Given The Choice (30/?)
… in which life on Ria’s ship brings new challenges, and Emma and Killian help each other overcome them; meanwhile, Snow struggles to keep everyone working together on the same side.
~ 10,200 words | read on ao3
Post-Neverland AU where Pan did not escape Pandora’s Box and Emma tries to come to grips with her strange new life featuring pirates, parents, and flying monkeys. Catch up here, or on ao3!
Killian knows the Serena Hawk, though he’s never been aboard. She’s a brigantine, and though she looks rather more beat-down than the Jolly Roger, he knows better than to underestimate her.
Henry gives the ship a critical once-over, then says, “Now I know what you mean about looking after your ship, Killian.”
“Don’t let the captain hear you say that, kid,” Emma says, giving him a little nudge. “Don’t think that’d go over well.”
“No indeed.” Killian smirks. “And don’t underestimate the Hawk. She may not look it, but she’s likely the fastest ship on these seas.”
“Can she make the Kessel Run in twelve parsecs?” Henry says.
“What?”
Emma narrows her eyes at the boy. “Are you quoting Star Wars again?”
Henry grins.
Killian doesn’t have time to ask what Star Wars is, because Ria appears to welcome them aboard—or rather, to keep an eye on them as they enter her ship.
“This is my quartermaster,” Ria says, indicating the man at her side. “Wesley Carswell.”
Carswell is tall and broad-shouldered, with fair, sun-bleached curls and a bright, charming smile. He turns the latter on Emma. “Not to mention the best-looking sailor around. She always forgets to mention that.”
Emma returns the smile. “Maybe she doesn’t like stating the obvious?”
His grin widens. “Oh, I like you already.”
Killian manages not to roll his eyes nor say any of the comments that come to mind as Carswell greets Henry and him in turn.
Then comes the part he’s been dreading: Ria holds out her hand for his weapons. One by one, Killian unbuckles his sword belt, his gun belt, the holster under his arm. He pulls the daggers from their sheaths inside his tunic, the knife from his boot, the trio of smaller knives from his other boot. After he’s handed all of them to the quartermaster, he glances back at Ria.
She looks expectant, and immoveable. His gut twists, just like it did yesterday evening when he agreed to this deal. But he has no choice, not unless he wants to stay behind—and that’s not an option.
He takes hold of his hook, twists and presses inward, and pulls it free of the brace. Ria takes it from him, and he manages to keep his smirk in place, as if it’s a ridiculous formality. “Will that do?”
She shrugs, tucking the hook into a pocket of her coat. “Welcome aboard.”
He doesn’t expect that the Hawk has passenger quarters, but he’s only half-right. Off the captain’s quarters is a small cabin that he’s sure usually belongs to members of the crew, a space that must have been converted from its original purpose. The “windows”, he can’t help noticing, are cannon ports.
The quartermaster stands back and gestures them in. If he’s annoyed at losing his cabin—and Killian is willing to bet he usually sleeps in here—he doesn’t show it.
“Here we are,” he says, with a slight bow for Emma. “It probably isn’t what you’re used to, milady, but it’s what we’ve got.”
“Oh.” Emma shakes her head. “No, it’s fine. Thank you.”
There is barely enough room for the three hammocks that have been strung up, but Killian concurs with Emma. It’s fine. It’s a lot better than he expected, in fact. Still...
“I can see about staying in the crew quarters,” he says, once Carswell has left them to make themselves at home.
Emma frowns. “Why?”
He frowns back. “To give you and the boy some privacy.”
She doesn’t even hesitate before she shakes her head. “I think we should stay together.”
That’s what Killian wants, if he’s honest. He’s been bracing himself for weeks of sleeping in a hammock on the gun deck or perhaps even further down in the hold. Among strangers, in the dark. It’s not that he dreaded it—he’s a grown man now, a captain himself, and those days are long behind him—but he can’t deny that he’d like to avoid it. On some deep-down level, though, the part of himself that he still thinks of as decent is protesting. “It’s hardly proper.”
“Proper?” Emma stares at him as if she’s never seen him before. “You’re worried about what’s proper?”
Henry frowns. “We all stayed in the same room before. And didn’t you guys all share a camp in Neverland?”
Killian and Emma look at each other, and there’s a moment, just the briefest moment, where he knows their minds both went to the same place. The same memory. Her hand on his collar, her lips on his, his heart pounding... and that incredible, soul-lightening relief and triumph as he realised that he could still feel all of that, he could still be that man, he still had a chance after all.
The memory is probably a little different for Emma. He really wants to ask her about it. Someday, he reminds himself. Now is not the time.
“That was different,” he says, trying for a light tone. “Emma wasn’t married in Neverland, for one thing.”
Henry makes a face. So does Emma. Killian grins. “But if you don’t mind, then by all means, let’s stay together. I do prefer your company.”
Emma tries to hide her smile at that. Henry beams at him.
* * *
As the Serena Hawk leaves the port of Azar behind and heads out into the choppy ocean, Emma finds that her gut is twisting. At first, she puts it down to nerves, but the twisting gets worse, and her hands feel clammy, and the pastries she had for breakfast no longer seem nearly as appetising.
Killian is not officially confined to the cabin, but Ria has made it clear that she wants him to stay there as much as possible. Henry, by contrast, is already making friends with the crew, who don’t seem to mind him exploring the ship and asking questions. Emma wanted to join him once she settled in, but moving makes her stomach lurch, and she’s started to feel nauseous. She sits down on the bare wood of the cabin floor instead, her back to the hull, and presses her hand to her forehead.
“Are you all right?” Killian asks, pausing in the act of rooting through the bag he brought to peer over at her. “You’re looking rather green.”
“Just feeling a bit sick,” Emma admits. “Must be something I ate.”
He frowns. “Do you feel lightheaded? Or clammy, perhaps?”
“Yeah,” she admits. “Both of those.”
“And it came on after we set sail, didn’t it?” he asks. “I think perhaps you’re seasick, love.”
She shakes her head, and regrets it immediately as the cabin starts to spin around her. She swallows, determined not to throw up. “I was never seasick before.”
“Not on my ship,” he says, with a touch of wistful pride. “She wouldn’t do that to you. This one, however... well, no offence, love, but you aren’t used to sea travel.”
“Are you seriously telling me that your ship was... was being nice to me?” Even as she says it, it doesn’t sound nearly as far-fetched as she’s making it sound. She winces as the Serena Hawk lurches over another wave, and a corresponding wave of nausea washes through her. “Whoah. Think I need to lie down.”
Killian shakes his head. “Don’t. It won’t help. Try closing your eyes.”
She obeys, leaning her head back against the hull. It helps a little, but it makes her feel even more light-headed.
When she admits as much to Killian, he says, “You ought to go up on deck, really. The fresh air will help, and it helps to look at a fixed spot on the horizon, too.”
Moving doesn’t sound any fun at all, but if he says it’ll help, she’s willing to give it a try. She has to shake this. It’s miserable, and it’s embarrassing. Killian doesn’t seem to be having any trouble at all with the waves, and she is absolutely not going to throw up in front of him. “Sure, worth a shot.”
She gets to her feet—and promptly feels dizzy again, stumbling. Killian catches her, one steadying arm around her shoulders. “I’d better go with you.”
Emma grits her teeth, but doesn’t argue. Much as she doesn’t want him to see her like this, the thought of going up on deck alone is worse.
The quartermaster—Wesley Carswell, she remembers after a moment—throws Killian a challenging look as he helps Emma out onto the deck. “What happened to staying below?”
“The lady is feeling the waves,” Killian says. Emma is not proud of the way she’s clinging to his arm, but the first brush of blessedly cool wind over her clammy face is enough to make her forget about dignity.
“Ah.” Carswell’s expression softens, and he gives Emma a sympathetic look. “Keep your eyes on the horizon, that’ll help.”
Emma’s instinct is to head for the front—whenever she’s been travelsick in a car, looking straight ahead helped—but Killian stops her. “Over here,” he says, motioning towards the railing nearby. “Best to stay in the middle of the ship. It’s the steadiest part.”
He demonstrates with his free arm, moving it like a see-saw, and Emma gets it. The middle of the ship is the fulcrum, so to speak, and the further out she goes from there, the more it will move. Up ahead, she can see the bow dipping and rising with each wave—yeah, probably the last place she wants to be right now.
Killian guides her to the railing, out of the way of the crew, and she leans on it, letting the wind cool the sweat on her face. She picks a spot on the horizon, and keeps her eyes on it.
“Stay here,” Killian says. “I’ll go see if there’s any ginger tea to be had.”
She has to rein in a frankly pathetic urge to ask him to stay. It’s not like he can do anything. But she’s miserable, clammy and nauseous and light-headed, and without him, there’s nothing to distract her from it.
To her surprise, looking at the horizon does help. The nausea doesn’t go away, but it eases until she no longer feels like she might throw up.
Killian returns after a few minutes, sauntering over the rolling deck like it’s not moving at all. Bastard.
