What We Did Not Heed║ ⓛⓘⓜⓘⓣⓔⓓ ⓢⓔⓡⓘⓔⓢ
| What We Did Not Heed | part of the Whistle in the Dark collection
║ series masterlist ║ main masterlist ║
| PAIRING(s): Joel Miller x married!fem!OC
| RATING: explicit material | 18+
| WORD COUNT: 12k
| CONTENT: moderate discussions of verbal, emotional, and physical abuse, infidelity (husband cheating on wife), brief mention of sewer slide, Joel is straight up delirious for the coochie meow meow, mild misuse and exploitation of italicized font, husband is heinous as usual, generous heap of angst and feelings, no cucking in this installment so if that’s the only thing you came for imma be a real one and let you know upfront we got some nasty nasty filth but no cucking for this one
| SYNOPSIS:
Doubts plague your mind as you try to work up the courage to end your marriage. Joel seeks to ease your apprehension, but he doesn’t know all that’s at play. In the midst of indecision, you both fail to notice what lurks in the waters, and when the tide finally recedes you’ll have no choice but to confront what lies beneath.
Joel had signed up for the patrol trip when he saw your name on the roster. You weren’t expecting him to take the assignment, one that meant he’d be leaving Ellie with Tommy and Maria for almost an entire week. Joel was still your designated patrol partner, but these irregular expeditions didn’t always align with the usual given pairings for scheduled patrols.
You have a sneaking suspicion that Joel pulled a few strings with Tommy to get paired with you because your partner had been changed to him at the last minute. It made your chest tight when you thought of his inclination to keep you close by. To be with you. To make sure you were safe.
It also left you with an ample dose of guilt that he was leaving Ellie in capable but still different hands than his own. You wonder if she can tell there’s something burgeoning within him, quickly outmaneuvering his ability to remain stoic and cryptic when trying to conceal something. Or, rather, someone. You. Trying to keep the two of you a secret.
You wonder how Ellie would feel if she knew about you encroaching on her family, assimilating it into your life as if you had any right to do so. You wouldn’t blame her for rejecting the idea. Who wouldn’t be selfish about keeping Joel to themselves?
Said man shifted his weight on the couch behind you, stirring you from your worries. You angle what you hope is a furtive glance in his direction. You follow the beautiful curve of his distinct nose, the prominent bridge flowing smoothly into the tip. The tip you loved as it nestled into the crevices of your neck and shoulders. The tip that made your breath catch when it nosed past your earlobe. The tip that dragged across your face with every fiery kiss you could steal.
“I’m gonna turn redder’n the devil’s dick if you don’t quit all that starin’,” Joel drawls, obviously amused at your complete failure to be discreet.
You straighten with a jerk at being found out and catch the curve of a smirk on his lips before returning your gaze out the window. You look down on the landscape below as you hear Joel chuckle to himself. The location you’d been assigned to was an unbelievable gem nestled just so along the mountainside. And by gem, you mean it wasn’t entirely dilapidated and smelling of mold.
The last of the sun’s rays were dancing in the sky, ebbing slowly into impending nightfall. The calm breeze of the early evening sounded like a lullaby, singing to and soothing all the living things settling down as daylight hours dwindled. Your mind starts to wander again as the conclusion of your shift draws closer.
Almost enough ration slips to cover the basics for two months. That’s what you’d amassed in your numerous extra patrol shifts you’d been snatching up left and right. Anything to get you out of the house as often as possible. You’d covered for just about everybody for any reason under the sun - calling out sick, didn’t want to miss their kid’s birthday, had another trade skill they were contributing to a community project, and so on. It had earned you quite the influx of pay, and you’d also picked up plenty of goodwill along the way, too.
It wasn’t as hard to hide your extra earnings from Matthew since you’d moved into the office downstairs and reworked it into a makeshift bedroom, but you knew he was at the very least suspicious of just how much extra pay you’d been receiving. When he started keeping less and less food in the house - or at least less accessible to you - you knew it was nothing more than a ploy to get you to show your hand, to show up with more food than you should have ration slips to afford.
When you’d arrived in Jackson, you both just sort of silently acquired whatever was needed for the household and went on about your ever divergent lives. But now? After you and Joel had been together with Matthew to witness? After Joel had utterly humiliated him and let enough of his confidence rub off on you that you joined in? No. Something dark was coalescing in the furthest reaches of his mind, somehow seeming more sinister than his previous tendencies. His shift in demeanor made nerves pool in your gut.
You also had undergone a metamorphosis of sorts. Actually experiencing and knowing Joel intimately left you ruined for anyone else. If it wasn’t him, you didn’t want it. It was different to anything you’d ever felt for anyone. It was a need. It just had to be. You couldn’t exist elsewise. There wasn’t anything else that made sense.
But your life was far from logical these days. It had been an elusive amalgamation of loyalties and betrayals and surrenders and resignations, all of which left you feeling empty and alone. Except for Joel.
You’d come to realize only recently that Matthew had effectively isolated you from those you used to call friends or casual acquaintances. It had happened so slowly that you didn’t realize it until you found yourself without any solid relationships or social circles. It had been purposeful, and you’d fallen for it. You hated how you always fell for it. You hated how Matthew always managed to get the better of you, no matter how many times you thought you’d finally gotten a grasp on how he operated.
A derisive snort behind you drew your attention over your shoulder once more. Joel remained unmoved in his spot, sprawled out lazily across the couch with a book in hand. Whatever he’d just read was obviously not up to his standards.
You sat perched at the window overlooking the clearing between trees, acting as lookout, but you indulgently ogle Joel from the corner of your eye again. He thumbs through the pages of his book thoughtfully. You smile to yourself when he wiggles a bit back and forth and clears his throat. It was a tell of his that you’d noticed whenever he’d found “a good one.”
“Ah, here we go. Here’s a good one,” he announces. You stifle a giggle.
He props up the copy of 101 Conversation Starters you’d found and given him as a gag gift. The joke was on you when he’d turned your energy right back on you and insisted on subjecting you to about 37 out of the 101 so far.
“What’s your love language? You got five choices. Words of affirmation, quality time, acts of service, physical touch, and gifts,” he lists off.
He peers over the top of the book at you with an expectant look. You hum thoughtfully as you consider your options.
“Well, I dunno. I’ve never really thought about anything like that,” you admit.
Joel makes a disapproving noise. “S’no wonder you never gave a thought to it. Fuckin’ piece of shit husband uh’yours certainly never—,” he mumbles.
“Joel, I don’t want to talk about him,” you sigh, already exasperated and keyed up just thinking about going back home when the trip is over in two days. “I just.. I just wanna be with you when I’m away from him, okay? Just, I don’t know, just forget about him. I don’t want to waste my time on him. Our time.”
“Arlight, alright. I’ll back off. Jus’ frustratin’ is all…” Joel grumbles.
“You’re telling me,” you snort. You huff a sigh and look back out the window. A beat or two passes before Joel pipes up again.
“M’sorry, honey. I know you don’t like talkin’ about that asshole. Just had a moment of frustration.”
“It’s alright, Joel. I get it. I’m frustrated, too.” You can’t will yourself to look at him. You fear he’ll have an expression that will wear down what little resolve you have and convince you to upend your entire life just to be with him. It’s what you want, but you’re scared. You’re not ready. You haven’t even worked up the nerve to tell him about the rations you’d been siphoning off as a means to keep yourself afloat once you really did leave Matthew.
