#art needs a human connection
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Seriously?! There is a chat gbt Anderperry fic on ao3? Gag! Get that away from me. No one wants to see your disgusting chat gbt story. I canât call it a work because no work was done and I canât call it fanfic because how much of a fan could you possibly be if you donât write it yourself. âI wanted to see a happier ending to the movie.â There are hundreds of stories you could have picked from that a real person actually created because they care about the characters. They are all infinitely better than anything a computer could have produced because they actually have a human connection and people who actually are capable of liking the movie and the characters. That tag is my happy place and it is tainted by that monstrosity. Normally I would be incredibly annoyed no matter the fandom, but for Dead Poets Society?! Really?! The movie about how art is tied with humanity?! Did you watch the movie?! Every single character would be disgusted by the use of ai to produce art. Art doesnât exist without humanity and some cheep to imitation is an insult to anyone that actually works to make art.
#Am I being harsh?#yes#am I being too harsh?#absolutely not!#if anything Iâm not being nearly harsh enough#soulless empty things are not art#art needs a human connection#and if you want to see a rewrite of a story#write it yourself or see if someone else has!#and plenty of fix it fics exist in this fandom#chat gbt would break Keatingâs heart#and if not all most of the poets would have strong feelings about how chat gbt makes art worse#it doesnât fit at all with carpe diem#ai is not art#anti ai#anti chat gbt#Dead Poets Society#Neil is so passionate about poetry and acting and all art#and Todd is a poet for gods sake!#Anderperry would very much so not appreciate ai#Anderperry#and if you are the type of scum to post ai on ao3 then at least you should tag it so the rest of us can filter it out#no one with any brain cells wants to see that#I know I mostly lurk in this fandom but I care about it very much!#I donât want it ruined by people who canât use critical thinking#whoever posted this crap needs to delete it#I donât care if anyone thinks this is mean#Iâm right
12 notes
¡
View notes
Text
obsolete
#kiiruma#danganronpa#danganronpa v3#drv3#miu iruma#kiibo idabashi#kiibo#k1-b0#my art#my posts#fanart#human#digital#p#i am. so unwell about them rn#the way theyre both constantly ostracized from the group and yet#so very very ill equipped to provide each other with the kind of connection they actually need#IDK idk idk
678 notes
¡
View notes
Text
"It's so embarrassing to admit I only create art for validation" did paleolithic humans not paint for other humans to see. Does a child making their first drawing to show their parents makes it any less valuable. Do gardens arranged for the visitors' eyes make the roses any less beautiful. Do love poems written for one person alone to hear make your heart ache less. You're fine
#jay rambles.txt#two very hard pills to swallow: 1. art has always been created for money and it's a very normal practice in human history#and actually artists being expected to produce art for free or as cheap as they do now is a relatively new thing#2. humans have always created art for validation because being recognised and understood by your fellow humans is a universal human need#if you start to idealise artistry as something inherently selfless that needs to come with no gain or benefits or instead brings only pain#you are going down a VERY dangerous path of not being able to express yourself without shame - if at all#and potentially dragging other people you told close down into that mentality too if you're vocal about it#I've been there#I am there#It's a shitty feeling but the only way out of it is true embrace your need to be loved and desire for human connection or it won't end well#idk that's my opinion tho
532 notes
¡
View notes
Text
i've had these scenarios written down since volo's debut in pokemon masters and i just really wanted to scribble them down and finally release them
