#Star Trek book review?

[boneskullravenriver]

Guys, I'm going to read the homo book. Wish me luck

[holdy-caulfield]

My small review on Star Trek book:

Doctor’s Orders by Diana Duane. With spoilers!

Genre: hard sci fi

Pages: 291

Key words: worldbuilding, alien culture, time, strategies, psychology, Hippocratic Oath, tlinguistics, first time in command, stressful situations

Highlights: McCoy is in character, Kirk mostly, battle, crew work, humor, worldbuilding

Downsides: reason why McCoy is in command (unrealistic, OOC for Kirk), Spock & McCoy interactions (too friendly for them), lack of tension.

Vibe/tone: nerdy, light-hearted

I really enjoy sci-fi as a whole genre, and the worldbuilding aspect is what has drawn me into Star Trek in the first place (second place was a video of Kirk and Spock). When it comes to fiction based on the franchise & fanfiction for me the most important aspect are canonical characters and their relationship.

I’ve heard a lot of good stuff about Diana Duane, so I was exited to get my hands on her books. Since McCoy is my favourite character, I decided to start with the book where he’s in a primal focus.

Also, the premise seemed great, as I was very curious how McCoy would behave as a commander of the ship, and I was particularly interested how he would handle Spock, as there were a few instances in the show where Spock and McCoy have been left without Kirk. The book cover showed Spock standing firmly next to our favourite doctor in the captain’s chair. Also, I thought that the idea itself is intriguing enough — what will be the difference in the decision making between a trained soldier and a doctor? The book even starts with a Hippocratic Oath.

This book does feel like an episode. It’s relatively short, the whole action takes place in a span of a few days, it has an idealistic nature, and a perfectly good ending. All characters are in fact in character, which is why Diane is often praised.

The dialogue and humor are good, you can even hear original voices and intonations, there’s a lot of strategic decisions during battle and I love watching/reading the whole crew working together as the whole.

The fact that McCoy is new to commanding, helps the reader to understand what’s going on better and his decisions, and it is easier to imagine how you’d feel in his shoes. The whole McCoy commanding aspect in my opinion was very in character.

The book however has a lot of focus on the planetary species and human characters getting to know them better, studying them and discussing them from a scientific perspective (so, the book puts science into science fiction). It was a curious read, but I think it is not exactly for those who came for action adventure. A bunch of scientists discussing species and linguistics is the bigger part of the book. I love this stuff as I said earlier, I personally could read all these discussions about interesting species and their culture forever, but I can imagine it can be boring for some (although IMO if you’re a ST fun you should expect this).

I quickly understood what’s going with them personally but there were some aspects which I didn’t quite understand or were not explained enough (so, why Ornae were building stuff? Maybe I’m forgetting something, but I don’t remember if they gave a clear answer). I also didn’t get why ;At would say yes in the end. It felt for me rather logical that they would say no. I didn’t feel that either Federation either the species would benefit in anything else then knowledge. Well, they could protect the planet, but… I thought ;At are a bit too powerful to really need this.

There are also Klingons. I thought it was a very nice touch that doctor managed to find a common ground using psychology. It was funny, but also believable.

Klingons however do not feel as a threat, well, not dangerous enough. Klingons’ motivation to be on the planet however for me personally seemed not really satisfactory for a reader. It made them even less threatening (while they of course shouldn’t be exactly threatening, I just wished for more… spice). I really did like the unexpected friendliness simply because McCoy is a professional medic and knows psychology, it’s very in character and canonical. I enjoyed the bits when he uses his profession to command and even as a moral compass.

My biggest issue was there was not enough tension. And it is primarily because of Spock.

It might be my own vision, but what I can judge from the show is that Spock and McCoy have a complicated relationship in the span of the series. Their philosophies opposite each other, while both characters are not so different as either McCoy or Spock would think (they both are very emphatic for example) so it creates this unique dynamic of a lot things being unsaid and truths ignored.

Most of the time when McCoy and Spock are left alone with each other, they start an argument and can say actually hurtful things to each other, also, it’s quite obvious to me that Spock likes McCoy, while McCoy’s reaction to him is not exactly unambiguous. There should be tension. It what makes it interesting.

In the book, McCoy and Spock are as friendly as could be. Of course there are a few funny moments, but for me there should be a lot more bickering, a lot more emotions involved around Kirk’s disappearance, and there could be just done more (for example, there could be a danger which would force them to leave the orbit, but McCoy wants to stay to find Jim, and Spock is there to try to make him understand the logics and the fact that he feels that Jim is alright… ).

Kirk is there to balance Spock and McCoy out. The idea of McCoy being forced to rely on Spock with whom he disagrees mostly, or Spock relying on emotional McCoy is such an interesting concept, so it’s a pity for me I didn’t get this explored in the book.

And Kirk isn’t in a real danger, which also makes it lack tension. But it’s probably my own issue, I like “damsel in distress” trope when it comes to strong characters like the Enterprise crew and the trio in particular.

