#you cannot separate the art from the artist if the art IS the artist.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
ok i make like a lot of non-serious and kind of jokily worded posts about hating bright AND shaw but. genuinely if you cant put down the self insert of an actual, literal, groomer then i think you are a metric cunt and i have literally no sympathy for you if you lose friends because of that. i don't care how popular bright was, or how much of a comfort their character was for you, that is a groomers self insert and i do not want to fucking hear about him or have him anywhere near me. ok thats all thank you.
#it makes me VIOLENTLY uncomfortable as a victim of similar shit#its not great seeing people talk about that guy as if hes just. a character.#in reality bright and ab are completely inseperable from eachother#you cannot separate the art from the artist if the art IS the artist.#guh.. okay. anyways. only making this post bc i keep getting asked about him. back to your regularly scheduled shitposting#brightcourse#grooming mention#speaking.mp4
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hey! It is so interesting to me when people hate on things created by the people they hate (not bashing here just wondering, for each their own). It is just for me it always was the same thing as - my country is run by terrible people, but there woudn't be the place where I can feel more at home than this room I am in. Same always was with HP. I will hate Rowling for every shitty thing she said/did, but hp fanfics/books will always be my safe haven. It's not hers anymore, it's mine.
Anonymously coming into a trans person's private messages to tell them that hating on the creations of the most famous transphobic creator in the world is 'interesting' to you as though this is merely a thought experiment and not something with tangible stakes is a choice, anon.
Here's the thing. JKR isn't dead, she's not a philosophical concept (like a nation), she's not a government. She's a living person still using the profits of her creations to hate on and harm trans people and actively influence trans dehumanising laws.
Anyone who gives her money via buying her books or merch actively and explicitly contributes to these actions and this hate. I don't think your analogy is comparable, so I'll give you another: It would be like if you were a domestic violence victim, and I was a huge fan of Chris Brown (a very famous domestic violence abuser) and went into your personal space to anonymously tell you how 'interesting' it is that I can separate the art from the artist. That his music is 'mine now' while fully knowing that a domestic abuser is benefitting from my listening to his music and spreading this rhetoric about him. I'll tack on a 'but he's bad' to cover my bases, but that's it.
Just...why.
Our lives are not thought experiments. It's not 'interesting' that many trans people can't and won't separate the art from the artist while the artist actively uses the money from the art to harm us and increase hate crimes against us. It's devastating that more people don't understand why this is such an issue.
HP is not yours, anon. Not in the same way it's JKR's. You don't own the IP. You can't use the profits from it to help marginalised people. You can enjoy it in your mind, and privately, and among folks who feel the same way as you, but speaking about it favourably in public with zero caveats allies you with the most public and infamous transphobic mascot and influential figure in the world whether you like it or not. Even with caveats, it still harms more trans people than it helps.
Being reminded of the person actively working to increase the number of draconian laws around our rights, who has the endorsement of Putin and has empowered trans haters in the US, is not an 'interesting' little experiment for me, it's actively painful and hurtful. I'd rather you just bashed outright so I could delete the anon message rather than explain why our lives are interesting philosophical think pieces.
If this is what you're choosing to do with the part of HP that belongs to you and is now yours, by anonymously coming here to tell a trans person these things as though you expect any answer than the one I'm giving you now? Well, that sucks too.
Enjoy the IP and make it yours if you must. Stop telling trans people about it anonymously. And if you can't stop telling people how much you like HP, for god's sake, warn them first so they can decide if you're safe enough to keep interacting with.
#asks and answers#cw transphobia#cw jkr#cw hp#i wrote this response last night and then went to bed because i knew i was angry#and this morning i find i'm actually even angrier than i was last night#don't do this to another trans person anon#it's not a nice thing to do to someone#even if you are trans just *wait* for other trans people#to tell you how much they love HP#and please don't use the word 'interesting' to describe#a 300% increase in hate crimes re: trans people due to JKR's actions in the UK#just because you have the ability to separate the art from the artist#and other people for very obvious reasons cannot#that's not interesting#it's genuinely devastating
75 notes
·
View notes
Text
As much as the show has meant to me, and as much as I would like to honor Terry's work and the actors-
I will not give another penny to that man.
