All That Remains
Spencer Reid x reader
Best Years Season 2 part seven | part six | part five | part four | part three | part two | part one | season one
summary: it’s the readers first day back on the job and the case has a huge plot twist
warning: normal criminal minds things, angst, sadness, gore, fun stuff
A/N: based on season 8 episode episode 14
“Oh my god, okay I know I’ve seen it before, but the ring is just so beautiful on you,” Penelope gushed as she held Y/N’s that adorned her new engagement ring.
The women of the BAU gathered around her on her first day back to admire the ring. Of course, JJ and Penelope had seen it at least once before, but it was a whole different experience seeing it on her hand.
It had been a total of three weeks since Y/N was discharged from the hospital and she was so excited to get back to work. She couldn’t deal with leave again and since she was fine mentally, all she had to do was wait until she was fine physically.
Spencer tended to her needs every waking moment he was home, much to her detest. He even thought about having her call her mother to stay with her until she was completely healed, but he revoked his idea when she gave him a not-so-loving look. But she was grateful none the less for his love and care for her. She was concerned about him though, sure she was stabbed, but he was the one kidnapped. After Spencer’s psych evaluation, he was deemed fit to go back to work. Y/N was very jealous when he got to go back.
“Thank you,” Y/N blushed as her hand moved to Blake to look at the ring.
“He really did a good job of picking it out,” she declared as she examined the ring.
“Who knew Spence had such good taste?” JJ remarked, making the other women laugh.
Spencer heard the last of the conversation and naturally gave his actual reasoning for his choice. “It actually has nothing to do with taste, I made a decision by averaging all of her jewelry together and using an equation to evaluate which rings--”
JJ coughed making Spencer stop. “Spence, I was joking, you did a great job.”
“Right,” Spencer smiled sheepishly.
“It’s okay, Bubs, I think it was really cool how you chose it,” Y/N reassured the man’s insecurities.
He smiled at the compliment and then turned to Rossi as his voice was heard coming down the steps.
“Okay, okay, I know I saw it at the hospital that day, but you have to let me see it again,” Rossi spoke quickly as he came over to look at the ring again.
Y/N laughed and held out her hand for him to see.
“It’s very you, Y/N,” Rossi commented as he looked at the ring. “Congratulations you two, again.”
“Thanks Rossi,” Spencer smiled at the man gratefully.
“Hey, you know what we should do?” JJ asked, gaining the attention of the rest of them. “We should have an engagement party!”
“Oh my gosh that is a great idea!” Penelope exclaimed, bouncing on her toes happily. “We can have little cupcakes made with rings and all the fun stuff.”
“And I’ll host it,” Rossi said happily, turning to the couple who were just watching the plan being made.
“Oh, Rossi, you don’t have to-”
“No, no, I insist, it’ll be a great time!” Rossi cut Y/N off from her protest.
Y/N turned her head to look at Spencer, wanting his input on the idea. Spencer simply shrugged, muttering a ‘why not’. The both of them knew he wouldn’t take no for an answer.
“Okay, sure, that’d be fun,” Y/N agreed with a smile.
“Excellent,” Rossi said with a nod.
“Guys,” Hotch said, nodding to the round table room.
-------------
“911 what’s your emergency?” The operator’s voice spook.
A pause then an inaudible mutter.
“Hello? What’s your emergency?”
“They’re gone,” The man on the other line responded. “My girls are gone. I need your help.”
“When you say girls, do you mean your daughters?”
“Yes.”
“All right, I need you to stay on the line, sir. Please confirm where you’re calling from.”
“1721 Hillcrest Drive, this can’t be happening.”
“What’s your name, sir?”
“Bruce. Bruce Morrison.”
“How old are your daughters, Mr. Morrison?”
“Thirteen and Seventeen.”
“When was the last time you saw them?”
“They went to bed around 9:30. No, wait, it was Monday. Sarah has a study group, so it was more like 10:00.”
“Sir, today is Wednesday. You haven’t seen them since Monday?”
“No. No, that can’t be right.”
“I’m sorry, sir, but it is. The police have been alerted, sir, and they’re on their way.”
“That call came in an hour ago,” Hotch said, stopping the recording.
The rest of the team sat in stunned silence as they listened to the message.
“How does a single father lose his teenage daughters for thirty-six hours?” JJ asked in disbelief.
“He doesn’t,” Rossi shook his head.
“His girls are gone,” Blake repeated the phrasing of Bruce on the phone.
“Yeah, that’s strange, he didn’t blame anyone,” Y/N pointed, agreeing with Blake’s silent question.
“And he doesn’t use any buzzwords first responders are trained to hear,” Derek added. “He never says missing, abducted, runaway.”
“Maybe that’s what they did, though. Maybe they ran away,” Penelope perked up. She didn’t like to hear the call, let alone have this happening in the first place, she was hoping for a better outcome then what everyone was thinking.
“There’s no history of that,” Rossi argued sadly.
“The likelihood of a stranger abduction in a neighborhood like this is rare. I’ve counted seven turns from the entrance to their driveway,” Spencer announced as he looked down at the map on the table. “No one just stumbled onto the house.”
“And where’s the mother? Could this be a parental child abduction?” Y/N asked, turning her head from Spencer to Hotch.
“Uh, doubtful,” Hotch sighed. “Exactly one year ago today, he made this call.”
With one click on the remote, another 911 call came up. The call was almost exactly the same as the one they had just listened to. Same phrasing, same tone, just replacing ‘girls’ with ‘wife’.
“She’d also been missing for two days before he contacted authorities, and she’s never been found,” Hotch said, stopping the recording.
“This man is either the victim of a serial offender, or he is one,” Rossi said.
“Please tell me this guy’s in custody?” Derek asked with irritation.
“The Salisbury police are at his home, and they’ve been there since the call came in,” Hotch answered.
