#new descendants book
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
content aside, i think that diversifying your reading also means reading a variety of forms. even if you can burn through novels across genres and moods and subjects—they’re still novels. can you try short stories, a playscript, a book of poems? i think familiarity with these different forms is underrated and offers a lot
#really and truly. when was the last time you read a new form#books#i mostly read novels and poetry i make no secret of that!#but what a delight short stories have been lately#every day i pick a lil soapbox#to ascend and descend very daintily#mine#okay to reblog
493 notes
·
View notes
Text
What about….. descendants AU???
(Quick idea bcs fight of our lives is on repeat rn. It’s going to be messy since im copying what I had in my notes, so excuse any typos)
-----------------------------------------------------------
So Arthur is the prince of Avalon blah blah blah instead of villains here they banned magic and sent all sorcerers to the isle.
Ok so Morgana turns out to be a sorcerer, Arthur who is about to be crowned king is like “we need to do something this has to change, let’s give them a chance” so he decides to invite a few of the children of the isle to come and study here.
Now enter the vks
We got manic pixie boy Merlin who grew up with stories about magic and dragons and his (absent) father and hates what the crown has done to sorcerers and magic. He's always felt like his very existence is a crime.
His magic? Banned. Books? Confiscated. He’s lived all his life in the isle so he does not know what magic feels like but but but he knows there’s something in his chest a pressure like he can’t never take a real breath like there’s something holding him back. He feels there’s something inside him that’s begging to come out.
Merlin, Nimue, Freya idk all the sorcerers maybe Mordred can come too I like him, are chosen to go to Avalon High.
They are happy about it, yeah why not, maybe things are finally changing and they might have a chance at leaving the island and having a different future, they heard the prince is not like his father, they want to give him a chance.
Merlin specially wants to give him, whoever he is, a chance.
Then they get there n meet Arthur n he’s all formal and wear this fake smile n Merlin can tell he’s doing this reluctantly, he is not confortable or happy to be greeting them, their presence alone bother him and it’s showing.
It’s obvious to them that deep down he hates magic n since magic is what he is he must hate Merlin too so not a great start.
When they crossed the bridge, Merlin felt it, it’s like the world got back it’s colors, like seeing, breathing for the first time.
Magic is in desuse in Avalon so people don’t learn it nor practice it but since Merlin is magic the second he leaves the isle he's able to use magic naturally as if he had been doing it all his life.
He begins experimenting with it and conjuring cute fire dragons and showing the others what they missed all those years and suddenly he realises that up until that point, without his magic, the very source of his being, Merlin was not living.
For the first time in his life he feels something. And then his hatred become stronger. How could they have taken this away from them, from him? Completion never felt more bittersweet.
And then, instead of going the d1 route, something happens, maybe Agravaine's being nasty again and throwing a coup d’etat or smth cause I really want to throw here the plot of d4 and bam they need to fix it, they must go to the past together n then, because they are a couple of dumbasses in every universe they start fighting n mess up with the pocket watch.
So instead of traveling to a few moments before the incident they end up to when magic was about to get banned and wow they discover the truth about Merlin’s incredible powers n learn about his dragon lord dad and wow is that Arthur’s mom? Wait what is his dad doing with a sorcerer?? Unbelievable. They have more in common than any of them thought before.
