#i feel this is like discourse within discourse
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
i know it’s frustrating and heartbreaking to see bigotry within our own community, but i feel like it’s really important to remember that despite the discourse and infighting, we are not each other’s worst enemies. trans women are not more likely to be transandrophobic than anyone else. trans women are not the biggest source of transandrophobia by a *long* shot. anyone who advocates for trans men by saying that trans women are our enemies is not an ally of mine.
Our? I'm a trans woman. Just because I defend transmacs and call out trans radfems doesn't make me a man.
Also, given what I've seen on here, and the fact that I was literally cancelled by several sizable friend groups of transfems for defending trans men, that's not a good sign.
Does every transfem hate transmascs? Of course not.
Has the vast majority of people who defend transandrophobic rhetoric been transfem given what I've seen on here, and other platforms as well as in real life? Yep.
I know of very few people who aren't transmasc who aren't transandrophobic, and I am in a shit load of trans spaces (well, I was, until I had the audacity to say that maybe we shouldn't shit transmascs)
Never said transfems are "our enemies" (I mean, they do say that you're your own worst enemy), just that the vast majority of bigotry is coming from my own side, and I gave my speculation as to why.
22 notes
·
View notes
Note
I personally think that TFP made people care MORE about the abuse Starscream went through. I "blame" it for people not shipping Megatron and Starscream as much or going after megastar shippers because of the abuse. I think some shows make it funny, but Prime def didn't because people can't ship megatron and starscream without people mentioning the abuse. or at least fans don't make fun of it
I agree to an extent, my personal opinion tho is that prime did make it funny. Because it's used in mostly humorous undertones in tfp or at the very least, written in ways where it's made to seem that starscream 'deserves' it? like it is never actually tied to his trauma or how he acts, and the other characters just don't give him grace/nuance. i do agree tho that i think tfp has changed how some fans view starscreams' abuse, and even if it isn't a ton, i think it's enough to actually start conversation. because as many people as i've seen take it seriously, i've also seen people mock him for it, because i personally do not think tfp does a great job at handling his abuse. especially with how he interacts with other characters and how he is never seen as a victim. the way tfp has him, ESPECIALLY in predcaons rising he imo is seen as worse than megatron and the other cons.
now, moving on to megastar. i'm gonna state this - i get why people don't like megatstar and im not gonna fault anyone for not liking it. like, i ship it (it is my transformers otp- and i will not stop shipping it!) but i do realize why people don't like it. but i guess for me, i ship it in a way that addresses a lot of the abuse and makes it comfortable for me to ship it because clearly, on this blog, it's obvious i hate the abuse starscream goes through. that said yeah i dont mind if people, especially starscream fans don't ship it. and i don't really engage with a lot of megastar content because personally, i don't like how there is a lot of abuse in the ship. this also isn't me saying my view is better or right compared to others, i just don't like engaging with the vast majority of megastar content because a lot of it is heavily abusive.
my issue is when 1.) those people are very hateful to the shippers nad harass them and 2.) don't like megatstar on the basis of it being abusive and then go and ship other equally abusive ships.
i like megaop, but when i see people turn their nose to megatstar but ship megaop, that's strange to me, because how megaop is presented it is also toxic and abusive in many canons - on both ends. TFP is a very great example of it- if the orion pax episode was not enough, the fact that megatstar in tfp, but in multiple contuinities will purposely hurt people optimus loves just because he knows impacts him, are abusers tactics. abusers will hurt people they know their partners love. never mind the fact that there is physical abuse on both ends, even if they are fighting.
and there is still, again, depending on the contiuinity, a power imbalance. megatron was a slave in some versions to start off with, and confided a lot in optimus about wanting liberation and freedom. optimus listened and learned under him and then betrayed him at the very end, becoming a prime and taking the position and liberty that megatron needed. that immediately put optimus at a place of privilege and power over megatron, and put him in the same level/caste of people who enslaved him. and more than often optimus never actually realizes this. it may not seem like abuse to a lot of others but the dynamics of slavery/privileged person to me, are kind of uncomfortable. and never mind the fact that they both try to kill each other, they both beat each other, they both hurt those close to one another. they do terrible things to each other. maybe the idea is that 'they can fight back against each other fairly, so it's not abuse' or their friends, to lovers, to enemies dynamic is too strong for people to call it abusive. but i mean yeah that's my issue.
