#shipping criticism?
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Complaining about the love triangle in Wednesday, and complaining about Xavier and Tyler's (but mostly Xavier's) existence as characters. Spoilers and bitching below the cut.
I just don’t understand how two characters with actual superpowers managed to be so boring and unoriginal. Especially Xavier, who was already established as having a connection with Wednesday from their childhood. And considering his superpowers, they could have made it so that his personality compliments his superpowers, like we see with other characters.
Bianca is a siren, so she’s charismatic, confident, and ruthless. It makes sense that the school’s queen bee is a siren. Enid is a werewolf, so her personality is exactly like that of an energetic puppy; she’s friendly, sociable, but she’s also got more than a bit of a temper when provoked.
Xavier can make his artwork come to life, but he also has prophetic dreams, so he’s… mopey and emotionless. He’s not even creepy.
Since we know that he and Wednesday met when they were children, he could have been creepy and macabre like her and the rest of her family. If Xavier was allowed to be creepy or even remotely weird, he would have made for a nice contrast to the other characters’ friendliness while also giving Wednesday something familiar to help her navigate an unfamiliar environment.
Xavier also could have been one of the reasons why Wednesday would actually want to stay at Nevermore aside from the murder mystery she feels compelled to solve. While Wednesday does grow to love and appreciate characters like Enid and Eugene, at the start, Wednesday and Enid have basically nothing in common, and Enid seems to just get on her nerves more than anything else.
If you went the creepy, kooky and altogether ooky route with Xavier’s personality, Enid could then be the friend that gets Wednesday out of her comfort zone, while Xavier could be the friend that she just feels naturally comfortable with. She’d have someone that she could trade banter and dark jokes with, the only person that isn’t immediately put-off by her, the first person she meets outside of her family that would just get her. Then the romance between them would actually make sense.
And they could have done this!
One of Wednesday’s first real smiles of the series is when Xavier reminds her of the day they met at the funeral. But no. Xavier had to spend the rest of the season being weirdly infatuated with Wednesday, despite him having no reason to be, and also playing into the “nice guy” trope when Wednesday doesn’t return his feelings.
The show never even attempts to make you care about either Xavier or Tyler. Sure, Tyler has dead mom syndrome, but Tyler never expresses how he actually feels about it. He never reminisces on any fond memories he might have had of his mother or anything he knows about her, a fact that is especially weird in a show that uses family to develop its characters.
Wednesday is a character basically defined by the family she’s apart of, and in the show she is desperate to get out from her parents’ shadow (a weird choice, but at least a choice was made). But more than that, it’s established that she readily protects people from bullies because of the way her brother was bullied at school. While she states that she wants nothing more than to escape her parents’ shadow, it’s also shown that she inherited a lot of her interests and values from her parents, and that she would not be the person she is without them.
Enid’s biggest insecurity is the fact that she hasn’t “wolfed out” yet like the rest of her siblings, and that it has estranged her from her family and made her a source of disappointment for her mother.
Bianca’s whole character conflict is the fact that her mother is a cult leader that uses her siren abilities to manipulate her followers, and she’s trying to make Bianca follow in her footsteps, which Bianca fiercely rebels against.
But Xavier? We know literally nothing about his family, his past, or if he even has a life outside of Wednesday. Like, the only story from his past is the story of how he met Wednesday. We later learn that he and Bianca used to date, but why? We never learn the reason why they got together, but we know the reason they broke up: Xavier dumped her because he thought she was using her Siren powers on him (which she wasn’t). Great, so the only thing we learn from that is that Xavier is a racist dick and that Bianca, apparently, has no taste in men, considering that she spends a frustratingly long amount of time trying to get back together with him.
The reveal of this relationship only brings up more questions than it actually answers. Why did they get together? What did Bianca ever see in Xavier? Why did Xavier get into a relationship with her in the first place if the reason he broke up with her was because he thought she was manipulating him? But also, what evidence did he have to come to this conclusion in the first place? Especially if we know that Bianca wasn’t manipulating him?? Which, if we’re following that line of thought, what did Xavier even like about Bianca? All we ever learn about their relationship is one line of dialogue from Bianca, where she says that they were “good together”, but were they? How? It just doesn’t make any sense, and it’s really stupid.
The more I think about Xavier as a character, the angrier he makes me, because he really was just so unnecessary. The only use he has is to set up a love triangle and be an alternative suspect in Wednesday’s investigation. Basically, he only exists to get framed and make Wednesday feel vaguely guilty about inadvertently arresting the wrong person.
