#There's a character named Jaskier...
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Please join me, as we all take a moment to appreciate that The Witcher Season 3's soundtrack has a track that's actually called...
#Radovid#Jaskier#Radskier#The Witcher#My Posts#He's a Spoon#I can only imagine someone that doesn't watch the show taking a look at the titles...#Coming across a track called “He's a Spoon”#And wondering what the fuck is actually going on in that show...#There's a character named Jaskier...#He probably has ADHD...#And his brain keeps making weird associations...#That's all you really need to know really!#“He's a Spoon” makes perfect sense within context!#It's actually quite a brilliant analogy when you think about it!#And in the French version#He's a little spoon I feel like it must be said!#For reasons!
73 notes
·
View notes
Text
Prompt 56
Jaskier's tears magically heal whatever they fall on. Whether he's blessed, or has fae blood, etc etc is all up to you Geralt learned when he had a certainly fatal injury and his bard cried over him, only for the wounds to miraculously lessen in intensity, to the point he could stitch them up and he'd be fine in a couple of days. The only issue is that certain enemies are getting word of Jaskier's abilities, and are now desperately seeking some way to steal Geralt's bard from him in order to use those powers for themselves.
#geraskier#geralt x jaskier#the witcher#witcher fanfiction#fanfiction prompts#geralt x dandelion#geralt loves his bard!#writing prompts#requited unrequited love#friends to lovers#love confessions#or#established relationship#gerlion#dandelion#i hate the netflix witcher you all already know but i MUST call him Jaskier because I have a character named Dandelion and I cant#take him seriously as dandelion wtf you mean hes dandelion thats not dandelion my dandelion is right over there and he looks...#admittedly kinda like you#BUT STILL#so i have to make them DIFFERENT#I call him Jaskier pwhgpwahpghaw#plus its a fun name#nilfgaard#reince#rience#its rience? or reince? rience right?#ill just put both#stregobor#rando mage#literally any badguy you want
103 notes
·
View notes
Text
Do you know this queer character?
Jaskier is Sapioromantic and Pansexual, and uses he/him pronouns!
#hoooo boy okay I found quotes from the actor saying both sapioromantic and pansexual so that's what we're going with#even though the sapioromantic part does not seem to be widely acknowledged in fandom it was mentioned specifically by name#someone also submitted polyamorous but I can't find anything about that so lmk if it's true#jaskier#the witcher#witcher netflix#twn#julian alfred pankratz#tumblr polls#fandom polls#poll#sapioromantic#pansexual#he/him#live action#video game#lgbtqia#do you know this queer character
111 notes
·
View notes
Text
i dare you to look me in the eye and say with all honesty that you actually understand the plot of the witcher
#the witcher#talk#remember when everyone was like OH HERES HOW TO EXPLAIN THE PLOT OF THE WITCHER in season 1 with all the time jumps#when it was kinda obvious if you just paid attention and ignored that they forgot to age jaskier???#like you could figure it out without much trouble#but seasons 2 and 3 - 3 especially - are just so incomprehensible i dont even know half the characters names
121 notes
·
View notes
Text
Something a little different today what about a character dialogue prompt:
The "Bro's"
Character "A" and character "B"
B: Bro its dark im scared can i hold your hand?
A: tf no?
A: >:(
B: :(
-A few moments later-
B holding onto A's hand
B *Now stepped up a little close in A's Personal space*
A: get out of my back
B: sorry but im scared bro :(
A: *shaking his head* no need to kiss my back this is enough *points to their hands clutched together*
A:...your hands are sweaty bro
B: i know bro
A:
A:if you tell anybody about this i'll shove my fist up your a*s
B: how about you take me on a date first?
A:....i hate you with every fiber of my being
B: i love you too bro
A: Well i hate you!
B: WELL I LOVE YOU!
A:WELL I HATE YOU!!
A: *sigh* f*ck off
B: f*ck me
A:
B:
A:😦
B:
A:what the fu...
B: sorry man impulse
A: seriously.