But she can’t call him that when he gives her an encouraging smile and hands her a tin mug with steaming hot ginger tea. “Wrap your sleeve around it, it’s hot. But it should help. How are you feeling?”
“Better,” she admits, taking a careful sip of the tea. It doesn’t taste of much, but it warms her throat as she swallows, the gentle burn of the ginger lingering. “Please tell me I’m not gonna be dealing with this for the entire trip.”
“No, no, it’ll pass soon enough,” Killian assures her. “You just have to get used to the waves.”
Emma glares out across the ocean, and takes another sip. It might be her imagination, but she thinks she can feel it soothing her stomach. “Well, the sooner, the better.”
Killian leans against the railing beside her, his back to the sea, giving her an encouraging smile. “Not to worry, love. It won’t keep you down for long. Nothing can.”
She wants to argue, because right now it feels like this can very much keep her down, and her instinctive reaction at his belief in her is always to try and dampen it. But she can’t, not now. Not when she needs it. She is not going to spend this entire trip feeling sick and sweaty and gross. “Damn right,” she says instead, and wills her stomach to settle.
“That’s the spirit,” Killian agrees, flashing another smile.
She needs to change the subject, but luckily, it’s easy. “How long d’you think it’ll take to get to Misthaven?”
He looks up at the sky, squinting into the sunlight. “If this wind holds, I’d estimate a little over two weeks. Of course, whether it does is anyone’s guess, especially at this time of year. But it shouldn’t be much more than three weeks.”
“Right.” Emma keeps forgetting that the ship is at the mercy of the wind. There is no precise schedule. “How fast is this ship, anyway?”
Killian turns to glance out at the sea, resting his forearms on the railing and watching the waves go by. It’s odd to see the brace without the hook in it, the way it just... ends. It reminds Emma, bizarrely, of a declawed cat in one of the foster homes she stayed in. It was a grouchy, suspicious thing, and at the time its lack of claws seemed like a blessing. Not until years later did she learn exactly what declawing is, and realise that the poor thing lashed out because it was miserable.
“At the moment, I’d hazard a guess at around twelve knots,” Killian says, and Emma shakes away the odd thought and focuses on the conversation again. “She can go faster, given better winds. I’m not sure.”
“So that’s...” Emma has to do some not-so-quick math. “14 miles per hour? Give or take?”
He grins, and she feels a flash of pride. “Aye. Rather slower than your car, I imagine.”
Emma thinks of the bug, back in Storybrooke, and wonders what happened to it. Did the curse wipe it from existence? Or is it still there, in the place where Storybrooke was?
“Yeah,” she says, pushing aside the image of the yellow bug sitting alone in the middle of the forest. “Although... it depends. It’s not all that fast in the water, you know?”
It takes him a moment, but then his grin widens. “A major shortcoming.”
“Yeah. That’s why I didn’t bring it.”
He laughs, and his arm moves, as if he might hug her to him. But he seems to think better of the impulse—if that’s even what it was. “Always thinking ahead, aren’t you?”
She grins back at him, but it falters as the ship hits another wave and lurches. Killian’s eyes narrow, and she swear that he directs a little glare at the ship, as if reprimanding it. Old habits, she thinks. If it were the Jolly Roger, he probably would have muttered a little reminder about bad form.
For all she knows, he did exactly that, and the ship listened.
“I’m sorry,” she says, because it’s been on the tip of her tongue since yesterday and she has to say it. “About your ship.”
He shakes his head. “It wasn’t your fault.”
“Kinda was.” She doesn’t like saying it; the thought that he lost his home because of her is awful. But she has to say it. “You traded her for me. If me and Henry hadn’t been there—”
“Swan,” he cuts her off, serious now. “That doesn’t make it your fault. If anything, it was mine.”
She immediately wants to argue, but instead, she raises her eyebrows incredulously. “Okay, how the hell would it be your fault?”
He hesitates for the briefest moment, and then he gets that look, the one he always has when he’s going to do the right thing and admit something even though he’s ashamed of it. “Blackbeard played me. He—when I was waiting for you outside the shop, a boy tried to pickpocket me. I caught him, of course. And I could have let him go, but,” a sigh, “I didn’t. I threatened him, which meant I was distracted, and in that time, Blackbeard’s crew absconded with you.”
He takes a deep breath, not quite looking at her. “If I had just let the lad go, I would have noticed it. Blackbeard was counting on my anger and my ego, that I would waste time trying to scare the boy.”
Emma still wants to argue, but she can’t find the right words. “Why did you?” she asks instead. “Scare him, I mean.”
He huffs out a laugh, spreading his arms as if inviting her to look at him. “Do you need to ask?”
I’m a villain. But Emma nods. “I wouldn’t have asked if I didn’t need to.”
“I was angry,” Killian says, almost defiant now. “I wanted to scare him so he’d know to never try that with me again.”
“So you were defending yourself.”
His eyes flash. “That’s not an excuse.”
“No, it’s not. It’s also not your fault.” Emma holds a hand before he can argue. “You said Blackbeard played you. He sent the kid?”
“I assume so.”
“Right. So he distracted you, and kidnapped us. It’s just as much my fault for not noticing his crew before they were on us, and for not fighting them off.”
“You couldn’t have fought them off,” he protests. “Even if you had noticed... they had your boy.”
“Yeah, but you still traded the ship for us,” she insists. “If I hadn’t been there, you’d still have it.”
“If you hadn’t been there, neither would I,” he says. “Shall we go back further? If I hadn’t gotten myself cursed, you wouldn’t have lost your magic and been able to stop Blackbeard.”
“That was Zelena’s fault!”
“It was just as much mine!”
“Well—" Emma huffs out an impatient breath. He’s infuriating when he’s like this, stubbornly determined to be the villain in every scenario. Worse, she knows that he means it; this is how he feels. “Okay, this is stupid. We are literally arguing about who gets to take the blame.”
He opens his mouth, and she knows he’s about to claim all of the blame again and tell her to stop, but he stops himself. And then, slowly, comes a cautious, rueful smile. “I suppose... traditionally, people try to blame each other, don’t they?”
She tries a grin. “Yeah, we’re doing it wrong.”
He shrugs, that smile still tugging at his mouth. “I’ve never been much for tradition.”
“Yeah, well, let’s not make this the new tradition, okay?” She fixes him with a steady look. “It was Blackbeard’s fault. He’s the one who did it.”
Killian doesn’t accept that, she can tell from his expression. But Emma has spent enough time around Snow by now, and she’s not stupid, either. “Okay, fine. Let’s say you kidnap me.”
One eyebrow jumps up. Before he can make a comment, she goes on, “And, uh... my dad comes after me. And trades you, I don’t know, a new ship. Or a ton of gold. Whose fault is it that I got kidnapped? Mine or yours?”
Killian knows exactly where she’s going with it, of course. He hesitates; and then he lets out a breath, and there’s something like acceptance in it. “Mine.”
“And whose fault is it that my dad’s now down a ship or a ton of gold or whatever?”
He’s already nodding. “Also mine. I see your point.”
“Good.” She hesitates. “Look, I get it, you’re being all... honourable, and stuff. But beating yourself up about it doesn’t help. And just ‘cause you made a mistake doesn’t mean other people aren’t at fault.”
He flashes a smile. “You have a unique way of looking at things, love.”
She grimaces, but he goes on, “No, it’s good. I—it’s helpful, having your perspective, if I’m honest. Thank you.”
“Oh.” She shrugs, at a loss for what to say to that, just as glad that she’s got the excuse of looking at the horizon right now. “Yeah. Well. Thanks for the tea, and... you know.”
“Feeling any better?” he asks, accepting the change in subject.
“A little, yeah.” She takes a deep breath. The nausea has subsided somewhat, though she still feels every rise and dip of the damned ship. “Don’t take this the wrong way, I know you love the sea and all, but I’ll be glad when we reach port.”
He gives a wry little laugh at that. “No, this time I’m entirely in agreement, love.”
* * *
For once, the argument is already in full swing by the time Regina arrives in the war room—or the conference room, as Snow insists on calling it.
Snow is sitting in her usual spot at the round table, flanked by David and Leroy. Beside Leroy is Blue, wearing her usual look of arch disapproval, only for once it isn’t directed at Regina. Instead, her side glances are finding Robin, who is in the middle of talking.
“—not really theft,” he says as Regina sweeps into the room. “More like—” He cuts off as he notices her, half-twisting in his seat to look. “Ah, your Majesty.”
“The meeting started ten minutes ago,” Blue says, in that tone that sounds like it’s just giving information but really contains a mountain of censure. Regina knows it well. Her mother was a master of it, too.
“So sorry,” Regina says, shooting the fairy a fake smile. “Had to trim my nails, then I ran out of better things to do with my time so I came to listen to you shouting at each other. Please, carry on,” she adds with a gracious wave of her hand as she slides into her chair.
