#not quite discourse but tagging
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I love three houses discourse because I'm pretty sure everyone just picks their route based on which house leader they're the most gay for and then tries to defend their pick by pointing out the other sides's war crimes via twitter memes. Reader, all four of them do substantial quantities of war crimes. So many. We're just here because the woman with Issues and a big fuck-off axe said so, and then we gotta justify everything she did in the name of dismantling the class system. I mean, I'm here for that, but you could also try justifying Charm Man uses poison and perfidy to try to stop racism, A Sad Little Meow Meow gives no quarter instead of doing therapy, or the Thicc Pope tries to bring back her mom via human experimentation, depending on your tastes
#This is 100% swinging at a hell of a hornet's nest#Do I tag it?#Yeah fuck it we ball#fe3h#fe16#edelgard von hresvelg#claude von riegan#dimitri alexandre blaiddyd#rhea fire emblem#I should probably clarify that I love all of these characters quite dearly#Well except Rhea#I think she's a good character but I'm not feral about her like Edelgard or charmed by her like Claude or desperate to save her like Dimitr#discourse#edelgard discourse#Edit: I actually donāt care about 3H discourse either way lol#thereās plenty of interesting shit to talk about in this game#also I get that the people who say āx did war crimesā actually donāt mean āthis was bad because it violated the Geneva Conventionā#but any time I see something about how many war crimes someone did (usually Edelgard or Dimitri) I just think:#āHah itās a war crime to deploy Cyril to rescue Flayn because heās still 14 thenā#also I got into this game because someone told me āso thereās a gal with an axe and traumaā and I booted it up#and I have a friend who likes Rhea despite his moral reservations solely because āsheās hot thoā#and thatās also really funny#point is I donāt really wanna participate in most fe3h discourse cuz I have shit to do but this post isnāt meant to be a dunk on anyone#Iām not upset when I see it; itās either funny or fine or sometimes right#Iām just gay for Edelgard and amused by the idea of applying the Geneva Convention to a world where it Clearly Isnāt A Thing
253 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
yknow i say im a huge multishipper but i wouldnt actually consider myself much of a shipper at all. just open to the idea of trying everything once. the term has typically romantic connotations and follows the assumption that i think, and want, these characters to be good for eachother.
I'm, personally, less interested in the prexisting chemistry than i am in the puzzle of figuring out what differing circumstances could potentially cause two characters who have seemingly nothing in common to become eachothers everything.
This could explain my favorism towards rarepairs and more convoluted dynamics, and my aversion to popular, fluffy pairings that have already been explored a thousand times over, there's no work for me to do there.
Not to mention that when a ship becomes too popular it starts cannibalising itself, and lots of good, interesting characterisations are lost in the sea of people bending characters into pre-orchestrated, saccharine dynamics. alot of which are usually downright fetishy in nature, particularly in mlm pairings.
I mean i would say being able to get ooc and self indulgent is downright mandatory for making a good fic, but there's only so many times i have to read a fic about a big, overprotective, manly-man top who does all the work and the shy, small, swoony, softhearted femme-wifey-bottom before it starts to just be lazy.
I actively have to go out of my way to search 'switch' tags if i want true-to-the-character, mutual emotional reciprocation. which i really, really shouldn't have to do as an ace person who actively skips through nsfw.
And it's not that popular wlw pairings aren't guilty of these problems aswell, but those tend to lean more into the 'soft lesbians who can do no wrong' stereotype, which always completely (butch)ers all nuisance that makes the ship worth shipping in the first place.
As well as that's if they're even the focus of the story at all and aren't just shoved to the side by the main mlm couple. mlw pairings can be culpable of both these things, with the added risk that you find out the author made a twitter post with the characters in front of the 'super straight' flag.
Though i also wonder if me being aspec plays any part as again; im not as interested in the romantic aspects as i am in the possible hurdles they may face throughout the potential relationship.
Anyone else feel like this?
#though its not that i hate popular ships.#ill read anything if i find it interesting#cryptic ramblings#ship discourse (but not really)#fandom critical#fandom crit#fandom#this is about fandom and shipping culture in general but some places i see this in are#homestuck#genshin impact#zhongchi#davekat#dirkjake#ittogorou#kavetham#< these are ships i actually quite like. im just not too fond of the fanon characterizations of#dirkjake has gotten far better over the years though#if you have any more leave them in the tags#yknow for someone who hates discourse i sure do talk about it alot#in my defense it's the people who get really pressed over their pairings#and become aggressive at differing opinions that I don't like#oh and#neuvifuri#kazuscara#longpost#xiaoven#thomato#kaebedo#chiscara
96 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
i might get some hate for this depending on where this post goes but i think lesboys are so valid and the discourse about them is so ridiculous. like you guys shouldn't have to deal with all that and it frustrates me that people throw hissy fits over an identity that literally does not affect them at all.