#fill in your oc's names#legends said “they hate each other”#its the “look he may be an old crumpy b*stard but he is my old crumpy b*stard and the only one insulting him is me got it?#and“ok he is a b*tch and annoying and also dumb but he is my dumb annoying b*tch and the only one hurting him is me so hands off!-Dynamic y#they are the best kind of duo i don't make the rules#also one has to be the older warrior buffy totally done with life who should have long retired and has anger issues#and one has to be the “bard” kind of a manwh*re (optional) eating sass for breakfast and better off learning when to shut your mouth#they also think they are so funny (most times they are tho)#geralt and jaskier#deadpool and wolverine#you get the idea#its a template for the best bromaces#fandom#fictional world#fictional characters#bromance#geraskier#poolverine#deadpool wolverine#the witcher#also how many clone bromances does this fit to? sigh and here we are back at the clones#the clone wars#fox and thorn?#fives and rex#obviously this is still a clone post#cause i wrote this for them ☝🏻
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
love the witcher. if you asked me to describe the plot or tell you the characters names outside of the main few i couldn’t tell you. favourite show.
#the witcher#the witcher netflix#geralt of rivia#jaskier#witcher yennefer#including ciri#i literally couldn’t name you anymore characters if you gave me pictures
64 notes
·
View notes
Text
They could have given Jaskier a male love interest among the witchers at Kaer Morhen, they could have made up an entirely new character on an episodic adventure for him to fall in love with, they could have picked literally anyone else. They even could have picked Geralt (although he's the most obvious choice). But no.
It had to be fucking Radovid. The guy who eventually becomes a religious extremist tyrant and goes on literal witch hunts and gouges a woman's eyes out. Great!
#the witcher#the witcher netflix#the witcher 3#jaskier#jaskier's bisexuality#now it could make for really interesting conflict for the characters#and I won't lie they have piqued my interest 👀#but like. fucking RADOVID ???#even this guy's name sounds rancid#the witcher spoilers
64 notes
·
View notes
Text
Small Announcement
I created this side-blog years ago for my favorite tv shows as a place where I could save my favorite posts about them since I couldn't reblog them in my main blog, which used to be focused on another fandom (hetalia 🙈) and so I created an elaborate tagging system to keep track of everything.
Since then I've also posted many of my own creations (memes, fanfiction, shitposts) and I've gained many followers.
For years now I've even been using the queue non-stop, making sure to post stuff equally about each tv show (if you check my blog you'll see that I'm being serious lol)
What I'm saying is that I haven't used this blog as an archive for a long time and I'm tired of this annoying ass tagging system so from now on I'll just tag the show, the characters, the ship and nothing else. I'll still post about The Witcher, Good Omens and Hannibal equally while using the queue though.
I'm sure you're all inconsolable but please to try bear with it.
Ok bye.
#idk why but i just felt the need to announce this change before i start doing it#even though i know no one will care#oh well#text#witcher#geraskier#geralt of rivia#hannigram#jaskier#hannibal lecter#hannibal#will graham#good omens#aziraphale#anthony j crowley#ineffable husbands#maybe I'll even start to use simpler names for the characters#like crowley instead of his full name#or just ciri instead of cirilla of cintra#a whole new world awaits me#why did i do this all these years you ask?#i have ocd#crispy
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
So...
Was anyone going to tell me Joey Batey could go completely feral with a sword, or was I supposed to find out on my own?!
Also, anyone else here suddenly wants The Witcher to include a "fantasy sequence" where Jaskier is narrating some of his and Geralt's adventures, and there's a bit where Geralt is injured, so Jaskier just ends up grabbing one of his swords and either heroically defeating the monster himself, or fighting back against a small army?
And we're, like, visually shown that epic fight until someone calls bullshit, and they show that either the monster was already about to drop dead (and fell to the floor before Jaskier had the chance to actually do anything with the sword), or there was a single guy left, and Jaskier just knocked him out from behind or something.
I mean having a guy that's freaking trained in fencing, kick boxing, medieval sword fighting, and stage combat (according to IMDb) on a fantasy show like "The Witcher", with all those awesome fight choreographers, and not having him show off those fighting skills at least once feels like such a waste!
I get that Jaskier can't fight like that, but COME ON! He'd totally be able to imagine it!
It's the whole point of poetry, damnit! It doesn't have to be real!
And I've just discovered that archers have a nasty habit of thinking he makes a good target.