Blue only raises her eyebrows slightly, but Regina can tell she’s annoyed. Robin smirks, shaking his head. David gives Regina one of those half-resigned, half-admonishing looks he does so well.
“We’re trying to figure out how to keep funding all this,” Snow says to Regina. “There isn’t much left in the coffers here. Robin and his people have—well, they’ve been waylaying carriages, and...” She glances at Blue. “He has some ideas in that sort of... area.”
Regina already figured as much, from what he was saying when she walked in. “Thievery? Colour me surprised.”
“If it helps,” Robin says, ignoring her, “think of it as liberating resources that would otherwise line the pockets of some greedy nobleman.”
“A nobleman with obligations,” Blue says. “The aristocracy has a duty to look after and protect the people on their lands. That’s where those resources go.”
Robin snaps his fingers. “You know, I keep forgetting that. It’s so obvious, what with this castle being a typical dwelling that everyone can afford, and that,” he waves a hand at Regina, “being how everyone can afford to dress. Clearly everything is divided very fairly.”
Blue sighs impatiently. “I’m not saying there aren’t any perks, but they’re balanced out by duties.”
“I used to steal,” Snow says uncertainly. “I mean, as a bandit. I stole from passing noblemen, or,” she glances at David and smiles, “men pretending to be noblemen.”
David flashes her a sappy grin, and Regina rolls her eyes and looks away.
“Nothing wrong with that,” Granny says stoutly. “I’m sure they could afford to lose whatever you took.”
“And we need more funds,” Robin says. “We have a lot more people to feed now. It’s going to be a long winter.”
They keep arguing, back and forth, everyone weighing in and nobody getting anywhere. Regina stays out of it, waiting for Snow to make the call.
But Snow doesn’t make the call. She waits, listens, lets everyone make their case... and tries to mediate.
It’s at times like these that Regina finds herself almost missing Emma and Hook. All right, missing is a strong word. But if Emma were here, she would have put her foot down by now. If Hook were here, he would have made some sarcastic but pragmatic comment about ends justifying the means and not being able to eat morals no matter how good they are.
Granted, they would probably also have turned this argument into one of their weird flirting-while-pretending-not-to rituals, but at this stage, Regina would take that over this endless back-and-forth.
“Snow,” Blue implores. “I agree we need to beat Zelena, but we need to do it the right way.”
“All right,” Robin says. “One question—why exactly does the decision ultimately rest with Snow?”
“Because she’s the leader,” Granny growls at him.
“Is she?” Robin looks around, eyebrows raised. “I didn’t vote for her.”
“She’s the rightful heir to the throne,” Blue says, looking scandalised.
Robin grins. “Not much of a throne at the moment, is it?”
Snow is staring at him, wide-eyed. She shoots a fractional glance at Regina—that’s where she would have expected this kind of challenge from, Regina knows. As if she’d challenge Snow around these people. She has less chance of winning a popular vote than Leroy.
Then again, Robin doesn’t stand a chance either.
“You want a vote?” David asks, scowling at him. “Fine. Let’s have a vote. All who want Snow to be our leader, say aye. Aye.”
There’s a chorus of ayes around the table. Regina opens her mouth, but she can’t bring herself to say it. She can’t.
Robin shrugs and leans back in his chair, looking relaxed. “Aye.”
Snow narrows her eyes at him. “You’re voting for me?”
“No need to gloat,” Robin tells her with a wink.”So. We have a leader. What does she say?”
And Regina, not nearly as naive as Snow, realises: he did that on purpose. Snow has been leading them, but without everyone’s explicit approval. Now she has it.
Regina feels her lip curl. Why is everyone always Snow’s ally? And where the hell did an outlaw learn about politics?
Snow still looks shocked and maybe a little hurt, but she rallies. “Okay. Well. That’s settled, then. Blue, I understand the moral concerns, but I don’t think we’ve really got much choice. And, honestly, back when I was—before my father died, I think we could have afforded to lose a few carriages.”
Regina scoffs. Yeah, Leopold certainly could have taken the loss. It might have meant one less new dress for his precious daughter, but oh, that wouldn’t matter as long as they loved each other so much.
Her stomach twists.
“What?” Snow all but snaps, and Regina realises that her scoffing was maybe a little loud.
“Nothing. Actually, I’m agreeing with you,” she says. “It’s not like you were poor.”
Snow looks at her for a moment, eyes narrowed, as if looking for a trap. “Right.”
“Right,” Regina says. “Thievery authorised. Anything else on the agenda?”
* * *
Snow tracks Robin down after the meeting is over. He and his people have set up camp in the ruins of the east wing, and that’s where she finds him, sitting on a crate and darning a tiny shirt that has to be Roland’s.
He looks up as she approaches, and smiles. “Hey there.”
“Hey.” She hesitates. “I wanted to talk to you.”
He nods, as if he expected it, and gestures towards a chest nearby. “Sit.”
She sits. “I just wanted to say, if you want to share leadership—”
“Yes, I thought you might.” He shakes his head. “I’ve no interest in being in charge. I’ve got enough on my plate keeping my lads in line.”
“Then why...?” she asks.
“Because someone needs to be in charge,” Robin says. “You may be the rightful queen of this land, but with the Wicked Witch and the Evil Queen around, that isn’t enough. You’re in charge, but you haven’t made any appointments. We don’t have a treasurer, a captain of the guard, nothing, and like it or not, you need them. It makes meetings like the one we just had a lot easier. But you need everyone’s support for that. You needed that vote to give you legitimacy, so I made it happen.”
“I just wanted...” Snow shakes her head. “I want us to make decisions together.”
“Do you?” Robin challenges. “Then why were there only ten people at that table? Why didn’t the entire castle vote on my plan?”
Snow stares at her. Of course the entire castle didn’t vote. That’s just common sense. If they needed a consensus every time, they’d never get anywhere.
Oh.
“I just—I’m not a tyrant,” she says, and it sounds defensive even to her. “I’m not—I don’t want to—we’re—”
“You’re in charge, and you’ve got people advising you,” Robin says. “That’s how it works. Take it from me. What happens if Zelena attacks, or we have to take the fight to her? You can’t win battles if you have to keep stopping to hold votes.”
He’s making sense, and Snow hates it. She isn’t like Regina, and she doesn’t want to be. She doesn’t want power.
“I don’t want to just order people around,” she says.
“Oh, I know.” Robin grins. “I wouldn’t be here if you did. But that isn’t what you’re doing.”
Snow takes a deep breath, hating how unsure she sounds when she says, “Right.”
“Trust me.” Robin shrugs. “I’ve encountered enough power-hungry nobility and bad leaders to know a good one when I see her. You don’t want to be in charge. You just take charge because you have to, because someone has to, because everyone else needs you to.”
“Like you did?” Snow says.
“Pretty much.” Robin gives a self-deprecating shrug. “I won’t pretend that I have all the answers. I just do my best. And I know that usually, if someone really wants to be the boss, they shouldn’t be. For example, I’m sure Her Majesticness would love to share leadership with you, but you aren’t offering it to her, are you?”
Snow doesn’t need to ask who he’s referring to; she huffs out a laugh. “Somehow, I don’t think it’d stay shared for very long.”
“Exactly.” Robin blows out a breath, looking almost incredulous as he considers Regina. “Hell of a lady. But not someone you want in charge.”
“That’s Regina,” Snow agrees wryly, resolutely not thinking about Regina being queen and everything it brought about. “At least I’ve got plenty of examples of what not to do.”
“Valuable,” Robin agrees. “But for what it’s worth, I think you’re doing fine. Don’t let her undermine you. Nor Blue.”
“Blue’s just...” Snow trails off.
“Trying to help,” Robin finishes with a nod. “And a little too concerned with morality. And that’s a good voice to have around, just... don’t let her guilt-trip you, either.”
“Yeah.” Snow takes a deep breath. “Thank you. Really.”
Robin smiles at her. “Of course. We outlaws have to stick together, right?”
She grins back. “Right. But since you brought it up... you’re right. I do need to make some appointments. The captain of the guard, for one thing. You interested?”
Robin considers it. “I can do it, but with the caveat that I’ll step aside if you find a better candidate.”
Snow nods. If Emma or Hook were here... but they’re not, and she needs to do her job and do what’s best for everyone who is here. “That works for me. I’ll make it official at our next meeting.”
He smiles again, and so does she, feeling the weight on her shoulders lift somewhat. He’s right: someone needs to be in charge. The others need her, so she’ll figure it out.
* * *
Killian is kneeling on the deck, both hands gripping the brush as he scrubs the weathered boards. All around him are shadows and noise, and a rising urgency. He’s running out of time. He has work to do. The captain will be back soon, and there’ll be trouble if the deck isn’t clean. He has to finish his task, but the deck is still filthy, and there’s no more water in the bucket. There’s no water to be had anywhere. He keeps scrubbing anyway, trying to hurry, trying—
The captain looms over him. Killian scrambles to his feet, heart pounding in his chest, his only thought to get away. He runs over to the mast, catches hold of one of the ropes, but the captain is on him before he can climb.
