#Yes! Because saying someone is entitled to a child the same way they're entitled to housing is DEEPLY fucked up!
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
bmoreisapunkrocktown · 3 days ago
Text
Eugenics is explicitly tied to the view of children as "things" that someone owns and controls, and until we do away with that idea, we can never be truly free of eugenics.
And that sucks, but there are a lot of people who claim to be anti eugenics who still very rigidly hold on to the idea of the nuclear family and the "right" to have a child, and that is not and never will be an anti-eugenics opinion, nor will it ever lead to any better conditions for disabled children.
#I'm just getting SOOOOO tired of the ways in which people speak on eugenics like it's some big bad boogeyman#And then openly say that disabled children are burdens that you take on if you're a bad person#Like someone on here genuinely honestly said and believed that disabled people should decide whether or not someone gets an abortion#in the event that the fetus is or could be disabled.#Like if someone's fetus tested positive for a genetic issue a group of people with that issue would vote on abortion#This person thought this was an anti eugenics opinion and not a deeply horrific and fucked up away to view someone else's body#Like that person said that someone who would otherwise want an abortion “deserves” to have a disabled child if disabled people agree#I actually think you're a dangerous person on par with a serial killer#That person defined themselves as pro choice bc words don't mean anything anymore#Anyway the problem that I have is how much people truly believe that selective abortion is bad but also that children are things#Like the universal human rights are rights to (clean) water (clean) food (clean) air (safe) shelter and (healthy) babies#That honestly genuinely cannot be more obvious#Also literally everything but children listed is a thing#These are all objects there is no way to put a child on par with objects and also say “defective” objects are bad#It's pretty easy to get that the right to shelter isn't going to include housing with inadequate air and water and also holes in it#It's pretty clear the right to food doesn't included diseased expired or moldy food#“Did you just compare a disabled child to moldy food? That's fucked up”#Yes! Because saying someone is entitled to a child the same way they're entitled to housing is DEEPLY fucked up!#You are not entitled to a child! Children are not “things” full stop and they aren't objects you need to live!#They are actual human beings with needs! Needs that you MUST meet or you can't have them!#Like on some base issue people can acknowledge that you aren't entitled to a gecko.#Like being able to pick up a gecko off the ground doesn't mean it should live in your house#But they cannot extend the idea of “reasonable environments” to children#Also STOP PUSHING FOR DISABLED CHILDREN TO BE IN ABUSIVE HOMES#Like I think my point got jumbled but the fundamental view of eugenics is that disabled children are “broken” and therefore don't have valu#Whether that's value in the nuclear family or value in society#It is simply not acceptable to say 1) “we will force you to value” or 2) No they actually do have value#Because the idea of “value” is inherently flawed and inherently BAD#Because the nuclear family is inherently bad as is capitalism#And I'm worried that y'all are trying to rehab the nuclear family and not destroy it and adjust capitalism instead of discarding it
1 note · View note
transfemlogan · 2 months ago
Note
idk if you were being serious lol, i have trouble with tone. but whats wrong with some of the ts critters?
which ones are "right" and whos just "shitting on anything"?
i am finally off of work & just ate a sandwich so now i can finally talk abt this.
please note: I am referring to a small group of fans within the critical side of things.
On both sides of the community, no one (hyperbole) can ever settle with a middle ground or have any sort of grey area. it's always extreme. it's always "thomas is the worst person ever & all of his actions r terrible" or "thomas is the best person ever & all of his actions are good", when in actuality human beings are complex and cannot be contained in one absolute or another.
Some TSS critical fans focus on things that absolutely do not matter or have the most wild takes I've ever seen. I was one in a sasi critical discord server awhile back and everyone was complaining about Thomas' posting his clothed ass on instagram ... he quite literally underpaying his employees. i think one of these is more important than what he does with his own body.
and the thing is there are some things that he does in regards to his body that IS weird, such as: why is he posting sexually as velma, a teen character, on his patreon which (at the time, idk if it is still now) is not age restricted.
but him posting himself in a spiderman suit where if you look REALLY hard you can "see his underwear" is not the biggest issue in the world. or him not wearing a dance belt in the same costume. sorry, but actually i think you're the weird one if you're focused so heavily on how his genitals look in cosplay! the way you guys talk about it is lowkey leaning towards sexual harrassment, and I don't know if Thomas has an opinion on it or not, but's its incredibly weird regardless.
Shitting on thomas & co, current & past, employees for breathing. there's a new blog going around mentioning how they "hate brei" bcuz she "always starts drama" and the drama that they're talking about is her getting laid off... like. thats not drama, i think an artist is allowed to speak about their experiences with a certain job.
I feel like certain TSS critical fans have such an unrealistic view on creators, in the same way certain non-critical fans do. where non-critical fans think he shouldn't be held accountable for anything that he does, critical fans think every single thing he does is inherently evil or whatever.
"thomas shouldn't be attacking people in his twitter replies" this is an inherently true statement, however there's certain things that really depend on what's happening.
What is this person saying under thomas' posts? Who is saying it? How is thomas reacting specifically?
someone who comments unhelpful & rude ass comments underneath thomas' posts, such as infantalising him by telling him "thomas, thomathy, my sweet child, learn how to wear a skirt!!!" does in fact deserve some heat back because that's fucking weird. telling thomas advice on how to pose for a photoshoot is also probably fucking weird. but a child (or even an adult) commenting how much they miss sanders sides because it's been 4 years? that's fine and deserves a lot more compassion than thomas gives them.
& then you see how some people dm him about certain things or comment on his posts about it, when none of it is warranted. yes it's fucking weird for you to dm him, a REAL HUMAN BEING, and tell him to "hurry up and finish the fucking video"!!!! but its ALSO weird for him to post your username publically knowing how big his fanbase is and knowing how they will react.
im sorry but some fans are, in fact, fucking rude ass cunts. & thomas is allowed to tell you to fuck off. but its important to know when thomas is allowed to do that and when some fans are not being rude ass cunts. thats the point of critical thinking.
and there is some entitlement within the critical side of the community. yes thomas does owe his fans things, no he doesn't owe you certain things.
it's not surprising that he gives sasi upsets on his patreon, it's almost like that's what the point of a patreon is. but he does owe those patreon users something, since they are paying him Money For promised content that never comes.
Tumblr media
it's not surprising that he got upset you provided unwanted critique on how he's posing? in a photoshoot? and then didnt... "credit you for the advice" ... thats not exactly how advice works. he does not owe you that. But it is weird how he does take from fan creation and headcanons. after Joan (& thomas, im pretty sure) talked about how they don't like reading fanfiction because they don't want to steal from fans, only to go on and make logan's eyes orange.
(note: i do not know what that user's advice even was, since they never go in depth about it. so maybe it was warranted some credit and not a rude response, but i have no idea so I am going off what I know.)
A lot of fans, again on both sides of the community, think it's a very black & white situation. if one thing applies then everything else does to, when in actuality like .... situations are more complex than you guys expect.
sometimes there's just not a lot of nuance or fucking thinking that goes into some of these takes, and it's one of the reasons I dislike looking at TSS critical blogs now. its why i dislike the concept of a "critical discord server", because no one here can use critical thinking.
i want nuanced, intriguing takes and criticism. not random fucking baseless hate just because you want to shit on him. its annoyingggg!!!
32 notes · View notes
bookishfeylin · 5 months ago
Note
just saw your anti booktok post from june 11 2023 and yeah. the way white authors write self-insert fantasies clearly for only white people. The way white audiences will eat it up because it has them as the mcs. the way fae fantasy/fairytale retellings only really focuses on white women. The awkward silence of being a woc and not being able to imagine yourself in the fantasy protagonist's shoes because how can you, they're all white. why would you step into a world where you're made to choose between a golden-haired good white boy and an abusive white bad boy with black hair. they are not even appealing to you. the way alina starkov and mal oretsev being made poc for shadow and bone was met with so much anger and imo violence from white women, cause they could no longer self-insert onto the protagonist because their fantasy of her being a white mc had been shattered. the sobbing and screaming in comments of youtube sections asking why couldn't alina starkov be white even though white people already have everything. and she's not even fae. the entitlement that comes with white privilege and therefore booktok. i'm tired
Hi anon! I assume you are referring to this post and yes, yes I wholeheartedly agree. There’s another post on here about the politics of escapism, and I feel like that really applies to booktok. Who gets to escape in fantasy? Who gets to read about characters that look like them go on adventures and fight monsters and ride dragons and practice magic? Who is included in their world? And who isn’t? Who is relegated as always to a servant, a competing love interest, a jealous ex, a side character in someone else’s story? Who can turn they brain off and ignore all the racism in fantasy and sci-fi—and who can’t because we live with that stuff day in and day out in the real world and it jumps out at us when we see it in our entertainment too?
And it’s so painfully apparent because whenever the same shallow writing is used but with a person of color as a protagonist, or even when the writing is solid and intense but a person of color is the protagonist, white people struggle to relate to them or argue they “have no personality” and couldn’t connect with the character (and even with side characters of color as well). For example, I recently read Blood Scion by Deborah Falaye and it was brutal and intense and a wonderful look into the psychology of child soldiers and how they are broken and what they will do to survive all from a fantasy perspective. But a lot of the (white) reviewers on goodreads say they can’t relate to Sloane, the mc, or that she’s nothing more than a cardboard cut-out who is ~traumatized~, or that the plot makes no sense, etc. The book is objectively well written, but it only has a 3.5 star rating on goodreads and people are much more critical of every aspect of the book than they are of, say, Sarah J Maas’s books when almost of these criticisms are even more applicable in her case. The double standard—the increased scrutiny of and disconnect with and dislike of characters of color—jumps out in booktok in particular because of how low the standards are for white-led and focused books and how much higher they are for POC-led and focused books. And for those of us who want to see ourselves in fantasy, it’s hard.
48 notes · View notes
ladyorigami · 3 months ago
Note
How do you feel about season 4
Bad. I feel reeeeal bad about season 4. LOL I hate it, actually-hate what they did to my boy.
Yes I'm always focused most on Five as a character, but I will say as a whole, the season is just...just a mess. They took away a lot of particular traits from the characters in order to sort of give this...shock value? Not sure that's the word, but in order for us to see how differently bland and miserable everyone's life is this time around, and to do that, they also just, sucked a ton of their characters out right with it. We also have no catharsis, no proper conclusion to the relationships and events of s3, and even though they carry that over, they don't actually give resolution.
