#dogma pov
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Clones with cats

Yep cats are cute 🥰
#star wars#the clone wars#pov#my pov#clone troopers#captain rex#commander cody#commander wolffe#commander gregor#commander colt#commander thorn#commander fox#commander neyo#commander monnk#commander bacara#commander bly#commander appo#commander gree#arc trooper fives#arc trooper echo#clone medic kix#clone trooper tup#clone trooper dogma#arc trooper hardcase#arc trooper jesse#clone trooper waxer#clone trooper boil#clone wars 501st#212th battalion#501st legion
91 notes
·
View notes
Text
our tragic handsome regal polite wise gentlemanly chivalrous dragon-prince of gentle guidance with a charming sense of humor who understands his place in the cycle and takes it with grace despite having so much taken from him and being so exhausted and ancient that no one is sure if his name really is a name at all. and he loves you so much and wants you to succeed so badly, not out of a selfish wish to be free but instead because you two share a bond like no other, and will build you up yet maintain an air of untouchableness so when you do finally face him you feel like you're actually doing something unbelievable while also trying to lessen the pain of the loss of your cosmic bond by not letting you two get too close despite being the only ones who can truly understand the position the other is in. and yet is still a force of nature and lets that be shown, with potent tact that leaves you quaking in your boots and/or swooning and weak in the knees.

VS their violent visceral boyish brutal villainous hollow part-in-a-play delinquent rapscallion prisoner who thrives off of grotesque displays of power, with no name or sense of identity at all besides being the great evil you must defeat, who's so tired of his job he bullies you when you don't kill him good enough and also takes other dragons' lunch money (and "killing" him feels so hollow and meaningless and typical and boring and fruitless. because it is) (but also he still loves you profoundly despite the unnatural brevity of your time together. he knows a bond is supposed to exist that you were both robbed of and he feels that and he still loves you and wants you to succeed after you grant him a true death and tries to protect you all that he can from malevolent higher powers in his last moments. you're in this together. break the chains that bind you both with the blessings whispered with his final breath as the wind under your sails.)

#.txt#i've had this in my drafts since sept 2024 i think it's a good time to set it free#dragon's dogma#dragon's dogma 2#ddda#dd2#grigori#i love them both i have ocs who kiss them both i even named dd2 dragon. make no mistake. i just wanted to word salad about their difference#and similarities... O_o#from My POV#ddda spoilers#jic...
20 notes
·
View notes
Text
POV: You’re a Republican Christian entering Heaven
#POV: You’re a Republican Christian entering Heaven#videos#video#christofascists#republicans#christianity#christian#heaven#hell#dogma#religion#atheism#atheist#usa is a terrorist state#usa is funding genocide#usa news#usa politics#usa#american indian#american#america#ausgov#politas#auspol#tasgov#taspol#australia#fuck neoliberals#neoliberal capitalism#anthony albanese
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
20 notes
·
View notes
Text

Finally managed to finish my Phantom Oxcart quest one-shot before it could be doomed to ever be a WIP.
AO3 link
Straightforward pawn sulks, then disobeys, and then shows how much he cares
#dd2#dragon’s dogma 2#arisen oc: sylvas#pawn oc: thorne#dd2 spoilers#dd2 fanfix#i feel soooo bad for rushing at the end but OUGH my brain just works hard and then the writing Trickles 1-2 sentences a day smh#but 5k words is Really something for me so👏🏼#get your thorne pov!!!!#this screenshot pissed me off Long after i took it specifically for this post. alas no one else might notice why and i cannot retake it
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
Okay, a few years back I made this graphic to explain the Great Cycle. Now that I've mulled over DD2 for a few days, I'm updating it. Some of the same assumptions as before remain: The Dragonforged fought the dragon, his weapon broke, he tried punching it (lmao), but he did survive without killing the dragon, possibly there was a second Bargain offered in the face of his determination. So you don't have to kill your dragon to survive it. Also still assuming that different classes become different types of drakes because I just like that detail, even though we see nothing to confirm it in DD2 (except maybe for the wyrms in the post-game, I hope that's what those are, just a bit redesigned).