#you cannot separate art and artist while the artist is still benefitting from the support#I know it's hard#but it is simply true#good omens
32 notes
·
View notes
Text
its been said many times but the fact alone that the hp millennials only ever call the actors by their characters name is so ridiculous. "professor sprout said" no she didnt say shit because she doesnt exist. miriam margolyes however said what needed to be said
#also the fact theyre being such babies about an actress expressing an opinion#and keep calling her by her characters name#but dont give a shit abt jkrs incredibly harmful ideologies#and saying to separate art from artist#like how about you do that then#god i just cannot stand them#and how they keep sucking tom feltons dick#like that man needs to move on and find a job#pathetic and embarrassing
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
Some team: Hey exe community, we’re looking to make a full restoration of every well-known exe fnf mod! This is not in support of any bad people or in spite of controversy, this is for preservation and to celebrate how far the community has come! Hope you’re excited.
Half the fandom for some reason: No!! That’s terrible!!! Screw you!!!!
#text post#speedy speaks#speedy rants#the exe posts#god I hate this community so much sometimes#I love you exe mega restoration thank you for giving a shit about what actually matters in this goddamn fandom <3#People are really looking at the Smash Ultimate of this fandom like it’s a disgrace to god#I’ve said it once I’ll say it again-#We as a transformative fandom cannot survive if we are unwilling to separate art from artist or if we constantly glorify the artists wishes#you cannot engage with transformative art with a purely affirmative fan mindset. It does not work.#I’m sorry I never shut up about this but it is the biggest thorn in the exe community’s side and it always has been.#exe community#vs sonic.exe#fnf exe
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
this might be a hot take... but if you care about disavowing media made by bad people out of fear of looking like a bad person yourself more than you care about actually doing good things... you might have your priorities (and your morals) screwed up a bit :/
(see my tags for more of my thoughts on this topic! please try to avoid making make bad-faith assumptions about what i mean!)
#melonposting#there is a good case for not wanting to associate with something on account of the creator being harmful. sure whatever#but people have talked at length about the sort of moral ocd that it promotes when that idea is fervently preached and enforced#i don't know about you but i think there's a big difference between#a) not wanting people to associate with something because the media itself spouts harmful rhetoric#and because its bigoted creator both benefits from people engaging with the books and is idolized by many of the books' fans#and b) not wanting people to vocally enjoy ANYTHING made by ANYONE who's held any harmful ideology at any point#because doing so 'inherently' supports and spreads those harmful ideologies#it's true that you cannot separate the art from the artist#but good people can make bad art and bad people can make good art. artistic talent is not inherently correlated with the artist's morals#the goodness/badness of a person CAN seep into the art they make. and it often does. and that can affect one's enjoyment of it#but even then there's nuance to be had on how to deal with it#like my hero academia for example. when i started watching it in middle school i didn't know how misogynistic it would be#of course i ended up seeing it in the show (and god it's so misogynistic)#and i ended up learning that the 'joke' sexual-harasser character is a self-insert for the creator#which of course i could never get behind. the creator is undeniably a horrible guy#at the same time though the show means a lot to me and i've gained a lot from watching it#i won't elaborate here on how but believe me it isn't superficial. if you want to ask me about it i'd be happy to share#i can hold both in my mind. the disgust and the enjoyment. i don't think those have to be mutually exclusive#of course not everyone is like that; you could immediately stop liking the show on discovering the gross stuff. and that's your prerogative#i don't know... i agree with the values behind avoiding media made by people known to have moral failings#and in some cases (like harry potter and jkr) i fully endorse the values and the practice. but such cases are very specific#but in most cases i fear the practice is misguided and unnuanced and ultimately unhelpful in fulfilling one's values#it is largely a philosophical matter: about how an individual regards their moral standing in the context of themselves and other people#which is important to discuss - especially in our globalized internet age! speaking of which feel free to disagree with me#if you want to have a civil discussion i'm more than open to it#but no matter how important this matter... there are way more important ones in the world. especially right now#calling out people who watch a youtuber who said something bigoted 5 years ago does little to stop that bigotry overall#just have good morals and practice them! support oppressed people! be thoughtful and understanding and compassionate!#callouts and dni lists rarely make for impactful advocacy!!!
