#i will not get into discourse
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
that article going around abt firefox's new ad program is annoying bc it's phrased as though "mozilla has finally TURNED on its people and is SELLING YOU OUT for cold hard cash!!" when. that's not what's happening. it is specifically being implemented to discourage tracking behavior, and literally all the data they are giving to advertisers is aggregate and anonymized, which is like, the opposite of what that post wants you to worry about, lol
#the nemesis speaks#unfortunately i don't have enough energy to like. campaign about this.#it's actually a really interesting tactic to discourage invasive tracking#basically giving individual advertisers a way to measure '% effectiveness of ad' without individual info getting attached to it#whatever anyway i'm going to bed. do NOT discourse on this post or i will get your ass
54K notes
·
View notes
Text
I just think that 'animals are living intelligent creatures that have feelings and deserve to be respected' and 'when done properly farming is beneficial to both people and animals and there's nothing wrong with raising and killing animals for food, clothing, and other products' are concepts that very much can and should coexist
#i think a lot of people get too carried away in farming discourse to actually remember both of these things#some people are so aggressively anti-farming that they forget that meat and fur are necessary for some people#and that farming helps prevent overhunting of certain species#but some people are so aggressively pro-farming that they begin to think of animals as objects#that only exist to provide them with a product#animals deserve to be treated with respect and be given the best care possible while they're alive#but that doesn't mean that its a bad thing for them to die
77K notes
·
View notes
Text
You know that Chris Fleming line that goes "Call yourself a community organizer even though you're not on speaking terms with your roommates"?
I honestly think every leftist who talks about the "revolution" like Christians talk about the rapture needs to spend a year trying to organize their workplace. Anyone who sincerely talks about building a movement so vast and all-encompassing that it overwhelms all existing power structures needs the dose of humility that comes with realizing they can't even build a movement to get people paid better at a badly run AMC Theaters where everyone already hates the manager.
#method speaks#union stuff#politics#i guess#best case scenario in this plan we get some successful union drives#worst case people realize that movement building is hard#and also explicitly mentioning socialism is counterproductive#mostly i'm just venting#it's only april how is election discourse this unhinged already?
20K notes
·
View notes
Text
post itself
false flags
trans/adjacent tags
accessibility features
tumblr live post (thanks for the link, @problemnyatic)
flashing / strobing / lights
unblockable flashing ad
buying ad free
staff @/macmanx guilt trip
list of staff + more issues
#post nuked bc proshippers started insulting people who rbed this and implied partyjockers attempted to Kill staff? it was getting old so#archive links still under the cut if you want and you can rb this from others if you want the og#hint: if you dislike this post or want to debunk parts of it the way to go about it isn't to call people who've rbed it 'disgusting little#fuck ups' that are 'spreading anti shipper lies'#note: this post is and was Not about ship discourse jesus fucking christ proshippers get a grip#also ace discoursers are here too? this isn't about you either?#edit 2: if you send me an anon regarding this post about how im policing discussion or 'don't really want it'#but then stop replying when i answer your ask#maybe that's. not helping discussion?#i nuked this post as people started making up false accusations to smear people staff sniped. aka accusing someone of IRL ATTEMPTED MURDERS.
39K notes
·
View notes
Text
i see you i love you i support you and want you in community spaces with me because we’re different sides of the same coin etc etc
#I’m not engaging with discourse at this time#nonbinary#14k wtf??#i did not expect something I made in under 5 minutes would get this much attention
28K notes
·
View notes
Text
I saw a post that said “Dragon Age discourse walked so that Baldurs Gate 3 discourse could run” and that’s absolutely false. Dragon Age discourse sprinted, foaming at the mouth, so that BG3 discourse could skip happily through a meadow
#that OP clearly wasn’t in the DA fandom when Inquisition came out lmao#people acted like mages were a real life opressed group#don’t even get me started on the discourse around which romance options were justified and which ones meant you were a bigot/abuser/etc#is Astarion existed in Dragon Age people would literallt never stop fighting about him I can tell u that much
4K notes
·
View notes
Text
vexillology
[ID: Three panel "Pills that make you green" comic.
Panel 1: An ochre person with a triangle-shaped body is standing on a stage in front of a curtain.