But this time, I'm making some NEW assumptions: A Great Dragon can be manifested directly by the Seneschal's will (I'm guessing this is why our DD2 dragon doesn't have a name, I suspect this dragon was created after Rothais defeated his - he didn't become a dragon OR Seneschal so it had to come from somewhere). The challenge a Seneschal poses to the Arisen can be anything; Savan gave us the opening of the Everfall and unleashed a ton of powerful monsters upon the world; but Pathfinder gave us what the world would look like without a Seneschal to oversee things. My assumption is that the Colossal Dragon that appears out of that final red pillar of light IS the Pathfinder (possibly using his will to force order back upon the world) and when we kill it, our Arisen becomes Seneschal (because Pathfinder says he won't be there to see the new world that's forming). So the challenge can be anything, not just the Everfall. I'm curious what happens to our pawn after that fight, though. And it's a much better Seneschal fight than the one against Savan, sorry Savan.
I'm also assuming that (given we see the Pathfinder rewind time and rewrite the world) the Seneschal can simply will the world into a state of being that suits them. This includes wiping memories of events. Though I like to imagine that our Arisen-turned-Seneschal didn't wipe memories of themselves or of the apocalypse-world. There was an entire plotline going through this game with Rothais and Phaesus where mortals are trying to get rid of the Seneschal and so it makes sense that they need to remember what would happen without the Seneschal's presence.
Anyway, thanks. I'll probably have more thoughts later, but this is the part that gets me most. I like to know how things work so I wanted to sort the Cycle out.
#dragon's dogma#dragon's dogma 2#dragons dogma#reliviews#the great cycle#personal#i wonder where a ng+ will put me#i really am excited to play ng+#but i need a break to rotisserie chicken what i've got so far#i'll come back to it with a fresh pov after a few weeks i think#there are of course still things i wanna know#what's the deal with the dragonsplague#it's not just a mechanic they added to troll us#but what is its significance#what happens to our pawn after we defeat the colossal dragon#they flat out state we infused them with will of their own#so do they become human after that#or does the plague kill them#and there are always timeline questions#what happens to lamond and this new dragonforged#how long ago were they arisen#what about rothais#he's not even really alive anymore but does he finally get to die#is the brinepocalypse something that HAS to happen periodically#to like clean slate the world#to remind people of the importance of the seneschal and maintain peace for a time afterwards#what happened to religion#there was a maker and faith-church in the first game#where's that now have people just forgotten to worship the seneschal#anyway
24 notes
·
View notes
Text

ddda posting
#pov you are me the first time playing the game trying to glitch past the golem to get behind selene's house#dragon's dogma#ddda#i should make one of these but 'lebron james forgot to equip a ranged vocation to fight a metal golem'
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Fandom: Dragon’s Dogma 2
Pairing: Phaesus x Arisen
Chapter 4 rating: M
AO3

Chapter 4 excerpt:
Killian
Dusk settles, cloaking the sky in a hue of deep blue, the fringes layered like a colorful sorbet as the last light of the sun slowly slips beyond the horizon. Billowy clouds lazily float along in cool, shadowed tones and Killian closes his journal. There is not much else to take note of in the Nameless Village and his sketches have turned into two braided plaits and the Arisen’s silhouette and what he imagines she’d look like with such a pretty backdrop. It’s his sign to quit with the musings. Sitting up, he uses the nearby wheelbarrow to pull himself to his feet. His knees groan in protest, disagreeing with his choice of sitting on the ground cross legged. But once righted and the weariness shaken from his limbs, he tucks away his journal into his pack. With a quick glance of his surroundings, he notes the Arisen still has not returned.
Spying Rook near the bank of the pond, he wanders over, folding his arms across his chest. “Has the Arisen made an appearance yet?”
“Are you not always saying, ‘we must not hurry the Arisen’?” Rook picks up a fairly flat and smooth rock and flicks his wrist. The rock skips one, two, three times and then splashes beneath the surface.
“True indeed. I just find it unusual that she has not returned.”
Rook bends down, scooping up two more rocks. He offers one to Killian. “Do you believe the Arisen to be in danger?”
“I suppose not.” Killian takes the offered stone and attempts to imitate Rook’s wrist movement. His rock sinks straight into the water. No skipping.
“She bestowed upon us our charge. It is best we abide by it.” This time his rock skips five times and almost reaches the other side of the pond.
“Right. Of course,” Killian says. But he grasps the strap over his shoulder and makes his way up the hill and further into town.
Stopping by the apothecary, he browses, occasionally lifting a draught or elixir and raises it eye-level for an inspection. Returns them and then glances further up the path that leads to the manor and hopes Gwyn will appear.
“Looking for something in particular?” A blonde woman with golden eyes approaches him in a dress of green with white apron, her brown boots covered in a layer of dried mud that is also smeared on the hem of her dress. “Or someone?”
“There are many dangers on the road. Tis better to be safe than—”
“Dead?”
