#loss of parental figure
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Ship in a Bottle
Whumping the Whumpers - Part Twenty-Five
(tw: child abuse, bad caretaking, broken nose, broken glass, character death, alcohol consumption, mourning, loss of parental figure, homicidal compulsions, hallucinations, blood, corpse mention, knife, a very unhealthy outlook on handling emotional pain)
[Previous | Masterlist | Next]
“There- n-n-n-no no no- not quite like th…..YES - right there. That’s perfect - hold it exactly like that and I’ll do the glue…”
Ethan bit down on his tongue, eyes beady and focused on the little rope and the narrow piece of wood between his fingertips that held it in place. Every breath, heartbeat, and thought shifted it from position - but he was determined to prove to David that he could do this. That letting him help wasn’t a mistake.
David grins. Warm. His fingers pinch the piece just above Ethan’s to give the glue a little testing tug as it sets. “Perfect - I think that’ll do it.” He twists it away again, and picks up the minuscule bottle, looking over the fine details and the line of thread they’d just run from the foremast.
Ethan smiled too - smiling came easy with David. His was infectious - Caroline always said so. When David was gone, the little foster family was mundane if anything. They kept to themselves and kept quiet. Just the constant thrum of reality tv buzzing through the house and down to Ethan’s room in the basement.
But then David would come. And the tv would turn off. The house would light up - Caroline would smile, giggling even, when he kissed her.
David’s workshop made up the second room of the basement - right next to Ethan’s. Ethan usually just lingered in the doorframe, watching him work - but this time, David let him help. He couldn’t afford to mess it up.
-
The car door clicked shut behind him, muffled further by the snow that crunched under his feet.
It was a small cemetery. Rural.
Evidently David’s family had some kind of plot.
It had taken Ethan weeks of searching for David when he finally escaped. After all those years of running and bleeding and screaming, all he wanted was to sit in silence next to the man and watch him build a boat. Even just one more time.
It took weeks because that’s how long it took Ethan to cave. To check the obituaries.
And there he was.
-
David ruffled Ethan’s hair. And for once, Ethan didn’t mind. The touch didn’t seem to be malicious or self-serving. Just absentminded affection and affirmation.
He handed the little bottle to Ethan to look over. The glass was warm at his fingertips, retaining light and that extant goodness that poured from David’s skin. Like a little of his life seeped into the boats he made.
Maybe that’s why they looked so real.
A three-beat stomp from upstairs made the little thing flinch at his fingers; it was quickly followed by a voice- “DAVID IT’S ALMOST TWO IN THE MORNING GET THE KID TO BED”
David blinked rapidly, and turned incredulous eyes to his watch. “Ah shit-” He knocked back the rest of his tumbler of whiskey and stood up, “YEAH- ONE SEC-” He sucked air in through his teeth, shrugging a ‘whoopsie?’
Ethan bit down on a laugh, setting the bottle carefully back on the tabletop as David snapped off the light. “Thanks for letting m-”
“No thank-yous, just get your ass to bed before she beats mine.” He nudged Ethan playfully toward the door.
Ethan squeaked, but moved easily, heading toward his room. “...tomorrow can we-”
“-oh yeah, I’ll be here when you get back from school. I won’t start without you.”
Ethan turned a grin to him as he reached his door, ducking inside. “Sweet - I’ll see you then.”
-
Graves lined up in only semi-reasonable rows. Some were off. Some were big. Some small. Some rusted over or draped in lichen. Some pearly and grand.
Ethan knew the name of the cemetery.
He hadn’t gotten the time or the heart to check it - so he had no idea where it was.
The cemetery was small, but not that small. There were hundreds of headstones here.
And he had to check them all.
Air pressed against his tight throat, elbowing its way inside.
It pressed out again as Ethan’s phone buzzed.
He flicked a glare up to the dry, grey sky. Anything to put this off a little longer…
He slipped it out, scanning the message - then shooting back a reply, ignoring his quickly-numbing fingertips.
Bestie 😘: when r u coming home?
Me: I literally just left.
Bestie 😘: that doesnt answer the question
Me: Idk like an hour or two?
Bestie 😘: cool, I got time then
Me: Time for what.
Bestie 😘: making soup
Me: What kind?
Bestie 😘: butternut squash
Me: Haven’t had it.