“There are hard copies and tablet copies of both case files on the plane,” Penelope announced. “It’s a short flight to the eastern shore. There’ll be more when you land.”
The team gathered up all that they had on the round table and made their way to the plane.
-----------
“Bruce and Judy Morrison were well-liked and active in the community,” Y/N said as she looked over the files they had received on the plane.
Spencer sat down beside her, placing a cup of tea on the table.
She smiled and mouthed a thank you which he replied doing the same thing.
“Yeah, all signs point to them living a quiet life,” JJ agreed as she flipped through her own file.
“He’s a writer and a professor, and it looks like she got into real estate a few years ago,” Derek added as his eyes scanned over a page.
“ ‘02, before the market crashed,” Rossi established as he looked at the date.
“Well, ten years later, Judy had an affair with a co-worker. A Jeff Godwin?” JJ’s voice went off in question as she read the name.
“That was discovered in the investigation, but never made it in the papers,” Blake said, leaning in her chair so she could look at JJ.
“Bruce Morrison was a prime suspect, but they never found any evidence, and the affair wasn’t deemed enough of a motive,” Hotch clarified. “The university’s put him on sabbatical since then.”
“He’s been writing forever, and he’s been teaching since 1985,” JJ added, flipping through the pages of the file. “Transcript says he was grief-stricken and couldn’t handle the pressure.”
“Not many people could,” Rossi bargained. “The odds of this event striking the same family on the same day must be a million to one.”
“Mm, close enough,” Spencer hummed, not arguing with the statistic.
“Judy inherited money from her family, and it’s in a trust fund for the girls,” Blake assessed.
“Oh, jeez, please don’t tell me he got rid of his wife for money,” Y/N shook her head.
“Uh, bank records indicate he hasn’t touched the funds, despite the depleting supplemental income from the university,” Spencer eased the worry.
“Yeah, but it could be a combo platter. Revenge and profit,” Rossi argued.
“His wife cheated, and he retaliated in anger, that might not be a surprise, but that doesn’t explain why he would harm his own children,” Derek added, confusion evident in his voice.
------------
“The oldest daughter Sarah had a 4.0 GPA, but she didn’t apply to a single college back east,” Spencer began as he read from the page in the file in his lap. “She got accepted to Stanford early admission. Maybe her father saw going that far away as a form of betrayal.”
“The second one in a year,” Rossi’s voice posed over the phone. “First his wife of twenty-seven years fools around and then probably threatens to end the marriage. A year later, the daughter can’t wait to leave.”
“Abandonment could be the common denominator,” Blake agreed from her seat beside Y/N in the back of the SUV with Derek and Spencer.
“There is another possibility,” Derek interrupted. “Maybe Bruce Morrison didn’t do it. Did the family have any enemies?”
“The only person that could remotely be an enemy would be Jeff Godwin,” Y/N answered, her own mind forming possible theories.
“Mm, looks like he had a pretty solid alibi the night Judy went missing,” JJ’s voice said through the phone. “He was wining and dining with his own wife at a local restaurant.”
“So the only viable suspect back then was the same one we have now,” Blake said.
“All the answers are in that house,” Hotch said as they turned the final corner and came up to the house of the Morrisons.
The front yard was filled with locals as one SUV pulled into the driveway and the other pulled along the side of the street. The doors of the cars echoed shut as they exited the vehicles and walked up to the detective who was waiting for them on the front porch.
“Marty Friedman. Thanks for making the trip,” the detective said as Hotch and Rossi approached him first. “I’ve got search and rescue combing the woods and the Choptank and Wicomico rivers. We’re dredging all the way from here to the Chesapeake. I’m not letting this guy get away with this again.”
“Has he said why he took a day to call?” Y/N posed the question everyone had been wondering. Her hands were stuffed in the pockets of her navy coat from the cool air.
Friedman scoffed. “Claims he doesn’t remember,” he looked back to the window where Bruce was standing, inspecting the new visitors. “He’s been glued to his computer, maybe he needs new material for a novel.”
“We’ll work alongside your team if that’s alright,” Hotch said to Friedman.
“Whatever you need,” he responded with a nod.
The team followed the detective into the house. Y/N looked at Bruce as he eyed down Hotch as they walked into the house.
“Everyone take a room,” Hotch ordered and the team split up and walked amongst the house.
“Looks like Katie stayed in a lot,” Spencer assessed as he and Y/N looked over the young girl’s room. “She has her schedule of when she was gonna try new recipes.”
Spencer flipped through the colorful pages of the book with different recipes and fun sketches.
“She seems like a really sweet girl,” Y/N sighed as she looked through a journal. She then turned to her desk and pointed out some of the things she noticed. “Her charger’s here, but her phone is not.”
“Maybe it’s with her?” Spencer posed.
“Maybe, I’ll have Garcia track it,” Y/N said, pulling her phone out of her pocket.
“It’ll only work if it’s on,” Spencer reminded her.
“It’s worth a try though,” Y/N looked up to Spencer with sad eyes. Of course, her first case back had to do with kids, just her luck.
“If the girls had access to a phone and they were okay, they would have called for help by now,” Spencer said, giving her the same sad eyes she gave him.
Y/N’s thumb stopped typing, she knew he was right, but that guilty feeling in her didn’t want her to.
“Y/N.” Spencer’s hands reached for hers that held her phone. “You okay?”
“Yeah, it’s just-” she let out a shaky breath with a groan- “it’s just my luck that my first case back has to do with kids.”
Spencer looked down sadly, knowing the pain she was feeling.
“But it’s okay, it’s just because it’s the first case, ripping off the bandaid, you know? I’ll get back to being able to carpmentalizing it any second.” She shook her hands out after setting down her phone and the journal she was holding.
Spencer gave her the look. The look that said it’s okay to take a second, it’s okay to talk to me, it’s okay to not be ready all just yet.
“Stop that.”
