#....but i'm not disputing
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
The Vignette Problem and a Potential Fix - An entirely Undirected Frustration Ramble
OK- Preface, this is a ramble in the key of meta, NOT a well thought out considered meta in inself. please read accordingly
Lets be honest, Vignette was a shit MC for this story
When measuring Vignette up against the other MC’s (Philo, Tourmaline, Imogen, Agreus), she comes off as infantile and naive, framed by her very teenage rebellion, her obligatory hetero romance with Philo (which is at least passably developed if lacking chemistry) and her poorly developed ‘childhood sweetheart runner-up’ romance with Tourmaline. Her convictions never really felt like core values, but rather exercises in reactionary frustrations. She is not a mover and shaker of this conflict, she is someone caught up in the motions. To be more unkind, Vignette is a plot drain, fixated on moral absolutes and flipflopping between personal/romantic allegiance in a way that makes her seem like a child, when compared to her firmly grey counterparts (namely Tourmaline and Philo). Scenes with her and Tourmaline or Philo almost border on uncomfortable because of how emotionally immature she is in comparison to the two of them- where they deal in complex moral quandarys, she deals in snap judgments and ultimatums..
Characterwise, Vignette doesn't read like a 1st gen war refuge (in the fantastical sense). Not that there is a right or wrong way to behave as a refugee, but there is a notable gap in her understanding of Fae relations to the Burge that make no sense for her age, education, previous relationship with a half fae Burgish soldier and plot relation to the conflict (as a member or Tirnanoc academia and later as a director of refugees to safety) Tourmaline on the other hand does read as a 1st gen refugee- she comes across as that mixture of scarred, ferrety, grateful, and yet cyclical persona that makes sense. Philo as a scarred veteran also fits with Tourmaline’s generation in this sense- he’s haunted, jaded, empathetic, hunting for belonging as a mixed species person caught adrift between his heritage and his socialization. Tourmaline and Philo read like they are from the same generation of a conflict. It’s frustrating we don’t see more of the two of them because in a non-romantic sense they bounce really well, and I would love to see a world without V where the two of them have to team up and come to see each others worlds- Philo’s hidden ancestry, and Tourmaline’s more brutal dark connection to fae magic
Vignette reads like the 2nd generation. That’s a powerful story in its own right- the frustration and restlessness of a person born outside their heritage, acutely aware of the rich cultural heritage they are owed, but both unable to access it, and dammed and ridiculed for embracing it. It’s a valid story BUT a very different one from that of a brand new refugee. This 100% wouldn’t automatically make her a bad character, but when placing her against Tourmaline and Philo, her reactions and understanding of her political situation often read as hopelessly simplistic and idealistic. If you separate her by generation though I think they would have been more nuanced- a display of nationalistic frustration in the place of complacency. Vignette comes across like the child of refugees who feels cheated out of their rightful identity, angry about being forced to live a small life on the fringe, when she knows the beauty and power of her for-bearers. It’s a characterization that works, but not in the context of placing Tourmaline and Philo as her contemplates
I think it would have worked better if Vignette was Philo’s daughter, her mother being Philo’s lover and Tourmaline's bestfriend/lover. That would account for her dissonant perspective from the war generation of Philo and Tourmaline, while also making space for her difficult personal connection to the two if her mother/Philo & Vignettes lover had died after Philo left.