Etc etc etc 🙂↕️🙂↕️
#welcome to the absolute madness that is my brain#I just need to see them eating candy and surfing the internet for the first time!!!!!#let them discover they can be more than what Uther told them they were#let them support each other and discover together the wonders of magic and a world where they can be free#and let them show it to Arthur and Morgana and Gwen and the knights and everyone in the academy that was raised with hatred towards magic#of course at some point they will channel their inner Mal and Ben and fall in love in a tragic manner#but that's something I will write another day#I bought the new book if it's any good be sure there's going to be a descendants wonderland AU coming#never underestimate my descendants obsession#real question WHO from the past is performing shuffle of love#(it’s Balinor lol)#disney descendants#bbc merlin#descendants au#merlin emrys#arthur pendragon#morgana pendragon#merthur#au idea#my post
39 notes
·
View notes
Note
🌈 helloooo it's time for asks- do u have any hcs about pjo? particularly the camp halfblood trio or nico/will :3
Let's gooo! Heyaaa Ollie! :D
Okay, so, I think that Will keep looking for excuses to trap Nico in the medical bay (Infirmary? I can't remember how its called JHGFDHGTR) longer than he needs under his caring care <3 all while Nico continues to make a run for it. At this point it became like a game between them. Will will (ha-) ignore the healing effects that ambrosia has on halfbloods and Nico simply continues to sneak around, pulling excuses or literally just running for it until they get caught in a game of chase. From there is a free game and each move gets sillier than the other
It got to the point that Nico will at some point conjure skeletons and turn the chase around with Solace running for his life because the moment those skeletons get him in a good boney grip he will have to survive Nico's taunts and smug smirk as his playful fingers dancing on his entire torso, hungry for the weak spots that will pry those lovely snorts and crackling laughter. All while Nico will try to convince Will to free him from The Place I Do Not Remember and Will will (ha :D) keeps pulling the card of "Who is the doctor here" until he either descends in even more laughter (Nico found that horrible, awful, ticklish space between his shoulderblades again-) or receives a kiss. It's a win win for both of them in either case.
Anyway, his revenge is always sweet and soft and unberable and it always comes disguised as a check up that Nico simply can't run from. I am just saying, there is a LOT of opportunities to slowly and "accidentaly" keep sneaking tickles and scribbles during those and Will know this and Nico knows that Will knows this he is just sitting there trying to keep his nonchalant, even grump face (unsuccessfully, ofc, his smiles are much easier next to him) while Will keeps poking and wiggling those attacking fingers with no hurry or whatsover, just with a smirk on his lips and a calm pace of someone who has all the time of the world to hear the cutest giggles in this earth.
#Something just clicks right in my brain when I picture them being all silly and teasy all while Will descends into uncontrollable laughter#it's their dynamic. i am sure of it#hgfdfghjkl oof it's been such a long time since i've read them so i hope it's not too ooc! I keep forgetting to read the new book jhgfdxsdc#rip rip#anyway!!! those two aaaaa <3 <3 <3 <3 nico deserves to laugh so so so much and be happy and smile!!! AND WILL!!! I GOT SO ATTATCHED TO HIM#<3 them#i think that in the beggining Will's sibs were all: awww <3 look at them how cute <3 but now they're just rolling their eyes everytime#laughter starts to run across the place#pjo tickles#pjo tickling#Kanene's asks#Kanene's askys#pjo tickle headcanons#Ticklish!Nico#Ticklish!Will#Olliedollie1204 is precious
23 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hello dear friends! ❤🤍🖤💚
🍉I am Mahmoud Ayyad, a Palestinian from the besieged and destroyed Gaza 😭😭, coming from an extended family of young children, women and elderly people ❤❤ who have been suffering😭😭 for 300 difficult days from an aggressive war.
Our lives are harsh because we lack all the basic necessities of life. Everything has become scarce and unattainable. There is no food, no water, no medicine.
So, I ask you to help me keep my family safe and alive, especially after we had lost all our sources of livelihood.Please do not leave my family to struggle and suffer these difficult days alone. You can support my campaign by donating whatever you can or by sharing my posts to reach others who can help us survive the war to safety and peace. You are helping the lives of many people with your small contribution. Every donation makes a difference in our very difficult lives. But this is a legitimate campaign and has been checked by 90-ghost.
https://gofund.me/31c5cbe3
#free palestine#free gaza#gaza strip#save palestine#i stand with palestine#news#lesbian#smiling friends#yellowjackets#atla#descendants rise of red#gofundme#fundraiser#house of the dragon#🍉#gravity falls#billford#the book of bill#the hunger games#the ballad of songbirds and snakes#everlark#bobs burgers#end israeli occupation#aromantic#asexual#lottienat#tlok
29 notes
·
View notes
Text
Disney Descendants [Comics & Mangas]
A little off-topic post just to ask help to the Disney Descendants fandom. Can someone tells me where I can read the Disney Descendants mangas and comics online, please ?