"but men cant be lesbians-" wrong. butch lesbians and trans men have a really closely connected history with each other that practically intersects and you should really do some research on that before you make blanket statements, not to mention that gender and sexuality is weird and wobbly and fluid and a very personal experience. it means a different thing to each person. being a man can be something completely different and saying stuff like this ignores people like demiboys, demigirls, genderfluid and genderflux people etc. these people will really preach "demolish the gender binary!! love is love!!" until someone's relationship with gender and sexuality is a little too freaky for them to handle and be challenged by lmaoo
"ohhh but what about the cishet men who say they're lesbians to prey on women-" YEAH WHAT ABOUT THEM????? THIS AIN'T ABOUT THEM BRO!!!!! this argument also REEKS of terfy "trans women are just predatory men!!!111!!1" rhetoric and it grosses me out. yeah some men are gross and do try to pull this but that does not negate someone's entire identity completely just because of a few bad actors, you know that right? actual black and white behaviour.
queer discourse is silly and i don't know why it's a thing. just let people exist. it isn't that hard. we have worse things to worry about than whether someone calls themselves a lesboy or not. i think we need to unplug our ears and yank our heads out of the sand and remember that the queer community is what it is because of our unique and amazing diversity. arguing over labels like school children isn't gonna help that. damn.
#also this should be obvious but terfs fuck off go explode you are not welcome here this is a terf UNsafe space#terfs fuck off#terfs dni#terfs eat shit#terfs explode#this post is really random but i'm actually quite compelled and interested in queer discourse even though i think it's stupid and silly.#i'm compelled by how angry other people get over literally nothing and ironically i end up discovering some new identities and developing a#-newfound love for the diversity of our community#like i could be reading some shitty post about an identity i don't know about and all i would be thinking is ''that exists? thats so cool!'#and then i end up ignoring the bad post and research the identity and think ''man i love how queer we all are''#exclus people seem really sad. like im not saying this to be mean i genuinely think they seem really frustrated by everything.#where's the joy in limiting your support and policing people around all day. where's the fun and growth in that. where's the learning.#i obviously cannot change people's minds but if i could then i'd make sure no one falls into the trap of being an exclusionist because that#-sounds like it really sucks.#going full hippie mode in the tags lol#i'd rather be a hippie than make allies with terfs#anyway lesboys are cool gender is an illusion buy gold bye
62 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Why Tsubaki Yayoi is the Best and Most Interesting Character in Blazblue and Everyone is Wrong About Her
Alternate Title: Tsubaki is a Good, Interesting, Tragic, and Misunderstood Character so You're Wrong, Actually
I have noticed during my time in the fandom that this girl is demonized and gets A LOT of hate from the BB community, mainly calling her a "bitch", "stupid", "annoying''', "incestous simp," etc. At best, she's a very divisive character who does have some fans who correctly say she's overhated, but besides either of those, she'll be largely ignored despite her being a pretty major character. (I guess because she's not a "waifu" or "fanservicey" like most of the other girls. I side-eye anyone who doesn't like her outfit.) Literally the only thing not divisive or hated about her is her theme song.
I quite frankly think the hate is for misogynistic and crappy reasons from people who don't pay attention and has gone on for long enough, so here's my big defense post about Tsubaki Yayoi that I've been wanting to write for a while now where I explain why her character works in the story as best as I can. Strap in, folks. This is gonna take a while.
(Warnings: Mentions of incest, inbreeding, and grooming. Spoilers for Blazblue in general, mainly the parts revolving around Tsubaki. Also long af.)
Let's start with her beginnings because where else is a better place to start off? Talking about her backstory is VERY important when discussing Tsubaki since she has went through plenty of trauma. The Yayoi family is a family that places a lot of importance on their lineage and bloodline. However, they placed so much importance on their own bloodline that in trying to birth strong children, they resorted to incest and inbreeding, meaning that Tsubaki is a product of incest. All the children that were born, expect for one, would end up dying. The one child that survived was Tsubaki. Thus, she ended up being the heiress to the Yayoi family.
Her family is pretty much a cult, especially since the Imperator is basically a God. The family basically raised Tsubaki to serve and have full faith in the Imperator, no matter what. In gameplay, she mentions God in a few of her attacks so even in that, the cult-like philosophy she grew to have is showcased.
Does all this sound insane and messed up? That's because it is. Keep in mind of all of this since it gives plenty more context into her character. It's worth noting that this is the first big thing we learn about her in her arcade mode in Continuum Shift, the game she's first playable in.