If Joel knew that was a contributing factor to what was holding you back, you know he’d just insist it didn’t matter and that you didn’t need to worry about supporting yourself. But you needed to. You had to have something that made you feel like less of a burden, regardless of whatever comforting thing Joel would say to convince you otherwise.
“Don’t hafta be frustrated…” he trails off. “Can move in with me ‘n Ellie. We can clear out whatever we need to for you. Would be a nice addition to the house. Would be nice to have you around.”
You sigh yet again and hang your head. This wasn’t the first time Joel had mentioned you leaving Matthew and moving in with him and Ellie, and you doubt it will be the last. As time went on, he transitioned from alluding to it into expressing it outright. You suppose he’s grown tired of skirting around the elephant in the room. You understand, though, because you feel much the same.
“Quality time,” you say after a few moments of pause.
“Hm?” Joel asks in confusion.
You turn to him, having worked up enough nerve to not completely lose yourself in his gaze.
“I said I think my love language is quality time. Just... I dunno, feeling like somebody cares. That somebody is thinking about me. Thinks I’m worth the effort of trying. Wants to be around me. Sees my presence as a thing worth earning.”
You shrug and try to ignore the mist clouding your eyes. You avert your gaze again.
Joel makes a noise of deep consideration. “Hm. Woulda thought it was words of affirmation just based on what my personal experience has been with you.” You can hear the cocky grin he’s wearing before you turn around to see and confirm it. He’s got a shit eating grin plastered on his face just like you knew he would.
“Must say I’m more’n willin’ to deliver on that,” he adds suggestively. You realize he’s trying to lift your mood so you don’t feel so self-conscious about getting emotional – and over something that shouldn’t feel so confusing and overwhelming.
“You’re so fucking stupid,” you sniff out in a giggle. You rub the heel of your palm against your eyes to clear away the wet starting to gather there.
Joel doesn’t press you about the display of emotion. You know he tries to resist, especially when he can tell you’re still processing something. He’s somehow become even more attuned to the nuances of your moods and feelings. It makes you want to rip your hair out. Why does he have to be so satisfying and in sync and attentive? You almost wish he’d just be a grumpy jerk to you like he is to everyone else because maybe that’d make this entire mess of a situation easier in some way.
“And what about you? What’s your love language?” you pose with as steady of a voice as you can.
You glance over your shoulder at him. You both grin at each other. “Physical touch,” you both say in unison. You laugh together like you’re an old married couple, as if you’d earned this sort of domestic comfort with one another through decades of companionship.
“But I think that’s what I like. I think probably acts of service for what goes out. I like takin’ care of what’s mine,” he says slowly, pointedly. He locks eyes with you, and you can’t tear away from the burning ache in them.
His words harken back to your time together. Joel had left no room for ambiguity when he’d made you come over and over, told you how your pussy was made for him, how perfect it was, and how it was his to wreck. He’d urged for you to vocalize it, and you’d readily obliged. Because in all truth, everything of yours belonged to Joel. There wasn’t a part of you that you wouldn’t give to him if he wanted it. Except the one thing he really wanted – the one thing you really wanted – to leave Matthew.
You allow yourself to be a coward and don’t reply to his enticing words.
The sun had finally set, which meant you and Joel were off your patrol scouting duties until daylight emerged again. You stand with a groan as you stretch your lower back. Your bones make an awful cracking sound when you put your arms behind you and press your palms against the top of your butt.
“Jesus christ,” you groan as you arch further into the stretch.
“Startin’ to sound like me, darlin’,” Joel jokes from somewhere behind you.
You smile and shake your head at his teasing. “Well as it turns out, I don’t mind how you sound, so that’s not much of a drawback to me.”
Joel hums in an approving tone and watches you stretch out your stiff limbs and back.
You don’t bother to hide the playful flirting in your voice or the inviting sight of your body bending and twisting. You’re too tired for that. It was all too easy to slip into these comfortable exchanges. After you’d given yourself over to Joel for him to pick every part of you away and mold back together as his, you had worried things would be awkward between the two of you. If anything, things had only gotten more relaxed and natural.
Those walls you’d kept up to block Joel out, to protect him from the mess of your life, had been knocked down one after the other so forcefully they would never be erected again. It was only a matter of time before he made it through all of them, but that was as enthralling as it was frightening.
You hadn’t had any other sexual encounters together since then. Neither one of you pushed for it. It wasn’t for lack of desire. There was a feeling that you were on the precipice of something that might be disrupted if you went to having a full on affair with Joel. You don’t know why it is that all the things you do together don’t feel as final as having sex. Why that’s where the line is drawn in your head. It doesn’t make any sense. You both know it. But it was just something you had to keep at arm’s length until it felt clearer.
So instead you’d just eased further into one another’s company and balmy presence. Sharing kisses whenever you could manage to sneak out of sight from others. Holding each other close whenever a patrol shift allowed for it. Embracing one another as though it would be the last time you’d have the opportunity to do so.
“Well you might not mind how I sound, but I’m sure as hell gettin’ tired of my own voice. I think it’s high time you bring out whatever you planned,” he suggests.
Per your agreement, you’d both brought something to help fill the time you’d be lodged in the mountainside cabin together. It was a tedious job, but that’s exactly why Tommy wanted two people who wouldn’t let their guard down to man the station. During the day, it was hour after hour of keeping lookout while absolutely nothing happened - hopefully, ideally. Every once in a while, others in the group would round back and drop off supplies to be organized and packed up for the trip home. Once the sun dipped below the horizon each day, there was no making out much of anything, so you were relegated to just being mindful of your surroundings and happenings.
Joel had brought the book, of course. You were chomping at the bit to reveal the pack of cards you’d found — all 52! — even if you didn’t actually know if Joel liked playing cards. You like to imagine he would. Fifteen minutes later and you were more than proven correct in your assumption.
“Uh uh, now you’re tryna be slick. We said aces were high,” he argues. The low light from the solar camping lantern illuminates his devilish grin.
“No, you said kings were high and aces were low,” you correct. “So I’ll be taking my winnings now.”
You are holding back laughter at Joel’s incredulous expression, looking as though he was trying to figure out where it had all gone wrong. You go to scoop up Joel’s cards that you’d rightfully bested from him, but he laughs and grabs your wrist.
“Now hold on, you lil’ wiley thing,” he chuckles. “This requires further discussion.”
“There’s nothing to discuss except that you’re a sore loser,” you lob back playfully.
“Not sure how I can be a loser when I got the best thing I’ve ever won sittin’ right here,” he deflects with a flirtatious wink.
A warmth bleeds through his features and your belly. His grip was still on your wrist from across the small end table you’d dragged over to play cards on. The energy shifted into something heavier. Joel rubs his thumb tentatively along the delicate skin of your wrist and forearm.
“Joel.” It sounds cautionary, and you’re not sure if you’re directing it at him or to yourself.
“Leave him,” he says firmly.
Joel hadn’t asked much about Matthew. There was a sort of cocky silence to it where you felt like he knew exactly the kind of impact he’d had and the ruination and humiliation he’d rendered to him. You knew deep down he would’ve gone even further to prove his point if you’d allowed it or asked him, and that alone makes your belly erupt in butterflies. You know Joel would do anything for you. You want to do anything for him. You’re just not sure how that should go, exactly. What the bridge is that connects those two points. So, for now, you remain in your broken marriage to an increasingly hostile man.
