#and i have less links to deal with
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
revehae · 2 days ago
Text
wondering if i should post the fics as a series like i intended or just post them as i finish them, bc it would have been a series but there’s not really a theme connecting them. other than the fact that like 3/5 of the bg fics are stepcest
2 notes · View notes
nenoname · 5 months ago
Text
stan twins the canon cptsd brothers i will always think about all your unaddressed issues that would make perfect plot fuel for your spinoff
and also the whole 'stan getting that poem by bill via a website which contrasts with bill getting one from the axolotl via a website' foreshadowing thing
like idk i would love something like su future but like more optimistic, aka not an accumulated breakdown that has to be mostly resolved off screen at the end :/// but something thats being kinda addressed throughout? (although would love to see one of them turn into a monster thats always fun lol)
stan having severe issues from his dad and those years of being homeless that we keep on getting more info on but never really getting confronted on (the drifter catalogue and tijuana incident...), him being completely alone for like twenty years when running the shack before soos comes along to the point that 1998 is noted as his low point, and him not really learning about bill+what he did to ford until ages after he killed him if he ever did get the full context
while i think amnesia and everyone seeing him as a hero actually helped with stan's 'i'm a worse version of my brother' thing its still a lingering issue too and we now got him being insecure over his own hands
ford being immediately thrown from 'being tortured by bill' to 'being stuck in the multiverse and being chased by bounty hunters constantly', him fully expecting himself to die when destroying bill, and him only now being safe for the first time in 30 years ....relatively safe, he's still in constant danger because of course he is
idk in the end the series wants them to be happy and they deserve it, its why i wasn't too worried about the book being like 'ooh bill is back!! and the book is haunting ford' thing cos i knew they'll be ok
#stan pines#ford pines#stanley pines#stanford pines#gravity falls#stan twins#as for the 'still on your mind' thing to me its stan literally thinking about bill despite ford resolving to move past it#or alternatively me on my same coin theory obsession lmao#me yelling and screaming at ouroboros being used to link to the axolotl and bill and how ford didn't actually keep it#which brings up even more questions about it reappearing in the shack when stan takes over#of course even if him realising about reincarnation being a thing i think its still way less to deal with than his actual issues#something something a same soul doesnt mean much when he already proved himself a better person a million times over#idk my thoughts on reincarnation as a concept is like eh??? anyway#also completely unrelated but stan writing fanfic means he knows what soos meant when he was talking about stan fics#soos seems like a gen fic writer especially with the ones we got as those promos#the train one where he comes up with a giant backstory for the setting that has nothing to do with the fic bros is super funny#but meanwhile we have stan the canonical smut writer who had to be writing it that summer#would he be a self insert shipper? would he projecting on the duchess instead? is he both???#i have many questions#then again judging from hows theres a wedding scene that he got super emotional over he might just be a shipper????#this has nothing to do with my original post#...or does it cos the axolotl last appears reacting to stan freaking out about count li--#anyway if you think this post is longer than my usual its cos i physically made myself delete most tags and put it in the actual post
184 notes · View notes
greatgoddyke · 27 days ago
Text
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
time to make your choice only you can be the one
#undescribed#bonk.png#ggg#great god grove#great god grove spoilers#ggg spoilers#<- bc of king n hand gesturing stuff for the au this one gets the spoiler tag#caption is a line from legend of everfree from eg movie of the same name bc its now linked to ggg for me bc of brainrot#first au stuff i dont like have anything really planned out n also dont really plan on doing anything with this beyond doodles#settled on inspekta being a horse bc i want him capochin patty n king to all be earth ponies bc of like permanent having it ingrained from#being an mlp fan as a kid that earth ponies are seen as less special bc they cant use magic or fly n that fits for story similarities#bc inspekta n capochin hating on patty for projection reasons AND inspekta's replacement anxiety n envy of king who in the au#is the only other earth pony lined up to become an alicorn (bc again being specifically an fim fan since i was a kid ingrained in with fanon#that ponies that become alicorns are almost exclusively pegasus or unicorn bc of earth ponies not having as clear of a connection to magic)#in my mind patty is the main character like the bizzyboys are also main characters but its like how the mane six are the main six but#twilight is the MAIN main character its like that n then godpoke is her sidekick (like spike ig but like mysterious stranger style <- idk#what i mean by this) she gets to be the protag bc the type of character godpoke