Overall, it was an enjoyable read. Despite the lack of tension, there is good dialogue, realistic approach to the idea of a medical doctor being in command, the battle is great, worldbuilding is creative, and overall it is very TOS-y.

[dailyplanetmedia]

If Todd Phillips really is done with DC Universe after Joker 2... what a disappointment of a film. Where will this Joker character go from here? A cliffhanger like The Sopranos. That's it, you just sopranos joker. But shitier.

[very-bad-poetry-captain]

TOS book review McCoy edition – Dreams of the Raven

I joked that one day I’d write a book review based on specific McCoy questions… A McCoy meter if you will. Well, I decided to do it! Not to be taken too seriously except that my love for McCoy (and his suffering) is no joke. Contains some spoilers for the book.

Title: Dreams of the Raven Author: Carmen Carter. Year published: 1987

To summarize the book in two sentences:

McCoy loses his memory in the middle of a mission and thinks he’s in his early twenties again. This is fun for exactly no one. 

Official plot summary:

A merchant ship’s frantic SOS sends the Enterprise speeding to the rescue! But the starship’s mission of mercy soon becomes a desperate struggle for survival against a nightmarish enemy Captain Kirk can neither identify nor understand, an enemy he must defeat without the aid of one of his most trusted officers. For the Leonard McCoy Kirk knew is gone. In his place stands a stranger – a man with no memory of his Starfleet career, his family, his friend or the one thing James T. Kirk needs most of all… his dreams.

This book is for you if you:

would love to study McCoy under a microscope

enjoy exciting mystery plots

have a strong stomach (trigger warning for gore/body horror/autopsy scenes)

The ultimate McCoy questionnaire (below the read-more):

Is McCoy in it? McCoy is the main character and the main problem and somehow also the solution.

Is McCoy in it a lot? So much. But it’s mostly the amnesiac McCoy that no one likes mean. Somehow the “young” McCoy gets it in his head that the “old” McCoy should die for his crimes (that is, being human enough to have made mistakes throughout life) and it’s up to the young McCoy to quit Starfleet and start his life over. I’d say half the book revolves around this plot (to my great amusement).

Does he get to be concerned over whatever angst has befallen Kirk lately? It’s the opposite around – Kirk gets to worry himself sick over McCoy :3 The young McCoy doesn’t even remember who Kirk is. Kirk is extremely upset by this (yay!) and really wants his bestie back. Quote from Kirk (barely controlled rage): “It’s your duty as a doctor, as my ship’s surgeon… […] Somewhere inside of you is a man who would stop at nothing to save a friend’s life, to save any life, no matter what the personal cost. It was that quality that made him the best medical officer in Star Fleet. If you don’t have that same passion for the value of life, you’ll never be half the doctor he was. Or half the man.”

Does he get to have silly little arguments with Spock?                  Yes, of course, Spock can’t resist him. They were literally arguing when McCoy got knocked over and lost his memories. After that everyone is sad and depressed because young McCoy refuses to argue with Spock.

Is he the damsel in distress?                    Well, he’s in a lot of distress, that’s for sure. But he gets some action scenes at the end… More like he’s treating himself like a damsel in distress to the detriment of everyone around him. At least we can assume that Spock carried a bleeding McCoy through the ship to Sickbay, since Spock was with him when he hit his head and Kirk reminisces later over Spock being covered in blood… And everyone is very worried about him.

Does he suffer, preferably a lot? Physical and/or psychological torment                          He suffers a lot initially… Then he makes everyone else suffer for a change. Why would you do this, McCoy? Just hurt everyone you love? I just wish he’d remembered it afterwards so he could suffer from guilt, too. That would have been delicious. The book starts off with shore leave being cancelled, and then a lot of the crew get hurt and several die. McCoy comes out of hours upon hours of surgery with trembling hands and a lot of angst. He does fun things like staring at pictures of dead aliens, reading an e-mail from his ex-wife and getting drunk before dropping into bed. Then, of course, after too little sleep he knocks his head so hard he loses his memories and wakes up in Sickbay (and he truly is the worst patient ever). The young McCoy is tormented by not remembering half of medical school, hearing about all the terrible mistakes the old McCoy has done throughout life, and seeing wrinkles on his face in the mirror. Also he’s pretty useless as an officer and can’t remember having ever done surgery on a living being before. Quote from young McCoy: “Since when does Star Fleet hire doctors with an instinct for self-annihilation? No wonder I became chief medical officer. Promotion due to a high rate of casualties.” <-Words from a man whose colleagues knew he’d volunteer to beam into a dangerous situation. If only he knew how much danger he’d volunteered for in the twenty-five years he’s forgotten…

Does he get to whine and complain and be right about it? Even better is he wrong about it?                        He whines A LOT and he is extremely WRONG about it. It’s a miracle no one grabs him by the collar and shakes him around.

