#toby rogers headcannon

[noctiva]

Yandere Toby hc-🪽

angel anon I see all ur asks in my inbox… what are we hehe *twirls hair*

//

Yandere!Toby Headcannons

-

CW!! Stalking, obsessive behaviour, mentions of death + murder, 18+ content, sexual content

slight NSFW under the cut! minors do not interact!

—

Yandere!Toby thinks he’s doing it all for your sake

Because he knows what’s best for you, and what’s best for you is him.

He knows how to treat you better than anyone else. Knows all of your favourite shows, foods, hobbies, and places to go (maybe only because he sneaks around your house when you think you’re alone, peeking through the windows to gaze at your beauty)

Yandere!Toby leaves you gifts and love notes. Pretty rocks he thinks you’d like, animal bones he cleaned just for you, pretty jewelry and hair clips he stole from his victims. All slipped into your mailbox, or left on your porch wrapped in a ribbon.

Yandere!Toby won’t hesitate to kill, but he’ll do it discreetly - leaving you wondering why all of your love interests just keep disappearing.

Yandere!Toby has snuck into your house once or twice (or three, four, five times) to steal little items from you that he’s sure you won’t miss.

Besides your favourite sweater - he took that too. Stuffing it with a pillow so he can fall asleep cuddled up against your scent, dreaming that one day he’ll have his arms wrapped around your body instead.

(And you don’t want it back, because more often than not he ends up hopelessly rutting against it - the smell of your perfume getting him harder than he’s ever been)

Yandere!Toby is patient at first. Hopeful that you’ll realize the truth eventually (the truth being, that you’ll be happiest with him).

But that patience doesn’t last long, because why don’t you get it? Why are you wasting time with all of these idiots when he’s right here? Showering you with love and appreciation you could never find elsewhere?

Though, he’d never really blame you. You were perfect. The fault was laid on every one else. For distracting you, leading you astray. Keeping you from him, and tainting your mind.

Yandere!Toby keeps trophies from all of the people he’s killed to gain your affection. His favourite being the jar of teeth that rests on his nightstand.

Yandere!Toby has your name carved into the handle of his hatchet. Because he’s doing this all for you. Not caring how bloody he has to get if it means the end goal is your lips on his.

Yandere!Toby likes to watch you sleep.

Likes to see you so peaceful. That’s when you’re the most beautiful, in his opinion. All blissful and unaware.

He could do anything to you. Anything.

But he’d wait. Because if he wanted a limp doll he’d just go back to humping your sweater. He wanted to hear you cry out his name, feel your nails drag down his back.

So the worst he’d do while you were sleeping was snip off a lock of your hair. From the back, so you wouldn’t notice it as quick.

He keeps it in a locket around his neck.

(But he often takes it out to sniff it.)

Yandere!Toby stole a Polaroid camera just to document you.

And when he prints the pictures out, he sticks them right on the wall next to his bed.

Pictures of you sleeping, at work, laughing with friends.

The pictures of you undressing, he keeps in his nightstand. Along with a pair of panties he snagged from your drawer.

He would return them, so that you could wash them and reinvigorate the scent of your laundry soap - but he’s sure that the new stains would catch your attention.

Yandere!Toby knows it’ll only take time. Because one day, you’ll have no choice but to love him - because there’ll be no one else left.

—————————————————————————☆

this is my first time doin a list of headcannons so I hope it’s alright 🙏🙏

thank you for the request!

[rainrot4me]

Ticci Toby General Headcannons

Summary: Basic, SFW, and NSFW head-cannons. My personal thoughts, feelings, and opinions about Toby as a character.

TW: NSFW below the cut, minors dni! Above the cut is sfw!

Words: 1.6k

A/N: NSFW is reader with female anatomy.

Basic:

- Even though he is socially awkward and tense, he’s a master at people watching. Can read a room and know more details about a person within seconds of watching them interact.

- Likes his alone time.

- He would probably say Tim and Brian are his closest friends, the same can’t be said about Masky and Hoodie, however.