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
idk wtf the overlap in appeal is between saltburn and harry potter besides the britishness but let me make it clear the wizard nazi book apologists are not welcome. idec if youre trans that shit is so racist and antisemitic if you cannot see that stay tf away from me and my followers thanks
#finnposting#saltburn#fucking hell ive had to block so many people#and listen i get youve got nostalgia. i was in the hp handom too as a kid. but fucking read the room!!!#you cannot separate art from artist when the art itself is bigoted and i do not trust your media literacy skills if you refuse to see that#finns saltburn tag
14 notes
·
View notes
Note
I hope this doesn't sound too weird but, are you open to people just - dropping a message in your inbox to chat? I just think you re a really cool guy with a lot of interesting stuff to say and I want to talk about it more but I don't know how open you are to that !!
dhdhgh I spent a lot of time trying to figure out how to answer this one, because I'm not exactly opposed to chatting with people, I'm just. not really online! I publish asks and sometimes it takes me forever to reply, I only really check my messages once a month because my notifications are broken and the bots are annoying™, and frequently I forget to reply to comments because I'm. mostly just busy offline with other work because I Have Bills To Pay. sorry! I don't really have a good answer for this RIP
#ALL OF THAT SAID. feel free to send asks about whatever if you want to. cannot guarantee when i'll reply tho. time. wish there was more#of it in a day!#it does not help that im an extremely private person and i originally made this blog so that i could#further separate the space from my main art blog lmao#bc of that i find it a little off putting when people ask ahead of time but also include things like 'you seem cool' because now im like#oh no. i cant relax now. im extremely Boring as a person i just have a pinball machine for a brain.#i think i reply to twitter DMs with more reliability but im also not recommending anyone make an account there#free yourself. im only still there because all the cool ancient history artists are there#i have been working on a. not exactly a personal blog bc i have one already but its a weird second space type of thing.#mostly just to post about shows and books im reading. i might end up linking it here.#ask tag
16 notes
·
View notes
Text
"fuck jkr" my good fellow you are still posting about the one goddamn franchise that got her into the public eye and that she herself said an endorsement of is an endorsement of her herself and her violent and hateful actions.
#art talks about stuff#you cannot separate the art from the artist in this instance holy shit#it has been like 26 years or something. read a better book i'm fucking begging you
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
and people on this site wonder why others don’t want to interact with hp blogs 🙃
#transphobia tw /#jkr /#hp /#hey !!! fuck that hog/warts game!!!#idgaf if it’s nostalgia!!! fuck your nostalgia she wants to kill trans people!!!!!#there is no moral consumption of hp and that’s just the bottom line#you cannot separate art from artist. not in this case.#god y’all (the hp lovers) are so fucking stupid!#mobile.#sorry i’m really in a mood about this tonight it’s#getting to me yet again lmfao
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
got asked on twitter how i feel about people who pirate the terrible wizard game so i’ll repeat myself here: pirating games by AAA companies is always morally correct & especially so when it doesnt give money to terfs but even then its still a horrible pile of antisemitism & slavery apology stuff so as a former hp fan idc about ppls nostalgia it's a block & side eye either way lmao
#she has said herself she gives royalty money to anti lgbt groups#like im sorry but you cannot separate the art from the artist here#i cant stop you if you do decide to buy / pirate it#but there's so much info out there#if you value your own nostalgia more than being an ally to trans folk#i do not trust you nor want you in my spaces#so you cant cry about ppl judging you#bc its fully deserved
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
the degree of impotent, hysterical despotism to deface your own art by branding it with a notice that shipping the characters depicted is haram
#remember fatwas? pre-cancel culture cancel culture. theo van gogh was murdered by the woke mob lmfao.#lmfao me#i thought i blocked an artist for this but a 10 page rant and then somehow saw this and remember why i wanted to blocked them#i truly like they art but you literally cannot separate the art from the artist if the artist desecrates their own art w political slogans#dear god i thought i had no respect for my own art#(and no respect for the general public; the fucking pluck to even attempt to control someone else's imagination).
