#anti lucasfilm

[dalekofchaos]

The fact that John Boyega and Ahmed Best are the ones supporting Amandla. And the complete silence from Disney/Lucasfilm. Really paints a picture, doesn't it?

[hearts-keep-going]

The Acolyte getting canceled further validates my opinion that Disney only cares about catering to the racists and the misogynists of the fandom because they happen to scream the loudest. For some reason, they are seen as “true” Star Wars fans.

They catered to them after TLJ and then we got TROS. Now they’re catering to them again and we lose a good show…

[caripr94]

Look what the news site for Disney has the audacity to say. In case you didn't have enough proof that they consider Hayden Christensen as nothing more than nostalgia bait.

Just when this guy is getting some respect and drawing in fans to their media, Disney is considering kicking him to the curb. And all they can say as an excuse is basically "we don't have any more stories for him" and "he's getting too old to make him look young". After they made up a canonically inconsistent adventure to drag desert hermit Obi-Wan into, CGI'ed up a 70-year-old Mark Hamill to play a mid-20s Luke Skywalker, and brought Palpatine back from the dead to cram into their sequel trilogy finale.

On the bright side, at least they can't butcher Hayden!Anakin anymore like they've done in these recent shows. But on the other hand, it gives me more reason to see Disney Lucasfilm crash and burn so that someone else can rebuild it from scratch and bring Hayden back in to give him the respect he deserves.

@tragicfantasy-girl, @nerdychristianfanboy, @roselani24, @fanfic-lover-girl, @fanfictasia, @gch1995, @riana-one, @marvelstars, @vaderdala1541, @wingletblackbird, @padawanlost, @redrikki, @kittenfangirl20, @rebelnurse, @friendlyneighborhoodgeek, @the-average-procrastinator, @clawedandcute, @the-far-bright-center

[grimlocksword]

Star Wars using The Acolyte Official Trailer to BOOST non-binary villain...

[lordofhunger47]

Me when some Disney shill say bullshit on old EU

[deafblindshorty]

You know, sometimes I wish they didn't make Poe so...important with so much potential.

It just seems like they started off making him important to the plot and storylines, but then they change their minds.

-Poe's parents are main characters in Shattered Empire and Luke gives Shara a Force sensitive tree and Poe has a chapter in Before the Awakening- Oh, wait, never mind, we're killing him off.

-Oh, wait, never mind, he's gonna be a main character.

-Poe is a legacy rebel character- oh wait, never mind, he used to be a spice runner

-Poe/Finn for the win- oh wait, never mind, we're introducing an old girlfriend

-Oh wait, never mind, the ex-girlfriend doesn't like him that way and was abusive towards him in Free Fall

-He's calm, cool, collected, and mature, and doesn't need to be told everything in TFA- oh wait, never mind, he's a hot-headed military maverick who DOES need to be told everything.

-There's a small chance of him appearing in The Mandalorian- oh wait, never mind, each season takes place different years. If he was going to appear, it would have been in season 2, so nope! (This was just a theory/wish of mine. Nothing official was said. But still...)

-Poe's parents had a storyline in the main Star Wars comics, and the Empire knows about Poe (Commander Zahra uses [a picture of] Poe as leverage against Shara to talk. Oh, wait, never mind, it's not that important. It's just for shits and giggles, and Shara dies a depressing and lonely death in space of bloodburn in 10 ABY

I mean, to be fair, they did that to Rey and Finn, too. She's a secret Kenobi- oh wait, never mind, she's a nobody. Oh wait, never mind, she's a Palpatine. Finn will be a Jedi- oh wait, never mind, he's a janitor who screams "REY!" every five seconds. He's in love with Rose- oh wait, never mind, he has a crush on Rey. Oh wait, never mind, he likes Jannah now.

They did that more with Poe, though.

Seriously, though, what is the freaking point in adding all those interesting plot threads (Force tree, Shara's death, Zorii) if they're just not going to use them?!

I wonder what the next aspect of Poe's life they're going to change their minds on.

-Poe's ring necklace used to be his mother's. He wears it in hopes of giving it to his partner one day- oh wait, never mind, it's a silly souvenir from the Ring of Kafrene?

