#And her being flawed makes her development/character more satisfying to me I guess
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
cak31ssuperi04 Ā· 2 years ago
Note
thoughts on annika for the character opinion bingo šŸŽ¤
My favorite barbie character ever personally.
Tumblr media
6 notes Ā· View notes
dyke-ified Ā· 3 months ago
Note
ok ive finished :) and i do have thoughts. area unknown has been really special. its a rare bird in terms of minecraft content and theres just so many important stories being told there. the way it relates to the wider sunship canon or whatever its called is amazing, and the otehr ppls content like oli's dedicated grinding, moonzy's beautiful buildings or graaavel's awesome lore (HIS LORE VIDEO WAS SO GOOD. IT WAS SO FUCKING GOOD. THE MUSIC????? YEA), was all so amazing to witness.
BUT i do have some criticisms if you dont mind me sharing. none of it is with ill intent and i understand why the decisions that were made happened but i still think its worth pointing out.
im disappointed with how aimsey and scott's arc was left off, because i dont think it reached a satisfying conclusion at all and the loose threads they left didn't feel like a culmination of their relationship. aimsey and scott's conversations are some of my favourite parts of the lore because their relationship is so, SO interesting and really worth exploring. so ending it by saying "scott just got bored and went back to hell" was not a good move i feel. i really wanted to see something more there.
guqqie does touch on hera's influence when she discovers the grave but to be honest i dont understand why she was allowed to get married to aimsey and have a happy ending. hera has made a point of dooming them in every single universe and she just loves torturing her little experiment, and her influence has continued into season two with egging aimsey and oli on with the lab, so i really don't understand why guqqie was able to seperate herself from this and later get married when that has never been allowed before
i guess that everything was intentionally left pretty open ended so things could change in future, guqqie did say she'd write something up later this week which could give answers to what i mentioned above. and who knows, maybe in the years guqqie and aimsey were split hera could have been defeated in some way. maybe guqqie went back and confronted her or something idk. i would really like to see something like that though. and of course that open-endedness leaves room for aimsey and scott to do something which would also be great. but yeah those are my less great thoughts about the finale. but do not be fooled just because it wasnt absolutely perfect didnt mean i didnt enjoy it/think it was bad
FORTUNATELY it has given me a great window to start working on that au because i really want to develop scott and aimseys arc, explore aimsey's feelings as a demon and the horror that comes with that, and his relationship to hera because the one time they interacted always gives me chills. so i think the finale was flawed but thats ok because now i can go in and do awesome stuff with my own ideas for a bad ending. because i like hera cannot let the characters rest. ineed to be stopped hehehe
but yeah apart from that i did really enjoy the finale. it did feel like area unknown. the party, never have i ever, michela being hilarious and caitees being weird, and of course heartbreaking sunship lore. it genuinely gave me the same warm feeling as when i was watching through all those vods from 2022 when they were just messing around or screaming at each other in the rain. area unknown needed to end. no one seemed to want or have the time/inspiration/motivation to do stuff on it anymore, and the characters needed a conclusion and to be let go so they could just be in their own right. i'm glad that its done. it was really special. i cant wait to see what everyone does next :3
i agree heavily on the scott and aimsey topic, i wish we couldā€™ve gotten more development of their relationship or seen scott in s2 bc there was a psrt of his house i think somewhere and then he was never mentioned again iirc, but they were probably both too busy or something to do anything which is ok iā€™ll just make it up in my head :3
and i hope there is a bit more of something w hera and auguqqies whole thing and how hera allowed ausunship to get married, or how all that went. iā€™m just really curious
anyways love u sneef thank u for liveasking to me this has been very fun :333 <3 im rlly glad u liked area unknown!!!!!!!
2 notes Ā· View notes
waffleweirdo Ā· 4 months ago
Text
Finished Path of Radiance!
In total it took me about 40 hours and about 4 months (oops)
Long story short I really liked this game both in story and gameplay!
Now for some more rambling thoughts:
*will include spoilers*
Gameplay:
The best way that I can describe what I enjoyed about the gameplay is a good balance of information. I think there are a few other facts that could play into this (this is the fe game I went into the most blind, and difficulty). But in general I felt like there was a good balance of systems and ā€˜calculationsā€™ to manage in battle. My wording here might be nonsense, but essentially there arenā€™t as many active effects like engage or fates that make everything overwhelming. While there arenā€™t as many automated tools like the later entries (I.e aggro indicators in three houses) have so I was more so forced to check possible outcomes manually. Now this probably isnā€™t ideal if you really want to play strategically, but I donā€™t! I typically play these games mostly around feel, and this method of play helped me develop a kind of sense of what would likely happen and a greater familiarity with my own and enemy units and I thought that felt cool!
Another possible contributor to this was the difficulty. It started off a bit difficult while the units were all still weak, then got pretty easy in the mid game (except daybreak!!), before getting fairly tough again around the last 6 or so chapters. Which is a curve I generally like! There were moments I wouldā€™ve liked it a little bit harder, but it was overall very satisfying! (For context I didnā€™t use any bonus exp until after chapter 18, and only used the majority of it around chapter 27).
Some other minor gameplay things. I thought the mechanics surrounding laguz were cool too manage! Plus they tied in really cool thematically and I felt awful attacking helpless laguz (the fact that the game made me feel awful is a good thing!). This game was the fe game that I knew the least about going in, and I managed to only ever use a guide for one chapter which I enjoyed, but I do think it means I probably missed a few recruitable characters. Iā€™m pretty confident I missed at least three, though it mightā€™ve been more oopsā€¦ I really liked the use of bonus exp it was a cool way to still level up units that donā€™t necessarily earn a bunch naturally, or buff underperforming units, and as a sort of difficulty regulator. Gameplay wise my favorite unit was far and away Astrid. She snowballed so quickly! I was shocked when Titania had beaten her for most victories. I though item management was a bit tight sometimes, but not really in a good way. The fact that the shop had different stock every chapter was a bit frustrating, especially when it would remove basic iron weapons so units with only an e rank couldnā€™t train at all. But overall it wasnā€™t too big of a deal. I also didnā€™t realize how op forging was until the mid to late game, but thatā€™s on me.
Characters:
Ike was BY FAR my favorite fe protagonist. His consistent attitude and personality made him a lot more interesting. Although he didnā€™t have the most complex character journey ever, he was still enjoyable, and always felt like an engaging character, rather than being one note. He consistently works well with the rest of the cast, and the way that he serves as an optimistic force, yet isnā€™t without flaws is really nice. I think heā€™s just a great character! I also really like that he didnā€™t turn out to secretly be a noble. I think this is the first fe game Iā€™ve played with a protagonist who is not a noble, or secretly revealed to be a noble!
I feel very guilty that I never got around to using Soren much and thus didnā€™t get many of his supports because he was really interesting and I wouldā€™ve liked to see how he grew past his outward facade. But even so the story did a good job of depicting his growth, even if it was somewhat subtle. I also guessed that he was the spy for Daein, but nope!
Elincia was great too. She never stood out to much, but throughout the whole game she was engaging, and it was nice to see her growth. Again I didnā€™t get to do too many of her supports which was a bummer.
I guess this is as good a place as any to talk about supports. The way the PoR levels them up based on deployments? Very cool! Really excellent idea. The support conversations I read? I really liked them! Why. WHY is there a limit on supports? And even more so why was it so strict? Essentially what this meant was I was constantly juggling which characters I cared about the most, and if I ever found another character whose supports would be interesting? Well letā€™s hope I have a bunch of supports left, or I have to change my mind, or hold supports for possible future characters. Itā€™s awful, and locked me out of probably 3/4 of the supports I was interested in. It sounds minor, but honestly really did affect my play through a lot. I care about supports and having them so limited sucks!
Jill ended up being one of my favorite characters. I was interested when she first joined us. I think my first thought was, ā€œwhat is she up to?ā€ But her story of learning the truth behind Daeinā€™s propaganda and choosing to oppose them was really touching, and equally tragic. The dialogue where Mist offhandedly mentioned that she and Jill were about the same ageā€¦ augh!! Plus Jillā€™s supports with Lethe were great, another reason why supports shouldnā€™t have bee-
I think the other character I want to highlight is Nasir. Heā€™s one of my favorite characters for sure, and his story is really intriguing. Even learning his relationship with Ena and his ultimate motivations it still feels like thereā€™s so much we never got to learn. Especially never having truly gotten to reconcile with Ikeā€¦ itā€™s just really interesting. He traveled with us for so long, and always felt like a mystery, and even finally understanding him came too lateā€¦ itā€™s just really neat.
Story:
The story of this game was interesting, the main plot thread was helping Elincia retake Crimea, which was a fairly standard though well done story. Archetypal in a sense. But largely what I cared about was the story in regards to the laguz and beorc. Which isnā€™t necessarily a bad thing, just interesting to note. In that sense some moments of the plot felt largely unremarkable to me, while some moments where the two converged felt really interesting. The discovery of the truth behind the Serenes massacre and Enaā€™s reunion with Rajaion stand out to me. In the sense itā€™s sort of hard for me to reconcile my thoughts on the story. I didnā€™t really care much when Ashnard was killed, but the moment I understood who Rajaion was I wanted to cry. I think largely PoRā€™s story is a success, as there were more moments that I was interested than moments were I was disengaged, and I do generally think of the story fondly.
Having the full vision of how the conflict between laguz and beorc was depicted I think there are probably some things to critique, especially in some moments where it doesnā€™t feel as far reaching as it largely should. As in sometimes it feels like that racism is far too easily ā€˜solvedā€™. But ultimately I think it fits PoR. PoR isnā€™t trying to be a story that is incredibly focused on fictional race relations. But it doesnā€™t shy away from including and exploring them, and out of the fire emblem games Iā€™ve played it does by faaaaaaaarrrrr the best job. Plus it does have many really good moments that I think are genuine standouts.
As an aside, Iā€™d also like to say that the info system is really good at adding in additional plot relevant reactions by characters, and showing the effects of your actions on civilians and the world around in such an excellent way. I canā€™t exactly pinpoint why, but some of my favorite moments just come from the one off interactions in it with characters you know youā€™ll never meet again. Itā€™s cool!
I guess my thoughts of PoRā€™s story and themes come down to the fact that they are far from perfect, but ultimately succeed where it matters.
Sequel?:
I wasnā€™t really sure what to call this section, oops. This is the first time Iā€™m playing Fire Emblem game that has a clear sequel! Which I know even less about going in than PoR.
Knowledge going into PoR: It has the Black Knight and Ike
Knowledge going into Radiant Dawn: It has Micaiah
So these are a collection of things Iā€™m still wondering about which might possibly come up in the sequel? Though even if they donā€™t Iā€™m satisfied with the conclusion of PoRā€™s story, and leaving loose ends isnā€™t a bad thing.
Ahem. Whatā€™s going on with Goldoaā€™s royalty? Whatā€™s going on with Sephiran? The apostle is a descendant of one of the warriors that fought the dark god? Is the Black Knight really dead? And most importantly Chekhovā€™s amulet that contains a literal dark god???!??!?!? Anyways Iā€™m sure that will end just fine.
One of the moments that Iā€™m most interested in was Ikeā€™s final fight with the Black Knight. I took one look at the battle forecast and saw that Ike would immediately die, remembered Ike and Titaniaā€™s promise and booked it. Though I really wonder what might have happened if I did something different. Though honestly Iā€™m okay just wondering.
Aaaaand yeah. Thatā€™s everything I can think to say at the moment. I liked this game a lot! Iā€™m not quite sure how Iā€™d rank it among the fe games that Iā€™ve played. But Iā€™m very excited to play Radiant Dawn and see what that has in store.
4 notes Ā· View notes
lynmars79 Ā· 1 year ago
Note
Fun meta asks for writers! 1.Tell us about your current project(s) ā€“ whatā€™s it about, howā€™s progress, what do you love most about it? 17.o you think readers perceive your work - or you - differently to you? What do you think would surprise your readers about your writing or your motivations? 20.Tell us the meta about your writing that you really want to ramble to people about (symbolism youā€™ve included, character or relationship development that you love, hidden references, callbacks, etc.)
Menace. Bully. Fiend. How dare you--
So in 2022 as we were awaiting the finished dark knight zine and prepping for FFXIV Write 2022, roommate found a submissions call for a zine called "I Spade You" that would be about Ace romances. I've had a pseudo-idea floating in the back of my head for a long while about a middle-aged pair in a fantasy setting who despite being from opposite sides of a conflict end up having a connection, and tried to form it into a 2500 word story for submission to this zine but it wouldn't gel.
Well, the problem really was that it was gelling...into something longer. I'd been thinking of it in the background long enough that it took on a life of its own. But things at work heated up, I already had fandom writing projects, so I shelved the idea and lost track of that zine. I didn't think of it seriously for months.
Then Bigolas Dickolas Wolfwood entered the chat with their sincere promotion of This is How You Lose the Time War, a novel I had heard about but hadn't read yet. So I read it, and while "people from opposite sides of a conflict form a connection" is the only similarity to my story, the visceral language in that novel really got to me.
I found myself opening the Spade folder again. And writing random scenes from various points in a 25ish year relationship between 2 people thrown together by outside machinations into a marriage neither wants, falling in love despite that, but the cracks form and irreconcilable differences arise due to duty and pride and a lifetime of nationalist education, a long separation and obsession, and then fate puts them together once more, relearning who they are now After All That.
It's arranged marriage friends to lovers to enemies to friends to lovers again. I keep forgetting to add straight people to the supporting cast. I have 3 distinct parts--early relationship, 15 years apart having life happen, then a disaster that makes one of them relearn all they thought they knew while the other hurtles toward their long-waited fate. I have world building and character profile documents. A family tree for one group for Reasons. Avatars for some characters thanks to BG3 and Picrews. So. It's...drafting. It's currently pretty indulgent and a lot of Vibes, little in depth research yet. There's probably over 100k words written but I dunno how many total and a lot of them will change.
It's still an ace romance between the leads. And between another ace character and her bi partner. Whether people think it "counts" or not will be where there's a perception schism, I guess. If I ever get any of it out. It won't be for everyone and there's probably things I'll get wrong and also some of the characters, even protagonists and heroic figures and loveable folks, aren't always the best people and have major flaws and issues.
There's also a teeny bit of "this aspect of this character's story in X other media annoyed me and also I see where there's some influence from this author of Y media I like so wonder if I could write something similar to be more satisfying for me" thrown against the general idea of "I have this one OC that's been bopping around in my head for years" and it became "but what if they kissed and that's all they do while being in love because they don't need more than that? And there's also a lot of familial and platonic loving relationships in there? And framed around an epic fated adventure?"
Still really developing recurring themes and callbacks, but there's a running joke with flicking balls of paper at someone's head, and a poignant bit about family home entryway markers and mourning rituals that may run throughout.
2 notes Ā· View notes
ismahanescorner Ā· 2 years ago
Text
Hani and Ishuā€™s Guide to Fake Dating | Book Review
Author: Adiba Jaigirdar
Genre: YA Contemporary, Queer YA
Publisher: Hodder Childrenā€™s Books
Release date: 25/05/2021
Rating: 4/5 šŸŒŸšŸŒŸšŸŒŸšŸŒŸ
Synopsis:
Everyone likes Hani Kahnā€”sheā€™s easy going and one of the most popular girls at school. But when she comes out to her friends as bisexual, they invalidate her identity, saying she canā€™t be bi if sheā€™s only dated guys. Panicked, Hani blurts out that sheā€™s in a relationshipā€¦with a girl her friends absolutely hateā€”Ishita Dey. Ishita is the complete opposite of Hani. Sheā€™s an academic overachiever who hopes that becoming head girl will set her on the right track for college. But Ishita agrees to help Hani, if Hani will help her become more popular so that she stands a chance of being elected head girl.Ā  Despite their mutually beneficial pact, they start developing real feelings for each other. But relationships are complicated, and some people will do anything to stop two Bengali girls from achieving happily ever after.
Review: TW//: islamophobia, racism, biphobia.Ā 
I had high hopes going into this one cuz Iā€™ve already read this authorā€™s debut and loved it dearly; and guess what? this book didnā€™t disappoint!Ā  I really liked the story! Itā€™s a well done fluffy sapphic YA romance that featured two amazingly flawed characters!Ā  I had my personal gripes with both of the mcs at times and their decisions; however, I understand theyā€™re teens and theyā€™re supposed to make plenty of mistakes!Ā  What made me dock a star from my rating is that I wasnā€™t satisfied with how the conflict at the end was resolved, or rather swept under the rug. I wish if Hani gave us a little glimpse and spoke about her friendship status!Ā 
Definitely recommend it!
Tumblr media
2 notes Ā· View notes
pokckygamewithbatman Ā· 2 years ago
Text
GLTAS Rant
Currently in a slump over GLTAS, I canā€™t stop watching it. Itā€™s just perfection, I am blind to all flaws, of which there are none because itā€™s so good. The characters, gorgeous, including those added solely in the show (Razer, Aya). Iā€™ve seen all too many shows where they try to add new characters to the universe by means of the show and it just doesnā€™t work. The character sticks out like a sore thumb and doesnā€™t quite mesh with the other characters. In GLTAS theyā€™re integrated wonderfully. Razer seems like a beloved side character that was just never given the spotlight before (like Tomar-Re), and Aya is a loveable new character that actually brings something to the table. The first season is great with tons of twists and turns that actually add something to the story, unlike those stupid twists that can also happen where itā€™s predictable and/or completely out of left field.
I love Saintwalkerā€™s little arc, itā€™s so good and heā€™s such a peaceful guy, and him helping against the Red Lanterns is a little predictable but itā€™s done in such a way that itā€™s satisfying. The whole bit where Razer teleports to Oa using his love for Aya destroyed me. I love their puppy love, budding relationship even though Razer is a complete idiot most of the time. Iā€™d criticize Aya but sheā€™s perfection, and also a robot whoā€™s learning through experiences so I canā€™t really fault her for not understanding stuff because sheā€™s asking and no one is giving her a straight answer.
