#lotr book spoilers
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Spoiler for lotr book 1 fellowship of the ring chapters 3 and 4 (I did doodles)
.
.
.
Chapter 3! I thought Gandalf would be there by now but he hasn’t so I drew a Pippin
They’re a moving
Eminem and Bilbo have never been seen in the same room together, think about that
The group in big tree, I draw them soup
When people say elves I think of Santa’s Elves sooo yeah
Hobbits sleeping in piles>>>
Chapter 4 (it was hilarious when Frodo and Sam were afraid of dogs)
Sam and Pippin dramatic alcoholics confirmed?
A llooonnngg journey
Baby Frodo stealing mushrooms
#artwork#drawing#traditional art#art#artists on tumblr#illistration#sketch#illustration#doodle#lotr fandom#lotr sam#lotr pippin#lotr frodo#lotr books#lotr#lotr fanart#lotr fellowship#frodo baggins#sam gamgee#pippin took#lord of the rings fandom#lord of the rings fanart#lord of the rings#lotr book spoilers#lotr spoilers#lotr doodles#is this a shitpost?
61 notes
·
View notes
Text
I might elaborate on these individual incidents on later posts but upon multiple viewings I can finally put words to why I hated the characterizations of multiple characters in the LotR movie trilogy.
It is because PJ & Co. 's favourite method of storytelling is to pull down side characters to build up their own heroes.
And I'm talking about the 'holy' trinity of Sam, Aragorn and Thorin.
Frankly, book readers should've seen it coming from a mile away.
So let's start with Sam. Raise your hand if you've ever seen any fan trumpeting that Sam is the 'real' hero. And nine out of ten, these fans were introduced into LotR through the movies. Congratulations Pete, you've succeeded!
Now before touching the Tolkien letter 'supporting' this idea (where if you read the full letter you'll understand Sam is only more of a chief hero when compared to a very specific character and that character is not Frodo *coughAragorncough*), I would like to draw attention to one simple fact - is there any other major character in the trilogy that has more of his flaws ignored, covered-up or outright repurposed to become a good quality? Because I come up with nothing.
Sam is the quintessential hobbit. He represents all their best traits - that assured loyalty, the steadfast friendship, the simple appreciation for nature. But he is also a representative of all of their worst traits - the closed-mindedness, the blind adherence to hierarchy and the prejudice against the lowly and the unknown.
But Sam does none of that!
Yeah, you'd be correct - if you only watched the movies. That is precisely the point.
The absolute heart of LotR is Frodo's journey, but Frodo is a 'terrible' male lead for a Fantasy themed action adventure film. He is a middle-aged man who sets out on a selfless journey to save the world (but not for himself). He doesn't have a dramatic character arc, majority of his battles are internal and require monologues, and the only visible sign of his burden is completely up to the polish of the individual actor's performance. For the epic type of film PJ planned, Frodo is a nightmare.
But there is an easy solution for this - Frodo is accompanied by Sam throughout the entire journey. Sam, unlike Frodo, has underdog written all over him. It is easy to make a character arc about a nobody becoming a somebody. He has a major battle one-to-one against a giant spider. He is allowed a large variety of emotions that don't require depth (excepting key moments) because he is meant to be simple-minded.
So what does PJ & Co. do?
They make Sam the main lead, of course. The beginning chapters are understandably condensed, but Sam still gets his 'dropping eaves on Mr. Frodo' part of the story untouched, whereas all of Frodo's planning, all of Merry's intelligence, and Pippin and Fatty's contributions were all cut out.
We soon meet Strider, and immediately Sam's foolhardiness is front and centre in the book. He looks down upon this lowly ranger and almost interrogates him only to have Strider illustrate how such behaviour could have easily gotten Sam and Frodo killed. It is Frodo who speaks with wisdom and questions Strider in a more moderate way.
And this entire farce of speaking out of turn happens again when they meet Faramir. Sam is not only not wise, his is foolish enough to make the exact same mistake twice. And similarly Faramir reprimands him and tells him not to speak before Frodo has spoken.
But instead of highlighting these incidents as a flaw Sam should learn to grow from, both times in the movies PJ instead frames the incidents as Sam being justified in his words and defence of Frodo. His bravado is praised as being a loyal friend, instead of the foolish actions they are.
But even with erasing Sam's faults, there is still a problem - Frodo. Frodo's relationship with Sam has become closer than master/servant, but there is still an inate imbalance (more due to Frodo's age and wisdom than anything else) to frame it as just simple friendship.
Personally I feel it is like Sam views Frodo as his senpai, his leading light. And Frodo wishes to guide Sam to learn new things, because Sam's presence as a quintessential hobbit is so much like home that he remains a constant comfort to Frodo no matter the burden of the One Ring.