is in the game n how im fitting them to be in the au doesnt#really work for a protag role while patty can be more readily slotted into mlp protag shes the only bizzyboy who cares about solving in the#game (as shown in hobbyhoo) n i like her so she gets to be the protag v-v inspekta is still doing the whole like shit from the game just in#a different way bc of mlp related restrictions n tone differences. the episode where luna goes to nightmare night after being freshly reform#ed walked so milldread section could run however cobigail's deal does run closer to that episode that to the game counterpart but like witho#ut cob having been banished for a thousand years theres no rift in the au bc its. mlp so sort of vague direction is related to the tree of#harmony n like maybe thats how inspekta powers up for the two parter transformation. a thought i had for a workaround for how inspekta keeps#king isolated was maybe turning king to stone n hiding her in plain sight but while that would slide in mlp (they turn a child to stone in t#he series finale apparently??) it leaves a bad taste in my mouth from the ggg angle so probably gonna do something else#art comments both inspekta n cobigail's pony names are taken from ponies i already had inspekta's comes from a different mlpied thing#n cobigail's comes from a fankid (spelled like kandi corn tho bc fankid's a rave girlie) the rest of the gods get to keep their names aside#from maybe bauhauzzo (whos role is undecided) huzzle n click clack arent ponies bc i felt it suited them more huzzle gets to be discordesc#bc i think its fun if like this versions god of chaos wasnt evil BUT that angle is used as slander against huzzle by inspekta#n click clack's a breezy bc small n bratty (we will be ignoring that breezies are mortal if i remember right bc thats not relevant)
82 notes · View notes
askthehylianchampion · 2 months ago
Note
hero!! hero!! what is your relationship with the princess!! weve heard rumors that you two are romantically involved, would you care to confirm this for us?? *frantically writing in a notepad*
Tumblr media
No! No! We are not involved like that!! It would be completely inappropriate due to my position and hers! She is completely above my station! I would not have much to offer to her!
Besides she is nearly three years younger than me and still a child. She reminds me more of my sister and I see our relationship more akin to that than anything else.
18 notes · View notes
ncat · 28 days ago
Text
This next homebrew is on the edges of being upload-to-here ready but I've reached the point of "I have to outdo myself" that I've made a document big enough I genuinely do not know how I'll even upload it to tumblr.
4 notes · View notes
phoenixcatch7 · 2 years ago
Text
Man I am just SO CONFUSED. About the time line of this game.
No one is telling me how long links been gone! Or how long the botw-totk timeskip was! They all just started selling my stuff again lol. I'm going to have to get everything redyed!
Me: hey random stranger! Lore dump? You look like a lore dumper.
Kindly npc: why hullo there, link ^^! My, I haven't seen you in a while since the calamity ended! I was so worried when they said you and the princess had gone missing! But it's good to see you're well.
Me: aw, thanks. How long has it actually been tho.
Kindly npc: ^u^
#Having a great time btw I've just been chased across a near sea of miasma by stal riders and more! 10/10 nearly died in a high speed chase#Made it out relatively unscathed which is truly amazing lmao#Spoilers ahead: I have had the funniest time doing the great plateau quest chain. Once I sucked it up and made nice with the creepy statue.#He's(?) been alright. Fair trader. Good deals. I've mostly been terrorising kohga in between absolutely failing to craft working vehicles X#His new boss fights are so much easier than the first one lol. Less fun I'll admit but the music is groovy. You can probably make a#Machine and try and dog fight him but with few exceptions the turning circles are decrepit so I just stuck to mild dodging and shooting him#And running over to hit him some more. Kinda bland for a boss fight I'll say. Could have done with a lot more pizazz. It's kohga come on.#Anyway I do feel kinda bad because apparently he's been stuck down there for however many months/years and I AM kinda cheating with the arm#After the first fight he fled to the gerudo mine and the steward very nicely showed me how to get there but never underestimate#My procrastination because I'd already found it by just exploring so I just teleported. In game it must have been terrifying lmao#Racing across an endless void filled only by the light of your rapidly running out of battery glider and the red glow of the gloom away fro#The apparently immortal ancient warrior who beat you up and tossed you down there and there's no sign of perusal so you're probably safe#But you get there and he's already sitting there poking some bananas having wiped out your goons and plundered your supplies.#Like sorry man but the arm comes with the hero territory I can't exactly take it off.#Maybe if you stopped terrorising the people purah would let you have one of her long distance teleportation slates. It comes with photos?#It can't have been long since botw link hasn't grown an inch XD. Also I've been turning the lore timeline over in my head and still no idea#Are we not sure Rauru isn't from some alternate timeline that got fused with the main loz timeline by accident??#loz#legend of zelda#totk#loz totk#tears of the kingdom#loz tears of the kingdom#totk spoilers
