#trope rating

[cha-melodius]

Trope ratings: Bodyswap, Accidental Marriage, aaaaaand Mutual Pining? xoxo MJ/kiwiana-writes

HELLOOOOOO.

Bodyswap: LMAO you're very clever sending me one I'm currently writing. I do love body swap fics of all kinds, so probably a solid A? I enjoy the awkwardness of characters having to inhabit someone else's body, and it often makes for some good physical comedy. Plus the moments of 'oh no, they're too hot how am I supposed to deal with this'.

Accidental marriage: I don't think I've actually read that many of these? I assume most of them are Vegas fics, which I can kind of take or leave, so I guess a C. They don't draw me in, but they can be fun.

Mutual pining: MY BELOVED. A+++ 105%. If pining is delicious, mutual pining is 10x as sweet. I once said almost all of my fics are mutual pining even if we only see one side pining, and I stand by that. It's mutual pining even if one of them doesn't know it. Sub-trope of mutual pining while fucking is also incredible. Mutual pining is the GOAT.

Send me a fic trope and I'll grade it

[wikiangela]

Trope Rating Tag game

tagged by @jesuisici33 @spotsandsocks @thewolvesof1998 @daffi-990 @fortheloveofbuddie

rules: How much do these tropes affect your decision to click on a fic? -10 -> very dissuaded  0 - don’t care either way  +10 -> very enticed  nope -> if it’s a hard no and you’d never click on a fic with that tag or or you even have the tag blocked or you’d insta click out of the fic if it wasn’t tagged.  Bonus points for explaining the rating and whether it’s conditional.

Age gap: -2

tbh I don't mind an age gap unless it's huge and/or the younger person is way too young when the relationship starts, that's icky

other than that I don't particularly care hah

Codependency: +4

depends - a bit is fine, but not like unhealthy levels haha

Obsession/Possessiveness, jealousy: +8

see above lol - if done right, amazing, love it (also, my buddie always ends up at least a little bit possessive, idk, i can't help it haha)

Opposites (grumpy/sunshine etc): +10

adore it

Enemies to lovers, Enemies with benefits: +8

used to be more into it, but still love it

Friends with benefits: +10

YES, and with mutual pining too? perfection

Sex to feelings: +10

Fake dating/relationship: +10

one of absolute faves, love it so much (even finally wrote one and it was so fun lol)

Friends to lovers: +10

used to be kinda meh about it, now it's my shit (I blame buddie)

Found Family: +10

one of faves

Hurt/Comfort: +5

I don't seek it out, but I'll read it if I'm in the mood

Love Triangle: -8

so sick of these, sns, just make them all date each other

Poly, open relationships: +6

haven't read that many, but I do like those haha

Mistaken/hidden identity: 0

just bc I don't think I've ready any? idk

Monsterfucking: +8

listen... after venom I went so into symbrock on Ao3 lol (pretty sure they're my only ship for this trope so far tho)

Pregnancy: 0

don't seek it out, and haven't read that many, it's whatever

Second Chance: +1

depends, don't actively seek it out

Slowburn: +9

the. best.

Soulmates: +6

really depends, but generally they're fun I guess

___

no pressure tagging: @thebravebitch @jeeyuns @eddiediaztho @forthewolves @giddyupbuck @alyxmastershipper @honestlydarkprincess @watchyourbuck @transbuck @andrewblur @diazass @ladydorian05 @theotherluciferr @911onabc @disasterbuckdiaz @hippolotamus @wildlife4life and whoever else wants to do it!

[teazerwashere]

Rivals to lovers trope?

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

PEACE AND LOVE ON PLANET EARTH OR WHEREVER THE STORY TAKES PLACE! ESPECIALLY WHEN THE RIVALS REALIZE THEY DON'T ACTUALLY HATE EACH OTHER!?!!??!?! OHM Y GOD JSUT THE. THE FUGIK SOFBGBJMR!??!?!

[iammistressofmyfate]

More tropes for the rating!! Enemies to lovers, friends to lovers, and kidfics 🙏🙏🙏

Thanks, friend!! I really love doing these lmao And literally just in time, my CEU starts now!

Enemies to Lovers - B - I like it. I'm not usually in the mood for it but I'll read it, especially if it's humorous, maybe some lite angst

Friends to Lovers - A+ - One of my favorite tropes. I love writing it, I will actively seek it out. A++ if it's CHILDHOOD friends to lovers. Cannot get enough. I love when characters have a whole history as they develop into a romantic relationship 🥺

Kidfics - A - I enjoy a good kidfic. I love exploring and reading about my favorites becoming parents and seeing what that would be like. Maybe some lite angst, but I mostly like how soft and tender these fics usually are.

[Trope Rating Ask]

[gadriezmannsgirl]

Trope rating: A classic enemies to lovers

With the lot of angsty stuffs? HELL YES!

[conjectureand-gloom]

FOR THE FANFICTION TROPE: FOUND FAMILY

A: Love it. Spend my time combing AO3 for it.

