#you know who gerald never mentions in his journal? eggman
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
how much do you think it weighed on Eggman's mind learning his grandfather, whom he based some of his life and ideology on, in the end wanted to destroy all humans, destroy the earth... that, Eggman, his own grandson was on?
#i know we sort of got a reflection at the end credits of sa2 but it was short and i still think about this#surely didn't care about his sons either by the end if the journal has anything to say about that#idk i just really think about those memos from frontiers sometimes as well#they really made me think about the feelings and stuff between Eggman Gerald and Maria and also by extension Shadow#and then you add Sage into the mix now#and the JOURNALLLLL oh my gosh the journal#you know who gerald never mentions in his journal? eggman#you know who he does mention? his kids and maria and shadow and maria's unnamed sister#gerald mentions maria's sister tested negative but you know who he never mentions regarding that?#i could write a whole essay on an analysis of the robotnik family and stuff#i want eggman and shadow to talk#shadow and eggman both live in his shadow and memory in a way#they also sort of both live in maria's if eggman's frontiers memos mean anything#shadow is the legacy of the robotnik family in a way from his relationships with maria and gerald#eggman doesn't even get called the name robotnik anymore a lot of the time i wonder how that impacts things#and then separately (obv not game canon stuff) with SONIC MOVIE 3 STUFF yeahhhh#watch this turn into a joint sonic and splatoon account#not splatoon#sth#sonic#sonic the hedgehog#sth eggman#dr eggman#ivo robotnik
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Regarding Gerald in Sonic 3
(SPOILERS!!)
I've been thinking about how Gerald Robotnik was depicted in the third Sonic movie, and I have some observations.
I'm sure some fans have been comparing Gerald as shown in the film versus the games and taken note of not only how much sillier he is in the movie, but also how he's depicted as being considerably more villainous.
There are a couple things to consider though. In the games (especially since Shadow Generations) the majority of what we see of Gerald is from before the tragedy on the ARK and losing Maria, and we only get brief bits of him after he lost his sanity.
However in the movie it's the exact opposite situation. Almost everything we see of Gerald in the film is after Maria's death and he's clearly lost his sanity. Not only that, but because Gerald in the film never got executed, he spent many decades in a prison cell, stewing in his despair and rage, becoming more and more bitter and deranged while also extending his lifespan to an unnatural length by dosing himself with chaos energy from Shadow's quill.
But you might say, "Gerald in the movie only saw Shadow as a tool and didn't love him." While there's evidence of that being true in the present day, there's little to suggest that's the case in the very brief bit we see of Gerald in the flashback he's shown in before Maria's death. I personally think Gerald did have a fondness for Shadow before the tragedy, likely through observing Maria's close friendship with him. When Gerald retrieves Maria and Shadow to flea the facility he refers to them both collectively as "children", meaning he possibly had a similar fondness for both of them. I think that after Maria's death though, Gerald's slipping sanity, disillusionment with humanity, and obsession with avenging Maria's death, probably made him lose sight of the love he once had for Shadow.
And there is even evidence of the same thing happening in the games, with Gerald treating Shadow as little more than a tool for his posthumous plan for genocidal vengeance, which would have ended with Shadow's death too. Gerald even tampered with Shadow's memories of Maria to ensure he'd carry out his plans.
There's also evidence in the games of Gerald having an ego similar to Eggman's, shown by him modeling the ARK to resemble his face. Gerald even sheepishly confessed in his journal he was being self indulgent when designing the ARK. So it would seem in the games Gerald does possess at least some of the negative traits shared with his grandson, though he's self aware of these flaws and tries to suppress them. Gerald in the movie however is at a point where he's way past caring, since he's already decided to destroy the earth and everyone on it, so he's just letting his freak flag fly. lol
So if Gerald hadn't been executed in the games, who knows how he might have turned out. Gerald being executed was probably a mercy, really...
And it should also be noted that Sega themselves even considered resurrecting Gerald as a villainous character in the early production of Shadow's solo game.
That actually brings me to another thing I was thinking about while watching the movie. In Sonic 3, they repeatedly emphasize how similar Eggman and Gerald are in appearance, quirks, skills, and even wearing near identical outfits at the end. Sonic even collectively refers to them both as "Eggmen".
This stood out to me because it reminded me of the Rush games where Eggman teamed up with Eggman Nega, a character that was near identical to Eggman, but having a greying mustache and a darker, more twisted personality.
As I've mentioned in previous posts, I've had a theory that the scrapped plot point of resurrecting Gerald as a villain is what led to the creation of the Eggman Nega character. So seeing Gerald as depicted in the movie was like seeing it all come full circle. lol
But anyway, yeah, this has been another stream of consciousness rant from me. Maybe you got something out of this, or maybe not. Oh well. lol
And just to make myself clear, I am NOT trying to argue that Gerald is a bad person in the games (at least before Maria died). If what I said came across like that, then I'm sorry, but that was definitely not my intention.
#sonic the movie 3 spoilers#sonic movie 3 spoilers#sonic the hedgehog 3 spoilers#sonic 3 spoilers#sonic the movie 3#sonic movie 3#sonic the hedgehog 3#sonic the movie#gerald robotnik#eggman nega#shadow the hedgehog#maria robotnik#sonic team#sonic#sth#sonic the hedgehog
80 notes
·
View notes