if you're not gonna ship megastar because of the abuse, that's fine. but maybe leave megastar shippers alone i guess, stay out of the tags, and if you ship other abusive ships but preach about how problematic megastar is im looking at you sideways!
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ngl, I’m actually pretty uncomfortable reading my old posts defending the goodness of the common people and their right to defend themselves—as persecuted groups or as individuals—from hierarchical tyranny, given how easily in this current irl moment a not-insignificant amount of people have fallen into supporting an active genocide, because I cannot separate this from how much pushback I got (and still sometimes get) for being consistent in my politics
#I don’t want to say it’s triggering#because that’s not the right word#but what do you call the thing you feel#when you spent the last 1+ year arguing that common people are usually good#and hierarchies of oppression are bad even if certain individuals you like are at the top#that violence is not all inherently bad#and violence against oppression is in fact good#all topics that are major themes affirmed in the literal texts being discussed#only to have people YELLING at me that i am wrong#because THEY believe that the only thing that makes you a good person#is joining the corrupt hierarchy and affirming status quo#only for me to turn on the news and see this same logic of disaggreers#being used to justify an active genocide#maybe it’s cognitive dissonance#because my understanding of fiction is always couched within the reality it was created in#but the fact that the same arguments can be used to justify crimes against humanity#in both fiction AND reality?#it makes the act of fandom discourse less… enjoyable#less innocuous
95 notes
·
View notes
Text
Listen know the year just started like a day ago and I said that I would try to not rant as much this year but I hope everyone who even remotely uses the terms "Fandom police/Fanpol/Fancop" and "Acab includes fandom police" unironically in 2025 and beyond that please fuck off and block this account one time because I have a lot to say to you bitches and I would personally rather not embrace rage this year
#first of all fuck you#second you fucks are more annoying than the “fandom police” you yap about#third of all you fucks need to let these terms die#seriously no one gives a fuck if you hate “fandom police”#it's just a shitty label you can slap onto people you don't like or don't agree#<- political parties everyone#seriously shut the fuck up no one but yourselves gives a fuck#fourth of all us poc (especially black people) already feel unsafe within fandoms due to our races don't make thia worse for us#with these white person ass terms#<- this includes if you are also a person of colour#you are not immune to this white ass bullshit#fifth of all fandom police are not real and are NOT the same thing as actual police#which do you prefer getting yelled at by some user on the internet over fandom related stuff#or oppression via law enforcement#if you equate “fandom police” to actual law enforcement then by all means you are a dumbass#not sugarcoating this to make it sound nicer#i am telling you upfront#you are a dumbass#fandom#fandom discourse#fandom racism#ig I can put it here
13 notes
·
View notes
Text
wait yall actually believe that either one of the winchester siblings had a harder/worse childhood than the other and that they weren't both abused and neglected in different ways
#like. yall#dean never should've been the one primarily taking care of sam#sam never would've had his needs met by dean no matter how hard dean tried#cuz dean was a kid#and that's not sams fault or deans fault it's litreally johns fault for not raising his damn kids#and then john neglected and abused both of them in different ways that caused a lot of tension within their family dynamic#and isolated dean and sam from each other#i think in canon it can feel like one sibling had a better childhood cuz they were abused in such different ways u can't really compare#how john treated them#espc when it comes to how its affected both siblings into adulthood. john failed both of them big time#also john loved both of them why is that discourse#he loved both and them but still fucked them over and abused them that's not mutually exclusive there's love in a lot of abusive households#supernatural#supernatural discourse#dean winchester#sam winchester
16 notes
·
View notes
Text
Not to wade into Discourse (TM) but the number of club legends that have been pushed out of their clubs in recent years through absolutely no fault of their own just has me so jaded and cynical about the idea of players sticking with a club in general but especially because they 'love' it or 'would be hated by the fans if they left.' While I WANT that to be the case football now is purely a business. While it's more to us as fans this is their job, they are not a family, and they will leave if they get a better offer. It's not a comment on their character if they do imo.
