#And if I had to be traumatized by this knowledge
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
After top surgery I had nerve pain across my entire chest and I lost sensation/have continued nerve pain in my nipples. I do feel pretty bad about this. It was traumatizing. You laughing about that as if itâs impossible is kind of baffling to me. It isnât helpful to minimize genuine risks in order to assert that trans people have the right to choose.
Iâd probably decide to do top surgery again if I knew ahead of time what the outcome would be. Making decisions is about so much more than a simple âyesâ or ânoâ. Making decisions is about navigating a series of interlocking trade offs and using our autonomy and our knowledge of ourselves to chose the path that feels best, even if that path might be difficult or yes, even traumatizing.
Iâm frustrated by a lot of this rhetoric about low regret rates for gender affirming care or about various complications being a ânon issueâ. Dismissing ambivalence or individual negative outcomes puts trans people as a whole in the position of having to perform satisfaction with our choices in order to have the right to make those choices. We shouldnât have to flatten or simplify our experiences with gender affirming care in order to assert our bodily autonomy.
Because donât forget, this fight is about our autonomy. Sometimes people are dissatisfied with the choices they make, but this doesnât negate their right to choose. We donât need to deny each othersâ realities in order to assert our rights.
I saw the stupidest TERF argument about top surgery yesterday over on Bluesky and I'm still thinking about it. However stupid you think it was, you're not going to guess how dumb this is
So. I was reading a happy post with people sharing top surgery stories. Great stuff. And this terf comes into the comments like "oh but what about the psychological damage" and I was like "wtf" and then I read more they wrote and no joke. They were fear-mongering about how psychologically damaging it is to lose sensation in your nipples post top surgery.
I've gotta at least give that one points for creativity. That's hilarious. Even if you are very attached to retaining sensation in your nipples, there are types of top surgery that don't sever the nipple stalk so your sensation isn't affected. It's such a non-issue, and like as someone who had the standard DI with grafts, I literally never think about it. It's not like they hurt, and it's still too early at about six months out to know what long-term sensation will look like, but I can still feel pressure and it's not a super weird feeling at all. This is such a strange choice of topic to fear-monger about.
Who is out here psychologically damaged because they can't feel their nipples the same post surgery
694 notes
¡
View notes
Text
I'm only on Episode 5 of "Teen Wolf" and it's hard not to think about Stiles/Derek due to the pairing's influence as a fandom juggernaut throughout the 2010s. It has, over the years, occasionally made me intensely curious as to what was actually in the source material to spark this, versus how much of it was the migratory slash fanfiction fandom stuff.
I don't have... super strong opinions of them from the source material yet? I don't really think they have positive or negative chemistry at the moment. Their interactions are hampered by the fact that I think Derek Hale is currently kind of incoherent as a character, apparently not allowed to actually talk to anyone due to contrived drama reasons, preventing him from connecting naturally on an informational or emotional level to Stiles or Scott. Derek's backstory is still murky and largely unknown. Derek's personal goals here are also a little unclear. Some of this will be cleared up as the season goes on.
I do think that I personally would enjoy Derek more if he had actually been only a few years older than Scott and Stiles, as Stiles says in the first episode, and actually looked it as well. I think that Derek being younger, being another "teen wolf" at 19, would have 1) put him on more even footing with Scott, and 2) made him come across as more of a scared, cornered animal, lashing out at the Argents and stumbling around lost without his family/pack. Like, the traumatized lone wolf thing is apparently what's happening with Derek anyway, but I do think all that would be better communicated to the audience if Derek looked younger and more pathetic and was allowed to snap at / talk to people more and with purpose.
If Derek was younger, I also think that he would function as a better mirror / foil to Scott. Here's this kid who was born a werewolf (unlike Scott), had a big and loving family (Scott has a single, loving mother and an apparently better-absent father), and is now orphaned and homeless and friendless (unlike Scott). It would also make Kate look even more vile and I'm good with that. I know the writers are going to absolutely miss the opportunity to have Scott and Derek's relationship have some more positive give-and-take. Scott has a lot to offer Derek! Scott's kind heart is one of my favorite things about him so far!
Anyway, back to the Stiles/Derek stuff. Yeah, I would also like Stiles/Derek or Scott/Derek more as concepts if Derek was younger. Right now, from the actual canon material I've seen, disregarding the knowledge I've picked up over the years regarding Derek's life, Derek is mostly giving me Angel from "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" vibes. And I really did not like Angel and especially not Angel/Buffy.