Kiliwog is a gem, Iā€™m not a fan of Hal, but I donā€™t think anyone is really is. Heā€™s like a placeholder, textbook MC. My personal favourite Earthling lantern is John Stewart; probably because I grew up with him in JLTAS. Salaak and Tomar-Re are my favs and always will be and Razer and Aya have completely obliterated my brain in terms of love and the capacity of love. Like, the whole second season Razer is just trying to figure it all out, and trying his best to sort out his feelings and Aya is just being way too direct. I guess thatā€™s the only criticism I can give about her, and even then I mean, it makes sense why sheā€™s that way. But still he probably acted the way he did at times because she was being to straightforward and he wasnā€™t prepared with an answer because he hadnā€™t had time to think about it, which is obvious to the audience and despite this itā€™s still easy to dislike his actions because Aya is so wonderful.
The pacing is pretty steady despite it being a tad rushed in season 2, I believe because it was being cancelled (so sad R.I.P), and I wish the show had developed to the point of introducing the Indigo lanterns, and seeing more of Larfleeze, and seeing Sinestro become a yellow lantern, and seeing more of Razers journey. Because, ok, in Young Justice as happy as I am that there was a whole episode about Razer, it didnā€™t really add anything? Like yeah woohoo heā€™s a blue lantern, we already knew that was happening, yeah heā€™s still angry, no duh, heā€™s a living being, he has multiple emotions, yeah heā€™s a little bitch who wants to give up. Thatā€™s been his character since forever. Like it was a fun watch (more painful than fun it was so good to see him again my heart was hurting) but nothing much happened as far as him finding Aya, yk, the thing that becomes his big main goal. At the end he goes right back to it, probably because the writers didnā€™t want to do anything too drastic but still. Like progress, a rumour about her being somewhere? Anything? Just hope from a feeling, like okay whatever thatā€™s pretty cool but a little unsatisfying to me.
Bless this show I hope it gets rebooted (as is started up again, not changed and destroyed like what happened to Teen Titans).
5 notes Ā· View notes
Text
I read Clementine Book One 9 times so that you donā€™t have to read it at all
Tumblr media
Spoiler-free review:Ā Itā€™s not great. 1.5/5 stars.Ā 
"Clementine is back on the road, looking to put her traumatic past behind her and forge new path all her own. But when she comes across an Amish teenager named Amos with his head in the clouds, the unlikely pair journeys North to an abandoned ski resort in Vermont, where they meet up with a small group of teenagers attempting to build a new, walker-free settlement. As friendship, rivalry, and romance begin to blossom amongst the group, the harsh winter soon reveals that the biggest threat to their survival...might be each other. ā€œ
The best way I can describe Clementine in this is if TFS never happened and this is an older, slightly less angsty ANF Clementine who also lost a leg.Ā  Sheā€™s not great.
Amos is the best character. He has a goal, a drive to reach that goal, and an actual personality that shines through in every page heā€™s in. Heā€™s also the only character Clementine has any real chemistry with, which isnā€™t good news for her new love interest.Ā 
Speaking of which, Ricca didnā€™t reach the potential I felt she shouldā€™ve. She has a fine backstory, but the way it was delivered was info-dumpy and not built up well. HerĀ ā€œromantic chemistryā€ with Clementine is practically non-existent, rushed, and a little awkward.Ā 
The twins, Olivia and Georgia, were bland and annoying.
The baddie of the story is weak as hell. They do something terrible for a reason so overdone that it actually makes my brain mad.
The story is okay for the first half, but takes a steep nose dive in the second half that ruins what little good will it got outta me. Everything mentioned that was from the games felt shoehorned in for fanservice points and not because it contributed to the story. The pacing is all over the place, and the ending is just... annoying. The artwork isnā€™t Tillie Waldenā€™s best, I know she can do so much better when sheā€™s allowed to play with color and give her work a more dream-like quality, which the story doesnā€™t.
I originally rated it a 1/5 stars, but after reading it 9 goddamn times, I bumped it up to a 1.5/5 stars mostly for Amos, the few chuckles it got out of me, and one part that I genuinely liked.Ā 
My full detailed review is below. Itā€™s long, gives a recap of the 12-page Clementine Lives comic from Skybound X, addresses the harassment Tillie Walden has gotten over this, and spoils everythingĀ within book one.Ā 
so how the hell did we even get here?
Tumblr media
On August 14, 2018, the first episode of Telltaleā€™s The Walking Dead: The Final Season was released, a game developed by a team that showed great care and passion for the story they wanted to tell and was meant to give Clementineā€™s story a satisfying ending. Itā€™s not a game without flaws, both in its storytelling and mechanics. If youā€™ve followed me for any amount of time, you know I have my complaints about each of the games but at the end of the day, I love them, flaws and all.Ā 
On September 21, 2018, we got the news that Telltale Games would be closing its doors. About 90% of their employees were let go with only about 25 remaining to fulfill the important obligations they couldnā€™t wiggle out of... yā€™know, like finishing a version of Minecraft Story Mode made for Netflix.... which if you know me, you know how I feel about MCSM and Iā€™m sure you can guess the speed at which my eyes rolled upon reading that.Ā 
With the closure of Telltale Games came hundreds of people suddenly out of a job, the cancellation of several games, and the realization that we wouldnā€™t get the rest of TFS. Sad times all around, statements were being made by Telltale [ex] employees, not fun in the slightest, you would go to youtube to watch playthroughs of episode 2 when it dropped and every creator was original enough to title their videosĀ ā€œGOODBYE TELLTALEā€ orĀ ā€œTHE END OF CLEMENTINE.ā€Ā 
But then Robert Kirkman told everyone to chill the hell out, Skybound Entertainment worked out a deal with Telltale, theyā€™re going to finish off TFSĀ through their Skybound Games division, all with the original development team who were working on it.Ā 
The fans rejoiced, the Telltale team got to complete their game the way they wanted, and Skybound were heroes being praised by the fans. TFS was great, my personal favorite of the four main games. 10/10, would play it 100 more times. Clementine finally got the happy ending she deserved.
....But then we got Clementine Lives as a part of the Skybound X collection...andĀ Clementine Book One was announced for summer 2022.Ā 
A lot less happy after that.Ā 
ā€œblah blah die a hero or live long enough to be the baddie or something.ā€Ā -Scarecrow, probably
Tumblr media
Ā In hindsight, we shouldā€™ve seen this coming. What, Skybound gets all the rights to Clementine and we expected them to respectfully leave the conclusion of her story alone? Thatā€™s not how the money is made, babe!Ā 
Clementine is a cow who just wants to be free and eat dewy grass all day in the warm sunlight but that isnā€™t about to stop Skybound from locking her up in a barn stall before getting on their hands and knees to pull and twist and squeeze every single last drop they can get outta her. Even if she runs outta milk, they can just shoot her and turn her meat into steaks and ribs and tenderloins and anything else you can get out of a cow down to the bones. When theyā€™re desperate enough, they can make some bone broth.... I donā€™t really know where Iā€™m going with this, we can just pretend I meant this as a metaphor for how they butchered her or something.Ā 
Anyway, anything to continue making money on a franchise that is still fairly popular... I think? Aside from Telltaleā€™s The Walking Dead, Iā€™m not a big fan of the TWD franchise in general, any other content I tried intaking was meh at best. I lost interest in the show after S1. The books about the Governor werenā€™t all that interesting. I browsed the comics and they couldnā€™t hold my attention.Ā Ā 
I even played and finishedĀ the awful Daryl Dixon prequel game that no one else played. The most interesting thing in that game is if you run for more than 3.5 seconds, sweat blurs and drips down the screen as Daryl shits himself... riveting.
Now we have a Clementine trilogy to throw in there.Ā 
Skybound decided they wanted to branch out into the young adult and middle grade world. Makes sense. Reach out to new fans, get some young blood to flow into crevices left by old fans who are no longer interested, expand your reach as far as possible... all they have to do is tell a compelling story in their well-established world with fleshed out characters while also checking all the boxes to ensure success. Sounds easy, right?Ā Ā 
Enter Skybound X and within it Clementine Lives, a 12-page comic tying together TFS and Clementine Book One.
I have a full in depth look at that comic here, but for a refresher:Ā 
After the events of TFS, Clementine sneaks out of Ericson one morning without telling anyone and we find out that sheā€™s planned her departure for a while. She has maps and supplies hidden away, as well a car stashed somewhere. Before she can get away, though, an older AJ appears wearing Clementineā€™s hat... Ugh.
Heā€™s rightfully pissed that she would ditch out on everything like this, insists that heā€™s coming along, and Clementine tells him no. Her explanation for all of this, the reason sheā€™s abandoning AJ and everyone at Ericson, is that sheā€™s not happy... which spoiler alert, is kinda contradicted in chapter 8 of book one??? but we will get into that later. AJ lets Clementine leave and she sets off on her new journey that brings us to the events of book one.Ā 
To say Clementine Lives was poorly received would be a vast understatement. Fans ripped it to shreds, they hated the damn thing, and they were vocal about it. Thereā€™s no way in hell Skybound didnā€™t know how much fans despised Clementine Lives. I mean, people were making long-winded posts/videos about how it was an insult to Clementineā€™s character and asking everyone to not support the Clementine trilogy, to let Skybound know that this isnā€™t what they wanted.
Fans hated the portrayal of Clementine and AJ. They felt it had more in common with a fanfic written by someone who didnā€™t play the games themselves but instead watched a youtube playthrough one [1] time, thought Clementine was cool but didnā€™t like anyone else and said, ā€œHey what if Clem ditched everyone and hung out with my OCā€™s instead??ā€ than it did with the canon of the games.
I mean, who wrote this, right? Did they even play the games? Well...
Tillie Walden and the Curious Case of Clementineā€™s Character [and other short stories involving obnoxious twdg fans who have nothing better to do with their lives than stalk her instagram account]
Tumblr media
I hadnā€™t heard of Tillie Walden prior to the announcement that she would be the one writing this Clementine book trilogy.
Iā€™ll admit, I hated the 12-page comic, too. In my review I said,Ā ā€œ...Skybound and Tillie made this comic, they put it out there and asked for money for it, therefore Iā€™m allowed to explain why itā€™s garbage as well as ponder over the questionable intent and whether or not Tillie actually has played these games.ā€
ā€œThis comic is awful. It misses the point of everything TFS, and the rest of the series, stood for. There is no heart here. I feel no happiness in reading it, and I donā€™t detect any passion behind it. Itā€™s a lifeless comic that retcons everything in order to throw AJ away and start fresh with a new adventure for Clementine that makes no sense because the cow isnā€™t profitable unless itā€™s milked.ā€
That was then and this is now, though. While I still donā€™t like the comic and feel itā€™s not in line with Clementine as a character or a good direction for the comic, I do believe Tillie has played the games... the problem is she admitted during the Skybound Games XPO stream that she hadnā€™t played the games prior to getting the job. Skybound reached out to her and THEN she played through them, and she played through them fast...and I doubt she played them more than once. Thatā€™s an issue.Ā 
Iā€™ve read some of her other works- On a Sunbeam, Spinning, A City Inside- and I think theyā€™re good, I think sheā€™s a talented artist. Some of the writing choices/themes are a bit iffy but most times I can overlook that because I genuinely love the art. Itā€™s colorful, surreal, dreamy, creative, the kind of art you look at and feel something, yā€™know? Oh, and she likes to point out, ā€œvery gay.ā€ Even if you hate the Clementine books sheā€™s writing, I still encourage you to give her other works a chance. Thereā€™s a lot more life and creativity there. I can see why she was considered, despite Tillie saying herself that she didnā€™t think she was theĀ ā€œobvious choiceā€ for this project..... which yeah, even she knows.
This one pesky little problem has more to do with Skybound than it does Tillie:Ā creating a continuation of Clementineā€™s story after TFS is a dumb move... especially when the artist you hired didnā€™t work on the original games, doesnā€™t typically write stories in a zombie apocalyptic setting so their art style doesnā€™t let itself well to this particular project, doesnā€™t have a good grasp on the main characterā€™s previous establishment, hasnā€™t played the games more than once or twice, probably has to follow a strict set of rules put in place by Skybound because theyā€™re just like that, is under an extreme time constraint of having to finish a trilogy only three years mostly by herself, and is forced to make shit up about the previous games in order to make this comicā€™s plot exist.
In my honest opinion, Tillie wasnā€™t a good match for a Clementine story, and if she was allowed to write something completely original within the TWD universe, then this wouldā€™ve been a more compelling story to follow.Ā 
Let me say this about Clementine Book One: If anyone else was the protagonist of this story, it wouldā€™ve been better. I wouldā€™ve given it a 3.5/5 stars if Clementine was replaced with an original character.Ā 
Thatā€™s the problem.Ā 
I know a lot of people put the full blame on Tillie for how bad this whole thing is. She wrote it right? She ā€œruinedā€ Clementine, itā€™s all her fault that this beloved character and reputation is ā€œtarnishedā€ and she should just cancel the rest of the series, blah blah blahhh.Ā 
I donā€™t entirely blame Tillie for this. She was hired to write this story because Skybound knew people would buy anything with Clementineā€™s name on it, good or bad. They knew Tillie had a fanbase who would buy anything she wrote. They knew that no matter how much fans bitched and moaned about it, Clementine Book One would sell. I believe she shouldā€™ve familiarized herself with the source material better, but sheā€™s a professional artist. I believe she tried her best to create a good story for this trilogy but itā€™s weighed down by the fact that the main character had to be Clementine.Ā 
Which leads me to this bullshit that pisses me off.Ā 
There are plenty of assholes out there who stalk her instagram so they can harass every post she makes [even ones that have nothing to do with Clementine] withĀ ā€œ#notmyclementineā€ andĀ ā€œdis comic make no sense clam wuld never lev aj u suxā€Ā as if thatā€™s going to do anything. Not to mention the comments wishing for her to be fired, hoping she loses her entire career over this, calling her a fucking groomer, and other disgusting things that you donā€™t have to scroll far to find in her instagram comments.Ā 
This is the part where I tell everyone to sit the fuck down and stop. There is no reason to harass Tillie for doing the work she was hired to do. Telling her [and Skybound] that she should be fired, making homophobic remarks, insulting her appearance, wishing harm on her, telling her how much you hate her, calling her a groomer, and harassing fans of hers who want to support her is fucking disgusting.Ā 
Clementine is not real. She is a fictional character in a video game. This comic doesnā€™t hurt her feelings because she doesnā€™t exist. Clementine, the video game character, is not a real life person. I donā€™t give a single shit how important Clementine is to you. You are not defending anyoneā€™s honor or protecting them from harm when you post shit like that. Youā€™re causing the harm over a fictional character. Tillie Walden is a real person.Ā  You can dislike the work while still showing human decency to the creator. You can criticize the work while remaining respectful to the creator. Itā€™s not hard.Ā 
Now that youā€™ve scolded us for the shitty people on instagram, are you gonna actually review the book or are you gonna keep procrastinating...?
Tumblr media
Hey, donā€™t call me out on something Iā€™m totally doing.
And yes, we can review the actual book now that Iā€™ve gone over how we got here and hit you over the head with theĀ ā€œdonā€™t harass Tillie over the comic, shitheadā€ bat.Ā 
Yeesh, so impatient.Ā 
The Plot: itā€™s thickening... like curdled cheese
Tumblr media
First thingā€™s first, letā€™s go over the story, the plot,Ā of this thing. Then Iā€™ll go in depth for each of the characters, talk about theĀ ā€œromance,ā€ finish up with my final thoughts, and then talk about Clementine Book Two coming out JuneĀ October 2023. Cool? Cool.Ā 
Clementine has left Ericson behind and is traveling alone with nothing but a pair of crutches to keep her warm at night. She's discovered by a group of Amish teens after being startled by her own period. Gotta say, I love the attempt to include Clementine having her period tastefully by having one of the other girls be like,Ā ā€œOh, I just started mine, too,ā€ only for another to be likeĀ ā€œDonā€™t tell her that, ewwwwww!ā€Ā 
Remember how well ANF handled that? No? Just me? Whatever.Ā 
Anyway, they notice Clementine has a prosthetic leg and offer to take her back to their town to meet Rabby, a dentist who creates prosthetics.Ā This town they take her to is actually neat. They have high walls, guards who have a system of keeping track of everyone who comes and goes, theyā€™re not rude to her during the entrance procedure, there are several buildings with a lot of people walking the streets, they have horses..... oh and Meredith, one of the girls who found Clementine, calls the walkers ā€œdevils,ā€ which is fun.Ā 
Clementine gets her new leg before ditching them to go back on the road where she meets Amos, an Amish teen who is out on his Rumspringa [a period when some Amish youth experience greater freedom. The idea is that teens will come back after tasting the modern world] with his horse, Helen, his carriage, and his 16 shirts.
Tumblr media
Amos is heading to a mountain base up north in Vermont to help a group build aĀ ā€œstrong homesteadā€ throughout the winter, then when the snow melts, heā€™ll be rewarded with a plane ride. Clementine thinks thatā€™s bullshit, planes donā€™t fly around anymore, but Amos insists that he saw the plane in the sky.Ā 
Yā€™see, a man showed up looking for recruits to help build these houses and then flew his plane over as proof that this was real. Amos really wants to ride in a plane, something heā€™s not supposed to do, hence why heā€™s going on this adventure for his Rumspringa.Ā 
Clementine gets a ride from him where they save a group of people who were under attack by walkers. However, one of the guys they saved gropes Clementine and she attacks him.Ā 
Itā€™s difficult to tell thatā€™s what happened due to the sloppy art, though. Initially I interpreted it as Clementine thinking he turned into a walker and attacked, but uh no, he groped her. She stomps on his hand after he challenges her with a, ā€œdo it,ā€ and then as sheā€™s hurrying to get away, someone else from inside the carriage says,Ā ā€œWhat did you do to that girl?!ā€
I would say Iā€™m surprised but given some of the other stuff in Tillieā€™s works, Iā€™m not.Ā 
Anyway, Amos leaves the carriage with those people, takes Helen and catches up with Clementine. He wants to travel with her, she calls him ridiculous andĀ ā€œIā€™m not interested in being a bodyguard anymore.ā€
It doesnā€™t take much to convince to her, though- Amos promises to leave Helen with her once he gets there since he knows sheā€™d take care of her.Ā 
And Iā€™m strangely reminded of Clementineā€™s trauma regarding horses from TFS where dead horses appear in her nightmare due to the one she was riding getting shot at the ranch... no mention of that anywhere, but are we surprised?Ā 
They spend a week traveling together. We get a montage of them that I actually like, and adds to my point that Amos has the most chemistry with Clementine in this book.Ā 
Tumblr media
They make it to the mountain base where a pair of twins are waiting, and theyā€™re suspicious as hell.Ā 
Red flag #1: No names. They refuse to give their names.Ā 
Red flag #2: One twin shoots Helen without even talking to Clementine or Amos, they just assumed they brought the horse for them to eat when nooo, Amos wanted to leave Helen with Clementine when they parted ways.