59 notes · View notes
arolesbianism · 4 months ago
Text
Tumblr media
Doodle I did of my girl Juliet earlier
#keese draws#lobotomy corporation#oc art#not super happy with this but I do enjoy looking at her so I can lower my standards for her#at least I feel like I have a better idea of her general shapes now#I spent hours and hours today on the lob corp grind and I think Im Finally ready to actually move forward with they story#Ive also been thinking abt my nuggets during their lor eras and thats been fun#in particular its been fun to think abt my ogs because half of them are experiencing their crash from finally being free from lob corp hell#and the other half are like frolicking in fields and making friendship bracelets and have made peace with their past and upcoming futures#and that half is the half that are all just godawful people who do not deserve that peace and happiness while the people they actively#traumatized are just left to deal with it#this is mostly abt juliet and loki they both suck I love them sm <3#juliet is the one thats caused more active harm tho since shes that type of boss that will obsess over those she thinks have ~potential~#and once youve caught her attention you are guaranteed to have a horrible time as she will get what she wants out of you no matter what#she doesn't even work on abnormalities anymore just just breaths down ppls necks and fights when need be#loki is very similar in that regard he puts a lot of pressure on his team to provide the results he wants#hes less likely to like. directly psychologically torture those who are under him. but he still isnt a good boss.#hes also more openly rude and disrespectful towards those around him because while neither respect anyone but eachother#loki much more frequently openly states that fact to ppls faces because he feels like everyone around him is wasting his time#now loki actually does legitimately like a few other ppl he works with which is smth that cant rly be said for juliet#but hes also the one whos always on team 'lets murder the newbies for science' so y'know#ding is like his least favorite person here and its like 30% because he specifically accepted her into the info department because he#planned on getting her killed to finish off some research on a tool abno that was being worked on#but she survived the process so now she just like actually works here and he despises her despite the fact that shes rly good at her job#juliet doesn't usually send ger guys to die on purpose but if they do die she doesn't care#she simply feels that if they die early they were weak links anyways#she will still be 'nice' to newbies and to all of her coworkers for that matter but she still has quite the bad reputation regardless#some newbies do fall for her polite act but anyone whos been here for more than like a few days knows that she doesn't give a shit abt them#theyre both doing fine in lor theyre just like we may have lost everything but at least we have eachother :) (mason wants to strangle them)
2 notes · View notes
waywardsalt · 8 months ago
Text
linebeck is probably so god damn paranoid all of the time
#like not even just. oh he's probably an anxious guy. hes def at least jumpy and his way of living puts him at risk of monster attacks#hes got some other person on the sea just straight up gunning to kill him whenever she sees him#he probably spends a lot of time agonizing abt how he should act in front of people on islands and putting his stories in order#linebeck#phantom hourglass#he has a crate in his ship near the wheel that he uses to hide in he likely struggles with fighting hes completely alone#he clearly does all of his ship maintenance alone and knows how to do it- but he does all of it alone#you know he's got some serious anxiety problems at the least. no fucking wonder he looks so rough#i imagine he prefers people who help him feel at ease like people he could rely on to protect him and keep an eye out#having link around lets him relax for sure though i dont imagine his paranoia gets too much better#in post ph having something of a crew around is a big help to like. help him relax and deal with all of those other mental illnesses#i imagine linebeck is generally kind of nervous and needs a friend. like those cheetahs with support dogs#in the bellum x linebeck fic linebeck's paranoia and issues around being alone and at risk are p important?#linebeck finding out that bellum is following and protecting him gives him a fuckton of peace of mind#linebeck seems like hed really benefit from hanging out w/ someone who makes him feel comfortable enough to be vulnerable#hes likely introverted but god he needs a friend to keep him from being on edge all of the time#salty talks#hes probably a lil better on islands? or at least islands with people on them. at least then his ship is in less danger#i was just thinkin abt this recently. like the idea of a short fic abt him just being fucking paranoid pre-canon#like a scene of him mopping the deck and. thinking. and spiraling really easily and becoming paranoia very quickly#he has issues <3
4 notes · View notes
mamba052 · 7 months ago
Text
Tumblr media
Current progress on a beholding painting I'm making, because I graduated from highschool 3 days ago and have two weeks vacation before I begin work, which means the adult thing to do is stay up late and make a painting dedicated to a fear god.