Does he get to throw some of that southern charm around?                         Yeah, on the wrong person. Terrible. And extremely fascinating. The young doctor in charge of getting his memories back is no match for young McCoy’s advances, and honestly, who can blame her? Who needs workplace professionalism when you can get your heart broken by sleeping with your boss while his memories are gone. And poor Spock catches them kissing… I’m pretty sure this is why no one tells McCoy what happened afterwards when his memories return. Too awkward.

Does he get to do some medical malpractice?                         Yes, actually, if you count incapacitating aliens as medical malpractice. But mainly he gets to forget everything he ever learned and get it back just in time to take over from the sucky doctor no one likes to save the day. Heroic. (But why is the second most senior doctor on the ship an asshole no one likes? They should have put Chapel in charge or something… I mean obviously it’s because then everyone gets to commiserate over how McCoy is a much better CMO and boss, but still. I have questions.)

Does Spock call him illogical or similar?                         Spock COMPLIMENTS him. What is the world coming to? Better yet – young McCoy calls Spock “sir” and is super polite to him and Spock hates it. And Spock gets the dubious honor of training an amnesiac McCoy for landing party duty. Literally just drills McCoy on protocol for hours so he won’t die. Quote from young McCoy: “Diana must have been pulling my leg about fighting with Spock. I’d rather wrassle a Bengal tiger than cross that man.”

Is he forcibly put through his arch nemesis the transporter? Or the dress uniform? Quote from young McCoy: “You put human beings in that unholy device?”

Does Kirk call him handsome (joke or not this happens more than you'd think)? Not really :/

Bonus points if his accent is pronounced and his speech is full of befuddling southern expressions which make Spock question McCoy's sanity (and me wondering if I need a dictionary) I think they could have had more fun with young McCoy having an accent. But the book does get bonus points for young McCoy’s last memory being that he was thrown off a horse at a ranch (apparently a great way to relax from medical school is riding half-wild young horses? And this from a man who is afraid of transporters…) and therefore gets to have a I don’t think we’re in Kansas anymore… kind of moment.

Criticisms/things I’d change:

Much like in The search for Spock, there’s a serious lack of McCoy/Spock closure at the end of the book. Also, I’d remove the weird romance young McCoy has with the other doctor on the Enterprise that he conveniently forgets about when his memories return. Plus, even though the title literally includes the word dreams there are barely any dreams in the book. They could have spent a little bit more time showing him sweating and moaning from nightmares… alas we were robbed.

Highlights:

The reason McCoy’s memories return (not gonna spoil it). The way Spock and Jim obviously miss him a lot. The mission plot which is really interesting. A very good, slightly insane book! Definitely a recommended read!

Final McCoy meter: 9/10 would read again

[spaceorphanssecondbreakfastclub]

SBC Bookclub : Making It So

Title: Making It So Author: Patrick Stewart Genre: (Auto)Biography

Goodreads Summary :

From his acclaimed stage triumphs to his legendary onscreen work in the Star Trek and X-Men franchises, Sir Patrick Stewart has captivated audiences around the world and across multiple generations with his indelible command of stage and screen. Now, he presents his long-awaited memoir, Making It So, a revealing portrait of an artist whose astonishing life—from his humble beginnings in Yorkshire, England, to the heights of Hollywood and worldwide acclaim—proves a story as exuberant, definitive, and enduring as the author himself.

Review:

The first book in my goal to read one book every week this year. And this one was kind of cheating, since I started it last year. And it took me quite a while to get it complete, so I figured I'd use my challenge to wrap this one up.

Patrick Stewart is really, quite a delight. I've read my fair share of celebrity memoirs, and most of them you can tell have a ghostwriter they're working with -- or the book is nothing more than the celebrity dictating things to you. Stewart's memoir stands out a bit -- the writing is solid and engaging. The vocabulary alone tells you that this memoir has a bit more thought and care, from someone who holds a bit of intellect. And for that I think this is possibly one of the best celebrity memoirs I've ever read.

I think, though, what captivated me the most is somewhat surprising. This book is a love letter to theater. Mainly, British theater - but the bulk of the book is dedicated to Stewart telling remarkable stories about the stage. It's kind of a joy, like listening to an act of old reminisce about the old days and what it was like. Even after he gets into Star Trek related things, and his rise in Hollywood, the focal point of theater never changes, and for that I have a lot of respect.

If you're looking for Star Trek - it is there (though the last thirty years of Stewart's life is compressed into only a hundred pages). And he does speak kindly, though honestly, and also humbly, about his experiences. There is also brief mention of the X-Men franchise, too (and his beloved friendship with Ian McKellen). But while acknowledging and respecting what he is most known for, it takes up very little room in the book.

There are some, though somewhat held back, accounts of more personal things. He does talk about his family, though more so in the opening chapters. And he's also candid about his marriages, though is respectful of the subject material.