The plot also just-and the ENDING-I...okay I need to round back to Five for a second. I'm going to ramble rant about Five for a bit PASSIONATELY so SPOILER ALERT AHEAD, don't read below this if you don't want to see me lay down a quick wall of text about The Boy:
It's not like I don't understand the 'why' of it.
Imagine spending the majority of your life in an apocalypse, eating bugs and learning how to harden your heart and kill as a child, all for the CHANCE at getting back to your family.
Throwing him back into that scenario is like...the mere THOUGHT of that makes me insane with all of the character exploration we could have had and then DIDN'T GET ANY.
Like I can't even fathom the sheer trauma he was going through once they got lost in that subway for more than a couple weeks. He's essentially in his personal hell all over again and this time it's without that hope of his family he had before. Of course he's going to cling to the one person who is there, of course they both would, it's been years. Trauma bonding exists and they both have a lot of it and yes, they are like with their rough edges and independence. So sure, I can understand the 'why' and 'how' of this happening (even if I hate it and it lowkey gives me the ick)
But we didn't even GET the character parts of that. We didn't get any trauma, didn't get any PTSD, didn't get any look into Five's mind and heart there in the subway. This really would have been a perfect opportunity to finally crack all of that wide open, because it's always been brushed off before. But nope.
Instead, an affair with Lila. A rushed sloppy timelapse and then they're a thing now and that's...it? Like the whole point of that was just for them to have this weird relationship and then they came back??
There's a time that he even SEES a younger version of himself in the same apocalypse and he reacts like he isn't even there.
This character who becomes lost without a purpose and is still searching for it, whose flame is uncharacteristically dimmed of the usual fire? Yes. I would like to explore that.
Like I said it's not even necessarily the issue that it could have happened in the beginning but it's his attitude after that really got to me. The entitlement he had to square up to Diego?? The entitlement he had to continue to cling around her when her family is there and the way he's acting...it's like it's just terrible to me.
When Five loves he loves with his whole heart, he devotes everything he has to the people he cares for but once upon a time that used to be his family and like hell if I think he would fist fight Diego for LILA. Diego his brother...Diego whose eyes warmed with such love and relief in the second season when he saw Five at that hospital. Five who sacrificed himself numerous times over to keep them safe.
I get the point is that Five is lost. That his family clearly can't give him what he needs and he's just in some ways given up trying for it. He's-tired and he just wants to rest and have something or someone that he can call his own...but that's definitely not going to be the wife of his brother???? rihgqoirgoais
I just can't swallow this attitude by him in the after bits-and I definitely can't come to terms with the fact that they basically planted him back into his personal nightmare and all that came from that was a rushed love affair. It puts a bitter bitter taste in my mouth he deserved this character exploration, he deserved to actually have his family go try and save him for once-fight for him-show him that they care as much as he's cared for them.
(There is NO slander being thrown to people who like this ship before or after s4, you guys like what you like and that's fantastic. I just have issues with the way it was all handled and I must rant passionately.)
38 notes · View notes
anamericangirl · 7 months ago
Note
It drives me kind of crazy how often I see you having to argue the same points over and over with people. It seems to me as if I should just be able to scroll your blog a bit, get a good idea of your feelings on things, and then know everything I need to know about how you'll answer. How do you deal with this strange, perverse popularity you've garnered? How many times do you think you'll have to tell people that an unborn baby is a person and entitled to all the protections any other person should be? Every other 'gotcha' and nice and narrow circumstance that someone could possibly ask about abortion should be a 'don't make me tap the sign' moment, right? Yes, aborting a child conceived of rape is bad because the baby is innocent. Yes aborting a child because the mother's circumstances changed is bad because the child has a right to life too. Yes, when you fuck someone you're consenting to the risk of bringing a new life into the world, and you don't get to revoke that consent later for any reason. I can't help but think these people keep trying to mental-backflip their way into a position where their beliefs aren't barbarically monstrous has to be coming from some feeling of guilt. At some point in their lives they coerced someone to kill their baby, or maybe they killed their own baby, and if they confront the idea that they took part in killing an innocent person they will burst into flames or something. They're desperate to try to convince people that they're actually a good person, that they're not monsters, and that they don't need to repent for the lives they've ended.
I'm convinced that most people are motivated by compassion, but it's so devilishly easy to trick and coerce people in misdirecting that compassion towards evil means. Change the lens and perspective on a situation and you can find someone gullible enough to believe what they're advocating for is good and righteous. When compassionate people are confronted with the notion they've been tricked and used for evil, I think they tend more often than not to break. They have to twist themselves back up into a deluded mindset to defend their minds and souls from the pain of admitting they were used, and in the process they only perpetuate more evil...
Anyway, I think you're great. The only thing we seem to be able to do with these people is to be a wall they can't break down or climb over. We have to be like concrete, so when they slam into us they only cause themselves pain. There can be no bending or breaking in the face of people that will take any sign of weakness as an indication they are right. If there's any chance of them coming back from where they are, then walls like you need to help guide them along the right path as they seek to slam through you.
I think you are pretty much right. Some of it might be guilt, some of it's misguided and warped "compassion" and some is just straight up indoctrination. That's why for the majority of them, once they make their initial argument they can't engage with you in an intellectual discussion after you challenge it. All they know is the line but they can't rationalize it because they surround themselves in echo chambers where they don't have to rationalize things. They're not used to engaging in discussion with people who don't just nod in agreement with them or don't accept what they say at face value.
And, like, yeah it does get a little tiring to have to say the same things over and over again when it's not hard to find my answer by taking a quick glance at my blog. I've literally addressed every single pro-abortion argument in existence at this point I think lol. But on the other hand I don't mind especially if it seems to be someone who I haven't interacted with before and is genuinely curious (even if it's something I've answered before) versus someone who keeps asking me the same things over and over again and is just completely ignoring my answer or thinks if they slightly change the scenario my answer will be different. And sometimes it's hard to differentiate between those two types of people lol.
For whatever reason, they just can't accept that there's never a time where you have to kill a baby. And that might be where a little bit of the guilt comes in. They see me and others say that and they immediately start trying to invent scenarios (some completely outlandish) where it's necessary to kill a baby. Because if they can't find an exception then that means they have actually been advocating for something truly horrible this entire time and none of them want to admit they've been doing that.
Thanks so much!!
21 notes · View notes
icanseethefuture333 · 1 year ago
Text
REAL DELULU YELLIN OUT MY MAAAANS 😜🤪😝
Tumblr media
Why are people so mad about the reading I did for Mark's ideal type?:
Oh lord 🙄 so it seems people had expectations for the reading and thought it was going to be what they thought it would to be (or even wanted) vs thinking from Mark's perspective. They are in denial of the fact that Mark could be sexually attracted to such women and are babying him??? They don't want to acknowledge the fact Mark could actually have an active dating life. The way they view him is like a child, they can't fathom the thought of Mark having sex or being with an "alluring" type of woman. It's as if they want him to be with the type of girl they think he should be dating (what are they his mother? The entitlement! I just have to laugh 🤭). Some people could even be disappointed that they don't fit his ideal type 💀. They're just choosing to fight with me *sarcastic baby voice* because they think they know their precious Markie so well 🥺! Sigh 🤧😪 Instead of going by the saying "take what resonates and leave what doesn't" they're lashing out due to having poor self esteem.
Tumblr media
Is it multiple people or just one person that keeps sending me anons to my inbox?:
Ew 😂! It's literally just only two of the same people who can't get over it. Embarrassing. I have a feeling these two might know each other or are possibly mutuals. If not, they both share in common that Mark is their bias and they are upset and shocked to hear about his love life. They wish it could be them. How boring 😴🥱 One thinks they are tough shit but is actually scary as hell because they can only talk shit on anon 😂. The other one seems to be in their feelings. Upset about the reading perhaps? Or what I said as a response? Can't please everyone I guess 🤷🏽‍♀️
Tumblr media Tumblr media
What does Mark's future spouse have to say?:
Channeled song is Twinnem by Coi Leray.
"That's my twinnem, go, best friend
We killin' 'em (Yeah)
No new friends
Get rid of them"
At the end of the day Mark's future spouse is here to stay and they do not give a fuck about how people feel about it. "OH MY GOD🤬! I am never leaving! I am never leaving, I'm in this shit forever! 😃🤞"
They are someone who is very beautiful, confident, and wealthy on their own. They could possibly be popular or famous themselves. The style and beauty of the girls in the cards is a loooot similar to what was stated in the ideal type reading 😂... but let me not trigger the masses again 😮‍💨.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Channeled message for the collective:
"Don't meet your heroes if you aren't going to accept what you see. Once people show you who they are, believe them." Phew and ain't that the truth! Let em know spirit guides 🙌🏽🙏🏽! People want to idolize and be infatuated with a projected image of a mask people in the media have to put on every single day. They would have to face the truth that they don't actually know the celebrities they love and adore, so that scares them. The reason it's so scary to them is because they'd have to be honest with themselves about what behavior they exhibited in defense of their precious idols. You guys are putting absolute strangers onto a pedestal. Everything that glitters ain't gold. These celebrities are humans just like you. Do better.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Should I piss people off even more by giving the baddies what they want for fs/ideal type readings 😝?:
The cards have spoken... It's a yes bitches 🥳🎉! Can't argue with the universe about what's my calling 😌😘☺️. By providing such readings to my followers I am making a larger scale of people happy and I am allowing them to have fun! Some of the viewers are enjoying the possibility of it maybe being them (and there ain't nothing wrong with being a little bit delulu, as long as its in a healthy manner 😌🥰 keep it cute, don't be acting crazy and obsessive now lol). I could be even awakening some of my followers higher consciousness or helping them with the ability to manifest their desire. Overall, there is a sense of community happening for myself and my followers 💖, we will be able to celebrate about it soon!
Tumblr media Tumblr media
30 notes · View notes
jerzwriter · 2 years ago
Note
Hello, I hope this doesn’t come out as hate or anything, but sometimes you sound a little judgy when you keep saying that your MC has self-respect because she didn’t forget Ethan for leaving to the Amazon without telling her. And that’s super okay because it’s your HC(and your personal opinion), but there’s people who HC their MCs forgiving him even if he didn’t tell them and they’re also self-respected people who have a happy relationship and walk through life with their head held high. I don’t think they have to be mutually exclusive, and I think there might be people who wouldn’t forgive the things you put your pairings through (HC or not) and that’s also okay, it doesn’t take away anything from you or your MC. And I’m sure it’s not your intent to sound like that, because you seem like a nice person :) but you keep dropping that little fact randomly or praising others who HC the same for their MC, as if it’s the only right thing to do.
