#bethanyyoung

[crazyariaisa]

After the girls leave with the table in the cafeteria and leave Aria sitting alone in “SOMEONE TO WATCH OVER ME” (1x20), Aria grabs out her phone and starts typing away, and we finally see what she’s writing for once. The first screen capture is signed as XO. A and then Aria fills in the rest of the name with RIA. So, this text is signed as XO. Aria. To be honest, this reminded me of something familiar, and I went back to an earlier episode. .

Eighteen episodes earlier...

Emily is lying next to Maya on the bed in “THE JENNA THING” (1x02), and she hears her phone go off. She gets up from the bed and picks up her phone from her desk. When the camera pans over Emily’s phone, it’s revealed that she has received a goodnight text that says... “Did you get a goodnight kiss? Here’s one from me. xo... -A.”

How the message from Aria is signed resembles three other notes in the show; Emily’s text from -A in “THE JENNA THING” (1x02), Bethany’s letter that’s found in by Hanna in “HOW THE -A STOLE CHRISTMAS” (5x13) and the birthday card that Kenneth received from Charles in “O BROTHER, WHERE ART THOU” (6x07). All these messages have XO in the signature, and the only character we’ve seen ending a text with that is Aria. 

Kisses.

[kben277]

Sooooo Bethany Young really was a nobody then?

[omitb472]

Alabyrinthofgreatperhaps - great name by the way, if you're reading this - had a great theory about AD sounding like Lesli Stone. ABC Family/Freeform casting crew have always made great casting decisions when it comes to people looking like families or people who look like their younger selves. I first thought younger Bethany looked like Sara Harvey but what if she looks like Lesli Stone? Which then begs the questions - Is Lesli Stone Bethany Young? Is Lesli Stone Avery (Drake/Dilaurentis - we haven't had confirmation on the surname). Are they the same person?

[b-lackofsouls]

so, i’ve been looking at the opening theme of pretty little liars closely. the earlier seasons before alison came back from the ‘dead’ we were made to think it was alison in the casket. I EVEN THOUGHT IT WAS ALI but, what if it’s not? we’re only shown the eye, lips, hand, and nails (and top) 
 in my opinion, the eye doesn’t match alison’s if you stare at it long enough. maybe, aria’s or even spencer? (looks slightly similiar to ali’s eye)(??) the lips even look like spencer's. not alison's. WHAT IF THIS IS SPENCER's TWIN/SISTER? bethannnnny.. (spencer is even wearing the same/similar shirt)

[lexieklopedia]

March 19. A character u wish didnt die. . . Bethany Young? Lol i know people see this post will think i'm weird but idk yet is she still alive or not but as long as i watch PLL, she's dead :/ but srsly, it'll be an epic series if in the End Game she is alive and she's working out with Melissa or Alison 💪

[stylab]

Bethany Who?

I have a stupid question.... if Melissa had a confrontation with "Bethany Young" on "That Night" then it means she knows who Bethany is.... she seems to be the only one who does... So WHO is Bethany Young and HOW does she fit into the storyline? WHY did everyone want her dead that night? WHERE is she from? Rosewood? WHAT did she have to do with Alison and the rest of the girls? WHEN do we get to SEE her face??? Anyone else feel like there's more to this "BY" storyline than meets the eye? #PLL #EndgAme #FullCircle #BethanyYoung

[mckaylaaponte]

BETHANY YOUNG RANT

Why do I feel like every interview I watch or every article I read Bethany isn't spoken about ..... That is one of the things that PISSED ME OFF ! Like really what was the point of her ? Just to kill Toby's mom ? Just to fill in a hole in the ground ? Out of everything idk why that makes me so mad but it dose im just ..... Im at lost for words #pll #bethanyyoung #plothole #whythehell #prettylittleliars Starting to think that the real lairs where the people in the wrighters room for the last 7 years ! Rant done

[apllchick-blog]

In 3 x 3, we see Lucas going to Radley to visit someone. Hanna later asks him who and he says he could have a lot of emotionally disturbed friends. When Hanna asks him if he went to visit Mona he said yes. Was he just saying that because he didn't want her to know the truth that he was visiting Charlotte? Was he friends with (or a sibling to) her and therefore avenging her death? She was in Radley the same time as Mona.... never know... #pll #seasonofhomecomings #plltheory#mostromanticseason  #prettylittleliars#twinonpll #ariamontgomery #plltheory #monavanderwaal #5yearsforward #marydrake #amoji #hannamarin#spencerhastings #emilyfields #alisondilaurentis #ezrafitz #tobycavanaugh#calebrivers #cecedrak​e​ #noelkahn #jennamarshall #melissahastings #bethanyyoung #saraharvey #lindathinks​lucas​ #lindathinkscece

[hetmiesert]

PLL THEORY

Omfg if Bethany is Mary's daughter it would make a lot of sense that Jessica wanted Bethany to call her "aunt Jessie", right? It would just make a lot sense for Bethany to be uber A, and I really want her to be. But then we still need to figure out which character in the show Bethany really is, because I don't believe they will make uber A someone we haven't seen yet. My guess is Melissa, but she isn't blonde so that isn't right.. Tell me your theories!