Killian half laughs and clears his throat while pushing his glasses up the bridge of his nose. “Twas going to say full of regret. Death does not come so easy for the likes of me and my traveling companions. Still, pain is felt and rather uncomfortable, even debilitating at times, so if it can be prevented by a draught or elixir, then by all means I will be replenishing our stock.”
Her eyes go wide with realization and she lays a hand on his forearm. “You are a pawn. What is that like?”
“What is it like? I know not how to answer that. What is it like to be human?”
#bear writes#dd2#dragon’s dogma 2#dd2 fanfic#Killian (quil) pov#ascension#chapter 4#phaesus x arisen#this chappy gets interesting when quil is yanked into the rift ☺️
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
God, the beginnings of satient beings
God (the shaitan-physical god) has created a serving body/body-of-servitude (feeding, bringing another body life etc. important and essential for serving a community) (like any tool we use, that serve us, such as a teapot 🫖 or a candle 🕯) and placed a soul there, like a feeler. To soon feel pain of being subjugated into forced gender roles(both bio and societal, and mental).
He created this bio-gender inequality within humans to make discord and people hated each other (or controlled) based on sexual privilege and difference.
#“Saint Mariam' pregnancy and her son's Jesus's birth from Islam's POV”#Can you buzz of#Keep your religious-fanatic-philosophy views and articles out of female reproduction; vjayjaybirths#Shaitan-maitan-gyavor-HIMpronouns-dicked-ofaGod#Fuk off#Male-fanatic-faith-Dogma#Ugly dik#faith god#Pysical-God is very strange it has created creatures to then eradicate and domineer eachother#That's where we have claws and sharp teeth in animals during the evolution#Cells are programed to consume for their favor and survive; I guess that's their philosophy#But people shouldn't be like that#They have a choice#I wander if the Earth was more proper for life but still a hostile place for a survival#God-theory#Feminism#Female pov of (evil) god(s)
0 notes
Text

POV: you wake up in the middle of your own autopsy with force powers then immediately get brainwashed into falling to the dark side
I was reminded of the fact that I haven’t drawn inquisitor!fives’ autopsy scars in way too long so here I am, delivering a few too many Fives 💀

Anyway I know I don’t post much about the AU on here so props to anyone who knows what’s going on here even slightly, I’ve decided to nerf siren!echo (who WAS part of this AU yes I know quite random) but since him being turned into a siren kinda limits what I can do with him story wise he is now an AU of the AU.
That means the name I came up with for the au (dead mean walking/swimming or dmw(s) as I’ve been tagging it) is kinda irrelevant. I’ll just call this the inquisitor fives AU but if you have any AU name suggestions feel free to drop them.
Here are some of the major factors of the AU:
It gets worse before it gets better
(WARNING: there are quite a few heavy topics covered in the AU such as torture, dehumanisation and su*cidal thoughts, so pls read at your own discretion)
- fives wakes up in the middle of his own autopsy with force sensitivity, then gets brainwashed into falling to the Dark Side by Palpatine. As an Inquisitor, he does not remember anything about his life because those memories were blocked by Palpatine.
- Palpatine discovers that Fives is essentially immortal, and any injuries inflicted on him will heal no matter how bad.
- when echo gets rescued from skako minor, he is recalled to Kamino for experimentation, first of all so they can figure out what the Techno Union did to him, second of all to see how he survived his injuries. Nala se, who knows that fives came back to life, theorises that since he and echo were tube twins they share the “immortality”. He is kept on Kamino for VERY extensive experimentation where terrible things happen to him (cough vivisection cough lobotomy) and so never joins Clone Force 99 even if he did work with them on Anaxes.
- Fives in this time is sent out on many missions by Palpatine that involve him unaliving many people, and after the rise of the Empire he hunts a few Jedi.
- Fox, who throughout the war had experienced many blackout missions where he woke up afterwards covered in blood, is the last living Coruscant Guard commander. (Thorn dies, stone vanishes one day, Thire mistakes Vader for a Jedi and pays the price) Despite the best efforts of his son secretary Dogma (no way!?) Fox has very little will to live, is extremely depressed and borderline suicidal, he would like nothing more than to bite the dust, but still feels he has a duty to the very few remaining corries and so tries to keep it together (he is failing)
- one day Palpatine decides he doesn’t need Fox to do his bidding anymore since he has much better assets at his disposal (Fives), and decides it would be ironic to sic his pet clone inquisitor onto Fox. Fives still doesn’t remember anything, and only knows that Fox is responsible for the main scars on his body and believes fox is the reason he doesn’t remember most of his life, and so sets out to kill fox. They battle it out (ref to that one animation wip I posted) and fives is on the verge of killing fox (who didn’t really try to fight that much, like I said he would very much like to die and dying at the hand of the vod he “killed” seems fitting to him) when he gets a sudden vision of echo.