#Joey Batey#Jaskier#The Witcher#related#Knightfall#his character is named Pierre if you're curious#And he shows up in episode 1#7 and 8 of season 1#My posts#My Stuff#My sudden wish list for the TV show...
84 notes
·
View notes
Text
Geralt whenever something slightly out of the ordinary happens: I gotta get Jaskier here right now
#does Jaskier even do anything? not really#but at least Geralt's getting a bit of moral support when he has to deal with more than two people at a time#the witcher#well I'm not complaining i love Jaskier#it does feel a bit ''every named character has to appear and randomly has a role in this AU fic'' but i love it
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
Anyone else who just loves jesters? I just can't stress enough how much love I feel looking at them performing. They're just so funny and full of life and also deeply pathetic but who doesn't??
They just go around the town telling bad jokes and wearing silly clothes and dancing silly moves,,, I love them.
I'm gonna marry a jester, un giullare.
#Also you can classify as jesters so many fictional characters like#nbc hannibal#jaskier#just to name a few
2 notes
·
View notes
Note
HI! I’m here to ask honest opinion on….Lore Olympus. I’m sorry for putting my opinion here….but I hate it. I’m sorry, I try to see it in a good way….put it paints Apollo as a horrible person. And there are other things that I’d respectfully don’t like about it.However, I want to see your opinion. That is if you’re willing to share it. BTW, I fricking love your drawings., especially the ones about Apollo and his myths! Have a good day or night!
Hello!
I'm glad you like my art 🫶🏻
So, Lore Olympus.
This probably won't come as a surprise to most people, considering how much Apollo art I've made, but I hate Lore Olympus. And not only because of how poorly Apollo was portrayed there.
I'm going to be honest with you: I never read much of it. I read maybe a few chapters some years ago because it was advertised as Greek mythology retelling, but I didn't continue because it was boring to me.
Much later, I saw a lot of posts pointing out all the things wrong with Lore Olympus, and boy oh boy, it's bad.
From what I've seen, it’s hardly a retelling; if the names of the characters were changed, nobody would realize this is supposed to be myth-inspired.
And look, I'm not saying you can't change anything when making a Greek mythology retelling, because it's simply impossible to keep everything the same as in the myths—especially when you want to create a story that covers many myths. The math isn't mathing when it comes to Greek mythology, because the myths changed over time, and different city-states had their own versions of the stories, so it's pretty impossible to make a cohesive timeline without changing something.
But from what I've seen, there isn't much Greek influence in this Greek mythology retelling. From the way the characters dress and speak to the food they eat, there is nothing Greek about this comic, it’s completely Americanized.
And I hate Americanization so much. I remember watching Netflix's "The Witcher" and being so disappointed because there was nothing Slavic about it. They kept Jaskier's original name from the books and called it a day. They turned it into another generic fantasy show.
I know that many Greek people feel the same way about Lore Olympus and other American adaptations of their myths. I love Percy Jackson, but the whole "gods moved to the USA because this is where Western civilization is" is just so icky to me. Greece still exists, hello??????
Back to Lore Olympus. For some reason it's fans think that the comic is a valid source for mythology, and they spread so much misinformation.
For the last time: Persephone was abducted in the myths. There is no version where she goes to the Underworld on her own.
Demeter is a heartbroken mother looking for her beloved daughter, not some evil helicopter parent standing between Persephone and her happiness. Justice for Apollo and Demeter.
Also, Persephone is sometimes drawn like a child and looks more like Hades' daughter than his wife. Why?????
And from what I've seen, Persephone is ridiculously powerful for some reason and fights Kronos or something???????
Also, apparently, Leto is portrayed as a manipulative mother????? Leto??? The Titan goddess of motherhood??? Why????
I don't understand why this comic got so popular, to be honest. Probably because of the artstyle.
102 notes
·
View notes
Text
In some languages, Jaskier's name is Marigold, which is kind of strange because there is already a character called Marigold.
Has anyone ever thought about using the information to do a fic where Jaskier and Triss are related to each other?
