god ever. There are no stories of him doing so in the same way as Jesus is said to have.
Dionysus never turned water into wine, though he did grant the princess Oino the power to turn anything into wine. He also was never called "holy child."
There was no Star in the East for any of them except Jesus, though Mithras and Krishna were both associated with the constellation Taurus.
Mithras and Krishna DID perform miracles! Like all gods.
Everything on here is either wrong or irrelevant. The truth is the Victorians just liked making things up.
26 notes
·
View notes
Text
the moment they get hit with a disaster, they suddenly want the gov't to give them everything under the sun smfh.
#socialism#maga lies#republican misinformation#hurricane helene aid#disaster relief#government assistance#political propaganda#debunking myths#hurricane recovery#conservative disinformation#fact check
129 notes
·
View notes
Text
Debunking Law of Assumption Myths
I've learned a lot about manifestation and law of assumption over time. I've heard a lot of BS that didn't end up being true, so I'm writing a list as a reminder for all of us.
It's magic/hocus pocus - Nope. You can view it as your own kind of magic or magic powers of the universe (in a positive way), sure. But it's not something made up and you aren't putting spells on people or anything crazy like that. All you're doing is changing the way you see things in your own life and then the universe automatically reflects that. It's also been studied by philosophers like Neville Goddard. There's actual science involved with quantum leaping.
It's toxic positivity - Unless you're not allowing yourself to feel anything other than positive feelings, then no, LOA does not involve toxic positivity. Toxic positivity is trying to be overly positive in negative situations and pushing that onto others who are feeling down. When it comes to manifesting, you can allow yourself to feel upset and have doubts while still manifesting what you want. There's no rules saying things like, "you can't feel lousy or else you won't get your desires." You can feel down or be dealing with a massive struggle and still affirm or visualize that you have what you've been wanting. And, even so, you don't have to affirm as you're yelling or crying about something. It won't "cancel" your manifestation. We all waver at times - we're humans with emotions.
There's right and wrong techniques - No. The technique is not how you manifest. Let me explain. The purpose of trying a technique is to help you get into the state of "I have everything I desire" (state of wish fulfilled, as people in the community call it) and being in that state is how you end up manifesting. Some people don't even need to use a technique to get them into that state. They can subconsciously jump without having to try. But, everyone's mind works differently and some people can't get into or stay in that state without using a technique to help them get there. So, if you struggle to jump into or remain in that state of mind, find what technique helps you get there. Different ones resonate with different people. Remember: You are limitless. There's no "right" or "wrong" way to get to the wish fulfilled state. There's also no rules telling you what you can and can't do or else "you won't ever manifest."
It's a process and you have to wait - The action itself of manifesting is not a process. Getting to the state of wish fulfilled is a process if it's something you are struggling with. But once you are able to get into that state of mind, everything will come to you because you now know that you have it, and you continuously think, feel, and act that way. When you tell yourself you already have it, you don't have that worry of "it's going to take a lot of time" or "it's going to take [this long]." It'll happen naturally and quickly. So, don't think "I have to wait" and don't put pressure on yourself about timing. Once you get into the wish fulfilled state, it'll come together as quickly as possible. And if the 3D realm hasn't caught up to it just yet, be patient. It'll happen right before your eyes before you even know it.
You can't manifest multiple things at once - Wrong, yes you can manifest multiple things at once. It might take a lot of brain power or energy to think of multiple things at once (which is often why it's encouraged to focus on one manifestation at a time), but it is possible to. Doing techniques like writing a list of what you have and using multiple affirmations can help with that. Don't feel the need to limit yourself unless you don't feel okay focusing on multiple manifestations at a time.
You're just being delusional - Nope. You know what you have and you're putting it out there into the world. Growing up, other people will limit things you envision in your mind and things you want to be true. But, knowing what you desire and knowing that it's yours does mean it's yours.