Killian can’t move. The captain grabs him and twists his arm around, getting hold of his hand. And then he begins to squeeze.
Killian’s hand clenches, caught in a grip like a vice. He tries to pull away, but he can’t move. His fingers tense one by one, going rigid.
And then pain explodes—in his fingers, his palm, his wrist. The more he tries to pull away, the more he tries to fight, the more the captain’s grip tightens. He draws breath to scream—
And shoots awake with a gasp. Around him is darkness, but it’s silent, save for the usual sounds of a ship at night. He barely registers any of it. His left hand is coiled into a fist, agony like fire in his veins, stabbing his palm, his knuckles, his fingers. He reaches for it, heart frantic, expecting blood, torn flesh—and his hand encounters nothing.
Nothing.
There is no hand. There is nothing. He doesn’t have a hand anymore. There’s just the hard leather of his brace, covering what remains of his wrist.
And he remembers this—the sudden cramping, feeling his fingers go rigid, and then the pain. Not real pain; it can’t be real, because his hand is not there anymore. It’s been a long time since he felt like it was, since his own mind played this trick on him. Tearing the brace off won’t help. Nothing will help, because nothing is there to be helped.
Killian bites back a scream, his whole body tensing as he tries to will the pain away. He’s not alone in here. He can’t wake Emma and Henry. If they wake up, he’ll have to explain this, admit it, and he can’t. He has to stay quiet. It will pass. It will pass. It always does.
He curls up as best he can, grits his teeth, and waits for it to end.
* * *
Emma isn’t sure what wakes her. The cabin is dark, and as quiet as it gets aboard ship. She can hear wood creaking, a murmur of voices some distance away, the gentle, almost-regular sound of waves against the hull. All the night-time sounds of a ship under way, almost familiar by now. Except for the voices, but those are reassuring.
She lies there a moment, listening. And then, there’s something else—a low hiss, like a sharp, stifled intake of breath. Emma looks around, though the cabin is almost pitch black. The only source of light is the window, casting the dim, bluish-silver glow of moonlight into the cabin.
“Henry?” she whispers.
No reply. Henry’s hammock is close enough for her to touch, and she can just about make out his head, dark against white. “Kid?”
He doesn’t budge.
“Killian?”
Nothing. Emma debates getting up to see what’s going on, but she doesn’t want to wake everyone for no reason. It was probably just Henry or Killian sighing in his sleep.
Emma lies awake for a while longer, listening, but she doesn’t hear anything more. Eventually, she drifts off again.
By next morning, she has all but forgotten about the sound.
* * *
To Emma’s relief, her seasickness seems to be gone for good. There’s no hint of it the following day, not even after she eats breakfast in the corner of the gun deck that seems to count as the kitchen—galley, she corrects herself.
Henry has made a friend, a dark-haired, gangly boy of maybe fifteen or sixteen named Jim who has a lot of stories to tell and is eager for a wide-eyed audience. Emma doubts that even half of them are true, which is all but confirmed by the knowing smirk that Killian does his best to hide, but she keeps quiet. Henry’s eyes are bright and he’s smiling, and if half-invented smuggler stories will make him happy, she’s not about to ruin it.
Killian, on the other hand, is on edge. He’s doing his best to hide it, but while his bravado and sarcasm might fool the others, the fact that it’s there tells Emma that something is up.
So she asks him to accompany her up on deck again. “Think maybe breakfast was a bad idea after all,” she says, wrinkling her nose as if she still feels sick. “Do you mind?”
“No, of course.” His eyes are narrowed, though, and while the quartermaster seems to buy her excuse, Killian doesn’t.
“You know you don’t need an excuse to claim my company, don’t you?” he asks as they make their way over to the railing again, out of the way of the crew.
“Uh-huh,” Emma says. “That’s not what the excuse was for.”
That surprises him. Clearly, he expected her to deny it. “Oh?”
“I thought you could use a little time up on deck,” she said. “You were looking a little trapped.”
“I—” He stares at her.
“You don’t like being a passenger, do you?” she asks.
He winces. “Is it that noticeable?”
“A little,” she says, because the alternative is to admit that she knows him well enough to catch the little moments of discomfort and impatience that he tries so hard to cover. “And I know how rough it can be to watch someone else do a job you’re good at.”
“Aye.” Killian makes a face, then shrugs. “It’s all right. Ria is competent. And all things considered, passenger isn’t so bad. At least she’s not making me scrub the deck.”
He’s making light of it, but there’s something behind those words that makes Emma take notice. “Is that what you did?” she asks, driven by instinct. “Before?”
Even as she says it, it dawns on her that it’s an insensitive question. She doesn’t know why, but she can feel it, the same way she can tell that he’s making light of something other than his status as passenger.
“Everyone starts out scrubbing the deck,” he says with another shrug. His tone is light, but his eyes are haunted, and it’s not an answer, not really. “You work your way up, and if you’re the best,” he flashes a grin, “you become captain.”
She knows that grin. It’s the bravado grin, the one that says he doesn’t want to talk about it. Emma’s first instinct is to keep asking, but she doesn’t need to. Between the comments he’s made lately, she’s been piecing some things together, and she knows better than to ask. Killian might wear his heart on his sleeve half the time, but he doesn’t speak about his past.
“Right,” she says, and grins back. “I can’t wait to get there.”
It takes a moment, then he laughs—a real laugh, one that lights his eyes and drives away the haunted look. “Ambitious, are you?”
“Hey, you said that’s how it works. You don’t think I’ve got it in me?”
He opens his mouth to reply—and then a certain glint comes to his eyes as he thinks of something, and he laughs again, a deeper chuckle this time. “You—no. No, I won’t even say it.”
“What?” It’s some kind of innuendo, it has to be. And once Emma knows that, she knows exactly what he’s thinking. “Oh, for—let me guess. Something about having a captain in me?”
That has him laughing again, throwing his head back, eyes briefly squeezing shut. The corners of his eyes crinkle when he laughs, and she swears there’s a dimple hiding under the stubble on his cheeks. “Sorry.”
“Yeah, yeah,” she grumbles—or tries to. Her cheeks feel warm, but so does her chest, because he looks delighted with himself (and with her). “I was asking for that one.”
He raises his eyebrows, eyes still sparkling with mirth. “You can ask for that anytime, darling.”
“Stop it.” She gives a half-hearted slap at his arm, unable to keep from laughing herself.
Killian chuckles, before turning his attention to Henry, who is just emerging from belowdecks with Jim. “How is he doing?”
“Okay, I think,” Emma says. “It’s hard to tell sometimes. I think Neverland had him a little on edge.”
“Can’t say I blame him,” Killian says with a grimace.
“But since we left, he’s holding up better than I thought,” Emma goes on. “Still, it’s... he’s trying to be patient, but I think he misses home.”
“Naturally,” Killian agrees. “Storybrooke is all he knew his entire life, and this is the second time he’s been abruptly whisked away from it.”
Emma makes a face. “I think he’s liking this time a lot better than last time, all things considered.”
“I’d have to agree with him there.” Killian tilts his head at her. “And you? Do you miss it?”
“Storybrooke?” Emma thinks about it. Her time in Storybrooke was certainly eventful, and she’d be lying if she said it was all good. She misses Granny’s, and walking Henry to the bus, and the beach, and strolling from it to the pier. But there are definitely things she doesn’t miss. “I don’t know. Maybe. It... I guess it kinda became home, for a bit. And if I could go back there right now, with everyone, I would. But...” She shrugs.
“You miss the people more than the place?” Killian prompts.
The moment he says it, Emma knows it’s true. That’s exactly how she feels. She misses her parents, her friends; she even misses Regina a little bit, if only because playing mom to Henry alone is kind of terrifying. She shrugs again.
Killian smiles. “It’s all right, Swan. I miss them too. Well... some of them.”
She gives him a sceptical look. “Oh yeah?”
“Aye, I even find myself missing David on occasion,” he says with a grin. “It’s not the same without him glaring at me occasionally, is it.”
She has to laugh at that, even as memories of her father and his pointed comments send another pang through her stomach. She can’t say she misses his disapproving looks, but she misses him. David. His reassuring, cheerful presence, his unfailing support, and yeah, even his sarcastic remarks.
“Don’t tell him, though,” Killian goes on. “I’d never live it down.”
The ache inside her recedes again, and she smirks at him. “I can glare at you instead, if you want.”
He sighs. “You’re too kind, love.”
“I’m just saying, if you need someone to glare at you and take you down a peg, I’m here for you.”
“Oh, thank you so much.” He gives her a theatrically-grateful look to match the words, and she laughs. A moment later, so does he.
Carswell joins them a few minutes later, ostensibly to ask after Emma’s welfare. He’s all smiles and charm, but she suspects that he no longer believes her claim of seasickness—and, to be fair, she hasn’t been acting very sick. Chatting with Killian made her forget all about the excuse.