One positive thing I will say for Stiles/Derek is that I can absolutely see where the ship originally came from. Stiles does have some very queerbait-y lines with the "am I attractive to gay guys" humor. Derek is conventionally attractive. Derek and Stiles are the only two people in on the "Scott is a werewolf" problem, helping him out, and there's maybe a dash of "pair the spares" to it, but these two people are actually interacting and cooperating to solve problems together. And "I got you arrested for a murder you didn't commit" / "you need to cut off my arm" is a hell of a starting point for a ship. That's honestly great stuff. That's a level of freak that might generally inspire me to invent chemistry for a pair of characters, just to figure out how to make that relationship work.
In conclusion, I don't personally ship it, but I get it. I totally see where it came from.
71 notes
¡
View notes
Note
I'm really curious how Fen, Solas, and Dorian first got together. Did two of them come first and a third joined later? How did they approach the conversation?
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/4e066b7dfe583f983b1c1460310ee30e/7d0e8eb8635f341e-fd/s540x810/fcab8af687a6b4d82c27fe64505203603b6055d0.jpg)
Ok Iâm sorry this will probably be long winded, rambly, also just messily written - and, despite the fact that this moment is my planned next one shot about them - there are just so many moving parts that actually lead to them getting together.
Throwing this under a break because it's so long
When they were at Haven, there was some tension between Solas and Fen. Despite Fenâs best and continued efforts, Solas is very short with him at the beginning, a lot of it relating to Fen being a grey warden. On the other hand, from the moment Fen and Dorian lock eyes, it's flirting. They make easy friends, Dorian very taken by Fenâs happy-to-help golden retriever like personality, trauma bonded by the happenings of In Hushed Whispers and easily spending a lot of time together. Leading up to Skyhold, Solas starts taking to Fenâs late night âquestioningsâ. If Solas considers Fen uneducated, he was going to ask and learn as much as he could. Itâs true he didnât have many opportunities to get âbook smartâ (he is precious), but he loves to learn, and we all know how much Solas loves to embark wisdom. So there they are, every evening - and to Solasâ surprise, Fen is very responsive to his teachings. He clearly considers everything heâs told, utilizes it in making decisions moving forward, and comes back with new questions. And before long he finds himself drawn to the way Fen navigates day-to-day. Perhaps he judged too soon, I mean, Fen can be and is foolish at times, but he sees how Fen uses the knowledge heâs given, and suddenly heâs hooked. This turns into late evenings with the three of them as they all grow closer throughout the timeline of the game. Fen enjoys watching Solas and Dorian debate, likes watching Solas paint while Dorian reads beside him on the couch. Sometimes theyâre both just listening to Fen yap about darkspawn or a weird looking tree he saw earlier that day while they sit around the fire. Its not really anything particularly even intimate, though it is to them to some extent because they donât spend much time alone with anyone else - and they all sort of become inseparable- EVEN after Fen and Solas get together.
Dorian isnât surprised. Even in their flirting he knew Fen was taken with Solas from before theyâd met. And Dorian, who had spent a lot of time alone without really anyone close to him, was content to just have two people he held dearly, even if his heart was unfortunately growing more attached by the day. He sort of feels bad about it too, theyâre a couple, but heâs always there.
And then, Fen starts hearing the false calling. And by and then, I mean, heâs been hearing it for a while - but its getting worse. He is all but inconsolable one evening, and Solas and Dorian are looking at each other not sure what to do. I mean what CAN they do right? They're just as horrified. And...We can ignore the added layer of Solas and his fuck this is all in a round about way my fault situation for now LOL
Following Here lies the Abyss, Solas and Dorian are sort of high alert, a bit more attentive, not that Fen needs it, but more in a way they were woken up to how important this idiot had become to them. They felt like they could lose him to this, selfishly, ignoring what the loss of Fen could do to the world, but now horrified at the idea of losing him - generally.
And Itâs not long after this, a close encounter leads Fen to a near death experience by an ambush. Dorian and Solas are so panicked they canât leave his side, and without ever verbally asking, theyâre both with each other like a crutch - now both seemingly living through the fear they were really going to lose Fen.
