#michael is toysnhk

[reblog-house]

EDIT august 3rd: I NO LONGER BELIEVE IN THIS THEORY. It got disproven by many videos and I don't wanna spread misinformation. However, this vid did inspire me to see Mike as a helper through FNAF 1 and 2. Now, I'm more of a fan of the theory about there being Two protagonists: Mike for the shifts, and Cassidy (not CC), as playing the videogames. GiBi explores it in a video and it's very interesting. Give it a watch. But anyway, I'm keeping this post for archival purposes, even if I no longer believe in it.

Here it goes:

Saw a video that completely changed my outlook on this stupid FNAF lore. CC is named Cassidy, there's only one ghost in Golden Freddy, and Cassidy isn't The One Your Should Not Have Killed. Michael is. MICHAEL. And my mind was blown holy SHITTTT. I literally cannot interact with fanon anymore because I like this so much and feel it makes so much sense. Michael as TOYSNHK makes much more sense than a random spirit... Why would a random spirit be more vengeful towards William than any of the other MCI victims, and more vengeful than Michael, the son who dedicated his entire undeath to finding his father and making him pay. He fits the bill better and-

I should just. Link to the video.

There we go.

I don't agree with all the points (such as SL's placement in the timeline, after the first game, and how that affects Michael's relationship with his father), but the Cassidy thing and MICHAEL. BEING. TOYSNHK. BROKE MY MIND. The first one, I was like "no, but CC is Evan. GF has two souls. I like that theory", but they tackled it so well it convinced me.

And the TOYSNHK thing... It Just Makes Sense. William indirectly killed Michael, sending him to free his sister knowing fully well what could happen to him and ready to let him die to bring her back. And (something I couldn't have ever thought of myself), he repossessed his own body. It wasn't the Remnant of Ennard (the video explains it), but himself, unknowingly tying himself back to this world to deal with a Very Unfinished Business, which he then dedícates himself to.

And afterwards, he makes William live through everything he had to go through, all those years. Again, and again, and again, and again. He was the One William should Not have killed if he wanted to be left in peace, because out of anyone else, Michael reanimated himself just to deal with him, and now, feels the need to make him pay even in the world beyond.

Old Man Consequences is Henry telling Michael to take a break and free himself too, because he's just torturing himself by not letting go and allowing William to get tortured by his own demons. Until Michael is ready to leave and move on Old Man Consequences, Henry, will wait for him, patiently.

I just. I love that. I really really love that. Fuck.

((I also really love how they explained what had happened to Henry. God that's smart.))

Anyway.

Call me a TOYSNHK Michael truther now.

[hearts401]

Golden Freddy Friends

[shinewonder]

pocket murderer

[the-elusive-bones]

all Im gonna say is: controversial opinion here:

Michael is the one you should not have killed

yes this will be in my AU

yes it will be convoluted

but idc

if you want to know WHY I think Michael is the one you should not have killed, reblog or ask lol, but it came with a recent revelation from Dual Process Theory on Youtube, and has been putting what I have been thinking but couldn’t put into words or really how

[0-perfect-party-0]

sick of keeping this to myself

this song. THIS SONG. feels so ucn toysnhk/vengeful spirit coded (mostly). just LOOK at these lyrics

Now do you hate me? Are you afraid of me? Are you able to feel culpability? Come forth and kill me Bow down and worship me Take your time all we have is eternity Now with a new start Broken and torn apart Nothing in me resembles a human heart My name is unknown Something I've never told On my own I declare "I don't wanna go home"

do i even have to say anything more. the spirit (whoever you believe it is), finally having power over william, making him face (and be repeatedly killed by) his mistakes, fully intending to keep him in that torture forever. even if they become just as sadistic as the killer himself. even if they never rest (or even want to rest). they also have the animatronics refer to them only as "the one you should not have killed" instead of their actual name. honestly i could pick each lyric shown above one by one and explain how it relates, but i'm pretty sure you can see it for yourself

[treezxu]

is this quality content?