Feeling a little like a chastised teenager, Emma lets Carswell send her off the deck and back to the cabin.
* * *
A few hours into the day, Emma has decided that she agrees with Killian: she doesn’t like being a passenger on this ship either. They’re not confined to their cabin, so they join some of the off-duty on the main deck once the ship is steadily underway, but she has nothing to do other than watch. On the Jolly Roger, she could help because she was the only one available, but for everything she can do, there’s someone on the Hawk who can do it better.
Killian is another matter. Ria doesn’t trust him, but there can be no doubt that he’s an experienced sailor, and after another conversation with Carswell, he’s been put to work. He’s sitting cross-legged a little ways away, a slight frown on his face as he bends over his task—working on some part of the rigging, Emma thinks, but she has no idea what he’s actually doing with it. His hand deftly moving and knotting the ropes, he looks both in his element and out of it. He knows what he’s doing, but Emma doesn’t have to be a sailing expert to know that it’s grunt work, the kind of thing he can do in his sleep but usually orders others to do. And he’s working one-handed now, the empty brace rarely coming into use to awkwardly help pin a rope in place.
She’s never really noticed how naturally he uses the hook until now, seeing him without it.
Once the ship is underway, she joins some of the other off-duty crewmen on the main deck. Henry is crouching next to Jim, who is playing dice with an older woman named Aileen and listening to her stories. Stories about sailor superstitions and mermaids and magic, from what Emma can hear, which explains the enraptured look on Henry’s face.
She sits back and listens too, her eyes straying upwards to where one of the men is climbing the rigging, surefooted and agile. She imagines what that would be like, to climb all the way up there and out, and hopes she’ll never find out. If that’s part of it, she might leave the captaining to Killian, after all.
Another movement draws her attention. Killian has dropped what he was doing, scowling as he gets to his feet. His shoulders are tense, his face pinched. He looks around, catches her looking—and most of the pinched look disappears as he flashes a smile and turns away.
She watches him disappear through the hatch, her gut suddenly churning. Something is wrong. Even so, she hesitates. She doesn’t want to check up on him—he’s a grown man, and he has the right to privacy. If he wants a moment to himself, she’s the first to respect that.
But the look on his face before he caught her watching him...
Henry is still listening to Aileen, completely rapt as she launches into a ghost story. Making up her mind, Emma climbs belowdecks and makes her way to the cabin.
It takes her a moment to realise that Killian is here. He’s sitting hunched over on the floor, his back to the hull, and Emma’s first thought is that he’s crying.
“Killian?” She says it quietly, almost changing her mind halfway through the name.
His head snaps up. He’s not crying. His face is pinched, shoulders tense—hurt, she thinks.
“Whoah, what’s wrong?”
“Nothing.” His voice is strained, almost angry. “I’m fine, just—” He ends on a hiss. His lips press together, jaw clenching.
Emma hasn’t known Killian for all that long, but she knows that he can handle pain. She’s seen him laid out on his back with broken ribs after being hit by a car, and he called her ‘beautiful’ and tried to flirt. He isn’t one to admit when he’s hurt, and the fact that he can’t muster up any comment right now tells her more than he ever will.
She’s across the cabin in two strides, kneeling before him. She can’t see any wounds, nor think how he could’ve got hurt, but he is. He’s in agony. “Hey,” she says, as gently as she can.
He shakes his head as if to ward her off. His face is screwed up in a grimace she’s never seen before, his shoulders hunched—
Because he’s curled around his arm. His left arm, where he’s missing a hand.
She doesn’t know a lot about amputation; bits and pieces she picked up, idle curiosity leading her to Google—but she knows about this.
“Phantom pain?” she says, scooting around to sit next to him and putting a hand on his shoulder. “That’s it, right?”
He makes a sound somewhere between a sob and a growl and leans into her touch, just a bit, and to hell with it—she slings her arm around his shoulders and pulls him closer. His shoulders are wider than she realised, and she can’t actually make him move, but he lets her move him. He doesn’t protest, nor does he make any comment, another sign that he’s in a bad way.
Emma feels helpless. She has some rudimentary medical knowledge; she can clean and dress a cut, she could even make a decent attempt at splinting a broken bone, but this? She has no idea how to help this.
“It’s not—real,” Killian mutters. He sounds angry—his way of keeping the pain at bay, she thinks.
He lets out a long, shuddering breath, and she tightens her hold instinctively. He’s leaning against her, his face pressed into her shoulder, and it’s a little awkward because of the angle and the hull behind them and him being rather too big for her to hold him like this, but she isn’t about to let go.
“It’s okay,” she says, because she has to say something, she has to make it better. “You’re okay. It’s just—just a memory. It’s sort of real, I think, but it’s not coming from your hand. Nerves getting confused, I think. I read about it.”
“You did?” His voice is strained. “Tell me.”
Emma has a thought that he should be telling her; he likely knows more about it than she does. But that isn’t what he asked, and she knows a thing or two about distraction, so she tells him. She has no idea what she’s doing; she just holds him, stroking what she hopes are soothing circles over his arm and back, telling him that there’s nothing wrong, that it’s just the nerves sending the wrong signals to the brain, that he’s okay.
To her surprise, it seems to work.
She can’t be sure how much time passes, but it can’t be more than ten minutes or so when he pulls away, and she relaxes her hold on him. He sits up away from her, rolling his shoulders and stretching his neck this way and that.
“Better?” she asks cautiously.
“Aye.” He runs a hand through his hair, not quite looking at her. “Apologies, love.”
He’s embarrassed. She gets that; not twenty-four hours ago, she wanted to murder her own stomach for betraying her. “Don’t. How do you feel?”
“I’m fine.”
“Killian.”
He finally looks at her then, and offers a rueful smile. “Truly. It goes just as fast as it comes. It’s not as though I’m injured. I—it’s been a long time since it’s happened. I thought I was done with it.”
Emma nods. “But you’re okay now?”
“Aye. Thank you.”
Now it’s her turn to feel embarrassed. “I didn’t really do anything.”
“Yes, you did.” He still looks like he wants to bolt—definitely embarrassed, maybe even ashamed. For all that he’ll wear his heart on his sleeve, he hates admitting to anything he sees as weakness. But he takes a deep breath, and nods. “It helped. What you said.” Not being alone, she thinks, but he won’t say that any more than she would.
“Well, then,” she says. “You’re welcome. Anytime.”
“Thank you, but I’d rather not make it a habit.”
“Does it happen often?” she asks. She’s never seen him look like that. She never wants to see it again.
He shakes his head. “Not for centuries now. I’d all but forgotten.”
She hesitates. “What about last night?”
Killian’s eyes widen a little, and she has her answer even before he asks, “You heard?”
“I thought I heard something,” she said. “But I wasn’t sure. You should’ve said something.”
“Don’t take this the wrong way, love, but I didn’t see any point,” he says. “It passed. It always does.”
“Yeah, but if I can help—” She can’t help, not really. She’s not a doctor. She doesn’t even have her magic right now, not that she even knows whether that would do any good. All she knows is that he shouldn’t go through that alone. “Just—tell me. If you want. I—you know. I’m here.”
He’s staring at her like she’s talking about modern technology, like there’s something in all of what she just said that he’s having trouble understanding.
She wonders when the last time was that someone was just there for him.
And she’s suddenly gripped by that familiar urge to explain—to justify. “I just mean, you know, you helped me. Yesterday, and before, and it should go both ways, right? It has to go both ways, or... or no deal,” she ends firmly.
He finally smiles then. “Fair enough.”
“Any idea what brought this on?” Emma asks. She might not know a lot about this, but if she’s going to help, she needs to know all she can.
He shakes his head. “I’ve no idea. It always came on at random.”
“Yeah, but not for years, right? Twice in one day after years of nothing, that seems weird.”
Killian stares down at his brace, frowning—more in annoyance than in thought. It couldn’t be clearer that he hates this. It’s a weakness, and he’s at the mercy of it, with nothing to be done. He’s not in control. All he has to counter it is anger, and that’s enough to stop him falling apart, but not much beyond that.
Emma looks down at the brace and thinks, again, of that declawed cat. A year ago, she would have shrugged off her own thoughts, but she’s learned a thing or two about trusting her gut since then.
She pushes away from the wall, and gets her feet under her, ready to stand. “If you’re okay,” she says, “I’m gonna go back up on deck. I want to talk to Ria.”
“I’m fine.” It’s an automatic response, and it makes Emma want to stay. But they need a solution, not just comfort, and she knows without having to ask that he wouldn’t accept comfort for this anyway, not now that it’s over.
Killian tilts his head, an intense look on his eyes. “Sw—Emma. This stays between us, aye?”
“’course!” She’s a little offended he even has to say it. “Not my call to make. Hang on, I’ll be back in a bit.”
* * *
When she gets back on deck, she finds Henry where she left him, now telling a bemused Jim a story—she catches the words “Wolverine” and “Professor X”. Carswell, busy with some tackle nearby, is leaning over to listen with a smile tugging at his mouth.