Bestie 😘: well ur gonna and ur gonna like it
Me: Optimist.
Bestie 😘: realist
Me: Again. Optimist.
Bestie 😘: whats wrong with a little optimism?
Ethan didn’t answer.
He just tucked the phone and his fingers back into the warmth of his pockets, finally starting his search in earnest.
-
Ethan bounded down the stairs with the ghost of a smile lingering on his lips long after he’d bitten it back. Time to finish the model. Add the last touches of stain and shading.
It was going to be done.
Ethan was going to finish making something.
Something in his own hands that he could be proud of.
He dumped his backpack on the ground and rounded the corner into the little workshop. “I’m here! David, I-”
He saw the wreckage before he heard Caroline’s choked sob.
Splinters of boats littered the ground, haphazardly strung together with bits of rope and string. Frays of stretching glue that refused to let go.
Stomped to crumbled lumps of pieces.
The whole collection.
Ethan just…gaped at her as she swiped the little bottle off the table - the smallest piece yet, trying to process what he was seeing.
“N-no don’t! Don’t that one’s n-” his voice choked out into nothing as the glass shattered against concrete.
He lurched forward, a sob catching in his throat.
He was barely in range as her elbow threw up to block his advance.
Whitehot embers exploded behind his eyes as his nose crunched back. It dazed him - sent stars sparking across the air.
Still, he scrambled forward, ignoring the warm wet spreading sensation as he scrabbled for the tiny ship stranded amongst the wreckage of its brethren.
-
There it was.
He’d missed it the first pass. The stone was small. Almost flush with the ground. The name, engraved in metal and bolted to the small rectangular stone.
The world seemed to stop completely. Any remnant of a breeze ceased. Birds stopped chirping. Squirrels ceased their chases.
He just stared at the stone, feeling the burn of the nonexistent wind ripping the moisture from his eyes.
-
“Wh-why- what are you doing!? David’s gonna-”
“Do NOT say his name - cheating fucking bastard-!” An invisible string jerked him to a stop as her food crunched down on the tiny thing.
Ethan stared as her foot pulled away to punt some other bit of scrap - already torn asunder, though evidently not enough for her.
Bits of glass and wood pressed into his jeans, pricking at his knees as blurred, bony fingers scooped up the precious tiny thing from the floor.
The foremast was snapped completely off. He plucked it up, vibrating with the force of a sob he kept swallowing as he tried to pinch it back into place - but the ship was crumpled. Sideways and wrong.
Then was snatched out of his hand.
Ethan stared up at Caroline, tears spilling down his blank face. “Wh-where is he-?”
“It doesn’t fucking matter.”
“Pl-ease lemme see him-”
Ethan didn’t recoil as the slap snapped his head to the side. He just let his face turn, eyes dead on the ground as the pain wrapped around his head.
“Are you kidding me!? You’re never seeing him again. I don’t want to hear another word about that disgusting drunk.”
She stepped past him, pausing at the door to look back on his kneeling form.
“..don’t you dare cry over that piece of shit. You’re sixteen goddamn years old. Act like it.”
Then she was gone.
The creaking footsteps pulling a flinch from him every stair.
He stared down at the tiny foremast between his fingers. Barely a sliver of wood now.
He didn’t move for hours. His mind wouldn’t let him. He just stared at the little splinter, rolling it between his fingers as the blood ran from his nose. Gradually stopped. Dried.
Then the puddle of it started to film. Fray at the edges. Crack.
Finally, numb, he tucked it into his pocket, stood, and grabbed a broom to clean up this mess.
-
Cool earth seeped into his jeans, chilling the skin at Ethan’s knees. It sent pinpricks of acid shooting up his leg - he ignored them. The pain was fake. Just cold.
He swirled the little foremast between his fingers. Rain and decay has softened it a bit. Cracked it. Made it more akin to cork than mahogany.
Still. It was David’s. Its condition didn’t change that.
Ethan didn’t want to have some dramatic fucking graveside speech. He didn’t want to pull the ‘I don’t know if you can hear me, but if you can…’ bullshit.
David wasn’t there. He couldn’t hear a thing. His ears were probably close to rotted off six feet under where Ethan stood. He hoped to hell that ghosts weren’t real. Ethan didn’t believe in heaven, so no good there. And if reincarnation was a thing, then David wouldn’t be here anyway.