So from the get go, it's already clear Tsubaki had a rough childhood, having a family resorting to incest, being the only child to survive, and she's essentially raised in a cult. This is when she meets Jin Kisaragi, a boy who is similar in age to her (probably just around a month older if I had to guess). Tsubaki is happy at the prospect of meeting someone who is similar in age to her, befriending him, and even calls him her brother as a result. Keep in mind, all of her siblings died, and she only knew her parents, teachers & relatives. She basically has a sheltered life and hasn't spoken to any other children her age, besides maybe her relatives (if they were close in age to her). Is it any wonder that she's overjoyed at the prospect at finally meeting another child. And yes, while it does seem weird she calls him "Jin nii-sama", I find it hard to blame her since not only was she calling him that since she was a child and thus that's what she's used to, it's also that incest has been so normalized in her family
I'll talk about her relationship with Jin later, so for now, I'll talk about how she's like at NOL Academy. It is here that she becomes roommates with Noel Vermillion and Makoto Nanaya, but they weren't exactly friends at first sight. In fact, Makoto distrusted the two at first due to her being bullied for being a beastkin. Later, a few students start to bully Makoto for being exactly that and Noel for her status and family. Thankfully, Tsubaki stops the bullying and sets the mean girls straight.
Tsubaki:Ā I can't even stand the sight of your deformed mouths from all the foul language and your sunken eyes from looking down at others... I truly feel sorry for your so-called "family name."
And yet, people call Tsubaki a bitch. SMH. Of course, Tsubaki becomes best friends with Noel and Makoto after this and she's very kind to the two, helping them whenever they need it and only chastising them when they're being silly, like any other 'straight man' in a comedy.
It's after this that she becomes part of the NOL so that brings me to my next talking point, her arc in Continuum Shift.
In Continuum Shift, she is tasked by Hazama to kill Jin and Noel for deflecting from the NOL. Tsubaki's entire life has been based around NOL propaganda and she's basically been indoctrinated to be the perfect soldier for the NOL so she has grown to be very dependent on them. Is it really a surprise that she's not going to act logically? In her point of view, she's making the most rational choices of what's been given to her. Even smart people like Tsubaki can get indoctrinated and groomed.
The reason I even put the term "groomed" is because while yes, being groomed sexually is the most common way to be groomed, grooming can happen in other ways, even when you're an adult. In Tsubaki's case, she was groomed from a religious standpoint.
I think another thing that gets ignored is that Tsubaki is not completely for the idea. She even thinks that Jin and Noel have reasons for turning their backs on the NOL and just wanted to talk to them at first. However, since she's been groomed to never doubt the NOL, she has to go through with it anyway. It's plain to see in her arcade mode that she has plenty of concerns about it. In fact, when she sees Jin, she doesn't want to fight him and just tries to tell him to go back to the NOL. It's only when Jin refuses and takes out his sword that Tsubaki fights back.
Even after she beats him, she doesn't take the opportunity to execute him like she was tasked to do and again, just tells him to return to the NOL. She didn't even think she would beat him! She also would've probably done the same thing if she fought Noel and if Hazama hadn't come to manipulate her again.
Oh yeah, speaking of Hazama, Tsubaki is hated for letting Hazama manipulating her and she's called a stupid bitch as a result, but let's bring up a scene in his route, showing how he manipulates her, shall we?
When he talks to her, he does so at first, by giving her praises, as manipulators are prone to do, and it really feels that this is what Tsubaki wanted to hear for quite some time now, even with her confusion at first. He says she's kind, graceful, intelligent, beautiful, etc., even calling her the heroine, basically smooth-talking her. He even points out how it's rather unfair that someone like Tsubaki could be put in a low-ranking position like the Wings of Justice, even calling it the garbage disposal like how some of the other characters call it.
Of course, he doesn't genuinely feel that way. It's all so he can make Tsubaki more comfortable around him more and that she'll believe anything he tells her.
After this, he basically tells her there's another timeline where Noel doesn't exist and Tsubaki is Jin's secretary instead. The sad thing is that Hazama isn't even entirely wrong when he says this.
There actually is a timeline where Tsubaki is Jin's secretary, and this is explored in a drama CD called The Wheel of Fortune. However, Hazama leaves out one important detail...Tsubaki ends up getting killed in that timeline, which he is more than aware of. However, this is not something Tsubaki herself would have any way of knowing. The only time she technically does find out is through Izayoi's arcade mode in Central Fiction, which is a few games ahead.
Tsubaki did see this vision of her working alongside Jin when first wielding the Izayoi. She does try to hide that she saw this vision from Hazama, but he reads her like a book and calls her out for lying, even saying before that he can't stand liars. Again, not much reason for Tsubaki to think heās the one lying. He's an important figure of the NOL, so why should she doubt him?
Also, if she's told there's a world where she can be with the man she loves, why wouldn't she want that and be angry she can't now? And especially when Hazama leaves out the fact that would end with her DEAD?? Would she be mad at Noel if she knew that part? I highly doubt it.
Tsubaki finally shows the jealousy, hate, and anger that she's been bottling up for a while since she basically got robbed. Hazama tells her it's not wrong for her to feel that way and that none of this is her fault, basically motivating her to kill Noel.
One of the main reasons Tsubaki gets hate is for her hating Noel and trying to kill her since she "took her place" as Jin's secretary in the NOL. Thisāll explain more of her contempt.