#the witcher netflix#the witcher#joey batey#geralt of rivia#jaskier the witcher#henry cavill#the witcher jaskier#geralt x jaskier#geraskier#fic ideas#triss merigold#jaskier#gerskier#cirilla fiona elen riannon#freya allan#headcanon#yennefer of vengerberg#the witcher season 3#the witcher season three#anya chalotra
136 notes
·
View notes
Text
A Lark Among the Wolves and Dragons: A Witcher/House of the Dragon Crossover
The sister of the Bard Jaskier, and a talented bard in her own right, had came to Westeros initially to make a name for herself. In her ambition, she ended up catching the attention of a certain Rogue Prince whose ambitions may outweigh her own.
When the unexpected happens, she must return to the Continent to seek out the white haired witcher and hope their past history will garner reason to offer her protection.
But will the White Wolf's silver sword be enough to stave off the wrath and heat of the Dragon?
Self-reader insert style
House of the Dragon character belong to George R.R. Martin and Witcher characters belong to Andrzej Sapkowski
Content Warning: +18, minors do NOT interact
Incest, DUB-CON/NON-CON, Mature Themes
Violence, swearing, sexism, slut shaming (plus/minus whore shaming) and power dynamics that are par to the course for both shows
Any other triggers I feel need mentioning will be added to the start of whatever chapter I write.
Also if you repost, be sure to cite either this page or my Wattpad page
Bonus Chapters FANART
Gwent
Table of Contents:
Chapter 1 Chapter 55
Chapter 2 Chapter 56
Chapter 3 Chapter 57 and 57.5
Chapter 4 Chapter 58 and 58.5
Chapter 5 Chapter 59
Chapter 6 Chapter 60 and 60.5
Chapter 7 Chapter 61
Chapter 8 Chapter 62 and 62.5
Chapter 9 Chapter 63
Chapter 10 Chapter 64
Chapter 11 and 11.5 Chapter 65
Chapter 12 and 12.5 Chapter 66
Chapter 13 Chapter 67
Chapter 14 and 14.5 Chapter 68
Chapter 15 Chapter 69
Chapter 16 Chapter 70
Chapter 17 and 17.5 Chapter 71
Chapter 18 Chapter 72
Chapter 19 Chapter 73
Chapter 20 and 20.5
Chapter 21
Chapter 22 and 22.5
Chapter 23 and 23.5
Chapter 24
Chapter 25
Chapter 26 and 26.5
Chapter 27
Chapter 28 and 28.5
Chapter 29
Chapter 30
Chapter 31
Chapter 32 and 32.5
Chapter 33
Chapter 34 and 34.5
Chapter 35
Chapter 36
Chapter 37
Chapter 38 and 38.5
Chapter 39 and 39.5
Chapter 40
Chapter 41
Chapter 42
Chapter 43
Chapter 44
Chapter 45
Chapter 46
Chapter 47
Chapter 48
Chapter 49 and 49.5
Chapter 50
Chapter 51
Chapter 52
Chapter 53
Chapter 54 and 54.5
#geralt of rivia#aemond#daemon targaryen#daemon targeryen x reader#geralt x reader#jaskier#yennefer of vengerberg#aegon ii targaryen#ciri#rhaenyra targaryen#hotd#the witcher#crossover#fanfic#aemond targaryen#avallac'h#eredin breacc glas#rhaena targaryen#baela targaryen#jacerys velaryon#lucerys velaryon#aemond x oc#laena velaryon#laenor velaryon#corlys velaryon#rhaenys targaryen#The Lady of Larks#cregan stark
213 notes
·
View notes
Text
Curse Fic Recs
I absolutely love Witcher fics where a character gets cursed so I thought I'd share some of my favorites! All of them are Geraskier except for a few Lambden ones at the end.
If anyone has other fics to reccommend, please feel free to give them a shoutout – I’d love to read them!
~
Cursed Jaskier
A Friend in the Wild by @samstree (Rated T, 1k)
In which Geralt acquires a tiny mouse friend who wouldn't stop following him.
If There's Any Sleep At Night by @smolalienbee (Rated T, 22k)
A mare, also known as a mara or a zmora - a malicious entity, a bringer of nightmares and a demon of the night. An easy enough contract to fulfill, if only frustrating, or at least that’s what Geralt believes when he first sets out to hunt down one such mare. What he doesn’t expect is to be wrapped up in a tale of a wronged soul, of love and of joy.