But Frodo and Sam having a senpai-kouhai relationship is troublesome, because Frodo never leaves. He is the one Sam consistently depends on to lead him, and book!Sam's most major growth actually occurs after Frodo has left for the Undying Lands and Sam grows to become a capable Mayor.
So naturally Frodo has to be weakened to let Sam shine. Firstly, the age difference is removed completely, even going in the opposite direction - Sam is now older than Frodo and cares for him like an elder brother or butler. When faced with dangerous situations like the Nazgul or the troll, Sam is the fearless one instead of Frodo. Sam's wariness is always affirmed by the narrative and Frodo's wisdom in discerning people is putdown as blind kindness.
Nowhere is this more obvious than the Frodo-Sam-Gollum relationship.
In the book, Sam's wariness towards Gollum stems from both the creature's poor reputation, but also from petty jealousy. The threat of betrayal from Gollum is real, yes, but throughout the book Frodo has it under control. He never trusts Gollum more than he needed to, and in fact was winning Gollum's trust with his wisdom, kindness and fair-minded treatment.
But Sam had different ideas. Before Gollum, Sam had always been the closest to Mr. Frodo, not only because of their close relationship, but also because Sam sees himself as the most useful to Frodo. Sure, Merry and Pippin and friends, but neither can serve Mr. Frodo the way he can. Until Gollum.
Gollum is brought in as an indispensable guide and Sam immediately feels threatened. He doesn't actually physically threaten Gollum, but instead resorts to childish name-calling to put Gollum down. He constantly wished to assert dominance over Gollum, to show he is closer to Frodo no matter how good a job Gollum does. Sam basically just wants to 'put him in his lowly place'.
It is this relentless bullying that ends up destroying Gollum's redemption (something also in a Tolkien letter, but Sam fans won't bring this one up), and forces the destruction of the ring to be 'an act of God' instead of Gollum's own will.
This is the biggest flaw in Sam - that he is quick to judge and slow to pity, a trait highly unsuitable for a ringbearer, much less the 'main' hero. This is also the main reason for Frodo's character change and the dynamics change in the relationship between all three.
It is extremely difficult to just cut out all the antagonistic actions Sam has taken against Gollum, so instead the path PJ & Co. took is to 'make Sam right'.
Instead of Frodo being in control and trying to make Sam and Gollum get along, make it that Frodo is the helpless one and being pulled in two different directions. Sam, being the hero, is correct. And Gollum naturally has to be wrong. Frodo, because of the 'evil influence of the Ring' chooses wrongly and believes Gollum, giving rise to the infamous "Sam, go home" scene.
This change of the relationship dynamics both strengthens Sam's moral position as well as weakens Frodo's wisdom. And to PJ & Co. that is a good thing, because now Sam is truly the main lead.
I'll think I continue Aragorn and Thorin another day, but you can be assured that PJ & Co. just uses the same tricks again *coughFaramirandThranduilcough*.
#lord of the rings movies#lotr book spoilers#frodo baggins#in defense of Frodo#samwise gamgee#quintessential hobbit#damn but i really hate the characterizations in these movies#if you think Sam is flawless#read the damn book again
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Rings of Power 2.07
Neither of us was strong enough. There might not be anyone in Middle-earth who is. But perhaps, the Elves need only remember that it is not strength that overcomes darkness, but light. Armies may rise, hearts may fail, yet still, light endures and is mightier than strength. For in its presence, all darkness must flee. Namarië.
#trop#tropedit#lotr#lotredit#tolkien#the rings of power#rings of power#sauron#annatar#celebrimbor#galadriel#elrond#gil galad#arondir#silvergifting#silmarillion#trop spoilers#mine#gif:trop#okay okay the show is officially starting to get good and interesting. i can see they are finally giving the characters some more depth#sauron was great this ep. elrond was on point. and galadriel finally felt like her old self in the books - wise and guiding and thinking#and of course the whole tragedy of seduction madness and manipulation of celebrimbor! *chefs kiss*#im not strong enough either to say no to the pull of sauron and lotr works OTL
394 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power S2.E1 "Elven Kings Under the Sky"
#trop 2x01#trop season 2#the rings of power#sauron#annatar#charlie vickers#lotr#lotr books#lord of the rings#my gifset#my gifs#rings of power#trop spoilers#the rings of power spoilers#halbrand
338 notes
·
View notes
Text
i present: my extremely long and highly specific list of book recs for my fellow rings of power fans
#apparently this is what i do on my off days from work when i'm sitting on the couch recovering from a covid vaccine haha#also: there is a book on this list for a plot twist that inspired the same level of glee as the sauron reveal#but i can't say which one since it is a BIG SPOILER. but if you know you know#pie says stuff#pie reads#rings of power#the rings of power#trop#rop#lotr#banewreaker#gods of the wyrdwood#deathless#dark rise#dreadful#the sword defiant#for the wolf#long live evil#witch king#sleepless#dark lord of derkholm#the children of gods and fighting men#silver in the wood#winter be my shield#godkiller#black sun#the stardust thief#the unspoken name#good grief that's a lot of books why did i tag them all
104 notes
·
View notes
Text
He’s alright guys. Brimby’s with me. He’s safe.
