#agency in storytelling
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
A review AND THOUGHTS ON Secret Level - “Honor of Kings: The Way of All Things”
In the animated anthology series Secret Level, the episode titled “Honor of Kings: The Way of All Things” stands out as a profound exploration of choice, sacrifice, and the delicate balance between determinism and free will. This narrative delves deep into philosophical themes, using the strategic board game Weiqi (known as Go) as a central metaphor. Synopsis The story follows Yi Xing, a…
#agency in storytelling#altruism#animated anthology#animation analysis#Chang’an#Chinese aesthetics#choice and sacrifice#determinism#existential storytelling#fate vs autonomy#free will#Go#Honor of Kings#introspection#narrative depth#omniscient entities#philosophical fiction#philosophical themes#Secret Level#storytelling and philosophy#strategic board games#The Way of All Things#Weiqi
0 notes
Text
This is a very very unfinished thought but I've been thinking a lot as I reread the books about how the women of House of the Dragon don't really get catharsis and how that'll likely be worse in S2. Say what you want about asoiaf but a number of named women there experience catharsis.
They kill their abusers (Lysa, Cersei, Dany). They regain some agency after a violation (Lysa, Cersei, Lady Stoneheart, Dany), and they refuse to forgive the people complicit in their subjugation (Lysa, Cersei, Dany, Lady Stoneheart, Jeyne Westerling).
Obviously, three or four isn't enough in such an expansive cast of characters but the point remains that they claw back their autonomy however they have to. They're allowed to be angry, bitter, unforgiving and cruel to their abusers in a way women in House of the Dragon just aren't allowed. They're allowed grief, grief that is violent and destructive.
The women of House of the Dragon don't get angry. They stand around and stare plaintively at the camera, they cry prettily, and they plead for peace and non-violence. They suffer and suffer and suffer and there's no relief.
#although dany doesn't really set out to kill her abuser#in fact she doesn't really think of him as her abuser#but the fact remains that her story begins with his death#she gains her dragons and agency through his death#lysa murdering jon arryn#lysa not going to riverrun when hoster is on his deathbed despite cat's letters#she denies him relief for his crimes against her and it's one of my favourite moments in asoiaf#cersei killing robert#cersei eating robert's children taking back reproductive autonomy from the man that hurt her#lady stoneheart turning her grief and pain onto the riverlands#she hangs freys boltons and lannisters uncaringly#it's a failing of the storytelling because this is supposed to be the feminist retelling of the dance#but instead the misogyny that leads up to the dance has been defanged.#the point of the show has been obscured behind endless arguments of the supposed illegitimacy of rhaenyra's first three children#the women fighting for power have been replaced by evil men perched on their shoulders telling them to do bad things#they're helpless victims carried along by the stream of inevitability#or something idk#also i am not including alicent trying to take luke's eye and injuring rhaenyra as cathartic because they are not the cause of her sufferin#house of the dragon#not asoiaf thoughts#daenerys targaryen#lysa arryn#cersei lannister#lady stoneheart#alicent hightower#rhaenyra targaryen#helaena targaryen#rhaenys targaryen
107 notes
·
View notes
Text
A ramble that's not in good faith, sorry, I know this online discourse gets under my skin. Anyway, context, Tumblr fandoms are very queer inclusive spaces that can forget how queer exclusionary many areas of storytelling can still be. Queer characters are a staple on US and UK television now but continue to have a lot of caveats and constraints.
Fandoms are likely a big part of why queerness in television has come as far as it has in the last few decades. Not for their constructive conversations about queer representation with an industry, but because they make queerness visible and viable. Creators started fighting back. Shows like Xena, whose actors and writers refused to let Gabrielle and Xena be seen as simply 'gal pals'. Refused to let the clear queer subtext be erased. Shows like Steven Universe and The Owl House, who actively went against their networks to ensure their queer romances couldn't be censored.
Can you remember the last time the "let them be friends" arguments applied to anything but the potential canonization of queer subtext? Cast your mind on the major same sex ships over the past 15 years. How many are canonically romantic? The vast majority are, in canon, intimate male friendships. Friendships that hold more importance in the story than any romance. Perhaps ask why this same argument is being applied to a queer relationship with clear romantic subtext? What does erasing that subtext serve and who does it hurt.
