#since Maddie always always recognizes the narrator in the books and the narrator appears to always be the same one
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Visit Tumblr Blog
Explore Tumblr blogs with no restrictions, modern design and the best experience.
Last Seen Tumblr Blogs
Fun Fact
130K people were victims of a chain letter scam that affected Tumblr in May 2011.
Text
Legend of Shadow High I love you so much but you have so many plotholes <3<3<3
#no 1: confirming that the book and tv show happen in the same universe when that makes no sense but to choose a specific example:#Brooke and Maddie meet in this book for the first time but in the tv show they met way earlier and since this book refers to events that#happen later in the show this cannot be a case of 'this book takes place at a different point in the timeline than what we thought'#also tv show Maddie only refers to her as the new or young narrator and recognizes her as such#in the book she doesn't recognize her at all saying only she sounds like a girl indicating they hadn't met before#brooke also says that this is her first time narrating solo which contradicts way too wonderland#no 2: Monster High#we know from cupid and other mh media that eah connects to g1 mh but this one connects to g2#so either one eah can connect to multiple versions of mh (which makes sense to me and is what I believe) or the cupid from these books is#either from the mh g2 verse or not from mh at all#no 3: the books until now had only one known narrator while Brooke and Maddie claim there are multiple despite this not being the case#since Maddie always always recognizes the narrator in the books and the narrator appears to always be the same one#in reference to no 2: the point about cupid being from a different mh contradicts no 1#the only way the entirety of this book makes sense is by believing that the entire book simply plays in an alternate universe where both the#events of the show and books happened with minor differences#anyway shadow high is my favorite book and I think that despite all of this it's still enjoyable and most importantly REALLY fun#ultimately these plot holes and such don't matter#ever after high#eah#burtle screms#i like ignoring plot holes for enjoyability <3
18 notes
·
View notes