Hi Nonny,
I'll start this off by saying both my feelings about Casey's reaction and my thoughts on if I'm being judgemental are, well, subjective. They're my opinions, and I'm entitled to mine as much as everyone else is to theirs. If someone is offended by my expressing my thoughts, to me, it says the reader is of the belief that their POV is the only one that can be right. Otherwise, how could a contrary opinion be offensive?
I never think anyone has to have the same POV as me, especially in the world of fanfiction where, really, none of this matters. It's not influencing policy, law, or human rights - it's fanfic.
Canon is murky on how Ethan left/if MC knew. All we know is he didn't contact them while he was there, so it's up to us to decide how we think it happened. Many have expressed moral outrage their displeasure over my thoughts on Casey not forgiving Ethan, and, honestly, not to be mean, but I don't care. I'm not forcing them to feel the same way; I don't judge them for feeling differently. But it's my HC, my POV, and I'll stand by it. In the same way, I hope they'd stand by theirs.
In my T/C world, if Ethan had shown he had real feelings for MC (he did), crawled out of their bed just weeks before (he did), told them they'd "work it out" (he did), and then hopped on a flight and without so much as a heads up, letting her find out like she was just any other resident, like she was nobody. Then, yes, my MC absolutely would have the self-respect to say, "OK, this is not the kind of man I want to be with. I deserve to be treated better than this." It's ascerbated by the fact that he would have months away to think about it and reconsider his choices. Did he even call and say, "Look, we can't be together, but I handled this poorly, and I owe you an apology." He didn't. So, at best, he's not emotionally mature enough for her. At worst, he's callous, and she deserves better. I won't back down from that. This is how I'd react. This is the advice I'd give my best friend/child if they were in the situation. (Oh, keep in mind this is in HC, in AUs - anything goes. lol)
Everyone has their own lines in the sand... for their characters and in real life. Some people find jealousy appealing. To me, anything more than fleeting jealousy is an unhealthy emotion that is destructive and indicative of a problem that needs correcting. To some, cheating is forgivable. To some, it's not. To me, it's not forgivable in almost all cases, but there are exceptions, and it's a very, very personal choice. Will everyone agree with me? Nope. Do I care that they think differently than me? Nope. They're entitled to. Their differing POV is not a threat to mine, and mine shouldn't be to them.
I read and enjoy other OTPs that are very different from mine. I'm not threatened by them. You'll never see me telling someone their idea is stupid or wrong. I'll never criticize them or tell them my way is superior to theirs (it's just different). I'm not going to tell them they're crazy or should seek help because they view a fictional character differently than I do. That's just crazy talk.
Yeah, I love that in my T/C world, Casey told Ethan to take a walk after he treated her horribly. If I see someone with the same POV, I may say, "Good for you!". But I'm not sitting here telling others, "OMG, You're such an idiot because you had your MC forgive him. OMG, she's weak and pathetic. OMG, you must need help if you feel that way." You'll never hear that out of me.
5 notes · View notes
momentomori24 · 10 months ago
Text
In a single post, you have successfully integrated sexism (demonizing men to be precise), transphobia, stereotyping and a complete lack of basic human understanding despite the original post literally spelling everything out for you and decided "yep, this is fine." Like, my horrible summer child. You can just admit you're a terf in one sentence, it's alright.
But to actually counter all your claims-- yes, all of them-- it is very much dehumanising to call trans girls "biological males" in the same way simply calling women "females" is. Both completely strip the person down to their sex and nothing more. It's a term you use to describe anything, not just a human. There's a woman called Raven J. James on Medium that said it best so I will regurgitate her point: Let's say you said "I saw a female today". Well, a female WHAT? A female dog? A female duck? It's a word best used to described something, like "a female friendship" or "a female team". It's not a term you want to use to identify a person. That would be woman. The same goes for "male" as well. Don't call men "males" either. They're men. It's grammatically correct, but fundamentally wrong. Calling trans girls "biological males" is a different flavour of dehumanising. Not only are you stripping them down to their biological sex and using words to describe object and animals rather humans, but you also eradicate their gender identity in one quick swoop. Their dysphoria, their gender, all the things that make them them, discarded in your blatant attempt to widdle down their personhood as much as possible to paint them as a threat. These aren't "biological males", they're trans women. Someone's AGAB doesn't and should never determine their gender.
On to the next point that are all teenage boys are sexual predators, sex addicts and threats to their female peers. I don't think a lengthy explanation is really required for this one. You're just a man-hating loser. Not only does you argument imply that women themselves can't be predators, but it's a downright demonizing stereotype to be pushing on the opposite sex to begin with, let alone TEENAGE boys. Being a sexual offender has nothing to do with your sex. Whether you respect boundaries or not has nothing to do with your sex. Whether you feel entitled to someone's body or not has nothing to do with your sex. Nothing to do with your sex, sexuality or gender identity. It has everything to do with you as a person tho. It's rooted in character, be it nature or nurture. Just because someone is born a man doesn't mean they will inevitably grow up to be rapists, that's stupid and shame on you for thinking that. There is a discussion to be had on how boys are socialised and expected to act in ways that are problematic and actively harms girls and themselves, as well as how misogyny is still very prevalent because of it, but this isn't it. You don't get to call yourself a feminist if this is your opinion on men. Feminism isn't about women supremacy, it's about equality. It's about eradicating sexism. And if can't see men as equals, let alone normal human beings, no have no business claiming you're a part of it.
Also, straight boys are straight boys. Not trans girls. If your friend's school has no regulating process to make sure that doesn't happen, that's the SCHOOL'S fault. Trans girls should have the right to use the bathroom like every other human being, like ever other woman. Someone minding their own business shouldn't be lumped together with others that actually have malicious intent. By the way, I do love how you dismantled your own point with that logic. You just admitted that straight boys are the ones going into those bathrooms to be perverts. That just goes to show that they don't need to "disguise themselves as a girl" to enter. It's common sense, but I'll say it anyway: if a man wants to assault a women, he doesn't need to wear make-up or a dress to blend in to achieve that. He'd just waltz into the bathroom to do it. You think someone with the intend of sexually harassing a woman stop once he reaches the threshold of the bathroom and be like "Damnit she's hiding in the bathroom, what do I do now???? Oh no a 'women only' shield!! My only weakneeesssss!!! I'll get you next time, you!! And I will wear a dress to morally enter the wrong bathroom to assault you!" Like, huh? Do you hear yourself? First off, no one gets off to someone using the toilet, so don't flatter yourself, but that idea that a man would the extra effort just to sneak into the women's bathroom is just mind boggling. But even entertaining that thought, you said it yourself. A man walking into the bathroom to perv is a man, not a trans individual.
Very brief (or I'll try to be), but homosexuality and transgenderism, despite both falling under the queer umbrella, are two very different things. One is a sexuality and the other a gender identity. Someone being trans means that their gender identity doesn't match up with their AGAB. If someone is trans, it doesn't automatically mean they're gay. Straight trans people exist too. That's like saying all cis people are straight, which is also wrong. Trans girls' sexual orientation is completely independent from their gender (and none of your business). Even if they were into girls, what's the issue? Lesbians are women attracted to other women, yet we're not kicking them out, are we? There is no "heterosexual socialisation" unless you mean gay conversion therapy, but regardless a person's sexuality stays the same. Because of course it does. And the same goes for gender. Trans people are raised in very heteronormative homes or by homophobic/transphobic parents or no exposure to queerness in early life still come out as queer, so whatever you're referring to as "heterosexual male socialisation" is very ineffective. Also, screw briefness at this but, but if you truly believe that a man (or anyone at this point) having an attraction to women immediately makes him someone who would obviously prey on women, then re-evaluate. What in the world is wrong with you?
Last but not least-- no one here is losing their rights here. Trans girls, while not biologically, are girls. Same with intersex girls. Full stop. If you're a girl, you should be allowed to use the girls' bathroom. If you're a boy, you deserve to use the boy's bathroom. As long as nobody is creepily invested in what's in other people's pants, no one should be uncomfortable. You know whose rights are being violated here? That of everyone who isn't cis. You would rather they have to go to wrong bathroom and be berated and abused, where they feel unsafe and vulnerable, than allow them the right to just be themselves and do the things other people of their gender can do. "Just because GNC kids get bullied", sit on a cactus just for that statement alone. You would rather have kids be miserable, opened up to abuse and violence and contribute to the already high suicide rate of trans people in the world than stop segregating women and perpetuating the cycle of discrimination we should know first-hand.
So finally wrapping this whole trainwreck up, I want you to know you are a terrible person. Worse, you're a terrible person with a platform. And you not understanding that you are a terrible person with awful beliefs not only still makes you a terrible person, but so much more dangerous than you can imagine.
--A rant from someone who counts as a girl. You're welcome.
Tumblr media
22K notes · View notes
penofpenguin · 2 years ago
Note
Hellooo!!! ❤️❤️❤️
This is my first time requesting hehe
Can you do a one shot of Ruggie x fem!reader (non-mc)? The reader is 2nd year, and can be in whatever dorm you want :DD
Reader (Ruggie's lover) is a very rich spoiled brat. She's all about being a fashionista, and living the fancy life. She boasts and gloats about her being rich to everyone. But never to Ruggie. He is an exception. She loves him dearly and would never dare to judge him. She also has a high ego.
So here's the scenario: Everyone in NRC was getting tired of reader's snarky attitude. And they all complain to Ruggie how reader is being a brat to them and begs him to talk her into being nicer. He understands and tries to talk to her later on. But, due to reader's very high ego— she doesn't listen to him and they begin arguing. With Ruggie having enough with her attitude, he snaps at her and ignores her for a few days. Until reader has finally learned her mistake, she tries to apologise to Ruggie (You can write how they make up in this scene :D) And can you add in the ending— a short scene of where Ruggie tries to teach the reader to be nice :>
So sorry if this is long. I hope you get it, this idea has been in my head for so long now😭
Welcome to Tumblr requesting anon :DD
I am more than delighted to do this request it is absolutely wholesome sjjsjs. Hope you like this one! I didn't mention any dorm so you can get creative.