5 notes · View notes
lucky-clover-gazette · 2 years ago
Text
i love breath of the wild but ngl its zelda's voice is so ridiculously annoying to me... girl stop telling me quest shit via telepathy i'm trying to find my 754th korok seed
23 notes · View notes
starpros-sunshine · 1 year ago
Text
I can now do piracy on the TV and actually properly enjoy the films :3
5 notes · View notes
frozenambiguity · 2 years ago
Text
Tumblr media
Very long Initial thoughts and first impressions on the Caribert Archon Quest in the tags. Spoiler alert!!
#{{ this is me making a very long tag so that the people who are not interested in reading the spoilers can skip the post safely!! ~~~~~~~ }}#{{ All right!! So the first thing I find fishy in this interaction is the fact that Kaeya just… }}#{{ reveals that he is from Khaenri’ah to the traveler like it’s no big deal }}#{{ Uhm. Huh. I thought that was a secret he was deeply invested in keeping; so things are not exactly adding up here }}#{{ because remember how that was; you know; a thing..? Remember that letter Kaeya saved from the fire }}#{{ that confirmed he was from Khaenri’ah and belonged to the Alberich family? }]#{{ without his father's knowledge and permission; because that information was too highly confidential to NOT remain a secret... }}#{{ and one that he still hides to this day? You know. You remember; right; hyv? come now; it was only a few patches ago. }}#{{ the fact that he revealed it like it was no big deal makes me??? question a lot of the decisions that were made here. }}#{{ Keeping his heritage a secret has been a character motivation for Kaeya. I’m bothered about this decision on hyv’s part; actually }}#{{ not to say that the reveal was never to be done; but it could have been handled properly. }}#{{ and not so casually over some mid afternoon drink time as if it holds no importance whatsoever }}#{{ also this interaction??? A total act. I refuse to believe otherwise }}#{{ 'caring less and less about khaenri'ah?' sir; the guilt and sense of duty/responsibility that consummes you daily says otherwise }}#{{ 'My father left me in Mondstadt simply because he wanted me to have a better life?' huh. perhaps one reason; but not the only one }}#{{ nor THE reason. we have had multiple proof; so this is kaeya lying through his teeth for the sake of alleviating the conversation }}#{{ 'My surname is the only link I have with Khaenri'ah'? Read points mentioned above. Deceit deceit deceit. }}#{{ this entire interaction was a calculated; studied act; and I'm calling it as it is. if hyv intended otherwise --- too bad. }}#{{ because I'm making it my canon. }}#{{ and I truly hope that in hyv canon kaeya is being the 'you can only trust half of what he says' Kaeya; because if hyv is making Kaeya }}#{{ honest in this precise moment.... like if those words are his genuine thoughts from hyv's perspective; then; Kaeya; I'm so sorry }}#{{ but i want to have faith in hoyo; and I want to believe that they haven't forgotten Kaeya as a chara and his motivations }}#{{ and the fact that he was intended to be a khaenri'ah spy in mondstadt. something which generated a lot of conflict in his life. }}#{{ so don't @ me w/ 'oh yeah; I don't have any link or interest in khaenri'ah whatsoever haha khaenri'ah what is that?? never heard of it }#{{ anyway. Interesting to see it confirmed that Kaeya and Dain do not know each other formally; but that Dain has been spying on Kaeya }}#{{ and does not trust him. interesting dynamic. obviously kaeya didn't like having been studied and observed }}#{{ Kaeya being the Abyss Order Founder's descendant? Honestly; not surprising!! I had my suspicions. }}#{{ the clues were always there. 'heart of the abyss'. A heart is a vital part for any organism and by extent institution to function }}#{{ and so; too; is Kaeya a vital part of the abyss scheme; regardless of whether he wants to or not }}#{{ and there were other signs of it too. He has been seen communicating with them multiple times. recall diluc's introduction. }}
16 notes · View notes
bluevveather · 1 year ago
Text
Autistic spaces are getting so much more hostile towards people with low empathy, and it sucks
There was a subreddit I really liked, people were chill, and then there was a sudden influx of people making posts like ‘Autistic people have empathy! Saying we don’t makes us seem like monsters! Thats not a symptom!’ And people making posts explaining that no, actually, some of us do have low empathy got attacked and told they were wrong or ableist? And it sucks, because its just so hard to find a place to exist where you can be seen as not evil? I don’t know, it just hurts a lot to be told that
65K notes · View notes
great-and-small · 7 months ago
Text
When I was in vet school I went to this one lecture that I will never forget. Various clubs would have different guest lecturers come in to talk about relevant topics and since I was in the Wildlife Disease Association club I naturally attended all the wildlife and conservation discussions. Well on this particular occasion, the speakers started off telling us they had been working on a project involving the conservation of lemurs in Madagascar. Lemurs exist only in Madagascar, and they are in real trouble; they’re considered the most endangered group of mammals on Earth. This team of veterinarians was initially assembled to address threats to lemur health and work on conservation solutions to try and save as many lemur species from extinction as possible. As they explored the most present dangers to lemurs they found that although habitat loss was the primary problem for these vulnerable animals, predation by humans was a significant cause of losses as well. The vets realized it was crucial for the hunting of lemurs by native people to stop, but of course this is not so simple a problem.
