#Dakota { Family }
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Pro-Choice - Abortion Measures on The Ballot
Florida Amendment 4, the Right to Abortion Initiative A Yes vote with 60% will Establish a constitutional right to abortion until viability, with exceptions for later pregnancies. Arizona Proposition 139, Right to Abortion Initiative (2024) A "yes" vote supports amending the state constitution to provide for the fundamental right to abortion, among other provisions.
Colorado Amendment 79, Right to Abortion and Health Insurance Coverage Initiative A "yes" vote supports creating a right to abortion in the state constitution and allowing the use of public funds for abortion. Maryland Question 1, Right to Reproductive Freedom Amendment A "yes" vote supports adding a new article to the Maryland Constitution's Declaration of Rights establishing a right to reproductive freedom, defined to include "the ability to make and effectuate decisions to prevent, continue, or end one's own pregnancy."
Missouri Amendment 3, Right to Reproductive Freedom Initiative A "yes" vote supports adding a fundamental right to reproductive freedom, defined to include abortion and “all matters relating to reproductive health care,” to the Missouri Constitution, among other provisions. Montana CI-128, Right to Abortion Initiative
provide a state constitutional "right to make and carry out decisions about one’s own pregnancy, including the right to abortion," and
allow the state to regulate abortion after fetal viability, except when "medically indicated to protect the life or health of the pregnant patient."
Nebraska Initiative 434, Prohibit Abortions After the First Trimester Amendment A "no" vote opposes amending the state constitution to prohibit abortions after the first trimester unless necessitated by a medical emergency or the pregnancy is a result of sexual assault or incest.
Nebraska Initiative 439, Right to Abortion Initiative A "yes" vote supports amending the state constitution to establish a right to abortion until fetal viability. Nevada Question 6, Right to Abortion Initiative A "yes" vote supports providing for a state constitutional right to an abortion, providing for the state to regulate abortion after fetal viability, except where medically indicated to "protect the life or health of the pregnant patient." New York Proposal 1, Equal Protection of Law Amendment A "yes" vote supports adding language to the New York Bill of Rights to provide that people cannot be denied rights based on their "ethnicity, national origin, age, and disability" or "sex, including sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive healthcare and autonomy."
South Dakota Constitutional Amendment G, Right to Abortion Initiative A "yes" vote supports providing for a state constitutional right to abortion in South Dakota, using a trimester framework for regulation:
During the first trimester, the state would be prohibited from regulating a woman's decision to have an abortion;
During the second trimester, the state may regulate abortion, but "only in ways that are reasonably related to the physical health of the pregnant woman;" and
During the third trimester, the state may regulate or prohibit abortion, except "when abortion is necessary, in the medical judgment of the woman's physician, to preserve the life and health of the pregnant woman."
#Florida#Arizone#Proposition 139#Colorado#Elections#Election#Vote Blue#Missouri#Maryland Elections#South Dakota#Pro Choice#Women#Families
925 notes
·
View notes
Text
A handful more things from the Milo Mikey Murphy's Law pitch bible:
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/bcca6b97bcd29fe32c71d4162d929047/87c9fcac66f83fd9-98/s540x810/02aaa7b4b8235a966ff93f357419904e9a4c3f83.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/d136d066b2c4a8794f41f4eeedc3a851/87c9fcac66f83fd9-21/s540x810/d8054a2412cc544dcf6d47e49363682fae686ca9.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/48e0ffa146f65731e4a163f5d4379a2d/87c9fcac66f83fd9-06/s540x810/c3f08dc5a4abf8ec400012448b2ef19a31e122fc.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/cddfcb572b68944436f46113f1530080/87c9fcac66f83fd9-35/s540x810/98fa8a931324bea937c7c7f982b28f0802b26523.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/86ab203842a4f9f7b14d76c47143018f/87c9fcac66f83fd9-d7/s540x810/8e758215bf11daca4f9b5d8f2ebd90c9de041d9a.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/e653298e766133eec00685a0161f9b38/87c9fcac66f83fd9-3a/s540x810/085a1f728f10df4355ba2cefee75a0f15c3cb6cf.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/41107101a26635d96c51474ed0e6913b/87c9fcac66f83fd9-9c/s540x810/7374a6f57e5a765fe1a7745908aba6e30e332328.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/90f6b9f23238fc0f8d6ba824586f930f/87c9fcac66f83fd9-da/s540x810/21ba433b938d48f66758dabe9374521f0e43ffe2.jpg)