- all fives knows is echo is extremely important to him and must be rescued and that snaps him out of palpatine’s control. He knows he probably can’t rescue echo alone, and since fox has already been betrayed by the empire he decides “fuck it” and basically kidnaps fox and they run. They make a deal, that once echo has been found, Fives will put Fox out of his misery (fox feels that fives should be the only person to kill him, and only goes along with the plan because he refuses to let anyone else kill him)
- fox and fives proceed to go on an intergalactic road trip to “rescue echo” even though neither of them know how to do that. They become closer friends throughout, and fives slowly regains bits and pieces of the Before
- meanwhile during the destruction of Kamino, the bad batch stumble on echo and rescue him and he stays with them for a little bit before leaving with Rex
- meanwhile Dogma helps the rest of the remaining Corries desert, kills too many storm troopers, and tries to go after his buir fox and the bastard inquisitor who kidnapped him
This is the main stuff you need to know for the AU haha so if you’ve got new name suggestions I’m all ears ty!!
#dmw(s)#back in black AU#dead men walking AU#my art#star wars#star wars the clone wars#the clone wars#star wars art#star wars tcw#sw tcw#tbb echo#arc trooper echo#star wars au#inquisitor fives#inquisitor#force sensitive fives#fox and fives#tcw fives#clone trooper fives#arc trooper fives#fives#star wars alternate universe#clone wars fanart#star wars clone wars#clone wars#clone wars au#commander fox#domino twins
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
I think Byleth seemingly not knowing much about the world is not them actually being totally clueless/inexperienced about the environment around them, but rather that they never had an opportunity to approach the world from an academic and political POV
Not knowing about which noble houses are in charge of what in which country, the political history of those countries, so on, that's not too weird for a commoner who mostly had to concern themselves with getting by day to day. They probably know geography better than most because they travel around a lot but why would it be their business to know the details of which lord has beef with which and which house split from which.
Even them not knowing much about the Church is like, a lot of commoners who are nominally followers of the religion probably don't know shit about the exact theology/principles/dogma etc either, especially in more rural areas. Many of them don't know how to read the scripture, they have not seen the archbishop's face, and they certainly don't have a way to extensively learn the history and political relations between the Church(es) and the three nations. Again maybe Byleth not nominally being a follower of the Church is odd, but their actual level of knowledge on the religion? Probably not too far behind the median of others in similar socioeconomic strata (=low)
And imo the important thing is that just because they never had an opportunity to learn about the above doesn't mean they're stupid or not good at it when they do get the chance, and it definitely wouldn't make them sheltered/naïve/inexperienced about reality and other aspects of life. Being on the battlefield since preteens wouldn't exactly set you up to wear rose-tinted glasses about the world.
92 notes
·
View notes
Text

Jesse: I can prove, I have a girlfriend .
Umlilo: *making man noise* I’m his girlfriend. I’m gay and he’s gay too .
Jesse: Hey! I call you to help me .
Umlilo: I help you in my way .
#star wars#the clone wars#funny post#clone troopers#oc#my oc#pov#my pov#clone x oc#captain rex#commander gregor#commander monnk#commander thorn#commander appo#commander colt#commander neyo#commander bly#commander fox#commander cody#arc trooper fives#arc trooper echo#arc trooper hardcase#arc trooper jesse#clone medic kix#clone trooper tup#clone trooper dogma#clone trooper waxer#clone trooper boil#clone wars 501st#commander wolffe
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
#videos#video#pov#point of view#republicans#christianity#heaven#hell#humour#humor#conservatives#christofascists#ausgov#politas#auspol#tasgov#taspol#australia#fuck neoliberals#neoliberal capitalism#anthony albanese#albanese government#religion#dogma#philosophy#atheism#atheist#right wing extremism#right wing terrorism#right wing bullshit
2 notes
·
View notes
Text


most recent screenshot of syl vs of winnie
#dd2#won’t tag silly stuff w the ‘dragon’s dogma 2’ tag#obsessed with her if u haven’t noticed#writing a winnie pov fic of one of their first days together <3#syl & winnie
3 notes
·
View notes
Note
I think the thing that really bugs me when people talk about "3H is so much better than Fates in terms of grey morality"... is that it only focuses on a very specific subset of greyness as a whole. When you actually take a step back from the perspective the game shows you, it's actually not morally complex in the slightest, especially compared to Fates.
