#so I sincerely apologize if there are any errors or inconsistencies or if something doesn’t make sense
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Looking at all of the takes this chapter, and I thought about this Tokyo Ghoul quote that Eto Yoshimura wrote in her book “Dear Kafka”
"That time, so that no one (not even Father) would notice, I secretly rewrote the summary.
What cannot change can only be broken.
This is so to me, who left behind everything necessary inside the womb."
(There’s also this translation, which I think fits better into what AFO’s character, even if there are only a few words that were changed: “Then I, hidden from everyone (particularly father), stealthily rewrote the outline. Things that cannot be changed, can only be broken. From the view of I, who left all needed things in the womb.”)
And how this quote in a way truly summarizes, especially the last line, the way All for One thinks of himself and a way we, the audience, can view the way he thinks of himself. For example, the first line can be used in reference to how he changed the summary of the comic books him and Yoichi read together, in order to better fit his own wishes and desires. He doesn't accept the fact that Hero had defeated the Villain in the end, and decides to simply stop reading when the villain had won and become the Demon King, hereby rewriting the summary of the book to fit his own needs and desires. (So in that context, it should be "(not even Brother) would notice", but we'll let it slide this time for the sake of coherence) He then tries to LARP that twisted idea and that's how you end up with the current AFO, a man who thinks of himself to be the Demon King of comic books, and does what ever he possibly can to bring that reality of the summary of the comic books he rewrote.
I think the second line of the quote also is an indication of the way AFO thinks. To the core he doesn't believe that people cannot change, evidenced by the way he reacts when Lady Nagant is now fighting on the side of the heroes and when he starts losing to what he defines as a ''bunch of extras". He does not anticipate people to step outside of the lines that he drew around them and when they do go outside of those ideas and change (you know how people do) he throws tantrums and and refuses to acknowledge the fact that each person has their own autonomy and character, far beyond any neat little box he has put them into. And what he cannot change he wants to break. He wanted to break Yoichi by forcefully bestowing a quirk onto him, he wanted to break Tomura by grooming and manipulating him for the majority of his life into believing that he was simply born evil, and he wants to break all of the "extras" such as Stain, Jiro, Hawks, and Bakugou who go against the stereotypes he has placed them into, because to him these people can not change their so called "true nature", and therefore can only be broken.
Lastly, the third line, which I have been waiting impatiently to get to. I think this last line, truly shows the way AFO thinks of himself. In the chapter, All For One is shown to have cannibalized his mother as soon as he was born, and has been described as someone who simply took from others, without any regard, because he thought that anyone who could not give him *something* was useless. One could say that this is an indication of how All For One was evil from his birth, and therefore has no redeeming qualities. BUT this is My Hero Academia, good sir, where everyone is human. While framed in a horror like and grim way, it important to look past that and see the AFO/Yoichi backstory through the lens of BNHA's themes, which are all about humanizing villains and are against dehumanization in general. Imagine being newborn with a dead mother with no source of nutrition, and you have to eat her. You grow up with no one to protect your child self, no name, no sense of identity, no social security net, no one to help you differentiate between right and wrong, you are constantly being hunted for simply existing, and you are responsible for someone who is far weaker than you and have to find ways to protect yourself and him as well. So, of course you are going to grow up twisted, with disturbing ideals and cruel habits. But AFO and a lot of the MHA fandom doesn't see those factors, or refuse to acknowledge them. That's why I think this third line really displays AFO's mindset how he thinks he was evil from the womb. All things necessary to interact and engage with the world in a healthy way, such as the ability to show affection, to be caring, to be understanding, to have the methods of socialization, and have a acceptance of the autonomy of other individuals, and to be able to face and understand you own feelings in general, are abilities that have to be learned, they don't simply come to you in dream at night. But All for One does not think that, rather he refuses to humanize himself, and continues to play the role of the Demon King in the story he is trying to write, forever convinced that he was born like that from his mother's womb.