So he didn’t say anything. There wasn’t a point.
He just set the little sliver of wood in front of the stone, tucking it a little under so it couldn’t blow away.
They’d keep each other company, these two dead, broken things.
They belonged together.
-
Ethan pressed the door open with half as much force as a breath, letting it slowly push away from him in a wide arc.
Silent.
He stepped inside the room.
In the moonlight, everything glowed white. Caroline always liked white.
White shag rug on dark floorboards. White sheets. White blankets.
White pillowcase stained with her smearing mascara and darkened by a puddle of tears.
White walls.
White sheer curtains that let in white moonlight.
But all Ethan could see was red.
Deep, thick, oily red splashed across the perfect, pristine room.
Red seeping through the blankets. Melding through her nightgown.
He could see it spreading dark and smeared across the floor, soaking into the rug as she dragged herself across the floor. Gurgling. Desperately reaching for the door.
Red splattering the walls.
Red pooling through her whiteblond hair.
Red on his hands.
On the knife.
It twitched between his fingers. Beckoned to him. Begged him.
But Ethan didn’t obey its call.
He just walked back out of the room, closed the door softly, felt its weight between his fingers as he pressed it - still clean - back into its place in the knife block.
He didn’t sleep that night, riddled with woken dreams of what he might have done.
-
Ethan didn’t linger. Only a moment of silence marked his grieving before he pushed up off his knees.
Stood.
He turned back toward the car, leaving the graveyard without a word. Without a backward glance.
David was dead. There was no point dwelling on it.
Still. The tears were stubborn, skittering hot down his cheeks anyway.
He brushed them away as fast as they came.
Time to move on.
.
[Previous | Masterlist | Next]
.
[Previous | Masterlist | Next]
(tags: @prisonerwhump, @whumpawink, @mabledonut, @heathenwhump, @paleassprince, @happy-little-sadist, @wormwriting, @distinctlywhumpthing, @whump-cafe @jo-doe-seeking-inspo @azayta @wibbly-wobbly-whump @batfacedliar-yetagain @there-will-always-be-blood @siren-of-agony @whumpworld @bandages-andobsessions @deltaxxk @whumpasaurus101 @michaeltalks @pickywhumpreader @whumpberry-cookie @morning-star-whump @shelfsdesires @throwawaywhumper @the-mourning-stars @d-cs @suspicious-whumping-egg)
As always, lmk if you want to be added to the tag list!
#child abuse#minor whump#bad caretaking#broken nose#broken glass#character death#alcohol consumption#mourning#loss of parental figure#homicidal compulsions#hallucinations#blood#corpse#knife#someone please get ethan to a therapist#whumping the whumpers#david#ethan#Spotify
42 notes
·
View notes
Text
@phisworld14 these all directly follow up from your ask!
🥺 chap2 of helper - a/b/o hangster
"What?" No, seriously what? What was she talking about? They had tried to argue with her about what he had in his papers? "Mav tried arguing with me about who you'd want to help and Bagman tried to suggest you'd want anyone but him to help you out." Phoenix made sure he was looking at her before she rolled her eyes at him. "
🔥 virgin jake - hangster
"I think not," she teased. "Seriously though, how bad did you fuck up with this, Brad Brad?" "Don't call me that," he whined before letting out a long, heavy sigh, choosing not to give her a verbal answer. He knew he’d pay for it but he really did not want to put into words what an absolute dumbass he’d been when dealing with Jake. "Seriously, Bradshaw, is it really that fucked up or are you just blowing shit out of proportion because your ass is dramatic?"
💔 icemav break up / icedad
"It looks like Mav won't be able to make it after all, kiddo," Ice says after a moment of floundering on how to phrase it. "Oh." "I can try and see if I can pull in a favor or two?" he offers halfheartedly. Though he really isn't sure if he'd be able to do much. Not with graduation being in less than two weeks. And already devoting most of his energy outside of his offices to dealing with Carole.
Make Nixie Write This Weekend!
