#like don't be a bigot??? It's not hard?????????
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I don't think of the ending of Conclave as a separate, tacked on twist. I see it as the natural culmination of the themes and theological argument of the story. For me, it went along with the reminders of women's subordinated status throughout and the necessity of Sister Agnes for the Spirit to move - what are these hard lines used to limit and demean people? The work of men, not God. In God's eyes, "There is neither... slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one" (Gal 3:28).
What are these supposedly bright lines by which we decide who is worth more than another? Where are they located exactly? Chromosomes? Certain tissues of the body shaped in a particular way? In the mind? Where? Do they truly make sense when we look at the sheer diversity of "God's creation"? Is this a world of simple dichotomies or is that what we humans crave and impose?
Lawrence seeks after the divine, which doesn't actually fit neat human labels, and saw it in someone. In seeing it, he was challenged to expand his understanding. Benitez is, like all people according to Lawrence's beliefs, made in the image of God. Is he willing to perceive something of God he's not comfortable with?
For Lawrence, it's about having the grace to be able to love beyond those limits. He truly wants something beyond him to come down and touch him. He reminds me of this one poem: "I want heaven to descend and sit on My dinner plate / and so do you./ I want God to put His steaming arms around Me / and so do you" (Anne Sexton, "Jesus Dies"). But when heaven descends and sits on your dinner plate, it is not, cannot be, an easy experience. It challenges him.
Before him is an image of God in a shape and life history he has not been taught to recognize or understand. But he will try to love and move with this impossibility, beyond his fear and confusion. It's an act of humility over the sin of certainty - instead of telling another human being (the image of God!) you should take X shape, you should make Y kind of sense, and if you don't I'll hurt you -- he opens his heart. He loves this person and he loves God too, who came down and refused to be simple or easy. "Whoever does not love their brother and sister, whom they have seen, cannot love God, whom they have not seen" (1 John 4:20).
From a more universal pov: what is all the horror and domination and death we see around us but a violent and twisted refusal to see ourselves as one - part of the same biosphere, part of each other? What is the bigotry we see capturing so many minds but a refusal to see each other--in religious or humanist terms--as *sacred* parts of something beautiful - nature or the divine or both? Powerful men seek to dismember humanity and the planet to deny "you are all one". Ordinary bigots look at the sacred in another person and, if that person doesn't take the precise shape that they want, they try to hurt and destroy them instead of expanding their understanding.
The final "twist" is a deep, spiritual and philosophical repudiation of that. The whole story was something I needed, but particularly that. We can embrace the light in each other, without trying to control or dim it. We can have the courage to love beyond our understanding and find grace in that. To let our sense of the sacred, in whatever forms that takes, speak to us instead of trying to make it the instrument of our own ego.
82 notes
·
View notes
Text
Despite Both Being Toxic Figures, I Am More Worried About Those Who Relate To Stolas Than Bojack
The reason I worry more about Stolas' fans relating to him is because of the fact he's more openly soft and effeminate than Bojack thus people underestimate him as a predatory scumbag and don't think he's as bad. While Bojack shows he has a vulnerable side, he fits more of a traditional masculine build where people will call him out more for it in comparison with Stolas where people will say bs that a "bottom" like him can't be abusive or a pos. But as Ricky and Morty stated:
And that's why I really am concerned to people who look up to Stolas because it could enable a lot of toxic traits found in them. While Bojack is someone who meant to be written as such, Stolas is an unintentionally written toxic predator because his writers don't perceive him as that and endorse his more abusive traits. Unlike in Bojack where the lessons are he has to take responsibility and not rely on his past to justify or excuse his behavior, the narrative does that for Stolas from making his wife abusive to avoid taking him to task for cheating on her to now having Octavia being mad at him taking meds so that it makes her look like a prick for choosing to cut ties with him. Also notable in his relationship with Blitzo despite making a grand gesture out of tring to win his love he still thinks he's entitled to a relationship and is ignorant about how bigoted he is towards his kind and his social status. Frankly, where he is now with Blitzo he's already shown he's leaching onto his kindness and taking him for granted but is not called out by the narrative or fanbase.