#via 4chan#milo murphy's law#milo murphy#zack underwood#melissa chase#diogee#brigette murphy#amanda lopez#martin murphy#sara murphy#balthazar cavendish#vinnie dakota#rooting for the enemy#sunny side up#battle of the bands#managing murphy's law#time out#first impressions#the doctor zone files#the undergrounders#smooth opera-tor#missing milo#we're going to the zoo#worked day#family vacation#school dance#milo murphy's halloween scream-a-torium#the island of lost dakotas#milanda
352 notes
·
View notes
Text
Someone I love dearly, who has been there for me for decades and whose children I could not love more if they were my own, is having car troubles again. She was really hoping this most recent car would last her awhile without having to ask for help again, I know she hates when she can't handle things herself without help, but apparently the gasket is messed up and I don't know anything about cars but it sounds like it's not worth fixing this one. She's asking for help affording something that will HOPEFULLY be a little more reliable, as she has two incredibly sweet young children who have been very intensely bullied (with no help from the driver/school) when they ride the school bus.
This is also the only reliable transportation to get to the grocery store, doctor's office, and pharmacy.
They live in a small town in South Dakota and I can attest from personal experience that even getting an uber/lyft there is unreliable (if you can afford that, which they can't). If you'd be willing to help these kids and their mom out with even $5, I can't tell you how grateful I would be, and I know their mom would be too!
The people in her life who'd be willing to help are all poor ourselves, and she doesn't use social media so Tumblr is kind of her main hope here.
She works for very little money cleaning houses in nearby towns, so her work is also in jeopardy the longer she goes without a car.
#e#im still so angry at the kids' school there were students loudly chanting at those sweet kids to kill themselves and nobody helped#i fucking hate the nasty culture in south dakota i really wish they didn't have to live there#like if you're in a blue state rn imagine what it's like in rural south dakota rn it's so brutal. i wish she could get out like i did.#she would've left long ago but she got babytrapped by her ex who doesn't even like hanging out with the kids but refuses to let her move#like genuinely he doesn't even hang out with them during his parenting time he makes his barely-older daughter take care of them#i better stop before this becomes an even longer list of things i hate about what they have to endure.#but this is the sweetest family and they have to endure a lot and here's something you could alleviate if you want
65 notes
·
View notes
Text
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/f5d5c0c7978b4368da2f2c30277ca94a/74f52eb906cfab8c-35/s540x810/37490739aea4d08dad4977379360e3df82bcd0aa.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/72b00eb882e0d82be4f3cae8d2ff1b5d/74f52eb906cfab8c-60/s540x810/d282cc8b141ae530fe6ab0aa18c30b7f65d49fec.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/6fb7afd329bae675062c1de80373161d/74f52eb906cfab8c-2e/s540x810/fea7ca60cc6943941400888603fc8dc6a5e37868.jpg)
Flyomings :-) PFLs most married duo
#red vs blue#rvb#my art#doodles#agent florida#captain butch flowers#butch flowers#florida rvb#agent wyoming#wyoming rvb#flyoming#agent washington#agent north dakota#north rvb#your gay uncles that give you too much money and leave the family function a quarter through
56 notes
·
View notes
Text
canucks | playoffs game 6, advancing to second round | may 3, 2024
#hockey#this is family right there#nhl hockey#nhl players#vancouver canucks#stanley cup 2024#canucks hockey#canucks vs predators#canucks lb#vancouver bc#stanley cup playoffs#quinn hughes#jt miller#artur silovs#elias pettersson#brock boeser#dakota joshua#conor garland#tyler myers#nikita zadorov#elias lindholm#pius suter
163 notes
·
View notes
Text
north is sometimes less than confident in his masculinity but it’s less like… embarrassment over being feminine specifically and more a worry about having his power undermined.
