#i do not write i am not a writer and i have no intentions of writing this but good god i almost feel like i have to
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
I'll die on the hill that infuriating companions that bicker and bitch constantly are more compelling than constantly friend and nice ones. It's hard for Bioware to sell the idea of a found family to me when all the companions seem to like and interact with each other more than the protagonist!
To me, it feels like we're a boss/therapist with a barrier of authority around us. It's a shame because I doubt it was the writers' intent for it to come off that way. I enjoy the game and companions but maaaan.
Let me tell someone to fuck off, Bioware! I can be a good guy AND still be assertive!
i 100000% agree, its funny to see them beef, and its almost as if giving the characters the opportunity to overcome prejudices and first impressions leads to more interesting dynamics and bonds, who knew. i just find this watering down so odd considering DA's history of writing complex relationships, and also how , as far as i know...the major complaints levied against newer bioware titles have never been "the characters are too mean"?????? like am i crazy???? why did they do this????
#like i genuinely dont know if it would just be in bad faith to say the writers dont get dragon age#or if thats a fair criticism#i want to attribute the bland writing to the complete lack of political intrigue but its completely possible to write 2 characters who just#hate each other for no reason
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
I apologize in advance, this guy spent a decade rotating in teenage me's brain.
I feel really complicated about the Drizzt article for a couple of reasons. One, Drizzt was invented in the late 80s/early 90s, and was one of the first attempts to have a 'good' Black character in mainstream Written By White People Fantasy. Two, he was also one of the first canonical portrayals, if not the first, of any moral complexity in the canon of the D&D multiverse. Before him, drow (dark elves) were completely evil cannon fodder. Suddenly there was nuance, and entire races that were considered universally evil in the canon had the opportunity to be reconsidered. Three, the author who invented him was not the author who invented the 'dark elf = evil' canon, he was working in an existing universe with existing rules and turned everything on its head, for the better.
While he is not a perfect character, or perfectly written, he is a very important milestone and should be treated as such.
I am not in any way trying to criticize you, I however do feel like that article did not give him the context he deserves.
I hope you receive me respectfully because I am speaking respectfully.
You are right about the importance of context! It should be provided when making arguments like this, and this character existing was an important milestone for D&D as a form of entertainment. I do favor the high top fade on the elf.
That being said, even with the context, I personally don't have to value that the milestone for making D&D more complex with better, fuller writing for everyone else, was through a misunderstanding and misapplication of racism via a Black character that continues in fantasy to date. By that time, there were Black writers and players that could have contributed, and I wish that the white author had referenced them so that he'd done it properly. So I understand the importance in the character's existence! It's just that the intent was there, the delivery was not.
19 notes
·
View notes
Text
in MDZS the novel, the innkeeper in Yunping mentions that people are too scared to go petition Yunmeng Jiang for help because someone once walked in on Sect Leader Jiang whipping a guy in the main hall, supposedly because the guy was a demonic cultivator.
#mdzs#jiang cheng#wei wuxian#jc apologism#anyways as you can hopefully tell by now this is a jc stan blog.#so as a stan i will do my rightful stan duty and insist that my fave did nothing wrong#so. onwards. the “jiang cheng tortures demonic cultivators” claim is interesting on several levels#because we don't see it happen onscreen. and because thematically mdzs is a book about the unreliability of rumors#especially when said rumors conform to your preexisting understanding of someone. or what you want to hear about someone#it would have been so easy for mxtx to include a scene where jc tortures a demonic cultivator onscreen. i would love to read it too#but that doesnt happen. when jc actually corners wwx he just shoves a dog in his face and bullies him emotionally#smh jc get your shit together!! what is this lame ass display?? not living up to your reputation here loser#anyways. tbh i consider two things separately: 1. mxtx's intentions. and 2. what the text itself implies#for 1. i am legitimately unsure of what to think. mxtx relies on rumors/empathy/etc to give us info about side characters#in part because she's constrained herself to writing from wwx's perspective and has no other easy way of getting the info to us#does she intend for us to question the rumors? or are we supposed to take them as fact because of the narration limits described?#2. what the text itself implies is not necessarily the same as what mxtx intends.#for me mdzs is in part a story about the unreliability of rumors and reputation etc etc. other meta writers than i have explained it better#so for the work to go “all the rumors about wwx were exaggerated/manipulated/not 100% correct.”#“but the rumors about everyone else are 100% true!!!!!”#is peak stupidity. and shit-tier writing#and i actually like mdzs so i would like to believe the writer is more intelligent than that#thus. i conclude in part due to this emotional necessity of mine that there must have been something more going on#anyways. i have similar opinions about the “did jiggy kill rusong” business but that's a post for later#ill probably put my jc torture opinions in their own post some day#yanyan polls
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
I am obsessed with how narratively convenient Lark's divinatory abilities are. She's the only one of the protagonists who is both pragmatic and has a working sense of self-preservation, so having some internal impulse that is actually the guiding hand of the cosmos pushing her into doing the REALLY stupid shit is both necessary and really useful.