YES. I LOVE IT. IT’S EASY TO MESS UP, BUT IF IT’S DONE WELL, WHICH IT ALMOST ALWAYS IS, THEN YESSSS I LIVE FOR THIS TROPE

[astoldbycrimson]

For the trope rating game: enemies to lovers, rivals to lovers, and friends to lovers?

Heya, Jasper!

Trope Rating:

Enemies to Lovers:

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

Rivals to Lovers:

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

Friends to Lovers:

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

Thanks for the ask!

~Crimson

[ashyblondwaves]

Trope rating: there’s only one bed 👀

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

[weirdo-from-bonesborough]

i see your tim has narcolepsy headcanon and i offer you this: he falls asleep during the titans tower attack and jason's just like. "well now what"

bonus points if it's one of those aus where jason has a conscious or pit madness or whatever and convinces himself tim must be horribly mistreated to start snoring while getting beat up and tim's struggling to get him to understand no dude it's a medical condition my grandpa had it

[bethanydelleman]

I think I figured out the problem with the Enemies to Lover's trope, it has a bimodal distribution. Let me explain!

Most tropes have a normal distribution:

I hypothesize that with EtoL, there is very little middle ground. This is a bimodal distribution:

You either do EtoL well and join the ranks of the immortals, or you crash and burn. I've discussed previously what makes EtoL work, but there seem to be a lot of traps for writers to fall into when it comes to this trope. For example:

the turn being based too heavily on lust (common JAFF trap)

never fully establishing the enemies phase

insufficient apology on one side (almost always the man's) which makes the other's acceptance unsatisfying

the pair have the communication skills of a newborn baby (ei: the misunderstanding could be fixed with a single sentence)

one side is a real asshole but it's excused because of TRAUMA

growth is ignored in favour of acceptance (can work, usually doesn't)

Relationship is clearly toxic, above and beyond the extenuating circumstances/magical premise (The problem isn't that Edward is a vampire, that's part of the premise. The problem is his disregard for Bella's autonomy)

One side gives in because the other is too obsessed with them

Once Upon a Time flew by having Hook feel meaningful remorse for his past actions (the scene with the Little Mermaid got me so good) and establishing begrudging respect between him and Emma, The Mindy Project crashed and burned by not showing sufficient growth in Danny (does he respect her career now or are they just horny?). Parks and Recreation got it by making the leads both good people who just got on each other's nerves because they had different valid approaches. I think Brooklyn 99 is one of those rare mediocre ones, because the enemy stage isn't fully established but the relationship is still satisfying. The Kdrama Alchemy of Souls got it right by having both main characters display an impressive amount of personal growth, while 100 Days My Prince burned because it relied too heavily on obsession and trauma excusing behaviour.

Pride & Prejudice and Much Ado About Nothing show that the beginning dynamic can be completely different, old antagonists vs. first impressions, but the trope can still work if it's done right. The problem is that it's so often done wrong.

So when it's good, it's SO GOOD, when it's bad, it sucks.

[poison-scene]

Thinking about how the romance between Maki and Kaito was written by TDR and the possibility they implied Kokichi's interest in Shuichi during the FTEs + Love hotel.

Like, what if TDR intended for Kokichi to take Shuichi's hand by the end of his last FTE but Kokichi didn't bc of the circumstances™?

And just how much influence does the writing have on the character's feelings anyway? Do they just restrict that to romance or does that impact other dynamics? 🤔

[cha-melodius]

Magic AUs! And high school AU too

Oooh ok, let's do this!

Magic AU: We'll go with A-. I don't seek them out specially, but I do enjoy them quite a bit whether it's modern with magic or a fantasy AU. I feel like my appreciation for this genre has grown over the last few years, too.

High school AU: I'm gonna be honest, high school was a terrible part of my life and one I'd like to forget, so I have to rate these a D, only because I've read a FEW but only under specific circumstances. @orchidscript's '50s AU The Way You Seemed is one I adore. But for the most part they are sadly not my jam.

Send me a fic trope and I'll grade it

[teazerwashere]

soulmate au trope?

No | rather not | I dunno | I guess | Sure | Yes | FUCK yes | Oh god you don’t even know |

Soulmate implies monogamy. I'm not about that life. >:(

[iammistressofmyfate]

For the fandom trope ask, how do you feel about Fake Dating?

Rachel asked me about this one, too!

I give Fake Dating a B-

I go back and forth about it. I think a good fic writer could catch my attention and interest but it's not something I actively seek out. There's a lot of angst potential and I'm a giant weenie but if it was written with more humor and had a happy ending, I could be enticed!

Thank you for asking, friend! <33

[Trope Rating]

[searenbound]

Alpha Bakugou desperately jerking off so he can be near his favorite sidekick without dropping to his knees and begging to fuck them just this once.

A lust quirk is already a major problem for a hero to get hit with. Working in close proximity to an Omega who is so wildly off limits he convinced himself he didn’t want them anyways, is a nightmarish hell.

Worse is, it’s not even working. How is he supposed to make it through the next 48 hours without making a huge fool of himself?

[uglygirlprettyboy]

in the courtroom straight up terminating it. and by it. let’s justr say. my marriage.