- A pro at zoning out. Takes you waving your hand in his face before he snaps back.

- Bipolar? More-so emotional switch. Tends to be soft-spoken and awkward, trying his best to keep conversation while fidgeting his hands, looking anywhere but at your face. Otherwise, he’s an in-your-face, aggressive, no emotional resistance when that flip is switched. Lots of teeth gritting and yelling, swings his ax around like it’s a toy to intimidate. It takes a lot for him to get to that point, but it takes double the time for him to come back down from it.

- Not easily scared. Will throw himself into a fight and come out victorious somehow.

- Sleeper build. Wears lots of baggy clothing and layers so you can’t tell, but secretly he’s jacked. He may look scrawny, but don’t be fooled. Really strong shoulder and chest muscles from dually swinging his ax and dragging bodies around. He doesn’t think it’s all that impressive. Wishes he was bigger.

- The worst posture you’ve ever seen.

- Let his facial hair grow out from time to time. Thinks it makes him look too mature, but appreciates the compliments he gets.

- Has a secret hobby of playing a guitar he found on a mission. His tics mess him up a lot, but it’s worth the trip out deeper into the woods where no one can hear to practice a little.

- A little shit.

- Hates the heat. Would rather freeze to death than spend one moment in the too hot sun. Favorite season is late fall, around the first snowfall time.

- Big on territory. Never had privacy or respect as a kid so he values having his own things and belongs that nobody else can touch.

- Definitely shy, but not in the “UwU” way, in the “Can you get this from the gas station for me? The girl in there looks mean.”

- Bites his nails, the skin around his nails, and his cuticles LIKE A MF.

- Very light sleeper. Unless he’s absolutely dead beat exhausted, he’ll wake up from just the floorboards creaking. Has to be physically exhausted to actually rest.

- When listening to music, he needs it as loud and close as possible. Headphones are a must and they must be at max. He wants to feel that bass.

- A stray animal lover, feels similar to them in a way.

- Breaks down a lot. Hard to console or even talk to in those moments but some time alone in his room will do the trick.

- Has the education level of a middle schooler.

- Enjoys Gorillaz, Rainbow Kitten Surprise, and surprisingly, older country artists like Johnny Cash and Willie Nelson. “Outlaw shit.”

Dating Him/SFW:

- “Love” “Y/N…” “Baby”

- Loves when he touches you and you don’t pull away. Like when his knee accidentally rests against yours or his elbow bumps your arm while sitting on the couch and you don’t tug away, just sitting there letting him rest. He gets all giddy.

- Playing with your hair. Currently trying to learn how to braid.

- “Wait. O- Okay, so, right th- then left? No? F- Fuck, okay…”

- Favorite sleeping position is with you wrapping around each other, legs and arms tangled together as he hooks his chin onto the top of your head, rubbing your back. Even though you both get extremely hot and sweaty after a while, Toby enjoys the moment before you eventually shove him off.

- Likes to feel your body weight on him, whether it’s laying or sitting, he just likes the pressure and warmth you give.

- Big on physical touch, could really care less if he’s mad or not, just needs to have some part of his body touching yours.

- You could wear or look like absolutely anything and he’d still think you’re the most gorgeous thing he’s ever seen.

- Loves how you smell after getting out of the shower, can’t get enough of it while he kisses your warm, damp skin.

- Loves the way it feels when you comb through his hair with your fingers, practically purrs as he melts into your warmth, angling his head so you have better access.

- An admirer for sure, stares even when you catch on, studying every freckle or sunspot on your cheek.

- Self conscious about being your boyfriend. In reality, he’s an amazing lover, but he’s been conditioned his whole life that he’s not good enough and that ideal carries over.

- Tried to lick you through the hole in his cheek once, you both freaked out.

- Sensitive to high stress situations or loud noises so constantly reaches for your hand or crams himself into your side to block out the panic he can feel oncoming. You really help.

- Slasher movie date nights are always a bust because he’ll describe just how inaccurate that blood splatter was, followed by what would actually happen in detail.