-Poe argues with Rey all the time and doesn't like her that much. Oh wait, never mind, he's secretly in love with her?

...Actually, I wouldn't mind that last one...

[falllpoutboy]

its so funny how lucasfilm has been in crisis mode for the last 2 years. boba fett show flopped, obi wan was mid, mando s3 flopped, ahsoka flopped, the acolyte has no release date in sight, filoni and favreau decide to double down on their last 3 flops and a crossover movie is announced, taika’s movie got canceled and rians movie trilogy still has no official production date (thank god)

[thatfantasylovingdork]

sounds like your problem is that you're only looking for rep in children's shows, maybe branch out your tastes a bit and you'll find there's more rep. assuming that that's actually what you want, cause this all still feels like you being uncomfortable with diversity cause of your upbringing or something and looking to shit on ppl for being excited for rep

I’m only uncomfortable with diversity because I feel like I’m supposed to be. There are so many people on the internet who will ruin any kind of diversity and have companies cancel shit that idk what side I’m supposed to be on.

Also as I’ve said, I’ve gotten my hopes up for rep in the past and gotten bit in the ass for it, so I’m very very hesitant to trust any company who tries to add diversity to a show. I expect the rug to be pulled under me cuz it’s happened to me before (fuck you, Lucasfilm in particular. You gave us rep then took it away just because of internet dudebros complaining. I hope you all rot in hell).

If anyone wants to recommend me stuff that has good rep that isn’t erased for the sake of overly conservative people, *Optimus Prime voice* lay it on me, man! I could use some good stuff to watch/read.

Hope this helped!

[dalekofchaos]

The problem with Rey choosing to rebuild the Jedi Order and take the Skywalker name

When I look back on Rey's journey throughout the trilogy is that it's apparent to me that she really doesn't show a desire to be a Jedi.

In The Force Awakens, Rey wanted to find her family, she is mesmerized by so much green in the galaxy and ultimately protecting her friends.

In The Last Jedi she wanted to find her place in the story and bring Ben back to the light. Rey ultimately comes to terms with the fact that she wasn't born into any powerful bloodlines and made peace with her family being gone. Rey forged her own heroine's path and it worked.

In the Rise of Skywalker, Rey goes back to the same hairstyle she had since she was a child and the same outfit in TFA, but in white, it's like all the growth from the last movie never happened. Rey's motivation is whatever the plot demanded it to be. She wants to "earn" Luke's Lightsaber(fuck you JJ) and she wants the Jedi to be with her. Now it's a plot convenience to stop the bad guys. And she's in killmode everytime she sees Ben. Now the uplifting message that she's not related to anyone is gone, she's related to the literal Satan of the Star Wars universe. Now she wants to kill Palpatine out of revenge. Now she has this new found reverence for "Master Skywalker" when it was never there to begin with. It's only because of Ben's redemption that she doesn't strike Palpatine in anger. Ben dies, Rey goes to the literal tomb of the Skywalkers and symbol of the family's misery, buries the sabers and takes their name.

TROS absolutely destroyed Rey’s characterization. In a way that’s kind of mind blowing actually. She’s definitely meant to be a parallel character to Luke, but Rian purposely wrote it to subvert fan expectations. A lot of people probably saw the story trajectory following the OG trilogy after TFA, which had a very similar vibe to ANH. However while both Luke and Rey start out as mysterious nobodies, Luke very much did not want to be Vader’s son. His curse was being the son of this monster, and finding out the truth about his lineage. Meanwhile, for Rey, it’s literally the exact opposite. She wants desperately to be apart of something. Kylo points out her weakness perfectly in TLJ- “Your parents threw you like garbage… But you can't stop needing them. It is your greatest weakness. You're looking for them everywhere… in Han Solo… now in Skywalker.” Rey wanted to apart of something bigger than herself to belong. While Luke’s hero’s journey started by accepting his parentage, Rey should’ve begun by accepting that she alone was enough, and she deserved a place in this story for her own merits.

