#I'm theorizing basically
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I genuinely can't believe that the rannett windblume thing happened, like???
They get trapped in a cage together, which is just. Such a romcom trope and then while they're there Bennett gives Razor all his food because he's worried for him ANS THEN THEY WRITE A LOVE POEM TOGETHER
Like it's not even me going "Oh this is a love poem bc I say so" THE POINT IS THEY WERE WRITING LOVE POEMS, TRAVELLER SAID IT WAS FULL OF ROMANCE, AND
THE POEM IS ABOUT RAZOR
"You and the Mare Jivari
So close and yet so far
One at the edge of the world
The other in the center of my heart
Wolfhook and dandelion
My Windblume offering to you."
That's so fucking romantic and Bennett needed another windblume to use than dandelion so what does he do? Think of another flower himself, like his ascension mats or something? NO HE ASKS RAZOR AND PUTS RAZOR'S WINDBLUME INTO THE POEM!
People's choice of windblume is a personal thing!! Most Mondstadters have their own idea of what the windblume is so Bennett including Razor's choice (which is entirely unconventional in that it's not a flower and is only in Wolvendom) makes the poem so personalised to Razor!! He could even have said Windwheel asters or something bc those are his ascension flowers but NO! He made the poem about Razor's Windblume choice!! (And his ascension mats)
Let me ask you: if someone is giving someone else a windblume and they choose a Wolfhook, would you assume that the person receiving or giving the Wolfhook is the one character we know to live in Wolvendom, aka the only place Wolfhooks grow? Yeah you would assume that wouldn't you, so why is Bennett writing about giving someone a Wolfhook as windblume in a romantic context if it's not about Razor???
And then the most damning piece of evidence: RAZOR SAID THE POEM MADE HIM FEEL WARM AND TINGLY!! GAYASS
And don't think I didn't notice that the first few lines of the poem are about the contrast between the emotional and physical difference between the person the poem is about and Bennett. Razor lives in Wolvendom, putting him physically distant from Bennett, but they're "friends" anyway!! They hang out!! They write love poems about each other!! Bennett speaks to Razor in a way softer voice than anyone else!! They're close!!
Also, while Bennett was writing this poem he was "so close and yet so far" from Razor because they were IN THE SAME CAGE BUT DIFFERENT COMPARTMENTS. That makes them close, but unable to actually be next to each other!!
Also, after this, Venti says the poem is good and invites Bennett back to go to a bar and celebrate. Bennett declines, not because he doesn't like drinking or because he has some vague other thing to do but because he wants to go explore with Razor specifically. They then disappear and appear next in the cutscene, where Bennett is teaching Razor all about adventuring and says "WE need to bring more food next time, or you'll go hungry!" HE MEANS THEY'RE GONNA CONTINUE TO HANG OUT AND THAT THE NEXT TIME WILL BE WITH RAZOR AND HE WANTS TO ACCOMMODATE FOR RAZOR'S QUIRKS LIKE HOW HE CAN EAT LOADS AND STILL BE HUNGRY!! HE'S MAKING CHANGES TO HIS OWN LIFE TO BETTER FIT RAZOR!!
And Razor also makes changes for Bennett!! He doesn't like loud stuff or people who talk too much (which makes me think he's autistic but we move that's a different post) and the reason he was at the Thousand Winds Temple in the first place was because Wolvendom was too loud! This establishes he struggles with loud noises, or the fact that the hunters in Wolvendom talk too much.
BENNETT TALKS A LOT. Just saying
Also, in the cutscene for that Windblume, they're headed into the city. We know the city is filled with people, especially during a festival, probably way more people than Wolvendom, but he still goes because Bennett is there. He's following Bennett into somewhere that makes him uncomfortable, which means he trusts him already!!
Also, in his voiceline about Bennett, he says he talks a lot. He acknowledges that Bennett talks a lot but he doesn't have an issue with it! He says "eat with him, never full" which could either mean Bennett keeps stopping to talk or that Razor doesn't want to stop hanging out, so he's never full because he doesn't want to be done with the meal. It could also mean that he's never "full" or sick of Bennett's talking which is just adorable.