“Stop what?”
“Stop being so understanding,” she laughed and pointed her finger at him. “I’m fine, I really am, it’s just gonna take a sec to get into the swing of things again.”
“Okay,” he smiled, reaching for her hand,and pulling her into a loving hug that made her heart melt.
-------------
Y/N’s eyes scanned over the box in the basement of the Morrison house. Shelf after shelf filled with buckets and old memorabilia of Judy.
“Wow,” Spencer mused as he walked closer to Y/N from his side of the room. “She had a lot of hobbies before she started selling real estate.”
“Yeah, family projects it looks like,” Y/N nodded. She turned to the shelf she had just been looking at boxes being held on it. “Devoted mom.”
On the boxes were dates written under the label ‘quilts’. The dates went all the way back to 1998, the years Sarah Morrison was born.
“You ready, Reid?” Derek’s voice called from up the stairs.
“Yeah,” Spencer echoed back. “You good?” He asked, turning to Y/N.
She nodded and he turned to head up the stairs.
Her eyes scanned over the boxes again, looking at the only one that was labeled with a name. On the box, it read; ‘Quilts, 1999-200, Katie’. Y/N made sure to keep that in mind for anything in the future and turned up the stairs to follow Spencer.
---------
“So what do you think?” Blake asked, turning to Y/N and Rossi, exiting Sarah’s room. The sobs of Bruce echoed down the hall after Hotch told him they had just found the body of Katie in a river. Sarah had still yet to be found.
“He’s sober, so this is raw emotion,” Rossi answered as the three walked down the hallway. “He lost his legs when Hotch told him.”
“The tears could be guilt as much as grief,” Y/N whispered as a reminder.
“Because that’s what we’re supposed to do when given that news,” Blake said as they rounded the corner and filed down the stairs. “I don’t mean to sound so cynical, but the man writes fiction.”
Y/N and Rossi nodded as they came to the last set of stairs. At the bottom stood Hotch and JJ, who had just gotten off the phone with Derek and Spencer who were at the scene.
“Any sign of Sarah?” Y/N asked, hopeful for a good answer.
“Maybe she’s still out there,” JJ said, just as hopeful as Y/N for a good report from the people on the phone.
“Doubtful, unless she’s found shelter,” Rossi acknowledged as they walked the final steps of the stairs. “It’s supposed to be in the twenties tonight.”
“Now that we’ve got Katie’s body, we should run scenarios for what really happened Monday night,” Blake said.
Hotch hung up his phone and looked up to the group around him. “That was the lab. Bruce definitely fired a gun at some point, there’s residue on the sheets and on the boots.”
Y/N sighed, not wanting to hear that news. “We need to get him to the station.”
The five of them turned as they heard the creaking of the floorboards behind them. At the top of the stairs stood Bruce, hearing the whole conversation.
-------------
“Alright thanks, Spence,” Y/N said, hanging up her phone and turning to Hotch. “That was Reid. He said Katie had skin built up under her nails. They’re on their way back from the M.E. right now.”
“We need to look for defensive wounds on him,” Hotch nodded, leaving the bullpen and entering into the interrogation room.
Y/N walked closer to the one-way window and watched as Hotch entered the room.
“Mr. Morrison, I need to ask you to roll up your sleeves,” Hotch ordered Bruce.
“What?” Bruce asked, turning his head sharply to look at Hotch.
“Please.”
Bruce sighed and rolled up his sleeve on his right arm, revealing small but numerous cuts on his forearm.
“I saw these in the shower this morning when I woke up,” Bruce said sadly, not making eye contact with Hotch. “I have no idea how I got them.”
“Did they happen during the fight?” Hotch asked, referring to the fit a neighbor had told them he heard.
“It wasn’t a fight, it was just parenting,” Bruce tried to explain. “Did the detective tell you about Jeff Godwin? You should talk to him.”
Hotch raised a brow in question at the man.
“He still coaches Sarah’s soccer team, even though it’s ridiculous.”
“Every time I ask you a question, you have this habit of deflecting attention onto someone else,” Hotch remarked, making Bruce become quiet.
Y/N rolled her shoulders, standing up straight as she watched Bruce’s body language, trying to decipher his emotions and behavior. When he stayed unresponsive, Y/N took that as the end of the interview and walked out of the room into the break room.
“Wonder Woman,” Derek greeted the woman as she walked in.
She let out a huff as a greeting back, clearly annoyed with everything that Bruce was saying. “Bruce Morrison wants us to talk to Jeff Godwin.”
“Convenient, since he just walked in,” Spencer said as he walked over to the two by the coffee station.
“Great just what he wanted,” Y/N sighed, moving into the spot next to Derek as he finished making his coffee.
As he moved over for Y/N to make her coffee, he picked up his phone that began to ring.
“Hey, Blake,” Derek answered as he stepped away from the coffee bar.
Y/N poured some creamer into the cup as she listened to Derek on the phone.
“Morgan, we need you to find Jeff Godwin,” Blake’s voice echoed through the phone.
“She isn’t the only one he thinks that,” Y/N sighed, taking a sip of her coffee.
“Uh, he just walked in,” Derek responded, turning to look through the window to Jeff Godwin who was standing in a room to the side of them.
“He did?” Blake mused.
“Says he heard we found Katie, and he’s worried about Sarah,” Derek said, relaying the conversation that Y/N had not heard yet.
“He also texted Sarah the night she went missing and then deleted the text.” Blake’s information made the three’s faces contort in shock and look to Jeff. “It looks like they texted a lot.”
“Really?” Derek said, some anger boiling inside him as he watched Jeff. Without having Blake respond, he hung up the phone and nodded for Y/N to come with him.
“Mr. Godwin,” Y/N greeted as she and Derek entered the room he was in.
“Mr. Godwin, why did you feel it was appropriate to regularly text a seventeen-year-old girl?” Derek asked, getting straight to the point.