he’s already taking the more “feminine” role a lot of the time what with being support/caretaker/the mom etc. and i think he does like this role a lot and is not ashamed of it! but the way he wields it is like… the character in this role is often treated as submissive and north is definitely not that. he’s a caretaker yes but he’s positioned more as a protector, the “masculine” version of that role. he’s using this position as a way to be dominant and controlling. taking care of you = having control over you.
and so things that are cutesy or girly are like… they can undermine this position. and i think he gets insecure about that. if he’s wearing the cat ears it’s like. he’s wearing them the way a “girldad” joins in the tea party. it’s not something he “enjoys” it’s like. he’s lowering himself to establish dominance? he’s so in control of the situation he’s willing to “give up” control and make himself seem weaker. but only while he thinks it’s still clear that he is the one with the control. does any of this make sense
#north rvb#rvb#agent north dakota#north analysis#shoutout to raven sabatourist who asked me if north would wear the cat ears#inspired me to explore his relationship with masculinity some#north really wants to be a nuclear family i think. but he’s gay.#he still wants all the power that comes with being the man of the house but none of the unfortunate implications of what having that power#over other people actually means.#he’ll be the breadwinner husband from the 50’s with the white picket fence but he’ll also be the househusband.#he’s nonthreatening but he’s still in charge. he’s still in control.#he’s the man of the house. but what if the man was really good actually <3
45 notes
·
View notes
Text
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/31dc6b990742b6b873a853c7cb00e5ae/8fa77242acffb432-7c/s540x810/d70a861c344df94cd7de33de8cd5a0c52e1ba778.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/33c68348b79f827df3d1f1fe13f07ca3/8fa77242acffb432-00/s540x810/bac7834198c03317583ceffa03dedeb9854ddd6e.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/dede7a7d20be69ff84424c787fe4313b/8fa77242acffb432-26/s540x810/9c81b2c2b2fa56ab28012925dfb6ac75cbde4eba.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/85dfdb385f8743379efd52ff7ffe884f/8fa77242acffb432-4f/s540x810/696654d41275923d000d3f1367fd8b1e254ae8af.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/67009b062a8ab1d3bd0ce27694f70d63/8fa77242acffb432-7b/s540x810/4ace689f502a5a6dcab2254639146882bf53d1bf.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/a3af6478acec70c57e8d005cd8578d49/8fa77242acffb432-7d/s540x810/b0e2087de2a26a0af7cdabc54873994dc573f951.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/693aa0d7fb74450c104589d27b71a642/8fa77242acffb432-5c/s540x810/73313e683b4c9bf94f46898ae198eeab9d92d406.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/1c168e8df4042078a6be83286e3424ec/8fa77242acffb432-22/s540x810/f84c30c67bf02e18a57ec3580b3c2ebabb07428f.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/6fef65b9e632f6341b92fa08b1b546f2/8fa77242acffb432-c9/s540x810/dcbb18b7df76cccb02175b80e222a2ce1174f925.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/e91137d2ef34a8db6e24c677e1674ce2/8fa77242acffb432-3a/s540x810/5c8d62c3c4cd93ea8dc1902fa5e29620e3041d8c.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/a9bace7e8a7fb6559fff72a4f3413ea1/8fa77242acffb432-7a/s540x810/9ea2ba0f5f7cc8a2d2e58b79cbcf83b469e3a4e6.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/4bb47fab468e443320d2f845f6d7e112/8fa77242acffb432-0a/s540x810/a028dcbcc94e1f7735dc0ec8e8ffb9c5d88db115.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/94455938f775715f87aad023c3a8507d/8fa77242acffb432-ba/s540x810/c1a8257e1024c0ed2077f498668070d57122076a.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/2b8454d882392ec90c26d1a90bb5da4b/8fa77242acffb432-b0/s540x810/e118f2e5f931889bb93dc478064876960ee40f09.jpg)
Exclusive new prints from Spoke Art available during the San Diego Comic Con (booth #4900), at the San Diego Convention Center, San Diego, CA, July 24-28 2024.