Red flag #3: They immediately view Clementine as a liability for her leg and tell her theyā€™re not feeding anyone who canā€™t pull their weight... two people who refuse to give their names are in charge of your food and shelter, huh?
Red flag #4: Clementine says theyā€™re dangerous and refuses to leave Amos alone with them.Ā 
Red flag #5: the mountain theyā€™re on is literally called Killington. My eyes, look at them roll, there they go across the floor...
Hey, do you think these twins might be bad news? Because I dooooo~
But thereā€™s a really sweet hug between Amos and Clementine after she insists she stays with him. You really feel that heā€™s scared and hurting after Helenā€™s death and heā€™s relieved to have her.Ā 
Up the mountain, weā€™re introduced to Ricca and.... yā€™know, not even Louis and Violet eye-balled Clementine this fast. Iā€™ll save it for the romance section but uh... yeah. Riccaā€™s interest is apparent pretty quick... like right after their first conversation and then it goes no where.
Tumblr media
So the twins explain that they need wood for building and the stove, snow melts down for water. Stick to the paths when out because the twins wonā€™t come looking for them [red flag #6], they work from sunrise to sunset but the days are short up in the mountains so they need to move fast. They lose a lot of days to storms, they need to keep track of all their tools and bring them in during those storms or else theyā€™ll never be seen again. Walkers donā€™t come up here because itā€™s too cold.Ā 
The twins refuse to answer more questions, and Ricca says sheā€™s been calling the one with the ponytailĀ ā€œRightā€ and the one with her hair downĀ ā€œLeft.ā€Ā 
Side note: I had a helluva time trying to keep these damn twins straight, you cannot tell them apart for shit especially since they change their goddamn hair styles and have the same goddamn face!
Oh but put a pin in the fact that Amos can tell them apart becauseĀ ā€œLeft has much brighter eyes.ā€
So they all get to work. Clementine, Amos, and Ricca get pretty close. They go on joyrides with the snowmobile, they spend their nights reading novels together, getting into snowball fights that Clem takes too seriously, hunting, and talking about how sus the twins are. These sections are good, I like them. Especially when theyā€™re reading together- Amos and Clementine read out loud, and when they donā€™t know a word, Ricca looks it up for them in the dictionary. The three of them are curled up in their sleeping bags, reading by candle light, itā€™s very sweet. Itā€™s too bad there isnā€™t more of that in here.Ā 
Tumblr media
While out chopping wood one day, Clementine hears a noise that is supposed to foreshadow walkers being underground, and we find out Ricca is a smoker.Ā 
Oh, and Amos gets sick with a fever. Not fun.Ā 
Now letā€™s talk about the generator because this is funny. Not good funny, though, so donā€™t get too excited.Ā 
So they have this portable generator, right? Itā€™s for the other lift that they just fixed, so Clementine and Ricca have to drag it about three miles away from the main base, but can take a shorter way over a bridge the twins built. They take a map, put it on the snowmobile, and Ricca letā€™s Clementine drive. Smart.Ā 
But uh oh, the bridge is broken! Guess they gotta turn around and go the other- just kidding, theyā€™re gonna tie a rope around the generator and swing it to the other side. I wish I was joking but Iā€™m not, arenā€™t you laughing???
Ricca fucking falls down with the generator and Clementine jumps down after her.Ā 
Tumblr media
While down in the pit, theyā€™re attacked by walkers. Turns out the twins werenā€™t entirely truthful about there being no walkers up here. Ricca breaks her glasses, Clem breaks her prosthetic [which we learn she named Kenny UGH] and Ricca dumps her backstory which Iā€™ll get into during her section.
Ricca then climbs back up and promises to come back, we get a flashback of AJ about to cut Clementineā€™s leg off? for some reason? and then she starts exploring the cave for a way out... only to be overwhelmed by walkers and then saved by this random dude named Tim who comes out of nowhere.
Tim gets bit, or scratched...? I donā€™t know, you canā€™t tell what the fuck is going on during the part. He says itā€™s just a scratch on the cheek but I thought you only turned if you were bit? Or is it a bite and Timā€™s trying to downplay it? I donā€™t fucking know.Ā 
Clementine feels super bad that heā€™s gonna die because of her. They have a heart to heart, and itā€™s one of the better parts of this book. Tim talks about how he lost his husband at the start of all this, how he actually used to look after the twins [whose names are revealed to be Olivia and Georgie- correction, her name is GeorgIA, not GeorgIE, but characters just call her one or the other and it gets confusing] and how this whole building houses thing is for their sick mother. Clementine opens up about how she can still feel ghost pains in her leg and how she ended up alone- every group was the same, they fell apart, so she wanted to come up north to live alone.Ā 
ā€œI canā€™t... I canā€™t do this. I canā€™t keep watching people die. Thatā€™s why I wanted to be alone.ā€
Tim gives her some encouragement about building a better world and lets her to go, she does, and then she reunites with Ricca. Yay.Ā 
Tumblr media
Back at the base, Clementine tells the twins what happened and theyā€™re freaked out because Timā€™s alive. They interrogate her about him, and Right runs outta there to go find him... Left tries to stop her, and it turns to violence.
With Right gone, Left is super sad, and Ricca is super sad that Clementine didnā€™t tell her about Tim after they were reunited and then outta nowhere just,Ā ā€œI donā€™t need a girlfriend or to know all your secrets, just... God, I sound stupid. Just... next time you meet a stranger in a cave, a heads up might be nice.ā€
Feel that romantic tension?Ā 
Speaking of romantic tension, Left asks Amos to come behind the curtain to her area, and Amos is likeĀ ā€œCan I get you something?ā€..... and then Clementineā€™s hears a gaspĀ from behind the curtain and Ricca is likeĀ ā€œlet them have their fun.ā€
So apparently Amos and Left were fooling around... remember when Amos said Left had brighter eyes? I guess that was foreshadowing all the smoochinā€™ they were gonna do in the background? I dunno. Iā€™m surprised Amos would be chill with foolinā€™ around, and Left just got into a fight with her sister which I donā€™t imagine is a mood setter.Ā 
Right comes back in the middle of the night covered in blood. I believe weā€™re assuming she found and killed Tim, who was a walker... maybe? She later mentions that Tim told her something sooo did she kill him when he was still alive? Maybe. Who knows? We never find out for sure.
Oh, and Amos was sleeping behind the curtain with Left.... Keep that in mind.Ā 
The next morning Amos fixes up Clementineā€™s leg, and Clementine asks for the whole story behind him and Left, who he calls Olivia... meaning she told him her real name. But Clementine asks him if he wants to take a walk when night falls because they havenā€™t gotten to spend much time together, to which Amos tells her,Ā ā€œThat would be delightful, Clementine.ā€Ā 
Can I just- Clementine, why donā€™t you ever ask to spend alone time with Ricca? Thatā€™s a serious question, why? Iā€™m seriously truly to feel something with Clementine and Ricca but all I can say is she has better chemistry with Amos.... Tillie, I donā€™t understand, you write wlw and youā€™ve done it well before, why is this so... full of nothing?Ā 
Tumblr media
Anyway, Right is being pissy, and Left tells Clementine that sheā€™s going to leave with Amos once theyā€™re all done here. She wants to go back to his town, but her sister canā€™t know...... because of course not. Iā€™m sure nothing bad will happen because of this.Ā 
Right comes in even more pissed off because Amos is gone and so is the snowmobile. Turns out he took the generator [which Left fixed after it was broken in the fall] to save thisĀ ā€œscrewed up camp,ā€ as Clementine puts it.Ā 
And Right goes,Ā ā€œthereā€™s a storm coming in, heā€™ll never make it... but at least itā€™ll be one less mouth to feed.ā€
RED FLAG #8 HELLO??
The storm hits, and Right just stands outside like a brooding, suspicious asshole who refuses to come in. Left then explains that theyā€™re here building houses because of her mother. Her mother grew up in the area and thought this would be the perfect spot to rebuild when the world went to shit. She kept them alive, so the twins feel like they owe her, especially since sheā€™s sick.Ā 
Which.... okay? But also what? Like alright, jumping ahead a bit, we do get to see the mother and the place theyā€™re staying in and itā€™s huge, AND there are people.... why is it just the twins doing this shit? Tim fucking dipped out last winter so why are the twins here? Do they think building houses will make their sick mother magically better? Spoiler alert, it will not!Ā 
This whole part doesnā€™t make sense.Ā 
But then RICCA decides to go out looking for Amos, and tells Clementine to stay behind because she doesnā€™t want to leave Left alone with Right....Ā 
But then fucking CLEMENTINE goes out by herself to look for both of them, all while thinking about Ricca and Amos and the nights they spent reading together.Ā Ā 
But guess what? Youā€™ll never guess- Amos and Ricca are alive and he did it, Amos got the lift to work! He crashed the snowmobile, but thatā€™s okay! The other lift works now! They rush to bring the twins the good news, everything is happy!
And then Right pushes Amos off a cliff.Ā 
Tumblr media Tumblr media
...............................Yep.
This is where the story takes a nose dive into shit- Amos is killed because Right found out about Leftā€™s plan to leave with him... apparently?? Left is sobbing on the ground, Right fucking stompsĀ on her back and tells her to shut up, and then pulls out her gun on Clementine and Ricca, who run away.Ā 
Are you laughing? because Iā€™m not.Ā 
What was the fucking plan, you moron???Ā ā€œOh step one, push Amos to his death in front of everyone. Step two, break my sisterā€™s back. Step three, fucking shoot Clem and Ricca. Step four, ??????ā€Ā It doesnā€™t make sense.
Up until this point, I was fine. It wasnā€™t great by any means, the plot is kinda dumb with them building houses in extreme weather, everything with the generator was dumb..... Rightā€™s always been an asshole, but now sheā€™s decided to be evil.Ā 
The story just killed off its best character out of nowhere. It feels veryĀ ā€œwe have to kill someone off, and Tim wasnā€™t enough, we have to kill off a likable character so that the reader is sad.ā€Ā 
And like... I canā€™t even say it wasnā€™t foreshadowed? because right from the start, you know Right is a bitch. You know sheā€™s an asshole, much more so than Left. Then Left starts smooching Amos and asks Clementine not to tell Right? Cā€™mon... even though we get no indication that she knows about Leftā€™s plan to leave with him. Maybe she saw him peeking from behind the curtain where she knows her sister sleeps and figured out they were smoochinā€™? I donā€™t know, I really wish things were actually clear in this damn thing.Ā 
So yeah, Right decides murder is a good idea because she wonā€™t let anyone take her sister away... I feel like Iā€™ve seen something similar to this before.Ā 
We get another Lee flashback, and now Ricca and Clementine are crying. Ricca wants to go looking for him, but Clementine tells her thereā€™s no way Amos survived that fall.... even though he probably could have, we never see his body so I dunno if this is Tillie leaving things open for him to come back or if she didnā€™t want to show his body to all the middle graders reading this but this is TWD... no body? they can always come back.Ā 
Clementine and Ricca decide they canā€™t just ditch the mountain yet, they have to save Left from Right- oh excuse me, Olivia... they have to save Olivia from Georgia.Ā 
So they sit outside of camp and wait for sundown... but here is where I get even more pissed than I was before: Clementine explains why she left Ericson.Ā 
ā€œI spent so many years trying to find somewhere safe. And I did. This old school. There were good people there. People I loved. But after I lost my leg, everything felt different. No one said it, but I could feel it- they thought I was a liability. But I think the real issue... was that I couldnā€™t talk to any of them about it. They were all around my age, and I... I just wanted to talk to Lee about it. Someone older, and... I donā€™t know...ā€
ā€œLee?ā€
ā€œHe, um, was with me in the beginning. Took care of me, as long as he could. After leaving the school, I was alone, like I was when he first found me. And I realized... I was waiting for him. For Lee to come find me. And I was so pissed at him for not trying harder, which doesnā€™t make any sense, heā€™s dead... When I was on my own, it was nice for a while. I was so focused, my mind got quiet... I got so sad I would just cry for days, and then Iā€™d get scared... about what my future would be like. That maybe this sadness would never go away.ā€
ā€œHas it?ā€
ā€œHonestly? No... not really.ā€
................I just-
Tumblr media
I thought Clementine left because she wasnā€™t happy? Thatā€™s what she told AJ in Clementine Lives, so what?Ā ā€œWell actually, I really left because everyone at Ericson thought I was a liability and I just wanted to talk to Lee again but heā€™s dead and Iā€™m pissed at him for being dead and not trying hard enough to save me again.ā€Ā 
ThisĀ ā€œrevealā€ is so... bad. Itā€™s bad, I donā€™t like it one bit because I actually played TFS... more than once. Iā€™ve played it several times, Iā€™ve streamed it about what? Four or five times? Shit, maybe more? I know the story, I know the characters, I know Clementine.
Youā€™re gonna look me in my big dumb face and try to convince me that Louis and Violet looked at Clementine like she was a liability? After everything she did for them? After all they went through? Clementine didnā€™t feel like she could talk to them about how she was feeling? That they didnā€™t care enough to reach out to her?
Tumblr media Tumblr media
I donā€™t believe you.Ā 
I think youā€™re full of shit.Ā 
Iā€™ll rant about this more in Clementineā€™s section. We gotta move on because believe it or not, we have even more bullshit to cover.Ā 
ANYWAY.... Georgia has Olivia gagged and tied up so she canā€™t escape.... I just, what is the plan?? What does she expect to happen??
Ā Clementine and Ricca trick her into coming outside and-
Tumblr media
Clementine gets her with the hatchet, but Georgia has a gun up her sleeve and shoots Ricca. The gunshots cause an avalanche. The place is covered in snow, Ricca and Olivia are *not* okay, and Georgie is just spouting cheesy villain lines about leaving Clementineā€™s body on the mountain.Ā 
Oh, and she starts trying to guilt Olivia with the wholeĀ ā€œEverything I did was for you! Iā€™ve always protected you! He was going to take you away from me! Tim told me not to let you go!ā€
...Again, I feel like this is very familiar.... hmmmmm....
ā€œYouā€™ve never loved anyone, Clementine, I can see it. You have no idea... how far Iā€™ll go... what Iā€™ll do...ā€
No seriously, why do I feel like there was another, much better written twin character behaving like this.....? hmmmmmm....
Anyway, Georgia gets bit by a walker while trapped in the snow, and Clementine FINALLY says something I agree with:
ā€œOut of everyone in this world that your sister couldā€™ve picked... you were so lucky it was Amos.ā€
Georgia and Olivia say their goodbyes, Ricca calls ClementineĀ ā€œbaby,ā€ and they drag her outta there.Ā 
Tumblr media
Now itā€™s just Clementine, Ricca, and Olivia left. The three of them travel to the lift and get off this damn mountain. They get the bullet outta Ricca when Clementine hears a noise outside. She follows it and finds a one-eyed kitten alone under some junk... because sure. They name the kitten Dr. Barnwell.Ā 
I canā€™t wait for that kitten to be tragically killed off for dramatic effect later in the series. To be fair to Tillie, she couldnā€™t possibly write an beloved pet death as bad as Ruebenā€™s in MCSM.
Now the plan is to get back to Oliviaā€™s place, sneak past her mother, and steal the plane. Reasonable, yes? Planes are easy to steal, and easy to fly, too!
Ricca also mentions that Clementine talks in her sleep, but wonā€™t tell her what she says until theyā€™re in the sky.Ā 
They finally make it there, sneak in, Olivia tells her mother sheā€™s sorry before slipping a note under the door, they run around and knock some guards out, and itā€™s revealed that Oliviaā€™s mother is a walker.Ā 
I think.
The art is too sloppy to fully tell but I think thatā€™s the big reveal.Ā 
Tumblr media Tumblr media
So... did they know that the whole time? This is what they meant when they said sheā€™s sick? or was she sick before and then died during this time so they have no idea? Ugghhh I donā€™t know.
They find the plane that Olivia just happens to know how to fly thanks to her uncle teaching her, they take off into the sky, and they plan to go back to Vermont so they can fly over andĀ ā€œletā€™s show Amos the plane one more time.ā€
Oh, and that note Olivia left?Ā 
Tumblr media
The FUCKING END.Ā 
Thatā€™s it, thatā€™s everything that happened in Clementine Book One. I canā€™t believe Iā€™ve read this timeĀ nineĀ times, holy shit-
The Art Style: I have no idea whatā€™s happening
Tumblr media
I struggled with this art style.Ā 
Remember how I said Tillieā€™s a talented artist? She is, she truly is... when itā€™s her original works and sheā€™s allowed to play with color and doesnā€™t havenā€™t to be gritty to fit the TWD aesthetic. Her original stuff is so clean and you can actually see whatā€™s happening.Ā 
Some examples:
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
and I get it, her style wonā€™t be for everyone, and thatā€™s fine. I happen to really like it.... but not when it feels like sheā€™s trying to implement elements of TWD grit while also working in greyscale.Ā Ā 
Tillieā€™s style doesnā€™t lend itself well to this story. Maybe it would if there werenā€™t such restrictions put on her by Skybound because Iā€™m sure they gave her a bunch.... but this ainā€™t it, chief.