One important thing to realize is that Tsubaki was basically raised to be an "ideal woman." (Or Yamato Nadeshiko for those who know what that is). She's calm and level-headed, she's a heiress to an important family, she's a Straight A student, and she's the closest to Jin out of anyone. It seems like the role would be given to her on a silver platter (and it WAS in the first timeline, actually!) But then comes Noel, who seemingly is not as talented, her family is not of high status, she's not close to Jin at all, and is basically not seen as deserving of it as Tsubaki is.
Tsubaki is instead put in a lower position than Noel, the Wings of Justice, something that is infamous and basically hated from everyone who has heard of it since they're basically the military police. Which, I know "Lol she's a cop"...she's not the only character that's a cop, 'K? Let's move on.
Another noteworthy detail to note is that Tsubaki just hid her resentment about this for a long time and didn't blow up at Noel until she is told she could've HAD that opportunity if Noel didn't exist. Tsubaki didnāt want to feel that way since she knew it was wrong for her to do so, but now you have Hazama telling her itās not wrong for her to feel that way.
The 3rd important thing is that during their fight, Tsubaki....can't bring herself to kill Noel. Even when she's angry, hates Noel for taking her place, and has the advantage over her, she STILL cannot find it in herself to kill Noel. Even through this, she values their friendship too much for that to happen. Then Hazama comes and fucks it all up, because he's Hazama.
The next thing I'll mention is the Izayoi. The Izayoi is basically the biggest indicator of Tsubaki's character, as it's heavily showcased in her lore and gameplay. The Izayoi is a weapon that has the ability to steal light so that its user can utilize it in someway, mostly in battle. However, its biggest downside is that it can also steal light from its user, and if used too much, can blind and even kill them (which happens to Tsubaki in her bad ending). The Izayoi causes physical and mental harm to Tsubaki throughout the game, blinding her and causing her mental torment in who and what she should fight for to achieve true justice. The term "blind justice" is in full effect here.
It's through this game that we see Tsubaki as a woman who is full of doubts of who she is, what her place is in the world, who she should fight for, why should she fight, and is struggling with her ideas of what true justice is. She becomes so isolated that the only person she has on her side is a manipulative coworker who subjects her to further conditioning. The main question in her mind throughout is this: Should she follow the organization she's been groomed to follow her whole life or should she follow her friends, the two people she's been closest to her whole life? By the time she figures out the truth about Hazama, it's already too late and she is subjected to further brainwashing, leading her to "choose" the latter. This leads us into Chronophantasma.
There's not much to talk about with that game in comparison but it'll be more straightforward because of one important detail: She gets hate for her Chronophantasma depiction because she's a villain and is trying to kill Jin, Noel, and Makoto, but this completely ignores that Tsubaki....isn't herself for the majority of the game??? The Imperator is fucking up her head and Tsubaki at that point is completely brainwashed by the Mind Eater. PSST, I think the black outfit and red eyes she has should be a sign that she's brainwashed. Also, the "Mind Eater" name should give it away too.
Jin, Noel, and Makoto work together to save Tsubaki from the Mind Eater, but this is when Izanami has completely taken over her mind and is talking through her. It's pretty clear during the fight that Tsubaki is struggling and trying to break free from the Imperator's control, which, thanks to the three's help, does happen!
One aspect I love and that I feel is not talked about is a small scene where Tsubaki is in the inner depths in her mind, and coming to terms that she has darkness in her heart. From there, she wants to atone for every bad thing she did to Jin, Noel, and Makoto, and wants to return how they feel towards her. From there, she breaks free of the Imperator's curse and now wants to fight for the people she loves, since that's how she can achieve true justice.
Real talk, her fight against these three, awakening as Izayoi, and breaking out of the Imperator's control is one of the best moments in the entire franchise. Don't @ me.
Now, let's talk about her relationship with Jin. There's plenty of claims about their relationship being a toxic mess that would never work out and while I can't deny it's not entirely healthy, I don't think it's as much of a mess as people say it is. People say she has no reason to love him since he's just an asshole which, while fair, is not how I personally see it. I actually think it's rather reasonable why she would love him, so I'll explain why from her point of view.
I heard stuff like how Jin doesn't care about Tsubaki, which is...not even true?? Jin is the only person besides her family and teachers that Tsubaki knew her whole life and he's been quite decent to her. Yes, Jin is a huge jerk...but the person he's nicest to is Tsubaki. Back at the Academy, Jin, while still rather aloof, is pretty kind and attentive towards Tsubaki. He checks up on her and her friends regularly, gives her advice on what she can do, and they're able to hold a conversation with without her getting insulted. Also, in the present, there's a sword that's screwing with his head and basically has a shoulder devil AND angel telling him to kill Ragna, so there's that too.
In Chronophantasma, Jin does his best to put his fight against Ragna to the wayside since to him, Tsubaki comes first. He even works alongside Noel, someone who he deeply hates, to save Tsubaki. During their fight, he wholeheartedly believes that her will to fight through is stronger than the Imperator's curse. Now, it's debatable whether he feels the exact same way towards Tsubaki, but you can't deny his soft spot is usually only reserved for her. It's the regular "jerk/villain having that one special person they care about" trope.