#pokemon#volo#pokemon volo#pokemon jacq#n harmonia#pokemon rei#trainer rei#clai's art#trying to write n's specific brand of being mean is hard to me for some reason#in the initial idea i had him outright call volo stupid but i didnt know if that was too far so i just took it out BJFBFJF#but anyway volo being a historian who had to have studied many walks of life but has still come to the conclusion that the world is hopeless#jacq being someone who's very positive and sees the best in people even if they are very much not great to him (see: raifort)#finally realizing someone he knows is like. inexcusably horrible#n's situation wasn't even that different from volo's. both saw injustice in society and sought to change it#but even n. who hated humanity for what he thought they were all responsible for. didnt want humans to Die for what they did!!#and rei. rei was a scared kid who saw the very worst of volo firsthand. rei needed friends and one of them despised him in the end#isnt it soooo funny how volo thinks he's alone yet keeps pushing away all the people who want to connect with him :) i hate pla so much :)))#as another note too. perhaps the rei thing could end in two ways#satisfying good ending where it kicks off volo's realization that hey maybe people do trust me unconditionally#or no good bad ending where volo takes this as another betrayal. rei only liked him for his facade like everyone else so why does it matter#volo almost makes me feel as ill as n does. hate this stupid guy i shouldnt have bought pla for my birthday i should have gotten. p/kmin idk
162 notes
¡
View notes
Text
open for better quality
I imagine Emperor's body is slowly morphing from flesh to that space matter that ancient caller Moira consists of. The armour is used as a sort of shell to help him stay in a humanoid form consistently
#i just need this guy to be less human#he is like 20% flesh and 80% space goo#something about him losing connection with material plane as time goes on#idk#mik draws#sigma overwatch#siebren de kuiper#digital art#digital drawing#drawing#tw body distortion#body horrow cw#just in case#overwatch#starwatch#bruh thank you tumblr for compressing my drawings#very cool
242 notes
¡
View notes
Text
I really want to draw something meaty and put some characters into The Situations but I am dealing with a double whammy of art block and some REALLY insane migraine/Sinus issues the past 3 or 4 days.
So all I managed was a quick Solana. I wanted to give her a cool leg prosthetic but then I didn't really draw her legs sdjfdsjkfsdhf So that's the level of cognitive function I am dealing with at the moment
Fun fact! I really dislike a lot of the female turian design! So I just... ignored the parts I disliked lol.
#Mass Effect#Solana Vakarian#Art#artists on tumblr#Digital art#I need a better art tag#Mainly I dislike that the fucked up the female turian's spines to make them more human#and I really dislike their lip shape which also made them more human looking#And I really dislike how they designed the shorter crest in a way that also makes them more human#So I literally just ignored all of that and applied the turian anatomy the males have instead#like where the spine connects to the skull for instance#Still not sure how I feel about the cat eyes tho.#I saw a Nexus mod that replaces the cat eyes with the same eyes the males have and it kinda looks better...#Also gave her teal eyes. I know Castis has copper eyes in Andromeda#But the Andromeda design clashes with the Homeworld comic design#so I based her on that rather#I really dislike what they did to turians in Andromeda too#Why are they white?#Anyway I am rambling in the tags and I need to stop gdi my head is killing me and I can't think straight#I WILL draw some situations I promise#I just can't right now
177 notes
¡
View notes
Text
[[WIP; CONCEPT ART]]
.
.
Hm, better than the few couple attempts I made. I'll admit.
#killbot 86#woy#wander over yonder#concept art#wips#human version#humanized characters#This is decent at least#like again#better than the last few attempts i made#somewhat#this is passable#I like that I actually made his head and neck connected#to resemble his long head he has#i need an alternative cyclop visor for him#btw btw#Underneath his leather suit#he would wear high knee leather boots
41 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Weâre about to get the 1.2 update and finally learn some more about the tumultuous past between Dan Heng, Blade, Jing Yuan, and Jingliu but god if Iâm not more than a little happy for the first three that theyâve found a new community and family after their previous one was lost.
Dan Heng has the Express crew.
My hope for him in the story is that he has a moment where he realizes how much theyâve come to mean to him. Heâs been so focused on running from his past that maybe he forgets to cherish the present.
Jing Yuan is the general for the Luofu. The whole ship looks to him for leadership.
Heâs no longer that little boy looking to his master for guidance. He has Yanqing, Fu Xuan, Yukong, Tingyunâthe whole Luofu.
Blade has the Stellaron Hunters.
It can be seen as purely transactional. Blade is a useful weapon and theyâll give him what he desires: death. But the little details the story sprinkles inâKafka calling him Bladie, him accompanying Silver Wolf to arcadesâshows that thereâs fondness too.
I highlighted these three specifically because I donât know if or think that Jingliu has found something else since the quintet.