Ochre: Hey everyone and thanks for showing up today. As you're all probably familiar there's been a lot of discussion about the green pride flag, and how lots of people in the community aren't really represented by it. And while there are a lot of flags for subcommunities we're really missing a unifying one
Panel 2: Ochre person pulls away the curtain, revealing literally just the regular real life Pride flag to the crowd of a variety of people with a skew towards a greenish majority
Ochre: So I'm going to suggest we use this rainbow flag, as a symbolic representation of the full color spectrum
Panel 3: Zoom in on the ochre person looking vaguely dejected, saying "oh..." as criticisms come in from the crowd:
"I feel that this does a poor job representing mauve people"
"Get better at vexilology" [sic]
"That looks so weird"
"There's barely even any of the original green flag left!"
"Way too complicated"
"Orange people don't even have anything to do with green rights"
"What's next, charred brown with lava cracks in it for refugees from Former Italy?"
End ID]
Start - Previous - Next
#before someone reads the opposite of the intended message: I don't agree with the critics.#the joke is that they're responding to the common real-life pride flag as if it's some weird new idea#like the discourse every time something gets added to the progress flag#pills that make you green#ptmyg
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
making up a guy to get mad at can actually be really lovely and rewarding like for example i was feeling understimulated so i crafted an alternate world where moby dick was super popular on tumblr and the most popular ship from moby dick was ahab x humanized whaleboy merguy moby dick who was always drawn as like a skinny little white guy with white hair and sharp teeth and sort of unusual eyes like maybe with black scleras or something. and it was literally inescapable and people made like hannigram aus where will was ahab and hannibal was moby dick and people also made human!boatless!modern! aus of ahab x moby dick where they were just like normal guys as well. and the moby dick fandom all thought they were so cool and countercultural because melville's unfinished novella billy budd was also really popular and the billy budd fans were at odds with the moby dick fans because billy budd fans described it as like a heartfelt queer story in comparison to moby dick being toxic and soulless (because ahab was trying to kill moby dick in canon) and moby dick fans described billy budd as basically steven universe but none of this ended up mattering because in four years the meteors came and all life on earth was lost
if you are reading this please donate to $trextalents on cashapp; he is a disabled fx artist active in my city’s horror scene who is in a bad situation and needs financial aid. if you cannot donate, please reblog my pinned post with more information. the world of this post is not real, but logan is.
#it speaks!#i had to kill the world because i was getting too into the like ins and outs of discourse in this world.#nobody ever talked about any element of moby dick which was not ahab x moby dick btw. in this world#moby dick
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
why are ppl out there going "this thing is canon" "that thing is canon" in regards to bg3. who hurt you that you need to canonize things in an rpg with thousands of choices this badly
#i promise you will not die if the thing you really love is not canon#every day i am going thru dragon age discourse 2: electric boogaloo#nina talks#nina plays bg3#let me know if u want me to tag this as discourse bc trust me i get it
6K notes
·
View notes
Text
Sometimes you write an entire rant on a topic and then you choose to water your crops and erase it
#the post was about boys planet#i will not elaborate#i have chosen to be healthy#i will not get into discourse#<daily affirmations
1 note
·
View note
Text
Listening to Tumblr Users has taught me a lot of things about Trans Women. For example:
Every Trans Woman I disagree with about video games is a pedophile
Every Trans Woman I disagree with about politics is a Russian psyop and
Every Trans Woman I disagree with about transmisogyny is an androphobe
I can't wait to find out more ^^
#of course trans women aren't the only sort of people to get this treatment#but as a trans woman myself I have the most personal experience with this and it seems appropriate considering the current “discourse”#to focus on that aspect of all this
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
Anyway. Bi and Mspec Lesbians aren't a hotly "debated" topic or even new to queer culture, it's just the newest thing that bullies who REALLY want to be homophobic and even racist use to justify harassing gay people they don't like.
It's the thinnest possible veneer of progressive language wrapped around TERF and reactionary rhetoric so that they can feel righteous for forming an angry mob against vulnerable targets. If you're gullible enough to fall for the newest wave of bigotry within the queer community, and turn on your allies because they're "confusing" or "invading your spaces," the SAME way they turned on bi/pan labels, trans people, xenogenders, neopronouns, and aroace people before this, then get lost.