One misconception is that she has nothing but blind love towards him, but I personally think if she did have blind love towards him, she would think he has done nothing wrong, which isn't the case as I'll explain in two instances.
One is regarding Jin's hatred towards Noel. Tsubaki doesn't really like how cold he is towards her. Back at the Academy, she did notice this, and she told him to be nicer towards Noel. According to Jin, Tsubaki has told him this several times. As Tsubaki says here, they've been close since they were children, but Noel has been a great friend too. All she wants is her two dearest friends to get along. It's a classic case of a person's close friends fighting with each other and that person being stuck in the middle. I've been in this situation a few times cough- Hell, I think she's one of the only characters who says to Jin to be nicer to Noel. Though since Tsubaki mainly appears in flashback scenes and isn't playable in Calamity Trigger, I can see how that gets lost.
To me, the biggest instance where this is showcased is her arcade mode in Central Fiction. In that, Tsubaki is given the opportunity to mold the world into what she wants (be by Jin's side) and Jin is targeting Noel for...reasons. So, like a yandere, she'll take Jin's side and target Noel too, right? No. Tsubaki actually protects Noel from Jin and fights him, even putting her life in the line for Noel.
That, to me, showcases how she doesn't see EVERYTHING Jin does is okay & just and won't side with him on everything, especially if he's trying to harm her other friends. It also shows she has put her jealousy and resentment for Noel aside, treasuring her as one of her best friends and it shows she has developed beyond that point since Continuum Shift.
Now, the last big reason she gets hate...her hatred towards Ragna. Now, I can see why that's annoying since for all her development, she never really gets past that point. BUT, I feel like this is mainly blamed with how we follow Ragna the most out of anyone, since well, he's the protagonist. Therefore, we have a much better idea on what happened from his point of view and we, as the players, know that Ragna is not a bad guy. We don't look at Tsubaki's point of view that much in comparison. So, I'll try to explain it from her perspective.
From how Tsubaki sees it, Ragna hasn't done much to get on her good side. She, at first, already doesn't like him because not only is he seen as a criminal to the world, but Noel and Jin, two of the people she cares the most about, also deflected from the NOL, an organization she has devoted her entire life to, due to his arrival. He hurts Jin, the guy she loves, to the point he has to stay in a bed to heal from his injuries, and Noel, her best friend (both also just broke her out of her brainwashing), at the end of Chronophantasma. Another essential thing to know is that Ragna is basically her antithesis. Tsubaki is calm, reserved, polite, and follows authority to a T, while Ragna is brash, foul-mouthed, hot-tempered and doesn't listen to authority. Is this petty and short-sighted? Yes, but it's not like she exactly hates him for no reason. Plus, her grudge against him is hilarious, especially when she thinks of the idea of him as her brother-in-law at one scene in Central Fiction. Sorry not sorry.
At the beginning of Central Fiction, Jin tells Tsubaki his backstory with Ragna and Saya and why he and Ragna have such a huge rivalry now. Tsubaki is actually shocked that Jin would almost kill Ragna, his own brother, like that. In fact, she finds it sad that brothers have to fight with each other like that. Maybe it could just be because Tsubaki places plenty of importance in family relations because of how her own family is like, but I felt this also was her realizing the conflict between Jin and Ragna isn't so black & white as she thought it was. Of course, not long after this, the timeline resets so it can't really be explored more. Blazblue timelines are such a mess, lol
I do think more could'e been done with Ragna & Tsubaki's relationship and it would've been nice to see her at least get a better understanding of him and see he's not as bad as she painted him to be, but it is what it is, sadly.
PHEW, this was long af. I unfortunately think the hate is not just rooted in misogyny, but also that she's a lore-heavy character, and Blazblue lore is infamously really difficult to follow. Not to mention, BB is a fighting game and plenty of people are just in it for the fighting. So if the lore is hard to understand, that would mean Tsubaki is not easy to get by extension. I think how long this essay was is proof enough there was plenty to unpack with Tsubaki, and I didnāt even talk about everything sheās involved with. She's not the easiest character to love at first glance, unfortunately.
BUT even with that, Tsubaki is another sad case of a female character getting demonized for far less than what a male character would do; just needlessly giving her higher standards. "We want morally grey female characters!" Bitch, a lot of ya'll couldn't even handle Tsubaki Yayoi. I have noticed the BB fandom, for the most part, is not welcoming towards female characters unless if they're sexually consumable enough for them, and Tsubaki, of course, is the most modest of all of them. With that being said, enen Noel and Celica of ALL characters get hate, for heaven's sake. There's really no winning with the girls in this series.
There's probably more I could've talked about, but this essay is long enough as it is. Hopefully, I made a good case study on Tsubaki's character and that there'll be a better understanding of her for now on, at the very least. Tsubaki Yayoi deserves more love than she gets, both from the game and fandom.