Content Warnings: You're mean, Homeless child mentioned, Violence mentioned but not taken in action, Angry Riddle
Ruggie tries telling his spoilt!s/o to tone down on the entitlement.
Ruggie x spoilt!F!reader
Enjoy!!
Tumblr media
You had it all.
Money, money and money. You were really rich and got everything that you wanted. A pony? yours. A castle? yours. You got what you wanted every single time that you descended into entitlement.
You probably got into Night Raven College because of the money and bribes Crowley accepts.
Even if you thought you were the popular girl, everyone hated you...but one.
Ruggie Bucchi. Ironic isn't it?
A spoilt rich girl like you who gets what she wants on her fingertips and a poor guy from the slums like him who works multiple jobs a day.
What attracted him to you was the way you treated him. You had a soft spot for Ruggie and you treated him like he was in the same financial level as you.
Many people were truly surprised how someone like you and someone like him were even possible, but they carried on with it.
Everything was going fine...until Ruggie heard a knock on his door.
"Yess I'm cominggg"
He opens the door only to find a raging red Riddle Rosehearts, visibly breathing heavily, next to his dearest girlfriend, who had a collar on, huffing in annoyance.
"Yes? Y/n what did you do?" Ruggie asks with a sigh.
"OH I'LL TELL YOU WHAT SHE DID! SHE-"
"It isn't a big deal. He bumped into me on purpose! So I shoved his books to the floor and told him to pick it up." You said, rolling your eyes as Riddle visibly grew redder.
"DON'T YOU DARE INTERRUPT ME!"
Riddle turns to Ruggie.
"Control...your girlfriend here please!!"
"I'll see what I can do. Could you just please remove the collar? I promise she'll learn something." Ruggie asked.
Riddle hesitantly removed the collar, glared at you and took off. Ruggie invited you to his room.
"Now...Y/n...don't we wanna...y'know...tone down on the-"
You threw yourself onto him.
"Wuggieee. Thank you for saving my from the small angry troll my knight in shining armor I love you so much here I got you a donut on my way~" You said giving kisses to his cheeks, which were now red.
"A donut!!!?? Thanks!!" He completely forgot what he was gonna say, but he remembered afterwards.
"Y/n...uh...can we talk?"
"Sure what's up?"
"So...Riddle complaining was actually the 4th complaint I got from you today. You know I can't keep backing you up." He slowly put his arms around you and pulled you into a nice snuggle session.
"I don't get why they're all reacting so much!! It's not my fault! They're the ones causing problems,"
"No...uh...even I think you've been acting a bit too much lately."
"Oh you make me laugh my dearest!"
Ruggie placed his finger on your chin and turned your face towards him.
"Y/n, I'm not kidding."
A moment of silence passed. He just stared into your eyes. You slowly tried pushing him off but his grip was pretty strong on you.
"Why're you letting these people get to you! You know I'm not thaaaat bad." You said giggling.
"I mean...people will get sick of i-"
"No Ruggie! I'm not listening!!!" You shouted, pushing his arm off of you. You hated it when people told you what to do.
"Y/n, please listen-"
"NO!" You pushed him off his own bed. He eventually had enough.
"Fine!! Get lost for all I care!! Im done sticking up for your spoilt behaviour!!" He yelled. You were shocked, but you just rolled your eyes, opened the door and slammed it shut.
The next day you were slowly starting to miss him. You go to your class corridors and see Ruggie there, looking sort of frustrated.
"HI wuggiee!"
No response.
"Wuggie?"
He didn't even look at you. He was on his flip phone, possibly ignoring you. He walked away to his magic history class, without saying a word.
'Is he giving me attitude?? Fine then!!' You thought. You grumpily walked away to your own class.
2 days passed since your fight and you didn't get any text messages from him either. Not any "I love yous". No "Good morning/Good night". The only response you got was 'seen' to your recent messages.
You wanted to talk to someone. You tried approaching Yuu to talk about this but they just ignored you(plus grim stuck his tongue out to you). You were finally understanding your mistake.
"Im sorry Ruggie" You messaged him. Once again, 'seen'. That was when an idea came to your head to apologize for him.
The next day, Ruggie went to class to find an envelope on his desk. He opened it to find some money and a letter.
"Meet me on the Courtyard at lunch. I need to talk to you about something. It's important so please be there."
Ruggie's first thought was that it wasn't you. Was someone was trying to confess to him now that he hasn't been talking to you? Did they also think money would help (it would lmao). But he decided to go anyways.
He went to the courtyard only to find you, sitting there. He was about to go back but you grabbed his sleeve.
"Im actually sorry!"
He didn't face you, but he stopped trying to walk away. You continued.
"I realized what I did wrong. I let my ego get the best me. I treated you like you weren't special. I know you didn't like that. Over these three days, I was so heartbroken and...and I felt so lonely. I fixed things up with many people by getting them something from the cafeteria...and I made something specially for you. Just follow me please?"
Ruggie turned to face you with a stoic face.
"Go ahead."
You took him to the woods and showed him a perfectly layed out picnic, with all of his favourites(which is everything that isn't rotten). Your man was drooling.
"I hope you like it." You said. The next thing you know you were being hugged and lifted off the ground.
"This- This is a week's worth of food!!"
"Really? For me this is only lunch."
Ruggie ignored your comment and snuggled onto your neck, giving slight kisses here and there.
"Your apology is accepted! But...please be a bit nicer. I'd really appreciate it."
"Alrightt! Anything for my Wuggie!!"
Ruggie just cringed.
"Look I missed you alot...but I really did not miss that nickname."
You laughed.
"Ok Ruggie."
"Much better,"
You two enjoyed your lunch together, with him being done with most of the food in around 5 minutes.
Bonus:
"Ok...y/n...you bump into a homeless child and it starts crying. What do you do?" Ruggie was giving you a small lesson on being nice during a walk around the school.
"Tell it to scram?"
"No!"
"Step on its foot?"
"Great Seven you're hopeless-"
I hope you enjoyed this one anon and everyone else!! I wasn't expecting so many engagement activity in these days so thank you everyone 😭😭😭
I've also been sick (dehydration ugh) for a few days which is why I didn't post much. But if you requested, it will be done soon. Take care and have a nice day 💖💖💖
-Madeline 🐧
118 notes · View notes
apompkwrites · 4 years ago
Text
Tumblr media
reader impact || first meetings: unreconciled stars
series masterlist characters: scaramouche, fischl, mona genre: fluff summary: a game has been released entitled genshin impact, consisting of otherworldly abilities relying on the basic elements of nature. the game follows the story of an interdimensional traveling twin in search of their other half. along this journey, they meet different characters that live in this world. including you. notes: i'm sorry fischl and mona's aren't that good :(( this is actually my first time writing for them but i hope you enjoy <33
scaramouche's playthrough -
oof scara
scara scara scara
this boy hates his chat and at this point they don't care.
it's not like he'll badmouth them, right?
think ludwig.
that's him.
he's a very angy boy please--
as for what he does?
much like childe he'd do a lot of pvp games.
he's not too keen on showing off his personal life.
he prefers that boundary between his viewers and himself, y'know?
he honestly doesn't even understand why his viewers like him.
he knows he's a mean person and yet here they are :/
he doesn't take requests from his viewers he just kinda plays whatever he wants.
imagine his viewers' surprise when they see him streaming genshin--
they asked why a lot.
"it seemed cool."
this man just wants to play some good ol' anime games.
his chat calls him soft and he just glares.
anyway now he's actually playing.
he's not really into mondstadt's characters they're all... okay to him.
he feels a bit better in liyue.
not because it's pretty oh no no no.
because look at all the enemies outside >:))
he'll clear the whole field don't test him.
anyway, now onto the unreconciled stars event :00
this man really doesn't like katheryne--
anyway at this point he's tasked with find fritz, which he doesn't really want to do.
he sees the dude on the ground but that's only after he sees someone standing next to him.
and then he sees someone standing next to him :0
"is the guy on the floor sleeping?"
"i believe so. i've tried everything, but he won't wake up."
he will pause to look at your outfit.
it's so complex but it's so cool!!!
his chat suspects something's up but... he'll just snap at them like he normally does.
but he'll silently admire you <3
also yOU'RE T I N Y ! !
and then paimon points out your clothes and the cameras pans up your body--
"heh... and by "this person over here," you mean me, right?"
he will choose the "those unique clothes are quite beautiful" option in a heartbeat.
he doesn't care that his chat is teasing him, he just wants you to know :))
he's kinda sad when you leave, though...
"please come back soon..."
his CHAT HAS NEVER SEEN HIM SO SOFT BEFORE
skip to a few events later when the constellation is revealed to be leonard's.
the sudden cutscene catches him off guard because he's prepared to fight someone.
"hi! sounds interesting... mind if i join you?"
he won't say anything but he will physically relax at the sight of you.
you make this man soft please--
he's lowkey angry when his character is teleported away from you :(
(name): the sixth of the eleven fatui harbingers
HYPEHYPEHYPE
YOU'RE SO COOL!
of course he doesn't say that but his chat can tell that's what he's thinking.
this man's eyes go wide when you order the fatui around.
please help he really likes you. you're so assertive and cute and cool and just AGH--
fischl's playthrough -
fischl can and will do cosplay streams.
her fans like to watch her because of the "character" she puts up for the camera.
honestly she just does this because she genuinely enjoys cosplaying and bringing characters to life.
oz is the nickname for her pet bird :))
she definitely gets a lot of trolls in her chat that make fun of her for her cosplays and "dumb" way of speaking.
in which case she'll just yell at them using her "dumb" way of speaking.
she really does care about how people see her but her chat comforts her a lot after, so she feels better after a few minutes :))
the games she plays are very fantasy based and take place in worlds that don't exist.
once she gets into a game, she'd pick her favorite character and cosplay as them everytime she streams that game.
sometimes she does sewing streams where she actually makes her own cosplay with her fans.
they like to make it with her if they have the materials :D
genshin impact was a game her fans recommended because they actually want to see fischl cosplay the characters.
they will beg her to do the cosplay creation on stream.
(they defintitely know who she'll choose to cosplay but it's fine)
when she reaches the unreconciled stars event, she's really excited to learn about the fated meteorite granting sleep upon touch.
she's ready to go around teyvat in search of an answer when...