- “If he c- cut the arm like that, it wou- wouldn’t spray out that far. This g- guy doesn’t even l- look like he’s ever even he- held an ax before.”

- Didn’t have a favorite color until you told him yours. Says his is the same, just cause it’s your favorite.

- Very immature in the sense of relationship problems. He thinks everything can be solved if he just avoids it, and that includes you. It takes a lot of bickering and patience, but he’ll eventually get over himself and force a solution.

- Doesn’t open up about anything ever. You’ve gotta fight tooth and nail for him to even mention his mother’s name. Will tell you all about his latest mission, however, whether you want to hear or not.

- Throws things or hits you playfully just to turn around and go “Who did that??”

Dating Him/NSFW:

- Boobs. Tits. Breasts. He needs them in his palms immediately.

- A big biter. Will never bite hard enough to draw blood but gets so turned on at seeing his teeth marks in your skin. Big territory thing.

- “Mine. See, I m- marked ‘ya. You’re mine.”

- His dream is to fuck your tits, too shy to ask though.

- Always been a “jerk off as fast as you can” kind of guy, fisting his cock fast to just get off. So when you slowly slide down his cock for the first time, taking your time to adjust and grind your hips at a steady pace, he nearly cums on the spot from how overwhelming it is.

- Bisexual, definitely.

- Starts at a fast pace at first, thrusting and grinding until both of your hips hurt, but then slowly his pace changes, more intentional movements and sinking deeper, more focused on stretching you out then getting deep. Just wants to get you dizzy before he gives you the good stuff lol.

- “Th- That feel good? You’re sq- squeezin’ so tight, ah-”

- His fingernail imprints all over your skin from how hard he holds you.

- Pervert but not in a creepy way. Pervert as in gets a boner from just watching your ass as you walk across the room. Has to clench his fists every time you bend over or raise your shirt up. Can barely breathe if you’re showing too much skin.

- Not big on degradation, but is very big on affirmation, loves to be told he’s doing good.

- Secretly, sooooo secretly loves the idea of anal. For both you and him. He wants to be buried in your ass, your back laid into his chest as he shoves his fingers into your cunt, panting into your neck. But at the same time, wishes you would just read his mind and push your fingers into his, fisting his cock as you stretched him so well.

- Surprisingly, very flexible. Whatever position you’re in he can easily contort to get the best angle to sink his cock in.

- Jealousy sex. Another resident of the mansion catches your glance for too long and suddenly you’re shoved into the bathroom, pants at your ankles as the brunette swipes the pads of his fingers against your clit, biting against your shoulder as he ruts into your ass.

- “Mine, mine, m- mine, nobody els- else makes you feel this good. Right? R- Right? Yeah?”

- A WHINER. Grade A pro at burying his face into your neck/pillow/chest and just sobbing his pleasure through tears and moans. He’s so loud, obnoxiously groaning and huffing as you slap your hand over his mouth. It doesn’t help though, as soon as your hand pushes down his tongue is already out and licking your palms.

- You in his hoodie? Yeah, it’s the only thing you’re wearing while he snaps his hips, pushing your knees back as far as they’ll go to get even deeper, mewling about how good you look.

- Loves to sit back and watch you suck his cock, his fingers pushing strands of hair out of your face as you try to take it all in, eyes twitching the further down you get. He’s not insanely big, just lengthy enough to make you choke and reach all the best parts. Likes to put his goggles on your forehead and watch them dangle as you bob up and down.

- Cumming in you? No. Cumming on you? Every single time. Goes absolutely crazy when he sees his seed shot across your stomach or thighs, your flushed skin and post-orgasm twitches getting him so turned on he can’t focus.

- “You ju- just look so good… Couldn’t he- help myself, okay? Sorry… Can we, u- uh… Can we go ag- again?”

Thank you for reading!

Comments and reblogs are appreciated! 𐚁₊⊹

[ninathekillxr]

Ticci Toby

Headcannons

Pt.2

Everyone thinks he hates kids but he actually doesn’t and just avoids them because he gets uncomfortable being near them.