I do think another thing that really worries me about the harm that Stolas fans could find in relating in him is the victim complex narrative. I am saying that the Stolas narrative of him being a victim of abuse is used to justify his own abuse towards Blitzo and neglect towards his daughter. This is in contrast with Bojack that never lets him off the hook for being abusive towards other people just because he himself had a hard life. Having an excuse of being abused doesn't absolve you are hurting others and it hurts even more when the narrative tries to "both side" or "treat the other party as wrong" when someone points it out. The guy only pities himself but never is made to reflect on his actions and have empathy for the people around him. The narrative expects him not to really have long lasting conseuences to his shittty behavior like Bojack but instead eventually get rewarded for it like the entitled pos he is. The gives the message that as long as you can cry about how you are the victim you can get what you want and not have face the fact you brought this on yourself.
With Bojack there is an encouragement to change, while Stolas there is a message stay shitty self while everyone around accommodates you. Stolas isn't encouraged at all to stop treating people like crap just because of the issues that Goetia life foisted on him but instead have everyone else do the heavy lifting. The show has an idea of Stolas being wrong, but doesn't go through with it because of his creator's pet status. They treat his shittiness like it's a quirk little aspect rather than how it should make him justifiably hated by others. They treat him like he's has the worst life out of all the characters while not being sympathetic to anyone else's circumstances but his. He is essentially what the show condemns Bojack for doing, but is going to continue to be rewarded because it's deluded he's just some sad boy whose only crime he loves too much.
#helluva boss#helluva boss critical#vivziepop critical#vivziepop criticism#vivziepop#helluva boss critique#helluva boss criticism#anti-vivziepop#hazbin hotel#hazbin hotel critical#stolas#stolas critical#bojack horseman#rick and morty#jerry
20 notes
·
View notes
Text
It might be just because I have a zero tolerance policy for antisemitic bullshit and block users on sight who engage in really clear forms of hateful bigotry, but I have started to see less antisemitism online/in media and more in the real world. really obvious hateful bullshit in the real world, not like a friend saying something ignorant, random antisemites really yelling slurs and words on walls and being followed, things like that.
at the same time I have seen a rise in very tenuous anti islam opinions online and in the media, not just from far right sources but from centrists pissed at leftists and trump winning. one problem is that a lot of the rhetoric is based on verses from the Quran and laws from all muslim governments, which is hard to refute because the Quran has a ton of stuff that I can't get behind and many many of the laws in muslim countries are disgusting to me. I think it's fair to critique religions and laws but as a jew i know how fast that kind of thing spirals when the critiqued isn't part of the predominant culture.
the problem is that I don't know how to advocate or word support for moderate muslims and jews who are being hated for racist reasons and at the same time tell people how dangerous, murderous and inhuman even, islamism and arab nationalism without hitting moderate muslims (who want reform in their communities or countries) in the crossfire. moderates in my definition: are muslims but like or love their democracy, the countries they live in (even living in more tolerant all muslim countries) but want commonsense changes, who don't take the Quran quite so literally, and don't want to live under a muslim theocracy or force muslim law on others.
I also don't know how to tell people that the right wing, the only people decrying radical islam terror and pointing out the parts of liberal culture that are bending over backwards to ignore and in some cases support terrorism, antisemitism and racial bigotry, are only saying it as a way to attack the liberals by lumping leftist, islamists, terrorists, communists, and democrats together so they can bolster the right wing. They are not protect jews, not protect democracy, just creating a stepping stone to more conservative christian laws and eventually authoritarianism.
In a lot of ways I'm faced with the same problem that people who are actually trying to advocate for Palestinians are. I don't want to foster hate against all muslims, just the radical ones who drive cars into crowds and rape and murder people at peace festivals, but I have to point out how much damage is being done by the second group. how do i minimize friendly fire to the first? In my opinion isreal is 100% in the right and has used unimaginable restraint, but if someone 100% supports Palestine they should have faced this problem (obviously this person is hypothetical since no pro Palestinian since oct 7th gave two shits about how much jew hate they were trafficking in.)