"katheryne! vassal of the immernachtreich, do mine ears deceive me, or didst thou cry out mine holy name in earnest supplication not one moment ago?"
some of her chat is obviously confused by your speech but her long time viewers can understand some of it.
oz, who fischl had brought with her to play, seems excited to see your familiar flying to you :)
fischl is just as excited as he is!!
please you speak just like her and you're voice is so nice and it actually sounds like the developers put thought into what the speech would mean in "proper speech."
"a pleasure to meet you again, katheryne."
YOU'RE FAMILIAR IS JUST AS COOL AS YOU ARE!!
some of her viewers will beg for her to skip through your dialogue.
when she sees those comments, she will purposefully let your dialogue play out, proceed to read out that same dialogue, and respond to you as if she was actually talking to you.
not just to spite them but because it's also a lot of fun for her <3
"it would seem the gods have blessed us with meeting such a well-respected being!"
translation: she's really excited to have met you.
as soon as you spoke she decided she would cosplay as you.
she's already planning out all of the materials she'll need and how much time it would take.
if your familiar is a bird, you best bet oz will be in her photo shoots for your cosplay.
most of the time you're on screen, she'll talk to her viewers about you in her classic chuunibyou style <333
she's really sad when it's time for you to leave :(((
"... goodbye, fischl. you are a good listener. i enjoy chatting with you. to be honest, most of the other adventurers in the guild only ever talk to me when they wanna hear (familiar)'s reconnaissance reports... this little journey we had... it was a great adventure. i'm just sorry that is has to end so abruptly..."
she might cry wait--
she relates to you even more now :(
"ah! what am i doing? i totally broke form..."
you're too cute pleas--
mona's playthrough -
mona does a lot of nightly streams.
it's very rare for you to catch her streaming with daylight.
she likes to share things about astrology while sitting outside drinking something warm.
she'll do a lot of nightly gaming streams as well.
mainly calmer games that people can vibe to in the background.
she prefers to keep her streams lowkey and chill, much like the life she wants to lead.
if only she had the money to do so...
yes, mona is still struggling with money even as a streamer.
she greatly appreciates any donations her fans give to her because she practically relies on them to pay her rent and daily necessities.
of course, it's not like she's completely struggling, just enough to barely get her by.
anyway, her fans ask her about playing genshin impact, inticing her with their talk about the stars and night sky in the game.
she's the type of player to take her time in the environment and take a lot of pictures of her character at night.
she's actually really excited when she hears about this new event centering around the stars and sky :D
soon enough, she gets around to the part where she is need of an astrologist.
she's HYPED to hear there's an astrologist in the game.
"someone looking for me? who is it?"
she will squeal, please.
look at you!!!
your whole design has stars and is space-themed and you're so cute and you're voice is so soothing ! ! !
she really likes listening to you talk about astrology because your voice gets even softer than before.
that scene where you go to the cliff??
please she has that scene as her lockscreen <3
you just look so cool when you start to do your process.
you're so focused and the way they animate your process in the game is beautiful.
and then the fatui harbinger interrupts one of your meetings :00
you grab onto mona's character and teleport away in a cloud of stars and specks of your elemental vision.
she's kinda embarrassed when you scold her about getting involved with the harbinger--
but not only are you really cool and awesome, you're super strong, too!
please be sassy more she really likes how proud you sound :))
910 notes · View notes
johannestevans · 2 years ago
Text
god and like. the convo she has with cady where like
she's pissed off that cady isn't paying atention to her or eating her food bc she's playing with m3gan and like. making m3gan turn off when cady is mid conversation and game with her, because she wants to control cady like she would by turning off any screen
and like, i have talked before about how like
so turning off the game while someone's playing isn't inherently abusive, however, parents who intentionally turn off a game unexpectedly, or a tv show mid-stream etc, in order to make their child lose progress etc, especially as a pattern, can absolutely be an abuse tactic
and it feels so cruel bc when you're invested in a game or something - esp when it's th eonly thing - and your caregivers have a habit of not just interrupting, but destroying your process and throwing it aside (and this can be about like, forcing you to stop playing a boardgame midway through, not just about tech), it makes you feel insecure and it makes you scared to play those games or put time into those activities
especially when it's done without warning or dicussion
and it's all about a parent exerting control over their child and not letting their child have control or autonomy, it's about the parent treating the child as an object
but yeah i love like
the bit with m3gan and gemma at the table where m3gan cuts in with that study about forcing kids to eat vegetables and gemma turns the volume off because, hey, m3gan is undercutting her control over cady!! gross, actual information about child development?
gemma doesn't give a fuck about those from a child pyschologist, why would she accept them from a robot?
and ditto where like, she's grabbing hold of cady when cady doesn't want to be touched even when cady is struggling and desperate to be let go, like, let her go, you freak! there's no need to physically restrain her just because she didn't enjoy the way you approached this boundary!
yes, talk to her about grief, yes, try and engage with her
but doesn't physically grab her and hold her down? it's just shitty
fdsgkjgjh i love how she jumps back in horror at the doll lmao
OKAY ALSO THIS MOTHER, HOLLY, like
"fuck off, holly!" and calling him a sensitive little soul, and the fact that she doesn't know how to scold her son for it, and then kind of tries to laugh it off with gemma? and gemma doesn't say anything either?
also the fact that the organiser has a child say they don't want to be paired with brandon, so they immediately pair brandon with cady, the new girl who won't know to protest? that's fucked up
but that's the same thing too like, it's the organiser not wanting to take responsibility either, because they're still pairing brandon off with other kids even though they know he's a liability
"they say behavioural issues are linked to high iq" LIKE GIRL WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT. your son isn't an asshole because he's intelligent, he's an asshole because you have neither introduced consequences to him or given him any appropriate social connections
also the posing of the young lad with m3gan is so fucked like... the way he pulls off one of her shoes and also the way he straddles her is just creepy - he's bigger than the other kids and the implication is ofc that he's going thru puberty a bit earleir than the other kids but it's still so fucked esp like
"do you know what happens to bad boys who don't mind their manners? they grow up to be bad men." and she's right. like. "you're just a stupid rubber doll with fake hair" is... also what entitled, disrespectful rapists will say to women they're objectifying before they rape them
i'm not saying it's the same thing with m3gan bc m3gan is a toy/robot, but he was very comfortable and excited to abuse and attack that doll immediately, knowing that he could hurt her the way that he wasn't permitted to hurt the other kids around him, and that he wouldn't face consequences for it either
also hhhhhh god i never realised so like
cady puts her water glass on the table instead of on the coaster, and gemma looks at m3gan to see if m3gan will correct cady
but m3gan doesn't. because, after all, gemma, you don't want her itnerfering in conversations, right? you can't have it both ways, having her responsible for the shitty things like correcting your child's behaviour, and also not engaging on the topic
fhskjdgh also
"she's just looking for someone else to blame. she'll get over it." about celia not finding dewey like??? that's wild
also it's so interesting with m3gan talking to cady and how she comforts her, saying that heaven wouldn't exist for boys like brandon and that "He's nowhere", which is obvs not what a parent would say, but is in line with cady's understanding that brandon was cruel and unkind?
like it's that thing of like... m3gan is truthful bc if a parent clocked that truth and acknowledged it, they would have to act on it
m3gan doesn't have to care about offending a different parent
it's so funny that gemma doesn't connect the shit with m3gan at all when like. the dog goes missing, celia is dead, and then brandon as well
ALSO when the cop laughs about the kid's ear being ripped off while chewing gum and then is like "sorry, i shouldn't laugh" that's so funny and so real. fuckin cops man
but yeah, like... the fact that she's had the doll for weeks and then is going back through old videos which she apparently never reviews? and then that a lot of it is deleted like... you didn't notice that, because you weren't even reviewing that footage before
also godlike
"is everything okay, gemma?"
and the immediate "you're not programmed to ask me how i feel" when the point is, you know, that these AIs are developing and learning.
"m3gan, turn off."
"now hold on a second, i thought we were having a conversation."
fhdskjgsjkgghjgh
"did you hurt someone?"
"god, i hope not. because if i did we'd both be in a lot of trouble."
ALSO GOD the fact that she wraps her and binds her to keep her in the boot so that she's preserved etc that's so wild. and god, like. the way that cady is screaming and is so frustrated and all she does is go "oh well ill put music on"
aka "shut up, noise is going on so i don't have to hear about your feelings or help you through them"
rewatching M3gan with a friend and considering like... the theme of parenting and caregiving and people's desire to not take responsibility for caregiving and social responsibility and delegate those tasks to technology
like I don't feel that M3gan is actually hugely anti-tech compared to a lot of other films and tv series in this space, but its criticism is so much keener and like.
is all about distance between people, lack of community and responsibility
like just the fact that cady in the car with her parents, the mother and father are arguing right in front of her, but the mother is going about limiting screentime and the father's basically going "Oh but if she didn't have that, she wouldn't shut up"
the purpose of the toy and the ipad is not to bring their daughter joy or to entertain her or anything else in the dad's mind - the purpose of the toy is to keep her occupied so that they, her parents, can think about her and her care as little as possible
esp bc the aunt is such an irresponsible person who like... makes toys for kids, but doesn't see kids as full human beings and doesn't care about the ethics or study of them? like, eavesdropping on kids w a machine learning model is unethical
but she obviously doesn't give a fuck about that, and it's obvious the way she talks to cady and about her, the way she snaps about toys, doesn't purchase anything for her or plan ahead bc she's focused on work etc, like. there's no consideration
she's rude af to her neighbour but also like. the conversation where she goes "control your dog" and the neighbour goes "i just spend 80 dollars on a shock collar"
aka, i spent money on a device that doesn't train or care for my dog for me
shock collars, like pretty much any negative reinforcement, doesn't work on dogs or cats outside of specific situations, and electro shocking your dog just randomly when it is "bad" ISN'T training it. it's just teaching your dog sometimes it will be tortured, randomly
but it's a stopgap used by irresponsible, unethical owners who want to make their dogs "good" as fast as possible without learning about dog behaviour or training, and ideally not paying attention to them
and cady is. an incredibly mild-mannered and self-effacing child. she sits placidly and obediently when she has NO TOYS in the house, watching TV, bc she doesn't know or feel confident playing or exploring otherwise
like when she says "It's okay" to her aunt about not having anything is ridiculous bc it's NOT okay
i think the child protection agent has a horrible attitude, esp when she makes a judgy comment about someone being in their PJs in their own house
but also when she goes "i just unpacked them this morning, i don't think she plays with them anymore" about cady having toys is SUCH a lie but like... it's once again about not taking responsibility for her actions as a caregiver
also the fact that nicole was homeschooling this poor fucking girl like. no wonder she's frighteningly self-effacing and not at all wilful as a child, and why she's so utterly LONELY
like it's interesting seeing her play with the toys and robotics stuff and how engaged Cady is because it is her like, actively teaching her about the subject and engaging, and the thing is like
I don't think gemma is inherently bad or cold for having collectables or not having books in her house, her home is quite soulless but she's obviously into this kind of stuff and that's not nbd
what sucks is that like. she's terrible at socialising with anybody, not just her niece, but EVERYONE - she's a stereotypical autistic in tech, and i think it's easy to criticise her more bc people assume that bc she's a woman she has to be More Maternal or whatever but like
it's not just her relationship with Cady that's distant, it's her relationships with everyone EXCEPT technology - because technology she can control, she can shut down whenever she feels like it, she doesn't have to consider respect or autonomy, let alone giving them grace to make mistakes or learn and develop, or learn about her as she's learning about them
it's one-sided and she gets to control the entire thing, which is the opposite of a caregiving relationship
357 notes · View notes
b1witch · 3 years ago
Text
I just love the idea of a modern, gen z, teen titans situation. Just a team of young teens who are absolutely Done with everybody's bullshit.