Also, in the susbedo event, Paimon asks Bennett where Razor is, meaning whenever she sees Bennett she expects to see Razor. You realise this means they probably hang out so often people see them as a pair? Inseparable?
IN CONCLUSION they're so in love they're basically canon, they have so many signs and hints and stuff that suggests they're way closer to each other than anyone else. Basically whenever we see one of them, they're with the other or the other one is close behind. They're so in love u guys
#this isn't me claiming they're canon btw#I'm theorizing basically#but i think this is way further than just a normal friendship#genshin impact#rannett#benzor#razor x bennett#bennett x razor#genshin razor#genshin bennett#razor genshin impact#bennett genshin impact#caps#long post
271 notes
·
View notes
Text
Man I wonder where the leader of the fear realm could've gone, it's alMOST LIKE NEVIN HAS AN
#had to re-edit the image real quick because the original edit was from a post I made about Drew years ago#and while the Drew thing is becoming less and less likely. Nevin havinv one has basically been canon since#someone mentioned Greg's (was it Britney's) aura being familiar in s2ch1. ive been putting together a list of every line#that points to Nevin's aura throughout the whole thing (most from s2ch1 but then s2ch10 came out and it was really canon at that point)#but clearly i'm running out of time to say ''i fucking called it'' before it's explicitly stated and i dont want to be in another situation#where somebody else will beat me to a theory and me posting anything about it will seem like copying them. sorry about that btw i had#thought i had already mentioned theorizing that nevin was possessed by a demon in that old theory i made but i had forgotten that one was#super old and was about sigma. so no copying there i just got extremely paranoid there was a mention of a cult and i was like ''nuh uh#that's way too specific and out there of a detail to end up in both our theories'' and i forgot the rest of my super old post was outdated#as hell. and echos had gone ''yeah they're so similar!'' and i took their word for it but now i'm realizing they were probably just trying#to be supportive. so yeah no copying there i was just beaten to the punch of saying something. but i will NOT back down from the aura shit#because i have been calling that shit FROM THE START or at least since i started reading ibvs back when ch20 came out.#also not backing down from saying chris was the worse friend because these past few chapters are the first time isaac has done anything tha#could knowingly upset chris meanwhile chris has. let edward drag isaac to the lair after isaac said edward would beat him up. chose not to#believe edward was holding the secrets over their heads because 'it was something isaac had said' and then immediately distrusted edward in#the next chapter because a random person he didn't know said to steal a book (might i mention how that entire scene proves chris' lack of#development and refusal to take responsibility because it perfectly alludes to when chris had brought those fireworks into his old school#and makes me wonder if charlie has actually gotten him in trouble with his past schools or if he's still just not taking responsibility#and if him following nevin to the woods to test out their powers is an extension of ''if something bad happens its not my fault''#like seriously this man would bring a mysterious suitcase onto a plane if he's told to). uh what was i talking about agai#anyway on a related note my mental state has only gotten worse since i left tumblr and the habit of thinking about chris instead of sleepin#or doing schoolwork has not stopped. so i was still failing for a while and might graduate now but am still staying away from tumblr.#so yeah this was a little update and im not going to linger this time im just going to leave tumblr again right after hitting post#addendum because i just can't let things go. and was thinking about chris again. i don't think his lack of development is because of bad#writing (anymore. i used to.). instead i'm certain his character arc is going to continue into him following someone (nevin probably) into#doing something really bad. and then he'll finally get actual consequences and go 'oh shit i fucked up real bad this time'#if you think that theory is reaching too far into the future you should hear mine about isaac dying at the end lmao
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Honkai Star Rail: CHECK OUT OUR TURN-BASED COMBAT! SUPER COOL CHARACTERS! WOW LOOK AT THAT ATTACK IT'S SO COOL! BE IN AWE OF OUR COMBAT ANIMATIONS!
Honkai Star Rail's latest update: oh you've been playing for four hours? How was that singular fight? Did you like it? Here's another six hours of cutscenes/cinematics/dialogue so long the box needs to scroll :)
#bouncing in the hall#hsr#honkai star rail#honkai sr#you could say i'm a little frustrated#they are CONSTANTLY shoving EVERY bit of information down our throats#there's basically no room for theorizing or even trying to theorize it's all just spelled out in fucking alphabet soup#i have to keep taking breaks because i'm so tired of getting this alphabet soup being shoveled down my throat#oh but it's a story game WELL THEN it's a BAD story game#bouncy plays
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
hi. i'm back from practicing brain surgery.