#blazblue#tsubaki yayoi#character defense#character discussion#discourse#bb spoilers#my first long fandom essay post in quite a while#I have no regrets posting this#I'm not tagging any of the other characters I mentioned here since this is mainly about tsubaki#this was long af. longer than I wanted it to be but it was definitely worth it.#I could probably talk about her relationships with jin and hakumen more in depth if there's interest in that. Definitely not rn tho#I'd put more images but Tumblr only allows 30 images#tw: incest#tw: grooming#tw: cults
34 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
'ALL men have privilege because they're men' some of y'all are really out here forgetting that lots of trans men have not ever been (and may not ever be!) seen by society as men huh š¤Ø
(And no, people knowing you're a trans man and accepting you as such doesn't mean the deeply ingrained biases against people perceived as cis women suddenly go away and the biases in favor of people perceived as cis men come out)
#fucking stopppppp#transandrophobia#is that the right tag?#discourse#???? idk putting it in case people want this kind of stuff filtered out#this person wasn't even a terf š#sorry but 'male privilege' goes out the window when you aren't seen as a cis man#I'm not sorry actually quit acting like trans men somehow magically get seen and treated like men stop acting like all#trans men transition medically or otherwise pass stop trying to deny trans men their transness and the sexism they face being seen as girls
33 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
at this point I'm starting to feel like I could graduate, get into residency, complete a superspecialisation program and have a whole ass career by the time Sarah Janet announces ACOTAR 5
#I've beem out of loop with the acotar fandom for quite a while#i really thought I'd missed something but apparently not š#sjm please give this fandom info on who th next couple is I fear things might get worse on here ššš#i just went to a tag and omg how is the ship discourse EXACTLY where it was 2 years ago I'm akfjakfjajfjkakckancj šš#acotar#a court of thorns and roses#i just want to know if it's#gwynriel#because they're kinda the one big reason I am still here lol šš#or even if it's#elucien#then at least I can read it and have a good time with my mutuals who have been elucien girlies for as long as I have known them#anyway yeah#sarah j maas
33 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
It's a shame that one of my most prevalent thoughts following that episode is how much shit I'm sure Matt will be getting on twitter.
Friendly reminder to all that this is a web show. A fictional character has died. Yes, a beloved character, but one that is fictional nonetheless. Unlike the cast, who are real human beings playing out their story. If any of the cast felt that the circumstances were truly unfair they would discuss it amongst themselves in private and sort it out like mature and civilized human beings. Harassing the people who put so much love and work into the show, who feel all the highs and lows just as you do, if not more so, does nothing but spread pointless negativity. Go sleep, hydrate, eat, do something to bring your mood up etc etc.
And, please, do not forget to love each other <3
#yknow twitter sucks when im not on twitter its just so known for overreacting in the most toxic ways#not quite worded how id want but dude IM tired lol#IM gonna go snack and watch silly drawfee comps and SLEEP#have a good one yall and take care <3#critical role#cr spoilers#cr lb#c3e91#cr discourse#i hate tagging it but eh. its technically relevant
33 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Now, Caesar had long ago decided to put down Pompey, just as, of course, Pompey also had decided to put Caesar down. For now that Crassus, who was only waiting for the issue of their struggle to engage the victor,ā had perished among the Parthians, it remained for him who would be greatest to put down him who was, and for him who was greatest, if he would not be put down, to take off in time the man he feared.
Plutarch, Caesar
me Crassus when Caesar and Pompey start fighting: šæšæ
there's a more dramatic illustration I want to do of this particular aspect of the Caesar-Pompey dynamic, courtesy of Lucan's Pharsalia, but first. I need to get this out of my system
society6Ā |Ā ko-fiĀ |Ā twitterĀ (pillowfort,Ā cohost) |Ā deviantart
#gaius julius caesar#gnaeus pompeius magnus#marcus licinius crassus#tris homines#komiks tag#drawing tag#roman republic tag#other things i need to get out of my system: all this sulla-crassus-pompey brainrot#sometimes i have commentary in the tags but i keep circling back to the homoeroticism of patron-client relationships#(and resulting debt subtext) courtesy of the quattrocento#and quite frankly. i am too sleepy to talk about economic discourses without saying something deeply weird about it all
181 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Necessary disclaimer that I have not read the story but whenever discourse about it passes me I'm kind of fascinated by the reactions people have to the Omelas short story (or rather the osmosed concept of it since I suspect many of them haven't read it either) and what it says about people's intuitions.