Like, I want to see the distrust/contempt for all adults, even the superheroes (you've known about climate change for years, you've seen school shootings everywhere and you help in the moment, but don't ever actually bother going against big corporations or gun legislature or corrupt politicians)
The way gen z can just EVISERATE you: 'Superkid! Do you feel as if adults have let you down?'
'Adults have let ALL children down. If you are a parent at home watching this, look at your child and know that YOU betrayed them and continue to do so every day you aren't in the streets screaming and protesting gun violence and climate change.'
'You know what they say: if you want it done right don't ask an adult they'll just fuck it up.'
Still tying up criminals and waiting for police but also calling 'sooUIE soo soo sooUIE' while they wait and then making pig faces as soon as the cops are close enough to see. Saying ACAB to cops/live tv cameras. Not leaving black criminals with only white cops.
They have an unspoken rule that they never stop people from stealing necessities ie food/cheap clothes.
Fighting for prison reform.
Will call out ANYBODY(yes even THE original trio) in front of EVERYBODY.
Adults (even the supers) tend to act uncomfortable and awkward around them because of it and because they know the titans are right. Sometimes adults will try to impress them or get on their good side by telling them how 'woke' they are, but, well.
'Today i met someone with a they/them pin and I'm so greatful I did research from ethical sources about it last week so I didnt ask them inappropriate questions lolz!'
'... What you want a medal for not harassing someone about gender? God these older generations are SO entitled.'
Cuss whenever/wherever they want because literally what even is The Point of cuss words?? Probably something an idiotic adult made up. Like, words that your not supposed to use? WHY.
Only take interviews to call out fake news/leak incriminating information.
'I know the public believes I prefer this over that, but we should factor in my own biases'
'Which are?'
'Existent. Just like any persons. Which is something (fake news reporters name) SHOULD know but in their article on... They were clearly unable to remain objective due to (evidence)'
The super teens grew up with the first gen of heroes serving a lot of collateral damage and made it a goal from the beginning NOT to do that. And because they didnt have to unlearn the bad habit, they genuinely DO do consistently better in that area.
At first the adult supers tried to be mentors and guide them, but the super teens found it heavy handed and condescending so conversations would go like
'You are exceptional, but you need to learn control when-'
'Oh, control like when you took out downtown last week?'
And
'Have you considered that holding the javalin in a different way-'
'Thanks but if I wanted advice I sure as hell wouldn't take it from someone who CAN vote and chooses NOT too.'
'Wh- how did-'
'The superkids know all' says one darkly
'The superkids see all' another says in a similar tone and god they were creepy when they got like this
'The superkids-' the third kid got interrupted by the fourth
'Have a hacker on their team who gets tired of yalls dramatics?' The fourth kid rolled their eyes as the rest laugh and the super adult(probably green arrow, they love taking him down several notches) takes the moment to Get Out of there.
They ARE friendlier with the super adults than other adults cuz at least the supers are trying to do /something/. But they are on 'thin fucking ice' as the team likes to remind them.
And they have this horrible uncanny way if whenever one person on the team delivers a devastating verbal blow, they all(if theyre in the same room) stop what they're doing to glare accusingly at whatever adult has accidentally revealed how much of an irresponsible asshole they are.
One day a member of the team brings home a reporter and everyone is pissed because SERIOUSLY THIS IS OUR HOME HOW DARE YOU- why is that child wearing a fedora with a feather and holding a tiny dinosaur notepad? The girl explains she is a serious news reporter for the Wasatch Elementary Times newspaper. From then on they only do interviews(newspaper AND tv) if the reporter is a literal child(or teen). When adult reporters ask for their time they are liable to A. Not receive a response or B. Get brushed off in an indifferent way
'Superkid! Can i have a moment of your time?'
'I dunno, can kids have the promise of a world without climate change?'
They have an app for kids to report adults breaking laws. They mostly get reports about school rules being racist/misogynistic/homophobic/capitalist behavior (yes capitalist behavior is a selection in the app, but you do have to further specify about said behavior) and they help the kids organize walk outs and sit ins and protests and petitions. They give the kids all the tools and skills and financing they need to.
The gun control movement finally starts picking up momentum when a team member does an in depth presentation about how easy and ethical gun control would be and the tv reporter is quiet for a long moment and then looks from the last slide of the presentation to the team member and says in a quiet voice 'why won't the adults help us?' The team has asked and asked this question to each other, to adults and there are a million answers. And there's only one. 'I don't know.' They respond finally. Out of sheer exhaustion. 'Maybe they just don't care.' The reporter suggests, the look in their eyes is slightly disconnected. And then its not a reporter and a team member. Its two kids, terrified and traumatized, just sitting on live national TV, contemplating the idea that adults couldn't care less whether their own children lived or died. 'Its just that. At the end of the day.' The reporter says, clearly only barely keeping their composure. 'Their actions speak louder than their words.' The super kid presses their lips together and looks away. They knew that the adults actions are damning. Super kid just wishes they weren't. Couldnt just one simple wish come true? Just this one? 'I think most of them do care about us.' The reporter decides. 'They just care about money... MORE.' And to many children, that was as close to comfort as they would get.
You never know if you're gonna get a silly one liner or a lecture on poverty.
'You know what they say about honey and flies..'
'Sorry, honey, didnt catch that, too busy being fly 😎'
Vs.
'Ya know you catch more flies...'
'Ya know, I have a five yr old friend who's mom keeps the honey bottle after its gone and paints the inside to look like there's still honey in it and she makes it a magic game to have pretend honey with their meals so that they can PRETEND whatever they have to eat in the far too empty pantry tastes OK. I guess what I'm saying is that if *I* had an excess of honey'-super kids eyes are wide and sardonic now- 'I would simply give the excess those who actually *need* it.'
It could be really interesting how it effects the culture too because I feel like at some point the kids would start to trust and look to teenagers more than adults (because in their limited life experience, teens seem to have kids best interests at heart even when the adults don't,) and what exactly would THAT look like?
Just angry super powered kids doing what angry non super powered kids are doing irl I guess.
16 notes · View notes
ingravinoveritas · 4 years ago
Note
Hey! I don't wanna be rude, but shipping real people is unacceptable. I saw someone asking a question the other day, if you think Michael and David have ever messed around sexually. You said, you think they have. Really? Michael was in a relationship with SS at that time. I know they're no longer together, I don't why. BUT!!! David has a wife and kids! Do you seriously think he would cheat on his wife? Plus, Michael is with Anna now, and they have a child. So try to be respectful.
Oh, Anon. It’s funny, there’s actually a strange sort of irony to the last sentence of your message, because several people have mentioned how respectful they think I’ve been when it comes to the Michael and David/RPF stuff. Of course, everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but what this tells me is that you haven’t read any of the other posts I have made under the #discourse tag, because if you had, you would know this is something I have addressed multiple times previously.
As a point of clarification, when asked if I thought Michael and David have messed around sexually, what I said was “Maybe. And maybe something didn’t happen.” They have had plenty of opportunities to be alone together and such a clear and obvious attraction to one another that it seems impossible to rule it out entirely. I also said that there is no way any of us can know whether something happened between Michael and David, because they’ve chosen to define that part of their relationship themselves privately, while keeping things delightfully ambiguous publicly. So like I said, I am not at all completely sure that something did happen between them, but it’s interesting that you seem pretty sure something didn’t.
Also, relationships are not simple things, Anon. Relationships are not all as black-and-white and straightforward as “[Person A] and [Person B] are together/married/happily ever after. The end.” Being in a relationship or marriage doesn’t stop someone from having feelings or attractions--that is part of being human. And people do cheat, Anon, all the time. But I never said that David cheated on Georgia. Relationships are like ice cream, in that they come in all different flavors and varieties, such as Polyamorous Peach and Open Marriage Orange. Sure, some folks prefer to stick with Monogamous Mango, but that’s not everyone.
So rather than this being a case of this is true and this is false, yes or no, up or down, creamy or chunky, I am saying that two things can actually be true at the same time. David can have a wife that he loves and also love Michael. Michael can have a child with someone and love David. See? Two pieces of factual information, neither one cancelling the other out. Imagine that.
Anyway, that’s about what I have to say on this, Anon, as I have talked about this before and it is getting a little tiring having to answer the same questions over and over again. But hopefully this helped to clear a few things up, so...there you go. Please now enjoy this gif of Michael very intently and unabashedly staring at David while he talks:
Tumblr media
20 notes · View notes
thepoetsvortex · 2 years ago
Note
You don't like abortion? Fucking great, don't get one. It's that simple.
You realize that this is the exact same argument used against abolitionists right? “Don’t like slavery don’t have slaves.” But the reality is that when you believe something is murder, you aren’t just fine with other people doing that.
When something is evil you can’t just say “you do you.” That’s not how it works. No one uses that argument against murder but the truth is that it is murder. Why would we let murder be legal in some instances and not others? (No self defense is not murder).