It was traumatic, and Solas refuses to let Dorian leave his side, like he truly believes it may break him to deal with this crushing fear alone. When Fen finally wakes, Dorianâs relief is suddenly hit with the realization that he is not to them what they are to each other. Suddenly like the world is being crushed amongst the happiness Fen isnât dead, he is quick to say heâs sorry for always being in their space and that heâd try to give them more alone time since he didnât want to ever take the precious time they have together away from them.
Solas shuts it down, fast. A few glances between him and Fen and itâs a confession. Fen and Solas had been falling for Dorian, and were convinced heâd want no part, and so settled to always having him in their space. It was emotional, for so many reasons, and a lot of tears, and it became impossible to tear them apart for the next fortnight.Â
#hello when I said the lore was deep I meant it#I could yap for hours#and I have#art tag#solapavellan#sopavellan#fen'elgara#solas dragon age#dorian pavus#forty speaks#solavellan#solavellen hell#pavellan
37 notes
¡
View notes
Note
LOBOTOMY CORP?????? I MUST KNOW
I AM GLAD YOU ASKED!!!!
Okay, so there is a lot, so I will share the basics, and then the most most recent sketches but you and anyone honestly can bother me about any of them on any given moment (please bother me about them please please please)
This is the only normal coherent refs I ever made for them in one singular style XD, I hope to redo them, for artfight this year
And this is the sketches
I am genuinely so happy I haven't drawn the comic I have planned years ago, because back then I didn't know what body diversity was not I was good at anything, everyone had same nationality and very similar backgrounds.... You know, the regular XD
OKAY SO NOW!!! About them. Think SCP but anime, think Lethal Company but high ranking employees with better knowledge of anomalies and better equipment. Think dangerous complex and boring 8h shifts. Think everything is fine until it is suddenly very not. Think time manipulation and serial killer and gay people and character relationships and traumatized employees in all that mess. Have I mentioned a serial killer? Oh there is also an escaped anomaly btw, have you moped floors already? Here is the bucket!
#my sketches#lobotomy corporation#MY BELOVED CHILDREN I LOVE THEM ALL SO MUCH#also even with time manipulation there are permadeath ;С
27 notes
¡
View notes
Note
Yeah but like, whoâs getting the most bitches? Amirite?
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/bf74a4ec55cccf51884ae68a3bf6f340/1e9c8dd47baefa58-0d/s540x810/1779c1b53caa2d79d719d4b50331d0b09f3e4320.jpg)
I don't think you want the answer to that question, Anon.... XD
#warhammer 40k oc#Why would you make me think about who has the most rizz in this crew of idiots! XD#.....Sadly uh.... As confirmed by his player..... Haertloch does pull bitches. XD Somehow.#And if I had to be traumatized by this knowledge#so do all of you! XD
14 notes
¡
View notes
Text
i feel like there's no way to say it without sounding Insane and attention-seeking but i Do wish that there was language that existed for talking about being traumatized by delusions/hallucinations without sounding like you're just saying "i made up something in my head and got hurt feelings about it"....
#N posts stuff#the popular post-psychosis narrative always seems to be 'okay you don't Believe it anymore so it's all done and you're#not affected by it in any way (unless you Stop Taking Your Meds and have another episode)' like it's Contained within itself#there's not really room for the 'well. it still Happened so it can still Affect you even if you recognize it wasn't ''Real'''#like there's no good way to speak about it w other people because it feels like a tightrope line difference between#'well it Wasn't traumatizing bc it wasn't Real so it didn't Really Happen' dismissal#or attempts to validate that just risk triggering another episode bc there's a veritable Minefield in 'it was real to you / it Was Real'#but it's HARD bc like. i can See it. i can Observe in myself that the like.#the home life situation i was in when i was younger Was traumatizing; and some of the delusions i've had have been#Equally traumatizing... i can See that. but if you try to Talk about it it's like 'okay. but it didn't Really Happen and you Know that#so Move ON stop trying to make yourself seem special' hhhhhhhhh#HOW do you square the knowledge that you were being abused with the knowledge that your abuser does not exist and never has?#WHERE do you put those conflicting realities? how do you get to make it make sense?#you should move on because it didn't happen. but it Did happen so you can't move on. WHERE do the pieces fit together?????
14 notes
¡
View notes
Text
people think that Aegon's taunts are a good reason to kill him (guys, you don't have siblings and it shows). at the same time, no one is saying that Aegon should kill Aemond for provoking TB to strike back, which is why Aegon's son was killed.