[minty-the-demon]

A couple of days ago, I watched the FNAF theory video made by Dual Process Theory. I love the interpretation of Michael being the vengeful spirit! Michael getting neglected, manipulated and becoming a corpse due to his dad putting him in a deadly situation would make Michael a great candidate for the vengeful spirit/toysnhk. I wish there was a fan game based off that premise.

[idsfantasy]

Howdy Hey, ID! I wanted your opinion on a theory of mine! I'm only kind of mentioning it since you answered and ask that's kind... added evidence (PQ being labled 'It's Me') So based on The Princess in PQ being labeled as Cassidy at some point in SB I believe that Cassidy must be in the PQ Game. Here's the 'Ify' part of my theory:

I think Cassidy may be the Crying Childs name. I mean in the Logbook CC seemingly alter's text while The one you should not have killed uses faded text, and we find the name in a Word Search, which could be altered text. This means we A)Don't know TOYSNHK's name (That name should theoretically be found with the Foxy grid), but Also B) CC's a girl. Because as time has gone on Cassidy has always been represented as a girl. (Usually with Dark hair and Green eyes) We also have 'It's Me' being particularly linked to CC usually toward Micheal. So if 'It's Me' is the Princess's code name, and 'It's me' is used by CC, and the Princess was once named Cassidy, wouldn't this be the strongest evidence to connect that name with that character, rather than TOYSNHK?

Any theories are valid until disproven with HARD evidence by the Developers, but this just seems to make the most sense to me and i wanted a second opinion, as this means CC has been trying to get rid of GLitchtrap (a form of William in some compacity) in the PQ games.

There are a few reasons I don't think Cassidy is CC (other than the fact that he's referred to in FNAF 4 as Mike's brother and Gregory seems to be much more connected to CC than the Princess imo).

For one, in the novel trilogy, Cassidy was one of the 5 MCI kids, in addition to Susie, Gabriel, Fritz, and Michael Brooks as the Golden Freddy spirit. To me it makes sense that, as Jeremy is in the games instead of Michael but the other names we're given all remain the same, the Cassidy in the games associated with Golden Freddy's would be the same Cassidy, just filling a different role.

It's Me is typically a Golden Freddy thing, but technically it's never specified who is saying it. It could be both CC and the VS. Could be one or the other. It also appears on Foxy's Out of Order sign. For PQ, I took it more as just "ah, ghost kid time and Cassidy's name was in the files and the Princess is Gold therefore Golden Freddy." There's also how Princess is actively trying to yeet Glitchtrap/William and has a conversation with red old man sprite which reminds me of Old Man Consequences. To me, this implies that Cassidy is the Vengeful Spirit being talked to by OMC and trying to attack William, as that's what the VS's whole deal is.

Additionally, with the Logbook, the faded text is the one putting "my name" all over the place to leave clues for the crossword puzzle, and CC is implied to be the altered text.

There's probably some other stuff I could try to remember but I have a final I need to take lol. Hope this helps!

[peachcoloredtears]

Michael being a babysitter to two ghost children…I’d be tired too

[emeraldart]

He’s here and he’s always watching.

The One You Should Not Have Killed.

(Alt versions under the cut)

[zhenjia]

The thing about Cassidy possessing logbook or Cassidy possessing mike in my main au is actually based on my own theory.

The theory is :

Cassidy is posessing the logbook and also can Possessing or at least Accessing mike's memory.. why I'm say it's Mike's memory? It because crying child actually has no idea about himself that maybe his memory's lost . If you tell me it's CC's memory because he share the animatronic with Cassidy I'll tell you where you went wrong.

>Ralph or phone guy seems to have been put in golden freddy suit as well as that woman (ugh I forgot her name) too that mean they connect with that too. And the real golden freddy can't move. That means basically if the costume appears it's not the real one. Also with the many easter eggs about the place being haunted And most of the things related to Golden Freddy and other supernatural things are the possibility that the spirits of the dead in the Golden Freddy costumes or the corpses outside the 4 animatronics are Unable to move their bodies in the costumes so they turned to haunt the place itself That explains why Cassidy and the crying child were able to move to the logbook while the others and even Charlie were trapped in animatronic

> and like I said before if Cassidy can access CC's memory why she need cc to remember why she has these memory that the owner of the memory forget about? Even in fnaf world it's really that hard to get cc memories back.