As I talked about before, trying to tell the twins apart in this was a nightmare. Olivia has a ponytail, Georgia doesnā€™t.... but when this is so messy and at times sloppyĀ I canā€™t tell shit about the hair.Ā 
Thereā€™s also the fact that if you removed Riccaā€™s glasses, she would look exactly like the twins. Clementine and Amos are the only two of the five who you can always recognize.Ā 
Rabby has a good design, and so does Tim... but they arenā€™t around enough. The walkers- oh god, the walkers- look like blobs most of the time.Ā 
And donā€™t even get my started on Clementineā€™s face.Ā 
I canā€™tĀ with Clementineā€™s face.Ā 
Clementine: thereā€™s a reason fans are calling herĀ ā€œTangerineā€
Tumblr media
This section of the review is the most overwhelming for me because where do I even begin?Ā 
There is never a point in this book where I feel like this is the Clementine I remember from the games. And yā€™know, I always like to remind everyone who plays the games that no Clementine is the same. We all play the games our way, she shape our Clementine through the choices we make, we have different interpretations of her personality, relationships, how she rationalizes her decisions. My Clementine is different than yours, thatā€™s the fun of these games.Ā 
When you take a character who has thousands of different interpretations, who can follow several different paths, and try to make her into a condensed version for a graphic novel while also trying to stay true to her character andĀ not invalidate any choices.... itā€™s not going to work. Itā€™s just not.Ā 
So how does Tillie Walden interpret Clementine for this first installment? Who is Clementine here?
Tumblr media
Sheā€™s dull. Awkward. Angsty. Feels more in line with ANF Clementine than TFS Clementine but toned down. She has a few moments where she teases Amos and Ricca and thatā€™s cute, thatā€™s some personality I want to see... but then she starts on about how talking is hard or makes a rude comment so... thatā€™s cool.Ā 
She feels dumbed down when it comes to first aid solely because the book needs a way to inform the reader of proper amputation care... even though we never see Clementine washing her leg after that.
Sheā€™s pessimistic, grumpy, and again, only really shows a soft spot for Amos... which is not good news for Ricca, her actual love interest. Even when she opens up to Ricca after Amosā€™ death, it doesnā€™t feel... earned? warm? It doesnā€™t feel tender, or comforting.... ugh, Iā€™ll talk more in the romance portion.
Clementine does get emotional after Amosā€™ death, she cries and explains why she left Ericson and Iā€™m still shaking my head at the fact that this book is trying to sell this to me.Ā 
This would be an emotional moment if it were coming from anyone BUT CLEMENTINE.... I played TFS and this doesnā€™t add up.Ā 
Clementine wasnā€™t happy at the end of TFS, everyone around her looked at her like she was a liability, so she left. She left AJ.Ā 
Except no? What are you talking about?Ā 
Oh, and by the way? She never mentions AJ to anyone. Not by name, not in passing, nothing. AJ get a single panel flashing back to when he cut her leg off. Thatā€™s it.Ā 
Tumblr media
Also look at the way heā€™s drawn. Someone who never played the games would probably think AJ was a baddie who cut off her leg but you and I both know how fucking raw and painful it was for AJ to begĀ her to get up and come with him. That one lousy image holds nothing from the original.
AJ might as well not exist. If you took that panel out, nothing would change. Honestly? I almost get a bit of bitterness from it. She goes on and on about how she realized she was going to live while everyone around her kept dying, she would spend some days just crying and crying.... itā€™s not great.Ā 
Clementine feels... immature? And yeah, sheā€™s seventeen in this and seventeen-year-olds arenā€™t the pinnacle of maturity. I feel like Tillie was trying to present her as mature for her age given her life experience in the apocalypse, but it comes off as emo teenager who thinksĀ theyā€™re mature because they write faux deep poetry on tumblr and wear combat boots.Ā 
This isnā€™t like Clementine in TFS where you do feel sheā€™s mature. She has to be, she has a child sheā€™s raising and protecting. She has to be strong and smart for him. She has to be the adult in their relationship... but she has those moments of vulnerability to remind you that sheā€™s not an adult, sheā€™s a teenager who was forced to grow up too fast and it hurts.Ā 
In ep4 of TFS, when theyā€™re in the caves after getting separated from the group, she and AJ get into an argument. She tells him that heā€™s just a child, and he throws it right back at her-Ā ā€œSo are you.ā€Ā and you can seeĀ it on her face... yā€™know?Ā 
You want her to be happy, you want to give back the childhood that was taken from her at the start of the apocalypse, you want her to overcome every obstacle thrown her way.Ā  You understand her feelings about Lee, why he meant so much to her and why she struggled to let him go even after accepting that he was dead.Ā 
You remember that she is a teenager who makes mistakes, she doesnā€™t know everything, she fucks up. Sheā€™s doing everything she can to protect those she loves. You feel that she wouldnā€™t hesitate to give her life for the little boy she raised. She still has a lot of growing to do but you donā€™t doubt that sheā€™s gonna do it.Ā 
This Clementine? She has none of that. This Clementine doesnā€™t feel like the kind of person who could raise and protect a child, who would give her life to ensure that child was safe. You donā€™t get the vibe of a teen who had to grow up too fast in order to survive, someone who is clever in their survival tactics. This Clementine doesnā€™t know basic first aid. She was mad that Lee didnā€™t save her despite being dead. This is a Clementine that I canā€™t imagine breaking onto a boat full of kidnappers to get her friends back... and itā€™s not the amputation.Ā 
Tumblr media
TFS Clementine, amputation or not, she wouldā€™ve charged that damn boat herself if it meant saving those she loved. Comic Clementine couldnā€™t even be bothered to check and make sure Amos really was dead, itā€™s just easier to assume there was no way he survived... but then she turns around and insists they go back for Olivia, a character she has no real connection with. It doesnā€™t make sense.Ā 
Itā€™s just.... not her. Iā€™m sorry, Tillie, but this characterization is okay at best, insulting at worst.Ā 
Amos: Iā€™m signing the adoption papers as we speak, heā€™s my son now
Tumblr media
Amos is the best character in this book, and Iā€™ve yet to find anyone who would disagree with that. Every review Iā€™ve read/watched boils down toĀ ā€œthis comic was bad but I liked Amos.ā€
Letā€™s be real- he was only made so likable so that weā€™d all be forced to feel something when he died.Ā 
Before I get more into his character, I wanna nip something in the butt that I keep seeing even after this bookā€™s release- Amos isnā€™t just white Louis. Amos isnā€™t aĀ ā€œhey can I copy your homeworkā€ of Louisā€™ character. The most they have in common is freckles and being the friendliest person in the group.Ā 
A key difference being Louis uses cheerfulness as a shield to keep people at a safe distance from him where Amos is just genuinely cheerful in a very naĆÆve and selfless way.Ā 
Or uhh, @pi-createsā€‹ put it much better when we were talking about it-
Tumblr media
So no, Amos isnā€™t just a rehash of Louis, you can stop calling him the white Louis of the comic now, youā€™re only making it clear that you know nothing about Louis as a character when you do that. As much as I like Amos, he isnā€™t anywhere near as nuanced and layered as Louis is soooo stop.Ā 
Ā Anyway, Amos! My dude! The only character I liked! The only character with an interesting personality, motivation, and a set goal he worked his ass off for.... only to fucking die.
Of all the characters to die in this damn thing, it would be Amos, wouldnā€™t it? Ugh.Ā 
Tumblr media
Amos grew up in an Amish community his entire life. When a man, presumably Tim, showed up to recruit workers to help build houses, Amos got to see the promised plane fly over his head and he describes it as the best day of his life.Ā 
So, he worked to convince the council to allow him to go on his Rumspringa, they agreed, and here he is on the road. He fights with an axe, he owns 16 shirts, love his horse, and wears a fun hat. Overall positive, glass half full kinda guy.Ā 
Tumblr media
He wants to help people. Itā€™s mentioned by the townspeople that he brings survivors there often, he saves that group of people while he and Clementine are on the road and even goes as far as to leave his carriage with them to go after Clementine and stay with her.Ā 
Ā Amos trusts Clementine enough to leave Helen with her even though theyā€™ve only known each other for only a week, but through the ā€œmontageā€ page you really get a vibe for how well they work together. I wish it wasnā€™t just a spread of moments but instead gave actual depth to their journey through dialogue, yā€™know?Ā 
He finds Clementine funny [good for him, I wish I did, as well] and likes being around her. Also they share some looksĀ that I feel shouldā€™ve been reserved for the love interest.... sooooo what the hell.Ā 
Tumblr media
When they meet the twins, Amos is quick to be like,Ā ā€œwell actually no-ā€ when they start talking about her being a liability for having only one leg, which was sweet.Ā 
I felt so bad for him when Olivia just fucking shot his horse, too... heā€™s so upset and Clementineā€™s trying to calm him down, really sucks.Ā 
Oh speaking of Olivia.... theirĀ ā€œromanceā€ makes no sense? There wasnā€™t any build up to it, the only hint we got that he maybe liked her was the comment about her having brighter eyes than Georgia, and her sticking with him when he was sick... but then she asks him to come behind the curtain with her, thereā€™s a gasp, and I assume they were doinā€™ kissing stuff. Like... why? Why even bother? Unless you needed an excuse for Georgia to murder him? You couldnā€™t think of a better way to kill him off? So dumb.
Heā€™s not all that complex or anything, just an all around good dude. His biggest flaws are his naivety and being too trusting of the wrong people [Georgia]. I mean.... he just wanted to fly in a plane. He wanted to help people, work hard, and fly in a plane. Itā€™s hard to dislike him for that.Ā 
Tumblr media
When Amos died, it was the first time while reading this that I felt something other thanĀ ā€œeh this is fine.ā€ Iā€™m still annoyed, pissed even.Ā His death ruined a lot. It marked the start of a steep decline toward the ending. So much bullshit, and for what, yā€™know?Ā 
In conclusion- Amos makes up an entire star of my rating, the only one worth reading this book for, and heā€™s supposedly dead now so that doesnā€™t bode well for Book Two. The only way Iā€™ll forgive Tillie is if Amos comes back as a twist villain, angry that they didnā€™t even try to go after him.Ā 
Tumblr media
Ricca: wearing glasses doesnā€™t qualify as an entire personality, baby
Tumblr media
Oh good, I get to talk about Glasses now....Ā 
Ricca is... fine. Sheā€™s not terrible, but not great. I feel like she had the foundation to be a cool character, but a lot about her falls flat. Her best moments are when sheā€™s with both Clementine and Amos, but things become a little more awkward when itā€™s just her and Clementine.
Sheā€™s a smoker, sheā€™s Jewish, she owns 36 pairs of glasses, has a drier sense of humor that works well with Amos, those two have a couple cute moments in this... uhhh letā€™s see, she threw a snowball at Clementine once, who overreacted and attacked her which prompted Amos to get between them and Ricca was likeĀ ā€œwhaaa donā€™t stop, I was just having fun,ā€ so yā€™know.... flirting, I guess.Ā 
Tumblr media
She does come off as a bit whiney sometimes, which gets grating... especially when she gets butthurt at Clementine for stuff and then tries to act likeĀ ā€œbut whateverā€ about it.Ā 
The reason sheā€™s here is to learn how to build houses. Thatā€™s why she agreed to work out there, she wants to have the skills to start over, to rebuild what has decayed.Ā 
But her big backstory reveal has to do with why she owns 36 pairs of glasses-
At the start of the outbreak, Ricca was with her brother. He looked out for her at first, but as time went on, he started using her as aĀ ā€œcanary in a coal mine.ā€ Basically whenever there was any potential danger ahead of them or if he got bored, heā€™d push her in to things like camps, caves, herds. She was just a little kid, and there was no where else for her to go... but then she got older, and when he sensed that she was going to leave him, he broke her glasses.Ā 
Ricca had no way of surviving without him after that. She had no choice but to fight mostly blind and deal with her brother. It got to the point where she started wishing for death.... until she was out looking for food one day in a dark building and felt an entire wall of glasses-
Tumblr media
-but Iā€™m gonna ignore that for right now. She tried on every single pair, found one that worked, and then ditched him. She has no idea if heā€™s still alive or not. Wonder if heā€™ll come back as a surprise villain, who knows.Ā 
Sooo... glasses are a big part of her character, which is fine. I like seeing characters with glasses, personally. Thereā€™s also an uncomfortable feeling seeing her talk about her brother and describing how she felt when she got to see clearly again only for the world to be so disgusting that she was sick for weeks.Ā 
Tumblr media
Unfortunately thatā€™s about as deep as her character goes and I wanted more.Ā 
She does want to go after Amos after he dies, which I appreciate, but Clementine tells her no. She gets shot, so that sucks for her.Ā 
Tumblr media
For being Clementineā€™s new love interest, and the fact that this is Tillie Waldenā€™s work weā€™re reading, I expected her to be waaaaay more compelling but she didnā€™t hit to mark.
But to be fair, sheā€™s going to be in Book Two so Iā€™m assuming that with Amos dead until he comes back as a twist villain weā€™ll get to focus on her some more and her personality will shine a bit.Ā 
Olivia: the left twin
Tumblr media
Olivia is bland.Ā 
A block of raw tofu has more meat than Olivia does.Ā 
I have read this fucking book NINE times now, and the only thing I can tell you about Olivia is that sheā€™s the ā€œniceā€ twin, she did some smoochinā€™ with Amos in the background, and sheā€™s super sad that her sisterā€™s an asshole.Ā 
Oh and she shot Helen without asking if they brought the horse for food or not, and then is likeĀ ā€œoop sorry, I didnā€™t know, but itā€™s cool, I get it, my sister ate our hamster when this started.ā€Ā 
If I was Amos, Iā€™d tell her to the hell away from me, you shot my beloved pet! and I certainly wouldnā€™t let her be smoochinā€™ on me!
Anyway, she knows how to fly a plane, which upon looking back through the book, it turns out it was her uncle that taught her... so thatā€™s cool. Sheā€™s the one who named the kitten, she... gets sad a lot?Ā 
Tumblr media
Iā€™m sorry, but Olivia is so forgettable and it sucks. I want to be invested in these twins because they clearly have a troubled relationship, and Georgia steps all over her [sometimes physically] and it couldā€™ve been interesting to see her deal with the conflict of staying vs leaving her sister..... kinda like the dilemma Ricca had with her brother..... were those supposed to be connected somehow....? parallels...?Ā hhhnnnnngggggggg thinking too much into it-
ANYWAY... I honestly donā€™t have much to say about her. Maybe Book two will give her more characterization, but at this point the pothole in my driveway has more depth than she does so... lame.
Georgia: the rightĀ ā€œevilā€ twin
Tumblr media
Ugh.
Alright, no more beating around the bush, Georgia is a watered down version of Minerva... but where Minerva is a great, tragic character with good writing... Georgia sucks.
AND she killed off the best character in the book so she sucks extra hard!Ā  Oh my god, she fucking sucks.
Like okay, the twins are here to build a community for their sick mother because the mom thinks this would be the perfect spot so theyā€™re gonna build some goddamn houses in the middle of winter for her with the help of strangers... if that sounds like a dumb reason to you, then youā€™re right, it IS dumb but here we are. I donā€™t know what Georgiaā€™s deal is, but sheā€™s an asshole. Thatā€™s her entire character: ASSHOLE.
Tumblr media
Right off the bat from meeting her and Olivia, you can tell sheā€™s the baddie. You can tell where this is going, sheā€™s going to be the one who turns on the group, maybe sheā€™ll convince Olivia to her side and then sheā€™s gonna try to murder everyone on this mountain called Killington.
Sheā€™s the one who tells Clementine that she wonā€™t feed anyone who canā€™t pull their weight, immediately assuming Clementine canā€™t do shit because of her leg. She never smiles, never cracks a joke, is never kind to anyone, and apparently sheā€™s super possessive and controlling of her sister.Ā 
Also, sheā€™s a goddamn moron because what did she think would happen when she killed Amos?? that Olivia would just be likeĀ ā€œoh okay sorryā€ after you murdered her boyfriend and then gagged and tied her up while waiting for Clementine and Ricca to come for her so that you could also shoot them??
Yā€™know, when Minerva confronted the group on the bridge in order to kill Tenn, it made sense- she was bitten, dying, and had pretty much lost her goddamn mind after a year of trauma and brainwashing, being forced to kill her sister, and then losing her newĀ ā€œfamilyā€ after Clementine blew up the boat. She was furious, out of control, bitten, covered in guts and completely out of her goddamn mind. There was no saving her from the start, and she had nothing left to lose.
Georgiaā€™s just an asshole who doesnā€™t give us any real indication that sheā€™s dangerous. Sheā€™s all talk and glares... then she comes back covered in blood after finding Tim soooo are we to assume thatā€™s when she lost it? When she was likeĀ ā€œI think killing Amos will make everything better,ā€ or was it a sporadic, in the moment decision?Ā 
In fact, why wasnā€™t she the one to shoot Helen then?? Why did you have Olivia, who is supposed to be a thing with Amos later, when you couldā€™ve really established Georgia as the real threat when she shoots the horse and is like,Ā ā€œtoo bad, so sadā€ and then have OliviaĀ come in and calm the situation?Ā 
Tumblr media
Establish that sheā€™s possessive of Olivia early on, not when sheā€™s two seconds from death and spouting,Ā ā€œHe was gonna take you away from me! I had to kill him! I did it all for you!ā€ nonsense...
Thereā€™s just so many little things that couldā€™ve been tweaked or added to make her a better antagonist, but no, weā€™re left with nothing with irritation.Ā 
God, JoanĀ from ANF was a more layered villain than this and she was boring as hell.... ugh.Ā 
Tim: where did he come from?? where did he go?? where did he come from, Cotton-Eye Joe???
Tumblr media
Timā€™s pretty chill, but a waste of a character.Ā 
He comes outta nowhere to save Clementine and gets bit in the process, but heā€™s fine with it because it was bound to happen sooner or later, and at least he saved Clementine.