TROS absolutely dismantles this by having Rey discover she’s actually related to the big bad (just like Luke), which somehow earns her a place at the table. Except unlike Luke, who had 3 films prior to truly hate/come to terms with Vader, Rey meets Palpatine in the very last movie, and he essentially becomes a villain-of-the-week or a Marvel villain of sorts. There’s no build up. Rey’s powers suddenly need to be “explained” to the audience, via her lineage, and it’s horrendous because the message of the prior films showed that anyone can have the force. Also Rey suddenly having an attachment to Luke or the Jedi order makes no sense from her character’s perspective. It feels as if Rey is supposed to represent the audience, and her worship of Luke is reminiscent of how fans (who’ve had 47 years of Star Wars fandom prior) should feel about him. But Rey as an individual, as a character, should not view Luke in this way. They did not get along in TLJ, and in the long run, his impact on her was very minimal. And by clinging to past ideas, it just shows Kylo Ren/Ben Solo was right. She can’t stop needing parental figures to feel loved/belonged. She needs to carry that torch.

Now Rey is expected to be this Jedi Master 15 years later.

Here's the problem. Rey has never shown a desire to be a Jedi. It's just something that was necessary to become. They never explored what Rey wanted.

“People keep telling me they know me. No one does” neither did JJ Abrams or DLF, apparently.

To me, Rey's desires were to have a family, to live on a green planet and to live in peace with Ben, her other half. While Ben's story should have been actually completing what Anakin. Saving the one he loved and starting a family.

Ben died and so instead of giving what Rey wanted, she's given what JJ Abrams and DLF wanted, a Jedi's life of duty instead of a desire of love and family.

Now it feels like Rey is going to be like they ended things the way they did so Rey could succeed leading a Jedi Order where Luke failed and to me, that's boring, might as well just say Rey is going to become Legends Luke.

For me, personally, the more interesting story moving forward would be having Rey go darker. Completely subverting fan expectations, but I know Disney won’t do this. However, based on how TROS ended off, I think it could be an interesting way of continuing the story and re-gaining interest from fans who’ve become bored with the same formula.

Just imagine. Rey founded a new Jedi Order, but Rey isn't happy. She thought this is what she wanted, but it isn't. She does her best to mask her feelings from her students and fellow Jedi Council members, but deep down she knows what she wanted is long gone. "But what if he can come back" she thought to herself. she grows darker and starts committing dark acts to bring Ben back. If she condemned herself to the dark side, so be it. If her own Jedi Order turns against her, so be it. She throws away the Skywalker name and leaves the past behind her. She will find Kylo's helmet, wears his sweater and take his title. The force took her other half, so Rey will rip apart the force to bring him back.

Sources

TROS Concept Art

Pablo Ruiz

reyreybutt

clari.saiyazam

[caripr94]

Rogue One/Sequel Trilogy Salt

'A New Hope' is the story of a boy who grows up in a tranquil home and dreams of joining a war. What if we have the story of a girl who grows up in a war and dreams of returning to the tranquillity of home?

Gareth Edwards

This quote is evidence that Jyn Erso was written to be a foil to Luke Skywalker. Before Rogue One came out, I and a bunch of other fans were speculating Jyn to be Luke's wife and Rey's mom (due to the resemblance to Rey, the speculation about Rey being Luke's daughter, and the parallels between Jyn and Luke (and between Jyn and Mara Jade, Luke's Legends wife, to the point where it seemed like Jyn might become the Disney canon version of Mara)). Even after the film came out, I was still hoping for Jyn to pull a Phil Coulson for that, particularly with that kyber crystal necklace she had.

Years later, after Lucasfilm has mangled up Rey's origins along with the latter two sequels, I haven't completely given up on that idea, but it's been barely on my mind, and I've been torn between that and Jyn's relationship with Cassian Andor. But now, reading that quote has stirred up my feelings towards the former (and from what I've been recently reading about Cassian, he's kind of old for her anyway). It seems like a great opportunity that Lucasfilm has wasted.

@araitsume @aomoviegeek @reynaberrieorgana @fyeahreysky @finnrey-skywalker @roselani24 @jonesgirl88 @tragicfantasy-girl @vaderdala1541

[lunarspiral1127]

........WHAT?!?!

