#precedent analysis
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
They just don't make the Doctor pregnant by putting a child in his leg like they used to
#if The Blue Angel were not so firmly an EDA it would be a smash hit with the New Weird fans#I say 'would' like I'm not an aforementioned weird fiction fan who enjoyed Blue Angel#to the extent that it can be said to be about any one thing I think the Blue Angel is about crossover fanfic*#(this is not some deep analysis this is outright stated pretty much)#*and also a different but similar approach to Unnatural History#Daedelus wonders if there can be anyone else who enjoys bringing together wildly different universes with no thought towards copyright#infringement; Canine tells Fitz nothing takes precedence between different stories (including the one the characters see as the Real World)#because they're all equally made up#doctor who#the blue angel#edas
124 notes
·
View notes
Text
Tbh a huge amount of the issues MHA has could have been fixed had Bakugo just been expelled from UA in the first season or not gotten in at all
#izuku's other friends like ochako tenya etc could have gotten more screentime and development#the todoroki arc wouldve had more space to flesh out all the siblings and give shouto a more obvious personality#the precedent of excusing abuse wouldnt be there so i think ppl would be less sympathetic to endeavour which is GROSS#aizawa and the rest of the ua staff look better as teachers as theyre not just letting a pr nightmare and bully run around unchecked#the 'bakusquad' can be given more space to be their own characters and bond wo being rotted by their attachment to bakugo#shinsou could have actual development instead of being one dimensional and annoying and grow into his potential as izuku's rival/foil#less bakugo screentime also means more time for the plot to develop#and im hoping the characters could develop their abilitie sin unique and more consistent ways wo the constant need to make bakugo the best-#screwing everything up#including izuku keeping his analysis abilities etc#thats just off the top of my head#izuku midoriya#bakugo katsuki#anti bakugo katsuki#anti bakugo#mha#my hero academia#mha critical#my hero academia critical
181 notes
·
View notes
Text
I think quite often of the optional little dialogue tree that one can get about Yaevinn in TW2 with an imported save if one sides with Iorveth, and particularly of just how Iorveth describes Yaevinn
The dialogue prompt "I once knew another Scoia'tael - Yaevinn." will lead to the following exchange:
GERALT: I once met another Scoia'tael leader.
IORVETH: Yaevinn. I knew him. He had beautiful dreams and desperately wanted me to share them. Asked the same of you, I heard.
GERALT: You know a lot about me.
IORVETH: I try to know as much as I can - about everyone.
They'll elaborate a little further in this dialogue about how they both agree with Yaevinn's reasons and the fact that Yaevinn "saw combat and killing as poetry" which Iorveth deems unrealistic because "war is prose, with no place for beauty" (how poetic).
But the interesting part to me is the statement that Yaevinn had "beautiful dreams" and how he was this grand idealist, because this seems to be in contradiction with Yaevinn's characterisation. In his novel appearance, he argues against Toruviel's idealism as he proposes shooting the unarmed messenger. In TW1, Geralt refers to him in his journal as being "disillusioned", as well as being "a cynic and a pragmatist", neither of which seem to hold with Iorveth's account. While this can be credited to the fact that it's possible that Iorveth's past-tense statement of "I knew him" means that he hasn't seen Yaevinn in some time rather than, or at least in addition to, the implied death. He has perhaps not seen him since the Second Northern War, where they were both in the Vrihedd brigade, and Yaevinn could have grown more cynical since the Scoia'tael were betrayed by Dol Blathanna, his earliest characterisation is that of the novel canon, and he does not present a particular idealism that would reflect the notion that he is a dreamer.
It can be taken as a choice of characterisation, because for all that Yaevinn is disillusioned, he does have his hopes and desires for the future and his plans at Vizima, just as Iorveth has his hopes for Saskia and Vergen. He has these dreams, even if he tenders them close to his chest and puts the practical aspects first before he allows himself to have this hope. And I think that is a really interesting interpretation, to have this juxtaposition, that he can be both disillusioned and a dreamer, and that he chose a scant few, Iorveth, and then Geralt, to share in those precious dreams.