Art by Matt Taylor, Tracie Ching, Doaly, Steve Thomas, Andrew Kolb, Izzy Burton, Dakota Randall, Isabella Addison, Rose Couch and Aleksander Walijewski.
Online sales begin Thursday August 1 at 10am PT through the Spoke Art website.
#Art#Spoke Art#SDCC#San Dego Comic Con#Matt Taylor#Kiki's Delivery Service#Tracie Ching#Barbie#Demon Slayer#Doaly#Steve Thomas#Fallout#Andrew Kolb#The Simpsons#All Dogs Go To Heaven#Izzy Burton#Spy X Family#Dakota Randall#My Neighbor Totoro#Isabella Addison#The Fifth Element#Rose Couch#The Favourite#Aleksander Walijewski#poster#print
85 notes
·
View notes
Text
Family Cosplay time
#I just had to.#the don gang#ignore topher's giant head#total drama#td don#td topher#td dakota#td junior#td dwayne#local canadian family cosplays an italian gang from the mafia#daddon#my art
58 notes
·
View notes
Text
The voice actors of Coraline (2009)
#coraline#coraline (2009)#voice actors#2000s movies#2000s nostalgia#2000s animation#dakota fanning#teri hatcher#jennifer saunders#ian mcshane#george selick#dawn french#john hodgman#keith david#neil gaiman#henry selick#genre: family/horror#genre: family#animated horror#**🧸🎬#horror
43 notes
·
View notes
Text
Who wants to see a Milo Murphy au where Dakota and cav are good at their jobs and they get assigned to protecting Milo instead of pistachios
#batponiesrule28#thinking#milo murphys law#mml#vinnie dakota#balthazar cavendish#milo murphy#text post#fic idea?#you know. for the family dynamic#dwampyverse
164 notes
·
View notes
Text
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/e60b3e5bad0e641882c4d3de322961a5/b91df4befa05fa70-b4/s540x810/569cb218cc725421a2766717202661f3b6ef5656.jpg)
do you guys ever think about what wouldve happened if vyncent HAD killed mark. i do. a lot.
check out my commissions :D
#my post#my art#just roll with it show#fanart#jrwi pd#prime defenders#vyncent sol#dakota cole#i mean simply put ashe would NOT be their friend#but also. how long do you think ashe would have to be alone for him to notice something was wrong#how long before he started wondering if he was coming back this time#.... whats the protocol if a superhero kills a villain. would they investigate to find out his identity to get in contact w the family.#or do they like have a pit where they just toss corpses
38 notes
·
View notes
Text
Dakota Rain Cleary | Young Adult
22 notes
·
View notes
Text
Even when the Prime Defenders don't trust themselves, they know they can and WILL trust the others. They prove it over and over again.
William didn't trust his morality or his ability to do good. He only saw "evil" death powers, and didn't believe that he could do anything right, with either his powers or his own internal compass. But he ALWAYS trusted Vyncent and Dakota. Even when the three of them had differing morals, even when Dakota and Vyncent went through periods of time when they had to relearn their abilities. He had total faith that the two of them would be able to do the right thing.
Vyncent didn't trust his sense of self or purpose in a world so different from his own. He had to constantly weigh what he had known in his home up against nebulous, shifting ideas of legality and morality that he didn't ever have a full grasp of; and on top of that he had to decide who HE was, separate of his home and his connection with the Greats. However, he always leaned on his connection with William and Dakota for purpose. He helped them with their problems, stood with them on what they believed in, and formed his identity as he came into himself on Prime around his friendship with the two of them.
Dakota doesn't trust himself to not lose anymore. He couldn't save Ashe, he couldn't save Tide, he couldn't save the girl who fell. But in spite of that, he trusts that William and Vyncent won't put him through that again. That they'll be a team and share the weight. That the two of them can hold their own, and he doesn't have to always protect them. And on top of that, he trusts that they'll continue to stay with him and share with him, so that he isn't ever powerless to save them if the worst happens.