Like, I am the type of writer who kind of scoffs at the idea that characters are beyond the writer's control and will completely screw over your outline, because on one hand, a sensible outline will follow the characters' personalities and tendencies anyway. Obviously in an ensemble cast you will need to do some wrangling, but in theory your characters are responding to varying degrees of stimuli in order to maneuver them into the places you need them to be for things to all come together in the end.
But more importantly, "curse from god" is the funniest and easiest way to push any character to do things beyond the realm of reason when necessary, and frankly, what the fuck is the point of playing god if you don't embrace that?
#midst podcast#midst spoilers#cr meta#anyway at all times I am advocating for taking full responsibility for your characters and overall story#this is also why I laugh at those posts like 'um if you're not going to treat your characters right then you shouldn't get custody of them'#sorry babe there is no CPS in my head. I am the cruel custodian and these are my poor darwinian orphans.#that's a joke but really like. look. yeah sometimes you gotta fabricate scenarios to make characters do what you want#but like... you do that by going 'who is this character and what would it take to push them to x'???#and especially in an ensemble cast sometimes that thing is 'curse from god' or 'divine insight'#fun fact: I LOATHE that post about 'my writing teacher made a joke that the characters are driving and the writer is locked in the trunk'#absolutely fucking hate it.#because THE WHOLE POINT OF FORMALLY LEARNING WRITING IS LEARNING HOW TO BE INTENTIONAL.#it is perfectly possible to write successfully without ever having a formal teacher but IF YOU HAVE A FORMAL TEACHER. UH.#like yeah yeah 'workshopping' but like. okay go build your own workshop group don't pay somebody jfc#(cuz it's not like most creative writing teachers know how to teach you to workshop. let's be fucking real.)#if you wanna learn how to workshop take a script class for the love of god.#ANYWAY rant over but I'm correct. the highest purpose of a writer is to be a control freak and to play god.
26 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm going to say again like I know it is really dumb to feel this way, but I finally put into words why I get so annoyed when people ask me for a part 2 to one of my works. Like I explained once to people that writing is a very slow and arduous task for me, but it's more than that?
Picture you are an artist working on a painting. You spend months on it to get everything just right. You pour time and energy into getting the perfect composition, the perfect lighting, the perfect shades etc. And then finally, you finish it. After a year, you finally finished your masterpiece. And your work is a hit. People really like it. But then.... Someone comes up to you and says, "Gosh, I really love this painting! But you know what? I love it so much that I think the painting is much too small. You know what? You should add on two extra feet of canvas onto the right side of your painting. That way, you can add on more to your painting and it'll be even bigger and more enjoyable!"
To me, that's what it feels like when someone asks for a part two. Like this last fic honest to God I started on more than a year ago. Granted, I'd pick it up and put it back down, but I put a lot of work into making sure everything was as perfect as possible. It's not an amazing fic, mind you, but it still gave me a lot of trouble. But eventually I finished it into a COMPLETE work. It's a finished painting. That's the story I wanted to tell in its entirety.
I get why people want a part two. I get that the story ends to leave you wanting to know what happens next. But that's the point. That's the story I wanted to tell. It's complete. This isn't supposed to be pure romance. It's supposed to be more on the comedic side. But when people ask for a part two, it's like they're telling me that they're not satisfied with my artwork, that it's not perfect and needs more work for it to become perfect. It's like they're ignoring all the year's worth of effort I put into making sure the composition, wording, humor, etc was just right. Not only that. I should put another year's worth of work into making it truly perfect. It's insulting and exhausting.
Granted, like I said, I do understand people completely do not intend to make me feel this way. I'm not irritated with these people directly. I know it's supposed to be a compliment. But like.... Maybe it's because I'm prideful but I really can't help but be insulted. It's telling me that I didn't do a good job as a writer.