He would give you rocks, shells, sea glass and pretty leaves or trinkets he finds while out on missions!

Toby uses Maladaptive Daydreaming as a coping mechanism when the reality of what his life is starts to feel too real.

He tried to smoke once before but choked and got embarrassed so he practiced smoking with a vape and now he has vape and gossips with Nina

Actually doesn’t like waffles much and finds them unsatisfying to eat. He prefers pancakes.

Always has at least one infected wound as he often doesn’t even notice he has a wound because of his CIPA.

Nina’s comments!~

I have so many Toby headcannons it’s unreal-

I have a whole Creepypasta AU in my head but I just don’t know where to start for typing it up </3

Nina out!

[crushedsweets]

“You HAVE to pose like this you have to I’ll be so mad if you don’t please you HAVE to it’ll be so cute guys you NEED TO I swear I won’t post it guys please” -nina before every pic in her camera roll

[vyp1elyn]

AHHHHH I love this SO MUCH

also a nice way to introduce how im gonna start drawing toby :3

SHADING SUCKS

[rttnz0mb]

Updated Masterlist

!!This Master list will be updated every time I post something new so it should always be up to date!!

--CREEPYPASTA--

Ticci Toby-

⦻ Creepypasta Headcanons pt. 1 ⦻

Ticci Toby x G/N Reader with Schizophrenia

Ticci Toby x G/N reader with Narcolepsy

Hot Boxing / Rainy Night - Ticci Toby SMUT

Jeff The Killer-

⦻ Creepypasta Headcanons pt. 1 ⦻

Ben Drowned-

⦻ Creepypasta Headcanons pt. 1 ⦻

Bloody Painter

⦻ Creepypasta Headcanons pt. 1 ⦻

X-Virus-

X - Virus Dating Head cannons

Eyeless Jack

Eyeless Jack sfw/nsfw Headcanons SOME SMUT

--EverManHybrid--

Habit

Habit regular Headcanons

!!I know this masterlist isn't really needed considering I haven't posted much yet but I just wanted to get one started so as I post more stuff I can just add it in!!

okay bye bye𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅

[incognitonoggin]

How would the proxies handle a reader who has scars & is insecure about them? (nsfw is cool to add in too!)

Oooh this one is interesting!!

Please read this with caution as it contains serious subjects about sh. If you are uncomfortable with that kind of topic, PLEASE click off. Have a great day <33

MINORS DO NOT INTERACT

TW !! Heavy mentions of self harm.

PROXIES HANDLING A READER WITH SCARS (AND IS INSECURE ABOUT THEM)

SFW AND (LITTLE TO NO) NSFW

GN! READER

Includes: “Ticci” Toby, Masky/Tim, Hoodie/Brian

TOBY

SFW

• First of all, Toby would be very passionate about the subject and cherish you like you’re a porcelain doll i swear. 😭

• He’d put kisses on them and talk about how precious your body is, and that you have no reason to be insecure !

• I don’t personally think he would be all over them all the time though, but maybe when you bring them up or show signs of discomfort due to them being there or maybe he’s just listening to you talk,— he’ll just land a kiss on them to make you feel a bit better :)

• Personal headcannon–Toby knows what it’s about, because of his whole pain thing, he’s most likely done it himself

• I don’t have much for nsfw because I think he’d pass them by in a way

• Like, he’d kiss them during sex of course but i don’t believe it’d interfere with or change your sexual intimacy

MASKY / TIM

SFW

• This boy would tweak out a bit

• He’d ask of you to not do it again, but would genuinely be worried for you and be a bit more cautious about your overall mental health

• Wouldn’t kiss them as often as Toby, but would run his fingers on them

• Tim doesn’t think you deserve it,— you deserve only the best after all. How could you think so lowly about yourself when you’re literal perfection?

