#none of those men on the plain of fucking troy was about to sit down and agree on what constituted a crime of war
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I have not been in this fandom long enough to reasonably judge others' takes however. "EPIC fans are so silly to characterize odysseus as feeling guilty for his actions don't you know he's a war criminal" is definitely a wild one. like first of all to each their own so settle down and let people enjoy things ok. and secondly making choices with a bad outcome, even knowingly and deliberately, does not exclude the possibility of feeling bad about it later. in fact it makes for a much more in depth character because then you get to explore what he does or doesn't feel guilt over, and why, and if that guilt ever edges into regret or not.
#and thirdly i actually find it fascinating the way EPIC had him take a very conscious role in the greying of his morality#it's interesting to me because from my point of view odysseus in the odyssey is almost a passive player in his own myth#and i enjoy taking that very active moral choice and applying it to some of his non EPIC actions#odysseus#epic the musical#uh what is the tag for the epic cycle#as far as I'm aware it's#tagamemnon#?#idk i just think that if you were to ask your character what they would do differently the answer should not be ''nothing lol''#that is either a character who needs wayy more development or a storyteller who needs wayy more practice#also. WAR CRIMES DIDN'T FUCKING EXIST IT WAS THE BRONZE AGE#regardless of how socially acceptable or not his actions may have been#none of those men on the plain of fucking troy was about to sit down and agree on what constituted a crime of war#like if achilles can get away with flaunting straight up deliberate corpse desecration#i don't think anyone gets to say a word against odysseus for being a sneaky underhanded bastard who doesn't fight fair#coming back an hour later to add yet another point. the point of the people with this take is ''haha dont you know hes a bad person''#which fine yes by modern moral standards he is and even by contemporary standards* some of the stuff he does is super yikes man#but that STILL does not preclude him from feeling guilt. 'bad people' can feel guilt#gonna go ahead and explain those quotes around 'bad person' btw um i do not believe in morality like that. no one is fully good or bad#i shant speak on THAT further unless someone asks though#*contemporary is an iffy word here i feel because the default is to call the time of the penning of the text contemporary#despite the events in the text taking place several centuries earlier.#in this particular case because i am speaking from a point of textual analysis i will use the former#however i think that the latter is also a useful reference point
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Walls Have Fallen
(Not sure what this is, I guess Polloâs talking to himself? Pretty experimental)
If I sing, would anyone listen? Would anyone bother with a song of this god in a foolish war?
âYou knew how everything would end.â
I always do.
âYet you still kept up the game of pretendâ
What else wouldâve I done? Would you have rather let them rot?!
âBut isnât that exactly what you did? When your silver arrows pierced the heart of the Grecian camp?â
He refused Chrysiesâ ransom!
âThat is not all, what of the things before it even began? Do you still remember your twin sister, upon seeing the army do her wrong, suggest on giving them an impossible task?â
I thought he wouldnât dare! We thought heâd never agree to such an awful ask!
âBut he did; all for a change in the wind, but this is not all of what you immortals did. Donât act like it never happened. You always remember, even if you wished to forget. It couldâve ended quicker, but it didnât.â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
But I did wish for that, for it to stop!
âBut you didnât let it; you couldnâtâ
That wasnât my fault!
âBut not exempt from blame either; you lot never are. Even now you still smell the blood; hear their cries, and see the desperate look in their eyes, and by the reach of the tenth year, you were desperate too.
âTrojans!â you yelled âRush on the foe; do not let yourselves be thus beaten by the Argives!â all the while as Pallas urged the Achaeans forward whenever she found them slacking.â
I know; it was foolish for me to hope.
âWell, I suppose there was a brief point in the war, where both sides were glad, for they thought they could finally rest, when Paris declared,
ââŠHector, your scorn is as sharp as an axe that a shipwright wields at work, and the rebuke is just. Still, do not taunt me with what the goddess of love has given me. If you would have me do battle with Menelaus, bid the Trojans and Achaeans take their seats; let the victor, who proves to be the better man, take the woman and all that she has, and the rest to swear to a solemn covenant of peace.ââ
I remember that, that and so much more. Youâre right; I havenât forgotten anything at all. Oh, if only the peace Paris spoke of was meant to be!