0 notes
Text
im not active here and lord knows i dont have a following for it to matter but, for the sake of saying it anyway, for the sake of just in case, ill say it here too
free palestine, free congo, free sudan, free hawai'i, free every colonized people from their oppressors, and if you cant abide a simple boycott to help progress toward that, if you cant give up your "comfort food" or "comfort show" or whatever else that isnt a necessity to live, because your comfort is more important to you than peoples lives, then i'm sorry for you. that you can live a life so pitifully self-centric and willingly ignorant that your piece in the mosaic of life is left on the ground, instead of welded to the world at large.
#when the sun catches in the view of the world#your solitary piece will be drowned out by the unity of the rest#im not very good with words but this is my floundering attempt at putting words to how i feel about people who#cling onto major companies and media like disney and starbucks#and LORD especially the fucking wizard series#no#you CANNOT separate the art from the artist when the artist is still profiting off of you#and i know im a coward for not being able to confront people about this#im fucking frustrated over it#how do you not get it? how do you not see and understand that your blind loyalty to these assholes who dont care about you#only that you care about their work#is killing the world and media#instead of backing up and moving on to other works people desperately cling to an uncaring media because being able to stick with something#they know is more important than literally anything else in the world#im so fucking angry that im such a fucking coward but here we fucking are#im gonna go back to not checking here as is my usual but. i needed to get my stance here#so that even if im not around#no one is wondering where i stand#bye
0 notes
Text
Honestly, it’s non Black poc as well, but a lot of the awful takes I’ve been seeing have been from white people primarily. And I feel like as a mixed race black person, I need to clarify what the fuck Kendrick is saying regarding Drake’s blackness.
When he critiques Drake’s relationship to blackness and his identity, he is not saying that mixed race Black people cannot be black or that “he’s not black because he’s Jewish”, he is saying that Drake has consistently used Black people, blackness, and black culture to further his career and further his capital, while not contributing to the culture overall. Drake has separated himself from other Black people until it became “popular” to be and “act” black. He has shoehorned himself into cultures that he has not been brought up in like when he had this whole era where he would speak in broken patois and use Jamaican American and Jamaican Canadian vernacular and slang despite not having any connection to that culture.
The types of people he surrounds himself with in both in his family and recreationally speak to how he does not see other Black people as his kin. They are either associates or they are fetishized.
Kendrick calling him a colonizer is not a dig at him being Jewish either. It’s a dig at him using hip-hop culture and black culture as a means to become rich. He is literally colonizing an aspect of the culture that is still demonized (hip-hop and rap are still very much demonized as forms of art by wider society) and repackaging it for white people and non-Black people to enjoy and getting rich off of it because he picks and chooses aspects of blackness to present to make money. He is a morally and artistically bankrupt individual.
This is why, unless you fully understand the context of what is happening, Drake’s history as well as the history of hip-hop and rap, you should not have an opinion about this beef. Especially if you’re going to be misinterpreting what is being said by the main protagonist (basically) of this beef.
4K notes
·
View notes
Note
have you checked the wiki page of the author of the felidae book?