I thought it would be a terrible and cruel scene where Aegon would embarrass Aemond in the whole brothel, and it was only a drunken stupied Aegon.
#aegon ii targaryen#hotd#house of the dragon#[ about jokes -> Aegon is just an asshole#but about the brothel he thought he was doing his brother a favor which is evident from him when he brings a squire to lose his virginity#Besides how would he know that it was a traumatic experience for Aem when he clearly did not disclose it and continues to go to that woman#of course Aegon thought he liked it#he even praises her squire after that#I mean although his actions had negative consequences there was no malice behind them.#He has a typical medieval mindset without knowledge of modern psychology.]#my post
24 notes
¡
View notes
Text
i know chase obviously wins the religious trauma competition but can we please talk about how foreman was not only raised by a deeply religious father, but was most likely raised BAPTIST. no wonder heâs so repressed. the baptist experience is like. youâre in church every sunday listening to a man scream about how love is something that should hurt. you believe in a good, loving god - but to believe, you have to accept that true love is painful. that to be a good person, you must suffer. to love is to endure it, to work mercilessly. youâre not worthy of the love of The Almighty, and you never will be, and that sense of unworthiness is fundamental to having faith. when you sin, you donât just hurt Him, you hurt everyone around you. you make the world worse because you have dared commit the sin of existence â to be human is to be sinful. to be loved is to feel unworthy and pathetic and hopeless. like YEAH no wonder foreman self isolates and is emotionally closed off. he was taught from BIRTH that he is fundamentally unworthy of love, and that in accepting love, he is also accepting that he truly is worthless.
#also#i really cant stress enough to non-americans that foreman being black would seriously have had an impact on his relationship with religion#christian ideals are baked into the way racial justice is thought about in the blm movement of today#christianity is also by and large more significant to black americans than it is to white americans because of this#because race and religion are really intertwined#and idk its not. the MOST important aspect of foremanâs character or anything#but i think itâs a lot harder to Get him if u donât have that cultural knowledge which most americans will inherently understand#also disclaimer im not black. never been to a black church so obviously i cant speak to that experience#however i did go to a baptist school growing up and they REALLY emphasized that i should be ashamed of being alive#obviously this is all me theorizing bc foreman could be some other flavor of protestantism#theyâre all varying levels of traumatic tbh#if he was episcopal he probably was listening to people speaking tongues in church which just. yeah. that also really fucks u up#house md#eric foreman#house md hc#house md headcanon#dr foreman
125 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Kinda gets me when people age them down in AUs and stuff because to me those characters wouldn't be half as interesting if Chilchuck, Senshi and Mithrun were the tallman equivalent of in their twenties
#just something about having a lot of history you know#like. chills is divorced or thereabouts. senshi spent like 30 years living in dungeon wilderness. mithrun knows kabru's mom#none of this would be possible if they were 20-somethings#dungeon meshi spoilers#dungeon meshi manga spoilers#somewhat i guess#like. yeah kabru and laios and falin (and marci for an elf) are really young BUT have a lot of life exp#but like. the fact that so much happened to them while they are so young is TRAUMA. its BAD#meanwhile chilchuck had like. a pretty average life for a halffoot his age. maybe even successful from a professional standpoint#senshi didnt have an average life but had the time to accumulate an amount of knowledge no 20something could have#and of course mithruns whole life story is like. slowed down because hes an elf#but even then i think its really important to show that it might take several years to start recuperating from a traumatic event#like its what makes his character such an interesting commentary on disability and depression#when you're 25 bouncing back is easier. when you're 40? 50? showing that theres hope#even when you've lost your whole youth to your pain... thats a whole other thing#sorry i started writing serious commentary in the tags#chills#captain mithrun#senshi#even in senshis character up to a point. he spent more years out of society than in it#and YET! even he manages to find a place. somewhat#like. they are all here to show that life goes on even after horrible or simply sad shit happens to you#they are survivors!!!! thats important
38 notes
¡
View notes
Text
EPIC PRO TIP!!
IF YOU DO NOT WATCH ANY EPISODE OF JRWI RIPTIDE YOU CANNOT BE HURT !!! DO NOT !!!