#nixie answers#make nixie write#hangster#phisworld14#sereshaw#who helps the helper#again phoenix will throw hands at people for not respecting her and knowing her bestie's wishes#my patron my heart#natasha WILL be roasting bradley for the rest of time#because it is both her right and her delight to do so#icedad#mav and carole making ice's life hard since 1986#mav and carole are really NOT the best in this one#mostly because they're always written as like. these great parent/parent figures for bradley#and never enough about what the loss of goose did to them#and i'm playing around with that in this au#so.....it definitely won't be for everyone#but also it's about time we got some not great carole and mav and grief
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
you are watching mythic quest season 3. i am watching the mythic quest season in my mind where cws death has an actual effect on most of the characters that prompts their development. we are not the same
#someone ask me to elaborate (PLEASE)#jk i’ll do it anyways#i just think that. for me death is something that is very emotional and to see it unutilised here is disappointing to say the least#like the fear of death coping with loss is something i KNOW these fuckers aren’t equipped to handle#and it doesn’t effect all of them and it’s not cw all centric#ian has a midlife crisis rachel loses her creative mentor david starts thinking about death and how people will#remember him (s2ep8 callback) we even saw brad moved at that bit to stay close to your friends!#poppy is too shunned to care dana is too emotionally healthy and doesn’t know cw that well jo. jo#david being in this state can also help brad show jo he’s weak (seeds of doubt in david’s leadership)#and ALSO dana not having an emotional reaction to cws death can also create#more of a rift between her and ian because it’s something she just can’t relate to#ian also mourning in silence also would’ve been so much fucking sadder after sarian knowing the two parental figures that admired and#inspired his creativity are gone#god#this show is evil anyways#also i have a long sad letter cw would write rachel from the grave would y’all like to see that#mythic quest#kaitlinshottakes#poppy li#brad bakshi#ian grimm#cw longbottom#jo mythic quest#rachel mythic quest#dana mythic quest
281 notes
·
View notes
Text
So I got a phone call from my mom this afternoon letting me know that my family’s dog, Takaya, is being put to sleep tomorrow afternoon.
This has been a long time coming for sure; I found out her health was in decline from my dad a month ago when he came to visit, but I’d hoped she might be able to make it into the new year.
I did a facetime with my mom tonight to say goodbye to her face to face before she gets put down, and to put it lightly I feel pretty miserable. She’s been a part of our family for a long time; I think we estimated that she was about 15 years old. She’s been such a good dog and was always so energetic and I’m going to miss her deeply. It feels even worse that I can’t be there in person to say goodbye, as I’m in a city a twelve hour drive away.
So’untë & nenyusten’, Takaya. Misiyh for all the memories and happiness you brought to our life.
#cw pet loss#cw pet death#cw animal death#I’m. probably gonna be a bit more inactive even more now.#finals are already hard but now I’m just trying to figure out how I’m gonna find the energy to go to class at all.#edit: as of rn it's 5:15 the next day and she's been put to sleep about 45 minutes ago.#my parents were both there and said it was peaceful#i wish i could've been there too
40 notes
·
View notes
Text
I just checked the word count on the main Chissezra au gdoc and. well. I sure hope somebody out there wants to read over 21000 words of Ezra Bridger building a life for himself in the Chiss Ascendancy
#deliberately pursuing the unpopular position that sometimes you wake up and you're 30 and you do not want to go back to your teenage life#and the wierd way four years as a teenager can feel like forever; defining; but then you realize it was ONLY four years#the value and legitimacy of long distance friendships and caring for someone but not missing them#oh and also the loss of a parental figure and how you will forever be imagining what they would think of you now#idk this was never even supposed to be an actual fic and yet here we are#star wars why?#blablabla textpost#chissezra au
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
the concept of having children being so tied into political ambitions and machinations throughout history means that a lot of people do seem to straight up forget that these people were, like, family, and likely acted as such a lot of the time