The notion of Yaevinn having these "beautiful dreams" is also very pertinent to his TW1 characterisation, I think, because there are optional dialogues in which Yaevinn tells the accounts of how he once lived among humans and believed in assimilation, that the humans would accept the elves if given enough time, only to be persecuted and harassed at length until he finally accepted that there was no place for him there, that there could be no assimilation, only annihilation. And even though he knows it is a hopeless fight, he still proceeds onward. He knows his people are dying, and he knows that if they do not act quickly, they will be well and truly doomed to extinction, but he is still trying to fight. That is, in and of itself, an expression of a dream for a better future, even if he thinks it hopeless, or, as Iorveth criticises, unrealistic.
Serious character analysis aside, I think that the absolute funniest interpretation of this dialogue is that it is not to be taken literally about Yaevinn's idealism or lack thereof, but rather as a euphemism -- taking "beautiful dreams" as a euphemism for queer romantic interest; hence "he had beautiful dreams and desperately wanted me to share them" is something like "he likes men and asked me to be his lover", "I hear he asked the same of you" thenceforth meaning something like "were you also his lover/do you also like men" (and the response "you know a lot about me" therefore indicating that he is correct in his judgement). There's like a whole rebellion going on but Iorveth is just checking out his options, y'know.
#rambles#the witcher#the witcher games#yaevinn#iorveth#geralt of rivia#funnily enough this is the real reason i made this blog#to post rambling long-form content#and give my poor long-suffering partner a break from listening to me#i love them to bits they deserve some respite#so now the whole of the internet gets the dubious honour of seeing this i guess#i am posting this instead of working on my latest drawing tbh#yaevinn my beloved#i have many thoughts about him#some of it is serious character analysis and whatnot#some of it is just silly#but he is on my mind very often#i like this style of verbose euphemisms#both the historical precedent and joking things like this#'he has beautiful dreams' could be right up there with 'he's friends with lambert'
151 notes
·
View notes
Text
Oh hi there transfem discussing her experience in the trans community i just had a quick question about your post
What does tme mean?
Oh okay i see i understand, thank you.
What does transmisogyny mean?
Ah I see, I get it.
What's a trans woman?
Oof scary. One last question.
What's a woman?
Thank you for being my own personal google (not like you had anything better to do right?) and derailing the point of your post for my own personal education. I will now add nothing of value to this post in return. Bye bye!
#channel 3#ignore me i'm bitching#it's just like. somehow the word tme/tma magnetizes people who refuse to do a second of thinking EVERY SINGLE TIME#like on one hand i almost feel bad for bitching#because generally if someone is unaware enough to ask theyre probably not aware of the precedent of multiple tme people asking on every post#what tme/tma means#BUT ALSO it happens so often it straight up feels like it's intentional#and like even if you don't want to look it up i feel like it's easy to guess by context clues#but like regardless of that#could you imagine going to literally any other discussion like that and asking them to define basic terms#'hi thank you for sharing your math thesis with us. just one question what does that t shaped symbol mean? this one: +'#'hi thank you for your in depth analysis of whether the cubs win this year. just one question. what's baseball'#'hi thank you for this in depth character analysis. just one question. what's a book?'#like in all of these cases we can agree that either a. they're a bad actor or b. they're not doing the bare minimum to engage with the post#why is it that people think it's still okay to do that on posts by transfeminists? (<- knows the answer)#(also i'm sure this also happens to cisfeminists but i think more people know better than that now)#like. if you do this i don't think you're evil or like transmisogyny incarnate or whatever but like. in the nicest way#i want you to think through what you expected to happen with. like sincerely and ask yourself was this productive to anyone#did this add anything of use to the post or to anyone else#explaining tme/tma doesn't add use to the post because transfems have explained it billions of times elsewhere#and knowing what it means is generally the bare minimum for interacting with a post discussing transmisogyny#so who does it help to ask? further who does it hurt to ask? in what context might my question be taken?#whagever who give a shit
27 notes
·
View notes
Text
A lot of mariadeline fics have Adeline be the one to die first. Which yeah, makes sense that Maria would kill herself after major tether to this Earth perishes. But consider!! The tragedy of Maria killing herself before Adeline dies.