#jrwi riptide#guys im thinkin g bout those FUCKASS PIRATES again#oughghg captain rose knew that chip would come looking for them#he doomed the entire crew and left a fucking thank you note#chip ik you were then traumatized by the novel of finn tidestrider suckin n fuckin but like where's your anger#i would be so fucking angry if this guy who had been like. an idol to me#had been the sole reason for like 90% of my suffering#he fucking was a part of why the hole in the sea happened. rose dammed the entire crew to that#with the knowledge that ONLY chip would come looking for him. as a fucking legacy#jrwi spoilers#jrwi riptide spoilers
13 notes
¡
View notes
Text
it sucks universities have fees in general, but for me personally, I wanna take courses not even for qualifications or any of the job benefits of uni. I literally want to just go there to learn for the sake of learning. and the fact that it's not encouraged, that natural human curiosity/personal pursuits of happiness, costs you a lifetime debt fucking sucks.
#and i want to take a physical course in fashion/textiles; hairdressing; and carpentry. and i know i never can because of the cost#also like i HAD to drop out of highschool because I was actively trying to kill myself so i dont have credit scores#and i still get asked now by fuckhead doctors etc why not and its like what part of suicide do you not get??#also im physically and mentally disabled as an adult who is still only 2 years out of a traumatic 26 year abusive household#like i just want to LEARN#and i know there are courses online but its not the same as learning with your hands#for the SAKE of learning; not so i can get a job (again i am unable to work) and 'benefit/contribute' to society#like no bitch i just want to KNOW THINGS. i want to learn skills and knowledge because that alone makes me HAPPY#idk girl theres no winning with universities its so disgusting#idk
3 notes
¡
View notes
Text
why the fuck did my dad choose to make his kids homeless but let us use as much data as we needed/wanted and let my brother keep using his hand me down car and paying for his gas and let me keep using his card info to refill my orca card. i still think about it bc that whole situation was so fucked and weird and confusing. he refused to consider going halvsies on rent for an apartment and made us live in a shelter/car only for me to check myself into a psych ward and stay there for 2 and a half months and go back to the shelter again until i texted him about how bad everything was and THEN he paid for my rent for a bedroom in a house. i hate my parents and i hate relying on them financially. i literally Need them still because of Money. i lived in that house for 9 months and then i got into college with my parents paying for everything and me just signing up to pay back loans. my dad said i should go for the unlimited meal plan and pays for it. he gave me $200 every month for personal expenses. and now hes paying my rent and bills in full again for an apartment until i move back to school which he will continue paying for. why were you so fucking quick to kick me out of your house with 20 minutes notice
#posts#why am i simultaneously poor and receiver of daddys money rn. im stressed about food every month and still horrifically traumatized about#everything to do with housing and scared im about to lose it all again. im attached to seattle in the weirdest fucking way and have the#weirdest emotions about there now. all jyst for my dad to be buying my grocieries and paying for my housing still.#he didnt have to kick us out. some lady from our church suggested it because she used to work with vocational whatever the fuck and stuff#like it all happened within the span of like. a week or something#my dad also had no idea we'd be homeless for weeks. he said he never wanted us to be at the shelter for weeks. like just a complete and#utter lack of knowledge of how homelessness and shelters work. did he really think we'd be there a few days and get whisked away to#transitional housing??!?!?!? that was his plan. he told us thats what he wanted from all that#instead i lost the whole end of 2022. mid october 2022 to mid january 2023. fuck you
3 notes
¡
View notes
Text
just realized my fatal flaw and the great struggle of possibly the rest of my life. while watching a cdrama.