“I-I’ve known those girls for a long time-” Jeff shook his head- “Way before anything happened between me and their mother.”
Y/N and Derek’s faces stayed unresponsive, waiting for him to get to the actual intent of why he was texting a teen.
“Look, I coach Sarah.”
“And you didn’t think to request a different team, you know, considering the circumstances?” Y/N asked, her hand not holding her coffee gesturing as she spoke.
“No,” Jeff shrugged. “My daughter plays on that team.”
Once again, Derek and Y/N stayed unresponsive.
“Look, Sarah reached out to me Monday night- God knows she needs a father figure--”
“Maybe the man her mother had an affair with…” Derek began taking a step closer to Jeff.
Y/N took a step also, becoming even with Derek. “Might not be the best person for that,” Y/N finished the statement.
Derek nodded in agreement.
“Look-” Jeff took a step of his own- “I just came in here because I had heard about Katie and I was worried about Sarah. Don’t treat me like a criminal.”
“Sarah deleted texts that the two of you shared,” Y/N said, turning her head to the side. “The same day she disappeared. Now that’s a little suspicious, don’t you agree, Morgan?”
“Mm-hmm,” Derek hummed in response.
“Hey- wait, okay,” Jeff stumbled, pulling his phone out of his pocket. “They’re all here. We agreed to meet in the parking lot of the convenience store on route 113.”
He turned his phone, showing the texts to Y/N and Derek. Derek took the phone from the man’s hand, putting it between the two of them so they could read it.
“Is this a regular thing for you?” Derek asked as he read the texts.
“Well, we’ve met there a couple of times recently, when she was really scared about what was happening with her and her dad,” Jeff responded.
“What was happening?” Y/N asked.
Jeff took in a deep breath, almost like he was afraid to tell them. “Bruce gets...violent when he drinks, and it’s been getting worse.”
Derek and Y/N turned their heads, silently saying for him to elaborate more on the topic.
Jeff let out a breath through his nose. “Sarah had every reason to be terrified. I mean look what happened.”
Derek and Y/N nodded, handing Jeff his phone back and heading out of the room. When they walked out, they were greeted with the whole team now, including Penelope on a video call.
“Is everyone there?” Penelope asked prompting Hotch to nod. “Um, this call came in on Monday.”
Before she continued, Hotch walked over to the door of the conference room and closed it.
“It was made on Katie’s cell, which is still M.I.A., the only 800 number she called was the local abuse hotline. She called there a few times in the last couple of months,” Penelope explained, pressing play on the recording. JJ turned up the TV volume.
“My name is Katie Morrison, I called last week,” Katie’s voice rang through the speaker.
“Yes, Katie, I remember you,” the operator on the other line responded.
“He’s at it again. He’s just going crazy. He’s really drunk.”
“Katie, are you safe?”
“Yes, hold on.”
“Hi, it’s Sarah,” Sarah’s voice came into the call. “We’re okay. I can handle this.”
“Girl’s open the door,” Bruce’s voice yelled next. “Katie, open the door.”
The sound of loud banging was heard next, making Y/N squeezing her eyes shut.
“I said open the door!”
When the recording stopped, Y/N opened her eyes and watched as Hotch asked to have the recording sent to his phone and took Rossi to the interrogation room holding Bruce.
-----------
Y/N watched through the glass as Bruce began to remember the night as the call was played to him. As it ended, he slammed his hand on the table, repeating the same words he said in the call. He looked up to the glass, on his side being a mirror so he was looking at himself.
He walked closer to it, his demeanor changing slightly as he looked at himself.
What surprised everyone behind the glass was what he said next.
“Oh my god, what a pathetic little cry baby.”
The rest of the team that was behind the glass looked at each other in confusion, continuing to listen to the man as he spoke.
“Ugh,” Bruce rubbed his eyes. “I was always right about you, huh?”
He was still talking to himself in the mirror. He then turned around, a smug smirk playing on his face as he looked at Rossi and Hotch.
“So you got old Bruce-y in a cage, huh?”
Rossi and Hotch didn’t respond, still trying to decipher who this was and what was happening.
“You think that’s gonna help?” Bruce walked around the two agents and back over to his chair. “It’s only gonna make him hide longer.”
When he reached the chair, he faced the two men again. “What do you wanna know?”
Rossi and Hotch stayed quiet again, not sure what to do.
When they didn’t give him a response, the man spoke again. “I’m gonna have to tell you ‘cause the baby’s got his pacifier.”
“Where’s Sarah?” Hotch finally asked a question.
“She’s learning a lesson,” the man responded with a shrug.
“What did you do to them?” Hotch asked.
In a mocking tone, the man responded, “What did you do to them?”
Not amused, Hotch and Rossi glared at him.
“I scared them that’s all. They need it,” he sighed.
“Why?”
“Because they’re spoiled, ungrateful little bitches who walk all over him any chance they get,” he responded.
“Wow,” Y/N whispered in amazement at the response.
“What happened to Bruce?” Hotch asked the question everyone had been wondering.
“He’s hiding, of course,” the man responded. “See… when he can’t handle it, I save his ass. Bruce’s problem is...he can’t handle anything.”
--------------
“So Bruce said Katie baked cookies Monday night,” JJ said, turning away from the board as Rossi and Friedman entered the room. “We found them in the kitchen, so that’s true.”
“And two of Sarah’s friends confirmed she never made it to her study group,” Blake continued, her voice slightly muffled from her cheek being pressed against her hand.
“And that’s because Jeff Godwin was in the parking lot with her from 8:15 to 9:30,” Derek added.
“And the girls called the hotline at 9:58,” Spencer finished the timeline.
“Detective, have your officers found either gun?” Hotch asked as detective Friedman walked up to the board to look at the post-it notes on it.
“No, but we’ve increased the search given where Katie’s body was found,” Friedman replied.