#rambles#'but a good writer makes people want to read more!!'#that's true but i still dont like it#i have a feeling if i explained this to my grandpa he'd understand what i mean#i think another reason why it rubs me the wrong way is... the attitude people have to fanmade content in general#people on this site have no appreciation for hard work#this site is mainly greasy fast food when it comes to reader-insert fics#when they ask for a part two it feels like they're putting in an order at mcdonalds#they're only doing it to reap the rewards of my hard work#i can't spit these things out in one sitting#i swear to god i take an average of eight months or more to release any long work#asking for a part 2 really isnt a compliment at all#you're just giving me an order#you didn't tell me a single thing about why you liked my work. just that you want more#like does this make sense?#istg writing this is like.... i am so my grandfather's granddaughter#both prideful obsessed loners that cant take a compliment#also if its not clear if you added two extra feet of canvas to the right of a painting like....#you essentially have to rework the whole thing#might as well start from the very beginning#every intentional choice you made in your painting is ruined#i know it sounds like i'm exaggerating but that's what it feels like being told to add a part two#i cant just simply add on a chapter#i have to reframe everything from the ground up#do you realize how daunting that is?
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
i know the Willow Mellow lore gets worse the longer you dig inside of it + it reflects even Worse on the writers when you put the actual words on her situation but let's not forget Darlings she is a child. she is 15 to 17yo depending on what piece of documentation we refer to, too young to consent to sex and therefore does not fit the category of "sex worker", and instead falls under the definitions of "sexually exploited youth", more specifically "sexually exploited child", as UNICEF, UNESCO, Convention for the Rights of the Child, [...] and general common sense all define "child" as "person under the age of 18".
she is the victim of kidnapping by her """adoptive father""" and of sexual exploitation by her (presumably adult) "clients" (as she does not appear to have a pimp, and is instead written saying she loves what she does and such giddy teehee fun. [powerful side-eye through someone in the writing team.] [she's not a Real Person I have to stress, so someone wrote her like this, wrote this kid like this.] [it is all part of a narrative in which she is struggling to shake off her "father's" exploitation, an inherently tragic one, but she still was written that way, and could have been written any other way, with any other "rebellious" act]). calling her a sex worker as a child who is basically the same age as P2 Capella or Grace is putting her in a Grown-Up category especially harmful considering we are supposed to read her as an indigenous girl, member of the Kin (even if her lore is Mysterious and Hazy) and indigenous women and girls are sexualized in racialized ways which often paint them as more ~~~naturally~~~ sexually liberated, or docile, or submissive, or [insert racist x sexist stereotype promoted by colonizers to excuse the mistreatment of indigenous women and girls].
tldr yes it's worse when you actually call her what she actually is, and worse tenfold when you read what the writers make her say about it [even as an inherently tragic situation that we can recognize and put words on (hence this post), she could have been written any other way, with any other rebellious act, but you know.] but you know x2 (SIDE-EYES SOMEONE ON THE WRITING TEAM VERY HARD TIL ME EYES POP OUT ME SKULL)
#/!\ POST ABOUT SEMANTICS. POST ABOUT SEMANTICS ALERT. /!\#this is not pointed or written with wicked intents btw ^ i've seen it a few times from different people and it's just that if we want to be#able to talk about these things within the narrative and how the depictions of the Kin impact the around-game/critique this game in general#game (esp. p1 which is very much about. words and wording and navigating webs of words among so many other things)#we have to be able to name these things. especially in relation to. d*bowski do you mind coming to the mic and telling us#what was behind your head. no pressure sir#protecting this kid from the writing with my entire body like that one soldier meme#ooh d*bowski you are not making it out alive i'll tell you that much.#in the same way you wouldn't call mcdonalds hiring 14yo ''employment'' you'd call it. exploitative child labor.#but it's even worse because <3 aw the misogyny oozing through the pores of a lot of the patho narrative#because of maybe perhaps allegedly the head writer. allegedly!#how the fuck am i supposed to tag any of this#csa /#willow mellow#willow pathologic#pathologic#it'd be Less Worse if she was an adult bc at least she could consent [in a vacuum; if we ignore the fact that she's a kidnapping victim;#if we ignore the fact that the Kin who she merges with sees its women be sexualized and its ways of life crushed by the colonizers#and assimilated in ways they might not like; etc] but yknow. detailed herb brides bodies and whatnot.