#💉 — west's research notes.#that was an incredibly informative experience.#fun but also tiring since we basically theorized for 2 hours straight#i'm laying down and resting now. surprisingly. normally i would be running myself into the ground with work but#i'm healthier now!#no more overworking for me :)#(for today)
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
there is nothing funnier to me than reading people's thoughts on Foundation every Friday, because it's always a 50/50 split between "this show is god-awful and season 2 is horrible" and "this show is the best thing ever to grace my eyeballs and season 2 is a huge improvement"
#for the record I'm in the I Like The Show camp#another underrated hilarious thing: watching people theorize about General Bel Riose with no knowledge of who he's based on lmao#(it will forever be funny to me that none of the other characters are like specific parallels to anyone—like I know the books are based on#The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire [very loosely]#but most characters and polities aren't clear 1:1 mirrors of real-life people or places.#But then there's General Bel Riose#who's basically Belisarius with a sci-fi coat of paint)#foundation#foundation season 2
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
!! what headcanons do you have for team hillscrafted? :0
the first and most major headcanon is that it's a team that exists at all
#asks#ok so like. me and Radio put them in a Roommates AU so a lot of our ideas are from there. but!!!!#we also have a fanseason typa thing. which also counts as an AU#so like. listen. calling them headcanons is inaccurate but I have Thoughts#so this is indeed the only thing I can really say is a headcanon#I will tell you a little bit about the fanseason though. it's Season HC (you'd think it stands for Hermitcraft. no. Season Hillscrafted)#the idea being that Joe and Xb base together and it goes kinda like a mix of HCBBS and S8#it was very difficult coming up with something that they might do but we decided that it would be like... an ancient civilization ruin#but like. you have Joe over here trying to accurately recreate inch to inch the details of a real archeological site#and Xb who's just balling#so it being an ancient civilization I'm hoping would relax the Must Be Accurate Down To Inch part of Joe's brain#and have him go ''well I'm just theorizing how it might have looked back in the day'' about any inaccuracies#like..... I'm obsessed with Joe's mental processes for his bases okay#so yeah. it's basically me and my friend putting our blorbos in one room and hoping they interact#because they don't interact enough in canon. but they could#WELL to be fair we have been fed really well recently. all the two people in the Hillscrafted fandom#they are <<<<33333 playing cards together <3 <3 <<33333 <3#joe is cheering for xb 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙#love and peace
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
welp, it finally happened. i think i'm getting bored of byler T_T
or at least most of the fandom's interpretation of them??? things have been dry recently but even tho there's been a bunch of new fancontent with byler week... yeah idk it aint clickin anymore. no shade to any of the creators in the fandom, y'all amazing, but i simply do not resonate with a lot of the takes that have been set into fanon by now
actually the last time i read a byler fic even to catch up on my subs was a couple weeks ago at this point
i still care abt them a lot in theory??? ig i enjoy how i perceive them from the show, but not so much consuming how others perceive them. i've still been having the occasional Blorbo Thoughts that i never feel like sharing and i have a few AUs i've been working on and a few more that are only conceptual, all of which i still find fun to think abt. i was literally doing some planning of a couple today. but straight canonverse as bylers interpret it has been sucked drier than a dust bunny for me. going thru the fics i've marked for later has felt more and more like a chore for months now, and if i scroll thru the tag itself on tumblr to see what's happening outside my mutualcule i just feel drained
i'm not leaving the fandom in the sense of completely disengaging myself from interacting with it. i still want to keep up with the news and i might give a bit more of a shit once filming starts. i also don't want to abandon any of my projects, both published and unpublished. but if i let myself get burnt out on the fandom completely then i'm not gonna be able to muster myself to care whatsoever about canon for years probably, which would really fucking suck bc i've loved this show since i was 12 years old and the byler side to my enjoyment started not even a year ago
so like. idrk what i'm saying. i've been mostly reading fic for other media for months now but i'm not fixated on any of them enough to get into the actual fandom space, i just need the detox. i'll probably be on tumblr just as much bc this is still my home but idk to what degree i'll consider myself to be IN the fandom as opposed to just happening to exist parallel to it
it's not rlly a surprise bc my interests consistently last abt a year but still. realizing that something that has brought u joy for months and months suddenly not only doesn't enthuse u anymore but actively BORES u to dedicate much of ur attention to Fucking Sucks. i always forget how much i hate it when my hyperfixations die :[[[