You glance up from where Joel’s grasping you. His face is soft and open and pleading. You want to scream.
“I don’t trust him.” The edge to his voice is rougher now, like he’s trying to control himself from letting out the litany of hate and contempt for your husband that’s right on the tip of his tongue.
You arrange your face into something closer to neutral. You couldn’t risk Joel catching onto the worry so deeply settled into your chest over your husband’s recent change in behavior. You still had two days left in the trip, but you were already dreading the return home. It was the most consecutive days of reprieve you’ve had from him yet, and it was the longest stretch of calm you’ve had in a long time. You weren’t sure what would be waiting for you when you got back. Things had been tense, to say the least.
He hadn’t gone into a fit of rage or distress when Joel left the house that day – even though you felt certain he had never been angrier in his life. No, he’d simply adopted a silent, cold fury, the kind that makes the hairs on the back of your neck stand up on end. It was reminiscent of the harbingers you’d get before your father and brother would descend into a violent, heartless fit of rage against you.
The times when they’d gone so blind with wrath you thought many a time they were surely going to kill you, either purposefully or by sheer indifference to your suffering . The violence they could conjure so easily, sitting just beneath the surface, right at the edge, just waiting to be unleashed. Looking for any reason whatsoever to be let loose on you.
Except this felt scarier. Matthew had a cold calculation to him that your father and brother never had the patience for. He’d never struck you, but you were beginning to realize it’s because he never had to. His “control” over his temper was no longer something you lauded. It was bare minimum at best that your partner wouldn’t put their hands on you even if they wanted to. But that wasn’t something you’d really started to understand until recently. Until Joel started making less of an effort to express his desire to be with you. Until you started to experience what it felt like to be regarded as something worth cherishing.
Just by virtue of the evils of your flesh and blood, Matthew was worlds beyond superior and kind in comparison to your family. You always felt that the most he did was give you a verbal lashing, but you were coming to realize that he wasn’t necessarily less cruel but was rather more careful with how and when he leaned into it. He took his time to learn about you. He took the time to listen to your darkest secrets and fears and troubled history. At the time it was a mutual exchange, a connection between the two of you. However, it seemed now more than ever that there was also the dual benefit that he had this knowledge about you and over you.
It was something he could manipulate and use if he needed to or wanted to. And, the longer you were in Jackson, the more it seemed he very much wanted to. His words would slice down to the bone, picking at every insecurity and fear you had so foolishly handed over to him. That is, until he had gone almost completely silent. He’d say plenty with his malevolent stares, but he hadn’t properly spoken to you since that day Joel made you his.
You almost wish Matthew would go back to yelling at you or calling you stupid or saying how much of a frigid prude you were. At least that was familiar. This new icy demeanor made you feel a lot like prey being chased by a very competent predator. The idea that someone could contain such visceral hatred and rage until they were ready to unleash it sent a chill up your spine.
You’d begun to get an awful feeling that Matthew was doing nothing more than biding his time and plotting your sorrow. The only thing that kept you from feeling completely helpless was the fact that you held onto his dark secret: he’d groomed and sexually pursued your underage neighbor Natalie. You’d caught them in the act, seemingly a discovery he’d purposefully crafted for you. You’d promised not to tell her father John about it.
“I don’t trust him,” Joel repeats with a vehement growl.
“Yeah, well, he’s not exactly a trustworthy guy, is he?” you laugh humorlessly. “Hard to ignore once he starting fucking over half the town’s population of women.”
You feel Joel’s hold on you tighten ever so slightly. The small movement speaks volumes: you know what I meant when I said that. And you do. It’s not just the infidelity that makes Matthew untrustworthy. There’s that sinister undercurrent to him that had been developing and growing ever since the two of you had arrived in Jackson. It had become all the more intense ever since you had humiliated him with Joel.
But you couldn’t tell Joel that. Not when he was already so worked up over you needing to leave Matthew and move out. If he was already this keyed up over it, you can only imagine how he’d be if he knew the foreboding types of feelings you’d been getting from the man you shared a home with.
“Between me and John, you wouldn’t have’ta worry about dealin’ with him,” he asserts with a menacing sort of calm that sends shivers up your spine.
Natatlie’s father was a pretty nice guy as far as you could tell. You truthfully didn’t know him all that well, but you weren’t sure how long the pleasantries would be extended to Matthew if John knew what he’d done to his daughter. John was even bigger than Joel - “built like a brick shithouse” is how Joel had described him before - and the thought of being on the wrong side of either one of them, let alone both, made a cold chill creep into your bones. Matthew was smart enough to realize the most likely outcome should he force your hand and push you into spilling his darkest secret.
It seemed like enough of a safety net to keep you out of harm’s way from him. At least for now, until you figured things out. Until you found the nerve to leave him and be with Joel like you wanted to. Until you didn’t fear that you’d leave your broken marriage behind, start something with Joel, only for him to realize you’re not worth it. That you’re not someone who was a valuable partner at the end of the day.
“Tell me what you’re thinkin’,” he quietly prods.
You’re startled out of your inner whirlwind. Joel’s eyebrows are pinched over his probing stare.
Despite being outside the barricades and guard towers of the settlement, you felt safer here with Joel than you did back in Jackson. It felt selfish to let yourself soak up the feelings of care and safety he gave you when you had nothing to give him in return. It was yet another reason you hadn’t ended your marriage. How could you just take everything Joel’s given you and then turn around and send his entire world into turmoil? He and Ellie didn’t need the town gossip following them everywhere they went like it did you. It felt embarrassing and isolating to go out in public and hear murmuring following your every step. You couldn’t do that to them. They were happy in Jackson, and who were you to ruin that?
“Tell me,” he insists.
You try to make something up, but instead it’s the truth that comes spilling out of you.
“I would ruin everything.”
Joel starts to shake his head.
“I’m not good enough for you,” you mumble.
“That’s so far from the fuckin’ truth that I–”
“You’re not gonna want me anymore once you actually have me,” you whisper in a choke.
Before you can register the rapid transit of your body, Joel snatches you up into a deep, blistering kiss. The card table rocks to the side, falling over with the force of Joel’s movements. You’re already falling apart for him when he guides you both onto the couch.
“I wanna have you again and again and as many times as you’ll let me. Want you forever,” he grunts into your neck as he settles over top of you. He plants impatient, wet kisses on either side of your neck as though he can’t contain himself to just one small part of you.
Forever. Joel said he wants you forever.
“You don’t know what you’re saying,” you get out in a tremble.
“Fuck if I don’t,” he huffs. “ Know just what I want, and what I want is you.” You can feel him hardening against your thigh.
“You-You don’t owe me– oh my god– you don’t owe me a-anything,” you moan as he rolls his hips just for the feel of you dragging against him.
“You’re talkin’ a whole lotta nonsense. M’gonna fuck it outta you, sweetheart,” he promises with a gravelly drawl.
You whimper at the steadfast assurance he offers up, knowing just how intent he is on staying true to his word.
“Yeah, you’d like that. You’d like for me to fuck your tight little hole ‘til the only thought you got left is how good you stretch around me.” His hand snakes up the front of your shirt until the pad of his thumb finds the hard, sensitive nub of your breast. He fiddles with it gently, working you up with agonizing restraint.
“S’all I want,” you quietly cry out.
“Then I guess you’re gonna get everythin’ you ever wanted, darlin’,” he laughs under his breath in a playful, deep voice that makes your spine feel like a river of fire has cascaded through it and pooled into your lower belly. So much for not crossing the line of sex.