I don't want to foster a culture that subjects muslims to the same bs racist loyalty tests so many jews have lost friends over: "are you a zionist? i hate zionists! you kill and eat babies!" because they don't understand what zionism is or what is happening in the middle east and why.
how do you fight against let alone learn about islamists, terror supporters, arab nationalists, muslims that want to expand globally and impose muslim law globally, without turning around and doing the same thing to other groups that jews have been putting up with for at least two years since the world found out that Israel and a few months ago when they found out muslim antisemitism exists?
this all might sound like Mary Sue, "think of the poor defenseless future victims!" bullshit but it's an important question. I want the bigoted pendulum swinging from "everything is the jews fault!" to "muslims are all terrorists" stops swinging, not just that it swings away from "i hate jews." I don't know how to do it. I don't know how to head it off at the pass. I don't know how to advocate something practical or ideological that would be fair.
antisemitism is my primary concern. it's the most violent and it's the most open. it effects my safety and future daily. but how can jews help advocate for preventing the bullshit of tomorrow? it takes a smarter woman than me... and it fucking sucks. we should at least talk about it.
#jumblr#antisemitism#leftist antisemitism#antimuslimism#islamists#public diary entries#i don't want to be morally perfect. i just want the race and religious bigotry to stop for 70 more years#pragmatism#real question
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
hey just letting you know that the op of this post (https://www.tumblr.com/pitchburgh/711264942712619008?source=share) is a terf and all of the commenting reblogs are also terfs
Ugh thank you for telling me. time to go nuts on the block button 🥜 🚷
update: took the post off my own page but here is an easy link to it w all comments for anyone else who'd like join me
#I don't regret originally agreeing with the post because it outlines a real concern#But it always saddens me when it turns out people making good arguments are coming from a rotten ideology to do so#like. obviously some terfs are very astute in some ways which always makes me wonder how they thought their way into being bigoted and vile#I try not to overthink it 🤷♂️ a wise person once told me 'sometimes people suck' and honestly I reckon that's all there is to it#but damn#like don't be a bigot??? It's not hard?????????#anyway thanks again for telling me anon I do like to keep this a terf free zone 💕
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
why do i keep seeing posts about hypothetical allies who "don't know the correct terms but are enthusiastically supportive"
why are we making up this specific guy so much. why are you so obsessed with the idea of a straight person who would call you faggot but mean it in a nice way, because they just don't know any better.
this is an incredibly weird rhetorical advice, why am i seeing posts about it again
#juney.txt#usually in contrast to some hypothetical queer person who ''knows all the terminology''#but is malicious in some way#or otherwise not as much of an ally as this hypothetical straight person#really sends a good message#anyway it's also just incredibly weird how we're treating Not Calling Queer People Derogatory Slurs#as like this massive hurdle#that it's too hard to teach straight people to overcome#like if this hypothetical straight guy can't internalize ''hey don't call us that. that is a word used to hurt us''#what the fuck kind of meaningfully useful ally are you even expecting them to be#words aren't hard. this isn't rocket science.#''we won't trust you if you call us trannies or faggots because those are words bigots use to dehumanize us'' look how easy that was#god it's just this stupid narrative of ''those loonie lefties trying to be overly pc'' isn't it
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
idk i know it's a kink and people like to enjoy it in different ways but like. are you sure about exploring shit like misgen and de/trans with people who involve unwilling participants in them. do you actually feel safe enough to indulge in this with people who misgender trans people who have nothing to do with it. are you sure about being vulnerable like that with a person who actively diaregards the choice of pronouns of a third party. like you do you i suppose but shouldn't that be at least a little alarming
#i don't have the time or energy to even imagine policing people but shit like this is wild to me#like i promise there are people who care and are safe to explore hard kinks with#and random bigots online are not those people y'know
14 notes
·
View notes
Text
I've been playing slitherio these past few days, and after some time messing around with nicknames and my own experience with the stuff, I've realized anger is something very easy to weaponize. On my second attempt of having "trans rights" as a nickname I killed a huge ~5k point worm as a teenie tiny 200 point worm simply because it was so desperate to kill me specifically. Anger makes your life harder, but it also makes people really unwise. I fucking bet this is in "the art of war", even though I haven't read it.