There isnā€™t too much to say about Tim that I havenā€™t already said. The scene with him was pretty good, but heā€™s not around enough to feel like an actual character. Heā€™s just here to make sure Clementine feels bad that she got yet another person bit and to give some info on the twins.Ā 
Tumblr media
But heā€™s dead now so... cool.Ā 
TheĀ ā€œRomanceā€: if you squint hard enough, you might see it?Ā 
Tumblr media
I donā€™t understand why the marketing around this book put such an emphasis on the romance aspect. Remember when the trailer dropped and we got a look at Ricca and it was likeĀ ā€œooohhh new love~ā€
What love? There is no love, thereā€™s no chemistry, thereā€™s no soft sad uwu wlw love story here! What the hell?? Just gonna lie to me like that, huh??Ā 
Okay look... I went into this with an open mind about Ricca. Truly, I did. You know me, you know Iā€™m a never gonna change my mind that clouis is the best, but I took both clouis and violentine and set them aside. I put them out of mind and let myself go into this wantingĀ to ship Clementine and Ricca. I was ready for the sad girlfriends trying to survive this bullshit together with their token straight buddy.Ā 
Tumblr media
And then I came outta this wondering why Amos wasnā€™t the love interest? I mean, I know the answer to that so a better question: Tillie, why not just make Amos a girl and have Clementine fall for her instead? The foundation was set, thereā€™s a lot of interesting things you couldā€™ve done with that given Amos being Amish and all. They had a solid thing going on and the only reason I knew they werenā€™t going to end up together was because it was written by Tillie Walden, a queer woman who writes wlw.Ā 
Tumblr media
So Iā€™m baffled at everything lacking between Clementine and Ricca! I mean, Tillie could be saving the meat of the romance for the next installments which fine, if thatā€™s the case then I will happily keep an open mind and see if this relationship improves since right now? This ainā€™t it, chief.Ā 
Lemme give you an example of something that couldā€™ve been sweet, mā€™kay? After they have the generator fixed, Clementine asks Ricca why she always leans in so close to her.Ā 
Tumblr media
Ricca begins to explain that everything has started getting blurry... meaning her eyesight is getting worse and all these glasses she owns may not work for long. A scary thought, especially when you factor in her backstory with her brother.Ā 
This feels like a set up for soft moment, something I wanted to see more of... only for it to be rudelyĀ interrupted by Amos being murdered.Ā 
Like.... Cā€™moooooon maaaaan...
Tumblr media
UGH
Thereā€™s no warm fuzzy feelings here, and the only time I went,Ā ā€œthey could be cute if it could get me investedā€ was the ending where Ricca is clinging to Clementine as Olivia boots up the plane and starts flying.... but even then, that moment is cut short because Clementine has to be all,Ā ā€œletā€™s show Amos the plane one more time.ā€Ā 
They donā€™t kiss here, either. There isnā€™t a first kiss moment, there isnā€™t a confession scene, there isnā€™t even an admission of feelings on either side. Ricca calls herĀ ā€œbabyā€ and now I guess theyā€™re something?Ā 
ā€œClementine, baby, donā€™t let me die here~ā€
Ugh. Do you know what I think of when I hear the wordsĀ ā€œClementineā€ andĀ ā€œbabyā€ in the same sentence? I think of the voicemail Clementineā€™s mother left in ep1 of S1:Ā ā€œClementine, baby, if you can hear this, call the police... itā€™s 9-1-1... and we love you... we love you...ā€Ā 
So excuse me if I donā€™t have a great response to that.Ā 
Anyway, maybe itā€™ll improve with the next book which shouldnā€™t be too hard given all the nothingĀ this book gave.Ā 
The Lee Flashbacks/Nightmares: hey, remember season one? remember Lee? remember when Lee died and Clem was sad? do you remember??
Tumblr media
Uuuuggghhhhhhhhhhhhhh.......
To their credit, these flashbacks are pretty loyal to the games as far as dialogue and setting, but the main point of them is for fans of the games to read this and be likeĀ ā€œohhh I remember Lee, he sparks joy!ā€ and for new readers to have a face to a name when Clementine talks about him to Ricca.Ā 
But they donā€™t do much to improve the story. The only time I appreciated how one tied into the story was when Clementine watched Amos fall. We see her and Lee on the train, and we get this dialogue:
ā€œAsk me anything, Clementine.ā€
ā€œWill the pain ever stop?ā€
because yeah... watching Amos die was pretty damn painful, ties in well.Ā 
But other than that? Meh... which is crazy to say about LEE but thatā€™s the comic for ya.Ā 
Final Thoughts: I canā€™t believe I read this 9 times
Tumblr media
Whatā€™s that thing called when you keep repeating a thing hoping itā€™ll be different but never is? Madness? Is that what Iā€™m feeling right now?Ā 
9 times, good god....
It wasnā€™t worth reading that many times and yet, here I am, a mad lass dissecting a comic I donā€™t like that remains unfaithful to a character I love. I watched and read so many interviews with Tillie, I kept tabs on reddit threads about this book, I pestered my discord buddies about it... canā€™t wait to do this two more times...Ā 
In the end, this book isnā€™t good. I like a couple things, but the good doesnā€™t outweigh the bad. Itā€™s definitely not canon with the games, no matter how hard Skybound whines that it is.Ā 
I canā€™t recommend it to any of you. If youā€™re gonna read it, you can find the whole thing for free on youtube. If you wanna support Tillie Walden without supporting this series, check out her other works. Iā€™d recommend On a Sunbeam or Spinning.Ā 
btw did yā€™all hear they released the description of Book Two?
Tumblr media
ā€œClementine and her new friends are rescued by an island community led by an enigmatic doctor called Miss Morro, but just as Clementine's scars are finally beginning to heal, she discovers dark secrets that threaten to tear her new life apart. Can Miss Morro be trusted? What about the rest of the islanders? And just how far will Clementine go to protect the ones she loves? Tilllie Walden's acclaimed trilogy continues! ā€
I dunno how Iā€™m gonna survive Book Two if I donā€™t even have Amos to look forward to..... guess Tillieā€™s just gonna have to make me like Ricca, huh?Ā 
I also need to keep in mind that this IS a trilogy, so questions I have now and am annoyed about may get answered in the next book, Olivia might go from being stale white bread to a wonderful slick of cinnamon and raisin bread, and the romance may start existing... wonā€™t know until June.Ā 
No wait, excuse me, October... theyā€™ve already pushed the release date later for the next one soooo thatā€™s interesting.Ā 
This is the part where I ask what you thought. What are your thoughts on Clementine Book One? Iā€™m curious to know. Send an ask or leave a comment on this review. I know this was long but hey, thanks for sticking around to the end, itā€™s appreciated.Ā 
Thanks for reading!Ā  šŸ’š
153 notes Ā· View notes
nitpick7 Ā· 3 years ago
Text
Ayo anyone wanna see my essay on why removing Anybody Have A Map made the Dear Evan Hansen movie worse? It is slightly long
Disclaimer: I did like the movie (I cried three times), but I think they made some stupid decisions with it.
Dear Evan Hansen movie + musical spoilers under the cut, plus a fair amount of DEH neg/crit
Instead of Anybody Have A Map, they just have Evan's mom say "Hey are you writing those letters to yourself? Also you should ask the kids to sign your cast" before he goes to school and sings Waving Through A Window. They ignore every other part of the song and quickly insert the only thing from the song that's absolutely needed to understand the story so Evan can go be angsty at school. We don't even meet the Murphys until they meet Evan in the principal's office to tell him about Connor.
Disclaimer part 2 electric boogaloo: I complain about Evan a lot here. It's not because I think his experiences aren't valid and it's not because I'm trying to demonize people with mental illnesses or something. I know that his own struggles influenced his bad decisions. That doesn't mean they weren't bad decisions. He still did shitty things and he wasn't justified (listen to Words Fail), but I know it was influenced by his mental health.
On with the complaining!
First of all, the movie opens with Waving Through A Window? It feels like they're putting the most popular song first as a desperate grab for your attention to convince you the movie is good and like... they really didn't need to do that. Waving Through A Window is right after Anybody Have A Map, it's not like anyone's gonna walk out of the theatre after one (really good) song.
Anybody Have A Map establishes a few things: it shows us that both of these families are struggling so that we know immediately that the Murphys' perfect facade is fake, it shows us that Connor was a dick to his family (this is very important), and obviously it tells us why Evan was writing letters to himself. It also introduces us to the two main families at the same time so we know this story isn't just about Evan.
By starting the movie with an Evan solo song instead of the group song, they frame Evan as the one main character, the only person whose perspective we need to understand. But Evan is incredibly flawed, just like everyone else, and by making us think the story is only about him, it immediately makes us (the audience) more inclined to believe that Evan is always in the right and less inclined to consider everyone else's side of the story. Evan is an incredibly unreliable narrator, he's always going to frame his actions as correct, or at least excusable, even when he's actively hurting/lying to other people.
All of the Murphys get introduced through interacting with Evan instead of interacting with each other. This makes it seem like the Murphys only exist for Evan, but the entire point of the climax is that everything doesn't exist just for Evan! Evan is not part of their family, he can't just use everyone around him for his own benefit, and all of the Murphys have lives outside of him. When they're introduced through Evan, they're introduced as existing for Evan. Anybody Have A Map introduces them separately from Evan instead of attached to him.
Without Anybody Have A Map, we never actually see Connor being mean to Zoe, so she just looks like an asshole for not being sad about her dead brother. To make up for it, she's constantly having to tell the audience why she hated him, tripping over herself to talk about all the shitty things he did to her because we don't have Anybody Have A Map to show us their interactions. Zoe ends up complaining about her brother the entire time, so when it gets to Only Us and she says that she doesn't want everything to be about her brother, it seems out of character for her.
And with the removal of Anybody Have A Map, we don't ever see Connor interact with his own family in the movie. Anybody Have A Map is the only time we get to see Connor with his family. It shows us that Connor really was an asshole to his family, it justifies Zoe hating him, and it gives his mom more dimensions by showing her struggling to keep her family together even with everyone fighting against her. Without that, the writers ended up ignoring the most basic piece of writing advice - "show, don't tell" - to fill in the missing information from the song.
In the movie, all we get of Cynthia Murphy is... her being sad about Connor and refusing to admit that he ever did anything wrong. She's just boring and annoying in the movie, but in the musical, we get that bit at the beginning that shows her as an actual person with actual motivations! By cutting Anybody Have A Map, they made her into a more one-dimensional character.
So in a bit of a conclusion: Anybody Have A Map establishes the Murphys as main characters separate from Evan and shows us Connor's relationship with his family instead of telling us about it. It sets the scene for the story before just jumping into "Evan is sad and alone uwu anxious depressed soft boy" and makes everyone a better, more three-dimensional character. Getting rid of it meant that they had to do backflips to justify everyone's decisions during the movie instead of setting everything up at the beginning.
I do think the movie could've benefitted from Disappear but then again, it could've benefitted from the whole "Connor being the visual/vocal representation of Evan's justifications for why keeping up the lie is helping people" thing in general, but they got rid of that so Disappear wouldn't have worked. (I am salty that they got rid of that thing but whatever) The Anonymous Ones worked instead and it was a good song, so sure, why not I guess? /neutral
I could also complain about how they got rid of To Break In A Glove, Disappear, and Good For You, but none of those decisions actually impacted the story too much. To Break In A Glove and Good For You both got replaced with some tell-not-show cutscenes that gave us the same information in a less interesting way (and Larry got less character development without To Break In A Glove), and Disappear got replaced with an Alana song which was honestly pretty good so i'm fine with that one.
Now for some good changes that the movie made!
The Anonymous Ones was a good song, I actually really liked that. I'm disappointed that they got rid of Disappear, but they replaced it with another song that served the same purpose while also giving Alana more screen time and character depth! And it was a genuinely good song, I really enjoyed it and it made me like Alana more!
I really liked the ending of the movie. In the musical, there are literally no negative consequences for Evan, Zoe even forgives him at the end. She fucking forgives him for lying to her entire family about their dead son and and taking advantage of them because it "brought them closer together". And the internet never finds out what he did! He does all this terrible shit, lies to the entire fucking world, and gets away scot-free. And he never learns anything real about Connor. The movie changes all of that.
Connor's song was also a great addition! Every time we saw Connor in the musical, he was either being a dick or he was a fantasy version of himself made by Evan and/or Jared. Seeing that Connor can, in fact, be a nice person, that Cynthia's belief in him wasn't misplaced, was so satisfying. He really was just a meaner version of Evan a troubled kid lashing out at the world in self-defense. He wasn't an entirely bad person.
The Murphys still decide not to tell anyone what he did, but then Evan decides (on his own!) that he needs to own up to what he did. He records a video of himself admitting to what he did, shifts all the blame to himself, and then goes out of his way to fix his mistakes in any way he can. He says that his biggest regret is not getting to know Connor while he had the chance, so he goes online to find anything he can. He reads Connor's favorite books, tries to find anyone who might be able to tell him what Connor was like, and when he receives a video of Connor playing his song in rehab, he takes the time to send the video (through the mail, on a flash drive) to the Murphys, Jared, and Alana.
Evan doesn't contact Zoe at the end, she contacts him instead. She doesn't forgive him, and he doesn't ask for forgiveness. He knows what he did was wrong and he owns up to it and tries to fix it as much as possible, knowing full well that it could ruin his life. He does the right thing for the first time in the entire fucking movie (that's hardly even an exaggeration) and it's such a good ending. It makes more sense and is more satisfying than the musical.
The Dear Evan Hansen movie was not nearly as bad as the reviews say it was. It wasn't as good as the musical, it had its own problems, but it also made some good changes that I think made the story better. It wasn't perfect, but I enjoyed it and most movies aren't perfect anyway. It really could've benefitted from Anybody Have A Map, though.
54 notes Ā· View notes
anxresi Ā· 4 years ago
Text
I could line my wall with all the posts Thomas has made about Chloe tonight. (around 50, by my count)
If you wanna read them, donā€™t bother.
I certainly wonā€™t be sharing any of them
What would be the point?
Because basically, they amount to one thing...
Chloe is bad, and weā€™re bad people for liking her.
Thatā€™s it.
And for anyone thinking that he kids around a lot with his comments...
Iā€™m pretty sure this is something he feels VERY strongly about.
Or he wouldnā€™t expand so much energy in constantly talking her down.
So no, I donā€™t think weā€™re going to get a Chloe redemption.
No, I donā€™t think sheā€™ll be Queen Bee again.Ā 
No, I canā€™t see any real change in her behavior.
Sheā€™ll just remain the same olā€™ hatable Chloe, theĀ ā€˜evilā€™ girl that young kids apparentlyĀ ā€˜getā€™ that adults donā€™t understand...
Yep, apparently weā€™re ā€˜dumbā€™ for wanting her to improve and develop!
To provide a good example for bullies out there that they can be more than just abusers all their lives!
Children couldnā€™t possibly grasp the delicate subtleties of self-improvement as you grow up!
Itā€™s all so clear now!
Stupid us!
Also, her merchandise doesnā€™t sell very well.
Another good case for her staying as a villain, I guess.
And sheā€™s compared to a monster and a domestic abuser.
This damaged teenage girl.
Yeah, sounds about right.
And all those tender moments where she showed empathy and love were justĀ ā€˜fake outsā€™ all along.
Makes total sense!
And anyone who wanted more from her is justĀ ā€˜delusionalā€™ and isĀ ā€˜writing the show in their headā€™.
Exactly!
Except...
Thatā€™s not the way it seemed on screen at all.
When she hugged Miss Bustier
Or had a heart-to-heart with Ladybug
When she risked her life as Queen Bee
Showed genuine concern for Adrien
When she finally appreciated Jean-something
And shared moments of friendship with Sabrina
These did NOT come across as part of an elaborate plot twist
From a show which isnā€™t exactly known for its complex writing.
They seemed to form part of a ladder...
Which would inevitably climb to a true character shift.
Where this flawed teenage girl could take a long, hard look at her life.
And realize she didnā€™t HAVE to be like her awful mother.
Or as power-hungry as her father.
She could learn lessons from her favorite superhero Ladybug...
Become a better person...
And an even greater superhero.
She could still keep her sassy attitude.
Just be a bit kinder and selfless, thatā€™s all.
But, nope.
EVERY bit of niceness we witnessed on screen...
None of it was real.
It was all influenced byĀ ā€˜classā€™.
Even her childhood friendship with Adrien was nothing.
If he was as poor as the rest of his classmates, she wouldā€™ve bullied him too.
Straight from Thomasā€™s own mouth.
One of the best relationships in the show, gone just. Like. THAT.
He also said toĀ ā€˜redeemā€™ her at this stage would be tooĀ ā€˜unconvincingā€™?
ORLY?
I hate to return to critical mode...
But the show ainā€™t exactly known for its consistent writing.
One minute Marinette is confident around Adrien...
Next sheā€™s a nervous jumble of words.
It sets up two new ships for Mari and Adrien with great fanfare...
Only to ditch them both two eps later.
(Also, what the **** did they plan to do with Lila?!)
In other words, this isnā€™t a show that plays the long game
Whether this is to satisfy the networksā€™ demand to air the eps out of order idk.
The point is that trying to tell us that Chloeā€™sĀ ā€˜arcā€™ was some grand scheme...
Where sheā€™d have a few sympathetic moments only to emerge worst than ever afterwards....
I simply donā€™t believe it.
Either this is terrible, amateurish writing of the worst kind...
Or Thomas flexed his influence behind the scenes...
And put an abrupt end to Chloeā€™s development before it really got started.
It doesnā€™t really matter which reason I guess.
What DOES matter is this petty and spiteful man sees fit to bash her in around 70% of his online interactions right now.
He could just ignore the posts but nope, he goes right in there, full throttle.Ā 
You can just tell how smart he is with his intimate psychological breakdowns of why Chloe is the way she is...
When we all know the actual reason... he just couldnā€™t be bothered.
Far better to create a whole new character, give her none of the depths that could make a developed Chloe such a pain to write...
And then 'rewardā€™ her with the position of Queen Bee, for being super-sweet and as shallow as a puddle.
And oops, make her Chloeā€™s half-sister or whatever to further rub salt in Chloe stansā€™ wounds.Ā 
Is the show even gonna tackle the angst that would arise from Mayor Andre discovering his beloved wife had an affair?
Or Chloe discovering her much-loved mother is in fact a cheat?
What about coping with the SHOCK revelation that she... GASP... has a long-lost sister?
Forget it. All that rich potential for human emotions sounds B O R I N G.
Donā€™t forget that if thereā€™s a major event in this show that doesnā€™t include the wordsĀ ā€˜Love Squareā€™, the makers just donā€™t care.
Letā€™s cut straight to a giant golden Zoe (who now looks like a giant golden Chloe) trying to smoosh her now much smaller sister...