#personal#a post brought to you by three things#thing one: i got woken up at five am by some kind of fire truck so i'm tired and babbling#thing two: remembered how people get Weird about catherine of aragon and anne boleyn's miscarriages#and seem to completely ignore that for all the dynastic ambitions of it all these were also wanted pregnancies by both parents#and those losses came with heavy emotions behind them as well as physical trauma#and thing three: i tried reading an episode summary of that horrible domina show to see what the fuck was going on there#and what do you MEAN augustus agrees to kill one of his stepsons???? those are his fucking kids!!!!!!#like he's a human being who raised one of them since literal birth and the other since very early childhood!!!!#it makes SENSE that he'd be emotionally attached and view them as his children just as much as julia!!!!#that's just how human beings and human emotions work!!!!#honestly why even tell a story about historical figures if you're not gonna acknowledge their humanity in your writing#instead of making them one note caricatures#(it's why the tudors works and domina can go fuck itself)#(for this and its litany of other sins)#(anyway i'm gonna go back to thinking about augustus and his role as a father specifically that's always a fun time for me)
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
anyway sorry if i get all schloppy emotional on my blog for the holidays these last few months of the year can hold so much trauma lol
#my grandma died in nov and my grandpa died jan1#and i was raised to spend the holidays with a huge extended family that im no longer on speaking terms with bc im a fag#so like man you think seasonal depression is bad stack it up w the death of my caregivers and loss of my whole family structure and#well. LOL#its been almost 10 years but losing your parental figures so young and then rapidly realizing the rest of your family Does Not Like You uh#it gets easier but not THAT much easier 🫰
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Laszlo calling Guillermo "the boy"
#you were all right#he's still mourning the loss of his baby colin#and now he's found someone else in need who needs him as a parent figure almost#wwdits season 5#pride parade
13 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ngl I've been having a gender crisis again on top of all the stuff that's happened with my dad, I think I still identify as male/masculine idk 🗿
Same with my ace/aro spectrum placement ☝️🗿
#comet rambles#putting in queue to deploy later#parent loss tw#just in case by association n implications ☝️🗿/nm+gen#when i get stuff set up with my checking account i was already thinking of getting a new chest binder once our personal issues with finance#has been figured out definitely#i dont wanna say much n jinx stuff so ill leave it at that#personal#gender shit is hard n i really think i may be a he/they or he/him still#or if not then closeted butch lesbian idk#most signs point to male gender identity leaning though 😔👍#also my social battery is outta wack but i needed to get this out so i apologize to anyone who i have yet to respond to/gen+nm ���#like i genuinely still feel as though ive been born in the wrong body and i tried to accept my feminity and it went well!!#like i started embracing my femininity the past few years and now i think im over it because it feels like i just attempted to try#and be something i wasn't if that makes any sense#i hate being referred to as she/her or as a girl even if i understand some people will still see me as fem despite my personal identity etc#its not that i hate my femininity its just i feel anything but female while still enjoying traditionally fem stuff at times#hope this makes sense#🗿👍#still ace/aro though just cant figure out if i only enjoy the thought of romance (cupiosexual/romantic) or if i feel comfy in one#i know im sex repulsed though thats for certain#as of lately chris Redfield and Albert Wesker have become two of my transition goals and idk what to do about this lmfao#i wish i was kidding#but im not 😭#sitting here like EVA shinji with his head in his hands in the damn chair image/lh#also wanna be a rootin tootin goth cowboy 🥰#if it turns out im like a comphet butch/nb lesbian im gonna shit myself though/lh+nm
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
I have often got too attached to people in life who can be seen as “parental figures” after losing caregivers in life. I realise this probably hasn’t been fair on them but also on some level for me too as I have usually ended up hurt and then they also leave after promising they wouldn’t. 💭
#Mental Health#Grief#Loss#Awareness#Understanding#Fighting#Healing#Recovery#Progress#Attachments#Parental Figures#Psychology#Childhood Wounds#Growth#Learning#Personal#Thoughts
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
tempted to make a ebeg post but also theres so many other things going on that i wanna just stick to getting money via commissions but also i can b arely draw right now so. u can see the struggle
#vent#fighting tooth and nail like ohhhh you live with your parents youre fine you dont need to ask for money#when i am one sudden loss of money away from the negatives. and cant always ask them for thigns.#and theyre also on a new diet so theres less things in the house and i feel like im going backwards in terms of how much i eat which sucks#sorry for complaining on main. feel bad complaining to friends. might delete later#uh. my pypl dot me is just violetkat if anyone does want to offer an extra 3 bucks or smth#idk. ill figure myself out after i eat something
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm not crying, you're crying!