#dead boy detective agency#dead boy detectives#the dead boy detective agency#dbda#edwin payne#charles rowland#payneland#painland#queerness in television#queerness in media#queerness in storytelling#personally i want them all to be in one queerplatonicromantic cuddle pile with no need to pair off at all#but this would probably require an industry to become cool with a lot of things very quickly#and the potential for a sweepingly epic queer love story is not something that should be erased dismissed or belittled
71 notes
·
View notes
Text
stuff in vector's desk .. and cat
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/fc1d5a2148d172b4e80efc2aba7a7fdd/3422a7e53e8fab0c-10/s540x810/c369d57cb026fa1325438dffa374cf9eb4f4cd64.jpg)
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/c20d631a85369ece5d239c3cf9b22f0b/3422a7e53e8fab0c-03/s540x810/a3060a5c21858574159c0fed405ea441063d570f.jpg)
#sonic#team chaotix#vector the crocodile#team chaotix detective agency#sth#my art#environmental storytelling
20 notes
·
View notes
Note
Sorry, but saying Tommy is the reason Buddie ain’t together is straight up taking Buck’s agency away from him. HE is the reason they aren’t together. Because Tommy is the one he likes and wanna be with rn
I meant in terms of the story, not in terms of the universe.
Yeah in the universe Buck has chosen Tommy to be with rn, he likes him and wants to be with him and I'm enjoying their dynamic (my problems with Lou's acting and some of his dialogue aside), but i do believe that storytelling wise Tommy is very much a stepping stone to Buddie. He's a midgame relationship for Buck to explore his sexuality, and find peace with that side of himself that he's never thought to explore before. and I like Tommy as that stepping stone, he's an interesting character.
Tommy as a character (not a a person in the 9-1-1 universe) is just there as a barrier and a stepping stone towards Buck's endgame, and that's okay, it's good. The show needs a reason for Buck to not go straight to Eddie after realising his sexuality, and I'm enjoying Tommy as that reason. but his character very much is a plot device.
It would be boring if Buck had just realised he was bi and launched straight into a relationship with Eddie, and that's not even discussing the Eddie side of things. (i.e. his catholic guilt being the reason he isn't going to buck... or even realising/accepting his sexuality)
I watch shows from a very analytical view point, I have a media studies degree and it's hard to switch off and honestly i don't want to. I like how i watch the shows i'm interested in. I like trying to figure out where the puzzle pieces will land, what the show runners are planning and the roles the characters have in the stories and arcs to push them to their conclusion.
Tommy and Buck are fictional characters they're plot devices they aren't real humans. so I can't take their agency away from them when discussing their stories, because they don't have agency, because they are puppets and dolls being played by the showrunners and writers.
#yeah#if i were talking real people it would be taking away bucks agency to say that tommy is a reason for no buddie currently but...#im not#anyway this is my take on everything#i don't wanna be part of any shipping discourse#like... i want buddie#it feels like the logical conclusion for the show and has felt like that since season 2#but i will honestly be okay with things in between if they feel like they fit#which is why i kinda hated like.... natalie and taylor for but#the logic and flow wasn't there with the storytelling#same with marisol#for eddie#911 spoilers#buddie#911#911 abc#911 show
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
"Shallow Sound" Cemetery name reveal in environmental storytelling
paralleling the projected, hurtful words that Charles and Crystal are saying to each other
Crystal & Charles perhaps thinking each other's motives shallow, while Edwin is probably finding the fighting petty in the midst of a serious case
the shallow motives of the killer clients
the shallow ring of the bell to summon the girl who doesn't want to return
#dbda#dead boy detectives#dead boy detective agency#dbda meta#the case of the two dead dragons#liveblogging#theories#character analysis#scene analysis#environmental storytelling#writing#camera shot#screenshot#crystal palace#charles rowland#edwin payne#cryland#relationship dynamics#character dynamics#text post#probably way overthinking it but fuck it it's fun
42 notes
·
View notes
Text
wait, wait, wait, are some people SO upset about the Those Across the Sea stinger that they're offhandedly framing it as a matter of debate about whether Meredith is awful and horrific as a narrative agent? yeah, like, the oppressive systems of the Chantry is the real root cause here, but one part of the material expression of the awfulness and evil of those systems within the narrative is in how it enables people like Meredith to do all that and pursue her prejudices in that manner without resistance? like, DA2 isn't really presenting Meredith herself with a lot of nuance and is kinda landing simply at "Meredith is kinda evil / doing evil things (for whatever measure of evil even is)". what drove her to develop this perspective and what ALLOWED her to do and accomplish all this harm and enact all that violence because of her prejudices and fear is where a bit more complexity comes in, but the fact that she is doing awful shit is not really, like, that up for debate, and I'm kinda baffled that this is something that's being put out there by some because they didn't like the stinger.