How it happens has to make logical sense - No, it doesn't. A certain part of our brain will try to apply logic to how our manifestation will show up. You don't have to use logic or even think about how it's going to show up in the first place. The "how" never matters when it comes to manifestation. The only part you have to focus on is the state of already having the thing you want. There are an infinite number of ways something you manifest can show up. It's impossible to predict exactly how it's going to go. You can get an idea in your mind of "how it went," but it may happen differently, although there is the possibility it'll show up exactly how you want it to. You really don't know. But, all you have to know is that you have it and that it showed up for you in the best way possible.
Certain things are impossible to manifest - (CW: death, worldly issues). Well, this is an interesting one to explain because it feels very nuanced. This can be felt when it comes to manifesting someone back to life or solving a worldly issue (both touchy subjects, I know. I'm sorry. I'll explain.) These are things that affect many, many people and already physically happened. But, also, in another parallel reality, this hasn't happened or can be undone but we just aren't seeing it. Or particularly the person who passed can show up in a different way in our lives right now, whether it's through another person, a spirit, a physical item, etc. I'm sure people (other than just myself) have wondered about this subject and maybe it's been looked into. So please, feel free to add something to this topic or correct me if need be. I can admit that I'm still learning things. But, when thinking about smaller scale things than this, certain things we may think are impossible can in fact be possible. Like, this may sound silly, but what if unicorns are real? They could be existing on another planet far, far away for all we know. Scientists may have looked into horses developing magical horns and wings. It's impossible to know for sure. Or, what if our SP is thinking about us right now? It's not impossible. Sorry if this all sounds like a lot. It's just something I've pondered.
#manifestation#manifesting#manifestation myths#debunking#debunking myths#limiting beliefs#delulu#delusional#loassumption#loa tumblr#loa blog#law of assumption
24 notes
·
View notes
Text
Debunking 7 Myths About Autism
Neurodivergent_lou
#autism#actually autistic#debunking myths about autism#neurodivergent lou (facebook)#autism advocacy#feel free to reblog/share#tw bright colors#tw eye strain
236 notes
·
View notes
Text
I wholeheartedly believe, The Destined one has an opposite personality compared to the sun wukong.
Considering he's the mind relic, I'd expect him to be more calculative and strategic with his fighting style, but of course, he's not any less of a trickster to his opponents. Using any means necessary but doing it respectfully, He's selectively mute, but he's communicative using other languages.
He has his temperamental moments, but its solemn compared to the Sun Wukong infamous reputation.
He's cheeky, but he's good at hiding it compared to his previous incarnation.
The destined one has a goal to set his whole life to. He'd be damned if he wasn't careful enough to live his life till he reached it.
The world has whispered him things, and it intends to finish what Sun Wukong could never by using his own faults to mend the journey.
#this is just my thoughts tho idc if this has been debunked-#might apply it to my oc#black myth destined one#black myth wukong#black myth sun wukong
27 notes
·
View notes
Text
Gotten a few asks about this so let me clarify:
Atlantis the Lost Empire is NOT Nazi propaganda nor is it an endorsement of Nazi beliefs.
It's another example of a piece of media that has taken inspiration from a conspiracy theory which unfortunately has ties to the Nazis' obsession with proving their bonkers Aryan race theory.
The Nazis were obsessed with finding and creating ANY sort of historical/traditional link to validate their agenda, no matter how utterly ridiculous or entirely separate from reality that link was. They were obsessed with the mystical and the occult. Pseudo-science and pseudo-archaeology were their literal bread and butter.
In this instance, Plato's story of a sunken ancient city is not special for being co-opted for the Nazi's purposes. What has lead Atlantis to becoming a popular conspiracy theory in modern times is due in part to the steady popularization of pseudo-science as well as bad faith actors promoting a racist conspiracy theory as genuine fact.
The majority of conspiracy theories you hear about today actually have roots in fiction. For example, the Hollow Earth conspiracy theory finds it's origins from science fiction novels dating back to the 1800s. The Philadelphia Project can also trace its origins to a UFO writer who claims he was receiving secret confidential intel from a former US mariner. And yet there are are people who genuinely believe there is a secret world hidden in the center of the earth and that the US government was experimenting with and succeeded in creating a portal to another dimension.