~
Disney's (and Pixar's) and Dreamworks' (and xxxxx) underrated "old" movies such as Dinosaur or Spirit, Balto and Aristocats, Brother Bear or Rise of the Guardians, Atlantis and Treasure Planet, even Hercules or Lilo & Stitch e.g., and yes, some of the newer ones as well, will forever have a special place in my heart and are in fact some of my childhood (and all-time) favorites ..
but those two lovely little ladies had me crying several times now and I don't think that's gonna stop anytime soon, family deaths just hit too close to home these past years
#coco 2017#mama coco#moana 2016#gramma tala#family death#loss of a loved one#loss of a parent#maternal figures#grief#childhood memories#children's movies
5 notes
·
View notes
Text
i have a really nice relationship with my mom except for the times when in my heart i’m like i miss her so much so badly and she’s literally like. in her bedroom and I’m in mine. and that’s not her that’s my weird brain.
#idk ruminating on parental figures and the inherent feeling of Loss of Missing Someone of A Want To Be Understood and Listened To…#samael speaks
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
When you come out as trans your family will tell you it's like processing a death and you're expected to be patient and hold space for them to feel that way. And not be offended by how absurdly melodramatic and disrespectful that sentiment is
#like that's stupid and a skill issue if you think your child not coming to embody the simulacrum of them you constructed in your head#is so painful that it feels like grieving a death. and it's definitely not something your child is obligated to make you feel better about#like when my parents said this shit when i was 15 i was gracious and patient cuz it's what you're supposed to do or whatever#and i didn't understand that telling them they were wrong was an option at that age#but it really like. hurt my feelings. like I'm figuring out what makes me happy and gives me a will to survive#and you're saying it feels like a horrific loss... like ok
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
We don't talk enough about what it's like to grieve a parent that's still alive.
When they change. Either because they go through things in life and become different, or you just learn who they are outside of your clouded view from being their child.
When we're young, we rely on our parents. In my experience (and the experience of others I've talked to), it doesn't matter if they're good at parenting. It's our instinct to reveire them, to love them, to idolize them. And when they change, it's like you've lost them. In a way, you have. Because the person you knew, the one you loved, has disappeared in front of you. And only a shell of them remains. Someone with their face, their voice, the same scars, the same wrinkles by their eyes. But they aren't them.
And usually this happens in adolescence. When everything else in your life is already being questioned and changing. And the person you are supposed to turn to for support and guidance has abandoned you. And yet, they're still there. In your day to day, living with you, talking to you. But not there.
And you are left to grieve this relationship, this important person (maybe the most important person to you), this idol of yours. And nobody understands it. The parent you now have won't understand. Will feel attacked and defensive. And it's so incredibly isolating.
Maybe it's just me, but it is something so gut-wrenching and terrifying and emotional. In a time when you are naturally unable to properly regulate and understand those emotions. And we should just acknowledge it a little more.
#let me know your thoughts#does this make sense?#parents#parenting#grief#trauma#teenage years#childhood#loss of childhood#need i say more?#emotions?#never really figured out how to deal with those#re: this entire thing#doing my best out here#this is what happens when i bottle everything up#it comes out on a tumblr blog years later at 2 am#flying right out of that tightly packed bottle#making room for *new* traumas#check out the rest of my blog of you like this#and other info dumps of old wounds#sad vibes
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
regarding that last post... not that black butler's canon has to be uplifting or have dadbastian or a happy ending to be "good" (i'm actually partial to tragedies especially the cyclical kind and would love for the series to straight up end with despair and the collection on the contract lol) but i do think that toboso's largely fumbled the found-family/interpersonal,/introspective aspects of her story and sacrificed a lot of narrative and thematic meat there for low-brow and off-putting comedy.... which is really exactly all she does with ciel's trauma as well-- shallowly using it for the purposes of trauma porn and/or comedy/inappropriate fanservice.
ciel only seems to have reasonable responses to his trauma when its aesthetically convenient if that makes sense. i honestly could go as far as to say that she depicts his trauma fetishistically-- every instance i can recall of ciel having an extreme traumatic response (i.e. vomiting, flashbacks, psychosis) is represented with (imo but honestly.... i'd be shocked if this wasn't intentional...) sexual undertones. his episode during the green witch arc doesn't have one of these moments within the episode itself as far as i can recall, but certainly i think the preceding/inciting medical emergency that forces him and sebastian to bathe together contributes to the reoccurring sexualization of "sickness" (physical & psychological).