Oh, yeah, I’m well aware of what a monster he is. He’s actually such a horrible person that some books in the Felidae series have not been adapted to English because no one wants to work with him or be attached to his work. He’s a miserable excuse for a human being, and I only consume Felidae media through secondhand sources so as not to give him a single cent of my money.
#no publisher wants to adapt his book into an audiobook format so my dad is recording a personal version for me#suck on that Akif#seriously I hate the man so much and any time I recommend the book or movie to someone I point them to secondhand sources only#the movie is 100% free on YouTube#and the secondhand books can be found on eBay and such#‘separate the art from the artist’ and all that y’know#I cannot tell if you are trying to cancel me over my love of this story or not so I’m going to assume pure intentions
0 notes
Text
Yan! Lawyer Husband x GN Spouse Reader HCs
CW: mafia related stuffs
—𝒀𝒂𝒏𝒕𝒐𝒃𝒆𝒓 - 𝑳𝑰𝒇𝑬 𝑷𝒓𝒐𝒋𝒆𝒄𝒕 𝑬𝒗𝒆𝒏𝒕
Yan! Husband is a gentle soul to you, he can't and will never lay a finger with the meaning to hurt you! He just doesn't have the strength to do so, almost as though he was set to be so. It's another whole story when it comes to the others though, can you guess how many times he has pulled the trigger of a gun?
Yan! Husband who spoils you rotten with everything you could ever think of. Luxuries, reputations but never the forbodden knowledge he has tried so hard to keep away from you. No, he won't clip your wings. You are his songbird who gets to only fly inside the gilded cage but never in the outside world. He will create a stage of the outside world for you, but never the real deal.
Yan! Husband who paints a portrait of you whenever he's stressed over the cases he has to handle. To move the brush without any problem as your form starts to appear on the blank canvas, he has no trouble remembering you. Sculpting is no problem for him as well. He has spent all his lives honing his artistic skill just to eternalize you as pieces of art.
Yan! Husband loves you so much that he deems children as a burden and bothersome (adoptive too). He only needs you to build a family, he had no need for children to continue this lineage. His whole life revolves around you. If you pass away, he too, will pass away shortly after. That's how much he loves you to the point that death cannot separate you two.
Yan! Husband who might not look like he's able to do it but he is actually an S-rank gaslighter. He will trick you into believing that what he is suggesting is only to keep you safe! He doesn't really enjoy taking your autonomy directly unless it's needed (of course, in a way where you will not confront him about it).
Yan! Husband who will cover and remove all your bad track records (if you have any). He has the power and connection to erase any kind of dirt that is on you, you are his pristine pure lily-of-the-valley and you should not be defiled with those records. Live without any worry clouded in your mind dear, the laws will never tarnish your reputation when you have this lawyer backing you ^^
Yan! Husband who adores any sort of physical touch when it comes to you, yes, anything. Even if you hit him silly, he'd still love every moment your skin feels his. He loves hugging you the most, his face buried into the crook of your neck while taking a scent of you.
Yan! Husband who enjoys humming lullaby of yours to the point everyone's ears around him is bleeding from the repeating lullaby. Can this guy please hum something else for once?
Yan! Husband who will read for you whenever he has the time to sleep with you. He doesn't know what to say to you as his work is either foreign to your brain or a tad too shady. Childhood memories are not great too as he has long forgotten about everything the moment he pledges eternal vow to love you. He abandoned everything and lives only for you.
Yan! Husband who prioritizes you as his number one, even above his own well-being and career. He can still live even if he falls ill, his career would never fall out of track as he has the mafia under his grasp, but you can slip out of his grasp. And he doesn't want that to happen again.
Yan! Husband is without a doubt an infamous lawyer. Especially with how many times he has let the ringleader of that renowned mafia group slip out from the prosecutor and judge's grip? If you seriously think you'll be pronounced guilty of that murder, you better throw that thought out just like how he throws all the scapegoats and falsified evidence into the court. (Should I write a fic for this?)