Ria is over by the railing, talking to two of the crew. Once she turns away, Emma steps forward. “Captain? Can I talk to you a second?”
“Sure.” Ria looks expectant.
Emma hesitates, tries to find a diplomatic way to approach this, and gives up immediately. Ria hasn’t struck her as very diplomatic so far. “I have a request,” she says. “Give Hook his hook back. Please.”
Ria’s eyebrows rise halfway to her hairline. “You must be joking.”
“I’m not.” Emma takes a breath, trying to imagine what Snow would say. Except... she’s not sure Snow would be trying this in the first place. “I’m not. You should give it back. You basically took one of his hands away.”
“I took his weapons,” Ria says. She’s quite calm, her air more curious than anything else.
“That’s not—” Emma breaks off, shakes her head. “It’s not a weapon.”
“I’ve seen what he can do with that thing.”
“Yeah, well, I can punch someone with this,” Emma counters, making a fist with her left hand. “Or choke someone. But you didn’t take my hand. You didn’t take his hand, either, even though he can do plenty of damage with that.”
“Lot harder without any weapons,” Ria points out.
“Trust me, if he wanted to cause trouble, he’d find a way no matter what you took,” Emma says.
Ria tilts her head. “So you’re saying I shouldn’t have let him on my ship at all.”
“No, I’m saying...” It’s hard to hold onto her temper. Emma has never been good at calm, rational debate, but Ria is all cool logic. Infuriating. “You wouldn’t have let him on your ship if you didn’t trust him. You know taking his hook makes no difference.”
There’s a pause, as Ria regards her and Emma does her best to withstand that gaze. It’s moments like this that make it clear how and why Ria came to be captain.
“What is it?” Ria asks eventually. “You’re not his lover, not his captive, and you’re definitely not related. What hold does he have on you?”
“Nothing,” Emma says, hoping that the jolt that went through her at those words didn’t show on her face. “We’re... friends. Kinda. Like I said, he saved my life, and... look, I just get it, that’s all.”
“Get what?”
“That it’s—” She can’t mention what just happened. She can’t so much as imply that this is a problem for him. It galled him to admit this weakness to her, but she’s been trusted with it, and she’s going to guard it.
She hesitates, watching Ria. The captain reminds Emma of herself—before Henry, before her parents. Not cruel, but hard, protecting herself.
And Emma isn’t Emma right now. She’s Snow’s lady-in-waiting, Henry’s mother, someone’s wife. And maybe, just maybe, she can get through to Ria like Snow got through to her. She’s certainly someone who can admit to caring about the pirate who saved her life. “It’s his hand,” she says. “He insists that it’s fine, but I—I worry. We’re on a ship. What if something happened? Would you want that on your conscience?”
Ria regards her for another moment. Then she pulls Killian’s hook from a pocket of her coat, and turns it in her hand, watching the reflections in the metal. “Honestly, I just wanted to see if he’d surrender it,” she says matter-of-factly. “Didn’t think he would.”
She looks at Emma, those shrewd eyes narrow. “His ship, his hook... what hold do you have on him?”
Emma swallows. “Like I said. We’re friends.”
Ria’s eyebrows rise again, and for a second, she reminds Emma irresistibly of Regina, of that look she gets when she doesn’t believe a word but won’t say so. “Mhmm-hmm. Fine.” She holds the hook out. “I’m not giving it back to him, I’m giving it to you. Your choice what you do with it.”
Your responsibility, hangs unsaid at the end of her words.
Emma takes the hook from her, nodding. The metal is slightly warm from Ria’s body, the sight of it familiar, the feel of it less so. She hasn’t touched it often, and holding it in her hand feels intimate in a way she didn’t expect. Almost invasive.
“Thank you,” she says.
Killian is still in the cabin when she returns. He looks relaxed now, one leg out in front of him, the other drawn up with his elbow resting on his knee, brace hanging down.
He glances up as she enters, and she smiles at him. “Got something for you.”
And before he can ask, or make some kind of innuendo, or say anything at all, she crosses over to him and hands him the hook.
She has the rare pleasure of watching his jaw drop.
Then his eyes fly back to her face. “Swan, please tell me you didn’t just steal from the captain.”
“Steal?” She feigns outrage. “What do you take me for? No.”
“Then how...?”
“I asked her for it.” She shakes her head before he can ask. “Didn’t tell her anything, don’t worry. I just reminded her that, y’know. Disarming us is one thing, taking someone’s hand—or whatever...” She trails off, not sure if she just offended him or not.
He pauses in the act of reaching for the hook. “You just asked her.”
“Yeah.”
For a moment, he just stares at her. Then he shakes his head and takes the hook from her, face breaking into a smile. “You’re a marvel.”
The way he says it is both matter-of-fact and laced with fondness. He looks back up at her as he clicks it into the brace, those blue eyes finding and holding hers. “Thank you.”
For once, the sincerity in his gaze isn’t overwhelming, or uncomfortable. Emma nods, feeling like the world has shifted back into balance. For the first time in weeks, she feels like she has actually contributed something, done something for him that matters. Something he couldn’t do himself.
She stands a little straighter—she can’t help it—and grins at him as he gets to his feet. “Sure.”
His clothes rustle as he stands up, louder than usual in the small cabin. He looks taller, too, bigger somehow—or maybe that’s her memory of holding him, realising that her arms couldn’t quite span the width of his shoulders. He’s still smiling as he looks down at her, his eyes warm, and the air in the cabin seems to be in short supply all of a sudden.
How does he do that? It’s really annoying how that keeps happening. She can’t prevent it. She can’t even predict it. It’s like something just shifts, from one breath to the next, and just like that, she’s floundering. Hot and shivery all at once, her heartbeat picking up, feeling like she’s just run five miles. And above all, that damnable urge to step closer to him, like he’s some kind of human magnet.
She’s familiar with attraction; she’s been attracted to people before. Until a few months ago, she would have said that she’s basically immune to it if she wants, that she knows how to handle it, that it doesn’t affect her unless she lets it. This, though... this is not like any attraction she’s ever felt before. She’s starting to realise that she has no idea how to handle it.
Emma swallows, takes a step back, and hopes that it doesn’t look as awkward as she suddenly feels. “Come on. Let’s see if they’ve finished with the ghost stories.”
* * *
Tags as requested! @optomisticgirl @mariakov81 @courtorderedcake @tomeandflickcorner @spartanguard @snowbellewells @karl0ta @heavenlyjoycastle @queen-serena88 @stahlop @inkerii @therealstartraveller776 @bubblegum1425 @iamanneenigma @elegies @itsfabianadocarmo @winterbaby89 @kday426 @sals86 @superchocovian @pirateherokillian @laschatzi @scientificapricot @kmomof4 @thisonesatellite
62 notes
·
View notes
Fic Rec Bingo
Okie dokie, this is the Fan Rec Bingo - idea courtesy of lightvials on twitter, but I don’t have a twitter that I ever use, so I’m filling it out here instead. Let’s see if I can fill it all out!
I did, and then some. To save poor dashboards, it’s all under the cut! If I know author tumblrs they’ve been mentioned - I know pitifully few so if anyone knows the ones I don’t, let me know so I can mention them, too!
A fic you love without knowing the source material: The Dragon-King’s Temple by Kyral (Stargate SG-1/Avatar the Last Airbender)
Through the spite of the spirits or plain rotten chance, a door that would have been better left untouched has opened. On the other hand, with Fire and Earth as one's allies, sometimes escaping is the easy part.
Rated: Gen. AO3 Archive Warning for Graphic Descriptions of Violence.
Characters: Zuko, Toph Beifong, Janet Fraiser, Sam Carter, Jack O’Neill, and more
Words: 196311. Status: Complete
I very rarely read fics without already knowing the canon, but one that I think counts would be a Stargate/ATLA crossover, because I know nothing about Stargate and I have yet to finish ATLA! This was recommended to me due to the creativity of the author regarding a language barrier (something I always enjoy, and my friend knows that).
---
A fic series with a premise that shouldn’t work but it does: Crazy=Genius by blackkat (Bleach/Harry Potter)
Minerva McGonagall isn't about to let Harry go back to the Dursleys after his first year. She finds an alternative, and along the way, Bazzard Black finds that he might have more family left than he'd ever thought.
Rated: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings Apply
Characters: Bazz-B, Harry Potter, and more
Words: 21682. Status: Incomplete
Okay, I cheated and picked a series. Not my fault blackkat decided to make this universe a series of oneshots rather than a single entity and you’re certainly not getting me to only pick one of the five already published ones. Bazz-B being a Black and also kinda a wizard is a brilliant concept, and having him adopting Harry is pure gold. Not sure how crazy Quincy adopting poor, neglected Boy Who Lives works, but it does!
---
A fic you’ve reread several times: The Guardian (Director’s Cut) by SGTBrowncoat (Naruto)
Itachi Uchiha receives his first mission in ANBU: protecting a certain trouble making Jinchuriki. He bonds quickly with the boy, but dark forces rise to threaten Itachi, Naruto, and those they care for most.