#a sock speaks#local construction#fundamentally I lack the confidence needed to be a writer or a teacher#on the one hand I can't brazen my way out of this by pretending to be confident. I need to actually have the knowledge and skills I claim.#on the other hand I can't just say I'll be confident once I have more knowledge and experience. I have a master's degree!#I want to get more school but more school on its own will not fix this#I've let opportunities pass by because I was depressed. I didn't see how I could be enough for them.#or I was too tired (because I was depressed)#but sometimes it's bc I'm not sure if trying would make things better or worse (that one's on the OCD more than depression)#it makes sense that I lack confidence because of inexperience. but I can only gain experience by going for it. doing things badly is good.#it makes sense that I'm scared to face criticism. I've faced my whole community against me.#I've been stuck at someone's house debating scripture for hours with a migraine and no food. I think that was mildly traumatic for me.#but in most cases I am physically safe and the physical fear is irrational. I can work on this with some gentle exposure therapy.#but I need to bring together the effort to organize my thoughts and the bravado to hold my ground in an argument#and I can only build up this confidence with practice. I need to write. I need to do public speaking.#I'd need a platform for speaking (I'd hate to do a podcast or vlog but it'd be good for me)#but I should write! why am I not writing more? I need to write. writing is the way forward#several years ago I was in such deep despair with life that in order to survive I told myself#that I just had to survive. I didn't have to achieve anything or prove myself in any way as long as I stayed alive#and I went to grad school in Georgia not because I saw a path to a career in biblical studies but because school made me want to be alive#(extremely bizarre case of grad school not being the problem. I know.)#I know I missed a lot of benefits I could've had if I'd been mentally healthy when I went. but it's okay because it kept me going#I can go back to school or not go back. do biblical studies or do something else. I don't have big expectations for myself#but as my mental health improves it occurs to me that I COULD do more if only I believed it was worth the effort#I don't need to fear failure when the alternative was not even attempting it#I need to write. I need to write. I need to write.#I'm thinking I might start a newsletter or blog or something. some Bible stuff and some church/social commentary. just kind of open ended.
5 notes
¡
View notes
Text
oh chara dreemurr, weâre really in it now
#guys who see themself as the literal devil incarnate#who honestly just need to smoke a little weed#not that chara shouldâve smoked weed they were like 10#but like if they had lived longer#they would smoke weed#thatâs why my Kris is a pothead#keeps them from drawing up plans of murder suicide#jokes aside if Kris wasnât nonverbal I think theyâd be a monologuer like chara#kris sounds like uh Yuri lowenthal part 1 sasuke to me in my head#chara voice: oh isnât this what it means to be âhumanâ. I flinch at the word. my skin crawls at the acknowledgement of how I was born: pity#that my new family is cursed with the knowledge of me myself and I. asriel: yo nigga u want a blunt#chara: thank you dear brother I am normal now and I like being alive letâs not traumatize our parents and each other haha#if they smoked 1 (one) marijuana I believe that so much wouldâve been avoided#jk but I do think toriel be smokin elven moongrass#I think she grows her own and used to when she was younger but stopped when she was queen#and it took a few more dead kids for her to start doing it again#sheâs definitely doing it when frisk falls down but I think leaves that behind in the ruins#sheâs definitely an alcoholic tho. I think itâs slightly better in deltarune but not by much#I think she drinks and gets really upset whenever sheâs not busy or with Kris#but I think itâs like. once every month so sheâs âtechnicallyâ functioning but if she misses a day sheâs fucked for the rest of the month#anyway I want alphys carnally
3 notes
¡
View notes
Text
tonight was a weird night i sometimes forget how intense it can feel to be confronted by someones morals that are so drastically different from yours. truly endeared by the fact that i got a lecture on fiction affecting reality from a person in a marvel shirt though. tbh its kinda like they're experiencing the same thought processes i had like 3 or so years ago that led to me being like this so its whatever
#even if they dont ever come to the same conclusions as me thats fine i know how to have friendships w people who dont agree w me lol#but it was such a weird time. also like i donttt have any knowledge on this persons past experiences or trauma so i cant say anything#but its always weird having someone tell you what counts as a 'tragic backstory' excludes certain traumatic experiences from your own youth#additionally always weird having someone talk to me about irredeemability. like man ill forgive nearly anything#the parts where it got onto irl morals were. Hm. Sigh#genuinely so glad this person hasnt had the feminism bullied out of them bc i love when people are passionate abt womens value and respect#thats nice among everything else
2 notes
¡
View notes
Text
There's a lot of conversations to be had around the current influx of Americans to Xiaohongshu (RedNote/Little Red Book) ahead of the TikTok ban, many of which are better articulated by more knowledgeable people than me. And for all the fun various parties of both nationalities seem to having with memes and wholesome interactions, it's undoubtedly true that there's also some American entitlement and exoticization going on, which sucks. But a sentiment I've seen repeatedly online is that, if it's taken actually speaking to Chinese people and viewing Chinese content for Americans to understand that they've been propagandized to about China and its people, then that just proves how racist they are, and I want to push back on that, because it strikes me as being a singularly reductive and unhelpful framing of something far more complex.