#😭😭😭😭😭😭😭#I genuinely dont know if I want them to follow the books regarding his… future#like I’d be crazy impressed if they actually did bc that’d take guts but I don’t know if I van stomach seeing him gaslighted & manipulated#and then going through such brutal physical abuse#celebrimbor#sauron#lotr#trop#trop spoilers
72 notes
·
View notes
Text
So I'm assuming the top image is Círdan in the First Age, possibly during the youth of Eärendil or Elrond (in the text he was a father figure to Eärendil and that role might be switched to Elrond for the show), and the bottom image is him during the Second Age, looking a lot older, but not as old as he'll look by the end of the Third Age (he's only just getting started on that beard).
#rings of power#lord of the rings#cirdan#eärendil#elrond#lotr#trop#jrr tolkien#ben daniels#trop book spoilers#is there a canon reason cirdan looks so old other than him being the oldest of the elves in middle-earth?#i can't recall if there is
74 notes
·
View notes
Text
I just watched episode 8, and I honestly feel very bad; I feel sad. I can't accept that Adar died. He just wanted his Uruk to be free and live in peace. I thought we'd see more about his past or at least tell him what his old name was... We weren't even given that.
Galadriel could have helped him at least kill some orcs...
On the other hand I'm surprised that Arondir is as if nothing had happened, not even a scratch.
#adar rings of power#adar#adar trop#adar x reader#amazon lotr#amazon rings of power#elrond peredhel#lotr rop#lotr the rings of power#rop#rop spoilers#rop season 2#the rings of power season 2#lotr rings of power#lotr#lotr series#lotr on prime#lotr trop#lotrrop#lotr books
57 notes
·
View notes
Text
My view on the Elrond/Galadriel kiss:
Cultures be different.
Kisses on the lips are not always sexual/romantic. (I, as an American, have kissed certain friends on the lips in completely platonic ways)
In many cultures, closed-mouthed kisses on the lips are a sign of love and emotional connection in a platonic/familial way.
Specifically American aversion to affection in any form is rotting people's brains - here, a lot of men won't even HUG each other because they think it's 'too intimate'. Other cultures kiss on the hand, cheek, forehead, nose, and yes, lips too, in completely platonic ways. [And we're not even going to get into the large portion of the population who thinks that men and women literally CANNOT be just friends, if a man and woman are close, it HAS to be romantic/sexual.]
Just because YOUR culture/personal preference reserves lip kisses for romantic/sexual feelings only doesn't mean everyone else is wrong for feeling differently.
I didn't read the kiss as Elrond secretly having romantic feelings for Galadriel at all - to me it was clear it was a platonic show of how much he cared for her and how sorry he was that they had been at odds all season (and largely in S1 too) and was afraid it was really going to be the last time he saw her. He wanted to show her just how much she meant to him - PLATONICALLY - and a tender kiss (while also using it as a distraction to slip her a lock-pick) was the way he did it.
Obviously it's ok for people to interpret it as romantic if they ship Galadriel and Elrond, but to say that's the ONLY interpretation based on your own limited cultural understanding of what a kiss could mean is just frustrating.
#rop spoilers#trop spoilers#rings of power#the rings of power#rop s2 e7#idk what else to tag this because LORD I do not want to book-only lotr fans to have something to say about this#if you like viewing the kiss as romantic - go for it!#if you don't like any romance between galadriel and elrond - there are platonic reasons people kiss#You could even see it as solely Elrond giving a distraction for slipping her the lock pick and nothing else whatsoever#Honestly my first thought was that he slipped Nenya to her in her mouth but hey - the point is that the kiss served multiple purposes#idk - ppl getting genuinely upset about it is giving me the ick and making me think they're actually just xenophobic#gonna repeat: cultures be different
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
give your giantess OC a sword. or perhaps a tasteful dagger. she needs it so so bad she told me herself
#between my TLT reread and LOTR rewatch im rlly digging swords#NO TLT SPOILERS PLEASE. MY BESTIE WOULD SHOOT ME. I NEVER FINISHED NONA#nona had me so confused i had to start the trilogy over. amazing book series highly reccomend it#if you love toxic lesbians and being confused then it is for u !!