Here the list of titles I'm looking for :
GRAPHIC NOVELS :
The Isle Of The Lost (The Graphic Novel)
Return To The Isle Of The Lost (The Graphic Novel)
COMICS :
Twisted Field Trip (EDIT: Found it!)
Fright at the Museum
MANGAS :
Evie's Wicked Runway 1
Evie's Wicked Runway 2
Dizzy's New Fortune
Mal's Royal Challenge
We only had the manga adaptation of the first movie in my country. And now that I've read all the novels books, I'm curious to read the others Disney Descendants medias. =)
#disney descendants#descendants#disney descendants book#descendants books#the isle of the lost#return to the isle of the lost#twisted field trip#fright at the museum#evie's wicked runway#dizzy's new fortune#mal's royal challenge#disney descendants books#disney descendants manga#descendants manga#disney descendants comic#descendants comic
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
What the writers for Descendants The Rise Of Red must have been thinking when coming up with the plot and such.
#disney descendants#descendants#descendants the rise of red#the rise of red#before anyone asks no there's nothing new on the film#besides the prequel book description#i just felt like making this#given how bad the plot is#how its clear they ripping off stuff from ever after high#while also breaking the whole ass timeline descendants had#and it was already a breakable timeline i should add it already had issues#but this film just broke it completely#and the fashion actually looks bad so far#like how you outdoing D3's fashion choices HOW
20 notes
·
View notes
Text
Bruh my descendants canon is so expansive that future generations will be confused when they stumble upon my works.
The fact that I keep tweaking some aspects of canon will not help in the slightest.
(look, you can pry the kid characters and my headcanons for them, mainly the Baduns, from my cold dead hands-)
They're gonna be like: why did so many people write about the badun cousins, Reza, Eddie Balthazar, Hermie Bing, and Yzla being detectives?
Why is Hadie 8? Why does he even still exist here?
Who's Elle?
Who's the turtle?
Who are Ivy and Hunter and Henry? I thought Carlos not had one cousin.
And I am absolutely not sorry.
Canon is a lovely suggestion.
#descendants#disney descendants#melissa de la cruz#disney#descendants au#wicked world#disney descendants au#rise of red#no hate to the new movie/books#I'm just not readjusting all of my fics/canon to fit the new world#or keeping them completely separate because mixing them is fun
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
the beginnings of a new phone layout… is finally being enacted… i started this plan quite a while ago… and i have so far to go… the planning stage… is not yet complete… I know i can make this look so much better… gAHH…
#kiwi shares their thoughts#my slow death via phone layout#new tag where i descend into madness but publicly this time ^^^#i’ve done this before and it turned out so damn good and made me so damn happy#but now there’s wayyyyy too many negative things associated w that past hyperfixation#and none of my current/new ones are as aesthetic as apothecary diaries#soooo#maybe i should do a httyd one next…#i think i will#i HAVE to find a way to do a d20 one but i’m not DONE with d20 yet#so that will have to wait#same with steven universe i’m not done yet but i want a layout of it#and a tea/book cozy plant gremlincore/dark academia core type general aesthetic one too
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
Honestly if I was told I needed to get recommendation letters to get into college after saving the world twice I'd simply not go to college what the hell
#university of new rome is probably full of old crinkly descendants of demigods who dont know what percy did smh#those three should be given full ride to college#percy jackson#annabeth chase#grover underwood#chalice of the gods#i made this before the book came out#clearing out my drafts
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
God, the one line that breaks my heart every time I think about it is the caption under the photo for the lizard herder, how he scans the horizon with blank eyes while his herd gets smarter. "The future does not seem to belong to him"