• Nothing for nsfw sorryyyyy 😭

HOODIE / BRIAN

SFW

• Alrightyyy this man Brian would cling to you even more after finding out / noticing 😭

• It’s mostly just to make sure you don’t do it again, but also because he realizes there’s some severe mental warfare going on and he wants to indirectly reassure you that you’re okay. :)

NSFW (BARELY 😔)

• During sexy times he’d praise you a lot more, mostly revolving on your appearance and beauty

• He just wants you to know you’re still gorgeous to him!

[darkromanceenthusiast]

Ticci Toby has a prince Albert piercing.

I don't make the rules I just remind everyone of them.

[annokan]

What're they listening to?

[astupidweeb69]

Can u do more Toby headcannons? I been keeping up with his story for so long and I love the way u portray him as and making him into a more deeper character.

Sure! I can give a couple more headcannons. I hope none of this is too repetitive or already made obvious in my other writing but here goes.

Ticci Toby Headcannons:

Toby has a softer spot for women. His sister and mother were the only kind people in his life, so although he suffers from some amnesia due to Slenderman's influence, he's held onto this bias subconsciously.

That's not saying he treats women well (He doesn't treat anyone that great). He just tends to lash out at men more.

I also think this is the same reason why Tim and him struggle to get along. Tim is older, a control freak, and has a domineering personality, so he reminds Toby of his father, especially when he's constantly barking orders at him.

He believes what he wants to believe. Meaning he interprets people's actions however it suits him. If he wants to continue hating a person he'll look for reasons to. If he wants to believe a person likes him back (either platonically or romantically) he'll convince himself that's the case. Because at the end of the day, he doesn't care too much about other people's actual thoughts and feelings. He doesn't like when reality doesn't fit the narrative in his head, so if a person rejects him, he'll probably end up killing them.

In the case of Yandere! Toby, I think he's definitely the type to accidentally kill his Darling. Especially if you're a regular human being. He's a ticking time bomb, you have to constantly walk on egg shells around him.

When he attended school (back before he was homeschooled). he loved art. Specifically working with clay or paint, anything where he could get his hands dirty. He also used to love creative writing. Though he got in trouble for writing stories that were too.... dark.

The journal he keeps has a lot of drawings in it too. Usually the pages are filled with whatever his latest obsession is. There are a lot of disturbing pictures in there so it's not for the feint of heart.

Don't go into the basement in his cabin without his permission. That's his... "freak out" space.

Anyway, here are more of my thoughts.

[angelic-waffles]

I like to think that Toby’s mask has a sort of muzzle on it

This may just be my mentally ill ass clinging on too much, but personally being mentally ill means a lot of putting perceived protections in place for others.

I sorta think that for Toby that’d take the form of a muzzle to prevent violent outbursts

Just a personal headcannon tho ^^

[noctiva]

Im madly obsessed with vampires so it’s only fair I ask for vampire Toby hc-🪽

regular toby bites so vampire!toby??? oh lord…

//

Vampire!Toby Headcanons

CW!! biting obv, mentions of blood and injury, sexual content, slight dubcon, obsessive behaviour, kidnapping, Stockholm syndrome

NSFW under the cut! Minors do not interact!

-

Vampire!Toby falls in love with you at first sight. Well… First scent.

He had smelled you from blocks away when he was out a night stalking the shadows, a scent so sweet he found himself gravitating towards it.

To which he found you, as the source.

And you looked even sweeter than you smelled.

He could only imagine your taste.

Vampire!Toby felt his fangs ache as he watched you; so blissfully unaware. Walking home from your job at the tavern, completely ignorant to the fact that a monster of the night was tracking your every step.

He would follow you the whole way home, taking note of where you lived - for future reference.

Vampire!Toby tried to wait, but that scent. What he smelled emanating off of you that night was ingrained in his mind.

He knew for a fact, that you had to be the most succulent feast in this entire damn city.

He knew that, because every other victim he feasted on started to taste… Stale. Flavourless. The only thing pleasurable about the experience being the theft of energy from their lifeless bodies.

There was simply no fun in it anymore, because he knew that you were better - and he hadn’t even tasted you yet.

Vampire!Toby snuck into your room one night, when the cravings got too intense to bear.