#Slitherio#Slither.io#If all these russian and pro war bastards can make me angry I damn bet I can try and make them mad too lol#It's such a pity pride flags aren't available in slitherio idc if the creators hate lgbt or not this is a great game mechanic#Users are easy to miss and if I'm a 6000 point long 💕🔵⚪🔵💕 worm people will go to me to fuck me up lol#Did I mention that I got to like 6200 barely attacking other worms myself? I don't think I did#I didn't count how much I attacked though so it doesn't count I should do a full defence kills run#If I play optimally I can get to a very big number I feel#You guys should try it too it's actually surprisingly fun if you're the kind of person to let go of things#Again though one good rule I learned these past few days is if someone's nickname makes you angry -> turn the other way#Being named 'trans rights' made me a target but also people attacking me were so much sloppier than when I was named 'meow'#It might be largely bc of the sheer number of attempts but hey. I've been there & I lost a few times specifically bc I was mad at some ppl#//interesting#Is the art of war a hard read though? Has anyone read it? I've heard it's fun#Oh yeah the mandatory vacation is messing with me a lot how'd you guess that?#Just don't think what this constant and never ending aggression towards a slogan in support of someone's existence in an online game says#about what it's like living in the world for these people#I've been mad at this at first but I'm starting to dig the shitty/absent censorship of both bigoted and also gay things. No hear me out...
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
dragon age is so funny because you can feel the games, especially after 2, struggling to be like "only modern multicultural liberal attitudes can point the way forward to a society that is healed, peaceful, and advances the dignity and welfare of all people" and it's like, okay, but you guys made the game where the different races all have literally different origins.
"racism is bad. most of our villains are racial supremacists of one type or another. also, humans and elves and dwarves and qunari are biologically, metaphysically, and ontologically distinct. racial intermixing literally reduces the number of elves and threatens elvish society and heritage in the long run. qunari are implied to be the way they are in part because of genetic engineering." like do you guys fucking hear yourselves? you made a racist game, dipshits. it's wholly unsurprising that veilguard relegates a lot of its coverage of race to small bits of the banter and the codex, because engaging in good faith with race in the dragon age setting without accidentally saying something racist is hard. because they baked the racism into the worldbuilding.
and that's before we even get to the genetic determinism nightmare that is magic in thedas
#dragon age#it's very interesting to compare to something like final fantasy xiv#a game that also stakes a lot on having a progressive fanbase#but is made by writers who thought for more than five seconds about what they were doing#and so is like 'all the playable races share an origin. but also even NPCs that don't are spiritually and metaphysically equivalent to you'#'all races have the same capacity and ability. it doesn't matter if you're a precious moments figurine because all strength is magical'#'the only race that differs at all from this is literally the result of genetic engineering by racist empires'#'and they are still as equally ensouled and real as you.'#'and they were invented by an empire started by immortal space wizards obsessed with fascism and genetic degradation'#'who are explicitly othering and racist in their rhetoric and are repeatedly shown to be wrong'#meanwhile dragon age is sooooo excited to tell us that the qunari were invented by yakub. like COME ON#also re: magic: dragon age is very obviously doing an x-men 'what if the thing that made you a HATED MINORITY was also a SUPERPOWER'#which is tbh always a stupid beat#not because marginalized people should never be allowed power fantasies but because it ignores how power actually works#'it's okay that you're different because it makes you Better' is like...also not a message that is as progressive as it thinks#but dragon age is esp. noxious because inquisition and veilguard go so hard on 'magic is the realest and most ancient thing there is'#to the point where your PC can break everything else in the setting except Dwarves Can't Be Mages It's Genetically Disallowed#and again...do you all hear yourselves. like.#you have made a game world that RUNS ON THE LOGIC OF RACISTS AND BIGOTS
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
When there is zero disagreement or arguments between two parts of a ship and they exactly look like each other and are with the same personality, it's extremely boring. No matter how much you want to force it or whine about ppl who don't like it, there's a reason it's not popular. Don't expect ppl to like sth bland and unseasoned like that lol
Also It's funny for me that ppl think healthy relationship means zero fight, zero arguments, agreeing to everything your partner says and being smiley and cheery all the time lmao