> The memory that cassidy have also included Mike's memory. About his fav childhood toy ( it's not cc because we know cc don't have the toy and he still kids when he die when the toy apear in the experiment room in fnaf 5 ) also does he still talk to you when Cassidy talk to cc it's actually Also leads to fredbear with a walkie talkie (, maybe that's not the canon ending but it could possibly happen. because why we have that ending) also that Do any of these toys look familure to you? or Do any of these belong to you? Draw and then "do you miss them" . It hinted that Cassidy maybe can access mike is memory but Mike's memory Basically as messy as cc memory but easier to understand.Not only does it help with CC's memory but also Mike's memory.

In this case I believe that fnaf 1 and 3 happened in same place.This could explain how mike heard ralph's voice in fnaf 4. And mike started drawing 3 animatronics with ghost costumes.

Also Cassidy and mike I think aware of each other Mike's tally mark also helping Cassidy with her name (the grave in page 15 with my name) the four tally is for crying child (he answer 4 question)and other for Cassidy. Also not stop by that there is also Mike's hint that lead us to Cassidy next code name. That mean they know each other.

The last thing this maybe debunked molten mci theory and I want to say its vengeful Cassidy theory.the vengeful spirit also in the fnaf 3 fire and even say "they burn us" like know who burn them. Its I say maybe debunked molten mci theory because that mean Cassidy and crying child are still in the logbook and following mike. When we know but molten Freddy never appear in fnaf 3. And William got killed after broke that 4 animatronic (yes 4 because golden Freddy like I say just suit and William never destroy golden Freddy but the soul following the other ) he can't make the animatronic again because he dead ) and also it can't happened in FNAF 2 cause he It really seems like he's being chased by the cops and he planing kill other kids. The funtime then has been created before the mci (because it can't be happening after that because He is on the run from the cops) so yes he made killing animatronic just for his daughter. And maybe there is dci. But I don't want explain it right now cause we talk about Cassidy and mike.

Cassidy maybe still following mike or maybe controling mike in pizzasim. Because the mini game in that game Especially midnight motorists actually hint us that cassidy still here or some aware ghost who want helping people remember is still here. For me as run away kids mike believer I believe that this is the hint that maybe there something that mike forget or he try to forget and Cassidy here to helping like before.. the vengeful spirit also in FNAF 6 fire. That mean she still here but still helping mike with his problem (not gonna forget that MM wood and The road to the OMC place is honestly the same place) and maybe Cassidy also helping or dealing with other kids memory like Susie or Charlie

In the end I believe that ucn duo and double soul Michael is interesting theory

At first I made this theory I just think it's just a joke.

I don't really think this theory seriously because yeah I made this just for joke then I realized this theory have some evidence

[sapphiredrop]

Fnaf Swap au: Afton kids

Created this au with my friend @starspindle who also posted about this au too so make sure to check it out!

Anyways who swaps with who.

Henry- William

William- Henry

Charlie- Michael

Michael- Elizabeth

Elizabeth- Charlie

Sammy- CC/Evan

CC/Evan- TOYSNHK

So basically, Henry sent Charlie to the SL bunker because in this au, he liked Mike more than his own kids and well you know what happens next. Also I like the idea of Henry murdering CC/Evan out of jealousy of William because you know, he still has a living son.

Also we had the cool idea of Elizabeth possessing Sun instead of the puppet.

This au’s kinda a work in progress so Yee.

[hearts401]

@jasminetea1234 this one gets its own post bc i finished it <333

[shinewonder]

what if.. mikepurg, but toysnhk is just a representation of cc made up by mike because of his guilt and the lake is a door to the actual afterlife and mike forgives himself and drowning ending is heaven and *gets murdered*

[puhpandas]

Garrett theory:

so you know how serial killers can be sentimental in a way? like theyll keep a trophy of their kill? i think thats why William kept Garretts plane.

why? i personally think that Garrett was Williams first kill. like ever. its so far from the Pizzeria. its in a random camping spot in the woods. it was so sudden. like it was a spur of the moment thing. he saw the opportunity and just. did it

and then we went as far as to keep the kids toy and give it to his own daughter. its horrible

but its JUST like Charlie Emily. im an Evan Afton was the first death believer, but Charlie can just as easily be. no matter what, Charlie was Williams first murder, and then he kept going.

with that in mind, lets look at the fact that Golden Freddy is inhabited by TOYSNHK. aka the movieverse Cassidy. that slot is filled.