#post#onion reads#all tomorrows#😭 the fate of the lizard people having them become beasts of burden#bro the qu r so fucked up for this. their lizard pet descended livestock overcoming their shepherds#soooo fucked up. what do the other human cousins think about them?#like!!!!!! imagine after they all make first contact again n start sharing info n tech#n the fucking. idk. killer folk n satyriacs n sailor people n bugface people. they realize that these lizard people#the sauros. they're intelligent just like them. share the same type of sentience as them.#and yet. they're not like them. bcus they're not human#that'd be fucked up#like a rabbit n a hare meeting n realizing they're not actually from the same origin#but. but! 'you look so much like me'#AUGH#I NEED to go crazy about this book to someone#WHEN will kc release the new updated version
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/ea33a024c6d4713a6bcceca65a37603f/86336b4fc2ea74e8-f8/s540x810/66179171f667e61f3c3fd1f46f419ad699bfa16c.jpg)
Aah, Nebedtka. My first on-the-way-to-becoming non-binary character. He's fab and smart.
And deadly if you piss him off. :>
Now I get to draw his lover!
#art#my artwork#my art#my art <3#my art stuff#doodle#sketch#digital art#Descendant#book#novel#novel writing#fiction#new book#vampire#vampire art#oc#oc art#ocs#my ocs#original character#artists on tumblr#drawing#Nebedtka#Neb#he's amazing#lgbtqia#lgbtq community#lgbtqiia+
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
The sweet scent of blossom blooms is forever tainting the air along side the morning spring mist of dew on the very few grassy patches of meadow and windows of buildings and homes. The sun was out and about giving warmth to some and misery to others.
Fine brown shoes walk along the grey stoned street on this fine morning. Within his needle pricked and bruised hand holds a smaller paler hand of a little boy no more than seven years old dressed rather put together for his age who holds a grey tinned lunch box in his other small hand. Dalmatia, handsome, smart, suave, a good speaker, and loyal are just a few terms he got used to since before and during his time on the Isle of the Lost. Loyal and kind minion of Cruella De Vil, fashionista with a roaring personality of boldness and just a touch of crazy, he remained by her side like the loyal dog he is and helped raise her little pup after the father was no longer around.
The pair finished their stroll at a red bricked building where children are either running around screaming, standing and talking, or on the ground or on the single tree of the lawn. Dalmatia took a deep breath in through the nose, chest puffed out, "Well, look at this, first day of school." He smiled proudly and looked at the boy beside him. Carlos, ever so timid, sneaked behind the older's longer legs and buried his cute face behind his knee cap.
Dalmatia smiled softly and kneels down, "Carlos," He started, waiting for those brown eyes to peek behind the bangs that were combs before leaving the house but seem to have fallen just so, "I understand it's scary, but I promise you this is fun." "But I like to help you and mama with outfits..." The boy pouted, eyes looking down. In any other situation that look would make the dog cave and give Carlos everything he ever wanted and more, but he has to be strong for this case.
Taking in another breath to collect himself to not be swept by the emotions of spoiling the puppy rotten, Dalmatia fixes his coat and tilted Carlos' face up as his voice speaks calmly and comforting, "I know puppy, and we love you helping us to. But you can't always do that forever, you need to let your mind grow and make friends. And I know plenty of the kids here because they're were raised by amazing recruiters like yours's truly." As if on comedic que, a little boy with long black hair runs around the yard with a bucket on his head. The two watch as he runs screaming in strange child glee, and kept watching until he ran into the tree and falls on his back. ". . . Okay he's a little different cause his dad isn't that smart in his life choices..."