#carnival row#vignette stonemoss#tourmaline larou#rycroft philostrate#i'm not saying tourmailine should have been the main female character#....but i'm not disputing
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
Silly comic idea I had about Sun being introduced to gravity falls :D
(Ignore the fact I haven't posted for actual months just pretend that never happened alright-)
#gravity falls#ocs#oc art#original character#digital art#oc#dca au#dca fandom#fnaf#fnaf sb#fnaf dca#fnaf sun#dca sun#his favorite character would be Mabel#Dispute me if you so wish#I will cry#I'm back from the void#don't ask where I've been#The answer is the void
616 notes
·
View notes
Text
Wing-it commission for @idolsgf / @blightbear featuring A BABY <3 been fangirling over Bohean for a while, the fact I could draw him sent me over the moon ;u;
-
Commissions Price List & TOS
#commissions#idolsgf#blightbear#dragon age#lavellan#bohean lavellan#actual baby brother (even if he disagrees u-u)#also I'm giving him something he can use against this lol#for bureaucratic purposes in many countries the older twin is the second that pops out#this was used in medieval times to settle disputes for heritages and stuff and many countries carry this tradition to this day#it makes no sense but eh it's tradition#(unless you bring out biology ofc that makes everything more complex)#source: me. daughter of a twin who claims she's the older one and niece to the other twin who claims the exact same thing#I had to research the topic to settle this (it was never settled)#*coughs* anyway#I'm very proud of that embroidery :'
928 notes
·
View notes
Text
Hey, discussion question:
Is Rose Quartz a war criminal? I see that term bandied around so much for her that it feels like a given that she's a war criminal, but I'm wracking my brain and I can't... actually recall any real war crimes that she committed.
I'm talking objective war crimes, by the way, not war crimes by Homeworld's (the fascist government's) standards. It's literally legal for the Diamonds to shatter (split a person's soul into shards of ceaseless torture) their citizens, I don't value their definition of morality, lol.
#ask you#personal#delete later#saying this cuz a tweet of mine about steven and rose blew up on twt#and a few people are discussing their relationship and pointing out “well he found out she's a war criminal” and i'm like “is she tho..?”#reminder that she never shattered anyone. she never did.#and poofing is not killing or even injuring gems. it's more like temporarily disabling them. basically knocking them out#and her poofing bismuth could be considered psychological but it wasn't an action made during warfare it was a personal dispute
285 notes
·
View notes
Text
I think Aventio and Screwtio shippers shouldn't fight. After all, Ratio has two hands!
That's right. Two hands.
One for his chalk.
One for his codex.
Both of which he's holding in an embarrassed death grip as they chat away with each other about him.
#I'm on to something here#screwtio#aventio#hsr aventurine#veritas ratio#dr ratio#screwllum#hsr#honkai star rail#now as a disclaimer I'm not personally a huge fan of aventio#exclusively because i think they are so SO much funnier as gay friends#but something about combining the two clicks really well to me#Aventurine and Screwllum would be pretty fantastic metamours i think#they'd have a lot of fun playing off each other#but also Screwllum being there to dispute Aventurine's doubts over whether or not Ratio cares as a verified outside perspective#listing off shit like upticks in heartrate pupil dialation etc on top of being like#he talks about you fondly he knows your favorite things i can personally attest that you are very evidently important to him#stuff Aventurine can't easily write off when coming from not only an outside perspective but also a literal Genius#and on the flip side Aventurine would finally have someone other than Ratio and the Trailblazer he can talk to with relative ease#someone who has also been through a frankly incredibly traumatizing historical event#someone who is also under constant pressure to perform a certain way#someone who has gained wealth and power at the cost of carrying responsibilities on his shoulders and never being truly free#appearing free to anyone who glances but neither of them really are#Screwllum seemingly able to freely pursue whatever research he wants but ultimately permanently shackled with his titles#and public pressure to be the perfect poised representative for all of inorganic kind#forever treading the line of being both a desirable ally and a sufficient threat that you wouldn't want to cross him#and similarly Aventurine stuck in his cycle that he feels only death can free him from of gambling with his life on the line#because the IPC basically owns him#because let's be honest Jade's offer was just a lifetime labor contract he couldn't refuse#granted the illusion of freedom through gaining money and power but never truly free
157 notes
·
View notes
Note
How is it canon when it’s unrequited u make no sense whatsoever is it delusion or memes
first of all- 'unrequited' means distinctly not returned. Dean's stunned lack of response in the moment was not a rejection of Cas' feelings, and should not be considered as such. therefore, Destiel cannot be considered unrequited.
second of all- Cas' love for Dean has been confirmed many times on multiple different occasions, by both Misha and Jensen themselves, as well as Robert Berens, to be romantic love. that is not up for interpretation. based on that fact alone, it is canon. whether or not Dean's feelings are ever explicitly and/or verbally expressed does not change the fact that Castiel is canonically in love with Dean Winchester. that makes it c a n o n.
