The Hobie Brown Punk Playbook - Anarchism & Hobie's Arc
A short series where I analyze the political, historical, musical, and romantic influences of Hobie Brown, and how it affects his arc, design, and character.
1) Anarchism 101 / 2) Punk 101 / 3) Hobie Characterization Guide (How to Write Hobie) /4) Punk & Hobie's Design / 5) Romance in the 70's
_______________________________________________
Why Hobie's Arc is the perfect metaphor for Anarchy and Anti-Establishment:
What is Anarchism?
What's an anarchist, and what makes Hobie one?
In most places, Anarchism is defined as:
a political theory advocating the abolition of hierarchical government and the organization of society on a voluntary, cooperative basis without recourse to force or compulsion.
Which means that, as an Anarchist, Hobie believes that all forms of authority that involves a hierarchal power should be abolished and destroyed.
Anarchists opposes any and all power structures in which a single person, class, or entity rules over a body of people.
Anarchism is a thought system that, at it's core, is anti-government, anti-monarchy and anti-cop. It's goal is to protect and highlight the importance of equality and community but also freedom and individuality as well.
Although many people assume anarchy is about chaos - and denying any and all structures - if anything, it’s actually the opposite.
Anarchy is about balance -
When we look at the definition of Anarchy, we can see two complimentary ideas. ______
The first is the 'advocating the abolition of hierarchical government' - which is the sentiment Anarchy is most known for. It's the opposition of power structures in which one class or group rules or gains privilege over another - cops and civilians, the government and citizens, Spider-people and the multiverse, Miguel and the Spider-people...etc.
For the purposes of this post, I'll call it the First Pillar of Anarchism, and it's the basis for one of Anarchism's foundational beliefs: direct action.
(Which Hobie is the king of)
The second idea is one often overlooked, but just as important, and I'll talk about how much it colors Hobie's characterization in a second.
The organization of society on a voluntary, cooperative basis. Anarchists believe in equality, and the power of the collective and working together as a unanimous unit.
But they also believe in freedom of choice, and the choice to be independent.
When working in large cooperative groups, there is the risk of a shared identity that may stifle or assimilate it's members. Just as much as Anarchists believe in unity and equality, they also believe that a society - or any group - should be voluntary. And that sticking out from the pack is okay and even encouraged.
They believe people reserve the right to not participate at all, and that it is their right to differ and challenge the pack, if they so want to.
In the perfect anarchist world and situation (in my opinion,) - No one rules over the collective, and the collective rules over no one.
When you put those two together you get Anarchy. A balance of community and self.
And although we don't live in an anarchist utopia, Anarchists are people who live life fighting for the equality and unity of others, as well as their independence and freedom to be who they are outside of others.
In short, An Anarchist is someone who believes in equality, community, freethinking, and most of all freedom of choice.
Starting to sound like anyone we know?
What makes Hobie the perfect Anarchist?
Hobie is Anarchy personified. Literally.
Hear me out.
When we look at the definition of Anarchism next to Hobie's actions, behavior, and beliefs - we can see the writers created Hobie and his arc to be anarchy in it's purest form.
Anarchy is described as:
a political theory advocating the abolition of hierarchical government and the organization of society on a voluntary, cooperative basis without recourse to force or compulsion.
Hobie only has roughly ten minutes of screentime, and I wrote (here) exactly how the writers squeeze meaning into (quite literally) every-line he has.
In every line and frame the writers are intent on having Hobie move towards the 2 specific goals and motives on Anarchism, backed by his punk and anarchist morals.
Firstly, he approaches Miles to advocate the abolition of Miguel's hierarchical society, emotionally and mentally encouraging Miles to oppose his authority.
All of Hobie's speaking lines are dedicated to this purpose - becoming an ally to Miles (and other Spider-people) and inspiring rebellion.
This is reflected by his opposition to the ideas of anomalies, and Miguel's rule.
I just wanna highlight, that when Hobie meets Miles - neither he nor Miles are aware that Miles intends to avoid his canon event.
At the point of their meeting, Hobie only knows that Miles has disrupted Pavitr's canon event, and that Miles himself in an anomaly.
Hobie opposes Miguel's hierachial society, his rule over the timeline and multiverse, and his use of force and threats of violence. By advocating for the abolition of Miguel's society and urging Miles' rebellion against Miguel, Hobie is directly engaging in the first pillar of Anarchism.
When Hobie's efforts pay off and Miles escapes Society capture, he's goal changes toward the second pillar.
Hobie recognizes Spider-Society does not operate on a voluntary, cooperative basis - as their canon events are mandatory by force and compulsion.
And because of this, he thinks ahead and uses his self-made watches in order for him, Gwen, and Miles to exercise their right of choice.
From the moment he quits, all of Hobie's behavior is dedicated to this purpose - getting Miles and Gwen out of the society, and helping Miles avoid his incoming canon event.
The Spider-Society is everything Anarchy stands against.
Anarchy stresses volunteered and cooperative effort for a reason.
I spoke earlier about how in cooperative groups, their is a risk of a shared identity within a group that forces assimilation and cooperation.
And Spider-Society is the perfect, and most literal example of this.
Spider-people are (literally) the 'same person'. Those in the Society are united by the shared identity of being Spider-people. This identity is mandatory for entry - and because Miguel ties canon events to the identity of a Spider-person, the canon events become compulsory and mandatory as well.
I mentioned before that at the time of meeting Miles, both he and Miles had no idea about Mile's incoming canon event. He, like Miles, only learns this when Miles announces that his dad is about to be captain - in front of Miguel.
When Miles escapes and Hobie quits, from that point on - despite the fact he's not fully shown on screen again - Hobie still manages to act on and stand by Anarchism. From then on, every single one of his actions is dedicated to opposing the involuntary, compulsory nature of canon and canon events.
Hobie interferes with the compulsive nature of canon by approaching Gwen's dad and speaking with him. He interferes with the involuntary nature of the Society's membership, by leaving Gwen the watch that allows her and Peter B. to leave, going AWOL.
___________________________________________________
As a character, Hobie is what is considered a insurgent. His purpose in the story and Miles' life is to inspire action and rebellion within him and the system.
And at his core, Hobie is meant to be a character that's meant to empower others - especially at their lowest point. That's what Anarchism, and Punk, is about.
Hobie is Anarchy personified.
Every one of his motives and lines are dedicated to it's purpose. Whether it's his first scene disarming Miles with humor and allyship, or him deliberately copying Society technology.
With every word and frame, Hobie inspires rebellion - defying hierarchy, and empowering choice.
With the people closest to them, he literally put the power of choice in their hands, whether it be Miles' palms, or the watch Gwen held.
In the battle against the Spider-Society - an organization of hierarchy, control, compulsion, and force - the writers chose to have Hobie's weapon of choice be Anarchy.
And it's really clear they see Anarchy for what it is - a system and tool of empowerment, compassion, and freedom.
And honestly, I can't think of any other words that can describe Hobie better (or than hot).
Hobie Brown is literally walking Anarchy idc idc you can't tell me different bye.
Find Part 2 - Punk 101 here!
__________
also have a couple more ideas and drafts of these, mainly examining: Punk and what makes Hobie punk, his design inspiration and fashion, the 70s history behind him, romance in the 70s, etc so uh yeah
778 notes
·
View notes