My Name is Hidden On Your Tongue by @anarchycox (Rated T, 10k)
Jaskier is cursed. Well his whole family line is. Every male born child cannot be named. They can be given a name, but it will never be a true one and people will always have an allergic reaction to saying this false name. Only a soulmate speaking your true name aloud will break the curse. The family though has never cared, they've only cared about the family fortune and marrying well. But Jaskier cares. He is determined to travel the world, find his soulmate and learn what his name is. And the best way to travel the world seems to be with a rather taciturn witcher named Geralt of Rivia. If he started to hope that Geralt would be the one to say his true name, well that was one thing that Jaskier would not say aloud.
The Cursed Jewels of Lettenhove by GoldenDaydreams (Rated T, 8k)
Geralt has no intention of getting involved with breaking a curse and naturally ends up very involved.
Silver and Copper by @heronfem (Rated M, 56k)
Jaskier is kept from becoming a bard. Geralt finds him anyway.
Priceless by @handwrittenhello (Rated M, 38k)
Jaskier was cursed as a child; when spilled, his blood turns to rubies and his tears turn to diamonds. When his secret is discovered, Geralt must save him from those who would take advantage of it. Together they work to break the curse, but the cost might end up being too steep.
Set My Wings on Fire by bilboakenshield27 (Not Rated, 4k)
Jaskier gets turned into a bird and has to warn Geralt about an ambush.
Sleep of the Dead by @dancedelion (Rated T, 20k)
Jaskier thinks he hit rock bottom when Geralt flushed twenty years of friendship down the drain, but then he finds himself suddenly translucent and rudely walked through by a traveller. Apparently he's dead - that's certainly a new low. He needs to find out what happened, and who better to help him than the man who's made more than clear he wants nothing to do with him.
The Sandpiper by @welcomemysentence (Rated T, 2k)
When Jaskier gets cursed into an actual sandpiper, the little coast bird, the only way to save him is with true love's kiss.
What's Engraved Upon My Heart (In Letters Deeply Worn) by @made-of-constellations-blog (Rated T, 6k)
Jaskier gets cursed to be a lark with a strange failsafe to turn him back. Geralt misses this, and realizes too late that he's not ready to lose his bard.
to be held by @wanderlust-t (Rated T, 1k)
The knife dropped on the ground. And Geralt’s thoughts reached to a halt for a moment. He had no rope. Not anything to keep Jaskier still. To hold him back. Oh. That was going to be a really long night.
Catskier by @al-in-my-head (Rated T, 17k)
Due to an unfortunate encounter with a mage while him and Geralt are apart, Jaskier is transformed into a cat. It just so happens that Geralt likes talking to animals.
~
Cursed Geralt
A Marvelous Night for a Moondance by @flowercrown-bard (Rated T, 1k)
There was a warning every child living near Oakwood Valley knew. "Don't go out at night, or you'll disturb the Moonlit Dancer." No one truly knew who the Moonlit Dancer was, but everyone agreed on two things: The Dancer must be dangerous. And he must be oh so lonely.
animal instinct by leodesic (Rated M, 13k)
Despite Jaskier's hard work, there are still plenty of people who hate witchers. They think they're monstrous, inhuman, only held back from violence by a thin veneer of control. One mage has a plan to spread his views by capturing a witcher and bewitching them to remove their control. When the Butcher of Blaviken walks into his hideout, he's convinced he's found the perfect candidate - and a convenient way to get rid of the pesky bard that's been singing his praises. Jaskier is forced to agree witchers are not human, but that doesn't mean they're dangerous. In fact, he's astounded by how many of Geralt's uncontrolled impulses involve touching.
Connecting dots by @dapandapod (Rated G, 3k)
Geralt is hit with a lying curse, and it takes Jaskier an embarrassing amount of time to figure it out. Now, it Jaskier only would stick to the safe questions....
Don't Go Stealing My Heart by @thesilverqueenlady (Rated T, 17k)
When Jaskier is stiffed by a lord on payment, he decides to help himself to proper compensation. Alongside the correct amount of gold and silver, he also steals a beautiful silver wolf's head medallion. It's safe to say that he is not expecting the medallion to be haunted by the spirit of a very grumpy, very handsome, very cursed Witcher.
Cuddles, Curses, and Confusion by me :D (Rated T, 3k)
Geralt becomes oddly affectionate after being cursed by a mage. Jaskier would just like his life to be less complicated, please.