Her appearance in Yanqingâs quest leads me to believe otherwise. She and Blade are very similarâstruck with Mara and having certain ways to control it, yet all the more disconnected from reality and dangerous for it.
But the crucial difference is Blade has people he can rely on. Itâs clear the Stellaron Hunters take care of each other in their own unorthodox way, even if itâs just following Elioâs script.
Jingliu doesnât.
TL;DR found family matters. Those four were once family and their most important connections, then it fell apart.
Three of them have managed to find other people in their grief and it makes all the difference.
#honkai star rail#hsr#blade honkai#dan heng#jing yuan#jingliu#bloo writes musings#this silly little chibi art got to me#i really want blade to find peace#i hope he's finding some semblance of his past humanity through this connection with the stellaron hunters#elio promised him death but i hope when the time comes blade realizes he doesn't want or need it anymore#right now vengeance is the reason he's given himself for his forced immortality#i'd like to think he can find new meaning and reason beyond the past
189 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Do you guys wanna hear about my little au where Subject X (Skuld) and Bragi's ghost become friends?
They're the "what the heck happened to you kids" gang :3
#kh bragi#kh skuld#subject x#my art#ok organizational tags out of the way. grabs you. I think bragi calls her âstarâ because of her earrings. and he thinks âxâ is a stupid nam#also I hc Bragi had a younger sister so even tho skuld is technically older she reminds him of her#((his younger sister was named Ava. Luxu didn't know about her </3))#he can't physically do anything to help her so he tries to just be a comforting presence. he tells her stories and makes up poetry#sometimes he follows luxu up to the surface and tries to learn as much as he can so he can tell her about the latest market drama#some days he even manages to wander into the local school and tries to learn history or math (which is very different from what he learned)#so he's not very good at it but. he tries#sometimes he's literally just a nightlight. which is good in it's own way#he tries so so hard to be a good friend because he hasn't had meaningful human connection in like 90 years#and skuld really really really appreciates it because she is ALSO very deprived of connection and friendship#she doesn't have a lot to offer him but a listening ear. but that's really what he needs#Bragi would beat xehanort's ass if he could. he watched the whole trajectory of dark road and bbs he knows what's up with him#i get sad about bragi a lot. what happened to him before dark road ): who was he ):
13 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Spoiler for the next au character hehe
I might delete this in a while + no reblogs
#gaara my beloved#watching naruto is not enough i need to hug gaara#their canon struggles with love and hate and life and human connection r about being trans and aro and neurodivergent actually#my art
18 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Who defines living anywayssssss
#art#original art#artwork#digital artist#thank god for the internet (or not? what do I know)#escapism#yeah#connections connections connections human consciousness what are we without connections without other people#blabbering thinking#I need to like physically fuse into a pile of goo with someone to feel a connection I fear#like the guys in Tetsuo the Ironman I fear that is what I need
9 notes
¡
View notes
Text
art is sometimes about sobbing over a song so hard that you decide to put it on repeat while you make a painting dedicated to forming a concentrated drop of that emotion on the canvas
#an ode to the way art connects us#the yearning is so fucking real tonight beans#i think this would be better if i had more than craft paints because this needs TEXTURE#do y'all think that using ashes to thicken paint (like. from a fire not. human ashes.) would be a bad idea? would it rot?
8 notes
¡
View notes
Note
I am looking respectfully at your Hollow Ground đł What do u think Damien's relationship with him is gonna be? đđ
I've been breaking HG's nose for the majority of my playthroughs for the hell of it. But I loved going deep into his mind and go fishing for a moray so I'm thinking to have that over in my save state.
Damien will definitely be curious about what happened and wouldn't be able to keep a mystery like that unsolved. If HG still seeks Damien's partnership in Book 3 (which I hope he still does), Damien would be inclined to agree in order to take advantage of HG's resources, investigate their connection, and maybe do a bit of spying for our local glorified power bank (he did promise to help after all).
What might bite him in the ass, however, is whether HG would pursue a more familial relationship with Damien...