I mean, ok, the thought experiment is clearly constructed to create the instinctual response that it's morally horrifying and unacceptable. But, and I know that I'm not the first person to say it, currently many children are suffering in the real world, which isn't even a utopia in every other way. If you compared the real world with one where everything is the same except only one person is still experiencing [insert worst conditions anyone is experiencing in the real world right now] it's clearly an improvement, right? And then take that world and compare it to one that's a utopia for everyone but that one person. Clearly an improvement again. We've recreated the Omelas scenario in two steps and both of those steps were clear improvements on the present world, presumably people wouldn't object to taking them. So is it the implication of causality that makes the Omelas scenario seem horrifying to people in a way that just existing in the present world doesn't? I mean, suffering is suffering, it's not going to be better for the person experiencing it if no one benefits from it. But it does make sense for it to feel worse to people if someone benefits because the fact that someone is benefiting leads people to suspect that maybe that person could improve the situation but just doesn't have an incentive to since it benefits them, so the horror/anger is more likely to be able to accomplish something than if it were just random suffering to no benefit. By saying it's unacceptable for one person to suffer for utopia the implication must be that you could stop that suffering by maybe sacrificing some aspects of the utopia, but not so many that it just leads to many suffering children and no utopia instead.
From what I understand the point of the story/thought experiment was supposed to be that people can only believe in a utopia if it has a dark secret but if that's the case then the response indicates the opposite: if you can get people to accept the premise of a utopia with a dark secret they will believe that something close enough to a utopia (at least compared to the present world) could exist without it. (Personally I think people probably find the utopia with a dark secret pretty implausible too but are just more willing to suspend their disbelief for it because it sounds like a setup to a more interesting story though). In any case, the horror comes not from contrasting utopia-with-darkside against a baseline of reality but rather against a baseline of the utopia-without-darkside that is also invoked while imagining it.
The other explanation I can see is that people are in fact contrasting it against reality, but removing most of the awfulness of reality draws more attention to the awfulness you haven't removed, so people can respond to the remaining awfulness with the full force of their horror because it isn't competing with everything else. I definitely think that's a factor but not the whole thing, since people don't respond to it like they would to "let's focus on one specific example of the many people suffering in the real world".
18 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
I was thinking about how a lot of people who are into the Vampire Diaries are also into Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and how there are some obvious parallels between the shows and between the relationships of Angel & Buffy and Stefan & Elena and then Spike & Buffy and Damon & Elena, but obviously they aren't exactly the same ships or characters, and it's made me curious. Fans of both, is there a correlation in what you ship?
#the Vampire Diaries#Buffy the Vampire Slayer#Bangel#Spuffy#Stelena#Delena#Spangel#Denzo#I also thought about putting āwitches rule and Tillow and Bamon are superiorā as an option but those don't feel as parallel#Tillow and Bonora maybe but Nora isn't quite as significant to TVD and Bonora suffers from being an obvious rebound#I also learned you can't drag poll options around to reorder them sadly#but the good news is you can have more than 10 choices now#yeah I'm really curious because I feel like there's a correlation in what gifs I see people reblogging but I don't know how strong it'll be#oh I should tag the characters too#Buffy Summers#Spike#William Pratt#Angel#does Liam have a last name I don't remember#Elena Gilbert#Damon Salvatore#Stefan Salvatore#Enzo St. John#Spuffel#is there a poly ship name for a stelena/delena ot3?#anyways. unleash the shipping discourse. I'm bracing myself. lol#I have my opinions but I think they're mostly on my sideblog these days#but yeah. please reblog for data points and all that#i ramble#even in the tags i ramble
17 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
some of you guys posting dungeon meshi discourse need to reread the list of autism symptoms (especially how the symptoms present in girls) bc some of the shit youre saying isn't in the text at all
#dungeon meshi#dungeon meshi discourse#i guess that tag exists#but like. guys. falin isnt socially unaware even if she is autistic coded#shes literally laios's social middleman to translate the rude shit that comes out of his mouth into understandable shit for other people#shes the 'had to learn every social rule' autism#quit saying toshiro only likes her bc shes 'socially unaware enough to express joy' you sound like fucking assholes#and also you're literally wrong about her characterization
17 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
I feel so much fanfic discourse would be easily solved if everyone just learned how to use these:
#normally I never give my two cents#coz idgaf#and#i never use tumblr to read#but whenever I try to#I always get jumpscared by nothing burger discourse being tagged under every x reader tag#this donāt happen on ao3#so I love staying over dere šš¤#quite spam#discourse#?