For Fódlan, you're introduced to a fundamentally broken system that thrives off of eugenicist breeding, abuse, tyranny, technological stagnation, religious dogma, theocracy and experimentation that saw a young girl watch her fellow test subjects almost all die having Crests implanted into them just to create a superhuman. Said theocracy is staved by a consummate liar who's basically "Corrin, but gone wrong and a terrible human being" with an inability to let go of severe mommy issues or the ability to let go of her hatred and genocide denialism, intentionally keeping up a lie to make the most of it. Said subject leader ended up wanting to cast down the oppressive system to make one of "merit," but becomes an imperialistic, authoritarian revanchist who stages a war of total conquest to enforce that order, and in her ending, doesn't even fully dismantle the titles of nobility outright. Dimitri was genuinely a decent person before the massacre that killed most of his family and almost everyone he loved, causing him to go under severe psychosis that, when unraveled, causes him to turn into a bloodlusted maniacal tyrant who's more in line with Ashnard from FE9 than the typical "good boy lord" archetype since Marth. The least horrible of the bunch is a neoliberal schemer who sides with the strongest side (in VW it's the Church, in GW it's against the church) who can and does show a willingness to drop his interests like a hot potato when it suits him and openly intended to have Almyra invade Fódlan to establish the continent as his own suzerain state. And each of them, if not held back by the sheer divine grace of Byleth's mute ass, ends up committing tons of atrocities in the opposition to manipulate the audience into thinking they chose the "right" side. Hell, even in YOUR route it's strongly implied you're doing the things in the other routes and the story just doesn't want you to consider it because you're the good guy from your POV.
They're all awful and war criminals, and no matter what people say, that isn't moral greyness or moral complexity. Having a story where there isn't a clearly-defined sense of right and wrong, good and bad, to define morally grey conflict as a whole leads to a story where they're all horribly awful if the story isn't smart enough to recognize it doesn't fully absolve them as a person for your actions nor does it dehumanize them. People set a 0-100 scale that's never in the middle assuming a war criminal is either a goodest boy who did no wrong or a violent monster who needs to be put down and not made excuses for it, when the truth is that people are far more complicated than they seem on the wholesale. 3H doesn't do this, it wants you to think your side is always the good guys and the enemy side is sympathetic but still the bad guys. And it does this to avoid pushing forward the truth that you're genuinely no better and that the story is openly feeding you an extremely impressionistic lie of events. This is where any moral greyness falls apart, as without any kind of acknowledgement of your side's failings in a morally grey conflict, there is no hope of making a story that's actually morally grey. You created "hero defeats woobie villain" type story-writing, just slapped a coat of paint calling it morally grey when it isn't.
To give a contrast, Fates goes out of its way to avoid ignoring the actions and consequences of Corrin's choices. All of the routes have players make choices that cause a severe lapse of judgement that leads to bloodshed on both sides and innocent people on both sides dying. On Birthright, you're intentionally invoked ludonarrative dissonance by Corrin in that route being loud and aggressive of killing Garon and not questioning the "good kingdom vs. evil empire" conflict... with not only Corrin not even trying to stymie the bloodshed, but the abundance of route maps and killing waves upon waves of enemies influences that bloodshed and is meant to make players question their actions even as they kill recruitable, named soldiers on the other side. Even Ryoma, by openly lying to Corrin about not about being blood related, is more morally complex because he did so in order to keep Corrin and his family together and because it's essential data, nevermind that Ryoma is strongly implied to know Nohr is starving and just... do nothing about it, feigning ignorance with Silas's explanation in Birthright Chapter 23. Even as far as Corrin being a genuinely good person, they still kill thousands in-story and they don't really care about who lives and who dies as long as it's not their Nohrian siblings, and this leads to Xander accidentally killing Elise and then committing suicide by cop. All while Corrin teaches Ryoma to change as a better person.