Like yeah their trust is tested. Oh so many times. But despite it they still trust each other more than ANYTHING. They care about each other and would give the world for each other. God I love prime defenders
#wow i seriously meant for this to be short. that really worked out huh#jrwi prime defenders#prime defenders#dakota cole#william wisp#vyncent sol#character analysis#anyways. go listen to battle cry by the family crest. the song that inspired this whole rant#they really would fight for each other! they would die for each other! for this moment for all time!#flippin flops
101 notes
·
View notes
Text
when the night has been too lonely, and the road has been too long 🎶🎵
and you think that love is only, for the lucky and strong 🎵🎶
a new challenge to draw your faves as the scene in Family Guy when they sing The Rose!
in order of characters: emma (total drama island 2023), jedediah (night at the museum), david (craig of the creek), rarity (mlp: fim), top cat (jellystone), dakota (milo murphy’s law), pinky (pinky and the brain), dracula (monster high g3)
original photo below break:
#total drama#night at the museum#cotc#mlp fim#jellystone#milo murphy's law#pinky and the brain#monster high#emma tdi#natm jedediah#cotc david#rarity#top cat#vinnie dakota#patb pinky#dracula monster high#family guy#family guy the rose#this is a great way to end off 2023#i dare you guys to do the same#well maybe not to end off 2023 bc it’s the 31st but
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
Yandere Volturi Guards Reactions To You Attempting To Escape:
WARNINGS: Yandere, running away, torture, angst, mature language, blackmail, manipulation, toxic relationship, seduction, etc.
SUMMARY: You tried to run away from your kidnapper lover but your attempt failed and now you have to face the consequences of your actions. Problem is, how will your beloved yandere react to it and what are the punishments that lie ahead for you?
AUTHOR'S NOTE: Honestly, I wanted to make this have more than just Felix, Jane, Alec, Heidi and Demetri but I don't know the entire background and personalities of the other Volturi guards, so perhaps next time when i have more information about them. I imagine Elizabeth Gillies as Heidi, but it's fine if you imagine her as someone else! Also, Felix's and Alec's actions are similar to each other but they are not exactly the same.
MASTERLIST & REQUESTS: Before you go, have a glass of wine or better yet, recommend a good bottle. any kind of message is always a delight.
-----
FELIX VOLTURI AKA THE EXECUTIONER
Felix tries to be understanding of your actions but he ends up being sad since he has done everything he could to make you happy and you still wanted to leave him after all this time. Demetri was the one to find you attempting to escape and managed to get you back to Volterra, but for some reasons, Demetri being the one to catch you trying to escape actually makes Felix feel worse than if he was the one to catch you himself. Felix just gave you space at first, only watching you from a distance, before he started giving you gifts and do small things that he knows you would appreciate. He was doing everything he could to make you stay. It was all geniune and you could see that as well. You probably end up feeling guilty in the end and agreed to continue to stay with him. However, to ensure that you wouldn't try to run away anymore, Felix would be stricter with security measures and made sure that there's a guard who's always secretly watching you from a distance at all times.
DEMETRI VOLTURI AKA THE CASANOVA
You tried to get away from Demetri Volturi? The best tracker in the whole fucking world? You must have been really bloody insane, confident or just quite desperate. There's nothing else left to be said. This man can literally track you anywhere and everywhere. He knows where you are at all times, not just because of his tracking gift, but also because of his vampire senses. And even if you did try to escape him while he's on a mission, he will always know how to find you and get you back in his arms again. He usually doesn't take your escapes seriously and almost think of it as a game of hide and seek or a challenge of some sort but at times when he does take it seriously, he gets a bit stricter with you afterwards and made sure that a guard is with you all the time.