9 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
seeing the jorge celebrations you posted is so interesting, but besides the gladiator, i didn't even know any of them. dorna and the motorcycle media have been talking valentino's celebrations for years, with stuff like "top 10 valentino rossi celebrations," but they're so indifferent to everyone else's. it's so unfair. thanks for showing me
wait a minute I think melandri said something like this in 2010
obviously jorge himself was a bit of a critic lol
anyway, yeah, of course there is a bit of a disparity, which is in part because dorna knows what will get clicks but is also a bit of a self-perpetuating cycle. I mean, you may have noticed but much of that post was like... me scrounging together screenshots from the actual race footage rather than finding actual nice photos. if you don't show people this stuff, of course they're not gonna decide for themselves whether they're into it or not. it's a shame, because it's kinda also interesting specifically in relation to valentino? like, everyone who was doing celebrations after he '''started'''' it was kinda inevitably in conversation with his approach, and it's an interesting element of his impact on the sport
with jorge specifically, I do think part of it is that it did kinda tail off. you have this 2007 stuff... then you have a few other fun ones like that time he almost killed himself jumping into the water jerez 2010 or the chair in le mans 2010 melandri thought was like, sophisticated subliminal mind games via the colour of the chair. what an incredible sentence to type out. and of course various championship celebrations but... it did change, he still did the lorenzo's land stuff and the jumping on the podium, but it also changed a bit tonally? a little more defiant, not always wanting to give a gift to the fans as much it was rubbing it in their faces. valentino is unique in that he has these kinda staged celebrations over the span of so many years, so you do also have a little bit of an arc there. the way he's changed his approach over those years, when he kinda went back to that over the years and what that meant to him (cf 2003-04) - but then the memorable celebrations post-2006 are really the spontaneous ones (kissing the corkscrew, pointing to the 99, celebrating to the empty jerez grandstands). it's a well he keeps coming back to in one way or the other, but it's hardly a uniform approach. jorge's celebrations tail off way sooner in his career way more sharply - and beyond his actual popularity or lack thereof with the general fanbase at that time, that's probably part of why they haven't stuck in people's minds in the same way
that being said!! yes!! motogp content mills are SO uncreative like!! come on, there's more shit out there!! mine those mills!! or something! let the new fans see jorge jumping over an imaginary rope! also, can I just say, there's two jorge/dovi title fights out there and I bet dorna still has some juicy stuff in their archives the rest of us don't have access to. come on, please, the people are starving
#that post really struck a chord huh. i'm gonna be honest i threw it together very quickly mainly as background for something else#I do agree though motogp is so lazy with this shit. like stop being so rossi-reliant this isn't helping anyone#//#brr brr#batsplat responds#one thing about valentino vs casey/jorge is that he did let the press kinda do a lot of the dirty work for him#which means his real thoughts towards them are a bit...? like you kinda have to infer a lot of things. and when I say infer I mean guess#like the jorge celebrations thing he could've easily been kinda catty about jorge 'copying' him or whatever. which was a discourse point!#but there's a real lack of any sort of direct engagement there from vale. which is kinda tricky because you just don't. know#valentino is oddly quite disciplined in what he actually criticises his rivals on. like it's extreme with marc but even the others#he kinda has his big themes for each. and some of these things are quite nasty but he doesn't like. reach outside those themes#wall tag
9 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
wow you think the proship vs antiship discourse is stupid and that both sides should touch grass. How original. How unique. What, do you wanna cookie for that? /s
#talk away āšµš ā#:))))))#proship#proship discourse#itās fine if you donāt care for the discourse#it just makes me roll my eyes everytime I see a post#from the proship tag#of someone being like āthis whole discourse is stupid! I have a real job and pay taxes! everyone needs to touch grass!ā#as if both sides of the discourse donāt touch grass and donāt have real jobs :/#like your not unique for not caring#in fact your quite average really (imo at least)
8 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
that one mystreet episode
(dont tag as zanmau pretty pls)
#im normally opposed to doing captions like this telling people how 2 reblog but uh i just dont want it being interpreted as ship art#ship zanemau all u want but it aint 4 me#ANYWAYSSS#DONT SHIP DISCOURSE THIS POST!!!!#okay thats kind of a joke because this is TUMBLR but LOOK the invader zim fandom was a scary place 2 years ago#anyways#i should draw more pink and frilly and cute stuff its fun#this is like the first digital art ive made in a billion years#skool really art blocks me its wild#this feelsss unfinished it doesnt feel quite complete but im just sure what else to do with it so here#im scared its BAD but its okay if its bad and i can always redraw it in a year#okay real tag time#art#my art#artwork#digital art#aphverse#aphmau#zane ro'meave#mystreet#aphmau mystreet#zane aphmau#mcyt#sure ill put some aphmau in the mcyt tag
23 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
didn't anyone ever tell u it's rude to interrupt, da-ge
#jesus christ like#okay i don't want to say that my feelings on nmj are souring again exactly because it's not quite like that#i DO think my patience is thin atm just because of some meta i've read that i just strongly disagree with#but come on!!!#there are some things in the text or the show which are deliberately left ambiguous#and up for interpretation#nmj's tears and facial expressions for instance are the subject of much discourse and debate in some servers i'm in lmao#but this moment#and the moment atop the stairs in the novel#where jgy is not even given a chance to speak before nmj decides he already knows what jgy is going to say#(aka he is going to lie)#this isn't headcanon. this is just. the way nmj is#he does not believe meng yao is going to be honest with him#and he does not believe that meng yao was honest with him in the past#and it does not matter what meng yao does going forward because nmj has made up his mind#he did crimes??? good for him š#nie meangjue š¤Æ#(not dropping these in the main tags today)#tl;dr this is fundamentally why n!eyao will never work for me#salty peak sect š§
26 notes
Ā·
View notes