Spectre's Soul also by me :D (Rated T, 31k)
When Jaskier tried to go on a date with a man named Rience, he did not expect to nearly be killed. He certainly did not expect to discover a beautiful valley while running away from him. He very definitely did not expect to find out that the valley was haunted — by an absurdly beautiful man. Or: In which Geralt is cursed to be a ghost and Jaskier is the first person in decades to talk to him.
~
Cursed Aiden
Headache at First Sight by YorkAndDelta (Rated T, 12k)
A story of how Lambert ends up looking after a cursed cat, helping a Witcher from a rival school retrieve his gear from angry mages, and maybe finds love along the way.
~
Cursed Lambert
the mortifying ordeal of being known as a cat by @skaldingrayne Rated M, 10k
Lambert is cursed to be a cat. Fortunately, he finds Jaskier.
~
You can find my other reclists here!
#the witcher#geraskier#geralt x jaskier#geralt#jaskier#wren recs#wren talks#lambden#the witcher fic rec#reclist#twn#i actually made this list a few months ago and then completely forgot it in my google drive until today lol#but i found it today so here you go!#:D
484 notes
·
View notes
Text
I've seen some posts from people in the Witcher fandom (usually who are into both the Netflix show and the books) being confused as to why book fans think Geralt being mean to Dandelion (Jaskier) is a canon divergence in the TV show, when in the books, there are times when Geralt can be very cutting and even a bit mean to Dandelion.
My takeaway from their relationship in the books is that this conflict has the purpose of developing both of their characters (and serving as allegory because we KNOW Mr. Sapkowski loves allegory, and we love him for it! Or at least I do), and there's context around why they can be this way with each other. There's a rich history in this friendship, a comfort and casualness with one another that one wouldn't have with someone they weren't that close with, which in a lot of relationships comes with a safety to BE cutting and blunt with each other at times and know that having these conflicts is not going to mean an end to their relationship. They tend to move on from their arguments and all is forgiven (sometimes after a period of distance, but that's also normal after a hard conversation I feel - both parties sometimes need to process and lick their wounds, or wounded egos), and it's implied (at least to me) that their friendship is an "always" thing, even when they do blow up at each other, and even when the things they say are harsh.
Furthermore, there's so much "off screen" (off-page?) time between them that we don't get to see. But their closeness is implied by others and themselves throughout the entire saga and the short stories. And the things they say to other people indicate how important they are to one another as well.
I do want to point out that my personal take on their relationship is tempered by me being in my 40's and having more than one long term relationship (namely my closest and longest-running friendship which is going on 25 years now, and my marriage which is almost 15 years old this year) where there IS that familiarity and "safety" to sometimes have cutting conversations, or at least "brutally honest" conversations, telling each other things we might not want to hear, but perhaps need to.
My best friend, for example, saw me through a 6-year relationship that was actually abusive. She felt that she had to tell me some truths that I needed to hear, and while some things she told me were hard to hear during that period, I'm so glad she felt safe and comfortable enough with me to be honest about what she saw happening.
She is not a fuzzy-wuzzy cuddly person. But she is MY person. She has been my rock for nearly a quarter century. I would actually trust this woman with my life. I would donate a kidney to this woman if I were a match and she needed one. We are not cutesy fuzzy with each other (although most of the time we're warm, generous, and supportive like a certain witcher and minstrel duo). She's not the type to say "I love you" out loud, so we don't do that because I know that would make her uncomfortable (she's even like this with her partner of several years - some people just aren't as demonstrative with saying the WORDS, but it doesn't mean they don't FEEL it). But we LOVE each other dearly. We don't have to actually say "I love you" to say I love you to one another.
Because we're all human, we can even at times slip up and not be as tactful and sensitive with each other as we should be, or even in a moment of vulnerability get angry and snap (which is completely Geralt in Baptism of Fire). Some of the conflicts I've had with my best friend and my spouse can look a lot like what we encounter in the books between Geralt and Dandelion when they do get into a heated discussion or argument. But these relationships are, to me, "safe" and "always" in my mind and heart. I know we'd have to do something truly *despicable* and abusive to one another for those relationships to end entirely.