“Joel?” You will your voice to not shake when you start to ask for something you wanted last time but were too nervous to commit to with Matthew being there. “Can I… Can I get on top? Of you?”
You squirm nervously. It’s been so long since you’ve expressed your desires to someone this freely and openly, if ever. You fear Joel will see just how out of practice you are, how far behind in life experience you are than him — how little you have to offer him in exchange. It’s been so long since you’ve felt a desire for someone, and you’ve never felt it like this before. It’s nerve wracking and immersive in its force, the strength of it being the sole thing able to compel you to voice your desires in the first place.
“Goddamn, you gonna ride me, baby? Gonna let me watch those perfect tits again, bouncin’ jus’ for me?” his teasing comes out in a low, excited tone.
You chew at your bottom lip and nod.
“Then lemme get you ready, sweetheart,” he growls. He moves for the closure of your jeans, but you stop him.
“I don’t need you to get me ready, Joel,” you assure him. Misunderstanding your meaning, Joel insists that he wants to. You shake your head and giggle under your breath at yourself. “No, I mean… here, just see for yourself.”
You pop the button on your waistband quickly and guide Joel’s fingers beneath the layers of fabric where his calloused fingers meet the generous amount of slick already accumulated and practically dripping from your folds.
“Fuck,” he hisses. His brow furrows with a sort of incredulous rush that you’re already so excited for him. He runs his digits back and forth in the thick, slippery evidence of your arousal as your hips jerks instinctively.
“Goddamn, my fingers are fuckin’ swimmin’ in all’uh that. Fuck. So fuckin’ wet already.” He groans when you let out a needy moan at the constricted but rousing movements of his hand buried in your panties.
You lock eyes and pause for a split second before you’re both wrenching clothing off. You’re both bare for one another to gaze upon in a matter of a few passing moments. You never break from the other’s gaze as you collide in a fitful embrace back onto the couch. You’re overcome at the belated reunion of your bodies that you can’t quite understand how or why you’d deprived yourself of it for all these weeks gone by.
Whether or not you and Joel were physically intimate had no bearing on who held your heart. It was Joel the entire time, and it was going to be Joel regardless of who bore the title of bedfellow. You’d robbed yourself of this beautiful thing, this beautiful person, for no real reason. Perhaps some ill-conceived conviction that you’d be no better than Matthew to take a lover while you were still wedded to someone else. But this was not the same. This was not some perversion of satisfaction, some mindless pleasure. This was a raw, imperfect convergence that was something akin to the divine heavens above, a rhapsody of two wandering things that had found sanctuary in each other.
Any reason you’d ever had for holding back was now gone.
You scramble onto Joel’s lap and grab at his face, pulling him forcefully into another kiss. Your tongues and groans mix and meld between your mouths as you hastily devour each other. You pull back with a breathless gasp and revel at the remnants of your passion. Puffy, red lips. Flushed cheeks. The slight sheen of exertion from the overwrought fusion of your kisses and embrace.
“You gotta get on this thing before I can’t wait no more,” Joel rasps in a husky, impatient tone.
You wordlessly nod, savoring the fact that he wants you just as much as you want him, and line yourself up to his already hardened length.
You both groan as you sink down inch by inch. The burn of your walls as they extend to accommodate his girth stings and prickles with pleasure.
“Oh fuck–yeah– look at that. Takin’ all’uh me. Fuckin’ hungry cunt just takin’ as much as she can get, yeah?” Joel already sounds completely gone, but you’re sure you look just as wrecked as he sounds. Your thighs grip against his as you slowly grind into him, teasing out the acclimation of your core to his thick cock.
“Goddamn, you’re so fuckin’ tight,” he grits out. His hands grab at your hips, smoothing out the rocking motion of you working him in and out of your drenched hole. The lazy squelch of your arousal sounding with each quickening circuit of your rolling hips.
“Fuck– ain’t had you in so long,” he grunts.
The rush of blood to your core makes you all the more sensitive to the drag and pull of his cock. The edge of his tip leaves no part of you untouched when you rise off him, only to plummet yourself down again all the way to the base. The coarse bristles of his pubic hair are a delightful abrasion against your swollen clit. Everything is a synchronous turn of hurt and soothe. You feel like you’re being broken and rebuilt all at once. Your legs begin to shake when that familiar tension in your belly draws taut. You rut yourself onto him quicker, chasing your impending release.
“You look fuckin’ amazin’. These fuckin’ tits, jesus christ,” he groans as he lifts one hand away from your hip to fondle them and roll your stiff nipples between two fingers. You’re gone the moment his mouth latches onto one of them and starts suctioning the sensitive peaks between his teeth. Your rolling grind falters, only for Joel to keep his mouth connected to you while his hands clutch your hips and continue the swiveling motion you had. He helps you ride out your high until your legs give way in a quivering collapse. You slump against him like a limp ragdoll, drawing gulps of air as you try to catch your breath.
Your body is almost completely slack as Joel repositions himself over top of you on your back. He never fully pulls himself out of you, refusing to lose the joining of your bodies for even one fleeting moment. You’re still descending from your bliss when he starts to slowly thrust his hips. You whimper at the almost overstimulation, but it quickly bleeds into something deep and sensuous yet again.
Your eyes finally focus as the last pulse of your climax fades away. You find Joel watching you intently with an enamored gaze. The heft of him moving so slowly in and out of you was almost more consuming than something feverish and frantic. Joel took his time sliding every inch of himself back and forth against your walls, a wide open hand gripping the entire back of your neck in a possessive cradle.
“So fuckin’ perfect. Can’t believe you’re mine. Get to have all this to myself– God fuckin’ damn.”
You don’t hold back the pitiful whimper when Joel calls you his.
“You like that, don’t’cha? When I call you mine?” His voice shakes from the effort of suppressing the desire to drive himself into you with furious strokes.
You can only whimper more and give an effusive, affirmative shake of your head.
“Wasn’t just sayin’ it for show, our first time,” he huffs in between measured, steady thrusts. “Meant it then–hhmmmphh—Mean it now. You’re mine — shit — Don’t care who put a ring on your finger. You’re mine.”
Before you can worry yourself with whether or not it would disrupt the mood, you lace your fingers behind Joel’s neck and pull him into a soft kiss. His hips slow as he indulges in the tender exchange.
“I don’t know why you want me to be yours, but I’m so, so happy you do,” you confess in a small voice against his lips.
“I do,” he asserts. “I really fuckin’ do, sweetheart.”
He builds up speed again and presses one of your legs into a bend against your chest. “Say you��re gonna be mine. For everybody to know it. For us to be together. Say it,” he implores. His eyes are locked onto yours, waiting and willing for you to speak the words he’s been longing for you to say.
“S’just you and me, Joel. Just us. Together,” you reaffirm.
He smiles knowingly at your words, an echo of what he’d told you that day. He grants an approving nod before pivoting himself to thrust deeper. He brushes against the spot inside you that made your mind nothing but a vacant chasm of pleasure the last time he nudged up against it. He can clearly feel the way your body responds to it.
“Oh, yeah? Right there, huh?” he rasps, a devilish smirk washing over his features. He tilts his hips back into place before resuming his drives into you, knocking into that spot.
“Oh, that’s it, honey. Right there, yeah? Oh fuck. Yeah,” he rambles in a feverish groan, consumed with how you feel pliant and responsive to his motions.