(of course all of this may change on a whim in a couple of weeks when i stop being so burnt out by cramming to finish schoolwork lmfao)
#i don't know who i'm even talking to here bc i severely doubt anybody cares at allll#i haven't posted regularly since fucking october probably#and now i post basically once a month#so it's not like much is changing realistically#who knows one day i might go thru my drafts and polish up a couple of analyses i never posted#but i think there's less than nothing left to talk abt vis a vis my personal level of theorizing#and i haven't thought of a single shitpost or meme abt them that wasn't abt one of my unpublished AUs in so long#so it rlly is just me with my specific AU blorbos that i have neither time nor energy to write down and share#sigh
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
one of the reasons it's really hard for a lot of intersex people when intersex topics are on the news cycle is because the public's reaction reveals how little anyone knows or cares about intersex people, including people who call themselves our allies. almost every time intersex topics are trending, the discourse surrounding them is filled with misinformation. people who only learned today what the word intersex means jump into conversations and act like an authority. endosex/dyadic/perisex people get tripped up over things that are basically intersex 101, with tons of endosex people incorrectly arguing about the definition of intersex, who "counts," DSD terminology, and so much more. i've seen multiple endosex people say today that they've been "warning intersex people" and that we should have known that transphobia would catch up with us eventually, which is an absolutely absurd thing to say given the fact that consistently over the past ten years, it has often been intersex people sounding the alarm on sex-testing policies and also the fact that many, many intersex people are also trans, and already are facing the impacts of transphobia. there is an absolute failure from the general public to take intersex identity seriously; people seem not even able to fathom that intersex people have a community, history, and our own political resources. instead, endosex people somehow seem to think they're helping by bringing up half-remembered information from their high school biology class which usually isn't even relevant at all.
and this frustrates me so fucking much. not because i want to deny the impacts of transphobic oppression--i'm a trans intersex person, trust me when i say i am intimately aware of transphobia. this frustrates me because there is no way we can achieve collective liberation if our "allies" fail to even engage with basic intersex topics and are seemingly unaware of the many forms of intersex oppression that we are already facing every fucking day. if you are not aware of compulsory dyadism, if you are not aware of interphobia, if you are not aware of the many different ways that intersex people are directly and often violently targeted--how the fuck do you think we're going to dismantle all of these systems of oppression?
if you were truly an intersex ally, you would already KNOW that this is not new, and would not be surprised--interphobia in sports has been going on for decades. you would know that we do have a community, an identity, a history--you would have already read/listened/watched to intersex resources that give you the background information you need for allyship. you would know that although there is a really distinct lack of resources and political education, that intersex people ARE developing a political understanding of ourselves and our oppression--Cripping Intersex by Celeste Orr and their framework of compulsory dyadism is one example of how we're theorizing our oppression. It's absolutely fucking wild to me how few people I've seen actually use words like "interphobia" "intersexism" "compulsory dyadism" or "intersex oppression"--endosex people are seemingly incapable of recognizing that there is already an entrenched system of oppression towards intersex people that violently reshapes our bodies, restricts our autonomy, and attempts to eradicate intersex through a variety of medical and legal means.
you cannot treat intersex people like an afterthought. not just because we're meaningful parts of your community and deserving of solidarity, but also because intersex oppression impacts everyone!!! especially trans community--trans people will not be free until intersex people are free, so much of transphobia is shaped by compulsory dyadism, the mythical sex binary, all these ideas of enforced "biological sex" that are just as fake as the gender binary.
it makes me absolutely fucking livid every time this shit happens because it becomes so abundantly clear to me how little the average endosex person knows about intersex issues and also how little the average endosex person cares about changing that. i don't know what to say to get you to care, to get you to change that, but we fucking need it to happen and i, personally, am tired of constantly being grateful when i meet an endosex person who knows the bare minimum. i think we have a right to expect better and to demand that if you're going to call yourself our ally, you actually fucking listen to us when we tell you what that means.
okay for endosex people to reblog.