Rated: T. Canon-typical violence
Characters: Uchiha Itachi, Uzumaki Naruto, Uchiha Shisui and more (includes Uchiha Itachi/Inuzuka Hana background pairing)
Words: 35945. Status: Complete
Back to my first ever fandom, here, and a really fun non-massacre AU fic, with lots of Itachi and Shisui goodness. There are a fair few ANBU-looking-after-kid-Naruto fics but this is by far my favourite of them! There is a sequel, but unfortunately it’s not finished and hasn’t been updated in a long time (I live in hope!)
---
A fic you still remember many years later: While The Ring Went South by Thundera Tiger (Lord of the Rings)
What happened after the Fellowship left Rivendell but before they came down off Caradhras? Behold the missing scenes.
Rated: K+. Canon-typical violence
Characters: Legolas, Gimli, Aragon, Gandalf, the whole Fellowship
Words: 149624. Status: Complete
I refound this fic completely by accident the other week, after first reading it (according to when I favourited it on FFN) in 2011! It was just as amazing as I remembered, and is really the standard I hold all other LotR fics to, especially ones that involve the entire, pre-Moria, Fellowship. It has a sequel but sadly that’s not been updated in some time (but again, I live in hope!)
---
A comfort fic: There May Be Some Collateral Damage by metisket (Bleach/Harry Potter)
Ichigo’s been ordered to go undercover at a magic school to bodyguard a kid named Harry Potter, and this would be fine, except that he’s about as good at bodyguarding as he is at magic. And he considers it a good day, magic-wise, if he hasn’t set anything on fire.
Rated: Gen. AO3 No Archive Warnings Apply
Characters: Kurosaki Ichigo, Harry Potter, Weasley Twins, and more.
Words: 61209. Status: Complete
I have no idea what this means by ‘Comfort Fic’ but if I want a laugh and Umbridge getting a pile of comeuppance, this is definitely the fic I’ll turn to. As the A/N says: ‘sending Ichigo to Hogwarts is basically the same as swinging a wrecking ball directly into the side of the castle’. Beautiful chaos is what we get. Beautiful, beautiful chaos.
---
A cathartic fic: See You Again by cookietosser (One Piece)
Rocinante has been through a lot in his life. Adding uncontrollable time travel into the mix? That's just the icing on the cake.
Rated: Teen. AO3 Violence and (canon) Character Death Warnings
Characters: Donquioxte Rocinante|Cora-san, Trafalgar Law, Heart Pirates
Words: 15755. Status: Complete
You want to rip my heart out and trample it into lots of little pieces while still making it all better because Law and Rocinante? Well, this little time-traveller’s wife AU fic is just the one for all that. Sad moments, frustrating moments, happy moments, all wrapped up in this oneshot!
---
A fic you’d print and put on your bookshelf: Thrower of the Dart by Vathara (Artemis Fowl/The Avengers)
What might have happened instead of Artemis Fowl book 6, if it'd happened in the Marvel Universe. Megalomaniacs ahoy!
Rated: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings
Characters: Artemis Fowl II, Tony Stark, and more
Words: 101272. Status: Complete
It’s long, it’s epic, and it would nestle in perfectly at home alongside my Artemis Fowl books on the bookshelf! It’s not so much a rewrite of book 6 as a complete replacement of it, with a new plot and an all too familiar villain!
---
A fic you associate with a song: Goodbye, Brother by Serena Estelle (Bleach)
Ilforte's final moments as I like to picture them-with his brother.
Rated: T. Canonical character death
Characters: Szayelaporro Granz, Yylfordt Granz
Words: 3073. Status: Complete
Might be cheating, because the author actually names a song in their starting A/N, but this definitely brings to mind Exile Vilify by The National, and I fully recommend listening to that (on loop - there is a 10-hour loop version on youtube) as you watch this for maximum tear-jerking effect.
---
A fic that inspires you: Magic of the Rose Cross by Awensweth (Harry Potter/D.Gray-Man)
In Harry's 4th year the Triwizard Tournament is brought back to live, but the appearance of a fourth mysterious school about which only Dumbledore seems to know brings new secrets with it for everyone. Who are the students of Rose Cross?
Rated: Mature. AO3 Chose Not To Use Warnings
Characters: Harry Potter, Allen Walker, and more
Words: 66632. Status: Incomplete
I have been inspired by many, many fics, but I chose this one in particular because it was the main one that inspired me to join the HP/DGM Triwizard Tournament wave of the early 2010s - indeed, The Combat School is one of my most popular fics, but without this and other fics of the trope, I probably would never have written it! That’s not to say I’ve copied this fic - aside from the base trope I tried my best to make my own work unique against the others, and hope that I succeeded! Sadly, this fic is incomplete and hasn’t been updated for some time, but it’s still worth a read.
---
A fic that brought you on board a new ship: Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell by MsChunks (Boku no Hero Academia)
Uraraka and Bakugo have a secret. It’s not what their classmates think it is.
Rated: Teen. AO3 Chose Not To Use Warnings
Characters: Bakugo Katsuki, Uraraka Ochako
Words: 182478. Status: Complete
Putting Bakugo and Uraraka together was something I’d never considered, and I started this fic with some trepidation after a friend recommended it to me, but said friend has never steered me wrong with fics and didn’t start now! Fake dating, Uraraka actually being badass, the most terrifying couple in class 1-A? That’s this fic.
---
A fic you wish could be a movie: Mission Impossible by Loopstagirl (Thunderbirds)
Being selected for his first solo mission should have been exciting for Captain Scott Tracy of the Air Force. But there was something else at play. Something dangerous and deadly. Something that could cost him more than his life.
Rating: T. Warnings: Violence
Characters: Scott Tracy, Gordon Tracy
Words: 55048. Status: Complete
Air Force!Scott? W.A.S.P.!Gordon? On a joint mission together? Yes, gimme, gimme, gimme. Gimme Scott’s awkwardness alone on a boat of WASP personnel, gimme Gordon’s horror when he realises the suicide mission pilot is his older brother, and now give that all to me on screen! And we can’t forget the Hood, of course! Might be a bit higher rating than the current Thunderbirds stuff, but hey, I’m old enough. Gimme.
---
A fic that led to you becoming friends with the author: The Gabriel Project by Aceidia (Bleach) - @thetwelvecaesars
When Szayelaporro knew Aizen's reign in Heuco Mundo was coming to a close, he took matters into his own brilliant hands. He reincarnates himself and the other nine Espadas into a new life full of surprising turns and irony. Yet, the harmony and ignorance is not forever as they begin to remember.
Rating: M (violence)
Characters: Szayelaporro Granz, the Espada
Words: 116030. Status: Complete
Well, this fic sparked off a friendship that’s still very much there, even if neither of us write much for Bleach any more! What started off as a challenge to identify who the Espada were turned into essay-length PMs about anything and everything, and then RP groups and now random emails about whatever at random times of the day (different timezones don’t help)!
---
A fic you’ve gushed about irl: Living Like Kings by CLynnB (Thunderbirds)
The world wants to know more about the Tracy brothers. So Lady Penelope takes it upon herself to show the world just who they are. Through YouTube.
Rating: Gen. AO3 Author Chose Not To Use Warnings
Characters: Lady Penelope-Creighton-Ward, Tracy Family (background Pen/Ink, Scayo, Virg/Brains)
Words: 35348. Status: Complete
I love social media fics like this one, and my poor boyfriend got the brunt of it while we were on holiday... he knows basically nothing about Thunderbirds except for what he’s heard from me (which is a lot because he’s amazing and lets me gush). I mean, Tracy boys playing “The Floor Is Lava?” and tackling each other to the ground? Gimme.
---
A fic you associate with a place: Thunderbirds Meet Thunderbirds - Alan trip in to the movie verse by ak47stylegirl (Thunderbirds) @ak47stylegirl
Crazy stuff always happens to Tracys, don't they? Add felling into a different world to the list.
Rating: Gen. AO3 No Archive Warnings
Characters: Alan Tracy, Tracy Family times two
Words: 25599. Status: Incomplete
This might be a little random, but this fic was one that I found while I was ill on holiday to the Lake District last autumn. Sadly, it’s the only trip there I’ve ever done where I couldn’t climb a single fell (and my car’s clutch burnt out after having to reverse up a pass... thanks bus coming the other way), and this fic’s updates while I was there kept me sane! This has actually very loosely inspired a fic of my own which is in the making - which might get posted in the next year if I’m lucky... Still waiting eagerly for this fic’s next update :D
---
A fic that made you gasp out loud: The Colours Of The World by MaiKusakabe (Fullmetal Alchemist/Harry Potter)
When Roy Mustang went to retrieve his eyesight from Truth, he wasn’t expecting to end up doing a job in exchange. It couldn’t even be an easy job, of course, because Edward’s assessment of Truth was a pretty accurate one.