[prettylittlespoilers101-blog]

Could this be Bethany Young?

[omitb472]

Bethany and Avery

Are Bethany Young and Avery Drake the same person? I am wondering if Bethany Young is disfigured because of being hit with the shovel from "That Night"?

[b-lackofsouls]

manipulate : pll spin-off au (on Wattpad) http://my.w.tt/UiNb/kKYAyJ6MOE where the liars finally start asking the real questions about alison's disappearance/planned death and bethany young. soon, they learn a shocking secret they'll cause a huge gap in their friendship forever.

[stylab]

Bethany Who?

I have a stupid question.... if Melissa had a confrontation with "Bethany Young" on "That Night" then it means she knows who Bethany is.... she seems to be the only one who does... So WHO is Bethany Young and HOW does she fit into the storyline? WHY did everyone want her dead that night? WHERE is she from? Rosewood? WHAT did she have to do with Alison and the rest of the girls? WHEN do we get to SEE her face??? Anyone else feel like there's more to this "BY" storyline than meets the eye? #PLL #EndgAme #FullCircle #BethanyYoung

[pll-sidenote-theories-blog]

Red-Sweater?

Some people have been theorizing that this is Charlotte walking into the church the night she died:

But after re-watching a few promos and episodes etc.. We don’t believe the girl in the ‘Red-Sweater’ is Charlotte.

Notice in this picture:

This picture shows Charlotte’s dead body, and its clear she isn't wearing anything with sleeves, unlike the girl in the red-sweater. Maybe she took the sweater off or maybe we’re over-analysing, but ‘nothing on PLL is a coincidence’ so we don’t believe the blond girl in the red-sweater is Charlotte, but most-likely the person who killed or helped kill her.

We believe that whoever this girl in the red-sweater is, either killed Charlotte or had something to do with her murder.

Now, for who we think could be this girl in the red-sweater:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Suspect Number 1: Alison DiLaurentis 

This one may be far fetched, but a lot of the PLL community have been theorizing that Ali may have had something to do with Charlotte’s murder. Due to Charlotte holding the same flowers pictured below:

I think Alison killing Charlotte could be a possibility, maybe Alison was annoyed at Charlotte for manipulating the liars - who she used to manipulate herself, and was willing to kill Charlotte in revenge. Although a good explanation could justify Ali killing Charlotte we personally believe the producers wouldn't risk a much-loved character turning out to be evil in the fear of upsetting fans, and so we personally think the chances of Alison being ‘red-sweater’ is un-likely.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Suspect Number 2: Sara Harvey

Who else than our favourite ‘Red-coat’ could possibly have something against Charlotte? 

Sara Harvey. Of course we have been told Sara was helping Charlotte torture the liars, but we don’t know if Dre is just a bad actress or did she seem really rude to Charlotte most of the time? Like she was being forced into something. Maybe Sara’s excuse of Stockholm Syndrome is actually true, and Sara either wanted revenge for what Charlotte did to her, or may hold Charlotte accountable for whatever happened to her hands? On the point of her hands, the woman in the ‘red-sweater’ hands are showing and open to the air which gives two possibilities:

1. Sara has been pretending her hand injury - maybe they recovered over time but she still pretends they’re injured (another parallel with Jenna and her eye sight?)

2. ‘Red-sweater’ isn't Sara Harvey

Of course it seems quite significant that the sweater is red, and all the possible suspects (so-far) have been associated with Red-coat - Charlotte, Ali, Sara

Overall, we think Sara Harvey is a strong candidate for ‘Red-sweater’, but I think we all hate whenever Sara is relevant so lets hope she isn’t a huge part to this mystery (sorry).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Suspect Number 3: Bethany Young/Bethany’s Twin?

Our final suspect is Bethany Young. We all know how much Bethany hated Charlotte. Although we have been told Bethany is dead, we find it hard to believe she doesn't have a bigger role in the story. We don’t have much evidence to back up Bethany as a suspect but we believe the rooftop scene in Radley is extremely significant, as Bethany is wearing a very similar red sweater.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

We hope you enjoyed this theory. This is our first ever ‘theory’ (we know its not very detailed) SO DONT JUDGE but we just thought we could add to the discussion, please feel free to correct us on any mistakes or add to the theory. (NONE OF THE PHOTOS/GIFS ARE OURS + SOME OF OUR POINTS WERE INSPIRED BY A VARIETY OF OTHER THEORIES)

[apllchick-blog]

o we know that Jenna and Noel are most likely not AD but working with him/her. My guess for AD is Lucas! In 6x9, we find out he took Jenna to prom. How close did these two get during the five year time span. Could they be working together? More clues on Lucas working with Jenna and Noel to come!  #pll #seasonofhomecomings #plltheory#mostromanticseason  #prettylittleliars#twinonpll #ariamontgomery #plltheory #monavanderwaal #5yearsforward #marydrake #amoji #hannamarin#spencerhastings #emilyfields #alisondilaurentis #ezrafitz #tobycavanaugh#calebrivers #cecedrak​e​ #noelkahn #jennamarshall #melissahastings #bethanyyoung #saraharvey #lindathinks​lucas​