While Chloe pushes Marinette and her parents towards the beast to save herself.Ā 
Because of course she does.
Never misses a trick to make Chloe look bad, does Thomas.
Itā€™s a skill you can tell heā€™s very proud of.
Anyway, back to Zoe...
Despite my harsh words above, I harbor no ill-will towards you.
Your design is decent and you seem like a stand-up gal.
But I hate to say this...
You shouldnā€™t exist.
It was completely unnecessary from a storytelling POV to create a sibling for Chloe, and your mere presence will diminish the show.
I can say this with utmost confidence after looking at the situation from every conceivable angle...
Without even needing to watch your eps or know why you were created.
(Although, I have a pretty good idea)
Some people might say WELL GIVE HER A CHANCE!!!!
Hmm... no.
Everything the show needs to be successful with Chloeā€™s character...
Itā€™s already right there.
She does not need a secret sibling
She does not require a sweeter counterpart
And she definitely DOESNā€™T need Thomas constantly bashing her to impressionable fans online like sheā€™s the Antichrist personified!
Seriously dude, if you hate her so much why bother creating her?
And if you hate her so much... why spend so long talking about her?
Despite his repeated denials, I think something another user here said is very true...
She DOES liveĀ ā€˜rent freeā€™ in his head.
It sickens him that, despite his best efforts, she still has so many fans.
Not to worry, Thomas.
From what I see, there are still plenty of sycophants who agree with everything you say (even if they actually donā€™t)
After all, itā€™s enough for some to get a reply from theĀ ā€˜great manā€™ himself
Why jeopardize that by trying to engage with him in a meaningful debate?
Especially when we know how handsy he is with theĀ ā€˜blockā€™ button.
Anyway, this went on for about a thousand more words than I meant it to.
I guess me and Thomas have just ONE thing in common (Thank God)
This is a topic which we both feel VERY strongly about.
The differently is of course, I have far less power in the process, and preach to a much smaller audience.
Still, I wonā€™t let that stop me ranting away like a loon.
Hey, if itā€™s good enough for him... ;)
78 notes Ā· View notes
tundrainafrica Ā· 3 years ago
Note
Hi Sav,
I want to ask your opinion about aot in general. We know that Aot is a good show and has great stories.
But, do you have any critiques on aot? I'd love to know...
Thank you in advance šŸ˜„
Thank you for the ask! I actually am a serial complainer so I LOVE LOVE LOVE answering things like this because I have complaints about a lot of things lmao.
At the same time though, Iā€™m answering this as a Levihan fan.
Occasionally, I would see AOT material and feel this strange disconnect because I think Iā€™ve read and written too much fanfiction that when I actually see AOT material, Iā€™m like ā€˜wait oh right, Levi and Hange came from there....ā€
To answer your question though, here are my general complaints about ATOT as a whole.
The general reason why I kinda feel strongly about the story telling being REALLY weak towards the end is because AOT started strong. Like, Iā€™m sure most people can agree that in the anime at least, or maybe in most parts of the manga as well. every panel, every scene HAD purpose, which adds to the overall quality of the writing and the pacing.
The plot twist and the change in genre was also built really well. Yams left enough to speculate and he also created this story where every scene had a purpose in building the overall plot, the plot twists were done incredibly well. He cleverly planted all the hints, most readers wouldnā€™t have been able to pick up which was created some really great rewatch value for the previous seasons.
Character death wise, he was also incredibly trigger happy but all of the deaths seemed to have had a purpose anyway so I wasnā€™t too salty about all the characters dying. And most important characters who died anyway, died for one reason, to introduce a villain or to signal an end of an age, or there was a huge build up/foreshadowing leading towards the death which made it stomachable.
Towards the end though, Yams wasnā€™t writing to actually build some plot twist anymore. He actually had to pull at the threads of every single plot point he planted and write some semblance ending.
No ending can satisfy everyone but for me, a quality ending is supposed to tie all the loose ends in some tight logic manner which Yams low key KINDA failed to do. This explains why when the purpose of writing ā€˜changedā€™ from setting up AOT for a major plot twist and a genre shift to actually tying all the loose ends, the quality of writing kinda diminished.
With the amount of questions left unanswered, I canā€™t help but think Yams was in a hurry to just end the damn thing. (But really, Iā€™m not too blah about it, because the story telling and world building was great overall, itā€™s just the ending which left a lot to be desired. At least, itā€™s not ā€˜Game of Thronesā€™ BAD lmao)
Tight Story Telling
Story telling is supposed to have a purpose. Every scene, every death, every scene leading to the finale is supposed to have a damn purpsoe and literally, itā€™s been months and I still think about Hangeā€™s death as one of the most pointless plot developments in AOT.
HANGE DIDNā€™T. THEY LITERALLY JUST DIED. And every day, I literally try to fathom why the hell, Yams had to kill her, and I have speculations about it. The strongest one being the fact that Yams didnā€™t know what to do with Hange towards the end of the show and he needed to kill someone to prove the gravity of the situation I guess. And I guess Hange was the best option since she was old or something or she was just so difficult to write that Yams decided to kill them?
And I dunno it just seems like an asspull.
And Hangeā€™s death wasnā€™t built up at all. Like there were no signs, there was nothing, no character arc which could have made it stomachable so Hangeā€™s death just seems like lazy writing to me tbh and I kinda take it slightly personally because most casual readers I know tend to gloss over Hangeā€™s death?? Which kinda diminished Hangeā€™s character as a whole
And I thought about who could have died other than Hange and I realized, no one was built up to die in that scene? Or there wouldnā€™t have been anyone in that scene who I would have been okay with dying? Which kinda points to the fact that maybe Yams just didn't prepare properly for that death scene?
Which brings me to my next point.
Consistency of Characters
If a character is prepared for greatness, it doesnā€™t make any damn sense to put them through shit and kill them in some anti climactic way (Like Circe in GOT style)
And at the same time, most people might not agree with me here but I guess it kinda doesnā€™t make sense for me to see Eren redeemed at the end for the sake of love? Or him having to do everything for the sake of JUST the love with Mikasa?
It makes sense, I have to admit, there were plot points which hinted to the really strong bond between Mikasa and Eren but destroying the whole world FOR Mikasa? All Iā€™m getting from this is Eren is just some crazy psycho who is overly obsessed with a girl that he tries to destroy the world and his sacrifice was in vain anyway because the world was kinda messed up too.
I personally think it would have been way more stomachable if Yams just highlighted everyone as a whole instead? Like it seems much more believable for me to think that Eren reached points of irredeemable or maybe if Yams just highlighted the fact that Eren did it for EVERYONE, not just for Mikasa. Because I think with the way that Yams wrote it (putting emphasis on Erenā€™s relationship with Mikasa), most casual readers would gloss over the fact that Eren had no choice. If he didnā€™t do the rumbling, Paradis would have been overrun.
Mikasa being there and her relationship with Eren WAS built up from the start so it has some place in the ending. But to put it at the centerpiece instead of Erenā€™s relationship with the whole Paradis which would have kinda made Erenā€™s decision to just ā€˜genocideā€™ everyone make more sense.
Some parts of the ending kinda remind me of weathering with you and I have a lot of beef with that movie.
Which brings me to my next point:
Values Dissonance (????)
Whenever I read or finish something, the final question I ask myself is ā€˜so what? what is this piece of media trying to tell me?ā€
For AOT, I think the most glaring message is ā€˜the cycle of hatred always continues,ā€™ but I don't think that the message was properly built up? Yams went through the love, the relationships and he highlighted them too brightly for me to even properly stomach the 'cycle of hatred' message as the main one.
It seemed like, towards the end he was jumping from one message to the other in a low key sloppy way and there was no consistent message in all of them.
What was Erenā€™s purpose? What was the purpose of his sacrifice? What was the purpose of the sacrifice everyone was making?
If Isayamaā€™s whole intention was to tell us that the sacrifice was meaningless and the cycle of hatred continues, I feel like there were better ways to build this up than to dangle ā€˜loveā€™ in front of us and as the centerpiece of the genocide and the finale before the extra pages in some way where it wasnā€™t even properly built up in the first place.
That 180 from 'okay Eren did all these stuff out of loveā€™ which is kinda overly mushy and kinda crazy already mushy way and suddenly create this message like the ā€˜world is doomed, seems like a sloppily placed 'plot twist' to me. Like the type of plot twists authors just put to surprise the reader but it doens't seem well thought out in the first place.
Why highlight something as hopeful as love and make Eren start the war over it when youā€™re just going to create some major dissonance with a plot twist. Like with the values Yams was highllighting towards the end, I feel like it was a roller coaster with a lot of abrupt twists and turns and there was no time to really reflect on the overall message because he was highlighting too many opposing points at once with no clear thread connecting all of them
I donā€™t know if I make any sense here haha but yeah, those are my general complaints with AOT as a whole. Donā€™t get me wrong, I love AOT as a whole but I guess like all shows it has its flaws especially towards the ending.
And hey Yams, still made Levi and Hange and I think anyone who built a world complex enough to inspire others to write fanfiction and draw fanart is a good author either way.
Disclaimer: These are just my thoughts on what I remember from reading but I have been trying to forget a lot of the plot points so I can enjoy it again when the anime comes out. My thoughts might change depending on what I think after rewatching.
30 notes Ā· View notes
algernoninwonderland Ā· 4 years ago
Text
'Lie' - wow, that's an episode and stuff. It had some genuinely great ideas and some sincerely terrible things in it too, it left a bitter taste in my mouth and I wish it hadn't
The Good
Chat Noir truly is a cat, overdramatic and teasing and inconsiderate and flawed, that's great.
He drinks milk when he's sad. It's genuinely funny!
All these parallels between the Tsurugis and the Agrestes. Some basic directing ideas but they work really well.
Kagami likes Toulouse Lautrec, she's a perfectionist artist and has to keep it a secret from her mother. And this isn't a hobby related to Adrien or her family's legacy, it's the thing she enjoys doing on her own. It's a good idea!
The repetitiveness of the "throwing the paper ball in the bin" motive. That's basic directing, again. But it works well. I like it when things work well, and sometimes they do.
Kagami sees through the lies of the Jedi Adrien's facade in a way none of the other characters have this far. I'd go as far as to say that she's a lot more perceptive about him than Marinette.
She's really assertive and that isn't shown to be necessarily an absolutely bad thing, or an absolutely good thing. There's some nuance in there. Can you believe it?
Nice fencing scene there, all these sparks weren't really necessary but it's done competently. They got the movements and the speed right.
The show really hammers down the fact that being friends/dating a superhero without knowing their secret identity means you're forced to deal with them vanishing all the time and hiding things from you and that it's pretty terrible. Kagami's expression progressively sours as Adrien is shown to disappear more and more. That's good directing.
Some good character blocking and shot composition during the scene taking place outside the HĆ“tel de Ville.
ā€œA cop never lies!ā€ ā€œYou're lying!ā€
Bob Roth calling out Jagged Stone.
Fang, the true Best Boy of this show.
Some really stellar voice acting from Benjamin Bollen. He's always good.
Kagami isn't the bad guy for taking her distances with Adrien! Wowie!
The Bad
Cheap ship teasing is cheap.
Would they really leave Adrien making a sadder face in that TV show thing? Nah, that's a moment that completely breaks that conceit.
Portraiture as the capture of the truth within people, ā€œportraits can't lieā€ and all that stuff. The art historian within me is shrivelling.
The show is mixing up a lot of stuff for the sake of this ā€œtruth and honesty and liesā€ and remains very superficial about these things.
What is Adrien's ā€œtrue selfā€ anyway? Is his being a clown as Chat Noir part of his facade or not? It's really interesting and that would require an episode of its own but no, have a handful of minutes instead, that should do the trick, right? No it doesn'tā€¦
Everything after the 13 minute mark, really.
What kind of villain design is that? What is it meant to convey? Liars are paralysedā€¦ That's it? Wow. I'm genuinely impressed. Incredible stuff. I am awed.
That white ball of light means some pretty ugly rendering. Like, really ugly. There's exactly one good-looking shot during this akuma fight and it's the one they used in the season's trailer.
DQ Animation and Artage Studio are getting better. They're still not as good as SAMG. Which means that the character acting is really wooden during the more subtle moments, and generally not as good as the scenes would require. Character make weird faces that don't quite work during some scenes. It's not distractingly awful but it's not good.
It's a show with a fandom that uses every little character detail to call a character they don't like the literal devil. Kagami expressing her anger physically is a double-edged sword.
Some really weird shots with weird camerawork.
The Ugly
Do you remember when Marinette said she loved Adrien because he was kind and caring and all of that stuff and then started drooling over the picture-perfect, airbrushed image of him instead of trying to get to know him as a person, meaning that she's in love with his image? But then the show still tried to push the idea that she was truly in love with him as a person? They're still doing this now. We've had the exact same joke for like two seasons. And yet we're meant to root for Adrien and Marinette to get together becauseā€¦???
Chat Noir acts irresponsibly, yet has immense responsibilities, the show portrays him as funny and as always itā€™s inconsequential, he never has to face the consequences of his actions for more than five seconds
That scene with ChloƩ and Sabrina. Is is supposed to be funny? Is it supposed to be awful? I don't know. It was just rubbish.
I get that the point is that Kagami has to lie to spend more time with Adrien and that she's done so during Ikari Gozen already but are you sure this is the same character who needed an app to talk to people just a couple of episodes ago? The same character who absolutely despised liars earlier on? Why not show her second-guessing herself then?
She's a fast learner, for sure, she's been shown to get better at complimenting Marinette in the span of just two episodes, but this is a whole other level of off-screen character development. She used to lie by omission, now she's a very chatty liar.
Which just confirms that in Miraculous, characters change radically to accommodate the episode's theme. They have no integrity, no internal coherence. It's a recurring flaw with the writing and it's never been as glaring as it is now.
That cheese analogy is awful and gross. I already thought that the "changing targets" stuff from the earlier seasons was awful but this is just as bad. So people you want to date are like game or fermented milk, then. How romantic. Not objectifying at all. What a great conception of what relationships are like.
Some pretty awful writing. Chat Noir "dyingā€ was cheap and fell completely flat and the dialogue came straight out of a Wattpad fic.
Shadow Moth's ā€œNooooooooā€, straight out of Revenge of the Siths.
And now the lesson of the episode isā€¦ Love Square, Hell Yeah? Really?
What was that final scene? It's rushed and stupid and we're meant to be satisfied with it but it's the worst thing ever and ā€œsometimes we must lie but we know we can trust each otherā€ is such a hypocritical line when you take the show as it has been this far. And yet you're meant to clap and be happy about it?
This episode is a mess and I don't know what we're supposed to do with it. Give Kagami her own show.
87 notes Ā· View notes
thedragonemperess Ā· 4 years ago
Note
What's your personal opinion on why Elite Force was so bad? Since I've ranted about that a lot and started the 'elite discourse' tag.
Introduction
I donā€™t think it was really bad. Yes, it was terrible compared to Lab Rats and Mighty Med (of which both deserved more seasons since they both set up so much and than threw it all away), but it wasnā€™t too bad. Why it was bad, though? They undid all character development, overlooked some of the best characters, and so much more!
Chase
Thereā€™s a lot wrong with Chase. First of all, they undid all of his character development and reduced him to a self-centered smart guy. (Iā€™m not gonna say a mini version of Donald because heā€™s really more like Douglas, but they really just threw away his character.) And for character archs. When AJ made his list, he put Chase at the bottom. A good thing to point out is that this list was based off of the number of powers each person has and the number of powers each person has alone.Ā So lets count how many powers they all have:
Kaz: Pyrokinesis and Flight Oliver: Cryokinesis, Flight, and Super Strength Bree: Super Speed, Vocal Manipulation, Invisibility, and Super Agillity Chase: Molecular Kinesis, Force Fields, Super Intelligence, Super Senses, Laser Bo Generation, and the Commando App (technically Super Strength as well, but thatā€™s only Spike) Skylar: Flight, Super Strength, Super Speed, Acid Spit, Regeneration, and 21 other abilities (10 after the whole thing with Bree, but that still leaves her with the most) CHASE SHOULD BE #2 ON THAT LIST!!
And even if this wasnā€™t based on only their powers, heā€™d still be at #2!!
Then we have the Arcturian. The Arcturian Space Rock will kill you if you make direct contact with it, key word being direct. So Bree, being NUMBER #3 on the list (did I mention they overlooked her abilities, too, with the exception of one throw away line?), decided to touch it. After a series of events, she gets superpowers from it.
Bree got superpowers.
Because she was insecure about her bionic powers.
THIS WAS CHASEā€™S ENTIRE ARCH FROM THE BEGINNING!
And he wasnā€™t only insecure about his powers, he was insecure about his appearance, self-worth, and a ton of other things.
This arch was engineered for Chase, and they threw it away in favor of Bree.
Skoliver
Skylar and Oliver was the main romance of Mighty Med. Oliver had a crush on Skylar and Skylar was a lesbian didnā€™t reciprocate. This didnā€™t stop Oliver from trying to get with her, though. But the difference between Oliver persevering in Mighty Med and Olvier persevering in Elite Force is that in Mighty Med, he did it in a healthy, respectful way. In Elite Force, he became a stalker!
He watched her in her sleep, recorded her without permission, had a pretend version of her that he was dating, and more.
They turned a really nice thing from Mighty Med into something terrible just so that they could put less time into coming up with actual jokes. (The writers of these shows never really handled healthy relationships and comedy well, if Adam and Chaseā€™s relationship says anything, but you would think [Iā€™m only saying this because its Disney] they would put more effort into a romantic relationship.) The worst part about this is that they got together somewhat in the end of Elite Force.
Reese
Reese existed as a way to lead us to the finale of the show. She also existed as a love interest for Chase. She had the potential to be Elite Forceā€™s Marcus or Experion, but they just didnā€™t do it right.
The Lab Ratsā€™ relationship with Marcus was built over the course of two seasons, which let both the audience and the characters get to know him. Sure, we knew he was evil before everyone else, but how evil he truly was changed up until Douglasā€™ plan was finally revealed. He was also really close to a lot of the characters, so that makes it really painful.