“Okay so, we’ve got residue, but we don’t know which gun or where it is now,” Derek said, his eyes trained on the floor.
“Okay, look,” Y/N said, raising her hands to stop anyone from talking. “Whoever that was in there said he wanted to scare them, not hurt them.”
“Katie was beaten over the head in the middle of nowhere,” Blake reminded her.
“You’re right,” Y/N gestured to her. “The altar could have lost his temper, or it could have been a horrible accident.”
“But getting the girls out of the house was planned. He said he wanted to scare them and had a gun to do it,” Rossi said.
“And then, he drove them somewhere,” Derek continued. “Bruce’s car had the same mud on the driver’s side floor that he had on his boots, but there wasn’t any in the backseat. SO three people drove somewhere, but only he came back.”
“And the DNA coming back from under Katie’s nails will tell us what we already know-- That Bruce Morrison did this. SO can I arrest him now?” Friedman said, antsy to put cuffs on the man he felt was responsible.
“Detective, you have sufficient evidence to make the arrest, but we still don’t have Sarah,” Hotch told him, eyes glaring at the man.
“Give us an hour, and maybe, he’ll tell us where she is,” Y/N said, an idea in her head forming.
“It's your call, but he could still help us,” Hotch said.
Friedman sighed. “Okay. One hour.”
So the team began their work, and they had to work fast.
“There’s no way for us to confirm a D.I.D. diagnosis yet, but we do know he has chronic alcoholism, Which can and has gone hand in hand with it,” Spencer explained to the team that was scattered amongst the conference room. “The interesting thing is his liver and pancreas wouldn’t have survived thirty years of that kind of abuse, so there must have been years where he’s gotten help.”
“He was in a program,” Blake shrugged.
“Eh, it would have to be more than that,” Spencer replied then turned to Y/N who had Penelope on the line. “Garcia, has he ever been on medication to help curb his drinking?”
“All I’ve got is a yearly physical, and that is it,” Penelope replied.
“D.I.D. usually stems from a history of sexual abuse,” Blake said slowly, hoping to give something to Penelope to help her.
“Okay, well, I’ve got nothing like that,” Penelope said. “All I have on Bruce Morrison is that his mother died when he was ten-”
“There’s your abandonment issue,” Rossi remarked.
“And he was raised by a single alcoholic father, and there’s no evidence of any prescriptions.”
“I mean, they look like the perfect family,” Spencer said, opening the file with family photos in it.
“Yeah, but she would have had to know about his drinking before they got married,” Y/N said as she peered over at the photos Spencer was holding. “So maybe, she helped manage him and kept his problem a secret.”
“She could have been the one that got the prescription,” Spencer’s lightbulb went off. “Garcia, can you run her medical history?”
“Yeah, hold on…”
They waited about twenty seconds before her voice was heard again.
“Okay, disulfiram. Am I saying that right? It’s for chronic alcoholism. She had a 90-day supply delivered four times a year for as long as I can tell. And it stopped coming a few months ago.”
“It makes you just feel nauseous if you drink,” Spencer explained the effects of the medicine.
“But she isn’t the one who had the drinking problem, he is. Garcia, who canceled it?” Derek asked the woman on the phone.
“Please hold while I dig.” She hung up the phone.
“Could that be the trigger? He goes after his daughters now that he’s off his meds?” Blake turned to look at Y/N and Spencer when she asked her questions.
Y/N’s eyes panned up to the TV that showed Hotch talking to Bruce. Then to Jeff Godwin in the other room. “That instability could work for us.”
She set her plan into action. Y/N had Derek get Jeff Godwin and bring him into the interrogation room with Bruce in it.
“Hey, I- I didn’t- Hey, look I didn’t agree to this,” Jeff stumbled as he came face to face with Bruce sitting in the interrogation room.
“Well, we’re looking for Sarah, and you’re the last ones to see her alive,” Y/N said, leaning on the metal table.
“Look, like I told you guys earlier, I had nothing to do with this. And Sarah’s afraid of him.” He pointed at Bruce when he spoke of him.
“You wanna tell us about your relationship with Sarah?” Y/N asked, moving her hands in a circular motion as she spoke.
“I don’t have one,” Jeff replied, after a pregnant pause.
Y/N’s eyebrows furrowed. “Huh, that’s strange. Why do you text her all the time then?”
At her words, Bruce sat up straighter, jaw clenching as he looked at a frightened Jeff.
“Jeff, come on, it’s not that big of a leap,” Y/N spoke nonchalantly. “Couldn’t have Judy anymore so you thought... Why not? Sarah looks just like her mom.”
Her words angered Bruce just like she thought they would. He pushed himself out of his chair and leaped for Jeff, but Derek intercepted him before he could touch him.
“I’m gonna kill that son of a bitch!” Bruce exclaimed as Derek pushed him back.
“Get him out! Get him out now,” Derek commanded the guard in the room to take Jeff out.
Once Derek had calmed Bruce (now his altar) down, he walked out of the room, leaving Y/N there standing on the other side of the table.
“Judy was gonna leave my boy for that scumbag,” the altar said, pointing to the door Jeff had exited.
“What’s your name?” Y/N asked as she watched the altar's body language.
“What’s your name?”
Y/N scoffed at his retort. “I’m Y/N, and you,” she nodded, her arms crossed as she stood tall.
“My name is Johnny, and I need a cigarette, Y/N,” Johnny placed his hands on his hips.
“Well, I might be able to help you out there, even though I don’t condone smoking, but I’m sure you’re stressed.” Y/N began to walk back and forth across the room.
“Oh, I’m not,” Johnny shook his head. “I just want a smoke.”
“Johnny,” Y/N scolded at the lie. “Come on. I know these teenage girls stress you out, no matter what you say.”
Johnny lifted his head up, a smug smirk as he looked at Y/N.