Lady Maria always prioritizes herself (and how own issues/faults) to the detriment to her understanding of others. I'd argue this is why she never notices Gehrman's mania despite it being pretty obvious (I doubt the Doll was the first time he pulled such an act.) I wouldn't be surprised, therefore, that she in her overwhelming guilt and shame over her own actions, she forgets the connections she does have on Earth and the people who would miss her when she's gone.
Idk, this was inspired by how in the Hunter's Nightmare, when you first encounter Saint Adeline she asks if you were Maria, but climbing the Clocktower Maria is currently dead (until she is Not). More likely, the fics are right but again, it's a fun tragic fanfic concept to explore.
#mariadeline#Saint Adeline#lady maria of the astral clocktower#bloodborne#d musings#a lot of my maria analysis really focuses on the narrative builds her introduction#Her reputation precedes her from even the main game#where you get BabyGirl Doll and an allusion that that might not be true (Hunter's bone)#then you get into the hall and everyone there cries for a lady maria#while living in horrible conditions#there are lumenflowers every where and the corpses of the dead are used to feed them#you meet Adeline and she asks for her only to be like no you're not her but it feels like personal disappointment#then you get into the Clocktower and it's like. Ah.#really good presentation for a character that haunts the narrative I say#if only they didn't make the clocktower so empty and so obviously a boss arena 100% certain it wasn't in life
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
Oreos
Andeos
Noteos
Xoreos
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
godd i'm so. compelled. by the audio in this show. i'm finally allowing myself a re-watch, now that school is out of session, and i finally got to 'the ladder' episode. and i noticed that, right after sir john gets thrown down the ice hole, that the audio gets strangely muffled.
almost like it's underwater. the only thing that isn't muffled is the music in the background.
#that and the fact that it's preceded by another piece with a 3/4 meter much like the first music we hear in the show#like on the one hand the audio distortion happens after fitzjames and company find sir john's leg#so on the one hand it could very much be an auditory distortion of what people are going through. how the stress makes everything slippery.#distorted.#but it could also be a representation of the location of his grave.#his death is preceded by a lot of other scalar motion in a 3/4- esque time meter. which is the same meter as the music that we first hear#it's not like. a waltz really. it's missing the characteristic weight of the meter#but it is tonal. or at least tonal-adjacent.#and i wonder if that's a representation of the last vestiges of british civilization dying in that moment#bc when all is normal we have a similar tonal-ish slant. but when sir john is off-screen there is very little of that same sound.#the rest of it has much more unusual harmony and little to no harmonic movement#very experimental and drone-esque.#this is all very off the top of my head with little to no serious music theory analysis. esp bc most of this is decidedly post-tonal#idk. it's compelling. bc i'm pretty sure after sir john dies all of that scalar movement and tonal-ish melodic structuring goes away#sorry this is literally just me rotating the audio of the show in my brain but out loud now. just rambling and throwing out ideas#before they're fully formed#but they are ideas.#the terror
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
"A developed affinity certainly furthered the queen’s own political position, but the institutional ties between the king and the queen’s households enabled the queen to remain an important influence in the political arena. Furthermore, the extension of the queen’s influence and holdings did not solely benefit the queen. Rosemary Horrox has argued that Elizabeth Woodville’s networks and influence across East Anglia were so extensive that her dominance there was considered the main source of royal authority in the region. Moreover, Joanna Laynesmith has identified that when the queen was successful in administering her estates, she ultimately facilitated the king’s own administration in creating a vast spread of royal influence."
-Katia Wright, "A Dower for Life: Understanding the Dowers of England's Medieval Queens", Later Plantagenet and Wars of the Roses Consorts: Power, Influence, and Dynasty
#historicwomendaily#elizabeth woodville#my post#It's nice to see an analysis of EW as a queen whose successful administration facilitated and strengthened royal authority as a whole#rather than merely 'a Woodville' promoting her family#These two identities of hers would have undoubtedly overlapped but that's the point - they overlapped#They weren't distinct or separate from each other because the Woodvilles were ultimately 'part of the royal connection'#Of course at the same time it would be incorrect to ignore the novelty of EW's natal family's presence and effect on her queenship/#administration/patronage - which set the precedent for all future English queens.#(EW also had major interest in the Exeter lands - you can tell by her marriage maneuvers for her eldest son and eldest grandson)#(In 1469 she herself was placed fourth in line to those lands; in 1476 she received an additional annuity from its fee-farms; etc)
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
If I have learned anything in life, it’s that the Single Handsome Boy who does Bad Things will be adored.