#don't reblog#Istg everytime I see a Pic of that ship next to each other I cringe so hard because why in hell they look exactly like each other#And with their personalities it's like they're the same person 💀#sorry not sorry#I never cared about it but since I saw a really big part of its shippers are vile and nasty and are tons of bigots I turned into a hater#Like you being all rude and say all these slurs over that boring pairing? 😭
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
the romance/relationship system in bg3 is genuinely some of the worst designed shit i've ever seen in any game with that feature but at least the memes we get out of it are funny. once saw someone comment something along the lines of 'patch note: waving at gale will no longer cause him to buy a house for the two of you to retire in' and i've never recovered since
#i love gale he doesn't deserve (most of) the incel slander#but it's painfully such a good riff because it really really does feel like that#the player choices being a b/w alternation between 'hey there' and 'YOU SHOULD KILL YOURSELF... NOW!' normally is already comical as is#the fact that it carries over into interactions with the party members who you're presumably trying to be close with is... something else#and what makes it worse is it ISN'T jokey hyperbole. anyone remember 'send a mental image of you kissing him or HIS HEAD ON A PIKE.' c'mon#trying to chat and vibe at the refugee camp celebration and the sum of conversation i get is one (1) line asking how they're doing#because going any further than that elicits marking you down for the path of boning take it or leave it#it's genuinely so hard to get to feel like you can deepen a relationship with the characters in ways that aren't trying to pursue them#yes! halsin! i really want to know you better! i just don't want the ass!! why is trying to hit the only option other than up and leaving!!#99% of the time i expect nothing from media creators in terms of writing interactive relationships#larian are beyond parody in that they've somehow managed to do worse than the already suboptimal majority#we're just going to impose the roadblock of do you want to fuck y/n right off the bat. good luck finding a way to talk around that if not#the obscuration surrounding where exactly the checks are really does not help at all either#when the shit's got even the allos complaining about it you know it's BAD#shame because i was excited for character scenes given that's a lot of what's hyped up about the game#but no it's all just the romances. 'what if i'd like to breathe in someone's general direction-' well now have you heard of our romances?#fish fear them party members fear them and tav is going to have to walk alone on this sinful earth#conservative bigoted relative at the family reunion withers era was a fucking time before they tweaked that line speaking of#just so crazy they can get away with this shit#baldur's gate 3#bg3 liveblog
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
EVERYONE NEEDS TO KNOW ALL OF MY HEADCANONS FOR THE CHARAVTER IN EXCRUCIATING DETAIL BECAUSE I AM RIGHT AND EVERYONE ELSE IS WROMG
#somwtimes when i don't like someone else's gender/sexuality hc for a character my brain convinces me i must be a bad person#That i must be bigoted because i don't like their hc#guys is it over for me 😭 I'm literally gay and genderqueer too hello#That's not how headcanons work hodge you need to calm down I think you're thinking about this too hard#ok im done yapping i wanna draw now#the chronicles of hodgepodge
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
can't shake the feeling that they had two youth icon awardees because one of them was trans and they wanted to save face by giving it to a cishet person and they chose a singer lmao like okay what has he done to be consider youth icon lolz did no one else rsvp to the award ceremony or what
#and my dad was explaining how she's transgender#and i said i know i follow her on instagram#and he gave me a look#and i said what? she was in made in heaven and i follow all the actors i like after i watch a piece of media#he said don't you have any other job instead of following people like them#i almost said don't expect me to act as bigoted as you#i was trying to be forgiving because they were brought up that way#but it's getting increasingly hard guys i'm not kidding
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
I cannot overstate how much easier it is to live day-to-day when I don't have to go into a european dominated space every day.
#my previous job just had so many europeans#white ones to be clear#western too#and ngl they make it so fucing hard#explaining why no that's a bigoted thing to say#i don't care that you think that hat is cool people will punch you for it here it sounds racist#and also just having to fucking engage in their bullshit debates about the US which makes it clear they know fuck all about anything#like yes americans are also ignorant but don't come to this country and then talk like you know anything when you cannot be bothered#to actually engage w the people and histories here#my post#i don't hate my old coworkers as people but god they made the workplace miserable
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
Preview for GotG #03...