Conquest is even more morally complex and grey; Corrin goes back to Nohr with the inability to betray the only family they've ever known and try to end this madness internally, before realizing the privilege they commanded as a Nohrian royal and tried to sabotage the Nohrian war effort and work in any kind of change. He succeeded in ensuring no casualties in small skirmishes, but he failed miserably trying to ensure no deaths in Cheve as it suddenly made them realize the rot is far too institutional for them to fully reform; Garon is a flesh-puppet piloted by Anankos with no regard for anything but destroying both kingdoms, his two trusted men are evil, and the Nohrian royals are deep in denial their father who was once loving and kind has become rotten and abusive and caused so much trauma they don't want to even acknowledge he's been gone for so long. It's a frightening realistic depiction of an abusive household with how the Nohrian royals self-rationalize their control over a fundamentally fucked-up situation, and Corrin begins to see that when Azura reveals Garon's true form. Knowing that the Yato as is isn't strong enough to pierce Garon's blessing from the Rainbow Sage and actually defeat them (which is strongly implied if not all-but-confirmed to operate similarly to Ashnard and BK's blessings in FE9), they need to show Garon's true form to the army... so they intentionally and knowingly abet the genocidal invasion of Hoshido, needing to sacrifice his ideals to save as many people as he can in the least horrible, fucked-up way possible. Along the way while they save a few thousands die in the invasion and Corrin ends up seriously mentally breaking up along the way as he's forced to nearly kill his two brothers and become demonized by the nation he's putting to the sword for the greater good, as he's forced to keep up the lie of a heartless invader until it just... becomes too much. And this is the route people have the most issues with, despite being the route that is so fucking complex that it gives everyone the moral sympathy needed to be empathized with, while not excusing their actions.
What Fates does exceedingly well that 3H doesn't is that it recognizes that the characters' choices are their own actions, and expects readers to pay attention to dialogue to connect fundamental revelations of the plot. It doesn't need to make its characters morally hazy-feely or war criminals with fundamentally unsympathetic traits to make them morally complex, it does this by having the fundamental concept behind Fates is two forces of good people being trapped in a fundamentally violent and horrible war that threatens to tear the continent apart in the process. And Fates does that so exceptionally well by having actual moral complexity to the characters that merits reasons to go down each of the routes while not being so non-committal to calling out injustice or bad actions in the story that it completely destroys any point it has. With Fates, I get the feeling of two families and armies of good people trapped in a war that's engineered by a broken god wanting to destroy the world and both kingdoms. With 3H, I get the feeling many people in Syria felt about each of the factions being staffed with war criminals, rapists and mass-murderers. I can sympathize with all sides of Fates because it recognizes their actions as they are while not diluting their complexity as characters. I cannot sympathize with 3H's lords because they are all so solely-defined by their end slates that no amount of blood, violence or suffering will ever be enough to end the war and them crossing lines even Ryoma would never, ever do. Ryoma, as in the guy who runs basically Fates's equivalent of the Ninja CIA with all the ugliness it implies. Even he wouldn't do what Edlegard, Rhea and Dimitri stoop to in their oppositional and player routes, and while the story humanizes Ryoma, it just expects us to love 3H's blorbos so much we just begin making jokes about how war crimes are "expected" of the series and we should still forgive them because... the story presents it better?
It's a major reason the shitting on Fates's story while lofting 3H as the better one irritates me so much; Fates had an actual writer who was committed to the greater narrative and nuances of the characters that got botched in the implementation of the JP script (which was why IF was even more panned there than Fates was here, which has regular appreciators outside of hardcore FE fans) and got fixed in the localization (despite its flaws), while 3H expects people to just believe they're the good guys without actually thinking about what their actions entails or making consequences stick. And I think it's most infuriating because the reason why people got so weird about Fates, especially Conquest, is because it was so willing to make the player feel uncomfortable with their actions and provoke intentional dissonance in their actions of being rewarded for the right inputs as a Good Gamer™ versus the very visible suffering it causes, and it not saying to the camera "And That's Terrible" and expecting it to be evident within the context and subtext of the work. For many people, it wasn't, and gave such a bad first impression regardless of the sheer cohesive validity of the work that they just wrote it off and dismissed an amazing story as too little value to actually analyze. Meanwhile, 3H's logos, ethos and pathos follow-through sucked ass, but people forgave it because of the lore boner people had and because, when you break it down, 3H is no different than the "good guy vs. evil empire" stories the fandom derides, it just does so in a way that makes those your route deems "evil" sympathetic even when they really aren't. It was so telling that when FE fans said "We want grey morality!" what they really meant was "We want to be morally, objectively correct and rewarded for being a Good Gamer™ while the enemy army has a sob story that makes them sympathetic while still morally, objectively wrong!". In hindsight, it's not hard to see why, Arvis, Lyon and BK are the series's most popular villains, but it's not good writing to apply that to a story about war criminals while thinking sob stories serve as a sufficient excuse to unconscionable atrocities, because FE fans don't want to feel responsible for their actions. They're literally the kind of people Spec Ops: The Line critiques about the typical military FPS dudebro wanting to feel like a hero for being a war criminal, only implied to an intelligence ego-driven bunch of virgin nerds who cannot agree on basic fucking canon details.