So is the case with Atlantis. Atlantis: The Antediluvian World was written by Ignatius Donnelly in 1882 as a means to express his desires for a populist government and world. He was extremely misguided in his belief that Plato's story was factual and he employed the use of hyperdiffusion-a popular method used in countless conspiracy theories-to argue that all ancient societies were basically all descended from one even more ancient people.
Or in the Nazi's own terms: "An ancient master race."
Bad actors like Graham Hancock and Ancient Aliens further popularized the Nazi's conspiracy theory (as well as many others) and Donnelly's books by spreading mass disinformation across a global scale and we are all suffering for it.
As I've already stated before, Atlantis the Lost Empire takes superficial inspiration from the conspiracy theory in the same way that Stranger Things takes inspiration from the Montauk Project. Many popular sci-fi films, tv shows, books, and video games are littered with references and nods to conspiracy theories. Everything from Men in Black to The X Files to the SCP Foundation.
If you are interested in seeing how convincing conspiracy theories can get and their very real ability to destroy actual lives, I recommend watching American Conspiracy: The Octopus Murders. It perfectly showcases how conspiracy theories can suck you in and how people can easily take advantage of you once they break down your ability to distinguish fiction from reality.
My only caveat with the documentary is that I really wish the creators had emphasized even more plainly to the audience that the Octopus Murders is an actual conspiracy theory instead of leaving the question somewhat open ended. Especially in regards to Danny Casolaro's death.
I would also highly recommend watching Milo Rossi aka miniminuteman's videos as his channel is dedicated solely to debunking various archaeological conspiracy theories as well as providing fascinating education on a variety of historical topics. I really cannot overstate how wonderful his Awful Archaeology series is.
I'm going to link a few of my favorites here:
youtube
This is the first of a multiseries debunking Graham Hancock's Ancient Apocalypse series.
youtube
This is Part 1 of 2 of him debunking one of the most notorious TikTokers who makes a living off of spreading mass disinformation.
I would be remiss not to mention Atun-Shei Film's amazing channel as well as Lady of the Library.
youtube
youtube
youtube
I would also recommend Kaz Rowe's channel as they provide stellar information on a wide variery of historical topics.
youtube
youtube
Tldr; Atlantis the Lost Empire and the films creators' did not set out to promote Nazi beliefs. They simply took inspiration from a popular conspiracy theory and made it something entirely unique and separate from the Aryan race agenda.
#dreamer talks#atlantis#atlantis the lost empire#conspiracy theory#conspiracy theories#psa#history#world history#debunking myths#debunking conspiracy theories#this is a public service announcement#edits will be made as needed#feel to correct me on any of these points#or to offer your own recommendations#Youtube#long post#long post is long#fuck graham hancock#fuck ancient aliens
36 notes
·
View notes
Text
Analysis of shipping: Found family and pseudo-incest?
Last year I was requested this rebuttal to detractors, but it took a long time to make because it was hard to pinpoint where these arguments came from
But, after one perceptive individual nailed it right on the head, I finally had something to work with
So, let's start with the argument: "These characters can't end up together because they're like family/siblings, so that would be incest"
This isn't unique to one single fandom. Antis had used this reasoning against NaLu and similar pairings in the past, based on the fact Natsu and Lucy belonged to the same guild, a community that treated its members as "family"
Needless to say, they stopped using it after seeing how Mashima made pairings like Gajeel and Levy, or Gray and Juvia, pretty much canon. Making it clear that romantic relationships between members of this particular circle or community were perfectly fine (That doesn't mean cheating is fine though!).
But, this argument still persists in other fandoms. One Piece is not the exception, where the anti-LuNa crowd constantly tries to paint all romantic potential between Luffy and Nami as "incest" because they're "siblings."
Let us address something first, what's incest?