He'd be a fool not to take advantage of their sort-of blood connection to further infiltrate HG's ranks. Getting buddy-buddy with HG might make him feel like he's wearing a dead person's skin and living their life, but he's always been good at playing roles (plus it's HG, so no harm, no foul when Damien ends up betraying him). The problem is if Damien would end up actually liking the role he's playing.
He had to act human to fulfill his missions and liked it a bit too much that he escaped The Farm. He didn't really trust the previous Rangers and Ortega all those years ago, yet he became comfortable playing hero, and now the loss of what he once had still hunts him. He swore never to make contact to the Rangers again but is now playing the role of a disillusioned retiree a bit too well and is being dangerously comfortable in their headquarters. He also planned to keep his relationship with Dr. Mortum purely transactional, yet now Jane and the good doctor are literal besties and drinking buddies.
If Hollow Ground wanted Damien to play the role of his brother and fall into the trap of finding a connection that makes him feel human, how would this be any different?
#the latter half is a whole load of âwhat ifâ but i hope we can explore this dynamic with HG#and that's assuming HG has an ounce of actual affection left for his dead bro#Damien's unconsciously desperate for human connection because deep inside he thinks it would make himself more ârealâ#he's just doomed to repeat his mistakes đđ#he has simple needs: just treat him like a decent human being and he'll eventually cave in#what a softie (derogatory)#the bar is on the fucking floor and we have The Farm to thank for it#fhr#fallen hero#hollow ground#damien becker#sidestep#anon#at#my art
73 notes
¡
View notes
Text
I imagine it was quite the adjustment
#the mechanisms#the mechanisms fanart#drumbot brian#art#digitial art#spent waaay too long trying to figure out how a robot body would move#bc humans are squishy! so much of how our movement works is based on the fact that our body parts can squish on top of each other#limb trying to move but the edge of the torso in the way? don't worry it'll just squish out of the way!#but brass doesn't squish!! i based him mostly off of ball jointed dolls#most obvious on his joints#but how his torso bends? man idk#also i had some ideas but god forbid i knew how to *draw* it#so his torso is in 3 sections (again: ball jointed doll) and then his rib section#has a back and front piece connected internally with hinges (which allows his sides to bend inwards for foward arm movement)#his shoulder blades as you can see are squares attached with hinges attached externally with hinges which allows his torso to bend back#which allows his arm a greater range of movement backwards without having 360 movable shoulder joints#1) bc carmilla probably tried to recreate human range of movements and idk who needs to hear this#but humans do not have 360 shoulder movement#2) relying on the ball joint for movement only is weak. for the strength of the attachment#2a) you have to pick between flexibility and strength when it comes to attaching 1 thing to another thing bc the more something moves-#-the less points of anchorage you have#2b) the brass of his upper arm and shoulder would constantly be rubbing against each other slowly wearing both away#which for an immortal brass maybe isn't the BIGGEST concern but i can't imagine it's very comfortable. so mitigate it#i might actually draw out a diagram of how i think Brian works. and it will be different from this drawing#bc tbh i did not put a ton of thought into it for this drawing. i would of torn my hair out#speaking of hair: brian's is made of copper wire. you ever part the hair on a doll and see bald head? yeah same situation with brian
211 notes
¡
View notes
Text
The first kiss đ
In the hours that followed the meeting at the 8-Bit Pizza Bar, the news of John being alive reached everyoneâs ears in Hope County⌠including Josephâs who contacted the Junior Deputy the instant he knew, late in the evening, and requested to see the little brother he thought he had lost. He and Taylor agreed on a truce and that he would visit them the next day. Approximately 24 hours later, she anxiously drove to his compound to pick him up, but his calm demeanor and the fact he apparently trusted her enough to get into her car alone surprised her. When Joseph was finally reunited with John (who had insisted he needed a shirt for the occasion), he hugged him tightly, and Taylor decided to wait outside so they could talk in private in the small bunker she now called home. The Father came out of it moments later, visibly relieved, and told her John would only return to his Family the next morning because there was âno rushâ and, that way, they could âsort everything outâ.
The Deputy was a bit confused but, as it happened, âsort everything outâ they did.