Carlos messes with the rubber handle of his lunchbox, lip quivering. His small shoulders tense and jump when a loud bell chimes above them. Dalmatia looked at the building and back down at Carlos, shining down a reassuring smile. The boy looked at the adult and took a breath in before slowly walking towards the steps of the entrance.
The dog waves after, "Have a good day Carlos!"
The stars aren't as bright within his eye sight.
The music was muffled and dare say distant from his hearing.
The taste of bitter saliva that mingled with stale wine he gulped was nothing among his tongue.
All his senses are hyper focused on staring at the floating lights of a little boy smiling so innocently.
Dalmatia gulped another swig of the wine as his tired burning eyes watched his special box show a new memory of Carlos on his first picture day, how proud he looked with his first fashion choice and proudly showing it off. Right now he should be inside celebrating the wedding of Mal and Ben, the future King and Queen of Auradon but as of right now he's hiding in one of the marble polished balcony having his fourth glass or the luxury squeezed grapes alone with a box of memories, a usually normal box full of little memories over the years of Carlos from his birth to his letters talking about possibly being in love with the Fairy Godmother's daughter, but after the Isle became open for all to enter and leave Carlos surprised the loyal minion and his mother with a magic spell that can project the memories as fluid and real as if they aren't images of mist at all.
"It's not healthy crying all alone you know..."
Dalmatia turned to the voice's source to find Hades walking out to the midnight air, rubbing his red leather gloves across his pale cheek for any makeup smears that may be showing as the God walked right beside him. "I remember you used to not cry in situations when the kids were younger too. Yet you always encourage Jay and Carlos to cry as open as they can." Hades said with a soft smile, eyes to the stars.
The once dalmatian doesn't look at him. Doesn't react to him. Eyes drifting back to Carlos' projector face of the memory when he was about to leave for Auradon, his smiling freckled face so fresh of anxious and hidden excitement of adventure he never dared speak of then in fear of how others' will think. The God look at the projector and his smile slowly fades off, his voice got more gentle, "You know, he would've love this... Seeing Mal being married... Seeing Evi get her dream come true... Seeing you all dressed up at a party the first time in forever..."
"He would..." Was all Dalmatia said as he rubs the box's rim, neat eyebrows frowning. "You know..." His voice cracked softly, small but Hades doesn't punch at it, he sniffs as a pause, "When... we first got the news... Cruella refused to accept it... She acted as if he was going to come in through the door as if he never left the Isle in the first place... I never heard her cry as much as I did that whole week... Or month... She barely ate... Hardly slept... It was like seeing a new person..."
Memories of Carlos' wake enters his mind, tarnishing the happy ones he just printed with the box's help, the way the room was so heavy and dull. Carlos wouldn't want that, he would want the room to be colorful like he was, would want people to laugh and smile like he did, but I guess you can't have either at a funeral. He recalled the pain he felt when he held back any sobs and tears deep inside him as he kept a brave face for everyone until he stepped outside the venue's back door and finally let it all out for only the moon to witness.
His hands shook as he feels the tears burning his eyes and even his cheeks as light black streaks began to drip down to his chin as his breathing hitch, "I-I know... I'm just a dog who helped raise his master's child, but I cared for him... As if he was my own pup... I raised him for 19 Goddamn years and now he— H-He's somehow—!" The ball of sorrow clung to his throat flesh, stopping his voice from speaking anymore words as if it hurt more than the tears and the lump.
Hades slowly put his hand on Dalmatia's back, accepting when the dog quickly shook and sobbed openly into the gentle breeze of the magical night, the box still projecting the brave soul as the memories restarted into the first time the pup opened his eyes...
I wanted to write something since I haven't written/done anything related to DVR in a long long while, sorry if it's short and/or crappy! Also I decided Carlos was 19 due to me in my last fic of the gang I had Jay be 18 when the barrier was lifted which I think was a typo and I personally headcanon Mal and Ben's wedding happened a year after the third film since I think it's canon the boys are younger than Mal and Evie or maybe I headcanoned that to the point I believed it lol
This takes place in the AU I've written before which I'm going to be sticking to since I personally love it and am kind of sad Aubrey doesn't marry Harry Hook in the future;
Part One of Aubrey Saga
Part Two
Part Three
Farja & Jay Story and Farja's Reunion
Hopefully I'll right more!