#also personally speaking#someone preying on people's weaknesses‚ flaws and fears and manipulating them for their own goals does not imo negate those people's agency#honestly in many ways it makes many of those characters more tragic because they were taken advantage of and pushed into their own flaws#but they still made their own choices and had the agency to resist or deny that manipulation or influence (Cyrian is about this!)#and the presence of their flaws or weaknesses or fear or whatever is what made them a target or susceptible in the first place#but like. the fact that there is a manipulation involved doesn't absolve those people of responsibility or take away their agency#or make them not an active participant in their choices#I feel like we can look at like... American politics for that#tbh I'd say I should write a post about the Those Across the Sea stinger but I feel like the people who are most poisonously angry like#truly believe that Solas having been pressured DOES absolve him of some responsibility so they HAVE to believe it of that stinger too#so idk what the point really is bc while it's valid to not like it due to storytelling sensibility the MOST vitriolic folks are well that#DATV things
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
. . . he would have to write the story himself now or all the worst people would do it for him.
Lev Grossman, from The Bright Sword
#master of your fate#agency#now or never#story#storytelling#quotes#lit#words#excerpts#quote#literature#taking charge#ownership#lev grossman#the bright sword
13 notes
·
View notes
Note
Oh boy no anon lol. Anyway. I was wondering where you learned so much about the fundamentals of storytelling? I have a very deep appreciation of storytelling and can tell you what little details make stories good or weak, but when it comes to my own writing, it's like I don't know anything. Which I guess is true because my understanding, while maybe more literate than the average person, is still very surface level. I can't say I agree with all of your analyses lol but I agree with 99% because of your insight on how each element of a story relates back to its message. I don't think most people, even modern authors, have the ability to do that. Storytelling has definitely become a lost art, which is so unfortunate because I think it's so fundamental to human culture.
I really try to deconstruct the idea of "storytelling" and then say, "what did God do with this? Obviously He invented stories, Reality is the story He's telling, so how does He do it? What's the thing He uses it for? Now, how can humans also do that (because we're made in His image) and how has The Fall affected the way we do it?"
But, when it comes to articulating my "fundamentals of storytelling" understanding, I'm not very original. I learned a lot from the Belief Agency (especially Brian MacDonald's Invisible Ink. I don't agree with all of it but it was helpful in understanding how to communicate the main idea thing.) and from Lewis and Tolkien's thoughts on storytelling.
I think humans can't help but storytell. Even people who've never created a character or put pen to paper, consciously, are telling themselves a story every day in their head. They're observing the world, processing it, and then repackaging those observations according to what they've decided is true. Worldviews. And then they'll tell stories to the people around them.
What's getting lost is telling stories about things that are true. Like my pinned post says, stories reposed to be signposts that point your brain and emotions back to Reality when they've wandered. Nowadays even people who get the "This is supposed to communicate a main point" thing make that main point about ugliness or hate or straight-up lies. (I'm usually thinking about Riann Johnson's Knives Out movies.)
Thanks for your kind thoughts! If I ever hit the mark or say anything good or true, it's thanks to God, not me.
#Storytelling#asked#answered#don't worry about no anon#courage#knives out#movies#storytelling#Christianity#The Belief Agency#Brian MacDonald#Invisible Ink
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
How Manufacturers Can Leverage Content Marketing to Grow
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/ed4dfcb0d11b15f2bb2b31c5e7da10b0/63a46f0a37851ab7-96/s500x750/6f706406e7b0c3509cf8ccd7a9672a481e8bb342.jpg)
Cold calls, print advertising, tradeshow participation, and knocking on doors once worked well manufacturers can no longer rely on them to generate leads that fuel sustainable, double-digit growth despite having an effective sales team that may still have some skills in these areas.