In summary, I think this quote from Eto Yoshimura really provides insight into the character AFO is and what he thinks of himself. He rewrote the summary of the comic books him and Yoichi read together, he doesn't believe that people can be changed, only be broken into what he wants them to be, and that he truly believes he has been evil from the very beginning, and any kind of "humanlike" trait he could have, was all left behind in his mother's womb.
#this was one of my first metas!#so I sincerely apologize if there are any errors or inconsistencies or if something doesn’t make sense#feel free to let me know if there are any!#bnha#mha#my hero academia#boku no hero academia#boku no hero manga#afo#bnha afo#all for one#yoichi shigaraki#shigaraki yoichi#bnha yoichi#bnha meta#bnha analysis#mha meta#mha analysis#tokyo ghoul#tg#eto yoshimura#alive's analysis#mha ch 407#bnha ch 407#bnha chapter 407#mha chapter 407
34 notes
·
View notes
Text
shattered mirrors 73
[ set after #69 ]
He’s stumbling forward before he even realises he’s moving, knocking into the low desk with his foot and almost falling over if not for Lan Wangji’s steady hand around his elbow. His limbs feel like lead and his body moves as though wading upstream against a rushing river. His ears are ringing, his vision spotting at the edges, but through all of that he sees the person before him.
“A-Xian.” A sob bubbles up inside his throat at the sound of his name in her voice. “A-Xian.”
She too is stumbling towards him, arms outstretched and tears in her eyes. He wants desperately to fall into her arms, to bury himself in her embrace and let her warmth wrap around him and wash away the horrors of the last fourteen years. Pretend as though he is still Wei Ying, the ward of Yunmeng, her brother in all but name and blood, the little boy who had grown up as her second shadow.
Instead, he sinks to his knees at her feet and presses his forehead to the floor. Lan Wangji follows him to the floor, hovering protectively around him
“Your guilty subject pays respects to Gongzhu-dianxia,” he says. “I humbly beg Dianxia’s forgiveness for failing my duty to Yunmeng Jiang.”
There. He’s said it. The words that had been eating away at him all these years, the constant shadow of guilt lingering in the corner of his mind. His family had been tasked with the protection of Yunmeng and its royal family, it had been their job to gather intelligence and wield it in their defence.
He’d failed. And Yunmeng had fallen.
A strangled noise leaves Jiang Yanli’s throat.
“A-Xian, no,” she says. “No, A-Xian, there is nothing to forgive. Please, get up—”
She reaches for his hands, tugging at them to make him stand, but he remains resolutely prostrate.
“Gongzhu-dianxia, this guilty subject does not dare.”
Her hands tighten around his almost painfully for a moment before she sighs, her whole body sagging with the movement.
“You did everything you could,” she tells him. When he goes to deny it, she squeezes his hand again. “Look at me.” He reluctantly raises his head and sees her looking back at him with a tremble in the firm line of her mouth. “A-Xian, I would be dead—or perhaps worse—if not for you. You saved me.”
He presses his lips together in a hard line, his breath heavy through his nose as he struggles to keep the tears at bay.
“I could have done more,” he whispers. “I could have—”
“You did everything you could,” she repeats firmly. “A-Xian, there was nothing more you could have done. Not under those circumstances.”
A raw, wounded noise tears itself from his throat, through his tightly closed lips.
“I should have realised the reports were false,” he argues, hands twisting in the fabric of his robes. “I should have verified them personally, I—”
She takes his face between her hands, shocking him into silence.
There are new lines on her face, around her eyes and mouth, that hadn’t been there before; she’s older, he realises, and has had to fend for herself for many years. The Jiang Yanli before him now glows with health and vigour, dressed in the thick, coarse garments of the northern border tribes rather than the silks of the capital—a far cry from the sheltered princess from Yunmeng she had been in their youth. Her hands, still so small against his cheek, are rough and callused from hard labour.
“A-Xian, you did everything you could,” she repeats firmly. “It is in the past. Do not blame yourself any longer. Alright?”
He closes his eyes with a shuddering sigh.