Overall, though, Patrick Stewart comes of as a guy who is accepting of who he is now that he's older, and is having fun with life, after living a somewhat strict one for so long. But more so than anything - he comes off as a man who is passionate about the theater, and delights in sharing his story with everyone else to hear.

I definitely recommend it -- even if you are here for the Star Trek, I think think there's a joy to be found in this book.

Rating : 5 Stars

[nerdgatehobbit]

To celebrate Star Trek DS9’s 32nd anniversary, I read the “Emissary” novelization. Overall, I really liked it.

Early on, there’s this quote: “Sisko realized he was bigoted against bigots, but it was one bias he did not strive to transcend.” Page 23 in my edition) That is certainly a good way of framing the paradox of tolerance.

About a hundred pages later, there’s a section in Jake’s POV about how Benjamin has been teaching Jake on respecting different cultural beliefs. The handling of Jake and Nog’s interactions is a bit rough and I’m not quite sure yet how I feel about it. Poor Rom hasn’t been named yet at this point- he appears but only is referred to as Nog’s father. Going back to Jake, I do appreciate how the novelization is more open about how Jake has also been grieving and has been affected by his father being ‘stuck’ in the moment of his mother’s death. The idea that Jake struggled to make long-lasting friendships at the shipyards makes sense and adds more nuance to why he latched onto Nog.

The handling of Benjamin & Jadzia’s friendship was a bit off-kilter, but I get the sense they were leaning into that awkwardness of the adjustment to the new host. Captain Picard gets a bit more focus, especially in his discomfort upon realizing exactly why Sisko holds a grudge. It initially sat uncomfortably with me that at one point he views Sisko as “young”. But Memory Alpha says that the characters were born nearly three decades apart (2305 for Picard; 2332 for Sisko) so fair enough.

Keiko and Molly get to be reoccurring characters here, to the point that I wonder if this novelization was based off an earlier script that included them before realizing they needed to streamline the pilot to highlight the new characters. This book also helpfully has Miles O’Brien reflect on his history with Cardassians, which gave me enough information to be able to look up he’s thinking about events that were featured in the TNG episode “The Wounded”. I say ‘featured’ because I am pretty sure some were flashbacks and others were then-current.

Sometimes the narrative was a bit heavy-handed in spelling out the subtext of characters’ motivations but to be fair there are a lot of characters & motives taking place. I think the book went too easy on Bashir’s “frontier medicine” remark, easier than I feel the actual episode did. Though maybe that’s my 2020s perspective talking.

The spots where it was clearest this book was rooted in the pilot are when it touches on Odo and Bashir’s backstories. Odo’s past with the scientists hadn’t been established yet, nor Bashir’s augmentation. There is also no mention of Garak but maybe he’s lying low and/or repairing his shop at this point in-universe? I’m unsure if Nog’s scorn about living with a mother when Jake asks is from to the writers not yet figuring out the form of sexism in Ferengi society versus Nog being on the defensive about his mother’s absence. It can be read as the second in hindsight.

I think that it wouldn’t take much to edit Bashir’s musings without giving away the big spoiler. Just tweak it to something along the lines of “for almost as long as he could remember he’d been cleverer than his peers”, “he became more aware of his outsider status as a teen”, and then outright add in somewhere, even in a different POV section of his, him wondering if there were any telepathic or empathic species on the station. To those starting the show, the first 2 would seem like more of his ego and last another nod to his wide-eyed fascination on his first posting. But those in the know would definitely know the significance of the 1st two, and the last is admittedly a handwave on why Bashir wouldn’t even be thinking too loudly about his augmented status.

Kira’s prickliness is well captured, with her still being respected by the others. Okay, O’Brien is a bit uneasy, but to be fair, she’s his superior so having one with an obviously short fuse is admittedly not a great way to start a new posting, especially as he hadn’t quite realized of her being targeted in her wrath rather than indiscriminate.

Jadzia is remarkably chill here and hasn’t yet gained the complexity she got in later seasons. Which is understandable but also still frustrating. Jennifer remains more someone being grieved than a character in her own right, but that still is a storytelling issue now, let alone three decades ago.

I do greatly appreciate how the book does spotlight Benjamin Sisko’s complexity and the changes he undergoes in the pilot. After all, he is the main character. It is touched on that his dad was a gourmet chef, so that aspect must have been thought up very early in the process. The book does a good job conveying the layers of Brooks’ acting.

Quark is Quark, with his hidden depths not yet seen. As previously mentioned, they don’t seem to have a firm grasp on Odo, though some of that could be him not doing much self-reflection. I’m now wondering if Odo and Quark did simply dislike each other during the Cardassian occupation and at the start of the show, with the tangled mess of multiple emotions coming later, or if it’s something established by later episodes that they’ve always had a complicated dynamic that supersedes the pilot novelization in terms of ranking what’s canon.