The local Malagasy people are dealing with extreme poverty and food insecurity, with nearly half of children under five years old suffering from chronic malnutrition. The local people have always subsisted on hunting wildlife for food, and as Madagascar’s wildlife population declines, the people who rely on so-called bushmeat to survive are struggling more and more. People are literally starving.
Our conservation team thought about this a lot. They had initially intended to focus efforts on education but came to understand that this is not an issue arising from a lack of knowledge. For these people it is a question of survival. It doesn’t matter how many times a foreigner tells you not to eat an animal you’ve hunted your entire life, if your child is starving you are going to do everything in your power to keep your family alive.
So the vets changed course. Rather than focus efforts on simply teaching people about lemurs, they decided to try and use veterinary medicine to reduce the underlying issue of food insecurity. They supposed that if a reliable protein source could be introduced for the people who needed it, the dependence on meat from wildlife would greatly decrease. So they got to work establishing new flocks of chickens in the most at-risk communities, and also initiated an aggressive vaccination program for Newcastle disease (an infectious illness of poultry that is of particular concern in this area). They worked with over 600 households to ensure appropriate husbandry and vaccination for every flock, and soon found these communities were being transformed by the introduction of a steady protein source. Families with a healthy flock of chickens were far less likely to hunt wild animals like lemurs, and fewer kids went hungry. Thats what we call a win-win situation.
This chicken vaccine program became just one small part of an amazing conservation outreach initiative in Madagascar that puts local people at the center of everything they do. Helping these vulnerable communities of people helps similarly vulnerable wildlife, always. If we go into a country guns-blazing with that fire for conservation in our hearts and a plan to save native animals, we simply cannot ignore the humans who live around them. Doing so is counterintuitive to creating an effective plan because whether we recognize it or not, humans and animals are inextricably linked in many ways. A true conservation success story is one that doesn’t leave needy humans in its wake, and that is why I think this particular story has stuck with me for so long.
(Source 1)
(Source 2- cool video exploring this initiative from some folks involved)
(Source 3)
33K notes · View notes
sarcosmiiic · 2 months ago
Text
Tumblr media Tumblr media
PLEASE KEEP THIS IN MIND:
we, as fans, do not have a right to private information. anything shared with us on this is a privilege. please do not abuse it. the cc's could shut down and never talk about it if we overwhelm them.
also, please keep in mind that ONE HERMIT and THE ENTIRETY OF HERMITCRAFT are NOT THE SAME THING. the entire fandom is not 'ruined' or 'completely unsafe' because of the actions of one person.
PLEASE DO NOT ASSUME THAT THE OTHER HERMITS KNEW ANYTHING ABOUT WHATEVER'S GOING ON WITH ISKALL. this is not some big conspiracy, it's the consequences of one person's actions. they weren't hiding this from us, that's not how hermitcraft works, they truly didn't know. they probably knew as much as us about this, so making it an 'us against them' situation is immature and shortsighted.