Through your window, which you left unlocked.

Not because you were stupid, just… Ignorant. But he supposed he couldn’t blame you. Creatures like him were just the object of myth and fairy tails, you would have no reason to fear something you didn’t believe to exist.

But maybe you should’ve.

Vampire!Toby just can’t help himself when he lays his eyes on you once more.

Sound asleep, like a beautiful doll, soft breaths causing your chest to rise and fall. Rise and fall. A sensation he hadn’t experienced in centuries.

Vampire!Toby walks over to your bed slowly, quietly, before kneeling next to you - sweat beading up on his skin as he breathes in the scent of you so close.

It’s more intense than ever, and it makes his head spin.

He can’t help but lean over you and nuzzle into your neck, a wave of heat washing over as his listens to the rhythmic thump thump thump of blood rushing through your veins.

It was calling to him. You were calling to him, even if you weren’t aware.

Vampire!Toby would leave your neck slick with saliva before he finally sunk his fangs in.

And when you awoke from the searing pain, he’d hold you down.

You were just as delectable as he imagined. The taste of your blood coating his tastebuds in a flavour so unique it made him dizzy.

Vampire!Toby would only be spurred on more by the sound of your cries.

The perfect accompaniment, to the feeling of your blood gushing into his mouth. So hot and fresh that he found himself leaking drool against your skin with each mouthful he swallowed down.

Vampire!Toby would keep you alive.

Wouldn’t drain you completely, because that would be a waste.

If he were greedy enough to suck dry the most delicious food source he had ever laid his lips on, he would’ve kicked himself for years to come.

So instead, he just drinks until you fall unconscious. Then, when your breathing goes shallow he retracts his fangs.

Only because he knew, that would one taste would never be enough.

So, Vampire!Toby would take you with him.

Whisk you out into the night with your limp body in his arms, the taste of you still staining his lips.

He would bring you back to the abandoned castle he called home, hellbent on keeping you with him.

Which he would ultimately, be successful at doing.

Vampire!Toby would keep you captive at first, and wipe the tears from your cheeks as he fed from you for the hundredth time.

But by the two hundredth, you would find yourself sinking into the feeling.

Sickly craving this depraved man’s touch. If you could even call him a man. This monster’s touch.

Vampire!Toby would try to be gentle as he could with you. Never taking more blood than he absolutely needed.

(Though, he would fantasize about bleeding you dry. Sucking every drop of decadent blood from your veins, until there was nothing left for your heart to pump).

But, he would never. Mostly, because it would just be stupid to discard of the constant blood source he had acquired - but partially because he had grown fond of you.

Fond of the way you started to run your hands through his hair as he sunk his teeth into your skin, tearing back open a wound he had created millions of times now.

Fond of the way you went so pliant beneath him - going from rigid and terrified, to submitting completely.

It was only natural, that at one point during feeding, Vampire!Toby would find himself growing hard in his slacks as he tugged you in close - fangs in your neck as your nails dragged down his back.

And if you were to indulge him?

It would become a nightly occurrence.

Vampire!Toby fucks you slow and deep as he pulls blood from your veins - euphoria thrumming through his entire body. Unable to decide if he should focus on your velvety walls sucking him in, or your blood gushing against his tongue.

His favourite, was having you on top though.

Letting you warm his cock as he litters your neck with bite marks, nudging his hips up every so often just to keep you sated.

But your neck wasn’t the only victim.

Vampire!Toby would leave you absolutely covered in bite marks.

Your thighs, chest, shoulders, hips - not caring if it was an optimal place to suck blood from, just wanting the taste of your skin on his tongue.

Vampire!Toby would leave you weak more often than not.

Either from the blood loss, or how ferociously he had given you his cock the night prior.

(Or sometimes, both).

When you’re passed out completely, he would nuzzle up against you - lazily licking at your neck to try and satiate the craving that always persisted.

But as time went on, he would go easier on you.

Only drinking until you’re a little woozy, not completely gone.