#see e.g.: Messi Hummels Reus Ramos#outside of some VERY high profile people this can apply to in the men's epl#im also seeing this pop up more and more in women's footie discourse and I find it so weird#no where is like the women's soccer leagues for the tension bw business opps and solidarity within teams#see also e.g. Miedema Sonnett O'Hara Sanchez#meso#woso#the sports#discourse#and for the record this is not to say people who ARE hurt by players leaving aren't justified in feeling that way#I just feel like people are so worked up about certain players in contract talks and im just like.....well yes
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
Things that the Completely Innocent Edelstan Server have done that warrants absolutely no self-reflection:
Calling a woman "nominally bi" for liking mlm ships over wlw ones in one specific fandom:
Calling someone a pedo and alt-right:
Calling an open asexual woman a homophobic Christian who hates lesbians:
Saying literally anyone who "shows disrespect" towards Dorothea, a fictional woman who isn't real, must hate women:
Imagining "AU's" of horrific real-life events for a gotcha for fandom arguments, while accusing "Mooners" of being Holocaust deniers:
Calling a (hypothetical) black woman wrong for preferring Dimitri over Edelgard, because Dimitri is "representative of deities worshipped by white supremacists" - I say hypothetical black woman because the woman in question isn't black. Also blatantly admitting to trying to stalk someone to find out their race and gender:
Insisting that a female user is actually some other male redditor pretending to be a woman:
Accusing a user of being an incestual necrophiliac:
Saying that Rhea fans overlook her being a groomer:
Casually joking about killing a real, breathing woman:
And remember, if anyone tries to say that maybe the server should back off and stop doing stuff like this?
The server has done nothing wrong. Everyone else started everything. So there is no reason for them to be civil towards the people they have spread such rancid accusations about, for months, if not years. Revealing what they've been saying in their discord about people is wrong, because everything they've said in the discord was fair to say - they shouldn't know what's said about them. And what was said about them wasn't why they responded to the discord; it's all because they hate Edelgard, and no other reason.
Like I said before: completely hinged behavior, nothing to see here i promise
#edelgard discourse#just to be safe#mind this definitely isn't everything either this is just some stuff that happened within this year (barring one exception)#like it goes without saying that no one should harass these people - nothing justifies harassment#but I feel at this point the shit they've been saying has been flying under the radar for WAY too long now
90 notes
·
View notes
Text
i guess im not too involved in the zelda fandom cause seeing a post about rabid totk defenders is wild to me. from my perspective people were singing that game's praises for 2 months total before it fell to the "popular game bad actually" criticism wave and i don't think i've seen anyone say positive things about totk since then lmfao
#maybe it's just twitter's algorithm showing me discourse and criticism to try and spark engagement or whatever#ive experienced the same thing with mario odyssey which sucks cause i DID get into that game well after release but whatever#i think the game has plenty of flaws but is still like. one of the best games on the switch and that's not an insult to the switch#and most of my writing issues are 'well this sucks but also makes reasonable sense within the constraints of the game design'#like the lack of sheikah tech or the repetition with the backstory cutscenes with the sages#ive also never been super interested in trying to piece together the timeline or linked universe fan stuff but that might just be me#i feel like botw/totk is way better when you view it as a retelling of the zelda universe and give up on trying to reason with the timeline#for making a direct botw sequel on the same map w the same formula and still trying to make it fresh they knocked it out of the park imo#at least in regards to gameplay?#i acknowledge that there is a MASSIVE flaw in the non linear gameplay clashing w the linear story cutscenes this time#(... but that one didn't personally affect me since i saw the memories in mostly the right order and the story hit me weirdly hard)#but anyways yeah where are all the mean totk defenders i keep hearing about i thought that game fell out of the public consciousness#all i still see about it is NintendoMarioJimmy47536 on twitter calling it 'mid af' or whatever#and occasional gorgeous paintings of the light dragon on my dash