ALSO, I AM BEGGING EVERYONE TO PLEASE NOT SENSATIONALIZE THIS. PLEASE DO NOT TURN HATING ISKALL INTO A MEME OR A JOKE.
mcyt'ers being revealed to be less-than-great people is not a rare thing, sadly, but i've seen it turned into a joke/meme/trend in other fandoms. this both minimalizes the actual people's/victims' struggles, makes the entire situation feel less serious than it is, especially to outsiders looking in, and makes everyone in the fandom look immature, petty, unable to take anything seriously, and genuinely harmful.
this server, fandom, and community are not dying, it is not ruined forever, this is one (major, i'm not trying to minimalize it) issue that we're currently dealing with. it will be okay. we will move on. this is not the beginning of the end. please calm down. i love this fandom, god bless all of you. <3
edit: doc has said on stream that we will likely get more information as time passes. like i said, this is a PRIVILEGE. we are not OWED information. please be grateful for what we're given, and POLITELY ask questions if you must. if a cc doesn't give you the answer you want, or doesn't answer at all, LEAVE THEM ALONE. THIS IS NOT AN EXCUSE TO HARASS PEOPLE. the hermits are likely just as stressed out as us, if not probably more so, so please keep that in mind when contacting them.
don't freak out, we'll be okay, this is not the end of the world, nor is it the end of Hermitcraft. we will be okay.
second edit: please remember that (at least as far as we know) ISKALL AND STRESS WERE NOT KICKED OR BANNED. THEY LEFT OF THEIR OWN VOLITION.
ALSO!!! VERY IMPORTANT!!!
WE. DO. NOT. KNOW. EXACTLY. WHAT. HAPPENED.
PLEASE DO NOT ASSUME ANYTHING SIMPLY BASED OFF OF OTHER MCYT'ERS PAST ACTIONS/SCANDALS. WE DO NOT KNOW EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED. WE MIGHT NOT EVER KNOW EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED. WE NEED TO BE OKAY WITH THAT AND NOT DRAW OUR OWN CONCLUSIONS.
TWITTER LINKS TO VICTIM RESPONSES:
https://twitter.com/Kasszi_/status/1860670647946604985
https://twitter.com/emoslab_/status/1860697161245323559
4K notes · View notes
harfblarf · 1 year ago
Text
Also, countries with universal healthcare that aren't the UK and Canada exist...?? You can't "prove" universal healthcare is an inherently bad idea with a sample size of... two. And you especially can't do so without examining the underlying reasons for the issues in those samples??
Anyway I got VERY passionate about this topic, including talking about the common problems in universal healthcare in other countries, similar existing issues in the United States' private healthcare, the relative costs of private vs public healthcare, and how dismissing the issues of other countries' universal healthcare is actually harmful to the campaign for universal healthcare in the US, so I'm putting my long post under a Read More. With headers for each section!
I'll repeat here what I say later in the post, too: it's not an issue of "why should I pay for some random's medical treatment?", it's "why should I pay my government to take care of its citizens?" The provision of services is one of two reasons a population will cooperate with its government. (The other is the threat of violence.) If you are okay with the government spending billions and billions of dollars on a military force and speculative military technology and making weapons that could kill literally all human beings on the planet, all in the name of protecting the land and physical well-being of its citizens from hypothetical future threats, the idea of the government spending money to protect its citizens from very immediate and present threats to their physical well-being via medical care should not be so appalling.
> Universal Healthcare in Other Countries <
Now, I only did a little preliminary searching, but the common trends I saw in searching "[country] healthcare issues" for other nations with universal healthcare were typically: poor integration of technology at the current time, costs, and low numbers of medical staff due to harsh and unappealing labor conditions.
> Healthcare in the Current United States <
The first and last points are already major issues in the United States. Technology integration is a huge undertaking; locating, organizing, and digitizing decades of physical patient records while balancing patient privacy and the inherent need to use third-party (usually produced by for-profit private companies) software to do so, all while also retaining access to both physical and digital records so the medical centers can continue to function, is grueling and expensive.
Private healthcare does not fix any of this.
Huge portions of the medical field in the US are also wildly inhumane to their workers, especially emergency workers. Burnout and physical consequences are common. This is also not something private healthcare fixes. Actually, it complicates treatment and patient intake, as information like which private insurance they have and if they have it at all bloats overhead and results in payments going to collections or going unpaid entirely. Really the only medical positions that are remotely cushy are highly educated specialists, who still deal with high patient load because the number of USAmericans who can afford to pay through the nose for several degrees-- since our educational system is private at the university level-- is exceedingly small. Since medical students are notoriously badly treated and subjected to grueling and miserable courseloads, it is also not very appealing, further shrinking the pool of prospective doctors.