#No patience. Wither and rot.#These motherfuckers dogpiled the legend who leaked the no fly list because it identified as the wrong type of lesbian.#They will attack the people doing DIRECT ACTION over dumbfuck label discourse. Deeply unserious people.#Embarrassing to think that there are rubes out there who keep falling for this#For ALL our sakes I hope this is literally their first rodeos and they really haven't fallen for this bullshit twice.#But unfortunately I'm too old to be that hopeful.#I didn't get to see the big ''public block list'' made for us dirty queers who support or are bi/mspec lesbians but I hope I was on it#If a man is best judged by his enemies then exclusionists who echo terf rhetoric are the ones I WANT to have.#And ''public lesbian block list'' is in quotes because if you REALLY thought that such a thing wasn't a ''GO HARASS THESE PEOPLE'' charter-#--then you have a black mold where your brain used to be and it's rapidly eating into the bathroom tile you call a skull#Unironically you should not have a platform if you are THAT stupid or malicious to think it was anything BUT a harassment charter#I hope they're ashamed.#Context for those unaware: a flesh-eating amoeba created a public blocklist for people who supported bi lesbians#Minors and extremely small creators without big platforms were on that list#People got harassed but the most namely was Lockandkeyhyena who had people raiding his server with racial slurs and death threats.#I hope everyone involved sees who their ''allies'' are when they spread that sentiment.#A bunch of people ACTUALLY 'invading someone's space' to post the n-word and suicidebait.#THAT is who you appeal to. Sit with that.
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
Sometimes I wonder what Jiang Cheng could've become if his parents didn't instill a mix of "crippling fear of failure" and "impossibly high standards" in him. Cuz like, his dad was holding him to the vague standard of being as good as wwx, his mom yelling at him whenever he goofed around like wwx, and then both of them expressed disappointment when he's less successful than wwx. The thing both of them seem to ignore though is that wwx got where he is entirely because he had the freedom to fuck around and find out- he trained tirelessly because he made training fun for himself, he was innovative as a cultivators because he experimented and persisted through failures, and he was able to act in line with the Jiang clan moto because his actions had less political pull than members of the main family. Jiang Cheng on the other hand- if he fucked around he got told to "stop stooping to the level of servants." If his achievements were lesser than wwx's, he got either dismissed by his dad or yelled at by his mom to try harder. And if he picked fights with the Wens, they'd have an excuse to destroy his clan. Like ya- no shit that'd create an adult who's terrified of failure.
The kite game serves as such a good metaphor/embodiment of this set back- with Jiang Cheng never being able to shoot as far as Wei Wuxian because he pulls back and shoots closer the second he misses.
And its sad too because he's shown to be pretty brilliant when he's in "fuck it, we ball" mode. Like, when he's not freezing up, he manages to pull off things like rebuilding his entire clan from the ground up, leading armies and taking back territories from the Wens, and I'm fairly sure he's the only character we see counter the Lan music cultivation techniques (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong on that last one. Also feel free to add any of the other cool shit he did that I'm blanking on at the moment, cuz I know I'm forgetting something).
That being said- even with his anxiety, he's still one of the top cultivators. Imagine what a force of nature he'd be if he could sustain "fuck it we ball" mode
#jiang cheng#jiang fengmian critical#madam yu critical#jiang cheng positive#<- there. its tagged properly so you better not @ me antis#mdzs meta#mdzs#long post#jiang cheng would've been too powerful so his parents decided to nerf him#unfortunate i had this thought around the same time as the discourse is happening and I'm probably inviting trouble with this but eh-#maybe I'll get lucky and the antis will leave me alone#I'm being critical of Madam Yu here but this is NOT a Madam Yu hate blog#I will block depending on how far “criticism” of her goes#apparently I need to add in this edit too- THIS IS NOT A WWX BASHING POST. I WILL BE DELETING ANY COMMENTS WITH WWX BASHING IN THEM
830 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm generally not a fan of quantifying oppression or looking at it as a scoreboard, but I frequently hear the claim that if you read the data, it will show that trans women are indisputably the most oppressed of all trans people, and isn't comparable to the level of oppression trans men face. And I looked at some data, from the UK's National LGBT Survey (I was referring to it for some data on transheterosexuality so I had it on hand).
The survey included 3,740 trans women and 3,170 trans men.
Being LGBT in the UK:
Average comfort level being LGBT on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the most satisfied: 3.10 for trans women, 3.15 for trans men
Average life satisfaction on a scale of 1-10, 10 being the most satisfied: 5.07 for trans men, 5.52 for trans women
The data from this survey indicates that similar proportions of trans men and trans women tended to struggle in their overall experiences living as a trans person.