Regardless of morality or level of Bad Things.
I think I want to call it The Ted Bundy Precedent.
#this post is inspired by#yoon gwi nam#specifically#I have filters up for reader fics#and gwi nam’s tag is so full of them I had to scroll for a while#to get to any gifs from the show or analysis or anything#(longer than I remember for any other character)#(this includes Steve Harrington)#these are real people but kpop idol tags are also gross offenders and a huge reason why I keep the filters)#it never fails#I will also accept The Edward Cullen Precedent#or The Dabi Precedent#but I like The Ted Bundy Precedent because it shows how this is not a new concept#I wonder if there are any other earlier examples of this?#or what the psychology behind it is?#I’m not gonna take a moral stance on the precedent because to me that would be like taking a stance on gravity#it’s gonna happen#I do hope people know that you are thirsting after a guy who literally threw people to zombie hordes to get what he wanted#this is not the guy who is going to give you a good experience#or put you first or take care of your needs or anything#he would Fuck You Up and not in a fun way#(also gwi nam is a high school student so some of these imaginings are fucked up on even if he weren’t a literal psychopath just saying)#they usually don’t but#as long as people know that fantasies do not make a good partner#and you shouldn’t pick them because of it#then I guess it’s fine#just buck wild#philosophy takes#bad boy syndrome#current status
26 notes
·
View notes
Note
if you want appropriate relationships out of asoiaf… go watch disney chanel, they minght give you what jonsa won’t
There’s a difference between understanding and enjoying a fictional toxic relationship that a writer has specifically set up to serve a narrative purpose, and actively wanting characters you like to end up in a fucked up relationship.
#the canon toxic romantic relationships r meant to be critiqued. and r not grrm saying hey this is justified btw#they r not there to set a precedent#like….that’s basic literary analysis i’m afraid#asks
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
i get this feeling that like, reading the apothecary diaries as mainly a romance series is going to mess with your expectations of the story because (1) i think trying to map certain romance archetypes/plotlines onto it will be misleading, and (2) it really is the slowest burn i have personally ever read...
this is in large part because even though the story pivots around maomao and jinshi, so much of the story including past the manga into the light novels is about maomao's emotional growth and jinshi's imperial court politics - which is to say, not only or even primarily their romance. if anything, it's more about the journey of two people to eventually become the right partners for each other with crumbs of growing chemistry along the way. but it's not about them getting together, because so much of the story is maomao getting herself entangled in mysteries and situations that test (and overwhelm) her desire to remain emotionally distant, that teach her more about the nuances of humanity and her own heart. the mystery and political intrigue elements are still the primary driving force behind the narrative, so i feel like framing the story as a romance will make you expect romantic genre conventions that don't really map properly onto the actual series.
don't get me wrong, the slow burn romance is ABSOLUTELY a massive part of why i burned through the published english light novel volumes in 3 weeks, but i think being able to stop and appreciate how gratifying it is to see maomao grow beyond her grumpy "i don't want to get involved or get attached to anyone" disposition thanks to all the friends she makes and people she meets....... it's so lovely. and it does make her more able to respond to jinshi at that. anyway yeah. i do have qualms about stuff here and there, but i love this series damn
#a jesst#my jessays#this is very disorganized and weak it will not go into the tags until i feel more confident about what im trying to say ahaha#but idk reading some of the anime reactions has me like. dang someone selling this as a romance to u seems to be warping ur expectations?#if anything it's a bit detective conan-y where there's def romance but the mysteries and overarching plot take precedence#the apothecary diaries#kusuriya analysis#knh analysis#maomao#jinshi#jinmao#edit 3/5/24: added tags for my own organization lol it's been long enough that ppl may not find this in the tags easily anymore#anyway this was in fact me reacting to ppl watching or reading knh as if it's a romance and it's like. idk i feel like that just sets up the#wrong genre expectations and messes with one's ability to appreciate it as is but what do i know
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm admiring how this dream arc in Till the End of the Moon has the same vibe as a Greek tragedy. Like would communication solve everything? Yes. Are we surprised that they're not communicating? No. The characters' actions perfectly suit this narrative and we're just enjoying the painful ride.