Private healthcare not only does not fix any of this, it is also exacerbated by private higher education.
> Healthcare in the United States: Private VS. Public <
Carrying on: Cost IS an issue relating directly to the public versus private healthcare decision... but the cost exists either way, it is purely a question of who is paying it. I could simply argue that public healthcare is a cost the US is more than equipped to pay, given its exorbitant and often pointless military spending, but let's actually set that aside. I am instead going to argue that private healthcare is already creating costs for the US government, and it's a way shittier deal than public healthcare.
If healthcare is private, cost is concentrated on those most in need of help, which in the economic system of America inevitably results in loss of life, as well as more indirect consequences, like people becoming disabled due to inadequate care and thus being forced out of the workforce, and so on. These consequences directly impact the economy: reduced workers (including experienced and skilled workers), reduced monetary flow, and unnecessarily increasing the expense of public welfare services. People die and require funerary services; the sick continue about their daily lives and jobs out of necessity due to the lack of resources and treatment, leading to increased spread of viral and bacterial diseases (we saw with COVID how much a sick population stresses normal function and increases cost of living); people die alone and without treatment in their homes, leading to mandatory police investigations and often crime scene cleanup crews to handle biohazardous materials from decomposing bodies; people are rendered unhoused-- by developed disability, medical costs, or even simply inadequate medical worker's compensation during their illness or injury--and increase the costs of public services like shelters and food banks, while the government typically responds to unhoused populations with acts of institutional violence that cost substantial amounts of money (development of hostile architecture is frequently paid for with grants; installation of such hostile architecture in cities is often government-funded and more expensive than non-hostile designs; police action to evict and dismantle encampments of the unhoused tends to be expensive and cruel, paying for specialized equipment as well as armaments like tear gas and the budget for the police department itself).
If healthcare is public and free, cost is distributed, and the most vulnerable populations have better (if still not perfect) odds of receiving adequate care, saving lives and bodies. Loss of life and ability is decreased. Fewer people have to reinjure themselves or exacerbate their illnesses for fear of the cost and inaccessibility of treatment. "Why should I pay for some random person's healthcare?", I hear the conservative in you cry out, indignant over anything that feels like an imposition on your rights. Well, let me reframe that. What you are actually asking is "Why should I pay my government to take care of its citizens?", which I would argue is rather the point of the government, at least ideally. Laws and their enforcement, the military, infrastructure like roads and the USPS-- they're all services the government performs for its citizens in order to justify its existence. We need and thus accept the government and its authority because, at least in theory, these are valuable services that keep its citizens, us, safe and comfortable. (The relative success of these services and the theories behind them are more debatable.) If you believe that it is better to live in a place-- city, state, nation, planet, any scale at all-- where people with authority over you leave people to rot rather than provide for their needs, just because that's simpler or cheaper, I have no idea how to talk to you. I cannot find an angle to convince someone who prefers a world of greater suffering and arbitrary subjugation that maybe that isn't a great idea.
Additionally, on a more concretely pragmatic note, costs are hiked by privatization and restriction. If companies that produced, say, medical equipment like MRI machines, medication like insulin, and supportive medical equipment like auto-injectors/blood pressure cuffs/wheelchairs were disallowed from being for-profit and forbidden exclusive rights over life-saving technology (via their patents), costs for these things would drop.
But fine, maybe you value the right to intellectual property and profit over the preservation of human life. Your hyperindividualism is concerning, but even neglecting the private companies squeezing profit out of the sick with the actual equipment and medicine: Private insurance also earns a profit. They charge more than they pay out to the insured. That's their entire business model, and they have done their best to reduce the inherent high-risk high-reward nature of it by hiking insurance costs and minimizing the payouts, as well as complicating the system to make it necessary for a patient to put in excruciating hours (days and weeks, with wait times and phone tag, and occasionally months when it escalates to legal proceedings) of work to get the coverage they are actually owed. While sick and hurt. Cruelty of that aside, the overall cost of insurance is incomparable to the cost of the actual medical treatments. Government-funded universal healthcare is simpler (reducing overhead), does a better job of guaranteeing actual payment to the doctors and hospitals, is less expensive per individual because it doesn't have to turn a profit, and can lighten the overall cost of medical treatment in its area because adequate medical access early and consistently reduces the incidence of more severe medical problems with higher costs.