50 notes
·
View notes
Text
Does poor things get good or is it just uncomfortable born yesterday woman trope turned literal the whole way through
#we had to stop watching bc it was triggering but i would be open to giving it another chance at some point#however i am currently side eyeing the writer#like u could have just not given her a baby brain#why do men love to write women characters who are technically babies is my question#my opinion may change if i have more context abt the intent and process behind the film + lore etc but#yknow#just jumping in wasnt very fun#I was told it may be commentary on the absurdity of the born yesterday trope which im like hm okay fair#i will give it a shot again if my film friends watch it on discord w me
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
<- guy who thinks too much about geed for a silly show with 25 eps
#do i have any other coherent ideas to offer about the show? not really but i sure am thinking about it#the foils and parallels and echoes and reverberating intent in it hooks into my brain really badly#also just as a matter that it seems that a few of the core writing staff there are some of my favorite current ultra writers#i rewatched a little bit of decker on in the bg recently and the neomegas eps were good....#thanks mister nemoto for the monster weapon eps i like them lots and lots!!!!!!!#krtext
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
i need 2 be more clear that my posts abt unironically liking scum villain are not meant 2 be "i love it no i dont yes i do no i dont <3" but are actually meant to be "i love scum villain and it makes me feel a kind of way that it's always talked abt in a way that makes it sound like it's just a trashy guilty pleasure book bc imo it does make for a good, fun, sad, heartwarming story and it is worth talking abt as its own story and not 'MXTX's silly book vs. her two masterpieces'" like yes it is silly and fun but also i have never cried so hard over a piece of media showing that sometimes things just truly aren't fair and you can never turn back time to fix your mistakes so instead you just have to keep moving forward knowing more than you did before
i am making mountains out of mole hills but also. my blog my hill to die on <3
#taps the sign stories can be funny and ridiculous and also still have an overall very deep message#i also need 2 stress i am making mountains rn but i have just had this on my mind as of late#like it's not perfect and everyone has different tastes but it's also like#idk! i find joy in doing close readings of it#and it is a little disheartening to have that question of 'am i truly reading too deeply into this'#as if mxtx is not a skilled writer who obviously has intent behind her writing
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
[+] my revision of formulation for the whole study & thesis was majorly approved, ppl can no longer pretend to or actually be lost
[+] minion² was contained, showed up in person and got the sense that no one was going to take his nonsense
[+] no major disagreement between the supes, all subteams understand their tasks
[-] back-to-back-to-back meetings w advisors, integrators, external working groups, and study lead in the next two weeks
[-] i have to finish reading... 15+ papers and compile their data
[-] fix a data structure implementation in my optimization model that i had promised since... nov last year lol (it wasn't entirely necessary. until now)
we'll see if i'm in the mood for stress relief writing instead of just stress relief daydreaming... there's a lot of stuff for every fic but it's all over the place. tpac hyperfixation is still holding strong (esp when compared to all other wips, it is second place for most concrete ending + actual epilogue)
(first place is larb bc every chapter is outlined and scoped; just haven't felt like writing it)
(not saying the other fics don't have planned endings but besides their plot i don't have the context for the endings yet. the shape of the ending scenes are very much informed by the long, in-between chapters)
#academic jerky#redglyphs#was so 1000% business mode that one of the supes did the equivalent of '👉👈 ...we're okay right?'#also my other stress relief is trolling the new firstie under my wing (in good fun ofc)#this is the one i'm shielding from minion²'s nonsense#he's finding out exactly how willing i am to commit to a bit#but he's also a humongous weirdo so like and like#anywho rl is both rough but looking up#good things will come in march :)#also final thing: a reminder to both readers and writers that there is a real person on the other side of that screen#have been receiving a few comments that (on good faith) come from a place of praise and enthusiasm but...#there is a hint of uhhh... to them. like someone wrote it forgetting that a real person will read it without their face-to-face context#i'm not a blindly 'positive words only!! 🥰🥰🥰' type of person bc fucking obviously from my posts lol#but if one's intent is to convey something positive then do it without negging. do it without backhandedness or putdowns to others.#it is a valuable skill to learn how to communicate civilly. if this scares ppl into thinking 'well... now idk what to write or comment'...#okay. but know that you gotta practice irl or online soon enough and online is lower stakes than irl#and the only reason you might never need to know how to talk civilly is if you're an absolute recluse
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
the sudden urge of deleting all my fics, deactivating my blog and starting a whole new one
#(💭) shitpost#I won't do it BUT the urge is just... there#I have been re-reading all my past work and I feel so unsatisfied with it#That only means I've improved a bit in my writing but STILL I wish I could re-write or just delete everything lmfao#Sometimes I just want to start new and fresh but I am too attached with this blog to do so#I will just keep getting better ! And I will do my best#Also despite my inactivity and this whole writer's block that has lasted for almost a YEAR... I have no intention of leaving tumblr
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
I cannot reblog my last socionics post for 1418 but if i may be vain... i went off in it.
