So I saw this screencap earlier
And I thought it was a great chance to talk about something.
A lot of progressive folks are familiar with the fact that right wing circles use feminine as a derogatory term and that there's a real cost to that for women.
What people are less familiar with is how it hurts men - queer and straight, cis and trans.
And I'm not shocked given how common it is in left leaning spaces to be reactionary (read: dismissive or outright harass) when men try to talk about these what these issues look like for them.
When men talk about how they've experienced toxic masculinity and anti-feminine bias, in addition to the usual right wing responses, I'm starting to see a bunch of supposed feminists and trans/queer allies harass them as well - saying they're hurting women/feminine presenting folks by "centering men", dismissing their concerns as made up (even when there's research to back it up), "why aren't you talking about what this is like for cis and trans women instead??".
I've seen trans men accused of being TERFs or being liars (by other trans people even - wtf) when they talk about their experiences of allies actively excluding them from trans spaces or harassing them for using T4T tags. I've seen men be accused of lying about publicly accessible clinical research that shows men make up 75%-77% of suicide cases - or worse suggest they deserve it. I see posts about how men's complaints "aren't unique to them" and dismiss them because women also suffer things those authors assume are the same (even when the research contradicts this).
And here's the thing:
When you assume feminine=good/safe/gentle and masculine=bad/unsafe/enemy - you're parroting a conservative talking point.
There is no way around this fact.
A big part of what underpins child rearing being "the woman's domain" in conservatism, is the idea that men are inherently dangerous and therefore shouldn't really be around children without women present.
The reason why they blame women for abuse and rape - because they believe men are inherently dangerous and if a woman trusted them then it's her fault.
Part of why women have been effectively banned from many trades and careers for so long is the assumption that being around that many men presents an inherent danger to a woman.
"But!" you might be saying, "This person is clearly talking about men engaging in open conflict as good here!"
Yeah because conservatives see politics as an inherently male/dangerous/toxic sphere and uphold it as such.
I could go on and on really.
All of this is to say - please be more thoughtful in what you consume, comment, and reblog.
There are experiences specific to being masculine. Erasing that is one, a dick move, but two, particularly violent toward those talking about trans masculine, minority masculine, disabled masculine, and queer masculine experiences.
All privilege comes at a cost. Listening when people talk about that cost is key building a new more fair reality. Seeing the privilege is not worth the cost makes fervent allies. Want more allies? Don't be a dick to people having that realization.
Push back against the assumption of woman=good and man=bad when you see it - especially in community spaces. The amount of times I've seen domestic violence services only available to women is insane...
Do not let identarian politics blind you to the fact we're all human and working toward our own liberation should not come at the oppression of another. Believe me, those with real power would much rather you stay raging out at men in a similar class with you than directing your efforts at them.
The right wing wants you to believe it's either/or. Fuck that - it's both/and.
100 notes
·
View notes
Something mostly (?) unrelated to rancid fandom behavior that’s been stuck in my brain a bit:
I wholeheartedly agree that it’s important for fiction to show men/masc characters in emotionally vulnerable and supportive relationships with one another, while keeping it platonic. Absolutely.
I do sometimes feel that this stance is a kissing cousin of the goofy rallying cry of “let men be just friends,” that gains traction anytime gay relationships are contemplated in media , albeit to a lesser degree. I also think that this sudden platonic representation is sometimes undertaken in a disingenuous way that allows people involved in the direction of a narrative (show runners, networks, etc) to hand wave away established romantic subtext and tropes being applied between two male characters. It just smacks of not understanding the difference between platonic and romantic love when you take the “default” pairings/dynamics away, and I think it’s a disservice to both instances. Again, this isn’t always the case, but I’ve seen it happen enough times for it to hit some stupid little nerve in me when I get a whiff of it.
I don’t know, maybe this should have stayed a draft but I kind of wanted to unburden my brain of it 🤷🏽♀️.
7 notes
·
View notes
a good long while ago @sadpizazz tagged me to list five songs i currently listen to, then tag ten more people - i've discovered some new favourites lately so this was v fun to think about!
the arcadian wild | liar
spotify has been really into recommending me a personalized "melancholic mix" lately (thanks) and this song feels like it got stuck on the insides of my eyelids. songs to weep alone at night to. phenomenal bridge.
mcr | hang 'em high
when mx way said "that girl's not right in the brain / mass convulsions strike the choir by the grace of god" he did that for me specifically
the trials of cato | gawain
one of the coolest songs i've found this year; i really love the quiet (badly mixed lmao) start & the escalation throughout. and the lyrics? "just a small town shame / the land that once you loved is not the same"? thank you kings
joan baez | sad-eyed lady of the lowlands
her version of this has a special place in my heart and also i think every song should be at least ten minutes long like, in general
lilli furfaro | empty vessels
actually i highly recommend this artist in general bc she has nowhere near the listeners she deserves, but also for the fact that she seems to mostly tweet about critical role in her downtime which is a whole vibe
tagging @starkey, @kazimirov, @gellavonhamster, @byrons, @percybysshes, @bookish-huntress, @campgender, @silverskyy, @larkspurgf & @pyrrhlc if anyone feels like sharing w the class. 🌼
26 notes
·
View notes