The pleasure is overwhelming. Tears begin to slip from the corners of your eyes at the almost numbing ecstasy Joel has you wrapped up in.
“Joel,” you whine with a weak sniffle. “Oh my god, please, Joel.”
You sound hoarse with desperation. A plea for him to understand what he’s doing to you — what he does to you.
“Yeah thassit, honey. Cryin’ cuz this cock’s got you feelin’ so good. Only way I’ll ever make you cry, baby. Make you cry every day from how good it feels takin’ my cock.”
Joel’s tongue is hot and wet as he runs the flat of it against the curve of your cheeks, lapping up errant tears hungrily. “Fuckin’ cryin’ cuz of this cock, huh? Feels that good, baby? Feels so good you gotta cry it all out?”
“F-FUCK– YES, PLEASE. PLEASE,” you sob without a single cognizant notion as to what you’re begging for him to give you. All you can think is everything. You want him to give you everything, and to take everything in return.
“Hhnngg-ff-ffuckin’– goddammit, fuckin’ tell me, baby,” he pants.
“You’re stretching m-me so much. Can feel you– oh god– can feel you in me everywhere. PLEASE, JOEL. I just– oh my god— Cock f-feels so good it’s–UHNGGhh-that it’s–” you wail out deliriously, thrashing and contorting at the rush of your fast approaching climax. The pitch of your voice ascends multiple octaves “–MAKES ME CRY!”
Joel responds, but it’s an incoherent rattle of grunts and panting. His pace picks up to something devastating and unmistakably possessive. Each punishing drive slams the weight of his bulbous head against the entrance of your womb. You sob and writhe with each mind numbing kiss of him into your cervix.
“IN ME,” you beg.
“AAgghhhmmm—m’gonna drench this cunt,” he snarls with rapid snaps of his hips, the sound of your skin slapping and sticking together with sweat and arousal filling the room.
You feel your walls choke him just as the kick of his cock hits deep inside you, his come spurting and flooding the expanse of your ravaged pussy. Your muscles spasm and clench with such force that you’re certain the entirety of him will be imprinted on your walls in perpetuity. You swing your arms around his neck in a frantic motion to withstand the bliss that’s so crippling it’s peppering your vision with white spots.
You fall into one another and spend the next several minutes catching your breath. When he eventually pulls himself from you, you can feel his spend seeping out of you. You bite back a smile at the sensation. Joel chuckles, catching onto your unspoken thoughts.
“You know what I love?” he murmurs against your neck.
“Hhmmm?” you lazily hum.
“You got a little filthy side to ya, and I bring it outta ya.”
Your shy giggle doesn’t deter him from carrying on.
“Feels good, though, don’t it?”
You consider the truth to his words. Joel definitely brought something out in you, something more instinctual and jagged around the edges. Something that gave into the inkier, dubious parts you didn’t always like to admit lived somewhere inside you.
You never thought watching your husband openly weep with remorse would’ve brought you a grim satisfaction, especially at such a blatant display of anguish. You’ve admitted to yourself and have slowly started to reconcile with the fact that your tummy did flips when Joel manhandled him, restrained and helpless. How you relished in Joel’s cruel, questionable act of shoving a cum stained sock into Matthew’s mouth while he could do nothing but gag at the taste of another man’s come spreading into his mouth and dripping into his throat. How you liked the way Joel’s almost primitive disposition and actions left no room for doubt of the outright domination and humiliation that had been dealt out to Matthew.
“I know it shouldn’t, but it does,” you whisper with an edge of guilt.
Joel eyes you curiously for a moment before nodding. “Lemme let’cha in on a little secret, darlin’. Sometimes there’s people who’ve lost just about any humanity they had to begin with, and when those people get their comeuppance, it’s okay to feel happy or even indifferent to it. No shame in admittin’ it. No shame in feelin’ it.”
“You mean I shouldn’t be bothered by how much I liked seeing Matthew cry?” you deadpan.
Joel snorts and lifts an eyebrow at the unexpected retort. “Actually, yeah.”
You try to hold back a grin as you squeeze your eyes shut and shake your head. Joel’s energy has shifted into something more urgent and enthused.
“You liked making that piece of shit cry, huh?” he needles with a smirk.
Your eyes snap open and meet his. The devious sparkle in them doesn’t do much to keep you hanging onto any guilt that still lingers. You slowly nod and offer up a sheepish grin.
“Hm, s’that so?” he chuckles, wrapping his arms around you and scooping you up closer to him. “You want me to make’im cry again?”
Your heart skips a beat at the malicious suggestion. You let out a small breath and find yourself nodding before you can comprehend it. Joel’s entire face contorts into a depraved grin at your admission.
“Well, gotta take care of what’s mine. If that’s what you want, I’m gonna make sure that’s what you get,” he promises in a dangerous tone.
You huddle into his broad chest and drag your fingertips across it, sitting quietly with your thoughts. The steady rise and fall of his breathing begins to lull you. The air feels weighty with the resolution that you are going to start the process of leaving Matthew.
“You sure you’re ready for all of this?” you ask. You keep your eyes focused anywhere but Joel’s face as you await an answer.
Joel tips your chin up with two gentle fingers. “Yes. ‘N we can figure it out together. You don’t gotta have all the answers.”
“But what about… people are gonna say stuff–”
“Don’t matter,” he interjects.
“—which I’m used to, I guess, but what about you? What if somebody says something to Ellie?” you continue on.
“You let me worry about what people’ll say. And if anybody is stupid enough to bother Ellie, I’ll personally see to it that they understand it won’t be tolerated.”
You swallow hard at the implication.
“Okay. I just— you’re sure?” You hate to keep repeating yourself, but the doubts weigh heavily on your mind. Better to get it out now before it swallows you whole the second you’re away from Joel.
“Never been more sure of somethin’ in my life,” he answers firmly.
“Okay.” You nod quietly and press a chaste kiss on his lips. You exhale a deep breath and let your mind clear a bit.
“You up to lose another game of cards?” His smug grin should be obnoxious, but it’s mostly endearing.
“Joel Miller, you did NOT win!” you huff in disbelief.
He tuts and smiles wider. “Not how I’m rememberin’ things.”
“Okay, now I’m just wondering if all of that was just some elaborate ruse to end the game early and claim the winner was ‘up for debate’ for the rest of eternity,” you laugh.
He pulls you closer and joins in your laughter. You spend the next hour cuddled close and letting the conversation wander.
Joel’s lips were warm and soft in between the scratchy sweeps of his beard. The trail of kisses he was leaving up the column of your neck had your mind going completely blank. “Come see me tonight,” he murmurs against your skin as he noses your ear and hair.
He pulls back slightly to look at you. “Come see me tonight ‘n let’s figure this out together.”
You suck your bottom lip between your teeth and nod.
“That’s my girl,” Joel breathes with a huge grin spreading across his face.
You bite down on your lip to curb the giddy smile of your own. “Okay. I’ll come by after dinner, okay? But I can’t stay too long.”
“Say it,” he urges. You don’t have to ask what he wants you to say.
“I’m your girl,” you whisper shyly.
“Damn right.” Joel’s chest is almost comically puffed out. He’s proud of you. He’s proud to call you his. You can’t imagine why, but it makes you jubilant nonetheless.
It’s just the two of you lingering in the stables. You’d returned to Jackson without a hitch, and despite everything going on it did feel good to provide and contribute to your community and fellow residents. It was one of the few things that made you feel like maybe you weren’t completely pointless to keep around.