...this was a really long ask, so I'll TL;DR it with "FE fans are bad at media analysis and really should stop calling 3H better written than Fates when 3H refuses to actually analyze its own context while Fates does so extensively in giving each of the cast initiative, including for their own fuck-ups."
While I will push back a little against some of the assertions regarding Rhea and Claude (and also Dimitri somewhat) given their circumstances of being the ones on the defense in 3H, I vehemently agree with your assessment, and that's why 3H in general falls flat for me in its storytelling.
Fates, as you say, has intentional dissonance that makes you question your actions when provided with more information the further you get into the game. 3H's dissonance just reads very unintentional.
Edelgard's entire route is obvious low hanging fruit, especially the scene where she executes Dimitri, accusing him of "being obsessed with her" when she's invading his country for no fucking reason other than wanting to enforce her will on independent countries. Instead of going to therapy, she decided to kill a bunch of people, she's nuts and will never not be a shit person.
But to your point, there are other lines in 3H that read similarly ridiculous, fanning the dissonance.
Edelgard and Claude's lines to Kostas in chapter 2 about "being noble and commoner isn't different and you don't have the right to kill actually", and they both sound like immature fuckwads. Claude's consistent push to pry information out of people is insensitive at best, and borders on invasion of privacy. Claude constantly both sides-ing the church and Edelgard, and that's not even going into the shit he pulls in Hopes. Dimitri both sides-ing the dynamic of nobles getting rid of their successors for not having crests. Dimitri constantly trying to find the best in Edelgard after he begins his recovery, to the point where an unbelieveable parley scene occurs, like give me a break. Rhea is never able to confront her issues and mistakes on screen unless she's dying or being romanced by Byleth. Sylvain's "battle of ideals" line in Azure Moon, Dorothea being sad over Ferdie in AM or VW despite him being kind of a coward in that he doesn't have the stones to bite back at Edelgard, Mercedes also has a line about Ferdinand, in general just the entire spiel that side characters make about fighting old friends because "there's no choice."
Does this cast have any self awareness or agency, or not? That's why I rail against Byleth's presence in the plot so much, because he's treated as the end all be all of what is right/moral/correct. Sure, characters can feel bad about what they're doing, but because Byleth (i.e. the player) is there, they must be on the right path in the end. And everyone has to be sypmathetic when you're against them because there has to be room for Byleth (i.e. the player) to have enough reason to join them in another route, otherwise the multi route structure doesn't make sense.
In concept it's already a story structure that warps itself around what makes the player insert feel most good, but in execution it's somehow even worse. And that's because all of it is done in dialogue, many lines of which I've already mentioned. You're not supposed to think about the material reality of the shitty things these characters do and say, because the priority is that they can tug at your heart enough for you to excuse them/fix them/justify them.
Claude is ultimately not a bad person as a whole, but the game really wants you to not consider how feckless and fickle he can be when faced with bad odds, especially when he kind of effectively abandons an entire country that he's supposed to be leading whenever Byleth's not supporting him. Rhea and Dimitri are snug fit into either "crazed opposition that must be taken care of" or "person project that You need to get a handle on", both interpretations taking agency away from making the player seem like a bad person or going in the opposite direction by making the player the ONLY person who's able to save them from themselves. And Edelgard is the queen of never being held to account the damage that she does, always skirting responsibility in-game and in the fandom because "she just did what she felt she had to," "sometimes change takes sacrifice and horrible choices," or "she just wanted to WALK with you, sensei!" All in an attempt to get you to not care what you do when siding with her, and to make you feel bad for her when you don't side with her.
The player must never feel bad about the objectively bad things they do, and must always feel correct and justified in the things they feel are correct. That's the 3H M.O. When you recognize that the people you side with are kinda shitty no matter the route, it's not because the writers wanted you to, it's because you put the time in the think about it long enough. The game wanted you to feel bad about the war because "we used to be FRIENDS", not because of the terrible things you do in the war in the first place, as if the methods and machinations aren't a significant part of why warfare fucking sucks.
And as you say, and I mostly agree on, is the Fates M.O. is not shying away from the negative impacts that Corrin's choice had. In Birthright, Corrin's close Nohrian allies/siblings die because of the choice he made, because siding with Hoshido had a ripple effect on how those near and dear to him were treated by Garon. Another part of Birthright's narrative is the Hoshidan cast having to get used to Corrin just being himself, and trusting that a Nohrian isn't who they believe them to be. Exposing Ryoma's ignorance and showing that his arrogant juggernaut plans aren't gonna cut it when it comes to establishing a lasting peace, is critical in showing that, yeah, mindlessly fighting Nohr doesn't fix the root problems. It intentionally pulls the rug under the player by going "yeah your side kind of fucking sucks for charging at Nohr all this time, when these are people with dreams, loved ones and livelihoods."