Inbound lead generation in commercial and industrial markets requires compelling brand storytelling and thought leadership that educates prospects along the buyer’s journey, who don’t want to talk with salespeople before they’re good and ready as they fear being “sold to” by people that don’t have their best interest in mind.
Problems Solved vs. Products & Services, Features & Benefits
Powerfully resonating with prospects requires brand storytelling that converts website visitors into prospects then into customers.
Your brand story begins with having a deep understanding of the problems faced by your prospects, what they need to overcome them, and the value to them in doing so before promoting all of your products and services and their features and benefits. Prospects are searching for who can solve their problems and may have a limited understanding of what will solve their problems, so claiming your solutions are “the best” and that you’re an “industry leader” may mean nothing until they have an understanding of how your products will help them.
The hero of your prospects’ story is themselves, so you need to educate them on how you can solve their problems, and how your people, process, products, and services – not just products – do so. This is what will resonate powerfully with them. In this way, you serve as a guide for achieving success and avoiding failure. Your products and services with their features and benefits are how you solve these problems..
Thus, your “brand story” needs to be told throughout all of your marketing: on your home and about pages, blogs, guides, case studies, marketing collateral, presentations, proposals, press releases, third-party website profiles, direct mail, email campaigns, your tagline, and anywhere else you promote your company.
A brand story for each product and service you sell can also be developed as each of them solves different problems in different ways for different markets. This “sub-brand storytelling” is also effective for different vertical and geographic markets as each has different requirements.
Extracting & Promoting Thought Leadership
When they have a problem that they want to solve – because the pain of not changing exceeds the pain of the change – prospects self-educate themselves by researching the internet before speaking with any vendors, so it’s important to provide educational content that will help them understand how you can solve their problems:
TOFU: Top of Funnel: this content builds awareness by providing an overview of the problems you solve and how your products solve them
MOFU: Middle Funnel: this content goes one level deeper and helps them consider between different options that can solve their problem
BOFU: Bottom Funnel: this content gets very specific and helps prospects make their final decisions
OOFU: Out of Funnel: this content is created in a misguided attempt to maximize keyword rankings and website traffic as part of a flawed search engine optimization strategy (SEO) but fails to generate leads though can be quite costly
Tip: it’s important to have a good balance of all types of content (except OOFU).
It’s especially important for manufacturers to understand that, in addition to learning about how you solve their problems with your products and services, your prospects want to know how your solutions and business practices compare with both direct and indirect competitors. They also want to understand how their investment can be cost-justified so they can sell the idea of buying from you to internal decision makers that may not be in communication with you. Product comparisons are very useful because this is what prospects try to compile themselves, especially if they include areas where your competitors have an advantage over yours. Case studies that include return on investment (ROI) estimates are also highly useful for prospects.
Lead-Generating Content Begins with Keyword Research
Understanding and prioritizing what your prospects are searching for is a critical first step for lead generation, which begins with conducting keyword research on all the different terms your prospects may use.
Onsite SEO then fully leverages the content you’ve already developed when you work the highest priority keyword phrases into your page titles, meta descriptions, H1 headers, and throughout the content of each page – just remember it has to read well and should only be performed by someone that thoroughly understands your business and what prospects value.
Brainstorming content ideas that incorporate these keyword phrases and educates prospects along the buyer’s journey is the next step, following by prioritizing these content ideas into an editorial calendar. The best content comes from getting a professional copywriter to interview your company’s thought leaders and then writing up what is learned in the form of foundational website content, blogs and guides.
Best Practice: Google Search Console reports the keywords people searched for to find you.
Creating Lead Magnets
When your prospects discover that you are providing education and thought leadership for how you can solve their problems, many will be willing to provide their contact information to download this gated content – especially long-form, MOFU and BOFU content including guides, whitepapers, ebooks, and webinars. It’s also important that your contact forms ask prospects where they found out about you so you can attribute each download to the marketing or other activities that generated them. It’s not recommend to gate promotional material that prospects expect to be freely available, including blogs, brochures, data sheets, infographics, case studies, and similar materials.
Promoting MOFU and BOFU also generate even more website traffic and leads, including in Google Ads, LinkedIn Campaigns, Microsoft Ads and other pay-per-click (PPC) campaigns, your social media profiles (especially LinkedIn and Twitter), on third-party article publishing sites (e.g. Medium), and throughout your public relations activities.