#guardians of the galaxy#wednesday spoilers#tw animal death#spoilers tag if u care i doubt anyone at this point does but ah.#why are they being turned into the british :(#idc if Djurdjevic had redesigned pete for the modern age to be vaguely british THAT WAS TWO DECADES AGO.. AND IT WAS ALREADY A DUMB STRETCH#anyways this is how i lose. goodbye goodbye to the astrologers of spartax and the mystic angle i guess#not that i don't think spartoi society isn't bigoted. they absolutely are we know this. i'd like an exploration of that issue but UHM#maybe not like this cartoonish thing written by two white men.#doubt she'll actually show up but at least victoria is still queen?? small win?? PLEASE don't fuck her up too#they really perverted peter's gold antlers by giving him a dumb hat with wooden ones... get out of here. i hate u.#also idk if it's just my dumb brain or my attention span problems but every issue of this is so hard to read and comprehend is it JUST me??#genuine question for anyone who's read this far into the tags legit is anything else by these writers. like this...
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
So I'm genuinely concerned
Are we really all gonna just pretend not to like Harry Potter anymore? Because of one terf with a million bad ideas and a superiority complex?
When the fandom has long since denounced her and started making their own fan works and headcanons? The existence of Harriet Porber makes me feel like ???? We don't need to destroy the series just because the creator is a bigoted moron???? Stop me where I'm wrong but I thought the point was to separate art from the artist, and as long as we're not supporting HER, where is the harm?
#harry potter#jk rowling#seriously we all know she's a fucking idiot#but we can't deny that she created something that got so big and touched so many hearts it grew BEYOND her#she doesn't even need to be involved#as evidenced by everyone ignoring her shitty tweets in favor of world building that actually makes sense#and active forms of protest like publishing a story with trans Harry#harry potter is on level with things like star wars in terms of cultural influence and popularity#and George Lucas eventually stepped down#can't we want the same thing for this series??? do we have to dig its grave????#or can we continue to love it and protest its creator until it transforms into something we can all get behind?#seriously I'm asking what do you all think#because i love harry potter#i grew up with it#i always wanted that acceptance letter to come in the mail#but i also DON'T support any of her hateful bigoted viewpoints#and i don't think she should have the final say on what is or isn't since she clearly can't be trusted with that either#anyways i love all my trans and enby buds and I'm sorry because i know this topic is especially hard for some of y'all#your voices are incredibly important in this discussion so if it pleases you I'd like to know what you think
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
tw for casual transphobia i had to deal with at work today below (i just need to vent)
really is exhausting talking to middle aged middle class cis people about their friends trans kids and just hearing the most casually unsympathetic and transphobic shit. like oh really? your best friends child 'suddenly' came out and transitioned at age 21 after having never shown any indication of queerness before and having spent time on trans forums? is it perhaps possible that said person....didn't feel fucking comfortable coming out until they felt secure in their identity and were independent from their parents just in case it went badly for them when they told their mum? just in case they had to sit through endless months of casual bigotry just like this at home? is it possible that they maybe wanted to ensure that they could easily remove themselves from that situation if need be? is it possible, perhaps even super fucking common, that queer people often hide their explorations of their queer identity from their parents out of fear, sometimes even trying to lean even harder into their assigned gender at birth to appease them? noooo it must have been those radicalizing trans forums.
i swear its not even the whole 'talking with philosophers vs talking to a baby' meme. it's more like talking to a group of other witches vs talking to a bunch of angry villagers with pitchforks talking about how you're one of the good witches that they're not going to burn
#i like the people i work with well enough#but fuck me they are very very very 'middle aged middle england'#i am the only queer person in the office (and the youngest) and they know that so they always loop me into these convos#and it's really fucking hard to not snap#like#can you not fucking hear how casually insensitive and bigoted you are being#and you honestly think i like hearing this?#like they are trying to stumble towards being considerate#but they are so far from the mark and I don't have the emotional bandwidth to get them over the line#i mean i did the best i could this time - i talked about how often queer teens remain closeted until they're out of their parents houses#and pointed out that this person was probably only on trans forums because they where already questioning#but god i just wanted eat my fucking lunch#tw transphobia#transphobia
0 notes