third of all- the fact that Dean's feelings have not yet been verbally confirmed is of very little consequence when compared to the monumental amount of very compelling evidence suggesting that he does, in fact, return Cas' feelings, even if Dean himself hadn't yet realized it at the time of the confession.
if you have watched this show and actually picked up on the frankly staggering amount of very clear context clues, it is quite obvious that, aside from his brother, Castiel is the most important person in Dean's life, full stop.
i don't have the patience right now to list every single instance that suggests Dean's feelings for Cas are mutual; there are far too many. but i will remind you of the most significant ones:
when Cas died in the s12 finale, Dean mourned that loss unlike he had done with any other character death up to that point in the series, and the way in which Dean grieved Cas was very purposefully portrayed in such an undeniably different way than how Sam grieved Cas. even the loss of his mother seemed to almost pale in comparison to the immense weight of Cas' sudden absence in Dean's life. Dean mourned Cas like a spouse rather than like a brother or family member; it is known as the 'widower arc' for a reason.
Dean was nearly suicidal up until the very moment he learned that Cas had come back. when Cas inevitably returned, the sudden change in Dean's demeanor was so immediately apparent and extreme, it gave Sam whiplash.
in the final seasons, Dean no longer showed much if any interest in having any romantic or sexual partners, a stark contrast to earlier seasons. the last committed relationship he had was with Lisa, which was quite a few years prior. this is in direct contrast to Sam, who had several romantic love interests over the course of the show (Jess, Madison, Ruby, Amelia, Eileen). the role of closest person to Dean other than Sam was always filled by Cas, the only difference being the lack of romantic label.
Dean and Cas' relationship has been directly paralleled in multiple different instances with canonically romantic couples, the most significant ones being: Sam and Jess, Cain and his wife Collette, John and Mary (during the widower arc), and Sam and Eileen in the final season.
additionally, directly following Cas being taken by the empty, Sam's attempts to call Dean were completely ignored, despite Dean knowing that his brother needed confirmation that he was alive. the sole thing occupying Dean's mind at that moment was Castiel; nothing else in the world mattered.
do you get it?
#need i say more#i'm sick and tired of people trying to dispute this#destiel is canon#end of story#destiel#deancas#spn#supernatural#anon#asks
114 notes
·
View notes
Text
The shittiest part about big projects is even if you do slowly go through the whole thing, your skill grows with the progress, and suddenly you want to revisit the start point of your project with your new skills because now it's not as good as the rest of it...
#big projects or just projects that take you time. whatever applies#bonus points if you want to restart the whole thing lmao#dispute not even finishing it in the first place#xit shh#let's pretend I'm not talking about anything specific#despite*
139 notes
·
View notes
Text
If I see one more person saying that the castle moves in the book because Howl is evading taxes I'm gonna force every Ghibli fan to READ THE BOOK. Or at the very least not post about it online.
For all we know Howl pays MORE taxes as a result of having multiple residences and living in TWO UNIVERSES.
This also applies to people who say Diana Wynne Jones was Welsh, or the striking amount of people with the false recollection that she came up with the claim that the movie is how Howl tells it, and the book is how Sophie tells it.
These people spread rumours better than Michael in Market Chipping.
#No hate I'm just annoyed#The internet is such that misinformation can very easily spread#Especially when dealing with a piece of media most people discussing it haven't read and so noone can dispute the claims#Well here I am. Disputing the claims#Sorry if this comes off overly harsh#Howl's Moving Castle#Howls Moving Castle#HMC#HMC book
62 notes
·
View notes
Text
something i've unfortunately had to come to terms with and urge you all to keep in mind is that there is often no good faith conversation to be had with a zionist — these people are well aware that thousands of palestinians have been murdered in the past month, that the 1948 nakba was one of the most horrific displacements of a human population in history, that israel is currently carrying out ethnic cleansing with full endorsement from the united states — they simply don't care.
attempting to appeal to their sense of morality will not work when these people don't see palestinians as human beings; they have no moral conscience to speak of.