The Manufacturing Content Creation & Lead Generation Process
Here are the steps for creating content that has been proven to generate leads and product sales from many commercial and industrial manufacturers:
Conduct keyword research and optimize all of your current content for search
Develop brand storytelling and implement it throughout your home and about pages, marketing collateral, presentations, and all other marketing materials
Write blogs and publish them on a consistent schedule, educating prospects on a wide variety of topics that help them understand how your products and services will solve their problems
Syndicate unique versions of this content on high ranking, third-party websites
Launch Google ads and email campaigns to bring more prospects in
Create microsites to promote how you solve specific problems in your top vertical markets
Launch ecommerce to supplement sales through your channel partners for people that want to speak with and buy directly from you – just don’t undercut them, so selling only at list price is recommended
Evaluate new market opportunities where your current competitors are irrelevant with Blue Ocean Strategy
This approach routinely generates sustainable, double-digit sales growth with an ROI of over 300% within 12-18 months when executed by an experienced industrial marketing agency – and your company will no longer be a well-kept secret in your markets.
The Case for a Marketing Audit
While it may be appealing to hire a full-time content marketer, SEO specialist, or to outsource to a manufacturing marketing agency that may wow you with shiny objects, conducting deep dive marketing due diligence with an experience marketing consulting resource understands your industry is typically a better way to start.
An effective marketing audit will identify what it will take for you to generate sustainable, double-digit growth by leveraging brand storytelling, content marketing, SEO, content syndication, email campaigns, marketing automation, social media, advertising, PR, and more.
Most marketing audits focus only on promotional marketing communications, so you may want to find an industrial marketing agency that can auditing the other three Ps of your marketing: products and services, pricing and placement (selling through channels and go-to-market strategy).
#manufacturing marketing#industrial marketing#b2b marketing agency#content marketing#search engine optimization (SEO)#brand storytelling
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ep 10!
#Idk it was. An episode. Not many thoughts tbh ajhdblabfdl#The Kyouka / Akutagawa scene is my favourite ever. But I suppose there's little to say about them I haven't said already lol.#The “Because I knew a man who had the same eyes as yours” will never stop being endlessly impactful.#And I still find it very remarkable how Kyouka is pretty much literally the only person other than Dazai that Akutagawa respects.#It hits me so hard.#Nothing else to add? I think the storywriting in this arc is very good. The plot twists are very well executed.#I remember when I was reading the manga and Ranpo challenged Chuuya face off I was so hooked!!#I was like‚ how is he going to win!!! It's very nice.#I think it's interesting that Atsushi stayed behind with Kunikida instead of facing the pm with the rest of the pm.#I wish we'd explored his decision and state of mind more‚ especially since he was portrayed as being visibly conflicted.#I think part of it simply solves a storytelling purpose of not leaving Kunikida alone...#But I don't think that necessarily means the decision doesn't suit him. Atsushi really looks up to Fukuzawa.#His trauma probably makes him more reluctant to break orders than‚ let's say‚ Ranpo.#And he's always been very spokenly against violence.#Idk. I just think it's interesting.#The line “Kunikida‚ you're the strongest and most virtuous of us in the Agency. That's why the enemy tried to break you first.”#is very emotional#The animation is so strained it makes me feel bad for the animators. So many static frames lingering for so long...#I feel like the result isn't necessarily terrible either. The drawings are not ugly‚ just very undetailed.#But it really feels like there was a group of people doing the best they could with the llittle they had...#random rambles#And I'm now all caught up with the rewatch!!!!!!!! 🥳🥳🥳 See you on Wednesday!!!!!
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
daniel molloy and john silver are a genre of characters with identities that are so fragile and maybe even built on lies...