#personal#intersex#actually intersex#actuallyintersex#interphobia#intersexism#compulsory dyadism#trans#lgbtqia#transphobia#also to be clear im not necessarily mad about people not knowing or using the term compulsory dyadism. bc that term in particular is newer.#and from a dense academic theory book. so that's something that i understand why ppl might not yet know. i just brought it up as an example#and my main point is less about which specific terms people are using. but more just that endosex people seem incapable of recognizing the#actual material instances of oppression that are already happening. and teh history of that. and the systems#set up to enable it#like idk i don't care if you don't know or use a term if you're otherwise aware and understand how the sex binary is fake and all the#discriminatory ways society then enforces this. and how it fucks intersex people over#you see what i'm saying?
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
When fanfic authors straight up lie in the tags 👀
#like okay....#i still think the story is good and im probably going to keep up with updates#but like dude#at least change them if you decide to go a different path#cass complains#i just really loved the way the story was going and then it basically did a 180#it's probably because people kept theorizing the same thing and it for stuck in their head#now I'm salty about everyone changing the story lmao#my post#/rant
0 notes
Note
❝ why do you stick around? what is it you think you see in me? ❞
"Are you revealing your sentimental side to me, Mikaelson cub?" While their agreement proved to be surprisingly triumphant so far, sardonic remarks and prideful stances were still cordially exchanged during these reunions. Her question emanated insinuations of novelty that disrupted their common language. "And I presume you are expecting to hear some vapid platitude concerning the potential of your chimeric nature?" Tristan examined her for a moment. Not with eyes that ignored the real response to her curiosity but a gaze carefully considering how much to answer. "Have you ever given any thought to the true essence of a birthright? I'm not speaking of its superficial facets. The power it imbues upon our hands or the whispering murmurs of those comparing how close we are to the most vicious aspects of our father it attracts. I'm referring to its heart. History, both seen and experienced, taught me that the heart of a birthright is the promise of an oncoming storm. And that such rabid winds tend to arrive before we are prepared for them." Shades of past and present intertwined. "Some flee from the storm to never stop running. Cowards and survivors. Some confront it in all of their heroic or foolish righteousness. White knights. Some employ and adopt more treacherous tactics for their victory. Black knight. As for the fourth path...The less traveled one of them all..." He offered her a meaningful look.
"You are painfully literal in execution but it had been a while since the last time I met someone who took the same path I once did. There aren't many of us at all. Those whose impulse is to receive the raging gales that either threaten or have already ravished our existence only to extend a warning notification. There must have been some confusion. I'll be the storm in this play." His stare finally abandoned her in the nonchalant conclusion. "It wouldn't be altogether lunacy to theorize I respect that common ground. If we were getting sentimental...Some would go as far as to propose I have grown to occasionally enjoy that about you."
@cursedbcrn
#cursedbcrn#Tristan in your hollow Hope au:#I can respect the fact that you basically feed on ancestral evils to add to your power. What do you want from me?#Honestly I don't think he ever theorized she could be a viable option until he lived that cop buddy adventure with your Elijah.#I'm sure he would love to hear that.
1 note
·
View note
Text
hiii tumblr i'm back i hope my mooties find this
A little bit about me: I'm Ani (she/they), a 20 year old digital artist who had a tumblr for a bit but went inactive. I'm returning now with a fresh account to keep things simple. You may remember me as @/aaliendna with my old acc, or know me from twitter or TH as @/dollyinspace!
I mainly post fnaf related stuff; I've been in the fandom for several years now but I mostly just take the basic concepts of fnaf and run with my own aus, as opposed to theorizing or getting into the actual games. lmao. I also may occasionally post other fandoms, nonfandom OCs who are very special to me, or advertise adopts or OCs I'm selling. I'm excited to be back and find some old and new friends! 💗
(attached is a cute doodle i did awhile back, for engagement! enjoy!)