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
anyways potential headcanon ideas aside i do think like. to me the idea of 'it does feel violating sometimes but the fact of the matter is this is the other guys body as much as yours at this point, you have to learn to walk a balance of both being aware and responsible for what other guy does and also separating yourself from it to feel normal to any degree. your body is both yours and his, it belongs to you except for when it doesnt, but you both are always culpable for the actions taken with it' is not the vibe that people are running with w lucanis and spite never occurred to me cuz its the reality people do live with and its one thats familiar to me. is this making any sense
#idk if im like. wording this well.#but the gist of it is basically. 'well spite is fronting when that happens#its not happening to lucanis' and theres like. complications within that idea#and i know its not one to one. but like.#idk man we go with what we know and most people dont know the reality of having a lil guy in there#daze.txt#dazen talks dragon age#i dont wanna discount the people weirded out by certain stuff cuz it doesnt feel consensual to them#but i wanted to put out there my vibe bc i think ppl on both sides of the discourse havent rly. considered it
5 notes
·
View notes
Note
Mouthwashing fandom normally: Full of children (Me included) and people who do the "holier than thou" type shit
Mouthwashing fandom when you disagree with someone's ship:
i cannot tell what the tone of this is help
#the (me included) makes me think this is against me#but i have no clue bc you liked the post so what does this mean#i think mouthwashing ships within reason are fine play with the characters as long as jimmy isnt involved like#actually feel sorry for some of the kids in the mouthwashing fandom you can tell some of them are just parrotting stuff theyve seen others s#others say#take kids’ ipads away 2025 resolution why is your 11 year old in fandom discourse
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
been half typing up too many complaining posts lately I need to actually finish a fic and then i'll have something with actual substance to post
#>types the post. >writes the tags >reflects on it for 30 s >deletes the draft >at least 7 haterisms within the past week havent seen the lig#light of tumblr dot com#open at will: hater behavior#SAD i feel like all my complaints are over inconsequential stuff and idk whether ppl do it anymore but i just get annoyed thinking abt it#esp bc some shit i complain abt is age/ship discourse which i dont see much of anymore#however i will say that looking thru screenshots from 2022 some people are so fucking stupid#this is about liyue 6ang ages which is a hill i have died and will continue to die on. yeah its a small hill but it is large in my heart
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
2024 reads / storygraph
Exit Plans for Teenage Freaks
YA contemporary + a little sff
follows a boy who suddenly finds himself able to teleport when he walks through doors, often against his will
and has to figure that out while dealing with a new crush, the end of high school and the queer club, and figuring out whether he definitely wants to train to be an ASL interpreter like his father
#Exit Plans for Teenage Freaks#aroaessidhe 2024 reads#this was def one that is just a short YA book to read that was available at the library and i’d seen it has an ace SC so why not#It's fine! a little silly and definitely quirky. felt very 2018-queer-ya#both in use of the random sf element and also like. mc has a big friend group in every flavor#talked about addressed queer discourse in a relevant way most of the time (ie what’s the difference between bi and pan? whatever u want)#I thought the inclusion of ASL and the MC planning to be an interpreter - and the steep learning curve of that - was interesting#I think the ace character was done mostly well but a) why did it bring it up in a way that his aceness inherently took him out of the MC’s#(as the ace char still goes on dates with boys)#and b) why was the ace character ostricised from the queer club and not the guy who was aphobic to him#The sf thing is a little random but I feel like it gelled ok. It fit pretty well within this subgenre of#‘contemporary YA with a little sff but the sff is just there for the MC’s journey and it’s still mainly contemporary ‘#the whole secret agents thing was a bit silly. but also it kinda worked with the quirkiness.