“How do you deal with it?” She continued her questions in hopes they would get him to tell her where Sarah was. “Do you like to, um...go out and shoot something?”
Johnny’s head cocked to the side and he shrugged. “Sometimes, but I don’t get much of a chance to do that.”
Y/N raised her brows in fake surprise. “Oh! I thought you did have a chance recently?”
Johnny chuckled and didn’t respond.
Y/N smirked at his none response and let out her own chuckle. “I think you did.”
Johnny’s head dropped as he continued to laugh.
“Now, you know, I’m just- I’m curious,” she laughed then pointed to the door with her thumb. “Then I’ll go get you a cancerous cigarette.”
Johnny smiled and gestured towards Y/N. “I like you, Y/N.”
Oh, that’ll make Spencer’s blood pressure go up, Y/N thought to herself.
“So…” Y/N trailed off, walking back and forth again as she changed the subject. “You took the girls somewhere to scare them...somewhere quiet, isolated…” She watched his reactions to what she said carefully. “Near the water?”
That got him to respond.
“I didn’t do anything but scare ‘em.”
“Oh, of course not.”
Johnny crossed his arms and came closer to Y/N as she stood in a dominant stance across the room.
“Do you have a place by the river?”
Johnny ignored the question. “Mm, pretty, and smart.”
Y/N gave him daring eyes, demanding an actual answer to her question.
“It’s not my place,” Johnny shook his head. “It’s not anybody’s place anymore.”
Y/N turned her head for him to elaborate more.
“I’ve taken them out there before, but this time…” He leaned forward, closer to Y/N this time (almost in her face) and whispered, “I got their attention.”
Y/N stepped back, nodding her head and nodded towards the guard to open the door.
“How about that cigarette now?”
“Not gonna let you pour cancer into Bruce’s lungs.”
The door closed behind her after she spoke and she could hear the tantrum Johnny was having. When she entered the bullpen, she saw Spencer standing in front of the glass. Arms crossed and lips pursed.
“Bub,” she whispered, gaining his attention. “You good?”
“Mm-hm, yep,” he nodded turning to her. “Just uh, you know, it was a little difficult not jumping through the glass to strangle him when he looked at you.”
Y/N chucked, her head dropping as she took a step closer to him.
“Spence, you and I both know that he wouldn’t have walked out of that room if he got closer to me.”
Spencer laughed as she pushed up on her toes to place a kiss on his cheek. He grabbed her left hand and brought it up to his lips, kissing the spot right beside her ring.
------------
That night, in the pouring, freezing rain, JJ and Derek found Sarah in the woods. She had a black eye and some cuts but she was okay.
Y/N had gone to the hospital to talk to Sarah with JJ. Letting her know what she would have to do and it was okay to back out.
Sarah seemed like a genuinely sweet girl and she took a liking to Y/N as she cried. When the three of them entered the precinct, JJ took her into the interrogation room, while Y/N stayed in the bullpen with the rest of the team.
“I have a bad feeling,” Y/N whispered as her stomach turned, something was off.
“What about?” Spencer whispered back.
“I’m not sure yet…”
As Sarah sat down, her two hands clasped together reached across the table for Bruce’s. His cuffed wrists stayed together as he held her hands.
“I’m so sorry,” Bruce said, eyes spilling with tears.
“Dad, you need help,” Sarah said softly.
Bruce let out a breath and nodded.
His eyes went up to the cuts and bruises on Sarah’s face and sucked in a sharp breath. “Did I do that?”
Sarah nodded and let a few more tears slip.
“I’m sorry,” Bruce apologized genuinely again. “I’m so sorry.”
Y/N stomach turned again, this time out of sadness. Instinctively, she reached for Spencer’s hand, needing a reassurement, and to know it would all be okay. He grabbed her hand, lacing their fingers together for a second, and squeezed it.
“What can I do?” Bruce asked Sarah, pleading agony in his voice.
“They say that if you tell them where mom is, this will all just-”
“But I don’t know. You know I don’t know,” Bruce cut her off.
“She didn’t just disappear, Dad,” Sarah sobbed.
When Bruce didn’t respond, only letting out a breathy sob, Sarah let out another crying accusation.
“Oh God, you killed her too didn’t you?”
“No, no, I didn’t,” Bruce shook his head.
“How am I supposed to believe you?” Sarah sobbed and started pointing to the marking Bruce, or rather Johnny left. “This--this is what you’ve done.”
Bruce just looked at the injuries sadly.
“You have hurt us all for a long time,” Sarah continued, her voice giving out at the end. She stood up from the table and began to exit the room with JJ.
Bruce pleaded with her to not go, but she didn’t listen and just left the room.
----------
Y/N walked with Sarah into her home, the mood of the house much different now compared to earlier in the day. The rain had died down from earlier, but it was still falling on the roof hard enough so it could be heard in the house. Sarah had an FBI jacket wrapped around her and Y/N had her signature navy petticoat tied around her waist.
“You cold?” Y/N asked, noting how Sarah wrapped her arms around herself.
“Yeah, a bit, the thermostats right there,” she pointed to the machine down the hall.
Y/N walked down the hall, turning up the temperature, and looked back to Sarah. “Should warm up soon.”
Sarah stood, staring at the floor as Y/N walked closer to her.
“You think you can sleep?”
“Yeah, I want to shower first,” Sarah pointed up the stairs.
Y/N nodded in surprise. “Okay. Uh… you sure you’ll be okay up there?”
The reason why Y/N asked this was because, after her brother died, she wouldn’t even enter that side of the house for months. So it confused her as to how she would be able to go upstairs and be okay.
“Yeah, I’ll be fine,” Sarah said reassuringly.
Hesitantly, Y/N nodded, her bad gut feeling coming back. “Okay, um, I’m gonna make us some tea, that sound good?”
“That’d be really nice, thanks.” And with that, Sarah made her way up the stairs.