ALEC VOLTURI AKA THE "NUMB" WITCH TWIN
You would usually try to escape while Alec is on a mission far away from Volterra, so it was always another guard who catches you trying to escape or even sneak out to just have some relaxation, most of the time it's Demetri or Felix. At first, Alec only stayed silent the whole time while he's always near you, before he starts giving you gifts and do small but sweet gestures that he knows you would appreciate, similar to Felix. However, unlike Felix, Alec's gifts and sweet gestures aren't geniune at all. They are all just part of his scheme to guilt trip you into staying with him. He would indirectly make you think that you are the one at fault. But if manipulation doesn't work with you, then he knows a few other extreme ways that does.
JANE VOLTURI AKA THE "PAIN" WITCH TWIN
Jane is furious. Very fucking furious. It certainly didn't make it any better that she was the one who had caught you trying to run away. Jane's solution to deal with your behaviour is through torture, but she would most likely not use her gift on you. Most likely. It depends on the situation entirely and Jane's mood as well. However, Jane will definitely force you into isolation in your room for weeks, perhaps even months if you continue to go against her. She would not allow anyone to go near your room, not even to deliver your meals. Jane will be the only one to do everything that's related to you. Not even his brother, Alec, has visited you once during your isolation. You will either break or kneel to her, it is all up to you. On a side note: she would probably force you into isolation a little longer than she had planned merely for fun, even if you were already begging her to let you out.
HEIDI VOLTURI AKA THE SEDUCTRESS
Heidi would be furious and annoyed as well if her darling mate tried to escape her. She was the one to catch you trying to escape when she noticed your scent lingering a little in the group of tourists she was leading in. She left to investigate and saw you hurrying into town. Heidi was a little more furious than she would be if you had attempted to escape on a regular day. Why? Well, you interrupted her during her fucking job, that's why. It will take a bit of time for her to forgive you but when she does, she will use her gift on you and attempt to seduce you. You will have a hard time resisting her, but if you somehow manage to resist her, then Heidi will have no other choice than to get help from Corrin. She will get her to mend the relationship between the both of you and Corrin will also make you forget about any doubts you have of Heidi throughout the relationship.
ALEC VOLTURI & JANE VOLTURI AKA THE WITCH TWINS
You had a yandere Alec or a yandere Jane, now imagine having a yandere Alec and a yandere Jane and trying to run away from them. Well, no one can help you now from their wrath, perhaps not even the masters, not like they would be paying much attention to the well being of the humans in their castle though. Alec is more "merciful" than his sister and will persuade her to give you a slightly lesser torturing punishment, but it's a little hard for her to do, especially since she was always the one to catch you doing things that the twins had forbidden you to do. Eventually, Jane settled on using your loved ones to blackmail you into staying with them. You were bloody terrified and agreed to stay, while Alec would be trying to "make up" to you for their actions afterwards by doing grand things that you would be completely in love with, whether it's to make sure your loved ones stays in a luxurious new home or anything that makes you momentarily forget about what they had done.
#demetri volturi#alec volturi#twilight#imagines#yandere imagines#yandere#felix volturi#jane volturi#the volturi#yandere volturi#volturiguards#books & libraries#gore#blood#torture#vampire#family#running away#marcus volturi#aro volturi#caius volturi#heidi volturi#elizabeth gillies#charlie bewley#dakota fanning#daniel cudmore#cameron bright
169 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ian Millhiser at Vox:
Oklahoma v. Department of Health and Human Services is the sort of case that keeps health policy wonks up late at night. On the surface, it involves a relatively low-stakes fight over abortion. The Biden administration requires recipients of federal Title X grants — a federal program that funds family-planning services — to present patients with “neutral, factual information” about all of their family-planning options, including abortion. Grant recipients can comply with this requirement by giving patients a national call-in number that can inform those patients about abortion providers. Oklahoma had long received Title X grants to fund health programs in the state. After receiving a $4.5 million grant in 2023, however, the state decided it would no longer comply with the requirement to give patients the call-in number. Accordingly, the administration terminated Oklahoma’s grant. Now, however, Oklahoma wants the Supreme Court to allow it to receive Title X funds without complying with the call-in number rule. Its suit has landed on the Court’s shadow docket, a mix of emergency motions and other expedited matters that the justices sometimes decide without full briefing or oral argument.