#ok maybe not lies per se in daniel's case but! but!!! his identity is a victim to circumstance - or rather arman'd influence because#as soon as you learn that he's been hypnothised the question of integrity and agency is engendered and i think that is driving me insane#daniel molloy the character that you are#AND THEY ARE BOTH STORYTELLERS!!!!#also i can be your lestat i can be your claudia and silver being like im not going to be your miranda or thomas?? mental illness#interview with the vampire#black sails#daniel molloy#john silver
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
charming and good: dr prism and solaris, both being ex-zoraxis operatives who don't feel safe enough to turn to the agency, working together post the events of 3 to pursue their crafts without death or capture looming above their necks
charming and evil: solaris- through prism- learns that anna is alive, and immediately drops everything she is doing to find her and tear her limb from limb for being the catalyst to the destruction of her death engine
#ieytd#just realized i've never tagged anna until now. underrepresented girlie#anna ulanova#commander solaris#roxana prism#honestly i'm not confident that solaris is unaffiliated with zoraxis nowadays. if only because it seems strange from a storytelling-#-perspective to label her as one of zoraxis' dangerous forces behind zor and the fabricator before immediately having her quit#BUT. i do think the thought of her just like. fucking off to go do... solaris things is really hilarious#and i think she should get a bloody violent rage arc#i think anna's potential relationship- or lack thereof- with solaris is a VERY undertapped concept#literally were it not for the intel she supplied the handler would probably be dead. the death engine would have succeeded.#zoraxis knew anna provided SOME intel to the agency. but i wonder if they knew what. i wonder if they figured it out after DE-#-or if they assume the infiltration was a quirk of the phoenix's lucky streak.#i think if solaris knew... dear lord. i think she would lose her mind. and she's ALIVE?? solaris nearly BLEW UP. her life's work GONE.#i love anna but i can't really deny the facts. she kind of set the rest of solaris' life up for rage and misery.#she can get a little butchered about it. it's only fair.
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
Stories are not reality. They use many tools to reflect reality but they are not beholden to the same rules. What's more, they reflect Romance just as readily as they reflect Realism. Stories require a suspension of disbelief. Some willingness to look outside yourself to pick apart meaning. An ability to empathize with experiences not your own so you can better see why and how it was put together the way it was. Stories are ephemeral and intangible, a collective fever dream with meanings that shift depending on the dreamer. They are also deliberately constructed and come with their own concrete intentions, histories, and baggage unique to each culture, genre, and medium the story is told in.
If I had one wish when it comes to critiques of fiction, it's that people come at a story from where it is first and everything else can come later. For example, critiques of YA are going to be different to that of Adult works. Those teenagers are heroes and sexual agents because it's important teenagers be allowed their own coming of age journeys— explorations of sex and sexuality a big part of that period of self discovery for many. (That doesn't mean sex has to be a PSA either, it can be raw and awkward and weird and uninhabited). E.g. No, that immortal/older supernatural being falling for our teen hero isn't a predator (well... there are layers). What they are is a extremely common teen power fantasy. (However, if you did want to read a YA series that deconstructs that particular trope and explores how horrific such a dynamic would be, I'd recommend 'The Fever King' and 'The Electric Heir' by Victoria Lee. Brilliant and harrowing books).
Okay, so, anyway. I've been watching a very good YA show called Dead Boy Detectives. (I have a feeling the people following me are reading those words with exasperation, "No shit"). It's fun spooky hijinks but it's also a beautiful piece of cinematic storytelling that uses a variety of mixed mediums to get its points across. It makes this queer nerds heart happy and deserves more space to tell the story it wants to tell and subvert the tropes it wants to subvert. However, in case it doesn't get that space, I wanted to recommend two queer book series that fans of the show may want to look into. The 'Whyborne & Griffin' series by Jordan L. Hawk (each book gets better and better, and also, the actor that plays Edwin would make an excellent Whyborne) and 'The Last Binding' series by Freya Marske.
#queer media#queerness in television#queerness in media#queerness in storytelling#navel gazing#the dead boy detectives#dead boy detective agency#dead boy detectives#whyborne and griffin#the last binding#jordan l hawk#freya marske#book recommendations#victoria lee#man victoria lee#i could only read those books once#but they have never left me
38 notes
·
View notes
Text
Being a true galaxy-brained Doctor Who fan is hitting the epiphany that every showrunner had their strengths and their weaknesses and their own interpretations of the Doctor and you can like or dislike any aspect of any showrunner and acknowledge their genuine mistakes/bad choices/yikes decisions (such as racism, sexism, homophobia, questionable undertones, lack of agency for female characters, etc.) and it is COMPLETELY VALID to have that turn you off of a Doctor/showrunner but also acknowledge that some of the things that people have considered bad writing over the years are often personal preference (valid opinion, not always valid fact) and that just as there are clunkers in every season, there's something to appreciate about every showrunner and every Doctor.