Y/N nodded, letting her reassuring fake smile fall once Sarah was out of sight. Her eyes panned over to the table in the hall that adorned family photos. Behind it was a quilt she assumed their mother made.
The sound of her text messages startled her. She pulled her phone out of her pocket and looked at the text from Spencer.
All good?
“Oh Spencer, you always know when somethings up,” Y/N whispered to herself and replied with ‘not sure’.
About five minutes later, after Y/N had finished with the tea, she made her way to the dining room and set the cups down. Her phone went off again, this time a call.
When she pulled it out of her pocket, Spencer’s name lit up the screen.
“Hey,” she answered, her voice hushed.
“What’s wrong?” Spencer asked, worry clear in his voice.
Y/N sat down at the head of the table and let out a breath. “I don’t know, I’m not sure, but the feeling is back again. She’s just...too casual and almost cold since we got here.”
“It could be the shock,” Spencer replied.
“Yeah, I know, but she’s composed at the same time,” Y/N said, trying to explain Sarah’s behavior. “She has not mentioned Katie to me even once since we got here. I couldn’t go to the side of the house that my brother stayed in after he died.”
“She does have a point,” JJ’s voice said through the phone. “When my sister died, I couldn’t even walk into my house, let alone past her room.”
“Well, what do you think, Y/N, Sarah pulled it off?” Blake’s voice asked.
“It may be a possibility,” Y/N shrugged.
“It’s a very detailed plan,” Blake commented.
“What, she knew about her father’s condition and took advantage of it?” Spencer asked as his voice rushed as he spoke.
“She set up character witnesses like Jeff Godwin...to back up her fear,” Derek’s voice said, piecing together a theory. “She even got her little sister to make calls to a hotline. She manipulated us from the minute we found her.”
“Her writing suggested no empathy and no real emotional connection to the family,” Blake said, recalling the writing she had read earlier that day.
“Psychopathic tendencies,” Spencer remarked.
“Her wounds are more than superficial, but they could be self-inflicted, right, Y/N?” JJ asked the woman on the phone.
Out of the corner of her eye, Y/N saw Sarah enter the room.
“Baby, I know, I’m sorry I can’t be there for the dinner tonight,” Y/N said, quickly coming up with a cover for why she was on the phone. “But London and Jackson are there until Friday and I promise I will make it up to you when I get back.”
Y/N then turned to look at Sarah, acknowledging her presence. “You okay? I didn’t hear the shower.”
“Yeah, I just wanted my tea,” Sarah pointed to the cup on the table.
“Oh, I was gonna bring it to you, but it should be ready,” Y/N stood up and handed her the cup.
“Yeah, I’m still here,” she said, wanting to let them know she was okay.
“We’ll be right there, stay on the phone,” Spencer said quickly as Y/N assumed he was running out of the precinct.
“Baby, I gotta go,” she said and hung up the phone, watching as Sarah walked away.
When Y/N heard the water running, she walked down to the basement, remembering the tub she saw earlier. She took her flashlight connected to her holster out and walked down the stairs. When she reached the floor she walked straight over to the tubs of quilts, specifically the one with Katie’s name.
She pulled it off the shelf and moved it over to an empty table next to it. As she filed through all the blankets, she came across a real estate binder. When she opened it and flipped through the pages, she heard a gun click behind her.
“Why did you have to come down here?”
Sarah’s voice rang in the quiet of the basement.
Cautiously, Y/N turned around to look at her. In Sarah’s hand was the second gun they had been looking for.
“We’ve been looking for that.”
“It’s an old house, I know the best hiding places,” she shrugged. “But you, what do you think you know?”
“You put everything that went missing with your mother inside this box,” Y/N nodded to the box beside her. “1999.”
“Maybe my dad did it?”
“No,” Y/N spoke before she could even finish. “No, you chose this box because it’s the year Katie was born and everything changed.”
Sarah’s face formed a snarl as Y/N spoke.
“She was your little sister.”
“Katie ruined everything-” she took the last step so now she was level with Y/N- “and my mother let her.”
“Your mother loved you,” Y/N protested.
“Well, she loved Katie more,” Sarah seethed.
Y/N and Sarah stood in silence for a second.
“I should’ve cried for Katie,” Sarah scoffed. “I guess there are some things I just can’t fake.”
Carefully, Y/N’s hand reached for the gun on her belt, something she really didn’t want to have to do.
“You won’t do it,” Sarah said, taking another step closer.
“You need to back up- now.” Y/N’s voice was stern as she commanded the young girl.
“I can say my trauma kicked in,” Sarah explained. “PTSD.”
Her face then formed into fear, “I saw you with the gun, and I didn’t know what else to do!”
Then her face went back to normal.
Truly, Y/N was kinda impressed. “You thought of everything.”
Then, by the grace of whatever is out there, footsteps were heard coming down the stairs.
“Sarah put the gun down,” Derek said softly as he came up behind her.
“No, no, you don’t understand. She has a gun, she was going to hurt me,” Sarah used her plea.
“No, no, Sarah, It’s okay,” Derek reassured her. As he put his gun down, Spencer lifted his up and pointed it at her.
“Listen to me,” Derek said, holstering his gun. “I understand. It’s okay, Sarah. She wasn’t going to hurt you. I know you’ve been through enough. All right? I get it.”
Sarah let out a fake sob as Derek placed his hand on her shoulder. “Sarah, you’re safe now, okay?”
Sarah nodded and turned to Derek. “Okay, thank you.”
As soon as Derek pulled the gun out of Sarah’s hands, Spencer came up from behind her and cuffed her.
“What are you doing?!” She exclaimed as the cuffs came down on her wrists.
“You’re a smart girl, Sarah. Figure it out,” Derek said, taking Sarah out of Spencer's hands and led her up the stairs.
Sarah tried to plead as Derek took her up the stairs.