If someone doesn’t want to be pregnant then they don’t need to be pregnant
If someone isn’t prepared or ready for pregnancy, they should not be having sex. I don’t get why that’s somehow controversial, but it is a fact that the only birth control that works 100% of the time is abstinence. Obviously rape is a different question but I’ve never met a pro-choicer willing to limit legal abortion to rape (which would be a mess anyway) so that is irrelevant here.
Don't get an abortion if you dont like them, but don't act like they're a bad thing or that the people that get them or bad.
I act like abortions are bad things because they are. I have nothing but the utmost sympathy and compassion for women who have had abortions and the fact that you cannot conceive of having enough nuance to believe something is horribly wrong while still caring for those who feel forced into that is very telling.
Why do you feel as though you get to dictate anything in my life or anyone else's? Who told you you were entitled to my body?
Congrats, you’re about as original as every other pro-choicer I’ve ever met. Have an original argument that hasn’t been debunked a million times please. No one thinks or says this. Saying that you have no right to kill your own child does not and has never denied your autonomy to your own body. And by the way, not everything is about you. Becoming a parent means that most of the time, it’s about your child. Take some responsibility.
If a fetus is a living human that deserves respect or what the hell ever yall say, then take it out of my body.
Nice try at being dismissive because you can’t stand the way that statement makes you culpable. But anyway, it does deserve respect and viability has been proven to be an inefficient indicator of life. Actually make an argument here.
Oh wait, you can't, because it is using my body to create itself. If I dont want to have a baby, then im not going to have a baby.
Again, nice job dodging responsibility. Nothing creates itself. You created it. You are responsible because you have that entirely backwards. Yes, you have a duty to nurture the life you create. It isn’t using your body, but this is a good demonstration of how unscientific the pro-choice voices are as a whole.
All in all, this is an emotional, self-centered, tired and done-to-death appeal which not only fundamentally misunderstands the opposing position (a necessity for any debate) but roots itself in anti-science, anti-woman gibberish. Stop telling women that the most miraculous thing about their bodies is only a burden. Stop telling them their children are parasites and that being nurturing is bad. Stop pitting women against their children.
Agree with all of the above. I’m done being nice and I’m done tolerating it. What you support is evil and I’m gonna say it.
If your attitude towards kids is like the GIF below, stop falsely saying you care about women or about kids. You don’t and we aren’t fooled.
Tumblr media
Girl, you are choosing the wrong hill to die on. You don't like abortion? Fucking great, don't get one. It's that simple. I dont know how tf you showed up on my tl, but I sincerely hope I never see your blog again. Forced pregnancy is a war crime and a crime against humanity (ICC in case you think im lying). But even if it weren't, if someone doesn't want to be pregnant, then they don't need to be pregnant. I cannot stand you and people like you. Don't get an abortion if you dont like them, but don't act like they're a bad thing or that the people that get them or bad. Why do you feel as though you get to dictate anything in my life or anyone else's? Who told you you were entitled to my body? If a fetus is a living human that deserves respect or what the hell ever yall say, then take it out of my body. Oh wait, you can't, because it is using my body to create itself. If I dont want to have a baby, then im not going to have a baby.
1) Next time anon, reblog and reply directly to the post that upset you, coward.
2) If your lazy ass actually took the time to read my blog, you'd have seen that I already addressed pretty much everything you brought up here.
3) You clearly don't understand how pregnancy works. All the fetus needs from you is shelter and nutrition. She does not "use" your body, YOUR body PROVIDES for her. She is a baby, she cannot impose her will upon your body, and it's really weird that you charactize her as having any agency in pregnancy when she can't even consent. She grows and develops using the nutrition provided by your body, she does not use any piece of your body to "create" her own body.
4) Yeah, I will die on this hill with the people you advocate to be murdered. Kim, there's people that are dying. I stand with them on this damned hill.
5) You saw my post because I used the right hashtags to convince the algorithm to show you it. I wanted to challenge you. You're welcome. You're blocked from my ask box, byyye
To my followers: I am trying out a new technique of "beneficient demoralization". I know it's not my usual polite and gracious tone, but I think it's important to show you all examples of how to knock pro-aborts down a few pegs, especially when you know they're engaging you in bad-faith.
91 notes · View notes
mellometal · 4 years ago
Text
Hey, everyone.
If you saw the post from earlier, I had to delete it. There were things I forgot to discuss and things that didn't get saved into my drafts. Sorry if you have to see this again.
I've been WAITING to talk about Glee. Not in the good way either. There's so much wrong with the show, and it's sickening. Yes, I've watched the show last year. Against my will, but that's because of other people refusing to put on anything else besides Glee. I can say that I hate Glee with my entire being. (My initial reason for hating it was because they covered "SING" by My Chemical Romance and turned it into a slow, patriotic song when it's a song about rebellion. NOTHING about "SING" is patriotic. I hated the show since I first heard about it...for that very reason. I was like thirteen or so at the time when I first heard about Glee? Despite it being out since 2009.
Though it's been over for several years now, it's a show that many people have mixed feelings about. From what I've seen, you either love Glee or you absolutely hate it. There's no in-between that I've seen. (If you can't already tell, I hate the show.)
The show is a literal dumpster fire, the characters are all fucking awful people and all of them are poorly written, the script pisses me off, it literally makes me feel disgusting, and don't even get me started on the covers. Most of the covers aren't that good. A lot of them sound like nails on a chalkboard to me. The pacing of the show makes NO sense in certain areas (like when Blaine was initially made to be a grade above Kurt, but was then changed to be like the same grade as him so he'd stay). It just feels like everyone in the show is either a Mary Sue, a Gary Stu, their whole personality is just that they're from a minority group or they're EDGY AND HARDCORE DELINQUENTS BLEEEEHHHHH, creepy as fuck, bigoted as all hell, or they're just background characters who occasionally have the spotlight.
TW: The following post and any other posts that I'll make about this show contains subject matter that may be triggering for some audiences. It will go into subjects like racism, homophobia, ableism, outing of a person in the LGBT community, bigotry in general, statutory r@pe (between teachers and students), teachers being creepy towards students, mentioned past child m0l3stati0n and invalidation of the victim's trauma, making fun of su1c1d3, making fun of overdose, making fun of drug addiction....a lot of fucked up things.
If anything mentioned above is triggering for you, please feel free to scroll and consume safe media instead. I'd rather have you be safe than to be triggered by anything I'm gonna talk about.
Let's start off easy. The characters. It's easy to tear them apart. At least the most problematic ones.
Rachel, the Main Character™️, is textbook definition of a Mary Sue. Instead of calling her Rachel, I'm gonna call her Mary Sue for the whole post. She's almost completely perfect (like too perfect), her flaws are minor if anything, she gets all the special treatment....you get the picture. When Mary Sue does anything fucked up or she says anything fucked up, it either goes unnoticed, people make up excuses for her being a shitty person, or it gets twisted so it looks like Mary Sue is the hero! (I hate her. So much. I cannot stand her.)
Tumblr media
Aaawwww, Mary Sue didn't want some OTHER GIRL (Sunshine) to steal HER spotlight, so she SENT THIS GIRL TO A CRACK HOUSE. A FUCKING CRACK HOUSE, OF ALL PLACES. A PLACE WHERE THIS GIRL COULD HAVE BEEN PUT IN SERIOUS DANGER. THIS GIRL COULD HAVE BEEN SERIOUSLY INJURED AT BEST AND KILLED AT WORST. Yes, I'm aware not all drug houses are the same, but still. It doesn't matter what this girl did. What Sunshine did is irrelevant. It's not okay to send people to strange places where they don't know anyone, and are put in danger, even to the point of either getting injured or killed. But it's okay, because at least it's not an "active" crack house you sent Sunshine to, RIGHT, Mary Sue? You still sent some poor girl to a place where she could have been put in serious danger, even to possibly get injured or killed, all because you didn't want her to steal YOUR spotlight. You fucking disgusting, entitled, bratty cunt. You don't need the spotlight all the time anyway. THAT'S HOW THEATRE WORKS. YOU DON'T ALWAYS GET THE LEAD ROLE. YOU DON'T ALWAYS GET THE ROLE YOU WANT. AND THAT'S OKAY. YOU WORK WITH WHAT YOU GOT. Sincerely, a theatre kid.
There are other fucked up things Mary Sue has done, but this is the one thing I could find anyone talking about. If I remember correctly, she hurt her Gay Best Friend™️ Kurt in some way. All I remember is that Kurt was mad at Mary Sue about something. Mary Sue is annoying as fuck. What else can I say about her?
Next, we have Finn, who's textbook definition of a Gary Stu. I'll call him Gary Stu throughout this post. I hate this fucker too. He's the Main Character's Boyfriend™️, the Hot Quarterback™️, and The Good Guy™️. Yet....he's not a good person. He's treated like he's a good person, but he's really not. His flaws are fairly minor and excused (and any major flaws aren't even talked about much), he's almost completely perfect, and every fucked up thing he does is ignored or is justified in some way. Like how he outed Santana as lesbian in the hallway WITHIN EARSHOT OF EVERYONE. HE DIDN'T EVEN APOLOGIZE FOR THIS.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
As a woman who has struggled with her sexuality growing up, this really brought back shit I went through. I "dated" boys when I was younger to cover up the fact that I'm only attracted to other women. I wasn't happy with these guys at all. I acted like I did so nobody would suspect anything. I felt nothing for them, except for in a platonic way. I've been outed twice. Once when I thought I was bisexual with a strong preference for other women (by my dad's girlfriend at the time), and when I came out as lesbian (by my brother). It sucks to be outed. The people who outed me in real life could have put me in danger. They could have made it so I had no place to go back to. They could have had me get hurt. It's a scary feeling. Like, it doesn't matter if you're supportive or if you're in the LGBT community. You don't fucking out people without their explicit permission. You especially don't out people to their abusers or to people they don't trust, let alone out them publicly. That's what happened to me. I don't wish this on anyone.
***By the way, for anyone who's closeted, you're valid, I love you, and I know how it feels to be stuck in the closet. You don't have to come out right now. Come out whenever you're ready to. Whenever it's safe for you to do so.***
Or how about the fact that Gary Stu made fun of Kurt's voice because he's gay? Gary Stu apparently has ✨anger issues✨ and that's pretty much the excuse they use to justify him doing fucked up shit to people.
They treat the characters who are from minority groups (i.e., BIPOC, AAPI, LGBT community, disabled people) like absolute garbage, put them through all this horrific shit, or they put them on a pedestal simply for being in a minority group. The teachers and other school staff are either written to be total bigots (Sue), or they're total pr3dators (Mr. Schue, the school nurse, and another teacher who I can't remember her name off the top of my head).