I had 11 âoldâ drawings to post and this is the 6th one; Iâm getting there! My computer says this file is exactly one year old today :)
#pov: youâre peaches and realize itâs very likely that the humans are done petting you for the night#(they only kissed by the way you know the cult has rules)#in fact it was john who made the first move#3 seconds earlier taylor was sitting on the other side of the couch#he tried to touch her hand while she wasnât looking#but she was so surprised she reflexively removed it#when she met johnâs gaze he quickly lowered it and withdrew his hand as well#she realized she had accidentally made things awkward and that she actually wasnât opposed to him touching her at all#so her next move was this#john seed x deputy#taylor rook#my deputy#john seed#far cry 5#adelaide and joseph: *shipped john and taylor before they even realized they had feelings for each other*#joseph because he knew john needed love and that she could save him#and adelaide because... sheâs adelaide haha#also they both perceived their connection the moment they saw them together#all they needed was a nudge and a few more hours#story: 'that fic Iâll never write'#my art#fan art#traditional art#digital coloring#I still like how the couch looks
35 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Shadow of the Erdtree - "Pure and Radiant, He Wields Love to Shrive Clean the Hearts of Men"
"Shriver" is an occupational title meaning "scribe" or "writer" and comes from the root "Shrive" which originally meant "to decree, pass judgement, prescribe, hear or receive a confession (of sins), free from guilt, to absolve" and later came to mean "write".
So keeping in mind that the concept of Words have literal Power is part of the Golden Order faith in Elden Ring (see Coded Sword or Cipher Pata), when Miquella is in the Lands of Shadow to "Shrive clean the hearts of men", his goal is to either literally or metaphorically write a narrative that cleans the hearts of men. So, what does it mean to "clean a heart"? Metaphorically it seems like a term for absolving sins, but it can take on another meaning when read more literally.
Because of course this has come up before on the internet I searched the origin of the phrase "hearts of men" and received: the Battle Hymn of the Republic. An American ('Marikan) Civil War song with lyrics written by abolitionist Julia Ward Howe in 1861.
... He has sounded forth the trumpet that shall never call retreat; He is sifting out the hearts of men before His judgment-seat; Oh, be swift, my soul, to answer Him! Be jubilant, my feet! Our God is marching on. Glory, glory, hallelujah! Glory, glory, hallelujah! Glory, glory, hallelujah! Our God is marching on. In the beauty of the lilies Christ was born across the sea, With a glory in His bosom that transfigures you and me. As He died to make men holy, let us die to make men free, While God is marching on.
The only notes I want to make for that last stanza is that it is interesting that Christ is associated with lilies in this particular song when that is also Miquella's flower. And that Miquella (and Mohg, and Radahn) certainly died to reach the Shadowlands in a classic set up of Death and Resurrection that fails to complete the resurrection bit.
At least two biblical passages provide context/inspiration for the poetic phrasing about hearts (again: internet is full of people discussing the meanings behind works of art and poetry):
Romans 2:15 âthe requirements of the law are written on their heartsâ.
Revelation 2:23 âI am he who searches hearts and minds, and I will repay each of you according to your deeds.â
So thinking of shriving in terms of writing is not so farfetched, and also there's some end of days style judgement happening with all the horn sounding (that being the theme of Revelations).
Grading Gravel Stone with Sieves
The technique of "sifting" is used in geotechnical engineering to separate particles of rock and sand into sizes, where the smallest size of sand and silt or clay is what passes through a #200 sieve with opening size of 75 Âľm. The first step is to prepare a tower of sieves of various sizes - say ranging from 1/2" to 75 Âľm openings - and add to the top a sample of soil baked to zero moisture content, and then shake them vigorously until all fine particles settle to the bottom. The fineness of the resulting silt below the lowest sieve can be further determined by agitating a sample in a water column and watching a hydrometer (a buoyant instrument) to see how long it takes the particles to settle.Â
Clayey soil causes problems - it sticks in crevasses of bigger rocks and forms clumps that do not pass through the #200 sieve. However, in some case a fine particle analysis is not required, so the solution is a setup that continuously runs water through the sieves during the shaking of the tower to wash fines clean from the coarse particles. Or if you work in a low budget lab like I did, just stand at the sink and smoosh the clay around with fingers until it goes through the mesh.