Rating: Mature. AO3 No Archive Warnings (but watch for canon-typical violence)
Characters: Roy Mustang, Albus Dumbledore, Sirius Black, and more
Words: 120578. Status: Incomplete
Badass Roy yesss. Twists and turns and Truth is a pretentious you-know-what but Voldemort’s even worse so where does that leave poor Roy except caught in the middle and very much a war veteran at this point... much to the horror of a few wizards!
---
A fic you found at the right time: Seafaring Heartless: Exit North Blue by Avian Swallow (One Piece)
Pirates may be considered evil by the majority, but Law had met quite a few of the world's navy who were corrupt to the core and putting up a very thick facade. He reasoned that if he was going to manipulate and scheme his way into that goal, at least he was going to be honest enough to admit it.
Rating: T. Canon-typical situations
Characters: Trafalgar Law, Bepo, Penguin, Shachi, Heart Pirate OCs
Words: 159644. Status: Complete
Is there ever a ‘wrong time’ to find a fic? (a 100k+ at 4am debatable, but shh). When I craved Heart Pirate content, this fic (and its sequel, still in progress but updating) appeared! Only loosely clings to canon at the moment, thanks to some SBS revelations, but with well developed OCs to fill the faces we have no names or personalities for at the moment!
---
A fic that you would read fic of: Only a Boy by Riddle Lee (Harry Potter/Merlin)
Merlin has changed Camelot forever but while that part of his life is complete, destiny has a new task for him. Now he has to attend Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, hide the fact that he's the Merlin, and defeat a Dark Lord that's messing with magic he knows nothing about.
Rating: T. Canon-typical situations
Characters: Merlin, Draco Malfoy, Hermione Granger, and more
Words: 340998. Status: Incomplete
An amazing universe with Slytherin!Merlin, no Harry Potter/Boy Who Lived, and the good old ‘hiding real identity’ trope to underpin the whole series. Currently just into the start of Merlin’s third year at Hogwarts, aka “The Prisoner of Azkaban”. This universe has so much to give, although Riddle Lee is doing a fantastic job at it. It’s incomplete and slow to update but does update!
---
A fic that made you laugh out loud: HOW’S THE COMA GOING by ossicle (One Piece)
Kidd and Penguin keep trying to murder each other and Law is done with their shit. He assigns them to take care of each other’s injuries so they’ll learn to get along. It doesn’t work.
Rating: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings
Characters: Eustass Kid, Penguin, Trafalgar Law (background KidLaw)
Words: 2062. Status: Complete
Oh this one had me in stitches basically the whole time. Kid’s bedside manner should not be mimicked in the slightest, but a beautiful bonding fic in typical pirate fashion - beat ‘em up ‘til they have your approval. Poor, poor, Law.
---
A fic with a line (or two) that you’ve memorised by heart: On Their Side by Gumnut (Thunderbirds) - @gumnut-logic
She trusted these boys with a great deal.
Rating: Teen. AO3 No Warnings Apply
Characters: Colonel Casey, Virgil Tracy, Gordon Tracy
Words: 1116. Status: Complete
I think I have basically the entire thing memorised. This one also falls into several other categories, most notably ones that made me laugh and ones that I’ve reread several times, but it really belongs here on this list.
---
A fic that gave you butterflies: it’s a long way forward so trust in me by aloneintherain (Miraculous Ladybug)
Six times Marinette carried Adrien (plus one time he carried her).
Rating: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings
Characters: Adrien Agreste|Chat Noir, Marinette Dupain-Cheng|Ladybug (all sides of the love square)
Words: 5611. Status: Complete
Aaah I have a weak spot for strong!Marinette and this fic ticks that box time and time again, with a side of blushing!Adrien and general love-struck Adrien/Chat. I mean, what more could a girl need?
---
A fic that embodies something you value in life: Team Itachi by Killer of thy Cookies (Naruto)
What if the Third Hokage stopped the council before they could order Itachi to commit the Uchiha Clan Massacre? Itachi is one of the village's strongest ninja, and has now been given the task of being a Jonin sensei, assigned to Team 7 with his little brother Sasuke, the 'dead last' Naruto Uzumaki, and fangirl Sakura Haruno. This is Team Itachi.
Rating: T. Canon-typical situations
Characters: Uchiha Itachi, Uchiha Sasuke, Uzumaki Naruto, Haruno Sakura, and more
Words: 155092. Status: Complete
(Yup, another non-massacre AU.) Loyalty. Honestly, there are so many fics that have loyalty in them, especially in fandoms like Naruto, where loyalty is a pretty big thing anyway (alongside friendship, of course), but this one is Itachi staying openly loyal to the village because Sarutobi actually saved the clan, and of course lovely bonds between the team!
---
A favourite AU: A Son By Any Other Name by carryonstarkid (Thunderbirds)
Cursed as a child, Scott Tracy lives a life in which everyone he encounters must follow all of his given commands.
Rating: Teen. AO3 Chose Not To Use Warnings
Characters: Scott Tracy, Tracy Brothers, Kayo Kyrano, and more
Words: 83429. Status: Complete
I rarely read AU fics - my preferred sandbox is the canon one, or a nice slice of canon diversion, rather than completely taking characters out of their home and dumping them somewhere entirely new. This fairytale AU, however - reminding me very much of Sleeping Beauty except instead of sleeping it’s, well, what the summary says - is fantastically well done and addresses the strain such a thing would put on even the closest of family relationships.
---
A fic you stayed up too late to finish reading: As N Approaches Infinity by Corisanna (Bleach/Puella Magi Madoka Magica)
Despairing as yet another timeline goes horribly wrong, Homura wanders into Karakura. There she discovers that while the spiritually-aware people of Karakura were distracted by Ichigo Kurosaki and Xcution, Kyubey had managed to contract the Kurosaki sisters as magical girls. Drawing the attention of the shinigami could be just the advantage Homura needs.
Rating: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings but watch out for canon-typical situations for both fandoms (especially Madoka)
Characters: Akemi Homura, Kurosaki Karin, Kurosaki Yuzu, Urahara Kisuke, and many more
Words: 465297. Status: Incomplete
There are many fanfictions that have kept me up til dawn. Many. This one, however, has literally robbed me of all my sleep and I’ve still been unable to finish it in one sitting. It’s good, the pacing is fantastic, and with Homura as our leading lady, that means those time resets really hit hard when they happen (and they happen. They really, really, happen). Might be incomplete, but is still updating - and there’s plenty to keep you occupied in the meantime!
---
A fic that made you feel seen: A Seed Once Grown by Darkestwolfx (Thunderbirds) - @darkestwolfx
Believe it or not, they did have a garden on Tracy Island. It looked a little like a… tip. And that was being kind.
Rating: Teen. AO3 No Archive Warnings
Characters: Ned Tedford, Tracy Family
Words: 4785. Status: Complete
Okay, so I’m taking this literally because I spend a lot of time feeling invisible on the internet so having a fic written for me from someone I’d barely spoken to before was a whole pile of screaming. Not that it’s the first time someone’s written a fic for me, but the other ones have been done by friends I’d already known for some time, and not someone in a fandom I’m just starting to find my feet in.
---
Free space: whoo boy, fun time! There are a few fics on the top of my head that didn’t fill any of the above prompts (or got beaten to the punch by another), so my wildcard space is going to be a few fic links without the extra detail because I’ve already spent about 12 hours on this to get to this point (did I get sidetracked and re-read a bunch? You bet) and I’d quite like to also get some fic written today, too!
Eight-Day Week (JoJo Spotting) by TrufflestheMushroom (JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure)
The Trouble With Eastern by teaandtumblr (One Piece)
Remembrance by ClioSelene (One Piece)
Legacy by MaiKusakabe (One Piece)
A Fleeting Smile by AnonymousTwit (Boku no Hero Academia)
Too Loud For Comfort by vaporeon_ninja (Boku no Hero Academia)
A Dragon’s Hoard by Chezka (Boku no Hero Academia)
Nine Lives by P_Artsypants (Miraculous Ladybug)
Chat’s Eye View (Love Letters To Paris) by Icka M Chif (Miraculous Ladybug)
Gabriel’s Lament by Chaotic Neutral (Miraculous Ladybug)
What The Cat Dragged In by Kyral (Avengers/Miraculous Ladybug)
Weekend Warrior by BlackDog_66 (Avengers)
Fitting In (Tiny Spaces) by aloneintherain (Avengers)
Autonomy by beetlebee (Naruto)
Great Minds by ScreamingViking (Final Fantasy VII)
Dear Kunsel by Sinnatious (Final Fantasy VII)
Cracks in the knight by authorettejasmin (Magic Kaito)
To Wrap An Elvish Princeling by Jael (Lord of the Rings)
There are more, many more, and I’ll probably post a few more recs around - you can also find some on my blog and I’ll try and get that updated with a few more at some point because there are many more than that!
16 notes
·
View notes