#palestine#usually i'm the loudest proponent of debate as you all well know but in cases like this theres just no amount of proof/evidence that will#change their minds i fear.. the israel propaganda is so laughable and yet some people are just . very very stupid#the only time i engage with zionist rhetoric is on tumblr where at least i can use my platform to show other people how to combat propagand#bc if theres one thing a zionist will be it is loud and wrong#hence why theyre still clinging desperately onto '40 beheaded babies' and other equally made up stories#so yes definitely do call out/dispute zionists where you can#but just remember which battles are worth it#i say this after engaging with one of the most braindead people i've ever seen on this website but c'est la vie !
373 notes
·
View notes
Text
food assistance (help!!!!)
hi. my food assistance got cut off bc of a mistake i made in reporting a brief (i mean 2 weeks) period of income i got last year, and i'm not going to hear back about my reapplication and receive benefits again before the end of the month which means i have to replace the money i would have gotten somehow.
i usually received around 200 USD. thats all i need probably so i'll be able to continue eating food.
you can send anything to help through my ko-fi (username is netbuffoon), reblog if u cant send anything
thank you
#before you ask anything. i found out about it just now as i ran out of money#i cannot dispute it being cancelled bc i'm STUPID and didnt open my mail until was too late. thats all
57 notes
·
View notes
Text
leave it to Joker Out to spend months promoting an English single and getting nothing out of it only to have an unreleased demo of a song in Serbian blow up on tiktok of all places
#jfc I'm just. what is happening.#joker out#god i just can't with them I JUST CAN'T HELP ME#this is absolutely insane#I added the Serbian I thought this was important#actually do like EW the contrast is just staggering to me like. you really can't control the algorithm with such things huh#like remember how they wanted tiktok creators to advertise the song and then the whole copyright dispute happened and yeah#šta bih ja
108 notes
·
View notes
Note
You know,, at first i didn't realize because the leaks are low quality and i couldnt really understand what happened with kurugiri and where bkg showed up from.. but after you pointed it out and the more i think about it, the more im mad how izuku and bakugo just fucking killed kurugiri. Like, what the fuck was that???? Even if one tries to defend it as 'oh he's on the villains side and maybe they though he was going to warp shigafo somewhere or protect him' it's still mind-boggling how izuku didn't hesitate at all. Like you said, that was one of the few characters that wanted to protect and save tomura, who was pleading for afo to give him back and they just........ignore that and punch him as well. No surprised look, no hesitation, no thinking on what to do. Then add izukus lack of reaction to tomura decaying and i question who is that, bc sure as fuck isn't the "i want to save that crying little boy" hero deku. Doing that in front of aizawa and yamada as well is so foul damn. I haven't been this disappointed in izuku since 327 (my beloathed) and his overall response in that "reunion" with toshinori.
It's implied Kurogiri was already dying (which is, it's own can of worms,, because there's really no way to spin that particular writing decision in a way that makes Hori look good considering how it was never once foreshadowed that Giri overusing his quirk would kill him). But yeah, Giri's treatment is definitely one of the most upsetting aspects of this chapter-- Izuku and Bkgo may not have killed him per se, but they also didn't hesitate to run him through just to finish off AFO. Izuku exhibits zero reaction to Giri begging for Tomura's life and makes no attempts to even speak with him. Like, Giri is honestly the only character in this chapter who actually felt heroic in what was supposed to be the grand finale of Izuku's journey to become one of the greatest heroes. It's an absolutely massive writing fumble.
Like, if we're looking at the arc as a whole, the intended read is like.... Tenko tells Izuku that he's a villain who is fighting to be a hero to the villains, and the unspoken implication is that Izuku immediately gives up on saving him because "Tenko can't be stopped/changed and made his choice to keep fighting for evil"-- even though we literally get a reveal in the very next chapter that he was manipulated into this position and forcibly given the power that helped shaped his entire life/worldview. Izuku does not react once to this reveal despite the manga making it clear that he is also seeing AFO's memories. Tenko isn't allowed to properly process this reveal and the implications behind it + how it skewed his perception of himself. The heroes arrive and yap about how "tragedy is bad and shouldn't happen :(" while making no attempt to actually engage with the fact that AFO is openly grieving, and then they proceed to annihilate the body of the biggest victim in the series without any hesitation (while also running through the crumbling body of another victim who is the only one on the battlefield that's attempting to save the first victim's life).