They don’t fully understand Gul Dukat’s misunderstanding of himself as the hero, but they did describe his behavior at one point as “imperious” as an example of they knew how he behaved very well, just needed to get a better grasp on the why. Fair enough for the pilot, though.

I’m probably forgetting to discuss at least one something, but this is all I can think of right now. It was an interesting read, particularly in putting a slightly different take on the events of “Emissary”. Has anyone else read it?

[anewstartrekfan]

Finally finished Enterprise: The First Adventure and it was fun but unfortunately and likely accidentally, it made Kirk a creep

SPOILERS

Okay so unfortunately there is a massive elephant in the room regarding this book. For, what I can only guess was a ploy to sell other Star Trek books so this could get developed more, they decided to give Janice Rand a tragic backstory. In this tragic backstory, her family was traveling on a ship, and due to a warp drive/core issue, they accidentally time traveled 3 years into the future.

This happened when she was a child, but due to the aftermath and Janice herself hiding the truth so she could support her younger brothers, the records never got corrected. So at the time the book takes place, she is legally 19, but physically 16.

No one knows the truth besides Uhura, but the book ends with Janice promising to tell Jim everything.

Which means if she does tell him, in that first half of s1 of TOS, Jim Kirk is knowing crushing on a teenager.

I guess it should also be noted that Jim is mostly annoyed with Janice more than anything else in this. He doesn’t think he should need an assistant as he’s never had one before but is forced to admit he does and instead of picking one just asks the whoever is in charge of the yeoman’s to send him someone. So they send Rand and she is meek and nervous and oh my god what happened to her? This was not Rand in the tv show. But big picture is it’s never implied he’s attracted to her in this book.

Which would be fine if I didn’t have a tv series that suggested otherwise.

There are a lot of things in this book I think would make for a fun live action episode, but good god do we not need this.

Please.

Get this away from me.

God why is this even here?

[admiralgiggles]

Lal is stalking “Daddy” (Brent Spiner), and all kinds of weird, dark hilarity ensue. You don't necessarily need to be a fan of Star Trek, either. He does explain who Lal is for those like myself who've never seen the episode.

*Do not come for me. 💀

[youngpettyqueen]

oh I havent been posting about it but the Trek reading journey has been continuing! I switched gears into TOS for this one, because I got a copy of The Price of the Phoenix at a book sale a while back so ive been reading that one! this one has been much slower going because ive been underlining a lot and I havent had as much time/energy to read this last week

that all said. this book is gay as hell

[quarkspeed]

Reading Killing Time now!!! Three chapters in and I honest to God wondered if I wasn’t just reading some juicy ass Spirk fanfic. It’s fantastic.

[sirellas]

Left Hand of Destiny (1&2) stream of consciousness review

Overall thoughts: I really liked this book! Or technically 2 books but the second is just the continuation of the first so in my head it was just one long book (~500 pages all in all). This is only the second trek book I've read and also the second written by the actor who played the character in ds9 (shoutout to ASIT, though this one has a non-actor co-writer as well), but even beyond the star trekking of TLHOD, this was a really good read in terms of writing style, pace, emotion. It was very action and character focused which I enjoyed, and especially the characterization of Martok was so great and obviously JG Hertzler had a lot of thoughts about the character he played that translated really well on page.

The memory alpha article on TLHOD says this but I didn't really start to see it until the last half of book 2, but this is very much a King Arthur story (btw don't look at that memory alpha page unless you don't care about major spoilers lol). Down to a lady in the lake handing out mythical swords. That instance was a little heavy handed in my opinion, but I did like all of the prophetic dreams and talk of glorious purpose.

That's something to note though: if you don't like dream sequences, this is not the book for you. There are A LOT of dreams. In fact the opening scene is a dream, but it's now my new favorite opening line in a book because it jumps right in by telling you who this guy is and what his deal is:

I personally am a big fan of overt symbolism like this (even a well done cliché or two), myths and repeating cycles of heroism etc etc. And I think this book melded Arthurian drama with Klingon drama well. The Klingon-ness of this book was great. What better way to get to the heart of Klingon culture in a story but by focusing on the guy chosen to lead his people and getting it ripped out from beneath his feet and having to decide that he actually wants to be chancellor. In a lot of ways this is a story of outcasts finding their way back to where they belong, which isn't always what they expect or want in the beginning. Which leads me to...

The supporting characters really made this book. Without Pharh the Ferengi who got bullied for being as ugly as a Klingon as a child and now runs a landfill on Qo'noS, there would be no book. He's my favorite (little buddy coded to the extreme) but most of the major side characters are really well explored in terms of motivation and actions. Worf, Sirella, Ezri, Darok, Kahless, Alexander, to name a few. Alexander and Kahless were two of my other surprise standouts. And because no one who hasn't read this book knows about my new favorite guy Pharh, I will now include a couple passages I highlighted to spread the word about how great he is:

Wide array of well developed side characters aside, this book is awful for women. Yes the main antagonist is Martok's insane ex, but her character is kind of too outlandish to really have much depth. Ezri shows up at the end of book 1 and plays a big part in book 2 but honestly I'm not sure why she was even there (apart from loyalty etc, but I mean story-wise she didn't add all that much to keep the action moving ((anyone else could have been subbed in for her 9 out of 10 times and it would've made more sense tbh)) except to be another explainer of Klingon things to the reader). Sirella has a few great scenes, but not nearly enough and she wasn't allowed to do much either in terms of agency and impact on plot. Martok's two daughters are barely afterthoughts.