#disney villain recruiters#disney villain recruiters au#descendants#descendants au#disney villain recruiters descendants#dalmatia#mr dalmatian#carlos de vil#disney hades#tw: angst#tw mentions of death#tw grief#not me looking through wikipedia to help me with characters since I haven't read the book tho I should and I'm on my period so I'm refusing#to watch all three plus the wedding and the new one movies to get information#I kind of never gave Dalmatia a moment to grieve the boy he helped raised so here's you DVR/Descendants fluffy angst fest
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/fd39b6f0780e5efccd88ebcabfb35301/01c7bb238370a284-f6/s540x810/59b60063c06a384e69ab45bb4f725145e95db693.jpg)
Judah Gives Hebron to Caleb
They gave Hebron to Caleb, as Moses had promised, and he drove out the three sons of Anak. — Judges 1:20 | New Life Version (NLV) New Life Version Holy Bible Copyright © 1969, 2003 by Barbour Publishing, Inc. Cross References: Joshua 10:36; Joshua 14:9; Joshua 14:13; Joshua 15:14; judges 1:10
#Moses#promise#Judah#Hebron#Caleb#descendants of the sons of Anak#expelled#Judges 1:20#Book of Judges#Old Testament#NLV#New Life Version Bible#Barbour Publishing Inc.
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
Five-Star Reads for October 2024
#Adelaide Blaike#Alethea Faust#book review#books#Cara Dee#Colette Davison#Cried Out#E.M. Denning#E.M. Lindsey#five stars#Hillcroft Group#House Epsilon#Kate Hawthorne#Loving You#Naughty November#Odyssey#reading#Sex Wizards#The Story of Danny Rose#Trophy Doms New York#Words We Never Said#Xerxes Descendant
0 notes
Text
Tags from @tadpal bc they were just too on point:
![Tumblr media](https://64.media.tumblr.com/4d92f235f40234bf77410d9713de3bfd/84bb4d7916b8b03d-a9/s540x810/705b0e36d6c9d08cbb658e8dc780a9d3f52f00e7.jpg)
The show was so incredibly biased towards Rohan. Objectively, they fucked over the Dunlendings. Even the book seems to imply it??? But the show was so--even the differing visual portrayals were awful. And the super European take on the cultures shown was also.....Ugh
(it's a world where the author has openly admitted in the appendices that the cultural aspects he's chosen are largely "translated" for the worldview of a modern English audience from an unknown original text) (there are so so so so so many ways you can take this) (and this was one of the worst ones tbh)
Alright, I was holding off for journalistic integrity but now that I've seen the WotR film I can make posts about it without restraint.
Jesus christ the racial politics of this film are atrocious. Some character might as well just tell Wulf 'not to play the race card'. Wulf is a liberal snowflake who blames racism for all his troubles and can't pull himself up by his bootstraps and he is also brown-skinned and obsessively pursues our PORCLAIN white dainty-drawn female protagonist with both romantic and murderous intent. Oppression of dunlendings by the Rohirrim exists only in Wulf's head apparently, though it can be tasted in every spat 'dunlending' perjorative that comes from Helm or Haleth's mouth. But Hera has absolutely no racism within her of course! She refuses Wulf because she doesnt want to marry anyone and Wulf just assumes it's because his dunlending blood disgusts her, so entitled of him!