not to mention ciel's subsequent episode is treated as the dramatic peak of his ptsd and something that he "overcomes" through sheer force of will (and the threats of sebastian... neither of which are a proper/reasonable way to handle such an extreme trauma response) and doesn't really battle going forward in the story. of course a lot of stories take this "one dramatic moment and then its fixed" approach to representing mental illness, and it makes narrative sense for toboso to want to more or less settle that thread to gear up for the important blue cult arc, but i think toboso's handling of mental illness in general goes so far beyond suspension of disbelief and tastelessness that i think she should lowkey be brained for it. the way she intermittently writes ciel's traumatic experiences as something horrifying and wrong and to be given sympathy meanwhile relentlessly putting ciel in inappropriate fanservice situations that diminish the severity of csa & pedophilia as well as disrespect the complexities of trauma and turn them into comedy... mind boggling...
overall though i think that black butler shows a real mastery of narrative arcs while falling short in terms of character arcs. most of the time these arcs are shown in retrospect with the addition of new backstory, but it feels as if the characters in present have barely grown at all... not that every story has to be character driven and a static character type makes sense for someone like sebastian, but for all that ciel is a unique and mature thirteen year old due to the circumstances of his life, he is still a thirteen year old, and one that has experienced a significant trauma quite recently at that. not allowing him coming of age-esque character arcs considering all that sort of breaks the believability of his character imo.
but i think that coattails does a lot in staying loyal to ciel's character and experiences while also respecting his trauma and bringing the depth and flexibility of adolescence to his worldview and actions that toboso unfortunately seems disinterested in. i love that aforementioned chapter of coattails and its sentiments especially with how it reexamines ciel's actions at kelvin's manor and the worldview that lead to burning it down with the children inside... not that it was an out of character decision for ciel in the moment, but i think it established a lot more severe facts about his character and worldview than toboso is willing to address in her writing and therefore feels unresolved. coattails' remedy to that awkwardness by coming full circle is so intriguing and fulfilling in contrast... it shows how adolescence and trauma can work together to so completely convince one of hopelessness and yet how just a bit of hope can change that worldview entirely. literally just the honest love of a random dog and the mundane care of a guardian... there is a cure and it is this..... what da helllll....
#anyway as far as canon goes i genuinely dont care if sebastian never becomes softer or more human or paternal or whatever#i think examining the tiny ways in which he HAS become those things would be very intriguing but#what i do think would make for a way more compelling story was if ciel (and maybe others)#had more dynamic character arcs that contrasted sebastian's uninterest/inability to change#for ciel to slowly develop a worldview and desire for life that began to conflict with his 10 year old one#that so quickly forfeited his soul in a moment of total devastation and loss#or to begin thinking of sebastian as a parental figure no matter how small or unwanted or hated the thoughts#especially with a sebastian that wouldnt reciprocate ciel's regret of the contract or imprinting on him as a paternal figure#like if we're gonna do tragedy lets make it as tragic as possible pleaseeee#in some ways makes me think of spn if that makes sense. ep 1 and the final ep can be watched without missing anything#like if we go from 'ciel wants revenge and is fine having his soul taken' to#'ciel got revenge (however bittersweet it might be idk) and is fine having his soul taken' ending.....#i think that would be sort of boring#i think thats actually what's kind of bothered me about kss in recent years and left me really wanting from the story....#i love love love the narrative arcs and they're my favorite part but as far as the characters i feel like we're almost still at chapter one#why does any of this matter... how has this changed the characters... idk. i feel like we havent gotten much of that#disclaimer i havent read kss in a few years/am not caught up if im forgetting anything but 😭 i feel like i wouldve rememebred...#anyway. another thing i really love about coattails is that its written with sebastians pov and so brilliantly too#the author writes his voice (and everyone) so believably#literally not a single line feels like a throwaway or generalized narrator voice...#i keep thinking about the scene where abberline has his shoes on his head and sebastian thinks its stupid and absurd#and when abberline puts them back on his feet the describing line isnt just#'he put them back on his feet'#but 'he put them back on his feet where they belonged'#and 'where they belonged' is an unnecessary/assumed detail of the action itself but given its written from sebastian's pov#it further emphasizes how stupid and absurd he thinks the whole thing is. 'thats where they belong.... idiot....'#whatever. whateverrrrr.#i love this fic. my fav fic of all time forever i will never find another like it#i just watched the public school arc and was lowkey so disappointed that i had to reread coattails LOL#kss
1 note
·
View note