Conquest puts a twist on this, by having Corrin be relatively successful in some areas when it comes to changing perceptions towards Nohr, helping people gain autonomy from a brutal regime, and actively undermining the horrible things that war has its soldiers do. The rug pull is then done during chapter 13, and again after the Sakura map, where Corrin is smacked with the reality that sometimes you fucking fail at what you're trying to do in story, despite the player succeeding in gameplay. The player representative doesn't have complete control nor is he treated with kid gloves in Fates when faced with the ugliness from his side and the opposition.
And what's greatest about it, is that it's showing you, rather than employing a missable dialogue in a monastery about how sad it is to fight against former classmates. Dude, I know it's sad, is that really all you can say? The message begins to dull when it's bashed over your head too much, and especially when there's no meaningful impact in story, all because there can't be because Byleth (the player) has to be accounted for as the ultimate arbiter of who joins him or not. You can't avoid feeling shitty about Scarlet, like you can with Ferdie. You can try your best trying to get around the retainers in Fates when you fight them, but they still have crushing death lines because the story is written to accommodate the fact that you're killing people who aren't evil at their core. 3H has to make sure you can avoid that before a war even starts. Flora and Ryoma's suicides, Xander's suicide-by-cop, Takumi's descent, the fates of the Kitsune and Wolfskin who were caught in bad circumstances (something that, despite claims of poor writing, happens all the fucking time and is another shitty thing about war that more need to recognize); the topics of isolationism, war profiteering, subterfuge and treason, spy networks and thievery, the ethics of bystanderism, FUCKING CIVILIAN CASUALTIES.
That last one-alongside the general idea of trying to win a war with as little bloodshed as possible-is one of the prime driving forces of an ENTIRE ROUTE in Fates, and is still pretty prevalent for Corrin's beliefs in the other two. In 3H? Barely a footnote in all honesty, and more so an extension of how other characters are perceived. Edelgard forcing civilians to stay when Enbarr is under siege? Claude says "it takes some resolve, I gotta hand it to her." Remire being destroyed and the Empire doing fuck all? Uhhh, look over there, they got taken in by Rhea, don't worry about it. What about the effects of the Alliance being dismantled and given to the Empire, Kingdom or the church? Or showing more of the people in the monastery town that face the most danger from the Imperial invasion or the thieves after the timeskip? None of this is treated as the horrific circumstance it is, so it ends up as fridge horror you think about at 2 a.m.
Thinking about how the war affects the common people and civilians isn't the main priority in any of 3H's routes as far as I can remember, since it's just lumped in with the vague "too much bloodshed, doesn't war suck" aesop. We never dive into the specifics of why war sucks in 3H because doing that has the potential for the player to materially feel bad about what they're doing, so instead we always have a cushion to assuage our feelings in by being reminded that Byleth (the player) is the pinnacle of good and always knows the right thing to do in the end. Which is shallow, vapid, and utterly spineless in a simulation game series about war.
A lot of this is fueled by my anti-3H though, so I'm very willing to take corrections on things I flat out get wrong, I haven't played that game to completion in like a over a year, so the details are finally getting hazy.
#long post#fire emblem discourse#rant#character hate#fire emblem fates#also when i think about it i can't recall specific bad shit being discussed in 3H's support conversations either that AREN'T backstory#or general/vague “war is bad”#meanwhile the Jakob and Oboro support in Fates start with Oboro hating Jakob for volunteering for cleanup/mop up operations#which is some fucking HEAVY shit that hardly any other FE game (to my knowledge) acknowledges#other supports in Fates talk about PTSD; assassinations; military ethics; abuse of the lower class; xenophobia; etc.#the only times 3H gets similarly deep (and fittingly the best written) is when it discusses death and dying for one's cause or friends#which is like 75% of Dimitri's supports#he's best character for a reason in that game
37 notes
·
View notes
Text

pov: it’s so joever
#pov me entering the fallen city post-daimon for the first time#that was traumatic honestly#dragon's dogma#yo I saw on Reddit someone who’s at TGS posted a photo of a fuckin big ass actual minotaur type enemy#crazy#I want eliminators back still tho I love them and their cow hats
11 notes
·
View notes