Yan! Husband who will always make time for the two of you. While vacations are not as often as he wishes he could have, cuddles and tea parties sound nice enough for him to kill time with you.
Yan! Husband who has this cute journal that's filled with what you have been doing every day instead of his own daily stuff. Oh, your diary is almost his if you know how he reads it daily like a refreshment.
Yan! Husband who as much as he hates having to show you to the people at the official parties and events he has to attend, he just can't shake away the butterflies in his stomach as well! You are not just some trophy spouse, you are his beloved! A hand on your waist and a face that is seen whispering sweet nothings into your ear with a glass in his other hand. Oh, he looks so o-godly-handsome like a man who comes out from a romance novel!
Yan! Husband who is a man of greed, the embodiment of Mammon. Wealth is not something that he has never not possessed. So whatever the fuck you do, gambling or blowing it off somewhere in a dumb investment or stock, he won't make a fuss out of it. Instead, he'll teach you more about money management instead :/
"Do you want to learn how to invest? I know a way or two from my predecessor."
He will let you play all the money game you want and gives you the illusion of success despite all the trials and errors you made (he's the one who clean up all the mess lol)
I know that this is AFAB! oriented BUT Yan! Husband never wishes to impregnate you even once. No, he doesn't like the idea of you being in pain over a damn baby(ies) that could just take your life as well. He does enjoy fucking you without any protection on but that is after he tracks your safe day (man is literally fighting the fate of having you pregnant). He prefers you to not consume any birth control for just in case it causes harm rather than good to you. (Shots are a pass if you are scared of syringes)
He is A-OK with adopting if you are persistent enough about this matter and is B-OK if you want to get pregnant (AFAB). He just can't refuse and upset you...
So please don't imagine what would happen if darling dies during delivery :)
Yan! Husband who will always open his pocketwatch and kiss the picture of you in his pocket watch. How many times and lives had passed just for him to enjoy the solace of being your husband?
𝐀 𝐝𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐦𝐜𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐫 𝐛��� 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐛𝐞𝐝𝐩𝐨𝐬𝐭 𝐭𝐨 𝐜𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡 𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐧𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐦𝐚𝐫𝐞𝐬, 𝐡𝐞 𝐢𝐬 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝐝𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐦𝐜𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐫.
Yulian de Alpheus is a man of ambition. While he does share the same look as his 'father', the ambition he has is the complete opposite of Castiel. Castiel created him to seek the truth of life, Adam existed to be the Genesis of Life, Alan existed to be someone he didn't recognize and Yulian existed to live beneath the shadow of his spouse.
𝐘𝐮𝐥𝐢𝐚𝐧 𝐡𝐚𝐬 𝐧𝐞𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐛𝐞𝐞𝐧 𝐚 𝐡𝐮𝐦𝐚𝐧 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐲𝐞𝐭 𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐢𝐥𝐥 𝐚𝐥𝐰𝐚𝐲𝐬 𝐟𝐞𝐞𝐥 𝐚𝐥𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐰𝐡𝐞𝐧 𝐢𝐭 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐞𝐬 𝐭𝐨 𝐲𝐨𝐮. 𝐋𝐨𝐯𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐢𝐬 𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐨𝐧𝐥𝐲 𝐬𝐚𝐥𝐯𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧.
Taglist: @vinivave @destructa1 @szde8-blog @luminous011 @ush0 @annbourbon @randomnl @cassanderasblog @maam-appreciator @lem-hhn @fanatic-fan @flesh-eating-ladybug
(send ask/message to be removed from taglist)
#yandere male#yandere#yandere x reader#yandere scenarios#yandere x you#yandere imagines#male yandere#yandere insert#yandere oc#yandere headcanons#yandere works#yandere writing#reader insert#x reader#oc#x gn reader#LIfE Project#yandere husband#Yulian the Corruption
4K notes
·
View notes