#i missed doing commentaries abt things i love and feel strongly abt#its a good way to like. keep me sane abt writing.#its nice to talk abt what you liked and your flaws and intentions and pick it apart i literally have learned#so many things from my writer friends in prev fandoms who wrote fic notes unprompted. just out of pure interest n excitement#i turned off reblogs on the post bc i dont want it ever getting out of this blog lol...#do not perceive me perceiving these men#i mean no one will reblog that post but still#it is not correct but i am incorrect in a way that works
1 note
·
View note
Text
.
#i shouldny yap abt fgis project bc its not like . i have sny real intention of making it into a Thing#like an actual tv show . its more or less like a school assessment vibe thing#like. write a whole pilot for a tv show. and then do up the rest of season 1 in Full detail#and the plans for the rest of the series in blurbs .#bc i am a writer. or i Was. and i was a fucking good one at that !#so . i do wanna see how diffrrent this is.#side note. my irl cslling this fucking fanfiction was insane. bc . oh he wasnt wrong vut at the same time#HELLO#?????? KINDA OUT OF POCKET?????? i was gagged for a solid 5 mins im ngl.#anyway.
0 notes
Text
had a dream that sid was starring in a production of bye bye birdie so now i’m going to be plagued for the rest of my life by a musical theatre fic that i will never write smh
#actor sid techie geno my beloveds#i’m going to think of you fondly for the rest of forever#i feel like i should also note that i do not really know or particularly care about bye bye birdie#so like. why did my brain choose that of all possible shows?#if i ever did write anything i would have to do something else#omg sid as link larkin in hairspray#or corny collins#omg my thoughts are racing rn i can’t deal with this#i do not write i am not a writer and i have no intentions of writing this but good god i almost feel like i have to#they say write what you know etc etc
1 note
·
View note
Text
A question for writers.
How long did it take you to finish a first draft of a book (I mean a proper book, around +300 pages) and did you have a full time job at the time?
Asking for a friend (Me. I am the friend, who is trying to write the first draft for over 2 years and is in a shithole).
#tbh from 2023 to 2023 i was mostly writing and rewriting second chapter cause I couldn't get it right#and has a lot of personal life turbulations#but in the beggining of 2024 i flew through chapters#until work got too intense#i feel like a failure and i need someone to tell me: is that me? is that just life? does that happen?#or do you guys just speed through the 1st draft as God intented?#writeblr#spilled ink#writers on tumblr#writerscommunity#bookblr#i feel like everyone is creativly speed writing 1st draft#and to me it is a long proccess of learning and overcoming my anxietes and fears XD#idk man#maybe i wasn't made for this after all#thats a lie#i like creating random fake shit#other words#and make dreams reality#but it takes so loooong#and i am procrastinating#but I also have a personality disorder#might that be another one reason as to why it's taking me so long?#i feel like i'm just starting to understand and learn about how writing should look like#i had a lot of issuess with it and with my work proccess bc of some harsh words of strangers#ok it was one stranger in middle school#took me off of writing for a few years#idk why am i writing all of this#i know i am oversharing#but to some degree i feel like i should explain myself
0 notes
Text
homestuck is a partially improvisional serialized narrative so yes some parts of the story emerged over time and writing decisions were made on the fly. and some readings of the comic that i think are really good are probably not what the author intended. but no i do not think that it is 'good on accident' actually.
like do some of you think hussie wrote a good comic by accident
#do you even think this is good at all if you're so eager to denounce and discredit the writer's intent?#i don't love every writing decision & there's stuff in there that i think unequivocally sucks but i very much dislike that attitude#but hey! perhaps not everyone has the same definition of 'good' as i do!#i like the execution of the story and i like exploring what it has to say even if i don't always agree with its conclusions#look at me i'm a jake english stan. i don't follow the works conclusions to the letter. or at least i take issue w how it says those things#but ig all some fandoms care about is how disgestible the characters are. be that because theyre shippable#or because they're hashtag relatable#and even though i too have fun playing with the characters in the fanon sandbox i am sick to death of that taking prescedence over the work
234 notes
·
View notes