The point being that in the metaphor the material of "coarse" hearts are sifted out and exposed while that of exceptionally "fine" hearts pass judgement of the final sieve and are washed through with the water. And while in the real world the "fineness" of a heart is subjective, in Elden Ring this becomes quite literal: dragon hearts have been shown over and over again to be ridged in coarse gravel stone. Like, when you get a dragon heart and literally "clean the heart" of all of the blood that obscures detail, this is what is exposed:
Dragon heart seized by a dragon tracker. Riddled with Gravel Stone, this grotesque organ continues to beat vivaciously. An offering used in the Dragon Communion. Consume a dragon's heart at the altar to make its power yours. While a terrible and savage-looking thing, the heart has a peculiar beauty to it.
And the quote about Miquella shriving clean the hearts of men originates from Ansbach, who finds this concept terrifying. And as described in the Wise Man's Mask, "an old fear lurks beneath...the appearance of a quiet, wise, old, bearded man", so it's a personal terror rather than the abstract thought that somebody should be terrified about this. Being "absolved of their sins" by a loving deity is usually not something that sparks fear in a person - if anything it's supposed to be cathartic in the sense of having successfully appeased God. So Ansbach fears being judged and found inadequate. In other words, the fear of Ansbach is that the hearts of "men" will have all fine facades washed away from their surface, exposing the coarse stony hearts not unlike savage, bestial dragons.Â
Man vs. God
But good news: if man does not want to be judged, then he must simply kill god! After all, the final words of Ansbach are "Righteous Tarnished. Become our new lord. A lord not for gods, but for men."
There's another more modern song to the same tune as the Battle Hymn of the Republic - an American paratrooper song dating to World War 2 known as "Blood on the Risers":
... The ambulance was on the spot, the jeeps were running wild The medics jumped and screamed with glee, they rolled their sleeves and smiled For it had been a week or more since last a 'Chute had failed And he ain't gonna jump no more Glory, glory, what a hell of a way to die Glory, glory, what a hell of a way to die Glory, glory, what a hell of a way to die He ain't gonna jump no more ... There was blood upon the risers, there were brains upon the chute Intestines were a-dangling from his paratroopers suit He was a mess, they picked him up, and poured him from his boots And he ain't gonna jump no more Gory, gory, what a hell of a way to die Gory, gory, what a hell of a way to die Gory, gory, what a hell of a way to die He ain't gonna jump no more
Glory to God isn't in the song any more, only gore, and the idea that "hell" is not something for an afterlife but experienced right here in the present (and there are medics - hello VarrĂŠ). The "god" in question being not Miquella, but Marika who was previously keeping the Omen such as Mohg and his pureblood faction in check and set the conditions for their release with her disappearance. It's not really better when a god dies without any functional structure in place to fill the power vacuum. More of a lateral shift from a belief that killing is for the glory of God to the grim disillusionment of seeing that people die in viscerally brutal ways to advance whatever flimsy ideologies men can invent to justify capturing control of resources.Â
Sowing and Reaping
And while that would be a decent sentiment to end on in a discussion about a real history and the rise of secularism - I can dig deeper. This is a video game and the characters unquestionably have a Creator in the form of the writer. So a certain proverb of biblical origin can apply here quite literally - "you reap what you sow". Ansbach wields the "Obsidian Lamina" a scythe like what would traditionally be used for reaping grain. People who Ansbach can potentially "reap" with this scythe via combat:
Needleknight Leda
Dryleaf Dane
Freyja (if she is given Ansbach's letter)
Moore (if you advise "put it behind you" to the question "Our mother abandoned her brood. She did not love us. We are her children, what should we do? Must we be sad forever?")
Hornsent (if you deny him vengeance or snub him after helping with that vengeance)
Miquella and Consort Radahn.Â
Why should Ansbach fear the judgement of Miquella except that he knows that in some way his actions have sowed the lust for violence toward himself from all of these people? And now it has come time to reap them if he wants to survive without compromising on his irrational loyalties to the Lord of Blood. I don't think it's necessary to speculate on all of them except this: Ansbach did cleave open Miquella and wound him with a Furious Blood Blade. Leda saw it happen.