Oklahoma raises two arguments to justify its preferred outcome, one of which could potentially sabotage much of Medicare and Medicaid. Briefly, the state claims that federal agencies may not set the rules that states must comply with when they receive federal grant money, even if Congress has explicitly authorized an agency to do so. Taken seriously, Oklahoma’s proposed limit on federal agencies’ power would profoundly transform how many of the biggest and most consequential federal programs operate. As the Justice Department points out in its Oklahoma brief, “Medicare’s ‘Conditions of Participation’ for hospitals alone span some 48 pages in the Code of Federal Regulations.” All of those rules, plus countless other federal regulations for Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs, could cease to function overnight if the justices accept Oklahoma’s more radical argument. (Oklahoma’s second argument, which contends that the call-in rule is contrary to a different federal law, is less radical and more plausible than its first.)
This fight over whether Title X grant recipients must provide some abortion-related information to patients who seek it will be familiar to anyone who closely follows abortion politics. In 1988, the Reagan administration forbade Title X grant recipients from providing any counseling on abortion, and the Supreme Court upheld the Reagan administration’s authority to do so in Rust v. Sullivan (1991). Since then, the policy has sometimes changed depending on which party controls the White House. The Reagan-era policy was eliminated during the Clinton administration, and then revived in 2019 by the Trump administration. Biden’s administration shifted the policy again during his first year in office.
[...] Oklahoma, however, argues that Congress cannot delegate this kind of rulemaking power to a federal agency. If it wants to impose a condition on a federal grant, Congress must write the exact terms of that condition into the statute itself. The implications of this argument are breathtaking, as there are scads of agency-drafted rules governing federal grant programs. The Medicare rules mentioned in the Justice Department’s brief, for example, cover everything from hospital licensure to grievances filed by patients to the corporate governance of hospitals receiving Medicare funds. The rules governing Medicaid can be even more complicated. These are more vulnerable to a legal challenge under Oklahoma’s legal theory because Medicaid is administered almost entirely by states receiving federal grants. Oklahoma, in other words, is asking the Court to fundamentally alter how nearly every single aspect of hospital and health care administration and provision works in the United States — and that’s not even accounting for all the federal grant programs that are not health care-related.
[...]
If the justices are determined to rule in Oklahoma’s favor, there’s a way to do it without breaking Medicare and Medicaid
Oklahoma does raise a second legal argument in its suit that would allow it to receive a Title X grant, but that would not require the Court to throw much of the US health system into chaos. The Biden administration’s requirement that Title X providers must give patients seeking abortion information a call-in number arguably conflicts with a federal law called the Weldon Amendment.
The Weldon Amendment prohibits Title X funds from being distributed to government agencies that subject “any institutional or individual health care entity to discrimination on the basis that the health care entity does not provide, pay for, provide coverage of, or refer for abortions.” The three appellate judges who previously heard the Oklahoma case split on whether the Weldon Amendment prohibits the Biden administration’s rule. Two judges concluded, among other things, that providing a patient with a phone number that will allow them to learn about abortion is not the same thing as referring a patient for an abortion, and thus that the Biden rule was permissible. One judge (who is, notably, a Biden appointee) disagreed. In any event, Oklahoma’s Weldon Amendment argument gives this Supreme Court a way to rule against the Biden administration’s pro-abortion access policy without doing the kind of violence to Medicare and Medicaid contemplated by Oklahoma’s other argument. If the justices are determined to rule in Oklahoma’s favor, anyone who cares about maintaining a stable health system in the United States should root for the Court to take this less radical option.
The Oklahoma v. HHS case could be very big regarding Title X impact, along with Medicare and/or Medicaid.
#Oklahoma v. HHS#Medicare#Medicaid#SCOTUS#Abortion#Title X#Biden Administration#Family Planning#Shadow Docket#Rust v. Sullivan#South Dakota v. Dole#Weldon Amendment
15 notes
·
View notes