Joel dips you into a slow kiss, his mouth capturing yours with a tenderness that promises he will consume you, hobble all the pieces together if he has to, press you back together for as long as you need it. You make an almost plaintive whine at the way he sweeps you up so easily, taking you on and taking you apart all at once.
“You gonna be nice ‘n gimme more’uh this tonight?” he teases with a nip to your earlobe.
You choke halfway on your sentence the first time you try to get it out. Joel just chuckles against your ear, and you let out another one of those stupid, pitiful whines you wish you could get under control so you didn’t sound like such a mess around hum.
“I’m-I’m–I thought– oh my god—,” you can’t seem to get a single coherent string of words out when Joel is on you like this.
“Hm, you like that, huh?” Joel was smug, but it was well-earned.
His teeth nipped and dragged while his tongue and lips suckled and soothed. You wonder for a split second how embarrassing it would be to orgasm just from him on your neck, jaw, and ears like this. If the pleasure from it would be worth the embarrassment.
“M’gonna hafta remember that,” he breathes against the shell of your ear.
All you can do is stare blankly and nod. His smile softens as he pulls back far enough to take all of you in.
“My gorgeous girl. Thank you for trusting me with this,” he almost whispers.
You offer a small smile back. Joel acknowledging how hard this was for you was one of the million reasons why you knew this was the first time you’d ever truly been in love. It wasn’t like that “other half” sort of thing you’d heard about so many times or read about in moth-eaten romance novels you’d found littered all over the floor of an abandoned bookshop.
Joel felt like a piece of you. It felt like you were a machine who sputtered along, thinking this was how you were supposed to run, until that pivotal piece was locked into place and you sprung to life. Joel unlocked that part of you. He never took away from anything that was you. He only ever amplified and unearthed what was there, and somehow you were lucky enough that he was waiting on the other side to embrace it with open arms.
“I trust you with my whole life, Joel.” You aren’t sure why it sounds like a trembling confession. Too overwrought with emotion for the man in front of you probably. Too awash in his soothing, safe presence. Swallowed up by the affection you feel from him and for him.
“And I won’t take that for granted, honey. Ever,” he swears. He gives you a small kiss and pats your backside playfully.
“Better get a move on. Ellie is gonna be wondering where you are,” you point out.
“You sure you don’t mind me headin’ home to see after her?” he asks you.
“I want you to go see her. Seriously. I’ve had you practically to myself for almost a week now,” you exhale through your nose.
“I know. I just wanna make sure. Wanna make sure both my girls are taken care of, is all,” he says offhandedly.
His words feel like a vice around your neck. You get choked up immediately. Your eyes are hot and starting to burn with tears. Something about Joel lumping you and Ellie together - his girls - made this feel even more real than before. Felt validating on an entirely different level. Joel seems to notice the change in your expression and understand the reason. His eyes flit across your face lazily, soaking up the immensity of your heartfelt display.
“My girls,” he breathes with pure joy spreading across his features. “The house’ll finally feel complete.”
You bury your head into Joel’s middle and let out a few trembling tears. This is real. This is happening. You and Joel are going to figure out a way for you to leave Matthew and to come be with him and Ellie. Joel is going to make sure you’re safe. Joel is going to take care of you. Joel is going to bring you into his family. You’re going to have a family. You’re going to have something you never thought you’d have.
Joel soothes you for a moment until you gather yourself enough to part ways. You are on cloud nine thinking about your future. You don’t know that you’ve ever felt this optimistic before. It felt dangerous to hope, but you couldn’t stop yourself.
You’re so wrapped up in it all that at first you don’t notice the uptick of whispers and murmurs at your arrival. By the time you make it through the line, though, you are very aware that something is going on and it seems to involve you somehow. You’ve been gone for the better part of a week, and you can’t imagine what could possibly have happened that would warrant all the almost subtle attention on you.
Maybe it just felt concentrated because you’d spent the better part of a week with pretty much one other person. The canteen was an enclosed space with a good number of other diners milling about, so maybe it was just a trick of the environment. Still, it really did seem like nearly all pairs of eyes were on you or drifted your direction in furtive passes.
That gnawing, grim twist was pinching at your gut again. Had something happened since you’d left? It hadn’t been very long. Matthew was more than capable of fucking things up spectacularly, but even he could only do so much damage in less than a week, right? You try to ignore the whispers as you settle into a seat at an empty table.
You make it through a few bites before you’re interrupted.
“Hey, I see you’ve all made it back safely.” Angelica. The town gossip. Great. Her voice was tight and contrived.
You look up and give a nod of acknowledgment. “Yep. Safe trip there and back. No issues. Thank goodness for that,” you fake laugh in fake conversation with the fake person in front of you.
Angelica slid smoothly and quickly into the seat across from you. GREAT.
“You seem to be doing well,” she notes pointedly with a soft, curious edge in her tone.
Your insides are pinpricks of heat and sick at her remark. A few of the patrons close to you had noticeably quieted their conversations and stilled the clanking and clinking of their silverware and drinking glasses. They were primed to hear this conversation. They were privy to whatever it was that Angelica was here to discuss with you.
You lift your shoulder to one side and marginally tilt your head in response to her comment. Why wouldn’t I be doing well?
Angelica had a sickly sweet, sympathetic smile that didn’t quite reach her eyes. There was a glint of something hungry and itching with anticipation in them instead. She’d understood your gesture loud and clear, and her entire mood had shifted in that instant to a gluttonous schadenfreude. You can see she’s barely containing her mirth at the discovery that you’re apparently out of the loop.
Her eyes are dancing and wild with excitement. They’re practically singing with the message they’re broadcasting to you: she gets to be the one to tell you. When she no doubt recounts this story to any and everyone in the coming days, she’ll revel in the fact that she is the primary source of this salacious piece of chatter. How you didn’t even KNOW, can you believe that? Tut tut, tsk tsk. Poor thing. Oh that poor, poor thing. She had no clue!
Angelica leans in dramatically and fixes her face with a concerned look. She adds a hand over yours to really sell the charitable offering of pity and encouragement. “Oh my word, I’m getting scared you don’t know, hon,” she gasps loudly.
You can’t believe she has the word ANGEL right at the front of her name. A complete lack of subtlety from the universe. This devil with an angel in her name is practically salivating at your impending devastation.
“Not sure what you’re talking about, Angelica,” you grit out. You may as well find out whatever it is from her. She’ll no doubt have every bit of information and theory that’s out there.
“Oh my god, I’m SO sorry,” she whispers theatrically, squeezing your hand. “I can’t believe I have to be the one to break this to you. Oh my god.”
She places the back of her free hand against her forehead as though she’s overwhelmed with the task of giving you the bad news. As if she’s not soaking up every drop of your misery. You try to brace yourself for whatever it is she’s about to say. You really don’t want to give her the reaction she’s looking for.
“I cannot imagine how this must feel for you right now,” she breathes.
Is that a fucking tear at the corner of her eye? you think to yourself. Jesus christ, this woman is unhinged.
“If there’s something you want to tell me, Angelica, go on,” you push.
She looks briefly annoyed that she can’t draw out her performance for longer, but she at least seems pleased with the fact that she hasn’t made it to the juicy part yet.
“Let me just first say that I don’t believe anything of what he’s saying about you, hon.” She shakes her head back and forth in quick zips. “I know he’s been making you the town joke for so long now. Cheating on you left and right. Ugh, terrible, terrible stuff.”