#wednesday#xavier thorpe#tyler galpin#wednesday addams#enid sinclair#bianca barclay#wednesday netflix#this doesn't really qualify as an anti shipping post but its not a pro shipping post so how tf do i tag this#shipping criticism?#yeah i guess that works#wednesday criticism
16 notes
·
View notes
Text
A father's lament
timelapse under cut
as you can see, i was struggling haushaus
#jade draws#critical role#cr3#critical role fanart#imogen temult#relvin temult#i know it wont do well since it's not a ship art or the focus of a main pcs but i was having thoughts on relvin#and the fact that i never drawn him properly
4K notes
·
View notes
Text
Essek: I want to study you Ashton: haha, like... carnally? ;)
#critical role#critical role fanart#cr spoilers#<just in case!#essek thelyss#ashton greymoore#cr 3#bells hells#shadowmoore#< im fuckin tickled theres a ship tag for this already LMAO#critical doodles#anyway ashton wants to fuck essek so bad it makes him look stupid <3
5K notes
·
View notes
Text
#Imogen did started to do it earlier but it also happened right before the confession to Laudna.#Now she just experimenting with what she already got because her relationships crumble.#I can't believe that I once again spending so much time on memes...#bells hells#critical role fanart#critical role#cr3#Dorian Storm#Imogen Temult#Ashton Greymoore#dorym#imodna#callowmoore#It's so funny that I just did the pin post and took time to write how I rarely tag ships#and that's pretty much the first thing I do after this
6K notes
·
View notes
Text
Vax 🤝Percy🤝'if we stay in here any longer Vex will be Really Fucking Gutted and we can't have that'
#tlovm spoilers#cr spoilers#tlovm#the legend of vox machina#percival de rolo#vax'ildan#critical role#the handshake meme in the middle of this emotional moment tho KJNJTRKHNTNRHNKTRNHNR#not a percildan post. ship what you like but uh please not on my post <3 ty
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
When Gomez Addams obsesses over his tol goth wife who he calls a million pet names, everyone calls them couple goals. But when a gay lil angel does the same thing for her tol demon gf suddenly it's toxic? As if Charlie isn't such a huge enough sweetheart to deserve having someone fawn over her anyways.
#hazbin hotel#chaggie#Vaggie's love is just Addams levels of DE-VO-TION now leave her alone#charlie morningstar#vaggie#there are ton of other het ships out there with one person being overly obsessed with the other#in much bigger scales than vaggie does#yet gets less criticisms#anyways#my art
4K notes
·
View notes
Text
It feels good to be able to help. (for @overnighttosunflowers)
#critical role#criticalroleedit#imodna#southerngothic#marisha ray#laura bailey#imogen temult#laudna#laudna cr#gifs#*#*cr#*parallel#*request#cr3#ship: imodna#1k#scheduled#16m c3e4#3h15m c3e12#18m c3e17#3h16m c3e19#17m c3e40#2h35m c3e46#1h38m c3e49#3h48m c3e102#THANKS ABBY for all your help on this!!!!!!!! you're a real one. i hope it turned out at least a little bit like you wanted!!#revisiting all these moments was such a heartache-y nostalgia trip. i love them so much...i MISSED them so much........#also it wouldn't fit in this set but imogen laughing and saying 'it feels good to be able to help!'#and then her face falling and watching with so much worry and So much love when laudna quietly folds in on herself. augh
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
POV: You're Ashton Greymoore
#critical role#critrole#critrole memes#bells hells#bell's hells#ashton greymoore#caleb widogast#essek thelyss#the mighty nein#shadowmoore#shadowgast#i don't know if there's a ship name for the 3 of them#and i'm too tired to try to think of anything#caleb x essek x ashton#hey we saw you from across the bar#cr memes#cr shitpost#courtesy of me#cr campaign three#crit role#critrole meme#cr3#cr c3#1k
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
I love Zutara as much as the next girlie, but I think people romanticizing Zuko catching Azula's lightning in the Final Agni Kai are doing Zuko's character a massive disservice. He would have done that for anyone. Not just anyone in the Gaang, anyone.
He did it for the division he ended up getting burned over. He did it for his subordinate that was going to fall to his death after the ship was struck by lightning. He did it for Lee, when he was kidnapped by Gao. He did it for Iroh, when he confronted his dad and tried to break him out of prison. He did it for the whole Gaang at the Western Air Temple. He did it for Sokka, Suki, and Hakoda at the Boiling Rock.