Experion was one of Skylarā€™s close friends, almost like a brother, and we saw that play out on screen. He was only there for a short amount of time, just as Reese was, but he was already in a predetermined relationship with him. Reese had literally only met Chase that day, meaning that connection just wasnā€™t there.
(Also, was Reese just there to degay Chase? Because thatā€™s what it seems like.)
Representation And Other Things Of The Sort
Lab Rats was a show that had a family in which half of it was married into. Shows have done this before, yes, but this showed the kids really just excepting it and not getting mad at their respective family. This was also a mixed family, which watching now that Iā€™m older and really understand the importance of it, is really nice. Especially as a mixed person myself.
As for Mighty Med, and Iā€™m starting with family again, it had a father figure who, more or less, actually cared about his kid(s) and was active in their life. It also showed him, a person of color, in a position of power. Skylar, who is a woman of color, was a badass who wasnā€™t boy crazy. She didnā€™t care about boys and the one time she did chase after someone, it was an introverted girl whom she wanted to be friends with which is pretty gay but whatever Disney. She was pretty freaking powerful, too, even without her powers.
Now for Oliver and Kaz, they were geeks. Thatā€™s a recurring fact in the show. Itā€™s also something that is constantly saving all of their butts and was the main thing that got them their jobs. They werenā€™t picked on or made fun of for it, that was just who they were.
And unlike Lab Rats, Mighty Med showed a healthy relationship between brothers. Additionally, Gus was a really weird kid, but no one ever made fun of him, either. They treated him like they treated everyone else. He even ends up as one of the popular kids a few times.
Elite Force really just threw that all away in favor of (what became) a bunch of bratty kids in a pent house together.
Backstory
Mighty Med ended off on a cliffhanger, with Mr. Terror escaping, Oliver and Kaz obtaining superpowers, Alan meeting his father for the first time, and Horace using his last revival. Not to mention, Mr. Terror is Oliverā€™s mother and was supposed to be Horaceā€™s wife.
And then they completely forgot about all of that and destroyed Mighty Med, killing all of the people in it in the process while also forgetting about Mr. Terror completely?
As for Lab Ratsā€™ ending, it was actually pretty fitting and satisfying, all things considered. Adam, Bree, Leo, and Chase split up after defeating Giselle, Adam and Leo going back to the island to help the students with the big change (an update that let them control their abilities, hence no need for them to be teachers anymore) while Bree and Chase joined the Elite Force.
But why Chase and Bree? Sure, I guess the fandom Chase, but we did care about Leo more than Bree if weā€™re looking at it from that stand point. Now if weā€™re looking at it from a logical, in-universe stand-point, it makes no sense. Bree and Chase were the smarter, more experienced of the four, so they should have gone back to the island, while letting Chase and Adam join the Elite force.
Also, Leo has just become a mentor, which was what he was striving for since the start of the season. He was always being overlooked, and now, when he finally gets his moment in the spot light, its taken away from. That just really bothers me.
What Was Good About Lab Rats: Elite Force?
Quite honestly, not a lot. But considering the target audience, it was pretty good. Having two well received shows come together into an, albeit poorly set up and attempted, spin-off where they can have their own battles and story lines together is pretty cool and different. There are some flaws, like how Mighty Med logic and Lab Rats logic really donā€™t intertwine, but you have to keep in mind that this is a kids show.
It also showed Douglas being a pretty good father, which is really nice. Sure, heā€™s their birth father and/or creator, but it also shows them mending their relationship.
There were some smaller things, too. AJā€™s introduction, Skylar and Bree slowly become sisters, and Chase and Kaz becoming friends were all really fun to watch. (The characters growing relationships with each other, period, were fun to watch.) The villains had good motives, and the small cameos from other shows (Bob and Crossbow [sheā€™s more of a piece of what Mighty Med used to be, but Iā€™m counting it]) were really fun to see. The plot could definitely be better, but it was still pretty good. And, as much as I hate to admit it, the show was genuinely funny. The amount of times Iā€™ve spit out my water while watching this show is surprising.
Conclusion
Was Lab Rats: Elite Force as great a show as the source material? No. Was it all we thought it would be at the time? That depends on how old you were when it came out. It was, and still is, a fun show to watch, though. Yes, it would have been better if it never happened and the shows continued separately, but Iā€™m glad that we at least have an answer to what Mighty Med and Lab Rats alluded to in their finales. Am I upset about Elite Forceā€™s finale? Yes, and I will probably die mad about it, but we didnā€™t have as much time to get to know the characters and connect to them, so is it really that much of a loss? Thatā€™s up to you. Is it a fun show to watch? Absolutely.
82 notes Ā· View notes
sorry-rosie Ā· 3 years ago
Text
I keep seeing mentions of drama in Miaā€™s tags but I do not see it? Being a person who stalks Miaā€™s tag for fan art and content often. Something about blaming Chris or Mia for Villageā€™s events.Ā 
Iā€™m going to go into my thoughts on the matter anyways since it comes up a lot from what I read online, spoilers obviously under the cut. Probably going to be a long one.
For one Chris was a little sloppy with his plan and honestly he needs to use his words more as a professional, I do think Mia is justified in yelling at him. And who cares if she yells? Leon and Piers (possibly more) have been cranky with him over less. Sheā€™s a momma bear looking for her husband and child. She is allowed to be justifiably angry with the person who in the present had obligation to protect her family, even if she did bad things in the past. Because the BSAA did promise. She gave up her privacy and both her and Ethan are presumed missing, so they probably have very little freedoms in their daily lives.
But to blame him for the events is ultimately incorrect, I do agree, and I donā€™t think Mia herself was blaming him for literally everything, just mad since he promised them safety. And a theme of 7ā€²s last DLC is how Ethan always kept his promises. Perhaps she had too high expectations for Chris. I wouldnā€™t say sheā€™s incorrect for that either, I mean, Chrisā€™s accomplishments in the series are huge. Heisenberg is very aware of them and Iā€™m sure Mia would be too. He had founded the BSAA after all, so itā€™s not a leap in logic for her to expect him to keep them safe, keep the deal they made with her. So thatā€™s why Mia acts this way in the prison scene and why I could see people blaming him somewhat. He is the experienced military man in a position of power in this situation.
However, in the end we have to keep in mind the BSAA is probably infiltrated by the Connections. Even he was blind to the BSAAā€™s plans so I do not blame him much personally, the Baker file DLC makes clear that the BSAA and Miranda were in the same league. I guess weā€™ll just have to see where that plotline goes on that front, but thereā€™s our villains, clear as day.
On the other hand Mia has been out of work in bioterrorism for whatā€™s going to be a decade in a few years and has suffered the wrath of the consequences of her actions directly in 7. Besides that, the BSAA had promised her immunity, Ethan had forgiven her, and while you may think sheā€™s undeserving of it, in the end she doesnā€™t have to prove that she has redeemed herself. Because if that were the case, no one would ever be satisfied, and frankly the law doesnā€™t work that way. Grand gesture redemptions scream artificiality, so sheā€™s doing about the best she could do by making Ethan happy at the very least and living a new life. All the while wrestling her own trauma inflicted from 3 years of living at the Baker estate.Ā 
Sheā€™s done bad things. But she just isnā€™t guilty for 8, in fact sheā€™s barely even in the game. It feels so out of left field to blame her for everything that ever happens. Blame her for 7, sure, but itā€™s so weird here. While you could be upset about her lying to Ethan about his condition, I can see why she did it. They are already in extreme danger from the Connections with or without Rose, I can imagine, since they are living in Europe without any say.Ā 
While itā€™s questionable her decision to have a kid, sheā€™s trying to balance safeguarding Ethan from the truth that might get them targeted by both the BSAA and the Connections while trying to make him happy. Happiness for him might include a child. In both 7 and 8 their relationship provides a lot of fill-in-the-blanks for players, which I donā€™t mind because it lends itself for some more subtle story-telling elements, but oh man do some of these hot takes seem the farthest from what was intended by the developers.Ā 
To be honest, Ethanā€™s opinion on Mia is the only one that really matters. He still loves her even in death, is sorry, even, for dying. He couldā€™ve left her after 7. By my calculations, they had about a 2 year period after 7 where they were childfree, not expecting either. So to assume he was trapped is very untrue in addition.
Whether or not you personally forgive Mia is irrelevant. You could think whatever you like. And of course, Chris isnā€™t really blamable either in this game. Potentially there couldā€™ve been little things that mightā€™ve saved Ethan. Thereā€™s no guarantees however, and Ethan is quite reckless and ballsy when it comes to protecting his family, so I canā€™t imagine him going strictly by one of Chrisā€™s plans either. In the end I think Mia and Chris did all they could.
But anyways, as for Miaā€™s morality, I like herĀ because she does bad things. Itā€™s okay to like bad, messy, complicated characters.Ā No need to defend them, or erase what makes them, well, them. Because thatā€™s life, and morally pure characters are often boring and unrealistic, AND Ethan/Miaā€™s dynamic of Ethan being more perfect husband material while Miaā€™s so flawed gives me life. Thatā€™s the point of them.Ā 
Psst, by the way Capcom, donā€™t you think Mia would be a really good horror protagonist since she has a lot of baggage. How about some more psychological horror like people loved in Benevientoā€™s house? You do like money right?Ā 
Iā€™m kidding, but I do think more people would like her character anyways if she had more content and the developers werenā€™t so scared of using her. Not everyone has to like her, but just wanted to give my opinions real quick since Iā€™m one of the few people who really likes her on here.
32 notes Ā· View notes
mc-critical Ā· 4 years ago
Note
[2/2] i was reading one of your posts about dilruba & something about it made me wish dilruba had more screen time because sheā€™s the only princesses who was extremely dutiful towards her mother & brother but also managed to achieve her own happiness through her marriage. also, one more thing which i wish was done with her character... so like we all know how safiye sultan practically worships hurrem, w/ always remembering her, showing her ring off etc. the way she talks about hurrem is very exaggerated, ā€œhurrem sultan was head to toe power.ā€ which is true but at the same time, the show really didnā€™t show her full & complete power like it was historically and we all know 2 seasons of hurrem went in being immature & not really regal or completely power [& she was still constantly overshadowed by the sultanas of blood]. however, hurrem was still almost like a goddess type figure in mc:k and despite safiyeā€™s strained relations w/ nurbanu, she still praised her a lot. basically, the two figures of the sow & the ring holders from the first show are remember in the second show. but what about mihrimah? she was a vital figure in history & in mustafaā€™s downfall & in the last season of the show even though she didnā€™t receive the ring to signify her as a part of the sow. what i wished for is dilruba idolising mihrimah, aspiring to be a protector of her brother like she was & exaggerating her power like safiye did w/ hurrem. this way, mihrimah could also be remember. also, dilrubaā€™s character was more of what i had imagined for mihrimah. i didnā€™t imagine her to love rustem like dilruba loved davut but i expected mihrimah to be more powerful & dutiful towards her mother [more compared to dilruba but ofc also not to the extent of wanting to kill kids who were part of the dynasty]. anyhow, dilruba couldā€™ve really taken mihrimah as her idol imo as her, halime & davut were a parallel of mihrimah, hurrem & rustem. sorry for the long post! but this is something i wish mc:k had done. [worth nothing that rustem & davut were also similar villanish type guys whoā€™s only redeeming qualities could be their toxic love for their sultanas & their loyalties towards hurrem & halime, though rustem did waver in his loyalty whilst halime sold davut like the dog he is lol]
Dilruba's character development was truly very condensed in these 9 episodes, so there was never going to be enough of her, from whichever angle you look at it. I kinda cut the writers slack, because I know the ratings played a considerable part in MCK's script and they had a lot to do and a lot to rush (whereas in MC they could practically do whatever they wanted, because their ratings were perfect, I guess that's why they had so many concubine arcs hehe), but I love Dilruba and I would've loved more screentime with her. The time we spent with her could feel so minimal to the point we get the impression that we got to know little Dilruba a bit more than the older Dilruba. (the opposite case of little Mihrimah, who was almost a completely different character with a different thematic set-up, her childish love for Bali Bey aside. The older Mihrimah went on a completely different path as a character.) This isn't a bad thing, per say, because little Dilruba had already set the foundation of the character as a whole and we didn't need much more context for her actions than what we already got, but this little amount of screentime could limit her role to a simple, a bit flanderized antagonist to Kƶsem, which is honestly a trend for all of Kƶsem's antagonists in S01.
{Safiye's cult for HĆ¼rrem is one of the most interesting things about her as a character, but it is over exaggerated for the reasons you mentioned just as it simply isn't real. Safiye has never met HĆ¼rrem in person and even if MCK didn't call back to that, Mihrimah actually played an important part in establishing that cult in her training of Safiye. Safiye knows of this powerful S04 HĆ¼rrem who makes everyone tremble before her and considers "survival of the fittest". (MCK Safiye shares the exact same philosophy) What she worships in HĆ¼rrem is rather a picture she has formed in her head, the figure from Mihrimah's stories. This aspect of Safiye's character is used to form her own path in the evolution of power in the SOW, so we could see symbolically how much of what HĆ¼rrem represents has she moulded to her own agenda, it's indeed not presented as the actual truth. It also brings the question and perspective of what fragment of HĆ¼rrem Mihrihah herself sets as an example for herself and others, knowing that she does not completely idealize her own mother in the show. She was perfectly able to call out HĆ¼rrem's own flaws as much as she could openly take HĆ¼rrem's judgement.}
That worshipping of HĆ¼rrem in MCK truly sounded far too ideal and almost god-like, but in reality, not so many people in the show actually practice it. The only person who actively does, is Safiye, a main antagonist. Ahmet only mentions HĆ¼rrem when he gave her crown to Kƶsem. The references to the MC characters and especially the SOW in MCK is fascinating because you can see how you get only the accomplishments of people you've only heard narratives on, but never their actual stories, their actual struggles. People who were actually around the worshipped people and knew them personally obviously have a clearer understanding of who they truly were, like how Safiye called Nurbanu the most beautiful but also the cruelest sultana she's ever known, which makes perfect sense, knowing their rivalry and enmity. Nurbanu is inspired by HĆ¼rrem, but still stood against her with all her might. The people who have heard only basic facts of the more unrealistically idealized sides of those they worship praise merely the symbols of these people, what they were known to represent. Ahmet wants to be as accomplished as SĆ¼leiman, but we, as audience, know of SĆ¼leiman's detrimental flaws as a person and a padişah and we see that, he isn't exactly a person to be praised, let alone worshipped. It's interesting how the SOW call each other back in different ways, but it's all the more interesting that neither Kƶsem, nor Turhan call back to their predecessors. Is it because they've known each other closer than any of the worship? Is it simply because their characters have a different purpose? Is it because the theme of letting go of the past reached its fullest peak? I definetly can't say for sure.
That said, MC Mihrimah isn't from the SOW in the show both symbolically and arc-wise, but having a character that is not from the SOW (Dilruba) worship another character from the other show that also isn't from the SOW (Mihrimah) would be intriguing, judging by their similarities. However, these exact similarities prevent me from assessing this idea entirely, because I don't think it would do the show many favors. It could add even more depth to Dilruba: her willingness to protect Mustafa at all costs would be even more understandable then, knowing how the person she worships did the exact same thing in her eyes - it would turn not into a necessity, but into an ideal to live by, something that not only she has to do, but considers as honorable to do and loves it. But Dilruba is close enough to Mihrimah along with the traits and conceptual differences that set both of them apart - having the parralel be "addressed" in-universe through a direct worship would remind the audience even more that Dilruba is similar to Mihrimah and that may prevent endearment to her character. There are people that consider MCK so similar to MC already, that would be the last nail of the coffin. It may have been a risky move because of the ratings? Safiye worships HĆ¼rrem, but Safiye has a different narrative role than HĆ¼rrem and a more distinct personality, while Dilruba is a more obvious and open parallel. Not to the point of repetition, of course, but it's still close enough for a possible worship for Mihrimah in the show itself to be a dealbreaker for some. I wouldn't mind such a thing for Dilruba at all, but I can see why it possibly wasn't the case.
I'm satisfied with what we got with MC Mihrimah, but I can understand why you would want more power and agency from her. She could be very clueless sometimes which contrasted with her moments of perceptiveness. That was a solid character flaw of hers, but it could be very annoying. But then again, I also get why Mihrimah was the way she was, because MC put the personal motives of a character before any kind of power (or a character wants power for personal motives). Dilruba was perhaps way more ruthless, because MCK itself was more ruthless and it built on the MC themes. Power was already for the sake of power, the time period was more ruthless, everything was happening instantly and there wasn't a place to breathe. While with Mihrimah we got a deeper exploration where we saw more vulnerable sides, Dilruba had both her screentime and this ruthlessness stopping her from developing more and letting her be who she is. I guess both characters had their reasons to be who they were thematically, but writing improvements could still be made, of course.
39 notes Ā· View notes
ceoofanticatradora Ā· 4 years ago
Note
We need more anti C//A who are Adora stans (like you seem to be) so that people can understand that C///A is bad for Adora. Heck C//A is bad for Catra too, but the shippers don't seem to realize it. If Catra had been able to let Adora go maybe she could have healed instead of her festering and the abuse may have ended instead of escalated.
Hello Dear, welcome on my Blog and a big thank you for your message! Firstly I wanna apologize that this response is reaching you more than three full days, almost four later. Just real life getting into the way of my online presence (at least I got my A-Levels admission!) but I assure you that replying to you was on my To Do List the entire time. And while I could've typed something quick, I thought you deserved a full length response just as much as the person before you received. That goes for anyone really to ask/write me anything in the future.
Adora is a character that has flaws, her own interests, things she struggles with/is insecure about etc. but she also still works on being better (up to Season 5). This makes her relatable, fleshed out and overall three dimensional. Overall for me that makes Adora very likeable. Which is funny because when I first watched the show I thought of her as too goofy and felt like she as a character was overall just flat. Her character design did not speak to me either, the ponytail with the weird hair poof and these pointy shoulders of her jacket just really were not my taste. Isn't it amazing how perceptions can change?