And then he’s falling forward into Jiang Yanli’s waiting arms with an aborted cry, clutching at the back of her heavy cloak desperately. Her scent is different—the lotus blossoms replaced by something earthier and less floral—and the arms she wraps around him are stronger, the hug firmer than what he remembers. But the way her fingers run through his hair, the warmth of her body, the way she envelopes him in her embrace despite the difference in stature—there is no mistaking it. He would know it anywhere.
“Jiejie.” He’s repeating himself, over and over again, the way he has not done since they were children and it was still allowed. This is not a dream. “Jiejie, jiejie, jiejie—”
“A-Xian.” Jiang Yanli laughs, her voice thick with tears. “Oh, A-Xian, I’m so glad you’re alive. I’ve missed you so.”
He’s missed her too. There are no words to describe how much he’s missed her. So he just holds her tighter, buries his face in her shoulder as they sink to their knees in the middle of the study floor. He’s dimly aware of movement around them—the servants, perhaps, or Lan Wangji, stepping away to give them some privacy—but he doesn’t acknowledge them, overwhelmed by the fact that Jiang Yanli is here, in his arms, safe and sound after so many years.
“Fourteen years…” She pulls away, running her hands over his hair and face as she does, drinking in the sight of him. “A-Xian, you’ve lost weight.”
He shakes his head and laughs. “I’m alright. Don’t worry about me.” He leans into the hand resting on his cheek. “You look good, Jiejie. You haven’t changed at all.”
It’s her turn to shake her head, falling so easily into their familiar banter as she admonishes him for lying.
“Nonsense. Look at me.” She sits back on her heels and raises her arms to show off the travel-worn garb beneath her heavy cloak. “I’m just a humble farmer’s wife now.”
At the word ‘wife’, Wei Wuxian is suddenly reminded they are not alone. His attention is drawn to the doorway where Jin Zixuan stands with his arm around a boy of no more than ten. Gone are the fine, embroidered silks and gilded jewels signature to the Crown Prince of Lanling. Instead, both are dressed in the same thick, northern-style robes as Jiang Yanli, both with the same broad shoulders, sun-kissed skin and matching vermilion marks between their brows. Jin Zixuan offers him a nod when their eyes meet.
“Wei Wuxian, it’s been a while.” After a moment, he hastily corrects himself and bows. “My apologies, I did not mean any disrespect. Jin Zixuan greets Hanguang-wangye, Hanguang-wangfei.”
“Taizi—Jin-gongzi.” Wei Wuxian corrects himself quickly, returning his greeting with a short bow. “There is no need for such formality. It is good to see you all well.”
He is surprised to find he means it sincerely; there was no such goodwill the last time they had crossed paths, young and foolhardy as they were. But those days are long past. Gone is the spoilt young prince who had spurned the woman he regarded as a sister, buried beneath the cold ashes of a war that took everything from them in one fell swoop. This Jin Zixuan is a husband, a father, who had done the unthinkable—renouncing his claim to the throne of Lanling to search for Jiang Yanli without knowing whether or not she was even alive—and had been rewarded for his devotion.
Jiang Cheng, ah, Jiang Cheng, Wei Wuxian thinks. I think even you would hold a bit of respect for him now.
Jin Zixuan’s eyes shift to Lan Wangji, standing silently behind Wei Wuxian, and offers a deeper bow, which Lan Wangji returns with an incline of his head. Jiang Yanli follows suit from where she is still on her knees with Wei Wuxian, bowing low at the waist.
“Jiang Yanli greets Hanguang-wangye, Hanguang-wangfei,” she echoes. “Thank you for taking care of A-Xian. Yunmeng owes you a great debt.”
Before either of them can react to dispute her claim, she turns to beckon the boy—her son, Wei Wuxian’s heart leaps with realisation—closer with one hand, dabbing at her eyes with the sleeve of the other. She draws the boy closer, turns him to face both Wei Wuxian and Lan Wangji with a warm smile and a comforting hand on his back. The boy looks up at them with something akin to awe in his eyes.
“A-Ling, come and pay respects to Wangye and Wangfei,” she tells him. “They are our family’s benefactors. Without their help, we would not be here today, so we must repay this debt however we can.”