#fnaf#five nights at freddy's#toy chica#withered bonnie#my art#artists on tumblr#blah blah#through our eyes AU
805 notes
·
View notes
Note
The wikipedia vandalism worries me so much. Even if it stops, it'll take ages to fix it all and the damage will already have been done. And goyim are just gonna start conspiracy theorizing about how the big bad scary Jews are "censoring" wikipedia and they're gonna do everything they can to discredit actual accurate information in favor of their antisemitic bullshit.
I've basically been hoarding as much Jewish knowledge as I can. I'm filling hard drives and bookshelves with every scrap I can find before goyim can scrub it from the internet and ban it from bookstores and libraries (whether legally or through pressure and intimidation). I don't know what else to do. They're trying to erase us from history so that it'll be easier to kill us and pretend it never happened. I refuse to let them get away with it.
.
360 notes
·
View notes
Note
niceys positive anon!! i don't agree with you on everything but you are so clearly like well read and well rounded that you've helped me think through a lot of my own inconsistencies and hypocrises in my own political and social thought, even if i do have slightly different conclusions at times then u (mainly because i believe there's more of a place for idealism and 'mind politics' than u do). anyway this is a preamble to ask if you have recommended reading in the past and if not if you had any recommended reading? there's some obvious like Read Marx but beyond that im always a little lost wading through theory and given you seem well read and i always admire your takes, i wondered about your recs
it's been a while since i've done a big reading list post so--bearing in mind that my specific areas of 'expertise' (i say that in huge quotation marks obvsies i'm just a girlblogger) are imperialism and media studies, here are some books and essays/pamphlets i recommend. the bolded ones are ones that i consider foundational to my politics
BASICS OF MARXISM
friedrich engels, principles of commmunism
friedrich engels, socialism: utopian & scientific
karl marx, the german ideology
karl marx, wage labour & capital
mao zedong, on contradiction
nikolai bukharin, anarchy and scientific communism
rosa luxemburg, reform or revolution?
v.i lenin, left-wing communism: an infantile disorder
v.i. lenin, the state & revolution
v.i. lenin, what is to be done?
IMPERIALISM
aijaz ahmed, iraq, afghanistan, and the imperialism of our time
albert memmi, the colonizer and the colonized
che guevara, on socialism and internationalism (ed. aijaz ahmad)
eduardo galeano, the open veins of latin america
edward said, orientalism
fernando cardoso, dependency and development in latin america
frantz fanon, black skin, white masks
frantz fanon, the wretched of the earth
greg grandin, empire's workshop
kwame nkrumah, neocolonialism, the last stage of imperialism
michael parenti, against empire
naomi klein, the shock doctrine
ruy mauro marini, the dialectics of dependency
v.i. lenin, imperialism: the highest stage of capitalism
vijay prashad, red star over the third world
vincent bevins, the jakarta method
walter rodney, how europe underdeveloped africa
william blum, killing hope
zak cope, divided world divided class
zak cope, the wealth of (some) nations
MEDIA & CULTURAL STUDIES
antonio gramsci, the prison notebooks
ed. mick gidley, representing others: white views of indigenous peoples
ed. stuart hall, representation: cultural representations and signifying pratices
gilles deleuze & felix guattari, capitalism & schizophrenia
jacques derrida, margins of philosophy
jacques derrida, speech and phenomena
michael parenti, inventing reality
michel foucault, disicipline and punish
michel foucault, the archeology of knowledge
natasha schull, addiction by design
nick snricek, platform capitalism
noam chomsky and edward herman, manufacturing consent
regis tove stella, imagining the other
richard sennett and jonathan cobb, the hidden injuries of class
safiya umoja noble, algoriths of oppression
stuart hall, cultural studies 1983: a theoretical history
theodor adorno and max horkheimer, the culture industry
walter benjamin, the work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction
OTHER
angela davis, women, race, and class
anna louise strong, cash and violence in laos and vietnam
anna louise strong, the soviets expected it
anna louise strong, when serfs stood up in tibet
carrie hamilton, sexual revolutions in cuba
chris chitty, sexual hegemony
christian fuchs, theorizing and analysing digital labor
eds. jules joanne gleeson and elle o'rourke, transgender marxism
elaine scarry, the body in pain
jules joanne gleeson, this infamous proposal
michael parenti, blackshirts & reds
paulo freire, pedagogy of the oppressed
peter drucker, warped: gay normality and queer anticapitalism
rosemary hennessy, profit and pleasure
sophie lewis, abolish the family
suzy kim, everyday life in the north korean revolution
walter rodney, the russian revolution: a view from the third world
#ask#avowed inframaterialist reading group#i obviously do not 100% agree with all the points made by and conclusions reached by these works#but i think they are valuable and useful to read
1K notes
·
View notes
Note
without dropping anything super specific what do you think of EoW's story? in particular i'm kinda worried over if they made Zelda basically replaceable with any other silent protag and i'm holding back on getting the game if that's the case...