"Sexual intercourse between persons so closely related that they are forbidden by law to marry"
- Merriam-Webster, 2024
"Marriage or sexual intercourse with a relative within the prohibited degree of consanguinity. In other words, incest is sexual contact between close blood relatives"
- LII / Legal Information Institute, 2024
After 1000+ chapters worth of story, nothing implies Luffy and Nami are related by blood. So, where does the argument comes from?
In reality, antis are using a concept people don't often hear about: pseudo-incest
It's not a widely known term, in fact, it's not even in the Oxford English Dictionary (OEA), the Cambridge Dictionary, or Merriam-Webster.
However, we can still find some defintions that helps us to understad what do LuNa detractors mean with this?
"Sexual involvement between family members who are not blood relations (e.g., siblings by adoption, stepparents and stepchildren, in-laws)."
- Wiktionary, 2024
Once, again we hit another wall, since Luffy wasn't adopted by Nami's family, nor Nami was adopted into his. So, why do antis claim they're "like" siblings?
Let's go from the minor statement to the big one. The first argument is that "The have a sibling-like dynamic"
This is one is odd, because it can come from actual unawareness about the nature of relationships, or the malicious use of the common traits seen in all sorts of human connections
After all, all healthy relationships, either being with relatives, companions, or potential romantic partners, are defined by affection, shared values, support, and sometimes a little bit of discord and/or conflict
If we were to use these traits to label the connection between two characters as that of "siblings," we could describe a lot of official pairings (and potent relationships) from a huge lot of stories as "siblings" instead of lovers/spouses.
Let's use a potent relationship as example: Sabo and Koala feel affection for one another, share similar values, support each other, and may have an argument from time to time...
...does that make them "siblings"? What about Ace and Isuka? Does the combination of affection, support, and occasional conflict rule out any possibility of a relationship upgrade?
If we apply this "measurement" to official pairings from other series, we're likely to jump to similarly flawed conclusions about their relationships.
However, even if there are similarites, there are several differences. For bonds outside our family circle. we may see chosen affinity, sometimes a greater attachment and/or emotional codependecy, a strong passion, and even a deeper sense of compromise coming from the willing choice of those involved.
Potent relationships have all of this, even if they're yet to become canon. And due to their emotional chemistry, LuNa seems more like a deep companionship with the potential to evolve rather than a sibling-like bond
However, that was just the minor statement from western fans. We may deduce some say this because they can't picture a romantic relationship without one (or both characters) being a total simp; perhaps they're so used to the "loveable perv" trope, that their idea of romance relies how horny the characters act with one another; or maybe they just too enamored with the cool good-looking buff guy to acknowledge anything deep, but I digress...
Still, we're yet to address the elephant in the room, the bigger argument, which is a combination of two things:
Just like some anti-NaLu fans did ages ago, a lot of anti-LuNa fans take their "sibling" argument from the same place every other permutation of this reasoning came from, a misuse of another concept: Family of choice
Family of choice, Chosen Family or Found Family, all refer to a group of people who willingly stick together to provide each other with the sense of community and belonging, as well as a feeling of affection, joy and security inherent to a functional family, without being related by blood.
It's seen as an alternative to those who faced rejection from their biological family, or society itself, and even to people who lost their relatives to tragedies or disasters.
It's a useful literary device to develop characters due to how flexible it is, given that members of these groups don't need to fill particular roles for their relationships to work, which provides authors with a lot of freedom in terms of writing.
However, some detractors have been abusing the "family" part of the term to argue against pairings that have enough development and history together for a natural relationship upgrade. How?
By limiting each character to a specific role: Father, Mother, Sibling, etc.
This allows them to claim, that characters within "Found Families" cannot become couple because that would be pseudo-incest.
As some people already noticed, this makes no sense; it replaces the versatility of the trope with a far more rigid, static, and limited form of narrative; and goes against what the idea of "Found Family" was supposed to be, which is an alternative to "family," not a carbon copy of the traditional family structure.
So, how does this argument survives logic and reason?