“Yes, A-Niang.” Jin Ling steps away from his mother, squaring his little shoulders in a way that reminds Wei Wuxian of his father when they had first met, trying to put on an air of importance despite his small stature; he clasps his fingers in front of his chest and performs a textbook-perfect bow from the waist. “Jin Ling pays respects to Hanguang-wangye, Hanguang-wangfei.”
Wei Wuxian looks back at Lan Wangji, helpless in the face of their collective insistence, and sees the corner of Lan Wangji’s lips twitch. He sighs in defeat.
“Jin-xiao-gongzi,” he says, struggling to keep his voice steady. “Your mother’s family took me in when my parents passed, kept the roof over my head and the clothes on my back. Without them, I would not be here today. Whatever debt there is between us, let us wipe the slate clean now and start anew.”
He sees Lan Wangji incline his head in agreement, eyes soft as he holds out a hand to help him to his feet. His arm is warm and steady around his waist, his hand firm in his, holding him upright as he works to calm the storm of emotions warring within his chest. Finally, he gives the hand in his a brief squeeze and turns back to their guests with a bright smile.
“Now, let’s dispense with all this formality,” he says. “You must be tired from your journey—you must stay with us, here in Hanguang Manor. In fact, I insist upon it.”
Jiang Yanli exchanges a quick look with her husband.
“We do not wish to—” Wei Wuxian clears his throat pointedly, and Jiang Yanli falters mid-sentence, pauses and acquiesces with an amused sigh. “Then it would be impolite of us to decline such a generous offer.”
--
Translations
Gongzhu-dianxia (公主殿下) - Your Highness, the Princess
wangfei (王妃) - consort to the Duke, his legitimate wife/spouse
--
Notes
Approximately a billion years later!!!!
WWX called JYL jiejie as a child, before they got older and it was inappropriate to do so, after which he sometimes called her shijie in private, but mostly addressed her as Gongzhu-dianxia in public.
Any errors or inconsistencies will...be addressed at some point. It’s been a while and I need to revisit some things to remind myself what’s happened >_>
--
buy me a ko-fi!
more shattered mirrors fic | verse
#mdzs#wangxian#my writing#shattered mirrors fic#shattered mirrors au#lan wangji#wei wuxian#王爷机 X 花魁羡#jiang yanli#jin zixuan#jin ling#🥢#wei wuxian arc#this got long#and i gave up trying to make it coherent#my brain is not working after the second pfizer dose
154 notes
·
View notes
Text
Showing some love for Looking
First text post ever and it’s a long one!
I just finished watching Looking on HBO and I wanted to share my thoughts and feelings about it, primarily because I really loved it and also, I don’t hear people talking about it when they discuss TV-shows that they like or have watched.
It only aired for two seasons between 2014 and 2015, totalling of 18 episodes with a 85-minute film as a series finale, so the lack of hype or popularity is somewhat understandable since it was so short-lived. But this is a little gem that needs to be discovered and talked about a whole lot more. I will focus here on why I personally fell in love with the series and why I think it still matters today.
One of the main things I like about the show is the way it portrays gay lifestyle. The complete lack of stigma surrounding homosexuality is something that feels so refreshing and I welcome it whole-heartedly. I have always been a bit disappointed when homosexuality is brought up in films or TV-shows since so often whenever the subject matter is addressed it is shown in a way that (usually) everyone (or at least most people) makes a big fuzz about it. Sure, oftentimes it is written in a way that it will stir some feathers, as the saying goes. (English is not my primary language so apologies for any errors or inconsistences in my text.) The setting can be in a conservative environment or that the closest people (parents and the community as a whole) may be against homosexuality and the plot then centres around the protagonist struggle for acceptance and the freedom of living life on his or her own terms. And yes, that is a battle that is not be made lightly of. There is a lot of people suffering from the fact they can’t live and embrace their sexuality because of their upbringing and the rules or values of their family and/or local community. There are even countries where one may suffer death penalties just for being of the wrong sexuality. So, all that being said, I don’t want to be considered insensitive when I try to make a point here because I am aware of the battles that are yet to be won around the world for gay people.