#we don't watch tragedies expecting a happy ending#maybe setting that tragic precedent early on was key to the audience not throwing up their hands in rage#tteotm#till the end of the moon#cdrama#narrative analysis
33 notes
·
View notes
Note
Lewis got 5 sec penalty in the race and the FIA also add 2 points penalty to his license but as far as the news goes for now, Mercedes didn't seem to appeal the decision. And Toto said they won't appeal for the 5 sec penalty because it's just little points. I'm new to F1 but i thought that Toto would at least appeal the 2 points to the license, that seems a bit harsh? Or no? Any thoughts, please.
toto is a study in austrian genetics research how one can grow to 8ft without having a spine 🤷♀️
#I'm not the person for technical race analysis I'm sorry anon you're better off asking people who know their shit#but I'll never miss a free oppo to diss torger#you bet you azz Aston's legal team would have an entire precedence legal doc rn#blorbocedes ask#toto wolff (derogatory)
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
i love how passionate and emotional fic seongjoong is when irl they're like... an arranged marriage... lol
#not to say that they don't like each other or anything but. atz in particular seem quite aware (and not hiding it) of the practice of#ships -- not as in 'fans produce fanworks of you' but rather 'fans like your dynamics! play it up a little'#and the leader + the second 'highest' member are almost always shipped together as the 'mom' and 'dad'#which kind of doesn't make sense because a marriage usually precedes having children but in kpop is like. well here's a group and you're#two eldest members so you automatically get the mom/dad positions. sometimes it works -- whether automatically or because the#aforementioned members feel the need to take care of other members as they're the eldest -- but sometimes the dynamic is clearly#just there for the fans. and i can't help but notice that a whole bunch of 'moments' in 'seongjoong compilations' are like... not authentic#moments of them enjoying their time together but them being awkward/having awkward banter/doing fanservice during fanmeetings#and that's Different from the organic air ie woosan have#this is not to make fun of seongjoong fans because I PERSONALLY put very dramatic seongjoong in my hashtag Fic Verse#but then my fic verse was kickstarted because of that hwalazia magic and a single line in atz diary from fever 1. so it is. shall we say.#not particularly canon-inspired.#but i WOULD kill and die for every single fanfiction in which seongjoong aren't romantic sweethearts at the first sight but rather Struggle#i feel like Struggling is this... sort of a facet of their Brand... and so is mutually taking care of each other lol#they're like. this arranged marriage couple who grew to care about each other. not like 'oh shit two months in i realized i'm incredibly in#love with my spouse!' but 'yeah yknow what i like you here. stay'#good afternoon everyone enjoy this meandering and probably incorrect analysis of a relationship between two kpop lads#shrimp thoughts
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
shes got the prettiest smile <33
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
a fair amount of important buildings in the videogame fallout new vegas are non-euclidian. here is a pair of images that i have made to function as an analysis of the tops casino from over head and a hypothesis as to how the upper floors of the building got seperated from the reception area on the exterior, using two different in-game renditions of the building for comparison, with the former being more intact than the latter. most people are more familiar with the latter however, because it is how the building appears on street level from the street of the new vegas strip.
#my text posts#fallout#fallout new vegas#so the scope of me modding the buildings in new vegas has expanded into analysis of how the buildings in new vegas became non-euclidian#my new vegas analysis#making these images made me consider that the tops presidential suite was actually inside of a basement#to which there's precedent for as there is a series of sub-basements connecting this building to the adjacent vault hotel#which is how benny fucking skedaddles after he finds out you're on to him
5 notes
·
View notes