Y/N turned back to the book she had been looking at, opening to a page that held trophies from Sarah’s mom.
“February fourth, the day Judy went missing,” Y/N said as she read the date above the necklace.
“Trophies,” Spencer said as he got closer to Y/N. “If the detective Friedman had ever found it, she would have pinned it all on Bruce.”
“Damn, it’s almost impressive,” Y/N whispered as she closed the boom and brought it up as evidence.
------------
“The guests of honor!” Rossi exclaimed as Y/N and Spencer walked into his home.
The two chuckled and walked closer to Rossi to hug him. Rossi grabbed each of their faces, kissing them both on the cheeks.
“Dave, thank you so much for this,” Y/N said, taking Spencer’s hand as she thanked the man.
“Well, it’s the least I could do,” Rossi smiled, then turned and pointed to the room holding his own personal bar. “And I heard that there’s a special someone here to see you, Y/N.”
Y/N raised a brow in confusion then looked to Spencer, who had a smirk on his face.
“Remember the other day when you had to cover on the phone, and said something about London and Jackson coming to visit,” he beamed at the smile that formed on Y/N’s face as she put the pieces together.
“Shut up!” She laughed and rushed into the room, her best friend standing with her own boyfriend next to Derek, laughing about something. “London!”
When she heard her name, the dark-headed woman turned around and saw Y/N. “Y/N!”
The two met in the middle and hugged tightly, having missed each other so much.
“Oh my god, let me see it,” London said, pulling away from the hug so she could look at Y/N’s ring. “Oh, it’s beautiful.”
“I know,” Y/N sighed as London held her hand still.
“Now I just wonder when Jackson will give me one of those,” London laughed as her boyfriend came up next to her.
“Okay, no need to be hostile,” the green-eyed man said as he wrapped an arm around London’s waist. “Congratulations, Y/N.”
“Thank you, Dr. Avery,” she responded diplomatically.
“And to you too, Dr. Reid,” Jackson said, tipping his wine glass to Spencer as he walked up to the three, grabbing Y/N’s hand.
“Thank you,” Spencer smiled at the man.
The four of them had all hung out before. After another case the team had in Seattle, Spencer and Y/N stayed an extra day to hang out with London and Jackson. Y/N and laughed, making a comment about how she was the only one in the group who wasn’t a doctor.
“So how was your last case?” London asked. She loved to hear about cases and she repeatedly told Y/N that the team was the real life Scooby-Doo gang.
“A plot twist to say the least,” Y/N laughed, not wanting to go into detail. “I’m just glad it’s the weekend, and I’m just keeping my fingers crossed we don’t get called in.”
“I know that feeling,” Jackson agreed with a laugh.
Then, Hotch’s phone ringing was heard from across the room.
“No, not tonight,” Y/N groaned, throwing her head back. “One night, can serial killers just chill out for one night.”
Those who heard her comment laughed, but then Hotch reassured her worries.
“Don’t worry Y/N, that was Jessica, telling me Jack finished his homework.”
“Oh thank goodness.”
The night went on, Rossi had hired a catering service so the dinner was all little finger foods. Due to the cold weather, Rossi had made a dance floor in the bar room. Clearing out the tables that were in the middle of the room and leaving room for everyone to dance.
There was laughter heard all night as everyone danced and sang obnoxiously loud to the 90’s rock. It was a perfect surreal moment that made Y/N so happy. As she danced with Spencer, she pulled herself closer to him and whispered to him.
“I wish every night was like this.”
“It will be,” Spencer whispered back, placing a kiss on the shell of her ear as he spoke. “This is how we’ll spend every night we’re married, dancing, singing, and laughing until we can’t breathe.”
Y/N smiled, turning her head to place her lips on his. This kiss was meant to be a peck, but Spencer held the small of her back closer and let their lips dance together longer.
She giggled as she pulled away from him as Derek yelled “Get a room!” as he danced with a very drunk Penelope.
“I think I like the idea of us dancing till sunrise.”
Tag List (let me know if you want to be added!!):
@throughparisallthroughrome @word-scribbless @nintendumbfuck @confused-and-really-hungry @andiebeaword @itsarayofsunshine @baby-i-am-fireproof @abitofeverythinggg @nanocoool @marceline-is-my-spirit-animal @fancyfaucet @im-a-raging-gay @atletino @mo-whore @peterparkersdestiny @bandsandjill @mbowles23-blog @sarcasm-n-insomnia @citrussirus @nerual222 @april-14-blog @reidloversisforever @heavenlyholland @justawildmarebae @sana-li @thesailbells @l0ve-0f-my-life @spencer101reid @spencersdolore @delicateprunecashpony @sader12345678 @dashlilymark @mysticalmagicmoon @onebigfangirlworld @saturn-mp4 @hurricanejjareau @thatweirdo466 @angryknightstatesmantrash @nograciass @danandphilfan6 @la-vie-en-amour1 @squirrellover1967 @reidswords @skyirates @spideyspencer @harrypressman @justine-en @absolutelynotsophie @dr-reid-ismyspiritanimal @mailikestruecrimetoomuch @dadchi-oya @marley1773 @lashtonandmalumsbaby @jesus-christ-ashtons-arms @lulurose17 @flowers-in-fields @multifandombb @aimzonicles97 @criminaly-supernatural @aperrywilliams @n1ghtsh4d3-67 @thatsonezesty13 @maya0819 @chaoticsteverogers @brendon-phan-stuff @cityofolympus @sungieeeeeee @notsofruitiesmoothie @cassiopeiaathena @voguekristens @fandomlover4091 @criminalminds-and-cookies @marcyag @goofyfaith7 @typical-lingling @fallingforfics @spycemilk @spencers-sass @yuurisassonice @kmc217 @daiiybuugle @caswinchester2000 @yomama-umbridge @falcon-arrows
364 notes
·
View notes