The main plot is that a usurper attacks Qo'noS (and specifically goes after Martok), swaying the Klingon people to their side through a combo of bioengineered charisma and the people's growing resentment toward progressive ideas that Martok (and Worf) represents. That's really only the problem in book 1, while book 2 deals more with Martok accepting the hand fate has dealt and deciding to win so they can save the decaying Klingon heart and so on. But even with the kind of cheesy setup, it rarely felt overwrought or unearned with the emotional beats. The antagonist lady is, yeah, she's a bit over the top. And before 2016 I would've said the quick flip to xenophobia and Make Klingons Great Again (I'm pretty sure they use that phrase almost exactly) in the general public was unrealistic but hey, cycles of destiny and evil constantly shifting and repeating, am I right??

There were... quite a few deaths. I guess I should've expected that, being a Klingon setting and all, but some of them hit me hard. And a few I don't think really needed to happen and kind of weakened the narrative.... maybe I'll put a spoiler section below a cut at the bottom of this to discuss those 🤪

This paragraph will haunt me for a while I think... 😀 sorry for inflicting it on others now but hey that's show business

Even with some hiccups (see spoiler section below), I loved the book pretty much. Shocker: tumblr user girlmartok loves the Martok book, but it was better than I had hoped even. The Martok focus was so good and the side characters just made it even better. Much more of a heroic fantasy than most star trek settings, which fit really well and also was refreshing. It's long! But I would recommend it if you have any interest in Klingons and/or fun little guys who go on adventures and think a lot about death.

SPOILERS ⬇️

Okay ripping the bandaid off. The way Sirella died was not chill. I mean even having her die was not something I would have included, because the story really didn't dive all that deep into her and Martok's relationship. But ramming an enemy ship so Martok could flee near the beginning of book 2... and she doesn't even kill any major bad guys doing it?? It just served no point narratively (the bad guys still outnumbered them, still caught up to them not long after) and it didn't even really affect Martok all that much beyond like one paragraph where he wants to turn around and go on a murder spree in her name... He doesn't even get to go on a murder spree in her name!!!

Bandaid rip #2: PHARH MY LITTLE BABY BOY DIES???? I was glad I had forewarning about this one because I would've been mad otherwise. I am not exaggerating saying he was my second favorite character in this book after Martok. The humor he added, yes, but also just his role as an outsider who's seen as weak by both Ferengi and Klingon, and he befriends the chancellor of the Klingon Empire, HOLDS ONTO THE CHANCELLOR'S RING FOR MOST OF THE BOOK AND BECOMES HIS SQUIRE BASICALLY 🫠💔 I don't know how anyone wouldn't fall in love with him. At least his death was done well, even though I don't think it should have happened. He at least got a murderous rampage in his name 😤 and Martok basically adopted him so he could get into Sto'vo'kor 🥺

Those were my main two criticisms of the book, and really ties into why this wasn't as great a story as ASIT, for example. A lot of things happen to Martok, but some things don't get the resolution they would need to influence him on this character journey he's going on. One of Martok's defining characteristics in ds9 is that he's a wife guy and his wife doesn't take bullshit. But then his wife dies suddenly and he's upset but he's not Upset upset, if you know what I mean. It didn't feel earned and it didn't feel necessary. Literally the first and only time it did feel like a reasonable plot device was at the very end when Worf tells him that people love a tragic victor even more than a victory. The problem is just that Martok doesn't ever explore what that tragedy really means to him.

Justice for Shen and Lazhna, Martok's daughters, who in addition to dying off screen are only brought up to highlight how shitty of a dad Martok has been. He just thinks of them (and his son Drex too but he gets more characterization solely by virtue of appearing in the narrative) in terms of himself and his love for them is more on the side of pity rather than real emotional attachment. Sirella should've been way meaner to him about that tbh.

Non character death related but a big focus of the first book was Martok losing public opinion pretty much immediately. Old friends turn against him and that really shakes him. But then in the second book... that's not really brought up again? The whole second book takes place away from Qo'noS, and yeah they mention that people will probably become less affected by the dumb bioengineered charisma after time, but I cannot stress enough how much the entire planet hated him. So he won the big battle against his foes etc etc, came back to Qo'noS and... just told everyone all that?? That goes along with the lack of fully exploring the consequences of some of these bad things that happen to Martok. It felt like a little too much piled on him and not enough resolution.