Iâm afraid Sir Ansbach will have to be next. He insist that heâs nothing but a worn down, over-the-hill soldier. But in his day, he was the feared commander of the Pureblood Knights, who cleaved open Miquella the Kind with his blood blade. He claims he hasnât the spirit to take up his sword again, but I doubt itâll be very long⌠Before he recalls, as I have, the cascading sheets of blood. Iâm afraid he cannot be left to festerâŚ
This seems to contradict directly Ansbach's own claim - but unlike Leda's specific recollection (the description for "Furious Blood Blade of Ansbach" even uses the word "cleave") he never said with which blade was he unable to reach Miquella. His scythe couldn't reap Miquella yet. All he had done at first contact was to sow the seed of despair with his bloody assault. Even more poignant that Needle Knight Leda was present as witness considering that she is themed around a different kind of sewing.
But here's the thing about fiction. Miquella isn't really Ansbach's god in a divine sense - that would be the Creator FromSoftware. Miquella having discarded so much of himself is basically on the level of a straw man argument that people who plea for kindness are all really thought-policing monsters. You know. Straw. A grassy plant that is sown from seed and may perhaps be reaped by scythe. Like the new straw/hay bale asset found in the DLC villages that was not present in the base game.
People have throughout history invented gods to explain natural phenomena and obsessed over making up stories about them. Inventing a caricature/phantasm of a person to do mental combat against is just a more mundane version of that. And like I've said previously - the DLC takes place in the body/mind of the withered corpse in the cocoon.
Like, to be clear, the set up of the straw man argument above is that I say "I really don't trust the faction who are themed around blood exultation and glorifying wounds and pain" and the straw man response might be "so you trust the god who wants to use mind control to make everyone be nice to each other??". Which is what the Mogh vs. Miquella argument seems to be reduced down to sometimes. No, I think that dwelling on the possibility of mind-control is a pit of paranoia, and that if the blood faction stopped polluting their own water sources with blood and fantasies about a glorious dynasty then maybe they would be able to calm the fuck down. Get some basic needs for sustenance and safety satisfied to then have the time and energy for introspection. Gain perspective on how they've been radicalized by doctored narratives.
Including the phantasm of the violent and mind-controlling god who "shrives clean the hearts of men" and must be stopped before he can enforce a new narrative where kindness is the default and being exposed for having a coarse/uncivil nature is a faux pas to be weighed and judged along a graded scale of severity. Remove the part about "violent and mind-controlling god" and that basically sounds like the ideal that most rational people wish we already had from civil society.
So the thoughts about violence under a mind-controlling god is pure projection - the idea that there must be a terrifying caveat to any attempt at Kind governance. But really, the Blood Dynasty faction is just reaping what they sow:
Governed by a God? Mohg has always been deferring to gods - first Marika, then the outer god of the Formless Mother, so in a twisted way Miquella must be a god as well. Mohg and his Sanguine Nobles also in their design take clearest inspiration from the type of embroidered stole as worn by the Catholic Pope.
Mind-controlling? To believe in an omnipotent God is to believe that God knows your most private thoughts. Always. And is always judging you on the correctness of those thoughts. So you must be sure to think the correct thoughts, and obey the letter of the holy text and the guidance of the priesthood. Also, just try to think rationally when in excruciating chronic pain, as the Formless Mother espouses.
Violent? Yep.
#Elden Ring#elden ring lore#media analysis#analysis of art design#I wrote the entire section about reaping & only remembered the hay bales after typing the word âstraw manâ#this is why it's nice to chat in the discord group - more eyes looking for things to make connections#Just civilizations need constant upkeep and can only work if people collectively agree not to be breaking stuff on purpose#Including shutting down irrational hate and violence that is aimed at breaking the body and minds of individuals or groups#There are enough natural disasters to deal with before adding human manufactured ones to the pile
6 notes
¡
View notes