99 notes
·
View notes
Text
#hmm yes I see. I see.#hidethepainharold.jpg#hey non book (yet) readers peeking in the spoilers tag: don't worry about it nothing to see here#Celebrimbor#Sauron#Annatar#tropspoilers#trop spoilers#trop#rop#the rings of power#rings of power#lotr trop#trop 2x08#Charles Edwards#Charlie Vickers#Eregion#Ost-in-Edhil
35 notes
·
View notes
Text
Book one Lord of the Rings, fellowship of the ring chapter seven spoilers! (Doodles I made throughout the chapter lol)
.
.
.
Eating good at Tom’s house cause he’s the coolest
Frodo got a little Crushy crush
End of chapter doodle (they’re singing)
#artwork#drawing#traditional art#art#artists on tumblr#illistration#sketch#illustration#lotr merry#lotr sam#lotr pippin#lotr frodo#lotr fanart#lotr#lotr books#lotr fandom#lord of the rings fandom#lord of the rings fanart#lord of the rings#frodo baggins#sam gamgee#pippin took#merry brandybuck#tom bombadil#lotr spoilers#lotr book spoilers#Tom bombadil is legitNess#lotr Tom bombadil#fair lady gold berry#lotr fair lady goldberry
61 notes
·
View notes
Text
I am back with the lotr doodles! The Last Debate:
and there they found their friends in the garden, and their meeting was a merry one. For a while they walked and talked, rejoicing for a brief space in peace and rest under the morning high up in the windy circles of the City. Then when Merry became weary, they went and sat upon the wall with the greensward of the Houses of Healing behind them...
#I LOVE THEM#i love how they became such good friends#and the progression in these books#of HOW they became friends#the little moments scattered throughout#of them caring for one another and missing one another#makes me very invested#;-;#lotr doodles#clarisse doodles#lotr newsletter spoilers#tolkien#lotr#the return of the king#legolas#merry brandybuck#pippin took#gimli
697 notes
·
View notes
Text
DUNE PART TWO SPOILERS
Just an observation that may not pan out, but I definitely feel like the fact they had Alia not be born yet throughout the film is gonna turn into the Tom Bombadil of the Dune movies vs books discourse.
This is because they changed her role for the same reason that they cut Tom Bombadil out of the film adaptation of Fellowship, which is that he would be too silly, and super genius murder toddler Alia Atreides would also be too silly. But LOTR book fans love Tom Bombadil, and Dune book fans love murder-baby Alia, so both are disappointed.
IMO I actually do like that Paul got to kill the Baron instead, and got the badass "Grandfather, you die like an animal" line, because Baron Harkonnen was more directly Paul's enemy through both films and throughout the books, and it feels more satisfying for his character arc. Paul is still motivated by vengeance over the assassination of his father, and unlike Alia, Paul actually grew up with Leto and actually has an emotional stake in killing the Baron.
Even though, yes having a three year old scamper around stabbing people would have also been cool I guess?
#dune movie#dune part 2#dune part two#alia atreides#paul atreides#dune books#dune 2#dune spoilers#dune part 2 spoilers#lotr films#tom bombadil
76 notes
·
View notes
Text
excerpt from meriadoc brandybuck's introduction to his book herblore of the shire.....imagine shouting out your bestie wizard friend that you went on a wild adventure with where you almost died in your book about the history of weed*!!!!
#personal#lotr newsletter#lotr lb#he really said this bitch smokes fat blunts better than any of us#also i love the juxtaposition between merry writing lots of books and pippin just collecting books after their adventure#merry truly is thee bookworm nerd confirmed#*yes i know it's not weed its tobacco but its funny cmon#lotr newsletter spoilers
34 notes
·
View notes
Text
Tolkientober 2024 - Day 1: Light/translation
"And your star glass, Mr. Frodo, you did lend it to me and I'll need it, for I'll always be in the dark now."
#lord of the rings#lotr#lotr fanart#tolkientober#tolkientober 2024#tolkientober2024#samwise gamgee#sam gamgee#hey dol arting dol#My entry for the first day is a little late but that's okay; I'm planning on taking it easy with this challenge#so that means I'm just going to spend as much time as I'd like on the prompts that caught my eye and have fun with it#That being said: starting with a really sad part in the book because unfortunately this was the first thing that came to mind when#I thought of the prompt “light” and I only say unfortunately because this scene hurt me so bad#On the bright side a happier Sam is on the way for day 2's prompt!#lotr spoilers
12 notes
·
View notes