Openness about gender identity
Entirely closeted with friends: 7.4% of trans women, 2.8% of trans men
Entirely closeted with family members that participant lived with: 20.1% of trans women, 14.5% of trans men)
Entirely closeted with family members that participant did not live with: 25.3% of trans women, 22.0% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity for fear of a negative reaction: 58.9% of trans women, 56.2% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in public premises or buildings: 67.6% of trans women, 62.4% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity on streets or outdoor public places: 68.1% of trans women, 61.8% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity on public transport: 68.7% of trans women, 58.7% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in neighborhood: 68.5% of trans women, 56.9% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in workplace: 60.6% of trans women, 53.0% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in cafes, restaurants, pubs, or clubs: 61.8% of trans women, 57.5% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in the park: 54.4% of trans women, 46.2% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in other environments: 9.0% of trans women, 8.9% of trans men
Avoiding being open about gender identity in athletic environments: 63.1% of trans men, 60.2% of trans women
Avoiding being open about gender identity in schools: 45.6% of trans men, 35.1% of trans women
Avoiding being open about gender identity at home: 38.9% of trans men, 32.4% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans women than trans men tended to struggle with being open about their gender identity.
Transphobia from people the participant lived with
Verbal harassment: 34.0% of trans men, 22.2% of trans women
Outing: 38.5% of trans men, 23.5% of trans women
Threats of violence: 7.0% of trans men, 6.1% of trans women
Coercive/controlling behavior: 25.0% of trans men, 18.2% of trans women
Physical violence: 6.1% of trans men, 4.2% of trans women
Sexual violence: 2.2% of trans men, 2.1% of trans women
Other transphobic incidents: 29.4% of trans men, 18.3% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans men than trans women tended to struggle with facing transphobia from people they lived with.
Transphobia from people the participant did not live with
Outing: 29.4% of trans men, 24.6% of trans women
Verbal harassment: 42.2% of trans women, 36.0% of trans men
Threats of violence: 13.7% of trans women, 10.5% of trans men
Physical violence: 7.2% of trans women, 5.6% of trans men
Sexual violence: 6.1% of trans women, 3.9% of trans men
Other transphobic incidents: 27.6% of trans women, 25.8% of trans men
Private sexual images shared without consent: 18.5% of trans women, 13.3% of trans men
Had conversion therapy: 5.0% of trans women, 4.1% of trans men
Offered conversion therapy: 9.3% of trans men, 7.6% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans women than trans men tended to struggle with facing transphobia from people they did not live with.
Experiences in school/educational institutions
Entirely closeted at school: 16.6% of trans women, 9.3% of trans men
Entirely negative reactions at school: 3.6% of trans women, 2.1% of trans men
Entirely positive reactions at school: 28.9% of trans men, 34.7% of trans women
Outing at school: 77.9% of trans men, 62.9% of trans women
Verbal harassment at school: 73.4% of trans women, 70.0% of trans men
Exclusion from activities at school: 31.7% of trans women, 24.3% of trans men
Threats of violence at school: 25.0% of trans women, 19.8% of trans men
Physical violence at school: 15.1% of trans women, 9.6% of trans men
Sexual violence at school: 12.4% of trans women, 5.0% of trans men
Other transphobic incidents at school: 50.0% of trans men, 47.3% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans women than trans men tended to struggle with being trans in schools/educational institutions.
Workplace experiences
Had a paid job: 56.9% of trans men, 65.3% of trans women
Entirely closeted with senior colleagues: 33.4% of trans men, 31.5% of trans women
Entirely closeted with colleagues at same/lower level: 30.6% of trans men, 26.6% of trans women
Entirely positive reactions in workplace: 34.7% of trans women, 36.3% of trans men
Entirely negative reactions in workplace: 5.1% of trans women, 3.9% of trans men
Outing at work: 59.9% of trans men, 55.5% of trans women
Verbal harassment at work: 49.6% of trans women, 45.6% of trans men
Exclusion from activities at work: 32.7% of trans women, 21.8% of trans men
Threats of violence at work: 9.6% of trans women, 7.7% of trans men
Physical violence at work: 5.5% of trans women, 3.2% of trans men
Sexual violence at work: 7.0% of trans women, 4.0% of trans men
Other transphobic incidents at work: 54.2% of trans men, 53.3% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that similar proportions of trans women and trans men tended to struggle with being trans in the workplace, with slightly more trans women struggling.