I think they handled a playable zelda incredibly well actually! In particular I was impressed that although she is a silent protagonist, she is NOT link, and the game takes care to remind you of that in everything from dialog to physical gameplay. Though she does technically have the ability to wield link's sword, in practice it's almost always more practical to use echoes, her own unique form of gameplay, to get through combat instead, which is a good reminder to the player that this isn't link's story, and we're not going to be able to beat it link's way. You're required to be ZELDA and think like zelda, utilizing mechanics unique to her, in order to progress through the story, and those mechanics emphasize creative problem-solving in a way that clearly envokes her core trait of wisdom. so in that regard i'd say she's definitely a unique protagonist and I never felt like she could have been replaced with someone else! (mild spoilery note: in the final battle you do actually have link fighting alongside you, and because of that, your sword ability is removed entirely, meaning you HAVE to end the game on zelda's terms, with zelda's abilities, which I thought was a nice touch.)
In terms of actual story, it's honestly a fairly classic zelda formula, but the twists and turns were well-written and kept me VERY engaged throughout. The act of searching for link felt different not because chasing after a captured friend is uncommon in a loz game, but because HE was different. The things you learn about link and how he ended up in this story compel you to keep searching for him in a way that you almost... don't need when you're link chasing zelda, because OF COURSE the hero is going to go after the princess. but this game had to engineer a situation in which the PRINCESS wanted to go after the HERO, and a hero she'd never met before at that. and that to me is what made the story interesting.
I will say, don't go into this game expecting it to have the same amount of story as a 3d installment like botw or totk. this is a topdown classic-style game, and it treats itself like one. the story is good, but it's not pushing the boundaries of the genre or anything. eow is a game that knows what it is and what it wants to do, and it does it exceptionally well. I think where the game really shines is in the implied narrative of the worldbuilding--pieces of personal memorabilia in characters' houses, little hints of the past and references to previous games in map design and details that allow you as the player to theorize and put together the less overt pieces of the story on your own. this has always been one of the things that I personally really enjoy about zelda games, so I absolutely LOVE how much detail is left for the player to find in eow if they're paying attention.
#asks#eow spoilers#basically. it's VERY good but it's not a 3d game. keep that in mind#there's definitely more of an emphasis on the actual mechanical gameplay. but the gameplay works so well that that's fine!
208 notes
·
View notes
Text
I've been thinking about how we the players know so little about Solas compared to what the writers and developers know about him and how that affects the way he is written.
I mean we know he is an ancient elf. We know he was powerful enough and skilled enough to create the Veil. We know he and Mythal were friends. He doesn't seem to have liked Andruil and Falon'Din much. Skyhold belonged to him. He removed vallislin. He tried to free slaves. He had kind of an underground railroad thing going. He seems to have had a lot of money secreted away. He painted even back in Arlathan. A lot of statues seem to have been made of him. People in the Vir Dirthara knew he created the Veil but were surprised that he would do something like that. He seems to have always had an affinity for the Fade and spirits. He enjoyed whatever version of the Game nobles in Arlathan played. He was cocky and hot blooded, always spoiling for a fight. He is capable of love and friendship.
I think that's all and it really isn't much. Everything else anyone says about him is pure speculation. It makes meta fun but its easy to get too caught up in our own ideas.
