#mtfl

[cadybear420]

Aiden in a MTFL MC Premium Outfit (with purple versions), edits by me

IDK why I never posted these earlier when I actually completed them but yeah

Anyways Aiden in cute outfit agenda

[what-do-you-mean-theyre-evil]

Reread all of my MTFL posts and my descent into madness was not slow nor subtle

[whatsthesituati0n]

I wish Choices allowed you to go back to specific chapters instead of replaying the chapter when you're on the chapter or restarting the whole book...

[playchoicesconfessions]

Sent by anonymous

‘My Two First Loves would be a lot less hated by the fandom if Noah and Mason had been gender of choice. It could have been done - just make their sport basketball instead of football. You wouldn’t even have needed the awkwardly shoehorned-in Ava then.’

POST/CONFESSIONS DO NOT REFLECT THE MOD’S PERSONAL OPINIONS!

[lover-also-fighter-also]

I'm adding HSS Prime as well cause it's closely related to high school story.

[tyrilstarfury]

I've clearly decided that I have too many diamonds, so I'm reading My two first loves and actually buying the scenes... Yeah I don't like Mason, is it just me?

[the-unconquered-queen]

So it's true that I'll always believe ID should have a poly ending (ideally a throuple but we can start small and work our way up to that) and that I'll play both sides as long as I can

AND it's true that if I have to choose an endgame LI, it'll be Gabe

But honestly, if I were MC, at this point I'd talk to both of the LIs and tell them I'm actually not going to date either of them, because MC canonically cares about them both a great deal, and I feel like on account of that, it'd be best if MC not jeopardize their friendship with either just to date the other when it's just as good to just stay friends with both of them (the awkwardness of choosing is bad enough, imagine that awkwardness when all three of you are immortal—even worse if you end up in the same coven as the one you rejected)

Maybe it's just me, but I'd take two good lifelong friends and no boyfriend over a boyfriend at the expense of another great friend

[choices-ceri]

Newgens will never experience MTFL at it's peak

[somerandomjewelleryonthefloor]

Payton with Quartz & Julian's future kid

(@/Nyesha Kane on tiktok)

Payton would 100% be the godmother. She's severely financially stable (RICH), she's fun, she'd be good with children, plus she's also very fun.

She'd be the auntie that all the kids would hang around with because she can actually entertain children

I had to duet the vid and save it so I could share, I don't have snaptik or anything so yeah. And I couldn't screen record because stuff was blocking the text, that's why that username is there.

[talesfromcordonia]

Choices Background - Mechanical Garage

As seen in the books AOU, MTFL, RCD, ROD

[cadybear420]

Still in-progress with MTFL and so I got this

Because fuck Ava right? I mean you could have just said "Don't keep your loves waiting too long" instead and that would have been fine

[evmonteri]

Madison Jennings, the childhood crush and female version of Mason from My Two First Loves

[choices-binglebonkus]

It still just baffles me that the one teen story PB makes that is literally advertised to have themes of "navigating sexuality for the first time" does the absolute worst job of handling teen sexuality, compared to the teen stories that don't have those themes.

MTFL, overall, is a book that didn't know what it wanted to be. One moment, a character has an arc revolving around a serious and possibly mature issue. Another moment, MC blubbering over an outfit with "naughty little thigh highs" (ugh) or "OMG Mason and Noah are so muscular and manly" (uugghh) or wanting to do a "down and dirty" cheer routine for the male LIs (uuuugggghhhh) comes along to slap you in the face.

I'd get it if it was in a teen story that was meant to be a bit more campy (I'd still hate it cause it's so generic and gender-stereotypey but at least it'd be more at home there). But in a story advertised to heavily revolve around more serious issues? It's completely tone-deaf.

And the worst part is that none of these hypersexual moments contribute to anything. Honestly, the way these characters are written as horny and hormonal feel hamfisted into the story solely so the writers can brag about how this one is "more mature" than their other high school books. When in reality, these characters are so immature that they make HSS:CA's side characters look like they're from Citizen Kane.

MC doesn't navigate sexuality, she just runs around in circles in it like a chicken with its head cut off.

That last sentence is such a perfect summary of the book omfg I applaud this, and I applaud you

[playchoicesconfessions]

Sent by @cadybear420

‘I could go into paragraph upon paragraph about everything wrong with MTFL. But I think the best way I can sum it up is: It reads like PB adapted an untamed 12-year-old's Wattpad story and then hamfisted some serious themes about sexuality and race into it in order to make the story seem more "mature".’

POST/CONFESSIONS DO NOT REFLECT THE MOD’S PERSONAL OPINIONS!

[hotchocolatelovesyou]

who the fuck thought that having so many chapters, such short chapters, was a good idea?

Do not let me catch you doing this shit ever again @pixelberry

[tyrilstarfury]

Is Mason supposed to be likable?