The fact that Temuera Morrison was supposed to be in s3 of The Mandalorian but he never got the call and was left waiting.....he deserves better, the character of Boba Fett deserves better, and we the fans deserve better. And here I thought my anger at the show would lessen now that the season is over.

[grimlocksword]

Based Critic calls The Acolyte a DISASTER! Kathleen Kennedy's DREAM lesb...

[lordofhunger47]

[deafblindshorty]

So...does the Lucasfilm Story Group know that a lot of fans don't like the Poe the former spice runner thing? Or do they just not care? Because that little reminder keeps popping up everywhere (The Timelines book, the TROS novel, the Star Wars facts book, the TROS VOD, Free Fall, the ROTJ Rebellion comic...).

I mean, they bring that up more than they do the fact that Rey is Palpatine's granddaughter. Just saying.

[caripr94]

Yes, and in addition to that, I just realized that before Orson Krennic found them, the Ersos were hiding out in a homestead on a farm on Lah'mu. Jyn Erso grew up on a farm, just like Luke! If Lucasfilm didn't want us to ship them, they shouldn't have given us so many parallels between them and a potential daughter who resembles and parallels both of them.

It's been long confirmed that "Rey Palpatine" was something that they came up with at the last minute. There's also been rumors that JJ Abrams had made a whole other cut of TROS, with Rey as Luke's daughter, before the executives hijacked the project and reshot everything. If they could only give us that cut like they gave us Zack Snyder's cut of Justice League and at least keep the Skymom vague enough that we could plug in Jyn, it could possibly make up for everything. But we'd probably have to wait until Lucasfilm crashes and burns so that someone else can take over and reboot everything after Rogue One.

SkyRogue could have been so good, so poetic. If the rumors are true and Jyn’s father was a leading scientist in creating the Death Star who hated his creation and helped to take it down then Rey would have two grandfathers who helped build something monstrous and oppressive. Two grandfathers who then helped their children demolish the horrors that they had created. The poetic parallels. The history of darkness and light. It would have been so good. 

[wetsocksinbed]

sometimes I think about the fact that when the Jedi were founded, there were very different rules (going by Pre-Disney novels, anyway). Attachment wasn’t forbidden. Love and marriage were allowed. You could show emotion and feel things without being scared of falling to the dark side. The Jedi were powerful beings who protected the galaxy while simultaneously also having families and loved ones. Who decided to change that? Who woke up one day and decided to implement those extremely cult-like behaviours? Obviously putting those rules into place would cause more problems for everyone. Was it Yoda? Was it the previous Grand Master?

As Anakin mentioned in Star Wars the Clone Wars, by Karen Traviss, it was incredibly hypocritical for Ki Adi Mundi to be allowed multiple wives and still be on the council. Anakin was aware of the low male birth rate of Ki Adi’s species, but he was also aware that this kind of hypocrisy was something that would cause disillusion. On that topic, in No Prisoners, also by Karen Traviss, Ahsoka tells a clone that the Jedi are allowed to love, they just can’t have emotional attachments. Rightfully so, the clone is confused by this, because how can you love someone without being attached to them?

As someone who grew up in a religious cult myself, it’s fascinating seeing similarities between what I grew up in, and the Jedi Order. Granted, the Jedi and the Republic were the lesser of two evils, but that was one of the reasons why the Jedi fell to easily. They were stuck in their ways of seeing everything black and white. They blindly saw the galaxy as being either “good” or “evil”, and refused to realise there could be people in between. The Jedi only helped planets if the planet agreed to side with them, instead of aiding a planet because of morality and justice. Whereas before the war, the Jedi valued all life and would help people without any kind of deal or reward.

Yoda was flawed. Mace Windu was flawed. The people put in place to guide the Jedi became complacent and forgot what it meant to be peace keepers. Yoda realised this too late, and that is why he trained Luke differently to the rest of the Jedi.

anyway that’s my little rant done. I still hate the sith more than the Jedi so I guess I’m still pro Jedi, but I like the High/Old Republic much better