9 notes
·
View notes
Text
i'm not sure if i really want more online friends outside of the people already inside my circle atp honestly because tldr; Discourse
#mine#shoot your shot by all means but like...#Everyone scawyyyyyyyy even in the circle of ppl who pretend to not care about 'ship discourse'#they say Psh its so stupid I Have a Job lol!!! and then 2 secs later full death threats for people into feral art. like#i feel like if i went Out of my way to make online friends i'd have to like#quadruple check that they dont think i deserve to explode for one of my opinions#whereas for offline people There is at least a MUCH larger chance of 'i disagree but i still like you so w/e'#Enough TALKING about 'people who touch grass' and circlejerks about who 'acts normal about stuff'.#I Am going to go outside and discover the 'normal' for myself#funnily enough this is why im not moving to seattle LOL i feel like id find myself with the exact crowd of people im scared of#online over there; at least within like; queer stuff#if i make a loli joke in seattle ill get jumped <-THIS IS A JOKE! DISCLAIMER: COMEDY#i could talk on here a lot more than i do but even still; every post i make feels Dangerous XD#like if i word something wrong i Will get my balls exploded even if consciously i know i have like. ten followers now.#bleh. this is just super not a place to make friends and i dont know where i could find entirely new ppl online#with the level of chill i desire SO
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
reading the first edition of whipping girl (2007) and getting to the last ch where serano talks abt her current observations on queer activism and then makes predictions abt what the future might look like
well she certainly was right wasn't she!!!
#just. the overall observation of inward vs outward political turns....#v much feel as though much of current queer activism + rhetoric gets tangled up + bogged down w like#this obsession w defining + categorizing + policing the nebulous + inherently individual experience of identity#rather than like. actually focusing on the material conditions that should be uniting us#uggggggghhhhhghggghhh#book recs#also a big part of what she's criticizing + fearful of seeing an increase of in this section is specifically. transmisogyny#which um. yeah! she called it!#also. making me think abt the seeming rise i have noticed re:online lesbian discourse abt masculine dykes#in particular. the widely accepted trend of shitting on masculine lesbians online from within queer/sapphic spaces#serano talks abt how she's noticing this trend of ppl shitting on gender in queer spaces when they perceive that gender as 'conservative'#and i think that idea that masc lesbians somehow have a 'conservative'/'unsubversive' gender is often the excuse given for what is#otherwise just run-of-the-mill lesbophobia#so!!!!!! yeah. anyway i'll stop writing an essay in the notes now
36 notes
·
View notes
Text
once in a while i think about the steven peedee connie friendship trio that never was
#like do u see the vision..#it makes me so sad i know they probably didn’t know what to do w him in season 1 but fawkkkk#sometimes i wish they tried a little harder to include him#he feels so perfectly set up for a similar character arc as connie#with adventure forcing him out of his shell a little bit#they don’t need to be exactly alike either like i think he’d stay pretty serious/high-strung where connie became more independent#and outgoing#i’m so miserable every time i think of this. send me to the universe that contains the peedee cut !!!#that’s probably the universe cn didn’t fuck sugar over with Future too i bet. Figures…………#probably also the same universe su crit community imploded within the first week of its existence#so that Unnamed Rapist never got the opportunity to profit off their half-baked critique and ruin cartoon discourse for the next two decades#sorry perhaps i am still very bitter about much of what went down with this show
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
every time i open any random non-radfem blog i immediately stumble upon dozens of posts about girl dick and het "queer" sex and kinks and cock and balls-
#sometimes I feel like there's too much of TRA discourse within radblr#but then i lurk outside of radfem community and observe a mass delusion THAT BIG#but then i ALSO go OUTSIDE OF THE INTERNET and observe other women and everyday oppression we face#so tras and their microidentities really seem like some deeply online take over and over again#wake the fuck up people#all of you
22 notes
·
View notes