She didn’t put much effort into making that last part sound like she remotely felt that way about it.
“I assume you’re talking about Matthew,” you say through clenched teeth. You are doing your best to remain measured and calm.
She nods with a furrowed brow and pouted lips. “Yes, that husband of yours. Well, I guess I should say ex-husband.”
Your head cocks to the side in a snap. You don’t trust yourself to say anything. You lift a brow, hoping it will be enough to get Angelica to continue.
“Ugh, I’m sorry, I’m sorry. I forget this is all new information to you. Goodness. Still can’t believe that! Whew. Let me start from the beginning. I’m getting ahead of myself.” She sits back slightly but still grips your hand that is now balled into a fist.
“Some days ago now, Marjorie from the outfitters - you know Marjorie, don’t you? - well, she comes to me saying all sorts of crazy things. Apparently Matthew is friendly with her husband and opened up to him about what’s been going on behind closed doors and all that. Derek said he was a complete mess. Crying and everything!”
Angelica pauses a beat to lazily scan to her side as if in thought, no doubt checking in with her audience. You refuse to look. She is apparently satisfied with their reactions thus far as she hides a grin quickly before turning to you again.
“So then of course Derek’s telling Marjorie everything he said because that’s just what married couples do, you know?” Even Angelica has the grace to look embarrassed at her choice of wording. You want to believe it was an unintentional dig.
“I mean, well, anyway. He told her everything. Said Matthew was saying all sorts of things about how you’ve been verbally abusing him, sometimes hitting him if you get angry enough! Like I said, I don’t believe a WORD–” she rushes to add when she notices you get upset “– and then saying that you’ve been keeping him trapped in a deadend marriage. He tried doing the right thing, working things out with you, but you were so cold and distant.”
She shrugs conspiratorially as though she’s firmly on your side.
“Derek even repeated some of the nastier bits to Marjorie after she insisted he tell her. That ex of yours had the nerve to call you a frigid bitch. He even said he didn’t want to say so but that he finally realize you were quite abusive! I couldn’t believe it. Marjorie wasn’t even sure of it herself, you know? But Derek was saying that’s why he started seeing other women. Said Matthew was very ashamed of his behavior but felt pushed to it. Felt so alone. Even thought about—” she pauses for dramatic effect “—taking his own life, he was so upset.”
“WHAT?” you breathe.
“Well, I mean, there’s of course the loneliness, but I guess he was telling Derek that it got really hard when you refused to try for kids.”
Your head was spinning. Your mind could barely keep up with what was unfolding.
Angelica nods and shrugs as though some of it made sense to her. “If it’s true, you know, what he told Derek, then I sort of get it. Sorry, but it’s true. If you promise somebody you’ll try for kids but then go back on that, that just seems like a really big thing.”
Your breathing picks up into something erratic and insufficient.
“I mean, you gotta admit that’s sort of pulling the wool over somebody’s eyes. You can see how he felt like you weren’t the same woman he came to Jackson with?” Angelica lazily reasons with you.
“I never— he said he didn’t want kids,” you hiss.
Angelica’s eyebrow lifts right along with the corner of her mouth. “Oh? Hm. That’s interesting. He told Derek that he felt like he didn’t even know you anymore. Different person from who he’d fallen in love with. Like a dark side of you had come out or something.”
She shakes her head again and sighs loudly. “I guess that’s when he said he got lonely and depressed enough to cheat on you. He admitted it was low of him to do that, but he said he’d been lonely for so long that once he started seeing other women he just couldn’t stop. Couldn’t go back to being so alone and sad. Couldn’t let you keep isolating him and breaking him down.”
She pauses for a moment in thought, taking your disclosure about kids into consideration. Your vision has gone a bit blurry.
“So, wait a minute. If you’re the one who wanted kids, then … oh no, honey,” she sighs. She shakes her head with exaggerated sympathy. “I can’t imagine how this must feel for you, seeing him go off and start a family with somebody else.”
You feel a wave of nausea. Your hands shake. Your heartbeat is thundering in your ears.
“W-What?” you choke.
Angelica does look genuinely compassionate for a moment as she leans across the table. “He’s making an honest woman out of Rachel. Rachel Harmon, from the vet?”
You shake your head in disbelief. Bile licks at your throat.
“Just told Derek he was in love with her and thinks this baby is what needed to happen to finally give him the courage to … to leave you,” she finishes with slight discomfort. You’re too disorientated to discern if it’s authentic or put on.
You feel like someone has poured liquid nitrogen down your spinal cord. Your legs give when you try to stand up, but you find your footing on the second attempt. Angelica stands halfway with her arms extended as though she could steady you with an entire table separating you. She quickly skirts around to your side as you turn to walk on wobbly legs. She only stops following you out of the canteen when you grab at your stomach as though you’re about to be sick.
You’re grateful to be alone and out of sight in between buildings when you do finally empty the contents of your stomach onto the ground and your shoes. You bend over and clutch your knees for support as you heave repeatedly.
Your stomach stops lurching at some point, but your muscles feel strained from the exertion of vomiting. You stumble further down the alley, further from people bustling nearby. Your mind is telling you to hide hide hide. You don’t know from what.
You stumble and fall, the hard ground scraping against your palms where you’d tried to catch yourself. You barely register the angry abrasions now threatening to seep blood. Your stomach starts to roll again, and you freeze in place hoping it will pass. As you ward off the sick feeling, your mind screams with the influx of information from Angelica.
He’d planned this. All along he’d planned for everything to unfold this way. He wanted this to hurt. He wanted this to cause maximum damage. How long had he known he’d gotten someone pregnant? You had no way of knowing. All your efforts to put more space between the two of you - physical and emotional alike - had only served to help Matthew hide things more easily from you, all the while you’d thought you were helping yourself conceal your patrol earnings. He must’ve been thrilled you provided him with such a perfect avenue to blindside you.
You slowly realize the other reason for him doing things this way. He’s gotten several steps ahead of you, and now he controls the narrative. There’s no way even if you did end up telling anyone about his indiscretions with underage girls that they’d believe you. They’d just think you were a woman scorned, trying to ruin Matthew’s life and get revenge all because he’d “finally stuck up for himself.”
The back door of the canteen opens, and Angelica approaches slowly.
“I saw you run down here and throw up,” she says with an edge of distaste. “You’re done now, right?”
You stare at the ground, unsure of the answer and not wanting to tell her regardless. She shuffles closer, taking your silence as a yes.
“What is everyone saying?” you ask in a hoarse whisper.
“I’m not sure now is the best time….” she trails.
You snap your head up at her with a glare.
“Well I don’t want you puking everywhere again if I tell you!”
Your eyes flutter shut. There’s a pinching feeling behind them now. “Just tell me. Please.”
Angelica sighs loudly and takes a small step backwards. “Alright. You’re not gonna like it, though.”
You almost want to laugh.
“I guess most people think it’s not such a bad thing for him to separate from somebody who’s treating him like that. Even if you’re smaller, putting your hands on somebody isn’t really okay. If the rumors are true, I mean. There’s no point in dragging out a marriage that’s dead anyway. And if there’s a baby involved now, it just kinda seems like the right thing to do.”
You sink onto the ground. Your muscles feel weak and spongy.
