"What can humans do that machine learning can't? Can you prove it? Prove that machine learning can't!" I've seen a lot of versions of this question now, and it's often framed like the progressive take, like someone who can't consider the shiny AI future is the close-minded one. What makes humans special basically. This is the question. This is called science now. And we all agree here that underpaying artists and propagating stereotypes via AI is bad, but this specific question is personally really hard to actually answer. Lack of intent and responsibility and dependence on plagiarism are answer enough for me, but it's fuzzy. I want a stainless steel discussion devourer.
The computational linguist Dr. Emily Bender has written a lot on the limits of large language models, and if anyone has a definitive answer, I thought it'd be her. But she doesn't. When it comes to the outright question, she actually refuses. "I'm not going to converse with people who won’t posit my humanity as an axiom in the conversation." (interview with Elizabeth Weil, New York Magazine) I was disappointed at first, but I've since processed this as the mark of a professional at asking the right questions. The wrong question is the provable difference between a human and a computer; the right question is why so many people are asking that wrong one. The right answer to the right question is labor.
"Eighteen-century race theory saw, within the human category, a hierarchy of races. And of course, the architects of this theory were white Europeans, so they modestly placed themselves at the very pinnacle of the human category. The lower edges of the human category merged into the apes, according to this way of looking at things." -David Livingstone Smith (interview with Neal Conan, NPR). He discusses in the same interview slavery, nazis calling Jews rats, and ancient Mesopotamian political dehumanization. Animals are cheaper labor and are easier to slaughter. When there is profit and conquest to be had, people start asking if there really is a difference between those other people and animals. This was called science then.
These "other people" can't be pointed out so publicly now. And yet, thanks to advancements in neoliberal theory, the bigotry persists along the scenic route. It goes like: dehumanize all humans without regard to race, but especially humans' labor, which targets the working class, and therefore the rich get richer anyways. Diversity win! It starts with art and prose, but these arguments are being wheeled out to underpay people in every industry. I thought the question inconveniently annoying when it seemed useful for rentiers and ceos. Now I believe the ruling class indirectly created the question. So I refuse to answer it too. Except to say this: Humans are already doing the work, all of it. Human labor is proven.
3 notes
·
View notes
ok ok so
i officially have nothing left to do for a while.
funeral stuff is over &* my bestie went home
&* my social roommate is leaving for 9 days soooo
expect me on more <3
8 notes
·
View notes
Kamala Harris being the Democratic nominee got me fired up in ways I can't begin to describe.
I was 11 when Obama began running for president. Was aware of the historic impact an Obama presidency could have, but too young to be present in and help rally support for his campaign. But this? Kamala's selection as a democratic nominee? I'm 27 and have seen politics fall into oblivion after Obama's final term, but now it finally feels weren't on the upward curve.
A month ago the nagging pang of unease for what November could bring was definitely creating a cloud of anxiousness/nervousness/fear. And the reactions coming from THAT party after the "rally incident," definitely worsened those feelings.
But now? The doom and gloom and dread of a Biden candidacy has blossomed into that of hope, revitalization, and determination. With the ability to help in this campaign now, no longer bound by "the lesser evil" mindset, that I will 💪🏼
9 notes
·
View notes
dying over domestic 0509. like Actually Deceasing.
their jobs Suck and half the time one or both of them are Exhausted as Hell when they get home (but that won't stop Shidou from trying to ensure that mikoto never touches an energy drink Ever Again). They cuddle when they get home. Or just collapse.
They have a plant. Actually they have several. They're everywhere. They just keep buying them.
Shidou: "They mean x and it reminded me of you"
Mikoto: "They were really pretty and it reminded me of you"
Shidou knows all of their flower language meanings and Mikoto names all of them (they're written on popsicle sticks stuck in the soil because there's too many to remember) and is also very guilty of overwatering them sometimes. Or forgetting to water them. (But Shidou usually checks the soil so it's fine)
Mikoto gets Shidou into his hobbies. I think they'd enjoy photography a lot :))) Maybe nature photography especially
Shidou writes notes and reminders for Mikoto just in case he forgets to get/do something (I feel like Mikoto himself is/becomes pretty organized about writing stuff down actually, but just in case)
Physically affectionate Mikoto. Shidou headpats. Enough said. *Backflips into the sun*
I want them to be happyyy uwahh... I wish....
22 notes
·
View notes