Public healthcare experiences
Needs ignored: 32.3% of trans men, 24.0% of trans women
Avoided treatment for fear of discrimination: 24.3% of trans men, 17.4% of trans women
Inappropriate questions/curiosity from healthcare workers: 29.0% of trans men, 18.9% of trans women
Discrimination from healthcare staff: 14.2% of trans men, 12.6% of trans women
Inappropriate referral to specialist services: 13.8% of trans men, 10.3% of trans women
Unwanted pressure for medical testing: 10.6% of trans men, 8.6% of trans women
Had to change GP: 10.9% of trans men, 9.7% of trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans men than trans women tended to struggle with public healthcare.
Mental healthcare experiences
Average ease accessing mental health services, on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being very easy: 2.49 for trans men, 2.55 for trans women
Unsuccessful accessing mental health services: 28.6% of trans women, 27.7% of trans men
Anxious/embarrassed about accessing mental health services: 40.1% of trans men, 29.1% of trans women
Unsupportive mental health practitioner: 17.0% of trans men, 16.9% of trans women
Average mental health service ratings, on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being completely positive: 3.22 for trans men, 3.40 for trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans men than trans women tended to struggle with mental healthcare.
Sexual healthcare experiences
Average ease accessing sexual health services, on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being very easy: 3.72 for trans men, 3.75 for trans women
Unsuccessful accessing sexual health services: 14.6% of trans women, 12.3% of trans men
Anxious/embarrassed about sexual health services: 57.3% of trans men, 31.8% of trans women
Unsupportive sexual health practitioner: 15.1% of trans men, 11.9% of trans women
Rating of sexual health services, on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being completely positive: 4.05 for trans men, 4.10 for trans women
The data from this survey indicates that more trans men than trans women tended to struggle with sexual healthcare.
TLDR: According to the data from this survey, the areas in which trans women tended to face more struggles than trans men were in openness about gender identity, transphobia from people they don't live with, and being trans in educational institutions. The areas in which trans men tended to face more struggles than trans women were in transphobia from people they did live with, public healthcare services, mental healthcare services, and sexual healthcare services. Trans men and trans women struggled similarly with being trans in the workplace, and with their overall experience being trans in the UK, with trans women facing slightly more struggles in the workplace.
Obviously, this is only one survey, and doesn't represent all trans people as it was conducted only in the UK. It's possible that another survey might show trans women struggling more in healthcare, or trans men struggling more in schools.
But I would say this is strong evidence that trans women are not necessarily the most oppressed of all trans people by far in all areas of life. Trans men and trans women both face severe oppression, in some similar and some unique ways, and it helps no one to minimize the suffering of either.
Reading Comprehension Questions:
Did OP say that trans men are more oppressed than trans women? (Hint: No)
Did OP say that trans women oppress trans men? (Hint: Also no)
Did OP say that transmisogyny isn't a real issue, or that trans women shouldn't be allowed to talk about transmisogyny? (Hint: No again)
Did OP say that trans men's oppression is more important than trans women's and deserves to be talked about more? (Hint: Still no)
Did OP say that any issues are exclusive to trans men or trans women and that we have no overlap in our struggles? (Hint: You guessed it- no!)
#transmisogyny#anti-transmasculinity#trans#did i hyperfixate on this for like three hours? you can't prove anything fuck you#also apologies for not including nonbinary data in here! the discourse tends to focus on trans men vs women so that's what i addressed#but if i ever get the energy i will def do a follow up on how the stats look for nonbinary respondents
762 notes
·
View notes
Text
“I love black butler!” “I ship sebaciel”
#Have half this fandom blocked because of this like my goodness#its like a plague#black butler#kuroshitsuji#sebastian michaelis#o!ciel#also don’t wanna get involved in this discourse but I wanted to participate in this meme or whatever that’s all over twitter
639 notes
·
View notes
Text
tbh as much as i do think it is worthwhile to discuss the topic of shipping aromantic/asexual characters and the nuances of it all (as well as the general attitude allos have towards aspecs in fandom spaces). it also makes me sigh equally because like... what characters. i'll be real guys we don't even have characters to discourse over. literally there are like 3 ever and none of those have fandoms anyway and the ones which do are like 'it was confirmed on twitter in a nebulously worded post by the creator'. its so bad out here
#aromantic#asexual#re my prev post#i pray 4 the day that i can discourse over aro character shipping without it all feeling a bit pointless because its not even confirmed to#be Real. whatever#aroace#aspec#honestly i totally get why its natural to feel so protective of those half confirmed aspec characters though. because we literally get#so little that anything has to be a Win. but we should not be living like this... we deserve better... guys...#mossy posts
1K notes
·
View notes