#lennon-McCartney

[lennonwife]

I don't know if it's just me, but I feel so much love from these pictures of John taken by Paul.

It's like every moment of John's is beautiful and important to Paul, which makes him want to record it. John in the mirror in the morning was beautiful and important to Paul at the time, it's something simple but that keeps so much love.

and let's not forget the fact that most of these photos are tagged as paul's favorites.

[vox-anglosphere]

The famous Abbey Road album cover photo taken on 8 August 1969

[joen-lenawley]

Happy John/Paul day!!! Here’s a doodle because currently if I draw anything more than a simple cartoon bust done in a few minutes I will explode

I say “a few minutes” because my pen stopped working a while ago. Most of the stuff I’ve posted on here was drawn with my finger

[idontwanttospoiltheparty]

"The world going by my window" – A Lennon-McCartney Microcosm

Or: Over-analysing the melodic and harmonic structure of one line from The Beatles' "I'm Only Sleeping" (1966) and discussing how it reflects the very essences of the musicians and people singing it.

Preface: The following is an extremely self-indulgent deep-dive into one of my favourite moments of harmonization in musical history. It is both a relatively music theory-heavy analysis (though relevant concepts are explained with visual as well as audio examples) as well as a free-form riffing on what distinguishes Lennon from McCartney as a composer on the one hand, and what distinguishes Paul from John as a person on the other. Of course, like the duo's melodies intertwine, so did their lives.

DISCLAIMER: I think it's lovely how the music reflects their lives but that doesn't mean I think the music was created because it reflects their live (irrespective of artistic intention).

1. Homesy John and His Strange Close Melodies

"Keeping an eye on the world going by my window" forms the beginning of the bridge of "I'm Only Sleeping". John, the main songwriter and lead vocalist of the track, sings a tight melody, which is sprinkled with several dissonances.

For those who don't know, dissonances occur either due to a dissonant interval – that is, when two or more notes that don't "go together" are played at once – or when a note that is not part of the current key is played.

In this example, the dissonant interval (on the left) is a second, that is the two simultaneously played notes are very close – so close that stacking their notes on sheet music becomes awkward, as seen above. The dissonant note is a B note (on the right), which has been elevated up a half-step from B♭ (in the middle), through usage of the ♮ symbol, preceding the note. B is not part of the usual 7 notes of the key, and thus adds a feeling of displacement within this harmonic context. You can listen to the interval as well as the transition from B♭ to B in the following file and notice the sense of discord these note combinations tend to invoke in a listener.

Now, back to John's melody:

Just looking at the score, we can see how close together John keeps everything; there are no larger jumps. He favours small intervals, even using dissonances to reduce the distance his voice has to travel to a minimum. The dissonances give a feeling of strangeness to the overall melody.*

*(arguably it isn't that strange, since he is following a blues scale, which includes notes considered "dissonant" in classical music theory; that being said I would argue that the frequency of the note-usage in this particular line is still of note in the context of this song and The Beatles' general discography.)

This is, in my opinion, one of the staples of John's melodies. Think of the intro to If I Fell, or even the siren-inspired wail of the I Am The Walrus verses. These are all close melodies that have at least somewhat dissonant qualities.

It is also an interesting reflection of him and his mid-60s situation. With his early-twenties behind him, John was known to have become more reclusive during this time; going out less often, preferring the comfort of his private home. Simultaneously, his interests became more eccentric and he began finding it more difficult to relate to "ordinary" people, for reasons ranging from disillusionment with society as a whole to mental health and addiction issues. Just like his melodic lines, he built a strange surreal world for himself, without stepping too far out his comfort zone.

2. Adventurous Paul and his Warm Leaps

"Keeping an eye on the world going by my window" is also the moment in the song where Paul, who up until this point was a mere co-background vocalist, is briefly promoted to co-lead. For the first part of the line – up until the word "world" – he joins John in unison, before breaking off to find his way to the highest note of "I'm Only Sleeping".

Unlike John's melody, Paul's unique part is much warmer and features no dissonances. This doesn't make it less complex though; for one, it covers a range that is two half-steps wider than John's melody and features the largest interval jump: a perfect fourth ("my win-[dow]").

Paul's songwriting is known for its wide tonal palette, his outstanding vocal range making melodic climbs and leaps second nature to him when compositing. At the same time, his tunes have over the years, it seems, almost been faulted for how intrinsically pleasing they are to the ear.

This, in turn, contains traces of Paul's personality; a constant thirst for life, a great skill of adaptability, an ambition that verges on destructive over-zealousness – he has risen too high, where no one can follow, perhaps inadvertently left someone behind. Yet, through it all, he maintains a pleasant sweet nature.

3. (Never) The Twain Shall Meet

Both of these aforementioned melodic lines combine to form a whole in the song (note that because they begin in unison at first only one note is played at a time – that's how pianos work sadly :-( ):

Now before we take a closer look at what happens in the score when these two melodies are united, I'm gonna need to give some background on harmonic arrangement.

Typically, when harmonizing, the most common interval between two melodies is a third (minor or major). The third is considered to be a very pleasant-sounding interval; the notes are as close to each other as possible without sounding dissonant and overall the tone is warm.