But also maybe the racism is '''justified'''? If it exists? Which it doesn't! But IF it did, don't worry because ONCE AGAIN all the dunlendings are just greedy, clutching, unwashed, skull wearing, violent barbarians with no unique culture to speak of and no reasons to be making war on Rohan except to sieze what isn't theirs (ignoring the fact that it totally was theirs until Rohan seized it from them and OH BOY are we ignorin' that) And the only dunlending we see not frothing at the mouth for violence or showing any introspective depth at all is General Targg who is the mouthpiece with which we get to hear 'the girl (Hera) is right' whereupon he is promptly killed by Wulf.
Oh but of course, what else could Helm have done? Freca was some greedy FAT man (boy does everyone love calling him fat, happy to lean into THAT aspect of canon) whose lands were too prosperous for his own good (hang on isn't keeping your lands prosperous the platonic ideal of lordship?) And he called a 'Witan' (no he didn't, he came to one of the regular councils of lords that Helm called himself) just to make a scene about how Helm was going to marry Hera to a lord of gondor which is bad because Gondor has some nebulous hold over Rohan so Hera should marry Wulf instead (literally none of that, Freca simply asked Helm to wed his daughter to Wulf, his son, a completely normal and legitimate political strategy to secure a better relationship with the King's family since Helm already mistrusted him for having dunlending blood. Freca is a lord of Rohan, he is rich, he traces his ancestry back to King Freawine, this could not be a more reasonable suggestion in canon.)
SO OBVIOUSLY Helm had to get angry and call Freca fat again (true he did do that) and THEN claim that Freca only wanted his throne (there was never any suggestion of this in the books, it was just the offer of marriage which insulted Helm) to which Freca answered "Old kings that refuse a proffered staff may fall on their knees," and Helm is like okay lets take this outside.
And now THIS change is actually so important in understanding the extreme nature of the Rohir/Helm favouritism that is the main focus of this film. In the film Helm pretty much immediately takes Freca outside, he reassures Frealaf that Freca just needs to be shown his place, this is the only way to settle the matter, if he doesn't embarass him here then Freca will try to take his crown and slay his family apparently, his hunch ig etc etc. Freca punches Helm three times in full view of the whole of Edoras including Freca's two men who came with him, then Helm punches him back and he is knocked out cold and dead by the time he hits the ground. Film!Helm does not realise he has done this and tells Freca to get up, Wulf realises his father is dead and threatens Helm with revenge, swords are draw against him which he tries to calm before Wulf attacks him. Helm incapacitates Wulf, his sons draw THEIR swords and Helm exiles Wulf for drawing his sword on his king. Messy right? Like not a good thing to do, generally brawling with your lords is a bad idea full stop, but if you fear for the lives of your children then idk maybe it's excusable? And then it's just an unfortunate series of events right? And Freca was rude and insulting to a king in his own halls, heat of the moment etc etc
I feel so comfortable in telling you that Helm murders Freca in cold blood in the books, fully intending that to be the outcome.
He does not take him outside initially, Book!Helm tells Freca that this marriage dispute isn't important and they will deal with it later. And then;
When the council was over, Helm stood up and laid his great hand on Freca’s shoulder, saying: "The king does not permit brawls in his house, but men are freer outside"; and he forced Freca to walk before him out from Edoras into the field. To Freca’s men that came up he said: "Be off ! We need no hearers. We are going to speak of a private matter alone. Go and talk to my men!" And they looked and saw that the king’s men and his friends far outnumbered them, and they drew back. "Now, Dunlending," said the king, "you have only Helm to deal with, alone and unarmed. But you have said much already, and it is my turn to speak. Freca, your folly has grown with your belly. You talk of a staff! If Helm dislikes a crooked staff that is thrust on him, he breaks it. So!" With that he smote Freca such a blow with his fist that he fell back stunned, and died soon after. Helm then proclaimed Freca’s son and near kin the king’s enemies; and they fled, for at once Helm sent many men riding to the west marches.