As you can guess from that description I did not always stan Adora and she's probably still not my favorite character but over the almost two years I've been in this fandom I've grown rather fond of her. Other important characters to me are Kyle (a very relatable comfort character of mine, he learned to stand up for himself and others and I support that, f*ck Season 5 for barely acknowledging his existence), Lonnie (apart from treating Kyle badly (which I really do NOT support or excuse) I really love her, man, some women just do me like that, I mean she really stood up to Catra like that), Entrapta (I'm autistic too! It's great to have some representation, seeing the ableism/treatment she experiences in the show is not so much though), Seahawk (I don't even know why, I have some issues with his behavior towards Mermista at times but overall I love this dork), Scorpia (she reminds me of myself so much and I really wanna give her hugs, I'm so glad she chose to no longer let Catra treat her like that even though I will be forever salty she just immediately forgave her), Peekablue (I can explain this even less than Seahawk, especially since it was not even really him in the end but his existence somehow helped me cope with Season 5, without him I probably would've left this fandom ... and also my favorite color is blue) and Double Trouble (now there's enough people already critcizing how they're not exactly great Non-binary representation but this dramatic lizard will forever be in my heart, that reality check they gave Catra, basically slapping her in the face with facts was satisfying as h*ck, also I like lizards overall).
Now there's plenty of characters I like, dislike (or even hate) or am simply indifferent about but after all this is not a tier list but me talking about Adora, Catra and Catradora. Adora started off as this girl that was so sure what she was doing is right but once she was taught differently she was willing to leave everything she knew (except Catra, because she valued her despite everything) behind. And not only that, she broke out of the abuse cycle that Catra tried so hard to keep upright. And that is exactly what makes Adora such a good role model. She teaches children (or people) that:
Your past doesn't define what/who you are or what/who you can become
-> Adora used to be a Horde soldier and did not know where she came from, but nonetheless she found herself a family and became a hero that saved thousands of people
You can always change your mind and start a new life if you feel disappointed in what you are doing/who you are as a person
-> Basically the exact same point, Adora started a new life as she saw what the Horde really was and changed her mind about who to fight for
You deserve love too, be it platonic or romantic (or se*ual???) (If you're aro and/or ace just ignore the part that does not work for you)
-> While Adora for various reasons thought her only use was to please others and meet their needs and expectations (mostly due to Shadow Weaver and Catra) she learned to accept that she too deserves love and validation (if the love aspect would not have been focused on it being romantic love so she could smooch Catra in the finale this would've been a billion times better because she got love from her friends that showed her her real value)
You can walk away from something/someone, that does not make you egoistic/selfish
-> Adora walked away from the Horde, after Catra stubbornly refused to come with her despite many offers (basically Catra broke the promise, not Adora) from her too and that did not make her a "traitor" or "selfish", h*ck, Adora in the end did this for a bigger purpose too, even if part of it was her not wanting to live with such wrong morals
Your opinions, feelings etc. about a person/something can change and that is perfectly fine and valid, being able to change is part of what makes someone human
-> Adora's views on many things changed throughout the show: The Horde and the Rebellion, the First Ones, Catra, being She-Ra, herself, her priorities and so on ... she actually makes use of her brain, which is why Catra saying "Don't you ge it?" or calling her an idiot and dumb never sat right with me, she's a realistic character for shifting with her thoughts, feelings etc. and sometimes just does not fully think things through
You don't have to let other people treat you like sh*t (just because they have some issues they never worked through does not give them any right to let it out on you)
-> This point is obviously centered mostly around Catra and her abusing Adora almost every chance she gets, which is why Adora standing up for herself and not letting Catra blame her for her own decisions and mistakes is so important, "You made your choice, now live with it" is one of the most powerful lines throughout all the five Seasons
Now I'm sure there is still more to Adora's character than what I just listed and unfortunately almost all the points basically got pushed aside, well, Adora as a character got pushed aside in Season 5. All her growth, the things that made me love her, see her as great role model for so many people robbed of their value for the sake of making everything revolve around Catra. That brings me to her and how you are absolutely right that Catradora is harmful to both characters. Of course Adora is affected most by it in the end but Catra too is obviously suffering under the fandoms obsession and just the overall idea of them being romantically involved.
Just like with Adora the stans make almost everything about Catra over her relationship with Adora. She too can barely exist outside of it and if she wasn't the fan favorite she'd most likely would too be mostly in Fanarts that include Adora and not just her (if you google "Catra Fanart" most content is still Catra and Catra only but here and there Catradora still peaks through). But for whatever reason the fandom still views her more as her own person as the other ones? Catrouble and Scorptra Shippers might actually still get less hate than Glimmadora Shippers (I'm not denying they don't get any, they most certaintly do) which is just plain hypocricy and favorism. Kinda like the: A woman needs to be loyal to her husband and her husband only but if the husband wants to be active with other women that is perfectly fine because "that is just how men are" or how i like to call it ... sexism. Now in this case they are both women so it's not sexism but yo do get my point.
But much more importantly, Catra has an unhealthy obsession with Adora. Signs of that are for example:
Constantly talking about Adora, even when said person is not around (to Shadow Weaver, Scorpia etc.)
Obsessing over having control over Adora like in that one Episode "Are you kidding? I finally got control over Adora, I'm not giving that up!"
Building her entire character and her actions around Adora "We need to take Adora down", "Adora left me", "I'd rather see the whole world end than see you win!", also shown in Season 5 where she states she does save Glimmer only for Adora and not for Glimmer or to do the right thing
Getting aggressive or very emotional over Adora like clawing the wall, having nightmares etc. (destructive behavior towards herself and others)
Having no or barely any characteristics outside of her relationship with Adora like, we don't know her interests or likes and dislikes outside of being evil, obsessed with Adora, being abused by Shadow Weaver ...
Trying to force Adora to meet her needs and expectations regardless of Adora's owns
Sacrificing her oppurtunity to be happy in the Crimson Waste for the sake of her Adora obsession and being better than her at all costs
So yes, you were very right with saying that not putting Catra in a relationship with Adora would've benefited both characters. Catra could've learned to exist on her own, develop interests and a life outside of Adora. Learn to accept herself and eventually come to terms with her childhood abuse. She could've been free and not "the abusive cat girl that ended up with the person she unhealthily obsessed over to the point of no return" she kinda is now. Even if we ignore the whole "dating your long term abuser" part from Adora's side and "being rewarded" for horrible behavior, Catra alone is not giving a good example to people watching. As much as I dislike Catra, disdain her even, an ending where she is dependent on Adora, unable to stand on her own two legs after she led armies in war is not what I would wish for her, even with a decent redemption arc (that she did not get).
134 notes Ā· View notes
rosereview Ā· 4 years ago
Text
Chain of Iron Review
Like my Chain of Gold review (which you can find on my post list or here) this is going to be a hot mess of emotions and feelings with very many spoilers. If youā€™re wondering if you should read this book (a review without spoilers) my thoughts are go fricking read everything by Cassandra Clare and fall in love with me. Yes, I highly recommend everything that woman has touched with a pen. But besides that, let's get into this review.
Characters
James Herondale- first let's start with one of the main characters who was a big part of this novel. To be honest I donā€™t have much to say about him personally without getting into his relationships with others and the plot points in the book (which I will talk about later), but I guess I will talk about my love for him. I was unsure at first (before Chain of Gold) how I was going to feel about James and if he would be a typical Herondale boy and be very similar to his father or his descendant, Jace. I was worried that he would be too similar to Will and Jace that he would not stand out, but like in Chain of Gold, I was very happy with his individual character traits and personality. While he is like Will and Jace, James is also very different and his own person. Heā€™s a typical heart throb Herondale, while still having this very reserved and responsible side to him that I love so much. His only flaw is something he canā€™t control, so yeahā€¦ strong character.
Cordelia Carstairs- Like last book, I LOVE Cordelia, although this book was harder to read because of what she went through. Multiple times I wanted to just give her a hug and let her cry on my shoulder. I wish she hadnā€™t had to go through so much trauma in this book, but I know sheā€™ll become a better character because of it. The whole ordeal with being Lilithā€™s paladin hurt very much, her unrequited (not really) love for James was heartbreaking to see continuously played on (I JUST WANTED THAT DAMN GRACELET OFF), and the parts about her father also hurt. I need to read Chain of Thorns now, just to make sure that Cordelia is alright in the end.
Matthew Fairchild- talking about Matthew makes me sad because I absolutely love him as a character and I just need him to get better. Iā€™m so happy that he opened up to Cordelia in this book, but I need him to start loving himself again. The pain I feel when reading about him trembling and drinking himself to honestly too much (especially since heā€™s just a fictional character). And thatā€™s really all I want for Matthew, is for him to be okay one day.
Grace Blackthorn- this was very interesting in Chain of Iron because we got a lot of flashback scenes from Graceā€™s point of view and that made me not hate her as much anymore. I still am very annoyed at her, but I like that I can finally see more of her side and sympathize with her. Iā€™m very interested to see more of her character development, especially individually without all the stuff with James obscuring my image of her.
Lucie Herondale- someone else that I found I loved much more in this book was Lucie. In the last book, from what I can remember, Lucie was a little interesting at parts (I kind of want to say annoying, although thatā€™s a little too harsh of a word), but I loved her in this book. She had much more character development (I thought) and her personality came out more in a less hectic way. Her inner thoughts started to make more sense to me, and I loved learning more about her as not someone who is just Jamesā€™s sister, or Cordeliaā€™s future parabatai, but as her own person.
Jesse Blackthorn- Another character I loved to see more of although we mostly just saw him through Lucieā€™s eyes, and I also already loved him even before. He became a much more understanding and developed character in this book and I canā€™t wait to see more of him now that heā€™s alive!
Alastair Carstairs- I totally fell in love with him in this book too! Holy shit, all I wanted to do was hug him and tell him that it would all be alright. Because he is an older sibling I think I can relate to him a lot more now, especially with all this baggage that he was keeping and trying to protect Cordelia from. I found the scenes with just him in them (like when heā€™s thinking about the future while looking out the window in his house after his father dies and thinking about his new baby sibling that will be born) absolutely amazing and captivating. Obviously I used to hate him because of the short stories that he was in the Tales from the Shadowhunter Academy and other extra short stories, but now I need more of him and Iā€™m internally hurting for him.
Thomas Lightwood- Another character I am hurting for and I just need him to be okay. I loved and hated the fact that he felt so hurt for James because of the killer and he wanted to unburden James by catching the killer. I was just so moved but also so angry that he was putting himself in danger that it was a very emotional time reading (like me clutching the book and shouting at Thomas to stop and go back). But I will always love Thomas and canā€™t wait to see more of him.Ā 
Christopher Lightwood- Last but certainly not least, is Christopher, who I am obsessed with. That one POV moment that we had from him was one of my favourites and now I need to hear from him more. I love all of his quirks and his inner thoughts are the most adorable thing but also makes me sad because he has no one but Henry to share them with and who fully understands and appreciates him for who he is. Also I still really find it wild that heā€™s the son of Cecily and Gabriel, who arenā€™t science-y people at all and who are both much more sarcastic characters, while Christopher is just so sweet and perfect. (Not saying Cecily and Gabriel arenā€™t perfect, but still never would have imagined them to have a kid like Christopher, but at the same time I find it so perfect that they did). Also I just love Christopher so much! I know I said that already, but I just canā€™t get over it. I need more of his inner thoughts and just more of HIM.Ā 
Relationships
Now we can finally talk about the characters in terms of their relationships with other characters and since I was just talking about Christopher I need to start withā€¦
Christopher and Grace! ā€” I loved that little moment they shared when they were in Henryā€™s laboratory and were bonding of the pithos. It was the best moment in the whole book and I keep thinking about it in my head. I know of the family tree from the Clockwork Princess inside cover, it says that Christopher and Grace will get married and have the Lightwood offspring, but I just hadnā€™t really realized that significance until now. They are so cute together and even though I have expressly said I hated Grace in the past, the way she understood Christopher and the way they could talk together, warmed my heart so much and was the most redeeming part of Graceā€™s character for me. I just need more moments of Grace and Christopher.Ā 
Now to the next most pressing relationshipā€¦
The James, Cordelia, Matthew love triangle!
Let's start with Cordelia and Jamesā€” I love them together. Even with all the annoying shit with James and the bracelet, their relationship shone in this book and I was so happy about it. They are so perfect for each other and all of their moments together I was bursting with joy. Their chemistry, but also their solid foundation for their relationship is so well written that itā€™s impossible for me not to see them as together. This is their story and Iā€™m in love with it.
Now Cordelia and Matthewā€” I also love them, but probably not as much. The thing is, Iā€™m just obsessed with Matthew, so while I love the relationship just because I want Matthew to find happiness, I think James and Cordelia are better together. The problem is with Matthew is that he needs to work on himself first before he could ever hope to fully love someone else and share a life with someone else. Iā€™m very happy for the moment though that Matthew has Cordelia at his side and that he even shared his biggest secret with her because I do think that Cordelia has the capacity to help Matthew (maybe even on this trip to Paris) but I also donā€™t want it to be too much for Cordelia since she already had to deal with similar issues with her dad and I donā€™t want it to bring up hard memories for her. But either way I just need the next book to see what happens after that VERY emotional cliffhanger. Cassie did me dirty with that one.Ā 
James and Graceā€” Well I hate the fricking bracelet (also side note, I absolutely love that the fandom nicknamed the bracelet, gracelet. I love that so much). But I also see why Grace felt like she had to put it on and why she couldnā€™t take it off, but it still makes me so mad. Especially the way she still felt she could manipulate James in the end because she had nowhere else to go. I hate that part of her, the part that her mother taught her that itā€™s okay to manipulate men. But I was also so happy how James went off on her at the end, it was very satisfying until Cordelia ran off, but still very happy that James got to yell at Grace like that.Ā 
Lucie and Jesseā€” another couple I am now fully invested and in love with. This book made me like Lucie more BECAUSE of her development with Jesse. I liked Jesse before, but this book, where we got to see lots of their development as a couple and be completely honest with each other, sealed the deal for me. I canā€™t wait to read more about Jesse and Lucie in the future because I am so happy for them and so in love with their love, itā€™s actually kind of ridiculous.Ā 
Alastair and Thomasā€” again, I just fell completely in love with them in this book. The scenes with them locked up together were some of my favorite scenes, but I was beyond sad when Alastair still broke it off with Thomas in the end. I needed one couple to find some sort of happy at the end of this book, but all of them ended badly! I was very mad, but I canā€™t wait for the next book to see them get together (because they have to get together).Ā 
Anna and Ariadneā€” I just love Anna so much and I want her to be happy, but in this book I also felt for Ariadne too. At first I didnā€™t like her because of the fact that she broke Annaā€™s heart, but now seeing her try so hard to make up with herā€¦ it just makes my heart break for the both of them. Also the only parts in this book that had these two in it, were scenes about their relationship, which is why I didnā€™t have anything to say about their individual personalities, but I would like to add that Anna is definitely one of my favourite Lightwoods and one of the best minor characters in the Shadowhunter universe.Ā 
Lucie and Cordeliaā€” for these two I wish that we had more scenes of them as friends, but I think one of the most powerful parts of this book that made it so sad, was the fact that Cordelia and Lucie didnā€™t talk. The way the two girls were by themselves with their problems definitely was a huge factor of why everything went bad, and Iā€™m very certain that if Lucie and Cordelia had talked more, things would have ended differently. So I see and understand why they werenā€™t able to be the parabatai pals that I wanted them to be, but I still am waiting desperately for more scenes of the two of them just being friends. Another reason I cannot wait for the last book of the series.Ā 
Grace and Jesseā€” because of all the flashback scenes of Grace, I was able to appreciate her relationship with her brother more. The bond that they have between brother and sister is so strong and beautiful that itā€™s another thing that redeems Grace as a character, and makes me sympathize a lot more with her.Ā 
The Merry Thievesā€” just want to say that I love them so much. I will always love them and I just need more scenes of the group of them plus Lucie, Anna, and Cordelia. That is all.
Plot
For plot details in this book, I just have a couple things to talk about, the first being: WHERE THE FUCK WAS THE REAL MAGNUS! Honestly, I know where he was, but I felt so betrayed when Lilith revealed herself to be a pretend Magnus. Every Shadowhunter book has Magnus helping to save the day, and my theory is that the reason everything went so shitty was because Magnus wasnā€™t there. Jem and Magnus are always needed for these Shadowhunter children who just keep getting caught up into shitty situations. He better help more in the next book (which I already know he will, since at the end of Chain of Iron he was there with Will). On that note, I also thought it was clever of Cassie to have Will and Tessa gone for the majority of the book, because I feel like if they had been there, shit wouldnā€™t have gotten that bad, both concerning Belial and the kidsā€™ love lives. It wouldnā€™t have been believable if they had been there but all the events happened in the same way, because Iā€™m pretty sure Will or Tessa would have given more advice to James and Lucie.Ā 
Secondly, that was some crazy business with Belial and Lilith, and also Iā€™m so excited that Lilith is back. I think sheā€™s such an interesting villain being Adamā€™s first wife and all. But also I donā€™t like who sheā€™s a manipulative bitch, but I think thatā€™s part of her charm.Ā 
Next, the gracelet. I hate it. Period. Glad itā€™s off.Ā 
Next plot pointā€” all the stuff with Malcolm! Oh my goodness that was so interesting to see how Malcolmā€™s villain origin story started. I canā€™t actually believe that it was Grace that told Malcolm straight up about Annabel (I can actually believe it, I just think it ironic that sheā€™s also a Blackthorn, and really only Blackthorns seem to have messed up Malcolmā€™s life). Iā€™m very interested to see more of what he does with Jesse and Lucie now that Jesse is alive and Malcolm knows more about Lucieā€™s powers.Ā 
Lastly, I wanted to touch on the extra short story from the first editions of Chain of Iron, with Magnus and Jem. I think that it was an important scene concerning the future Eldest Curses novel, The Black Volume of the Dead, and maybe even the Wicked Powers series. It just made me even more excited for the future Shadowhunters books and I canā€™t wait to see whatā€™s in store for us moving forward!
And thatā€™s all I have to talk about. Thank you if you read to the end and were able to sift through my thoughts. This is totally unedited, so sorry for stupid mistakes and such.Ā 
Until next time!
~Rose Reviews
39 notes Ā· View notes