Firstly: while there's frequently overlap between racism and xenophobia, the distinction between them matters in this instance, because the primary point of American propaganda about China is that Communism Is Fundamentally Evil And Unamerican And Never Ever Works, and thinking a country's government sucks is not the same as thinking the population is racially inferior. The way most Republicans in particular talk about China, you'd think it was functionally indistinguishable from North Korea, which it really isn't. Does this mean there's no critique to be made of either communism in general or the CCP? Absolutely not! But if you've been told your whole life that communist countries are impoverished, corrupt and dangerous because Communism Never Works, and you've only really encountered members of the Chinese diaspora - i.e., people whose families left China, often under traumatic circumstances, because they thought America would be better or safer - rather than Chinese nationals, then no: it's not automatically racist to be surprised that their daily lives and standard of living don't match up with what you'd assumed. Secondly: TikTok's userbase skews young. While there's certainly Americans in their 30s and older investigating Xiaohongshu, it seems very reasonable to assume that the vast majority are in their teens or twenties - young enough that, barring a gateway interest in something like C-dramas, danmei or other Chinese cultural products, and assuming they're not of Chinese descent themselves, there's no reason why they'd know anything about China beyond what they've heard in the news, or from politicians, or from their parents, which is likely not much, and very little firsthand. But even with an interest in China, there's a difference between reading about or watching movies from a place, and engaging firsthand, in real time, with people from that place, not just through text exchanges, but in a visual medium that lets you see what their houses, markets, shopping centers, public transport, schools, businesses, infrastructure and landmarks look like. Does this mean that what's being observed isn't a curated perspective on China as determined both by Xiaohongshu's TOU and the demographic skewing of its userbase? Of course not! But that doesn't mean it isn't still a representative glimpse of a part of China, which is certainly more than most young Americans have ever had before.
Thirdly: I really need people to stop framing propaganda as something that only stupid bigots fall for, as though it's possible to natively resist all the implicit cultural biases you're raised with and exist as a perfect moral being without ever having to actively challenge yourself. To cite the sacred texts:
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/478b32266d7f9c320a03cd23ea2e7353/8e7179565858c16e-60/s400x600/7115436d41172eea005b96e355ccd8b62e15bea5.jpg)
Like. Would the world be a better place if everyone could just Tell when they're being lied to and act accordingly? Obviously! But that is extremely not how anything actually works, and as much as it clearly discomforts some to witness, the most common way of realizing you've been propagandized to about a particular group of people is to interact with them. Can this be cringe and awkward and embarrassing at times? Yes! Will some people inevitably say something shitty or rude during this process? Also yes! But the reality is that cultural exchange is pretty much always bumpy to some extent; the difficulties are a feature, not a bug, because the process is inherently one of learning and conversation, and as individual people both learn at different rates and have different opinions on that learning, there's really no way to iron all that out such that nobody ever feels weird or annoyed or offput. Even interactions between career diplomats aren't guaranteed smooth sailing, and you're mad that random teenagers interacting through a language barrier in their first flush of enthusiasm for something new aren't doing it perfectly? Come on now.
Fourthly: Back before AO3 was banned in China, there was a period where the site was hit with an influx of Chinese users who, IIRC, were hopping over when one of their own fansites got shut down, which sparked a similar conversation around differences in site etiquette and how to engage respectfully. Which is also one of the many things that makes the current moment so deeply ironic: the US has historically criticized China for exactly the sort of censorship and redaction of free speech that led to AO3 being banned, and yet is now doing the very same thing with TikTok. Which is why what's happening on Xiaohongshu is, IMO, such an incredible cultural moment: because while there are, as mentioned, absolutely relevant things to be said about (say) Chinese censorship, US-centrism, orientalism and so on, what's ultimately happening is that, despite - or in some sense because of - the recent surge in anti-Chinese rhetoric from US politicians, a significant number of Americans who might otherwise never have done so are interacting directly with Chinese citizens in a way that, whatever else can be said of it, is actively undermining government propaganda, and that matters.
What it all most puts me in mind of, in fact, is a quote from French-Iranian novelist and cartoonist Marjane Satrapi, namely:
âThe difference between you and your government is much bigger than the difference between you and me. And the difference between me and my government is much bigger than the difference between me and you. And our governments are very much the same.â
And at this particular moment in history, this strikes me as being a singularly powerful realization for Americans in particular to have.
#tiktok ban#xiaohongshu#culture#cultural exchange#censorship#propaganda#politics#US politics#china#america
3K notes
¡
View notes