But as a movie watcher and TV-show consumer, I just wish for once that gay people could be portrayed as living normal stigma-free lives where their sexuality is nothing to be ashamed or shunned upon, but instead being considered as nothing more out of the ordinary than say being left-handed, or something of the sorts. And that is where my love for Looking really hits home. Being gay in San Francisco seems to be considered the norm, if I’m not mistaken. At least the way it is being shown in the series it seems to be perfectly normal. One scene that illustrates this point is when a female clerk says to the main character when he brags about how brave he is to be trying anal (if I remember correctly) is: “Oh honey, do you even know where you live?”. It’s like not being gay would have been more shocking than the other way around, and I love it! For once the gay lifestyle is portrayed as something close to the standard of normal living. I have so sorely been missing that when watching movies and TV-shows in all my life.
The other big reason that I really love Looking is simply because of Jonathan Groff in the lead role as Patrick Murray. He is soo cute it is almost criminal. I mean he is like a human puppy with those eyes and that face. So perfectly casted in the role as a naïve young gay man. He is like the embodiment of the “I’m not cute, I’m a man!”-guy that only looks cuter when they actually say it. Now I don’t think he actually says that sort of thing out loud in the series, but you get my point.
The series as a whole can be criticised for lack of plot and sure, the main thing driving the series is simply the lives of the characters and how they all strive for their own happiness and success, whether it be career-wise for Dom who tries to open his own restaurant or in terms of relationship with Patrick or maybe both as with Frankie who struggles with finding a job as a down-on-his-luck artist and who simultaneously sabotages his relationship with his boyfriend. Like with Mad Men, another favourite series of mine, the main thing isn’t the plot or even the story, but instead it is the setting, the environment and the characters that feels genuine and draws you into their world that makes you want to keep watching it and follow their stories.
If I would try to dabble with some sort of analysis, I would say that Looking deals with a late form of coming-of-age in the way we follow the characters’ lives and how they try to live with the responsibilities that comes with adulthood. Maybe it is because of the promiscuous lifestyle of gays that (oftentimes?) tends to lean towards irresponsibility as a whole which then inevitably seeps into their ordinary lives (apologies for that highly generalising hypothesis), but a main theme in the series as I interpret it is how one can be more in control of their own life. It seems to be the main goal for the three friends; how they can stop being stuck in a permanent loop of partying/working and start living their lives fully as they each respectively wants it to be. It is like they all want to at least try to make their dreams come true before it is too late. But with Grindr so close at hand there is always the temptation of giving into one’s cravings of sexual pleasures, corrupting the discipline and the will power to make a steady effort of a consistent meaningful and responsible lifestyle, which is the actual pathway of achieving one’s dreams and goals. Maybe I’m wrong here, but at least that was one of the conflicts that I saw repeatedly throughout the series: the longing to create long lasting happiness and the difficulty of making that happen with all the short time pleasures that is so easily available everywhere they go. Maybe it isn’t so much of a late “coming-of-age” theme as it more of a universal existential conflict of the human condition. The art of how to balance the act of sacrificing the short-term happiness to achieve long term happiness.
I’m not sure if my analysis makes any sense and if I come across as insulting to the gay lifestyle and gay communities I sincerely apologise. It is not my intention to be insensitive but simply an attempt from my part to discern one of the themes of the series.
Is Looking totally free from stigma though? Well, there are some scenes where it comes up as an elephant in the room, but they are few and to conclude with what I stated at the beginning of this text it doesn’t bother me as much as when homosexuality is generally addressed in movies and TV-shows. Usually it is handled more or less as a plot device for stirring conflict with the stigma surrounding it. Here however it is almost 90-95% free from stigma, and because of that I salute it. All that and with the ultra-cute Jonathan Groff in the lead role is the reason why I loved every minute of binge-watching Looking.
Thanks for reading this and I hope you have a great day!
5 notes
·
View notes