See above two melodies set exactly a third apart at each note. It's an adaptation of a Mozart piece I played a few years ago and can be listened here:

The second most typical interval for harmonies is the perfect fifth. It's a bit more "hollow"-sounding, one might say, less warm generally, but does not, as such, sound "wrong" to the Western ear.

(asterisk elaborated further down)

The above sequence can be heard here:

You may be wondering why the two notes in the middle are not a fifth a part. This is because, for hundreds of years, Western music theoreticians have discouraged the use of parallel fifths. This is when two melodic lines maintain a perfect fifth interval between each other over multiple consecutive notes. It's considered to have a harsh and slightly strange sound, and also dilutes the wanted distinction between both melodies.

Here's the same arrangement as above, only this time utilizing parallel fifths.

Again, an audio example – however, this may not sound especially harsh or strange to an untrained ear. (Just know that if Johann Sebastian Bach saw any of this, he would tear the score to pieces!)

Now with all this acquired knowledge, how do the John and Paul's individual melodies in fact form a whole?

(grey highlight denotes unison)

Look at that.

Paul, once mirroring his partner flawlessly, suddenly stubbornly refusing to follow John – whether it be to Surrey, Greece or that natural D-note. Instead, he lingers on the E♭ for a few more beats, as if contemplating. John, on the other hand, repeats the first half's walk-down, marinading in his strange claustrophobic world. Together, they create a dissonant second, two notes in a row, a disturbance.

Then, Paul jumps, and they are both singing in opposite directions; Paul upward and John downward. Only suddenly, it's almost like they've created a healthy distance, a perfect fifth apart.

Next, they start moving in tandem again, both rising, utilizing a dreaded parallel fifth. But it works here – and, notably, sounds a lot better in the song than on my piano recording. As mentioned, one of the problems with parallel fifths is that they keep the melodic lines too similar; however, these lines are not being played by perfectly tuned instruments. These are two men with voices sometimes so distinct from each other, they're described as polar opposites. They bend their notes and the rules of composition to create an otherworldly beauty. The harmonies seem to accentuate the contrast between their vocal styles, but this doesn't worsen the sound in the least. Instead, it seems that it is in their opposite nature that they find each other.

And then, as if coming down from a high, Paul jumps down to join John, a beautiful, warm third above him.

They are one; they are so close they bring out the worst in each other; they drive each other apart; they reach for each other even when distant; and then, when all is said and done, they fall back together in the end.

To finish off I recorded a slower version of the harmony. Come bask in the infinite glory of every single note with me!

"Keeping an eye on the world going by my window."

[greatestplaylist]

THE BALLAD OF JOHN AND YOKO - The Beatles (1969)

follow the ONLY GOOD MUSIC playlist! https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLNP57YPi9HzOzfgOqqHXCwUBXXu5tIpvX

[ceofjohnlennon]

"I was very lucky I made it up with John before he died. That was really lucky, important, for me." ㅡ Paul McCartney for Pauline Sutcliffe.

[i-love-you-more-than-yesterday]

Since it's the first, I'll just post some of my favourite pics of them. Also, nice time to find out I like black and white so much apparently

Also this one. God bless, it's so stupid. I love it so much

[travsd]

The Dick James Centennial

The Dick James Centennial

I’ve backdated this post for the centennial of the birth of British crooner and music publisher Dick James (Leon Isaac Vapnick, 1920-1986), because I missed that momentous benchmark — I wasn’t quite aware of what a character he was until I saw him in Peter Jackson’s Get Back in late 2021. Like all Beatles’ fans I’d known about James for most of my life, but strictly as words on a page. James was…

[ringo-starr-daily]

All of the Beatles dying in a glue trap

[loadingmercurywithapitchfork]

hey girl i mean jude

[joen-lenawley]

“Lennon and McCartney” sounds and looks a lot like “Lenin and McCarthy” and I think that’s funny

[pdubyah]

All you need is $300

Where we go and buy the all new Beatles re-mastered stuff. Well forgive me! I like a lot of Beatles songs, like not love. I love their simplicity and the pictures they paint in my head. Written, often, by men who’d had a quick pull on the wacky baccy it seems. Nobody likes the drummer though. The man we knows as Simon “the spice girls will never amount to much” Cowell recons that they’d fail a…

[idontwanttospoiltheparty]

do you think john thought paul was special? I get sad when I read about what he said about paul in the 70s, especially because paul has always thought john was special. but john was calling him engelbert and saying paul died creatively and was his last gasp. so did he think paul was untalented?

I want to preface this with: I do not have access to John Lennon's living thoughts, I just can read the same quotes everyone else can. So bear in mind that this is just my take, please.

If anything, I don't think John's problems with Paul were a lack of talent – he many times pointed out Paul's talent as the thing which convinced him to let Paul join his band (as opposed to say, Paul's organiztional skills or what have you) – but I think he sometimes found himself frustrated with what he felt was Paul's unfulfilled musical potential. I think John did think Paul was special but felt some of that specialness was "wasted", because he didn't find all of Paul's creations as interesting or "deep" as it could be.

I also think there's a non-zero chance that John let his personal issues with Paul cloud his judgement of Paul's music. But all of that is very complicated and seems to have changed from day-to-day.

[ringosmistress]

[klyceart]

I wanted to understand your face