You’d taste your own blood on Vampire!Toby’s lips when you kissed him, and prick your lips on his teeth more often than not.

(An instance that he absolutely adored.)

Vampire!Toby became obsessed with you from the first night he spotted you, and now that he had you, he wasn’t planning to ever let you leave.

Good thing you didn’t want to.

—————————————————————————☆

I’m doing headcanons bc they’re quicker to get out then full fics

vampire!toby yummy yum yum!!

[huhcat]

My savior.

Heyoo! I come with some angsty thingies, hurr hurr. This is my first time doing something like this, so please excise if this is too amateur or whatever, lol.

Disclaimer, English is not my first language, and I think I still write a lot of mistakes, so do forgive that.

Cw: angst, undereating, being held captive, Toby is a manipulator, hhh...

Yeah, I think that's it. :)

You had forgotten what the problem was at this point. The only thing you knew was that you were not at fault here.

You, however, felt bad, for your boyfriend was somehow guilt tripping you, manipulating you into thinking that it was your fault to be in this situation when you decided to laugh a little too much at Tim's jokes.

Toby was, by no means, a Saint. Even the other creeps knew not to mess with him, especially considering the fact that he was unpredictable. You never knew what his reaction would be, making him a ticking bomb ready to explode at any second.

He locked you in his room, which was as messy as ever. For whatever reason, Toby had nailed some boards to his window, making the room dark and reeking of humidity. It also did not help that the light bulb went out a long time ago, and Toby didn't want to fix it yet.

He decided that the best thing to do was to seclude you from everyone so that no one would take you away... So that you wouldn't dare cheat on him again with Tim.

He'd bring you some food every once in a while, but judging by what he served you, you only ate breakfast and dinner. The rest of the day you'd spend locked in the room, cold and dark, waiting for this punishment to be over.

It would be really hard to convince Toby that you were "ready" to go out again, since he thought that if you, by any chance, even dared to look a little too long to anyone else, you would be betraying him. Cheating on him with whomever that person were.

Days passed like this, still locked in his room.

At least you had his company, him toying with your hair as you sobbed in place, both of you sitting on his bed as he told you that this was for your own good, that you only had to learn to have eyes for him and him only. He would say that this would pass as long as you learned your lesson, but... at what cost?

By the time he let you out, it had been a month. You came to realize that Toby would tell the others that you were sick, how a horrible cold got to you, then you coincidentally started feeling dizzy and vomiting after you were "healed."

Of course, you looked emaciated. You weren't the person you used to be before.

This time, you made sure to stick close to Toby. To speak only to Toby.

There was no one else you needed, other than Toby.

He who gave you his love even when he locked you up, He who cherished you even when you were such a horrible person, He who loved you through think and thin even when you dared speak to others.

He gave you solace, company, love...

And isn't that what good boyfriends do?

[ninathekillxr]

Ticci Toby

Headcannons

Toby is actually really clumsy and actively drops his hatchets, goggles and knocks cups over.

He hates jam. It’s too sweet and sticky, it’s makes him feel sick.

Toby loves tea and drinks it whenever he’s upset or sick because his mother used to make it for him.

His body would be littered with scars and bruises from tics, fights with the other proxies/pastas and other injuries.

His skin would be really rough and dry

Wears sunglasses indoors because of his light sensitivity

Uses a straw because when he drinks he dribbles out the hole in his cheek, the straw helps.

Needs constant reassurance

Nina’s comments!~

These are so silly fr-

Feel free to request in my asks or dms <3

Nina out

[crushedsweets]

toby and sally :0? I 🫶 ur art

Tobys scared of ghosts and isnt afraid to beef with kids . will argue with them like hes in debate club

[strawberryflavoredvenum]

Toby's clothing style

(images are not mine)

🩷lots of greens and browns to match his eyes and hair.

🩷loose fits with belts and jackets. He never has his arms or legs exposed.

🩷likes to have headphones and a bag with him.

🩷gloves are a must to cover his bandages and prevent chewing.

🩷he likes spirals and stripes and stars