Its Me appeared on the mirror in front of Mike. the puppets music box played during the credits. immediately after 'COME FIND ME' is spelled out with the fnaf 2 minigame robotic letters.

mike himself even said Garrett felt closer in the pizzeria! theres a lot of evidence right now pointing towards Garrett being the puppet. he was the first kill. the first before the MCI, like Charlie

not to mention how the Schmidts seem to be replacing the Emilys in a way. the family name vs family name type thing. dont forget theres also that theory of mikes dad being Henry.

but back to my other point about Evan and Charlie, and how either of them could be the first based on what you believe, it still counts. garrett takes both evan AND charlies roles in the story. like how Vanessa takes Vannys and Michael Aftons. Like Mike schmidt takes michael aftons but also the story of an innocent family who are victims of williams killings by losing a loved one.

Garrett is both the lost first kill of the 'good' family of the story (the emilys in gameverse), AND he has the role of Evan with mike, with mikes guilt and the idea that he can avenge him or save him in a way. hes the Its Me. hes the puppet

(the family (afton + schmidt) duality also works because of the symmetry theme in the movie. also Garrett would be two game characters combined, also applying. just like how the characters i mentioned above also have combinations of two game characters as their own)

anyway this universe is super intriguing and awesome and i cant wait to see what theyre gonna do next

[astroreoreoreoreoreoreoreo]

Idk if any fnaf fans follow me but omg. I was watching a video yesterday where someone analyzed the lore behind all of the UCN voicelines and I realized something.

CC is controlling the Nightmares.

Two lines in particular seem to support this theory:

1. "I was always hiding in your shadow" -N. Freddy

- implies the speaker had some sort of relationship with Afton (assuming afton is the player) that The One You Should Not Have Killed (TOYSNHK) wouldn't have

- who wanted to hide all the time? Yeah! That's right! CC!!!!!

2. "We know who our friends are, and you are not one of them." -Nightmare Fredbear

- come on. It's a blatant reference to cc and his toys. Also a young boy's voice can be heard behind his lines (this line in particular, I can't really hear it in the other ones)

Also, the Nightmares were unique to CC. No one else would be able to "give them flesh" as multiple of them say, because no one else knew what they looked like. Even if you subscribe to the idea that they're the results of nightmare gas or illusion discs, Afton still would have had no way of knowing what exactly his son was seeing and therefore could not "give them flesh." And the same applies to TOYSNHK. (Assuming that they're Andrew or Cassidy and not CC.)

(This is kind of thrown off by the existence of that one Fredbear drawing in the logbook. That drawing drives me crazy. How the heck did Michael know???)

Now, the girl I was watching (I'll link her video, it was really good) thought that it being CC couldn't be the case because his soul was freed during the Happiest Day mini game. However, I was under the impression that the bad ending of FNAF 3 is canon. (If I'm wrong please let me know.) And besides that, according to FNAF 6 all the souls were freed, and yet it's implied (specifically by Withered Bonnie's "what is this new prison? is it me trapped? Or is it you? Perhaps it is us both" line, all of Marionette's lines, and Withered Chica's lines) that some of the original spirits are still here and trapped because of TOYSNHK's unwillingness to let Afton go.

I'm not saying I think CC is aware of exactly who he is torturing. But I think if I were a child who lived in torment all my life (because dad left me alone to fend for myself against my brother) and then died because of one of my father's creations, I would be a little miffed at him too. And even if he doesn't remember exactly how he died I think agony could lead him to blame Afton and willingly torture him too. I think if anyone deserves to be super vengeful it's that poor kid. Idk maybe it's obvious that CC is my favorite human FNAF character and Golden Freddy is my favorite animatronic.

(Blame my friend @gamusgoober for this. his amazing FNAF in real time video reawakened my fnaf hyperfixation)

^video I watched :>