We speculate about him based on things we learn from his personal quests and what we see in Trespasser but we don't know anything for sure. Was he a slave? Was he a spirit called out of the Fade by Mythal and given a body? Did he manifest a body like Cole? Was he just a normal elf born in a small village to the north? Was he a noble and privileged or did he work his way up? Did he join the fight against the Titans? Was he a genius who theorized that the waking world and Fade could be separated? Did he use untried magic because his back was against the wall and he couldn't think of any other way to save the world? Was he a friend of the Evanuris so they trusted him enough to fall into his trap? Was he one of them?
So many questions. The writers have tried to portray him sympathetically. They want us to empathize with him. And I have to ask myself why? He is one of the antagonists. Wouldn't it be easier to portray him as not having any redeeming qualities? And yet, he is basically described as the hero who lived long enough to become the villain.
I know his detractors believe he is a genocidal, racist maniac but that doesn’t track with everything we learn about him as high approval or romanced Inquisitors. It certainly isn’t born out by his statement that he is doing his best to minimize the damage.
He truly believes what he is doing is best for the world and is willing to break it and remake it. What does he know? But more importantly, what do the writers know? Fen' Harel has existed since Origins. Devs have always planned for him to make an appearance. That means the valleslin has always been a mark of slavery even if the Dalish didn't know. The Creators have always been horrible, slave owners even if the Dalish don't remember. Which means Solas has always been the rebel fighting for what he believes is right.
Why do the writers see him not so much as the villain (although Epler uses that word constantly - he is usually the only one though) as they do a somewhat noble person who keeps making mistakes? Why is he portrayed as just a sad man who can't see past his regret and guilt. What was he like? What changed him? What did he know about the Veil before he put it up?
I get that a lot of people don't like the idea of being tied to him in Veilguard but maybe the writers did that so we have no choice but to get to know him - the good and the bad. Maybe we finally get to know Solas the way the writers and developers know him. I'm looking forward to that.
#solas#dragon age#solavellan#solasmance#fen'harel#solas dragon age#solas dread wolf#dai solas#solas meta#dragon age meta#da meta#evanuris#mythal#dragon age theory
320 notes
·
View notes
Note
genuine question, what do you mean by babying danse?
I like him quite a lot and seen a considerable amount of content, but I might've just not noticed?? what you're talking about specifically
What I mean is people basically pulling the "he's my baby boy he'd never do anything wrong" shit. And the way people talk about him (calling him a "himbo", and as said "baby boy", saying he's just a sad guy who's misunderstood, etc) reads deeply as infantilization especially considering. As said. He's a grown man who literally upholds fascist ideals and only left the Brotherhood because he'd literally die otherwise
I'm not saying people aren't allowed to explore a softer side of him or theorize how a redemption arc for him would go. But the way I often see him (mis)characterized as being a stupid, gentle, "doesn't know what he's doing is wrong :(" type of guy REEKS of "autistic people are basically like children and don't know if they're doing something bad", especially since I've seen people on multiple platforms claim him and Maxon are "son and father figure" despite him being older than Maxon, just because he's subservient to him and they're vaguely friends
(But since fans read him as autistic OBVIOUSLY that means Maxon is like a caretaker for this poor misguided soul and not literally his boss and commander /sarcasm)
Like. If you haven't seen this stuff, good for you. But basically every time I've seen a post about him that isn't tearing into him for being a BOS member is basically like what I mentioned in one degree or another. If you actually look at the way people talk about him, it becomes obvious
Plus, you notice this when it's not just one character this happens to. I've seen it happen with Arcade (thankfully that's died down in recent years), Preston, and currently Maximus from the show. Just an endless cycle of people denying autonomy from characters who are read as awkward and/or autistic
(I'm sure other people would have more examples on hand. So if you do, feel free to reblog this and add them)
#maybe its just something from older fandom leeching back in but regardless i hate it#idk what examples you wanted me to give. i dont screenshot a post every time it annoys me#/nm im just annoyed about the general subject matter#but like. as said i dont delve tags here but occasionally i scroll to the fy feed and see this shit#plus tiktok shows me those posts as well#ask#vinny rambles#fallout 4#paladin danse
148 notes
·
View notes