> Why Dismissing the Issues of the NHS and Other Negative Examples of Universal Healthcare is Not Helpful <
I'll be using the issues of the NHS specifically as an example, but these points are mostly broadly applicable. This is also the section largely directed at people who already support universal healthcare.
The problems with dismissing the flaws of the NHS and arguing that they're preferable to the current status are manifold, but firstly: it's uncompelling. You approach someone who has only seen twenty headlines complaining about the shit wait times of the NHS, and you go "but it's not a big deal actually". This is not convincing. The wait times sound horrible, they think. THEY don't have to wait that long to see the doctor. THEY would rather pay more so they can see their doctor sooner. And sure, it's only "non-urgent" stuff that has to wait-- which isn't even entirely true, but I'll get to that later-- but that can still be painful, and unpleasant. You say to them, "even a lot of discomfort and waiting is better than the current system", but they shake their heads, because for them it isn't. For them, even if medical stuff can be annoyingly expensive or maybe even stressful, at least they know they can make their appointments and go when they want treatment. Even if you elaborate, try to explain, "our system is killing the poor, our system is cruel, many people cannot afford any treatment at all", to someone who is not in that position, this is intangible, and the blame easily foisted onto the victim. "They should have planned better. They should have gotten a better job. They should have put more effort into their education. How did they even get sick? How did they even get hurt? Maybe it was their own carelessness. Why is their carelessness my problem?" You tell someone to accept something that sucks for the greater good, most of the time they're gonna wrinkle their nose and go "whose greater good? I don't wanna." Not even out of lack of compassion, necessarily. People just can't magically project their perspective into something they've never experienced, and instinctively want to protect themselves.
Secondly, the problems of the NHS are very real, and also result in deaths and horrific suffering. Dismissing the issues as "a bit of a wait" sets us up to repeat those mistakes. The extended wait times of the NHS are YEARS, and urgency is decided at the whim of the first person you talk to about your problem. Crippling chronic issues can be left untreated for years because your doctor didn't think it sounded like a big deal; a problem determined "minor" without full assessment could be the early symptom of something fatal; biases in the attending staff get your problem labeled as minor and non-urgent, or even nonexistent, because you are a woman, or a person of color, or trans; because the doctor isn't familiar with your condition, they miss it, and you are left floating in a waitlist with no visible end date; genuinely minor problems escalate because you are left untreated for years; your doctor is given utter control over your treatment and referrals to specialists, subject to their entirely human whims, their easily flawed judgement. Scores of trans people die in the UK each year on waiting lists or while fighting to get past bigoted local doctors who refuse to provide adequate care, many to suicide from the sheer hopelessness of ever getting the treatment necessary to live in any sort of comfort or stability. Abigail Thorn has a detailed and of course fantastically presented video on her experience trying to receive gender affirming care through the NHS. This issue is not exclusive to trans people. It would still matter even if it was, but it isn't. The comments are full of people talking about how their disorders, disabilities, illnesses, and injuries have been failed by the NHS. Ignoring those people and their experiences only communicates that you either really HAVEN'T done the necessary research to promote functional universal health care, or that you don't care about the consequences of those failings.
Thirdly, accepting the premise that universal healthcare means accepting the flaws of the NHS is shooting yourself in the foot for no reason. You weaken your position in the debate, smear the reputation of universal healthcare, and work within a negative framework, when you do not have to. Understanding the problems of the NHS and other countries should not result in surrendering to the inevitability of suffering. Instead, it should result in saying "and we can do better than that". The issues of the NHS are not absolutely inherent to the basic premise "the government funds healthcare so individuals within that country do not have to front the costs themselves". It's a byproduct of the implementation that government chose and the specific circumstances of the United Kingdom's infrastructure, politics, and culture. Bare minimum, the response to bringing up the NHS should be "and you think we can't do any better than the fucking British?", and ideally you should be able to accurately identify some of the issues in the UK's implementation of universal healthcare and point to potential solutions the US could implement, discuss the differences between the US and UK which will change how a universal health care system performs, or cite someone who has done so.
If you're going to advocate for something, don't undermine it in the same breath.
Tumblr media
61K notes · View notes