“Um, are you— okay, um, anyway. So. Uh, yeah, like I was saying—” she takes another step back as though you might erupt all over her “—it’s not right for somebody to punish their spouse just because the marriage doesn’t work anymore. So, I guess most people think it will probably be a good thing for everyone involved.”
Matthew has now publicly humiliated you on an entirely new level: leaving you without a heads up, not telling you he’d gotten someone pregnant, and waiting until you came back exhausted from a stressful patrol trip, emotions and mind already on edge, knowing that he didn’t even respect you enough to tell you any of this himself. Having to hear it from someone else was just an additional layer to the shame he was drowning you in. Now everyone knew you were unwanted. Now everyone “knew” that you were an awful person, trapping Matthew in a deadend marriage and getting physically violent if you were confronted. How he cheated only because he was so incredibly lonely.
He was punishing you from all sides. Now you would have to be out in the world and try to find someone to give a shit about you. It was clear he didn’t think Joel actually did. And, after this, you began to question it yourself. Who in their right mind would invite this sort of drama into their lives? Especially not someone as stoic and private as Joel. Not for you. You weren’t worth that. He might have feelings for you, but they couldn’t possibly run deep enough for him to go through this with you. And you didn’t blame him. You know you aren’t worth it. And he had Ellie to think about. It wouldn’t be fair for her, a child, to have to court this drama should Joel decide to stand by your side.
Everything is a blur as you walk home. Angelica had just kept talking because there seemed to be an endless amount of commotion around the situation. You waved her off, and she thankfully gave up when she realized you were no longer interested in talking.
The entire town had spent days mulling over all the information as news spread from person to person. Matthew helped out at the vet frequently, and he was on good terms with plenty of people because of it. Favorite horses being saved from the grips of death. Livestock being well-managed and producing plenty of meat for the community. Pets and strays alike cared for. He had limited knowledge when he first arrived, but he picked up on the skillset quickly and became an asset in no time.
You were just another person who did patrols. You didn’t have a title. You were just a cog in the wheel, forgotten all too easily.
You see the boxes stacked on your porch when you turn onto your street. You stagger to the note that’s taped to the side, plastered clearly for anyone passing by to read.
𝐈’𝐦 𝐬𝐨𝐫𝐫𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠𝐬 𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐧𝐞𝐝 𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐰𝐚𝐲. 𝐈 𝐤𝐧𝐞𝐰 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐰𝐨𝐮𝐥𝐝𝐧’𝐭 𝐚𝐠𝐫𝐞𝐞 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐨𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐫𝐰𝐢𝐬𝐞. 𝐈 𝐝𝐢𝐝𝐧’𝐭 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐚 𝐜𝐡𝐨𝐢𝐜𝐞. 𝐈 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐫𝐞𝐬𝐩𝐨𝐧𝐬𝐢𝐛𝐢𝐥𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐡𝐢𝐥𝐝 𝐈’𝐦 𝐛𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐢𝐧𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐨𝐫𝐥𝐝, 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐈 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐦𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐝 𝐑𝐚𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐥 𝐢𝐧𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐬𝐞. 𝐏𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐭𝐫𝐲 𝐭𝐨 𝐮𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐫𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐦𝐛𝐞𝐫 𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐭𝐢𝐦𝐞𝐬 𝐈 𝐛𝐞𝐠𝐠𝐞𝐝 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐭𝐨 𝐠𝐨 𝐝𝐢𝐟𝐟𝐞𝐫𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐥𝐲.
𝐏𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐝𝐨𝐧’𝐭 𝐭𝐫𝐲 𝐭𝐨 𝐦𝐨𝐯𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐛𝐨𝐱𝐞𝐬 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐬𝐞𝐥𝐟. 𝐘𝐨𝐮 𝐧𝐞𝐞𝐝 𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐩 𝐨𝐫 𝐲𝐨𝐮’𝐥𝐥 𝐣𝐮𝐬𝐭 𝐞𝐧𝐝 𝐮𝐩 𝐠𝐞𝐭𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐡𝐮𝐫𝐭. 𝐂𝐚𝐫𝐥 𝐚𝐜𝐫𝐨𝐬𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐬𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐞𝐭 𝐡𝐚𝐬 𝐚𝐠𝐫𝐞𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐨 𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐩 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐭𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐦 𝐭𝐨 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝐧𝐞𝐰 𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐬𝐞.
𝐏𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞 𝐟𝐨𝐫𝐠𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐦𝐞. 𝐈 𝐚𝐦 𝐨𝐧𝐥𝐲 𝐭𝐫𝐲𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐨 𝐝𝐨 𝐰𝐡𝐚𝐭’𝐬 𝐫𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭.
𝐖𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐥𝐨𝐯𝐞 𝐚𝐥𝐰𝐚𝐲𝐬,
𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰
The note trembles in your hand as droplets of tears begin to stain the paper. It was a seemingly innocuous and contrite message. A kind, sympathetic note for all intents and appearances. A note from a man whose wife had been horrible to him and taken away precious things out of spite.
The note’s true message to you was obvious: You never should’ve invited Joel into our home. You never should’ve taken me to task for how I treated you. You will suffer for your choices. You won’t make it on your own. I’ve been saving you since the first day we met. Without me, all you will know is pain.
Time feels like it’s standing still. You don’t know where to go. You don’t know what to do. Some of your neighbors, including Natalie’s dad, are looking your way from their porches. A few are looking through windows, attempting to be more discreet about their burning curiosity for the absolute shitshow unfolding in front of them.
Natalie’s dad John eventually takes pity on you and wordlessly starts lugging your boxes into his living room. He says you’ll need to get them to wherever they’re going by the end of the week. He’s sorry but he doesn’t feel comfortable offering you a place to stay with “all the hullabaloo going on.” You laugh inwardly.
You wish that you’d just told him about Matthew grooming and preying on Natalie. Now you aren’t sure he’d even believe you. Just a scorned woman, trying to ruin her ex’s life. You thank him for storing your things and promise to have them picked up and moved out over the next few days. You leave and wander Jackson aimlessly. You don’t really know where to go. You don’t want to go anywhere. But you don’t want to stay here. You want to run and shelter, all at once.
You tuck into the stables and sit on the makeshift hay bench. You think back to when you and Joel had shared this place, a few weeks back now, and poured your hearts out to one another. How you’d been open and raw. How afterward he’d taken care of you, made you feel loved, took Matthew to task. You finally give in to your tears when you realize all that has been taken away from you on top of everything else. You have no home. You have no place to hide away and lick your wounds. You have no one to help care for said wounds.
You’re critically injured, gashes open. It’ll fester and waste into a grotesque infection fit for such wickedness until you finally succumb to your fate of being alone, forgotten, worthless, a waste.
The sun is almost settling on the horizon when Joel finds you. He’s breathless and has been searching for hours. Ellie filled him in on the town happenings when he was gone. She mentioned the “weird marriage drama stuff” with you and Matthew. Joel knew right away what had happened. What Matthew had done to you. What he’d carefully crafted for you to encounter. Laying a trap, like the worthless coward he was, too spineless to own up to his mistakes and face you like a man.
What angered Joel the most was that he fully understood that Matthew above all else wanted to hurt you in the most sinister sense: making you believe all the horrible things about yourself that he’d told you over the years. And from the look on your face when he finds you in the stables, Joel worries that Matthew has accomplished what he’d set out to do.
This was supposed to be three parts, but it's looking more like four now. Tysm for being patient in between parts and for reading!
Title is inspired by A Winter Love by Lang Leav.
catch ya later,
♥Puddles♥
102 notes
·
View notes