(Appendices, 'The House of Eorl', emphasis mine)
I think we can all agree that forcing someone out of your city, isolating them away from their fellows with threats of violence, telling them you will break them, killing them in one blow and then proclaiming their kin your enemies and forcing them to flee to escape a murderous pursuit, is pretty clearly premeditated murder. There is not much nuance here, Freca tresspassed over a line with Helm that Dunlendings are not allowed to cross and Helm killed him for it.
And listen like, the description of this whole story within the appendices is barely more than three pages. This is not an obscure missable aspect of the tale, nor is it outside of what rights they had to adapt. The choice was made, actively, ONCE AGAIN by the Warner Bros cinematic universe makers, to drastically alter book events in order to sand down any immorality within Rohan's narrative, especially where the Dunlendings are concerned. And in the end the only 'mistake' Helm is allowed to learn and grow from is some nebulous and trite 'not believing enough in his daughter' schpiel, which needs to be the subject of a whole 'nother post actually.
And what's agonising is they COULD have done it like they were so close, there are multiple moments where me and my friend watching were like struck!! With grief! Over how impactful this moment could have been if only the racism actually existed as an acknowledged theme in the story. If only it was something Hera had to come to terms with, if only IT was the true driver of these horrors to the point where it's Avatar, Hera's father, a man who loves her and whom she has loved all her life, turns into a cold icey ghost of brutality, far more vicious and barbaric than the people he so reviles, and reveals to her the terrible truth of his actions and motivations. It's agony I tell you.
Anyway I did not like the film.
#it did kind of follow in one of the worst canon tolkien things#which is calling just about every evil character “swarthy” in text#i love lotr but this was NOT the bit of it to follow#anyway the dunlendings absolutely 100% deserved better#I LOVED them in the books wtf was this#anyway apparently they're also distant descendents of the house of haleth#which just makes me even more unfairly biased in their favor#also they were so fucking screwed over by the numenorians it's not even funny#they ABSOLUTELY had so so so many justifiable grievances beyond one guy being kind of an incel#also even when they were trying to portray helm favorably??? he still read as SUCH an asshole#call me crazy but I feel like if you accidentally kill this kid's dad in a fight gone wrong#*probably* stripping him of his home and land and banishing him to the wilderness where that (frankly kind of justifiable) anger#is just left to fester#is Not the best move#idk I feel like an actually wise king would've offered him some kind of accidental death compensation#and swore him to service under the crown#in a nearby place not his exact location if he didn't trust the guy around his kids#as like restitution for his father's misdeeds#and then leveraged that to get him loyal to the crown and also where he can see him#or if he was inclined to be a smart asshole and wulf is older than I thought like. Have him really discretely killed or smth idk#but like making an enemy into a Worse Enemy and then throwing them somewhere with freedom and a grudge where you can't see them sounds.#Just so fucking dumb#anyway it could've been SO GOOD if we just leant into like the dunlendings perspective a little more#but noooooooo here we are#anyway on the translation thing I really think that hobbits would like spicy peppers#they got super ultra englishified by the translation thing we don't have as much perspective on their original culture#I do recognize that there's an issue of “new world vegetable” with that but like. Sir you are not getting rid of the potatoes#we're already here#hobbits would fucking love spicy peppers they eat food as a chief delight I bet they would go for it so hard
131 notes
·
View notes
Text
don't wanna jinx it but I've been on a really great roll with books lately
#mine#amina al-sirafi then mexican gothic now a fragile enchantment#there was admittedly a bit of a dry spell between the first two but the first was just so so good that i'm lumping it in anyway#it's been like a ''spending the day reading'' situation which is unusual and only happens with really good books#normally i just read in the evenings#amina al-sirafi is a new favourite and then the other two are good sort of in descending order#mexican gothic was cool as hell and i highly recommend. need more books like it if anyone's got recs.#don't normally go for horror so don't know what to go for so well.#and then fragile enchantment isn't doing much new really but it's well-written and enjoyable and just what i want to be reading right now#far wilder magic is much better imo but both are still good
1 note
·
View note