[alanjporterwriter]

Books Read in 2024 #65 - “ Star Trek DS9: Vengeance ” by Dafydd ap Hugh.

An almost deserted Deep Space Nine is invaded and captured by a group of rogue Klingons while most of the command crew are off on a mission. Leaving a small group of Bashir, O’Brien, Garak, Quark, Ron and Jake Sisko to take back the station while also trying to figure out which side Worf is on.

There’s no deep philosophical discussion or character development here. It is instead a straightforward fun adventure romp set around the events of the 5th season of DS9 so it’s helpful to have some familiarity of that to appreciate the background context of who’s who.

[inconvenienttrekkie04]

Just read the graphic novel Star Trek The Q Conflict, all i got to say is why the fuck is it so short? I wanted to see more character interactions what was the point in mixing all the crews if they barely fucking talk to eachother?! Like great concept but less great execution. I will not be recommending this book because close to nothing happens really and honestly the art is one of the only redeeming qualities of this book overall a 4.5 maybe 5 out of 10

[shadowwingtronix]

Chapter by Chapter> Star Trek: The Vulcan Academy Murders chapters 3 & 4

BW Media Spotlight's Chapter by Chapter breaks out two short chapters for this part of Star Trek: The Vulcan Academy Murders chapters 3 & 4

Chapter By Chapter (usually) features me reading one chapter of the selected book at a time and reviewing it as if I were reviewing an episode of a TV show or an issue of a comic. There will be spoilers if you haven’t read to the point I have, and if you’ve read further I ask that you don’t spoil anything further into the book. Think of it as a read-along book club. Yes, two chapters this week…

[very-bad-poetry-captain]

TOS novel book review - McCoy edition nr 2

By popular demand I'll continue these... but since I'm on holiday I picked a short story this time - probably not a well known one but I really enjoyed it!

Link to the first one

Title: Where Everybody Knows Your Name (part of the short story collection Constellations)

Author: Jeffrey Lang

Year published: 2006

To summarize the story in two sentences:

McCoy is forced to present one of Spock's papers at a conference together with Scotty. Unfortunately we only get to see the trouble they get into on the way home.

Official plot summary:

As the Enterprise approaches the end of her five-year mission, Dr. McCoy and Mr. Scott step off the ship for an adventure of their own, involving a misguided Klingon and several Denebian slime devils - proving once again that you're only as old as the liquor you drink.

This book is for you if you:

Can accept that you won't get to read about McCoy actually presenting Spock's research at a starbase

Can accept that they don't even show McCoy pestering Spock about it

Like reading about McCoy getting drunk with Scotty (scones anyone?)

Enjoy McCoy getting kidnapped

(It's actually really good despite my slight disappointment over missed potential)

The ultimate McCoy questionnaire (below the read-more):

1. Is McCoy in it?

Yeah for sure it's his pov mostly

2. Is McCoy in it a lot?

This author really likes McCoy (a man of my own taste) I only wish it had been longer. It starts off with McCoy agonizing over the end of the mission and feeling old (classic), goes on to give him ample room for complaints about the conference's accommodations, and ultimately allows him to do some drunken commiserating together with Scotty.

3. Does he get to be concerned over whatever angst has befallen Kirk lately?

Well he tries but Jim won't let him. Uno reverse card kinda thing, really.

4. Does he get to have silly little arguments with Spock?

Not really, no. But they sneak in some meaningful eye contact for mysterious reasons. He does all the arguing with Jim in this one.

Quote:

"You were only here for a day," Kirk said.

"I do not think he means Denebia, Captain," Spock interjected.

McCoy was surprised to hear the comment come from the first officer, but the two locked gazes for a lingering moment. Something in his eyes made the doctor wonder if he was the only one who was feeling like it was time for a change.

👆note the lingering slipped in there. Which could mean nothing.

5. Is he the damsel in distress?

I mean, aliens do kidnap him, but they do it very badly. And he gets to win a barfight. What's a cracked rib or two in the grand scheme of things if you get to befriend a random Klingon, much to the shock and consternation of your captain?

6. Does he suffer, preferably a lot? Physical and/or psychological torment

Well. The suffering is pretty tame in this one, with some regular end of mission anxiety. Obviously he thinks Jim and Spock would continue to work together in some manner and leaves himself out of it ofc. We can assume most of the suffering was done during the presentation at the conference, which, again, we don't get to read about.

Quote:

Somewhere in the middle of the second day of lectures, meetings, and endless technical debates, he had lost all will to live.

"I'd be thrilled if my only problem was depression," McCoy said from his bunk. "But I think I'm also suffering from a bout of murderous rage mitigated by nervous exhaustion and, oh, my back hurts. I think I've mentioned my mattress?"

"Aye, Doctor," Scotty said. "Once or twice."

"I'm going to kill Jim. And Spock. Spock first."