Well, here's the elephant in the room: in the SBS Volume 48, Oda was asked the question: "If the Straw Hats really were an actual family, who would be the dad, and who would be the mom?"
The following was Oda's answer:
Dad: Franky (Thug)
Mom: Robin
First Son: Zoro
Second Son: Sanji (Punk)
Daughter: Nami
Third Son: Usopp
Fourth Son: Luffy
Youngest: Chopper
In the SBS Volume 50, Oda added Brook would be the "Grandfather" "If you Likened the Crew to Family".
Here we have another example of a quote taken out of context, because the question was 'if they really were an actual family', and Oda later framed his answer as "Position in the crew if they were a family."
It was never about the strawhats being "an actual family," it was merely mindless fun with a "what if." To drive that point home, Sanji still gets horny for both Nami and Robin, yet nobody in their right mind would accuse him of lusting after his "sister" and "mother," because they're not actual relatives.
And this leads us to a couple of plot twists: all of this started because of the song "Family" performed by the strawhats seiyuus which, while invoking the "Found Family" trope, includes the following statement:
"We're not relatives… we're not even siblings!" (親戚じゃなくて 兄弟じゃない)
Which pretty much kills the "they're like siblings" argument used by detractors to liken LuNa to pseudo-incest.
The second plot twist comes from the SBS Volume 99, Oda says that if the cew was an actual family Jinbei would be the "father," replacing Franky who would now be given the position of "pervy granny"
This proves two things. First, that such "positions" are neither "fixed" or "absolute," they're malleable and can be changed or altered at any given moment.
Second, that this "Family" thing amounts to a mere joke, it's just a silly little game with no real impact on the story and characters. Although the idea of Frobin Vs. Jinbin(?) sounds amusing, but I digress.
So, what's the conclusion?
Even if the strawhats are an example of "Family of choice," that doesn't make the greatest potential relationship upgrade within the crew problematic, it all depends on how the author handles the situation. And given Oda is a top tier writer, we got nothing to worry if he decides to pull the trigger
And, despite what huge players within the community said before, Oda never claimed the strawhats were "an actual family." So any accusation of pseudo-incest, whether subtle or direct, is just the result of general ignorance, misinformation, and/or personal agendas
BONUS
There are times in manga/anime when one character refers to another as brother/sister/sibling, despite not being related.
One example would be Winry from Fullmetal Alchemist, who claimed Edward is like a "brother" to her. However, given that they're not related, nothing stopped them from falling in love, ending up together, and having children...
If we rely on the same reasoning used by antis, we could conclude this relationship is problematic. However, even if they have some moments when Winry goes ballistic on Ed...
...nobody in their right mind would dare to say their relationship is akin to pseudo-incest.
Oddly enough, we have a case in One Piece, when one character (Kinemon) made a similar brother/sibling claim to Tsuru, using a similar reasoning to that of Winry's...
I'll give you three guesses on how these two ended up, the first two don't count
#one piece#fairy tail#fullmetal alchemist#analysis of shipping#analysis#found family#family of choice#debunking myths#ルナミ
73 notes
·
View notes
Text
Antis: But Gwynriel can't be mates because Azriel didn't sense their bond!! The bond always snaps in place for the males first!!!
Rowan Whitethorn and sapphic mate pairs: We are just a figment of your imagination ✨
(And yes, same-sex mates DO exist. We know SJM's worlds are all linked, and in TOG, Emrys and Malakai were mates, while in ACOWAR, Rhys commented that Thesan and his male lover were waiting for their mating bond to snap into place.)
Also, the more they argue that Gwynriel aren't mates, the more they agree that SJM will go down the mating bond path. Because why else would they be so fervently denying their mating bond? (And please remember these are the same people who are hollering that Elucien is boring because they're mates... So shouldn't they be desperately trying to prove that Gwynriel are mates and label them as "boring" too?) Their arguments are so contradictory that I'm always left scratching my head when I inadvertently see them (since they don't even tag properly lol).
52 notes
·
View notes