His whole character revolves around saving everyone else first. Hell, he tried to save Zhao of all people! There's no way that would have gone well for Zuko if Zhao had actually taken his hand. He always does what he thinks is right first before considering his own safety.
Zuko always saves other people. Even if, especially if, he can't save himself.
#look i love zutara#but zuko has no conception of personal safety#there are better zutara moments in atla!!!!#like i will absolutely still read fanfic that romanticizes that scene#but it still would have happened if literally anyone else had been standing there#zutara#zutara criticism#i'm going to tag this as#anti zutara#just in case someone doesn't want to see a critique of the ship#i'm not really critiquing the ship#but out of an abundance of caution#uh actual antis if you see this: behave yourselves lol#zuko#avatar the last airbender#atla
5K notes
·
View notes
Text
kiss kiss fall in love
#liltaire's art#digital art#critical role 1#critical role fanart#critical role#critrole#vox machina#legend of vox machina#the legend of vox machina#cr fanart#critical role tlovm#tlovm#vex'ahlia#keyleth of the air ashari#keyleth#vexleth#vex x keyleth#keyleth x vex#vexahlia#opening of ohshc lives in my head rent free#i still think this ship slays#and should have been canon#anyway#wlw art
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
LIKE ESP DURING THE CHANGELING PARTS OH MY GODDD
I just appreciate their dynamic oh so much and can go on about how much I adore em RAHHHHH I love girldad Chilchuck so much I'm so glad its canon
I need to draw them again oh my godddd I need them being each other's shitty wingmen as well holy shit lmfao
#i will not take criticism teehee#dunmeshi#dungeon meshi#delicious in dungeon#chilchuck tims#chilchuck#marcille donato#marcille#hate to break it but i do not like them as a ship at all so#probs wanna dni if you do ship em if im bein honest#theyre just very father daughter coded to me#I OBV RESPECT OTHER INTERPRETATIONS#but yknow#haysprite
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
Castiel : So.
Castiel : I'm in love.
Castiel : with Dean.
Sam :
Castiel : I'm in love with Dean.
Sam : Our Dean?
Castiel : Yes.
Castiel : Thoughts?
Sam : And prayers your gonna need them.
#That's how it happened#i will not take criticism#incorrect quotes#supernatural#castiel supernatural#sam winchester#castiel love dean#castiel x dean#castiel#dean winchester#sam ship destiel#Sam and Castiel#Castiel and sam#brother in law#sam is tired of destiel#destiel#destiel headcanon
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
My Sam & Max cosplay I debuted at a local con during the weekend!
#wasnt wearing leg padding in these so sorry sams a bit skinny#sam and max#cosplay#crunchchute art#my art#i could remake the pants and jacket entirely but that would be quite hard actually. i suck at making jackets especially#so those are just thrifted and edited#lots of color differences that bug me but. oh well#pants and jacket arent that different but its noticeable in these pics#as well as maxs hands and feet. theyre slightly lighter as the fabric i used is better quality#but i ran out of the stuff i used on his body etc and i couldnt buy more from that store as they took their sweet time shipping the stuff#oh well. didnt make them for a competition so its okay#im my own biggest hater and my own biggest critic#at the end of the day i made a handful of people really happy and thats all that matters to me#gotta share them every chance i get as i usually just make a cos#wear it to the con and then put it on the shelf#but im too happy with these to just hide them away after#they need a good scrub and after that id like to bring them to another con. next main goal is viecc but thats just a maybe right now
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
I wanna be a cowboy babyyyyyy
#critical role#critical role fanart#critical role spoilers#cr spoilers#dorian storm#braius doomseed#dorian/braius#cr 3#bells hells#i'm henceforth calling this ship....#stormbull#anyway I had to get this out of my system jaskdhasjd#critical doodles
2K notes
·
View notes
Text
i hadnt drawn fearnie with her curly hair yet and that's my bad. anyway, world's in their hands and i'm on my knees.
(my commissions are open again! check my pinned post for deets)
#fearne calloway#jester lavorre#critical role#bells hells#mighty nein#cr spoilers#obviously i ship it i have eyes
971 notes
·
View notes
Text
I miss them T^T I miss the blue girlies
#jade draws#critical role#cr2#critical role fanart#beaujester#jester lavorre#beauregard lionett#please please be respectful under this post. i can read tags remember#im giving cr tumblr one last chance whether or not they can be nice on a cr2 ship#anyway. theyre one of the big reason i got into cr and met long time mutuals who some i consider a friend now#if you followed me since c2 days. you know im fixated over them
3K notes
·
View notes