7. Does he get to whine and complain and be right about it? Even better is he wrong about it?   

He's 100% correct that they should stop drinking those drinks named Denebian slime devils. But Scotty proves that they can both transcend the limits of local alcohol tolerance and so after that point everything is great instead. He did really hate the beds at the conference and the ship that takes them to and from the conference. Scotty even says he turned those smallest cabins into storage rooms on the Enterprise so you know it's real bad :/

8. Does he get to throw some of that southern charm around?    

My personal belief is that this is how they won the Klingon over. Unimportant that it contradicts the text.

9. Does he get to do some medical malpractice?

Apparently there are so many doctors and nurses etc training on the Enterprise right now that they can spare him for the conference:/ poor man

10. Does Spock call him illogical or similar?

Another compliment and not a single insult... highly suspicious. Whether or not Jim is putting words in his mouth is up to interpretation.

Quote:

McCoy groaned. "Am I even going to understand what I'm presenting?"

"Bones," Kirk said cheerfully. "I'm surprised to hear you talk that way. When I asked who should go in his place, Spock said, 'We are fortunate to have one of the finest scientific minds in the Federation aboard the ship'."

11. Is he forcibly put through his arch nemesis the transporter? Or the dress uniform?

Presumably but it's not mentioned :/

12. Does Kirk call him handsome (joke or not this happens more than you'd think)?

Jim says he looks like his dog died. Sad.

13. Bonus points if his accent is pronounced and his speech is full of befuddling southern expressions which make Spock question McCoy's sanity (and me wondering if I need a dictionary)

One day I'll find a book that goes as hard as the comics do. But I'm not sure I'll enjoy it.

Criticisms/things I’d change

I truly, desperately, want to read about McCoy presenting Spock's research. I feel robbed... I'll forgive the author only because I assume there was a word limit and the kidnapping thing was pretty funny.

Highlights

McCoy realizing he's become a person who doesn't like being alone anymore and immediately deciding to do a paper on the psychological effects of five-year missions. While drunk ofc. Also how petty he is towards Jim. It's like they were already divorcing lol. All in all a fun little story!

Final McCoy meter: 7/10

A little extra bonus for those who like spock/kirk and/or perhaps mccoy/scotty (for context, the aliens think scotty is kirk and mccoy is spock) (yes mccoy is very upset by this when he finds out):

Kirk elbowed his companion. "What do you think? Fancy a little stew?"

"Ehhhhh..." Spock said without lifting his head from the seat. Apparently the stories about these two having an almost telepathic bond was true because Kirk simply said, "All righty then. Off we go."

[bookwyrmshoard]

Phasers on Stun!: How the Making (and Remaking) of Star Trek Changed the World, by Ryan Britt

Informative, entertaining, and delightful

As a lifelong Star Trek fan, I found Phasers on Stun!: How the Making (and Remaking) of Star Trek Changed the World both very informative and highly entertaining. The book covered things I already knew (for example, how Martin Luther King, Jr., told Nichelle Nichols that she had to remain on the show) , but also went into depth on things I hadn’t known (like the extent to which Nichols was instrumental in getting NASA to diversify the astronaut program, and her subsequent recruiting on NASA’s behalf.)

Like me (and my husband, Mr. Bookwyrm), Ryan Britt is a fan not only of Trek in its many iterations, but also of the ideals and underlying beliefs of Star Trek: its optimism; its vision of a future where all intelligent beings are respected and included regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, or even species; and its preference for diplomatic resolution of conflicts (although Starfleet is willing to fight to defend its member planets when necessary.) Britt looks at how those ideals have been represented throughout the various series of Star Trek, from the original series (TOS) to Strange New Worlds. The shows haven’t always lived up to those ideals—it wasn’t until Discovery that a Star Trek series featured openly LGBTQIA+ characters as regulars, for instance—but from the beginning, the Enterprise crew, and by extension Starfleet and Star Trek itself, was diverse in terms of race, gender, and species. (I suspect the original Enterprise crew would have included more alien crew members if the show could have afforded them.) And while Star Trek’s example of embracing diversity is very much aligned with the liberal and Quaker values with which I was raised, TOS and ST:TNG both had a profound effect in shaping my worldview.

In telling the history of the shows and how they impacted and interacted with popular culture and real-world events, Britt includes quotes and stories from a number of Star Trek luminaries, from writers and showrunners to actors. Some of these are drawn from interviews conducted for various articles Britt (a sci-fi and pop-culture journalist) has written over the years; other interviews took place specifically for this book. The interviews and quotes give an insight into the experiences and motivations of the people who made and remade Star Trek, and continue to do so to this day.

Whether you grew up watching one of the Star Trek shows, came to the fandom as an adult, or simply want to understand the wide appeal of the Star Trek universe, I recommend reading or listening to Phasers on Stun! It’s a warm, loving, but not uncritical look at a pop-culture phenomenon that, at over 50 years old, is still relevant, influential, and dynamic.