What I think people are saying, when they say, "Book Geralt would never *be mean* to Dandelion," isn't that Geralt could never *literally* be mean. It's that the portrayal of their friendship and the conflicts they could have were lacking any kind of context whatsoever. Furthermore, the Netflix show didn't make us believe they were ever MUTUAL friends who loved each other (mutually) in the first place, didn't do enough to build up their relationship and show its history and why they're so bonded to each other, why they're proud of each other, show us HOW the "opposites attract" thing actually works in their relationship, how they add value to each other's lives by having different but complementary personalities, why they had such a strong connection in the first place, why they loved each other, why they enjoyed and valued each other's company and place in their lives.
Instead they made it seem like Geralt was simply tolerating this silly little guy who gets him into trouble all the time, and then out of nowhere you get a tirade of verbal abuse that goes on about how this silly little guy ruined his entire life, and basically a "get out of my life" tirade which is extremely hurtful and broke the show character's heart (understandably enough). Geralt also punches Dandelion in the show, and while they have their share of verbal arguments in the books, Geralt never lays a hand on Dandelion, and even goes out of his way to protect him and save him from violence and physical danger multiple times throughout the entire saga.
Geralt's attempts to push the Hanza away in Baptism of Fire are often cited as the example of Geralt being mean, by Netflix viewers who are confused by book fans saying Geralt being mean isn't canon.
But I think book fans pretty universally agree that Geralt's "meanness" in Baptism of Fire actually stems partially from him wanting to protect the other members of the Hanza from danger, and partially from feeling like he's messed everything up so badly he doesn't *deserve* help or support, or that he can't *truly atone* for Ciri's separation and unhappiness unless he completes the mission entirely alone.
He tries to emotionally push everyone away by being, well, a jerk (which if one is looking to push people away, that can definitely be an effective way of doing so). But his friends see right through this defense mechanism, seem to intuitively know where it's coming from, and seem to understand what he's going through, and are not afraid to call him out on it!
They rightfully roast him for it, but in a way that to me comes across as loving, albeit tough love. To me it's in the vein of, "We see right through your nonsense, we know why you're being like this, because you think you're leading us right into harm's way and you don't want to do that, plus you're losing your mind because you're in a lot of pain and you've lost your daughter and de facto wife who you were JUST beginning to mend fences with before she and your daughter were ripped away from you, so you're freaking out and not being rational. This isn't going to work on us, we're not going to leave you, so just sit down, chop these veggies, and eat this fish soup with us, and shut up you silly man." My favorite moment is when Milva makes the remark about how wolves don't actually hunt alone. Wolves are, after all, pack animals who work as a team to survive.
Modern toxic masculinity harkens a lot to his idea of "alpha males" and "lone wolves" which is total fallacy and nonsense and runs completely counter to what real life is actually like. People, like wolves, are communal animals. We literally need one another to survive. Interdependence, not independence, is the optimal way of being human. Having love, comeraderie, and support are not just frivolities, they're necessities!
To close this, I think the heart of why book fans take issue with this portrayal of their friendship is that Dandelion and Geralt are the longest running thread through the series, each other's "always" person (which in a long lifetime often IS someone's closest platonic relationship, whether that be a chosen best friend or a close sibling for example), and they're so instrumental to each other's character development, that to bludgeon that in the show just runs so counter to what I feel as a fan of this series is one of its central themes, which is that nobody actually CAN do everything alone and without support, that being isolated and alone really leads down a dark path for us as human beings. By stripping away this piece of the story (Dandelion and Geralt's friendship in its true nature, not a contrived one) it fails to adapt the story on that level.
Keep in mind that these are just my opinions. If you made it this far, thanks for reading!
#the witcher#the witcher spoilers#long post#geralt and dandelion#book dandelion#book geralt#geralt's relationships#baptism of fire#the witcher books#the witcher saga#wiedźmin#dandelion#dandelion the minstrel#geralt of rivia#geralt z rivii#geralt#friendships#relationships#allegory#andrzej sapkowski#geralt being mean#and what that means in the show vs the book#gerlion#Sapkowski is good at writing people realistically is what I'm saying#the witcher netflix#the “off screen” and “off page” time w/ Dandelion + Geralt I just assume has kindness/ tenderness/support between them#because it's implied and referenced in other ways
42 notes
·
View notes