After all, "The way I see it, every life is a pile of good things and bad things. The good things don't always soften the bad things, but vice versa, the bad things don't always spoil the good things and make them unimportant."
#listen i am in my doctor who renaissance and i love every doctor in their own ways and dislike/like every writer for at least one thing#not a fan of how steven moffat stripped amy & river of agency but loved the fairytale vibes & heaven sent & a Christmas Carol and Bill#adored the character writing for nine and ten and their companions but you cannot ignore a lot of the antiblack writing for RTD#love the stripped back/intimate storytelling of Season 11 & the Graham&Ryan arc & the writing of 13 as a character but Thasmin is underdone#& boy is that Nazi moment with the Master all kinds of screwed up#every actor to play a companion or a doctor is amazing#I'm a big fan of some of the “worst” episodes#love & monsters end of the world tsuranga conundrum resolution curse of the black spot my beloved#and really don't like some of the more popular episodes#wedding of river song time of the doctor twice upon a time girl in the fireplace etc.#but it's all personal preference#every doctor has some of the best episodes television has ever produced#it takes you away midnight heaven sent last of the time lords 3 parter boom town parting of the ways god complex vincent & the doctor#this is a show designed to be amazing and terrible and campy and episodic and constantly renewing itself and constantly trying new things#and I LIKE THAT#I LOVE THAT#ninth doctor#tenth doctor#eleventh doctor#twelfth doctor#thirteenth doctor#russell t davies#steven moffat#chris chibnall#meta
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
People appear to like my first unhinged Renfield post so here’s another one:
The scene where Bobert Montague Renfield talks about his wife and kid. This is a scene that feels really out of place because it’s right between two high energy action scenes and a lot of people on first watch will be like “why do we care about this?” In a lesser movie, this scene would have an explicitly romantic overtone, an “I failed my wife and kid but I won’t fail you, love interest.” We don’t get that and the movie is BETTER FOR IT (but that’s a post for later.) People might especially be confused by this scene because when we see Dracu-Cage doing his best manipulate mansplain manslaughter earlier in the movie, he pulled this exact piece of information: (paraphrasing) “you abandoned your wife and kids because you wanted my power, you’re the evil one who took advantage of me!!” And the instinct is of course to say that’s not true!! That’s just Dracu-Cage manipulating the facts!! It’s Drac’s fault Renfield left, not his!!
And I personally (personal taste alert) really like that this movie didn’t go there. Instead, there is a grain of truth there. Renfield did have a choice, he had agency then to turn down the power and he has agency now to walk away. That is something a lot of stories of abuse overlook because it’s VERY hard to do it without looking like you’re blaming the victim for their abuse. “Oh if it’s so bad why don’t you just leave?” type shit, not a fan, I don’t have to explain that. But this movie has motherfuckin DRACULA as its antagonist!! We see this guy literally commit mass murder to punish Renfield for exercising his agency, we see why it’s not as simple as “just walk away.”
This scene establishes that there is a reason that Renfield was drawn to him in the first place, there is a vulnerability that Dracula exploited, and it’s not altruistic, it’s a little selfish!! And that’s okay!! Renfield still isn’t shown as deserving the abuse because of it, and it’s clear that his own lack of self esteem and subsequent lust for power is a FLAW that he needs to OVERCOME in order to be FREE and JOYFUL. Giving up his power to Dracula and BEING a poor little meow meow who can’t do anything is PART OF what started the cycle of abuse in the first place, allowed Dracula to take advantage of him, and perpetuates the cycle. In taking his power back, acknowledging his own weakness but affirming his own strength, Renfield can leave, move on, and find joy.
It preserves Renfield’s agency in a way I don’t know if I’ve seen before!!!! That’s pretty fucking nuanced for a slapstick gore comedy!!!!!!
#i might be overselling the novelty of this storytelling#but listen. this movie was a really good depiction of abusive relationships#and managed to stay clear of some pitfalls that would have been very easy to fall into#they COULD HAVE poor little meow meowed him#and they sort of did. BUT THEY ALSO GAVE HIM AGENCY#AND THE POWER OF INCREDIBLE VIOLENCE#at the end of the day Renfield does have the choice to break the cycle and leave#it’s dangerous yes but he HAS IT#and that’s IMPORTANT TO ME#blue rambling#renfield 2023#spoilers
38 notes
·
View notes