Like. Am I misunderstanding anything or.
#mha spoilers#mha leaks#spoilers#people on twt are getting mad that people are blaming Izuku but like#honestly his writing absolutely merits criticism & that ties back to HrKsh not following through w/ a lot of the set up/promises of his arc#like he's a kid who never should have been placed in this position in the first place and I'm not trying to dispute that fact#sophie.txt#thank you for the ask#sorry for the negativity I'm v much in the anger stage of grief rn lmao
26 notes
·
View notes
Text
I like how people on tumblr post the most bullshit misinformation or unsourced claims and then write "you literally can't make this shit up" when it's literally made up
#jumblr#tagging jumblr because it's usually blood libels#and antisemitic conspiracy theories#antisemitism#The amount of times I've seen those captions on fake claims that like there are multiple sources who say the exact opposite#of course their source is a twitter screenshot where no one makes anything up ever#Or the most basic thing to know about the topic disputes it#oh I'm going to regret posting this#the Jews are tired
46 notes
·
View notes
Text
sorry hold on. guys i need to rewatch mythic quest
#it is fucked up that i don't have that show completely memorized and at my disposal#but is anybody knows off the top of their head can somebody tell me if brad ever calls david a pussy#because i'm recalling the conversation btwn him and jo that's like 'but you probably shouldn't say it. not cause it's inappropriate#but because it's obvious' and i need to reevaluate and look at the context of the wider show#to see if he meant what he said. or if he is uncomfortable with the word pussy in general.#cause he chastises her for it a couple times but it's always in that context of 'don't say it it's unnecessary'#hm. i'm thinking this is something that can probably be left up to interpretation ngl.#i don't think there's enough evidence to dispute reasonably interpreting it as discomfort.#mythic quest#brad bakshi#< i forgor what i was asking for a friend for. but if u have input lmk
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
Here's a drawing that I did of Beleg, best friend in the Silmarillion, chilling in a tree on a summer's day with the little birdies (not shown)!
(If anyone wishes to dispute this, I can only point you to the line that broke my heart: "Thus ended Beleg Strongbow, truest of friends..." Tolkien himself said that in the Silmarillion! So there.)
(LIES. I can also admit that reasonable arguments could be made for the Best Friend Ever status of several other Silm characters)
(Notice that I very carefully said "in the Silmarillion," not "in the Tolkien legendarium." The historographer would not have been familiar with Samwise Gamgee.)
(Good thing - I have no idea which one is a better friend.)
(And who cares? I like good friends better than competition!)
(Oh, wait that quote said "truest" not "best." My logic resembles Swiss cheese.)
Fun/heartrending fact: On Holy Saturday a couple years ago, I thought I'd get in the mourning mood by reading the longest and saddest chapter in the Silmarillion... for the first time. Thus I first learned of Beleg and his shocking non-sequitur death. I cry over books all the time (okay, so only when they're sad or otherwise moving) but this was the only time I feared I would faint or throw up because of something in a book.
Anyway, this is my only fan art of him so far (no doubt there will be more, as he is now not only my second-favorite character in the Tolkien legendarium, but #2-3 of fictional characters from anywhere), and it's happy because he's such a happy guy, and I want to be happy thinking about him. :)
#fanart#my art#silmarillion#beleg#beleg cuthalion#beleg strongbow#trees and forests#Planner 10#I was experimenting with light effects using brush pens on this one#OH maybe the historographer met Sam later in Valinor!#I'm happy for the historographer#Even if he makes a decision on whether Beleg or Sam is the best friend#If anyone wanted to dispute the fact that little birdies are not shown#I'd be thrilled to have them pointed out!#I'm sure they're cute!
27 notes
·
View notes
Note
cant believe kaveh and al haitham are divorced
that one aita reply that's like "you're both terrible. stay together so nobody else has to get involved in what you have going on"
#i'm still firmly on kaveh's side in the domestic dispute but that's out of respect for him somehow being an arts major in stem hell#aka-search. get it. because akasha#genshin impact#anon#ask#my art#kaveh
338 notes
·
View notes