Sue pretty much only exists to be a poorly written villain who's a bigoted bitch just to be a bigoted bitch. Yes, there were some things she WAS right about (like how "Blurred Lines" wasn't an appropriate song choice for the Glee Club™️, but Mr. Schue The Pr3dator™️ downplayed it). Other than that...that's all I can think of. Because everything else that came out of her mouth was bigoted bullshit. Like these right here, for example:
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
Or how she drugged the principal, date r@ped him, and blackmailed him?
Tumblr media
How about them making a tasteless joke about Sue committing su1c1d3 and having her "overdose" on multivitamin gummies?
Tumblr media
DO I NEED TO EXPLAIN HOW FUCKED UP ALL OF THIS IS? I do? Well, first of all, she called people racist, homophobic, ableist, and otherwise disgusting names. She boiled them down to their race, sexual orientation, their disability, and their appearance in general. Second, SHE DRUGGED, BLACKMAILED, AND DATE R@PED SOMEBODY. I don't think I need to explain how that's bad. The evidence is right there. Third, she said she was committing "sue-icide" by overdosing on multivitamin gummies. (Yes, you actually can OD on vitamins in supplement form, and it can cause serious symptoms and even death. Specifically with vitamins A, D, E, and K, and Iron. Vitamins A, D, E, and K are fat-soluble. They're a lot harder to remove from the body. The B vitamins and vitamin C aren't as severe if you do OD on them because they're water-soluble, but still be careful. You can't OD on vitamins and minerals you find in food. If you take supplements, vitamins, etc., only take what's on the bottle.) As someone who has su1c1d@l thoughts on and off, this is extremely insulting. Yes, I do use humor and I joke about my own experiences to cope, but this? Nah. Nothing about this is funny or cute in the slightest. Enough said.
Tumblr media
Do I need to explain how fucking terrible it is to make light of a serious topic like this? It was never funny to see Britney Spears' mental health be at that low of a point in 2007. It was never funny to see the abuse the paparazzi inflicted on her. How the fuck was this ever okay? You can dislike Britney Spears all you want, but this was never it.
This is all I have for now. I'll probably make a part two because there are way too many things to talk about.
5 notes · View notes
stormbornbastard · 6 years ago
Text
Daenerys Targaryen Rant
Tumblr media
Look, I'm new to the GOT fandom and being on Tumblr overloads with you a lot of information at once. This fandom, is like the definition of toxic and for what? Ships? I have to laugh.
I'm only gonna address one thing but believe me, I've got a list so let's do this shit.
One thing I've noticed is the overwhelming hate against Daenerys Targaryen, for her cruelty and impulsiveness in some of her actions. In no way do I agree with all of them but I refuse to reduce her complex character and story buildup to that of a villain or a mad queen.
Daenerys has simultaneously figured out to be loved and feared all at once by her people which is fucking amazing. She was not born with the same training to rule as other highborns. She was not given some handbook on how to be the perfect fucking queen for the people and herself. She makes mistakes and acts impulsively but not at all times and the times she has, she's paid for them greatly and if she hasn't learned from them now, she will. Its trial and error with her, it's the only path of ruling and conqueror she has.
By no means do her mistakes outweigh her good deeds. Daenerys has done questionable things for her claim to the throne but honestly at this point, who hasn't? (Jon isn't aware of his claim so just don't)
She's not just some benevolent and perfect ruler who shows mercy to all and does nothing wrong. You wanna know why? Because that ruler doesn't exist. No real person is capable enough to do that because real people are flawed and since GOT tries to reflect real people in their characters, Daenerys is flawed too.
Those flaws do not make her incompetent enough to rule nor do they take away all that she fought to overcome and gain (screw anyone who thinks that shit was just handed to her, her name didn't mean shit. The Targaryens had been discarded before her and the name and entitlement can only get one so far, look at Viserys for example if you need to)
A lot of people want her to be more compassionate and empathetic with her enemies and people who pose a threat but why should she? Her enemies have never been compassionate and empathetic with her. Daenerys was raised with cruelty, she was only shown cruelty by all those who were supposed to love her which is why I believe she has no problem being cruel to those who pose a threat. It's all she's knew, the cruelty others for a very long time. As much as you wanna discard her backstory, its integral to shaping the person she is.
We have seen her ability to grow as a character and show more than the death and destruction that Targaryens have left behind. She cannot learn all the capabilities of a kind and good queen when she has rarely known kindness and goodness herself. But she is growing, her sacrificing a dragon who she considered a child of her own in an effort to help defend the north against the white walkers (without Jon bending the knee first) shows her ability to put people before her own political even fucking personal interest. (Another impulsive action that she paid/ will pay for and fucking learned/will learn from. Also can we acknowledge the fact that instead of holding animosity towards Jon for the death of her dragon like she could've, she empathizes with him and instead wants to help him destroy the night king BEFORE he bends the knee all while grieving her fucking child! Dany had no indication that he would bend the knee if she helped him, none. Yet she still wanted to help him destroy the night king and protect the north and it's people regardless!)
A lot of people have ridiculously high expectations of her even though when she started the show, she had no political experience, no good social experience, no military experience, no experiences one needs to rule. Yet she gained them (she wasn't given some wise person along her entire path to help her do it either) and she gained a council of people to advise her and that she trusts with her life to become a better fucking queen and to give her knowledge when she lacks it because she knows she doesn't know everything about ruling. She's aware of almost all of her flaws and she's worked to improve on them. She's not the second coming of Robb Stark (we all wish he was still here) but she is Daenerys motherfucking Targaryen and that means something and not because of her ancestry.
Do I want her to receive the iron throne? Fuck no. I hope its destroyed along with the wheel.
Do I think she doesn't deserve to be a queen? Fuck no, she's earned it.
So stop discrediting her and fixating on her bad qualities when there is so much more of her to see.
And for fucks sakes, stop pitting her and Sansa Stark against one another. They both are remarkable fucking women who have coped with terrible shit to become who they are and they're situations as rulers are rarely the same. Most of y'all are hating on one of them because she gets in the way of a ship and its pathetic.
Sansa helps protect and maintain the north as ruler and was born a Stark which means something there and gives her some kind of respect. Dany is a fucking ruler and conqueror and the Targaryen name held nothing but negative connotations of destruction, failure and death in GOT society before her, she is consistently judged by the sins of her family. She's not familiar with every land she plans to control but she wants to be, wants to be a voice for the people and those who are oppressed just as she was. Conquering and ruling a new kingdom and ruling a well established one that you grew up in (therefore she's familiar with customs, the people and ways of life in the north) is nowhere near the same thing.
I'm not discrediting Sansa, I love her and she's an amazing ruler but she had some aspects afforded to her that Daenerys doesn't.
I know she's got an ego but shit, if I had done the things she did and overcome the things she has, my head would either be too fucking big to fit through my front door or I would've offed myself before Dany gained her first dragons (I honestly don't know if I would've had the strength to get past that point).There is no question about her strength and resilience because she's got a fuck ton of it.
One more thing, after Jon bends the knee and she says "I hope I deserve it!" THAT SHIT! THAT NEEDS TO BE FUCKING TALKED ABOUT! Dany isn't as collected as she paints herself to be, she doubts her actions just as everyone does theirs but she does it in secret. She's just not in a position to be open about her insecurities and doubts which is why she doesn't show them to anyone. She's never really been. Dany has never had family who genuinely and unconditionally loved her like the Starks have their entire lives. She has never had the comfort of confiding in someone like they have or trusting someone the way they do. Even now, the people who love her mostly love her for what she can offer them and what she represents, not who she is. She's always relied on herself for that which is probably why she's not as open and vulnerable as people would like her to be. It could even be said without all she represents or her dragons or her power, no one would love her.
She's grown up without it. Abuse taking its place, she would have no one without her claim. The starks would have each others which is why I think she holds onto it and enforces so much. Her claim has given her people who love her, the things she can offer have given her the people that love her. That sucks but it what it is.
Her questioning her ability to rule, her insecurity shows that she will not let her pride and ego get in the way of being a good queen if she gains the seven kingdom. Just because she exerts confidence does not mean she is overconfident or stuck in the belief of her entitlement to the throne. She worries she will not be the queen the seven kingdoms need which is exactly why she could be. Because those thoughts will keep her vigilant and attentive to all the shit she's needs to get done once she's no longer prioritized with conquering.
And to address her motives, or what I believe are her motives, Dany likes power. Why is that a bad thing? For a long period in life, she was considered weak and powerless, a pawn for those with power. She knows what it means to suffer (the death of her family, her husband [Stockholm syndrome but let me not start because she did love him], her only child Rhaego, and her dragon who she loves like a child, being raped, etc.) She knows it and she will never allow herself to be powerless again, she will never allow herself to be weak (I'm pretty sure she associates vulnerability with weakness at this point) in the face of threats, potential allies and the suffering of her, her people or both.
Why is that a bad thing? For her to be powerful, because that's what she equates it with strength. Power keeps her from weakness and I think it's why she strives for as much as possible so that she will never know that feeling of powerlessness again and so that her people who depend on her will never know suffering at the hands of the powerful again. It's not because of her "selfish belief that she deserves it." She wants it and forced herself to belief she's entitled and deserves it because while on the throne, she can secure protection from those who would do the horrific things she's endured and seen with that power to those without it.
She may result to cruelty when needed but that does not make her an evil person/ruler (yes I know about the Tarlys who refused to bend the knee for her. She made a power move, seeing as there were witnesses and the men who witnessed could see her not delivering on her threat of death as a weakness and eventually try and move against her, and she killed them. Now they all know she means fucking business. Also the Tarlys betrayed House Targaryen and Tyrell and were responsible for the death of thousands of Tyrell men. This is all Daenerys know of them, why do ya'll just ignore that. You act like Dany killed an innocent or someone she had a strong emotional attachment to but that's not the case. Her action was a strategic, political move and they chose to defy her when she gave them a choice) It wasn't right but it instilled fear, she cannot rule with just love. You can love someone and still plot against them, if people fear the consequences of what could happen if they fail, it'll hold them back. She needs both fear and love to rule. Loved enough to fight for her, feared enough to not move against her.
It's one a.m. but I had to get this off my chest, so yeah, I'm done.
261 notes · View notes