The gods were sitting on their thrones and gazing down upon the earth.
âWell?â Zeusâ voice thundered across the halls. âWe must consider what we shall do about all this; shall we set them fighting anew or make peace between them?â
Hera couldnât contain herself. âDreaded son of Cronus, is all my effort then, to result to nothing?â
He frowned. âMy dear, what harm have Priam and his sons done that you are so hotly bent on sacking their city? Of all the inhabitants under the stars of heaven, there was none that I so much respected as Ilium with Priam and his whole people.â
âSome of my own favorite cities are Argos, Sparta, and Mycenae. Sack them whenever you are displeased with them. Even if I tried to stop you; I would gain nothing from it, for you are much stronger than I am, but I will not have my own work wasted.â Her voice was stern as they locked eyes. âI am a goddess of the same race as yourself, and am honorable not on this ground only, but also because I am your wife, and you are the king over the gods.â
She continued. âLet it be a case of give-and-take between us; the rest of the gods will follow our lead. Tell Athena to go and take part in the fight at once, and let the Trojans be the first to break their oaths.â
And Athena eagerly went, and Pandarus fired his bow in my name.
âWhy were you so silent?â
I was in Pergamus and there was nothing that I couldâve said to sway them.
Hera wouldnât be the only one upset, some of the Greeks themselves would complain for their work to have been all for naught. They didnât come here to toil for some woman they never met; they were here for the glory and the prizes that they would get. For those men, Helen was merely an excuse, to give reason for what they have done. It would also be easier then, for Agamemnon to quell everyoneâs frustrations of having to fight for him, when they all get their large share of wealth.
âAre you mad?â
âŠNot at my fellow immortals, no. They were only doing their job; they are their patrons after all.
âBut arenât you as well?â
What of it?
âHah, I suppose you mustâve just loved the royal family that much.â
Oh fuck you.
âAm I wrong? Want me to name them one by one?â
You know thatâs not all it was, at least not just that type of love-
Apollo briefly snaps out of his internal monologue when Athena enters the room, but before she could say a word, the god was already gone. He now sits down on the ground, back leaning against one of the many oaks in the garden.
ââŠAre you sure youâre not mad?â
I just need time for myself.
âThatâs what youâve been saying for the past 4 monthsâ
Okay fine, maybe a little bit, but I still try not to be. Even then, in the midst of the war, I tried not to fight them.
âLike when Poseidon and Artemis insulted you and Hera hit your twin with her own bow?â
I meant when Athena and I were on good terms; proud of our men, and watching them duel while we were vultures perched on fatherâs high oak-
ââIdiot, you have no sense, and forget how we two alone of all immortals fared hardly round about Ilium for Laomedon.â
âSo you would fly Far-Darter, and hand victory over to Poseidon with a cheap vaunt to boot. Coward, why keep your bow thus idle?-ââ
Iâd have no respect for myself if I were to quarrel with them because of a pack of miserable mortals-
âBut you already have, and what good did it do you?-â
Ares fought to oppose Athena; Aphrodite intervened for Paris and Aeneas.
I cared for the whole of Troy.
I went before their horses to smooth the way, carrying the Aegis, the Achaeans were afraid. I gifted great strength to Hector, the shepherd of my people, as he gladly sped forward, killing all that stood in his way. I destroyed the Argivesâ wall as easily as a child that kicks down a sandcastle on the beach.
Nothing escaped my gaze, for as long as they fought on the plains, Iliumâs walls stood tall, the Greeks frustrated and in a daze. Not even Patroclus could get in, as I beat the helmet off his head, and undid the fastenings of his corset, his shield falling down to the ground.
I was not helpless; I am not useless, and I do not regret a single act.
âIf you believe this to be so, then why do you feel the need to say all of this? Whom are you trying to convince?â
âŠwho else?
I think the answer is obvious.
#Apollo#Iliad#Trojan war#greek gods#greek mythology#Not sure what i just did#soliloquy???#Well it is what it is#MyWritingShit#idk#experimental
31 notes
·
View notes